Pod Insights The Property Academy Podcast 1 In 4 New Builds Fail – Here's Why That's Fine⎟Ep. 2501 About this episode 1 in 4 new builds fail their first inspection. Here's why that's actually not bad news.
In this episode, Ed and Andrew sit down with Jeff Fahrensohn – Auckland Council's former inspections manager, now independent – for an honest look inside the build.
You'll learn:
The defects building inspectors find most often in new buildsThe questions investors don't even think to askThe documents smart investors demandThe biggest takeaway? Most new builds are good. You just need to know what to check.
As mentioned in the episode, here is the link to Fahrensohn Building Consultants website http://fahrensohnbuildingconsultants.co.nz/
Book a meeting https://bit.ly/3QE2XJN to start your path to financial freedom with a detailed financial plan for $0.
For more from Opes Partners:
Sign up for the weekly Private Property newsletter https://www.opespartners.co.nz/newsletter-sign-upInstagram https://www.instagram.com/opes_partners/TikTok https://www.tiktok.com/@opespartners
Transcript 0:08 Speaker 00 Hello and welcome along to the Property Academy podcast by Opes Partners. I'm your host, Seb McKnight. And I'm Andrew Nicoll. And this is the show that helps Kiwis go from zero to five investment properties. So you could be financially free and stick around for the next 15 minutes because you're going to learn the dodgy stuff that building inspectors find on construction sites, the questions investors don't even think to ask and the checks you really should do and the single most common new build defect and how to spot it before you buy. And to walk us through it is Geoff Fahrensohn from Fahrensohn Building Consultants. Welcome along to the show, Geoff. Good morning. Did I get your last name right? Yeah, yeah. Oh, there we go. Close enough. Now, I remember hearing about Geoff probably last
0:50 Speaker 00 year, there were a couple of One Roof articles because this was back when you were working for Auckland Council as the inspections manager and you had recorded this video on LinkedIn showing what you were finding on construction sites. For anybody who didn't see those articles last year before you went out on your own with Fahrensohn Building Consultants, just talk to us about what you were showing on LinkedIn. There was a lot of flux in the industry at the time. You know, there's reform to the Building Act. There is also a lot of pressure on developers to try and get things done under the financial constraints they had. So we were seeing a lot of issues out there that I thought was quite important for people to understand the sort of climate in terms of quality that we were seeing in the build. So I put up a few videos there
1:35 Speaker 00 just to show some of the worst cases that we were coming across. But I also had some really good examples too on there. So, yeah, it wasn't just one sided. Well, one of the things that I've noticed recently is there was a survey that came out from One Choice and they said that seven in 10 New Zealanders that they surveyed, these are young New Zealanders, people 18 to 39, seven in 10 worry that new builds are going up too quickly and that the quality is being compromised. From where you Stand and you were on the ground for many years inspecting them from Auckland Council's perspective, are they right to be worried? I think there's a little bit of, it's been blowing out of proportion a little bit.
2:20 Speaker 00 It's quite interesting, being built too quickly is quite ironic because the build time at the moment is very slow. You know, you're talking 10 months for a build now, whereas 15 years ago, it was four, four, five months. So, yeah, the majority of the bills are being completed today are good. And I think there may be a little bit of scaremongering out there in terms of some of the media stuff, the coverage that you're seeing. But generally speaking, you know, most defects are commonly discovered in the first year as the building sort of settles and, and, and finds its own equilibrium as they do. You know, timber shrinks as it dries and, and all that sort of thing. So I guess there is an important thing here that people need to understand is that the
3:02 Speaker 00 inspectors are probably the most trained and knowledgeable that they've ever been. And these are the council inspectors and they continue to stay ahead of the game just by the ongoing trainings. So they're constantly looking for issues that could come back to bite. And like I said, the vast majority of buildings out there are good buildings. But Jeff, in that article that I was reading, I'm gonna butcher the statistic, but this is what's in my mind. I think the stat was that 90% of new builds or some massive proportion fail their first council inspection, but then you're saying that most are, are fine. Yeah, it's probably more around 25% failing. So, so when you look at that, 25% of failing, 75% of passing.
3:46 Speaker 00 And keep in mind that when you fail it, that means we're coming back to look again to pass it hopefully. Yeah, so Jeff, I, I think the misconception there, when someone reads it, they think, oh, one in four properties is therefore bad. I'm gonna, I've got a one in four chance of buying a bad property. Now, the council aren't gonna let you buy it or aren't gonna sign off the code compliance. While it's still bad, it just has to be brought up to the code so that then it can be issued. And actually Jeff, as someone who signed off and failed thousand Of these kind of properties. What is the dodgy stuff that you pick up the most often? Where do you see most new builds fail? Oh, that's, uh, that's a longer thing than this podcast. Where, where do you start? Are there common themes?
4:31 Speaker 00 Yeah, there is. So, so generally speaking, there's a lot of time pressures at the end of bills. And so there are a lot of things that are missed from human error. So when you talk dodgy, they're not generally dodgy. They've just been a human miss. And that's what the inspection process is there for. So things like forgetting to install your smoke alarms or you, or you've done your landscaping too high on the cladding or something like that can be picked up at the final inspection. Okay. But yeah, it's, it's, there are dodgy builders out there. There are corner cutters and generally it's to save money and time. And I can say this now that I'm not in council, most of the inspectors know who those builders are. And those builders know who they are. Yeah.
5:11 Speaker 00 And I guess that if you are known to the council of cutting corners every now and then, the person coming out to inspect is going to be extra thorough. They're going to allow two hours rather than an hour when they go through and check all the boxes. And in terms of, you know, things that are, you know, actually critical, like, like forgetting a smoke alarm. If I bought a new build property and oh no, this one's ripped me off, they haven't put in the smoke alarm. It's not the end of the world. Is there much that's like actually catastrophic? Like, oh, they haven't put the foundation down. I mean, that terrible example, but you know, something like that. There can be, yeah. Probably the main thing is, uh, well, there's two sort of topical issues. One is cladding and we saw that through our leaky home crisis.
5:55 Speaker 00 And New Zealand's got really good. In fact, I think we're probably one of the best in the world in terms of weather tightness design now. But that is still a problem because there's always new products and materials coming onto the market. People struggle to keep on top of the, the knowledge needed to install these products compliantly. So that's, that's always an issue and I always look out for that. Uh, inspectors went through a period in 2018 where we saw a big drop in cladding quality, uh, compliance. Basically because there was so many people, uh, wanting. That the industry didn't have enough qualified people. So a lot of apprentices, a lot of unskilled labourers were working on sites. And in those cases there, a strategy was adopted by the council where they had inspectors
6:38 Speaker 00 having very close look and taking time to look at the cladding a lot more than all. And then you've got the internal moisture issue, which is sort of a rising, emerging risk now. Because of the way the wet areas have become more and more high risk with walk-in showers and and whole rooms being needing to be waterproofed. That's something else that needs to be closely looked at. You can't look at that too closely. At the final, it's got to be done during the construction and the application of those membranes. And can I ask you, Andrew mentioned before, oh, you might allow two hours for a council inspection, but it just got me thinking. What does a council inspection actually look like? And and actually, before you answer that, who are the the council building inspectors? Like, what's their background?
7:24 Speaker 00 Yes, so council building inspectors are building surveyors. They have a tertiary qualification in building surveying. Normally, it's a diploma or it could be a degree in engineering. Gone are the days where it's just an ex-builder, unqualified, doing building inspections. So a day in the life of an inspector, they get given a list of jobs to look at. Each inspection is kind of timed based on the risk factor, so how complex the building is, and they get given that time to look at it. Now, what inspectors are very skilled at is what we call sampling up and sampling down. Whenever you find issues, you look a little bit deeper. Hmm. Um. You see whether it's a systemic issue and you move through the building that way. But when you start finding that it's very high quality, you can start speeding things up a little bit.
8:07 Speaker 00 So, yeah, it is based on experience and knowledge for for an inspector. So when they first start inexperienced, they'll spend a lot more time on jobs. But as they start getting a good feel for it and they start developing a nose for non-compliance, as I say, they get a lot more efficient. But generally speaking, yeah, you can spend two, you can spend four hours on a job and not worry too much about having to be late for the other inspections. The the the job is Designed around a team. So there is a team to support. If they need to offload inspections to spend more time on a job, they will. And getting it done correctly. And actually, I remember reading a couple of articles over the last few years. And there was a bit of criticism on the Auckland Council and, you know, the inspectors getting it wrong, but it certainly doesn't sound the case.
8:51 Speaker 00 And I don't think that's been my experience either in terms of seeing some developments finish. Sure, there are some that finish them better than others, but having a few loose ends is not the same as having a leaky building. And actually, just came back to leaky building for a minute. I know that's been a really common concern for lots of people buying new build today. Particularly when they see something that looks the same. They've got plaster and they think, oh God, that could be leaky. What's your kind of thoughts of that? Probably to remember that the council is only there doing a snapshot inspection. If you're buying a property that does have monolithic cladding, it's always advisable to get a third party to do a more thorough inspection on it.
9:32 Speaker 00 And accreted to building surveyors, I mean, they're probably the sort of pre-purchase experts, I would say, out there. From boines that can probably give you a better look at the cladding if you do have any fears over it. Now, Jeff, if a buyer is walking through a new build, and of course, the building inspector's already been. But if they're going to walk through it, are there any things that they can look out for to try and tell whether it's good quality or not? Yeah. So start with the cladding, walk around the outside, have a look at how it's finished. Even an untrained eye will tell whether or not there's a lot of silicon being used. And one of the key sort of tells, and hopefully it wouldn't get to this level, but
10:15 Speaker 00 a use of silicon is not there as a primary defence against weather. So if you can see silicon as the primary defence of weather, that's a big flag, a red flag for me. Silicon should be there as a secondary defence. And so you should be relying on mechanical flashings. Good, tight fitting cladding being installed correctly. So that's one thing. And then walking around the inside. Looking at the sort of junctions where you have, say, window corners or ratch slider corners where there may be. Uh leak signs where water has come in or mould growth. So there might be some condensation issues. And generally, the wet areas, making sure that um the tiles are, the grout's not
10:57 Speaker 00 cracked, or there are no swelling around sort of skirting near the shower edges and stuff like that. So you can kind of get a fairly good grasp of of walking around a new build just by looking at those high risk areas. Another probably high risk area they should be aware of, and that's internal gutters, membrane decks, you know, tricky or complex sort of wall junctions, different claddings going into each other, those sorts of things there, depending on the skill level of the builder, it's the the variety of compliance in those areas can be a lot during construction. And when you've got that, I think that's probably where you need more of a trained eye to look into those things. And how many inspections do the council do throughout a build?
11:42 Speaker 00 Generally, they plan for about 12 on a on a standard sort of standalone house. Wow. And then you add the 25% fail rate on top of that. So so say about 15, 16 inspections. It's amazing. There's a lot more than probably people think. It's not just On a single house? Yeah, yeah, it's not just, yeah, see, it's not that people just, the council just comes in at the end and go, oh, no, that all looks good. Flick the lights on and off, turn the tap on. Well, I suppose because the thing is, when you get a building inspector done when you buy a house, they always have disclaimers up the wazoo. This has been visual only, it's been non-invasive. We don't know what's behind the walls. So we'll do, you know, thermal imaging and, you know, they'll do their best and take moisture readings. But that's quite
12:24 Speaker 00 good because that gives you confidence that somebody is looking behind the walls as you go. Well, as a bit of a side, Jeff, one, one of Andrew's favourite stories that he ever told me was about a builder. Moving the pink bats. Moving the pink bats in between council inspections that they'd get a, you know, Jeff comes along, oh, yeah, the pink bats are all there. Yeah. Right, I'll get tomorrow and see you at two. Does any of that dodgy stuff actually happen? Or is that just Andrew making it up with his builder mates down at the pub? It's one of the most popular urban myths in building inspections. Oh. The builder removing the reinforcing mesh from a slab after getting a pass or or taking out the insulation. How hard it is to cut insulation so it fits perfectly in framing and having to take that
13:09 Speaker 00 out and then try and refit it. It's probably going to cost you more in the cost of the insulation, I think. We've had those sort of complaints over the years and we've always tried to investigate it to see whether or not we could find those because we had no time for those builders. If we found anybody doing anything like that, the hammer came down hard in terms. I mean, it's a criminal offence, negligent offence anyway. And when you see that, it's generally escalated to, you know, sort of the Licensed Building Practitioners Board or whoever. But we never actually found any evidence. No matter how hard we pushed, no one would ever come up with an address. And if. So it turns out that might just be a story that I've been told and passed on to you. Actually,
13:53 Speaker 00 maybe it was candy floss. He put candy floss on the walls. That was it, Geoff. And so Geoff, is there, is there a pattern? Actually, sorry, no, I got it. Let's just say there was some issues when insulation was being split. Ah, yeah, that was it. As thicker insulation requirements came into play, a lot of builders, when they're pulling the bats out of the bales, they weren't as tight as they are today and they were easily split. So we did come across that. And inspectors, once we started seeing a few of those, and this was a long time ago, I'm talking, you know, early 2000s, the inspectors would start looking specifically for that. So they'd pull a bat out and measure its thickness to make sure
14:35 Speaker 00 that wasn't happening. And as time went on, the bat industry sort of clicked on that they needed to sort of have a more tighter design so it wasn't split that easy. So Geoff, thinking of some of these, you know, recidivist offenders of people that maybe, I mean, they might not be splitting bats and replacing them with candy floss, but, you know, the people that are doing things like winding up companies, like are there, are there those Are people still around and what are the things that people could look out for? Yeah, there are, unfortunately. We come across things where, um, gosh, yeah, like I said, this is a whole different podcast that could go on for hours. Using no more nails to stick reinforcing into foundations or swapping materials for cheaper versions.
15:18 Speaker 00 Some developers importing their own materials that were dumped on the market because there was a a class action suit in America because they were carcinogenic to people living in the houses. So we came across things like that and inspectors, you know, eagle eyes and picked up stuff. There was a container load of asphalt shingles that was brought in and that was the carcinogenic thing that they had in America where people who harvested water off their roofs were really getting getting some health issues from it. So that ended up in a container, turned up in Auckland. One of the inspectors saw the labelling, recognised it and called it out. By the time it had been found, the container had roughly 20 houses worth of shingle roofing in it.
16:00 Speaker 00 So we had to go back. They pulled off all the roofs of that. The developer ended up paying big time. But those are the sorts of things where generally you call it out and you find it, it does disappear. You know, I don't know where it ended up. Did it end up on Trade Me? Did it end up in Hamilton? There is also stories, and we've seen this ourselves actually, where builders have got to the point where their reputation is so bad in Auckland, they weren't passing any inspections and they just move on and they service in other cities. And that's where it's a bit scary because there's no sort of teeth. I mean, apart from a complaint to the R P B board, there's nothing stopping them from turning up in other areas. And I guess working for the council is not like you can put their name on a website like we would.
16:45 Speaker 00 Yes. So one of the things that I would recommend, if you're buying a house, don't just rely on the limb. Get a property bag and in that property bag will be the inspection records. And that inspection record will tell a story in itself. So if you're looking at a lot of failed inspections and the reasons for the fails will be articulated in writing along with photos from the inspector. And that gives you a really good heads up. A nice, clean inspection record is good. And where does someone get a property bag from? So you order those online from the council. So once you know the address, I think it's about a hundred and fifty bucks and you um you can down download it. It's a digital download, yeah. We're gonna go do that. We'll go, we'll do a whole podcast about it. I'll look at some of our new builds. Yeah.
17:29 Speaker 00 And maybe we'll do one of yours and one of mine. Great. And we'll see who bought a dodgy property.
17:35 Speaker 00 And Jeff, just before we wrap up, I I note that at Farin's on building consultants, you're doing something which sounds very cool. Forensic analysis. Just walk us through. What is that? Sometimes you you you find defects in a building and and fixing them is one thing, but understanding the causation or where it all come, where where it started is probably the key factor to a good remediation strategy. So it does sometimes become forensics. You're you're looking at analyzing materials, you're looking at testing mold, air sampling, all that sort of thing there. So it's building pathology, basically. And that could be anything from your your leaky houses to just tracking where water is coming from.
18:18 Speaker 00 I've recently just come across a a building where one of the sewage pipes was damaged and it took months for it to, it was, sorry, it was damaged during the foundations where concrete got into it and blocked it. And as you can imagine, it filled up, but it took months for it to fill up before it got back to the house. And this pipe was feeding two or three other houses up the hill. So by the time it got back up, it would have been, everyone's finished, the the house is completed, it's got a new buyer. And as as the effluent backflowed up the pipe, it got to the the the gully, which is where it's supposed to go, the outside gully. But the but the toilet paper blocked the gully. So the next place it went was inside the shower wastes.
19:02 Speaker 00 So this person, almost, you're just randomly, six months later, is getting effluent from his neighbours coming through the the the the shower waste on the ground floor. And what's worse is they're away for the summer, so. Back two weeks later and they walk in and the thing's been cooking. So now the first thing you've got to work your way backwards from there. And that's the sort of the causation thing that the analysis, the forensic analysis and trying to find out where it all starts from. And that could be down the road. What a shit show. Thought you'd like that. Jeff, thank you so much for coming on. This has been so interesting. It's given me a lot more confidence actually in the number of building inspections that get done. I didn't even know it was 16.
19:45 Speaker 00 We're going to go and download some property bags and do another episode digging into that. But if you want to check Jeff out, we'll link his website down in the show notes, farins on building consultants.co.nz. And over the last 15 minutes, you've learned the dodgy stuff that building inspectors find on construction sites, the questions investors don't even think to ask and the checks you can rarely do, and the single most common new build defect and how to spot it before you buy. Right, let's wrap it up there, but please don't forget to rate, review and subscribe to the Property Academy podcast. Really does help us get the message out to more people.
20:23 Speaker 00 Thanks for listening to the Property Academy podcast. I'm your host, Stephen Knight. And I'm your host, Nick. We're going to be back again tomorrow with even more daily strategies, techniques and insights to help you get the most out of the news in the property market. Until next time.
Previous Don't Choose Your Agent Like This⎟Ep. 2500 Next "Earthquake Hit 1 Day After I Signed – What Happened Next"⎟Ep. 2502 Page updated November 14, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated