Pod Insights The Pool Guy Podcast Show Why I Prefer Cartridge Filters Over DE About this episode Send us a textItused to be all about DE filters, but over the years, I’ve come to appreciate why cartridge filters are the smarter choice for both me and my clients. No more messy DE clouds, fewer parts to break down, and less hassle with city backwash restrictions. In this episode, I’ll explain why I’m recommending cartridge filters more than ever when they make the most sense and how switching my clients over has saved me time and increased customer satisfaction. Support the Pool Guy Podcast Show Sponsors! HASA delivers clean, healthy water solutions. https://bit.ly/HASAhttps://www.orendatech.com/The Bottom Feeder Professional Battery Powered Vacuum System. Save $100 with discount Code: DVB100https://bit.ly/THEBOTTOMFEEDERAnd Skimmer, America’s #1 pool service software! Try Skimmer FREE for 30 days at:https://getskimmer.com/poolguy Thanks for listening and I hope you find the Podcast helpful! For other free resources to further help you:Visit my Website: https://www.swimmingpoollearning.comWatch on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@SPLPodcast Site: https://the-pool-guy-podcast-show.onpodium.com/
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 This episode is brought to you by Hasa. Pool pros, are you using the new Hasa Pro Rewards app? Earn points on Hasa and Orenda purchases, redeem them for gift cards and product rewards. Download the free Hasa Pro Rewards app today and get rewarded by the bottom feeder. With their new cartridge filter assembly, now you can vacuum dirt in a pool down to 10 microns. Don't just vacuum the pool, finish it.
0:27 Speaker 01 This episode is brought to you by Skimmer, the number one pool service software in North America. With Skimmer, you can streamline your schedule, grow your revenue, and keep your customers coming back with five-star service. Whether you're a one-person operation or an established team, Skimmer is your partner in success. Visit getskimmer.com/poolguy to try Skimmer for free for 30 days.
1:04 Speaker 00 Welcome to the Pool Guy Podcast Show. In this episode, I'm going to talk to you about why I think a cartridge filter is much superior to a DE filter, and why you probably should be replacing any DE filters on your route with a cartridge filter. And I'll go over some of the pros of the cartridge filters, there are some cons as well, and why they are, in my opinion, superior to a Diatomaceous or DE filter. Are you a pool service pro looking to take your business to the next level? Join the Pool Guy Coaching Program, get expert advice, business tips, exclusive content, and get direct support. For me, I'm a 35-year veteran in the industry. Whether you're starting out or scaling up, I've got the tools to help you succeed. Learn more at swimmingpoollearning.com.
1:49 Speaker 00 I've been in the industry long enough to where a lot of the DE filters, when I first started, had what was called separation tanks. And these were pretty horrible devices that they put into the DE with the DE filters. They were a small tank, you may still have some of these out there if you have some old 2000 series filters. And basically... Basically, they are small tanks. Usually the pool pro that's taking care of that account will bypass it and cut it out already. So they're just sitting there dormant. But basically, inside there is a bag. And that bag captures all the DE when you backwash the filter. And it's really a messy thing. It's more messy, I think, sometimes than just actually just having the line
2:32 Speaker 00 going out to a drain or on the cement. You can clean that up even better sometimes than a separation tank. But a lot of those are gone now. So this is like, that was like the dark ages of pool service. A lot of times, people will plum the DE, backwash to a P trap, and it goes into the the drain or sewer system. There are a lot of regulations in states like California, particular cities, everything in LA County, you can't wash the diatomaceous earth filters into the street. It can't go into the storm drains and into the ocean. They don't want that to happen. And so if you are cleaning a D filter and the D goes into the gutter outside,
3:15 Speaker 00 and the city code enforcement comes by, they'll give you a pretty hefty ticket. And in some areas, I've heard it as high as $5,000 for the diatomaceous earth being in the street and going into the storm drain. So that's a word of caution. Also, in the powdered form, it does have potential, the cellulose in there has potential to cause problems with your lungs. And so if you're recharging a lot of D filters on your route, it is considered an industrial carcinogen, which means if you get enough of this in your lungs over the course of years, it's going to cause lung problems for you. And so that's another issue as well. Now, when it's wet, it's inert, and there's no problem with that.
3:56 Speaker 00 I'm not really sure that, you know, how much of it comes back after, let's say you backwash a filter or clean a filter and there's residue on the cement, how much of that is active again, or how much of that is inert still? But it's just really a messy process anyway when you do a D filter. You can hose off the equipment area, and then the customer will still call you the next day saying, hey, there's all this white Powder everywhere. It's all over the place. I even had it where I was putting into the skimmer and I spilled a little bit on the deck and I cleaned it really well. And you know, I got water from the pool with the cup and I splashed it everywhere. But the next day, the customer's like, hey, there's all this white stuff on my deck. And sure enough, I went back there and it was still some DE residue.
4:40 Speaker 00 So that stuff sticks around pretty much forever and it's just hard to clean. And if you are cleaning the filters into a planter, the customer may eventually complain saying, hey, you know, the planters are turning white. There's this white chalky stuff everywhere. And again, it's another problem. Now, there is alternatives to diatomaceous earth. You have Paralight, which is very similar, but it is something that breaks down a lot better. And it's not quite as messy and it's also safer. But my whole thing here is to say they're not a highly effective filter type to begin with, in my opinion. And they've kind of outlived their time in the industry. A lot of builders aren't putting them in mainly because there's a lot of extra steps they have to do to put a DE filter in.
5:23 Speaker 00 And the cartridge filters in most cases are just superior for many reasons. So let me start with some of the reasons why I think if you have a pool with a DE filter, you probably should consider replacing with a cartridge filter. There is one thing that you should know about a cartridge filter to begin here. And that is you can't backwash it. And if you are in an area where you have a lot of dirt, you know, sometimes it does pay to have a sand filter or even a DE filter at that point because you're going to be backwashing it a lot when you're cleaning it. You may have a multi-port, you can vacuum the waste and that's the advantage of the DE filter, the ability to vacuum the waste if you need to, if you're in an area with a lot of dust. A sand filter or DE filter may be a better choice.
6:07 Speaker 00 But you can simply install a three-way valve in a, in front of the cartridge filter and create your own kind of vacuum the waste as well if you wanted to do that. If you're in an area where you have a lot of dirt and you don't want to vacuum it into the cartridge filter. That's really easy to do. The advantage manufacturing Portovacs have that bypass valve so that if you have a pool that has a lot Dirt, you can just simply vacuum at the waste and you can easily install one of these on your equipment pad. When you're installing a new cartridge filter, that way if you do need to vacuum the waste, you can just turn the Janney valve. And attach a hose there and that will allow you to vacuum to waste.
6:46 Speaker 00 So again, that's probably the main drawback with the cartridge filter is that you can't backwash it and you have to actually take it apart and clean it. The good thing is that most of the cartridge filters will be much bigger and better than a DE filter. Let me just give you some of the numbers based on square footage. And I guess I should mention that the cartridge filter can't filter down as fine as a DE filter. Before I talk about the differences there with the sizes. So a DE filter will filter down to about three microns, which is a pretty small particle. It's because the diatomaceous earth coats the grids and it traps everything to that micron level.
7:26 Speaker 00 It's not because the cloth necessarily is that fine, but with the cloth material and with the DE on top, you have that three micron filtration. Cartridge filters are rated from anywhere from 10 to 20 microns. So to be honest with you, there's no way to tell if a pool has a DE filter or cartridge filter by walking back there and looking at it. Just because the cartridge filters have improved over the years to where they filter down just almost as good as a DE filter. And there's no noticeable difference in the filtration, in my opinion. So as far as sizes go, most of the accounts here in California have a 48 or 60 square foot DE filter. There may be somewhat some 36 DE filters still left out there, but those are far and few between.
8:11 Speaker 00 And you'll see most of the pools here in my area with a 48 square foot DE filter or a 60 square foot. But I think the 48 square foot still outnumbers the 60 square foot filters. We also only install quad cartridge filters in my area. In Florida, I know there's a lot of single cartridge filters that may be actually similar in size to a 60 square foot DE filter. As far as filtration area, you know, 100 or 150 square feet filter, the DE filter. is pretty close to that if you have a single cartridge filter. But in most cases, you're putting in the quad cartridge filters. Or you're putting in the AquaStar Pipeline Filter, which is a special single cartridge filter. That has a wide square footage, or they increase the square footage.
8:57 Speaker 00 By the design of the cartridge. But let's just say if you had a 450 square foot quad cartridge filter. You know, you have a Pentair or you have a Waterway filter. And 420 or 460 square, 450 square feet, I should say. Are those sizes for those filters. They also make a 520 and they make some that are even bigger, 700 square feet. Filtration area, but let's just take the basic. Let's just say you have a 420 or 450 square foot cartridge filter. That's seven and a half times or seven times. More filtration area than a 60 square foot D filter. So you're going to have a much larger filtration area because of the pleats in the cartridge. That's what gives you that extra filtration.
9:42 Speaker 00 And you're going to have better flow and better water quality. So there may not be any need to backwash your filter if you're going from. Let's say a 60 square foot D filter. To a 450 or 500 square foot cartridge filter. Because of the extra square footage. More dirt can be trapped in there. And you don't have to backwash the filter. So you may find, and this is the case, almost every time I replace a D filter with a cartridge filter. There's some D filters where I'm backwashing it. Two or three times every six months, then I'm cleaning it. And when I put the cartridge filter in. I'm thinking sometimes, well, I can't backwash it, so that may be a problem. But I've never run into a problem where I replaced a D filter.
10:25 Speaker 00 With a 450 or 500 square foot cartridge filter. And had to clean it more than every six months. So the extra square footage really. Makes it a much better product. You're not needing to backwash it because it has more. Square footage and it traps more dirt. You'll notice also the flow. Of the cartridge filter is much better. Not only initially when you change it out. But kind of consistently, what I mean by this is that when a D filter starts to get dirty and it starts to get a lot of dirt on the grids because of the nature of it, again, I mentioned that it's coated with DE and then when it starts getting compacted with dirt and maybe some dead algae on there,
11:08 Speaker 00 it really affects the water flowing through there because there's so much gunk on it now that it slows the flow down and you're going to see the PSI or the pressure gauge rise on a D filter. And when it gets to 30, the flow to the pool is also impacted. You'll notice that the return jets aren't pushing a lot of water back in. You'll notice that the spillway isn't spilling water back in. You'll notice the automatic suction cleaner isn't moving well and that's because the D filter is basically full at that point and needs to be backwashed or taken apart and cleaned. With a cartridge filter, you really don't have that problem with the quad cartridge filter. I've really never run into a problem. You know, unless it's really extreme and they're not cleaning the filter when you take over the account.
11:53 Speaker 00 But there hasn't really been a problem with the pressure going up to a point where it affects the flow of the pool. Now with a single cartridge filter, that can be the case because there's not a lot of area. So 150 square feet versus 500 is a big difference. So if you do have a single cartridge filter, you may see the PSI raise to a certain level and you may see the flow to the pool affected. So that's one main difference. So keep that in mind that it's not universal. It's only the larger cartridge filters that tend to have a better return or the flow regardless of how dirty it gets over time.
12:33 Speaker 00 And you won't notice an impact in the automatic cleaner nor in the return to the pool. And so that's another advantage with the cartridge filter. You may not be able to backwash it, but you may not need to backwash it because it will hold more dirt and it doesn't affect the flow of the pool. And so it's not going to impact the water quality. I can tell you many times I've been to a D, a pool with a D filter. Where they had a party, they had a lot of people in there. The pressure went up to thirty PSI. The pool wasn't running well that week. Algae developed, the water quality dropped down tremendously. The water is cloudy and murky because of that. And then so I have to, you know, backwash the filter or clean it. And I have to shock the pool and treat it, run it twenty-four hours.
13:16 Speaker 00 But with a cartridge filter, I've had this happen many times where I have a five hundred square foot or five hundred twenty square foot Penter filter. And in the count, they have a party, the pool's used heavily. You know, the chlorine level's really low. But the water quality is really not affected too much because the flow was not impacted by all the bather, heavy bather use. And so that's another main difference is that you're going to have a more sustainable pool, especially if the customer uses the pool a lot. Now, the only exception is if they have dogs swimming in the pool. I haven't found that the cartridge filters do any better than a D filter in that case. The pool water still suffers, maybe a little bit better.
13:57 Speaker 00 But that is something that impacts both filter types to an extent where you don't have a huge advantage with a cartridge filter. If there's two or three dogs swimming in the pool, the water quality still will drop regardless of the filter type. It's just the nature of having dogs in the pool and swimming, that there really isn't anything that's going to protect the pool water from that. And but the cartridge filter, in my opinion, does a slightly better job. What about a green pool cleanup? Well, here's where the D filter probably has another advantage over the cartridge filter. Because in the green pool cleanup, it seems to be a better filter type because you can backwash it and you can, of course, clean off the grids and the algae will come out.
14:42 Speaker 00 Cartridge filters do a pretty good job with the green pool. But I find that the way to make it work the best is to replace all four cartridges when I'm doing a green pool cleanup. It sounds counterintuitive because the pool's green. And why would you want to put brand new cartridges in there and, you know, ruin them? But you technically don't ruin them. Because if you clean them right away after you're doing the green pool cleanup, all of that will come out and be cleaned off the new cartridges. The problem with the old cartridges in there during a green pool cleanup, or if the pool is cloudy or murky, is that the old cartridges, you know, those, that material does get built up, it does get stained, and it does affect the efficiency of it. And so I find nine times out of 10, when I get to a pool that's green, I'm doing a green pool cleanup and there's a cartridge filter.
15:27 Speaker 00 I'll change those cartridges out and it's gonna make the green pool cleanup work much more effectively. I've done it before where I left the old cartridges in there and I cleaned them, and the green pool cleanup did not come out as effectively. So, there may be an advantage with the DE filter during a green pool cleanup because you can backwash it. You don't have to necessarily tear it down all the time. But, it's one of those things where it's not an advantage that I think would be something to count on because you don't really want a green pool to begin with. And so if a DE filter is more effective in a green pool, then, you know, that's fine, but you shouldn't have a green pool in the first place to have, to have to put that to the test, I should say.
16:07 Speaker 00 And then, probably the biggest advantage of the cartridge filter, and I started the podcast talking about how messy DE filters are, and how I had to deal with separation tanks and, you know, pulling that bag out full of DE, which is a pain to begin with. But DE is messy. Cartridge filter, it's just dirt. So if you want to clean it off into the street, they're not gonna hassle you. Clean it off in your driveway, clean it off on the grass, clean it off into the planters. You're just spraying off dirt into the planters, into the grass, into the, into the street, or the gutter, and it's, probably don't want to do it in the middle of the street. But basically, it's just dirt and it's perfectly safe and there's nothing to it. And, easy to clean up as well in the deck.
16:51 Speaker 00 Because if you have just all cement back there, and you have maybe a drain in the center and you're cleaning a cartridge filter into that drain, yes, there's gonna be dirt residue everywhere, but you can easily hose off that dirt into the drain afterwards and you're not gonna have... You know, the powder dried, dried powder to deal with, or D powder to deal with later, because it's just dirt. So the ease of cleaning is something that makes these much better, in my opinion. D filters can be problematic to clean. Then you have to worry about torn grids. You have to worry about, you know, where the D is going. Whereas in a cartridge filter, if you have a good cartridge brand, you can hose those off pretty easily without having to worry about, you know, oh, is there a tear in it? Is it going to leak the E back into
17:35 Speaker 00 the pool? And therein lies another issue with a D filter, and I'll just touch on this briefly, is that if you have any problems with the grids, a tear in the grids, or a crack in the manifold, or the stem pipe O-ring is bad, you're going to get diatomaceous earth back into the pool. And it's a messy thing where you have to vacuum it out. It's coming into the pool all the time. The water's cloudy. Not so with a cartridge filter. You won't have that problem because there's no diatomaceous earth. There's nothing to leak back into the pool through the cartridge filter. If you have a bad cartridge and there's a hole in it, maybe some dirt will get into the pool. It's pretty rare to have a bad cartridge if you change them regularly. And it's something to consider having a three-year cycle with
18:17 Speaker 00 the quad cartridge filters to change them, so that you're always having new cartridges. And as far as the single cartridge filters, of course, you want to change those every, you know, three, six, one-year mark, because those wear out pretty quick in those single cartridges. But you're not going to have to worry about D in the pool, or D in the spa, or if there's air in the line, this happens sometimes with D filter. There's some kind of air problem, and it's getting in the line, and the D filter drains down. And then all the D comes back out to the skimmer, and that leaks into the pool. So that won't happen with a cartridge filter. If there's an air leak somewhere, and the water's draining out of the filter, it's not going to drain dirt back into the pool, because all the dirt sticks into the pleats in the cartridge filter. Whereas in a D
19:02 Speaker 00 filter, a lot of that will come off in the water. I mean, in the filter itself, you have this murky diatomaceous earth water that's there, and that's going to leak back into the pool. So another advantage of the cartridge filter, you have to worry about D leaking. To the pool with a torn grid. And again, they're much easier to clean. The D filters with the top manifold are just a pain to clean. You can take the top manifold off, take the grids out one by one and hose them off. Takes a long time, it's a messy process, whereas the cartridge filter, you know, a single cartridge, you just take it out, hose it off, you're done in three to five minutes. If you have a quad cartridge filter, you can clean it pretty rapidly. There's all kinds of tools out there like the Cyclone Filter Cleaner that helps speed it up.
19:46 Speaker 00 And that's something that I find to be the biggest advantage of a cartridge filter over a D filter is the ease of cleaning a cartridge filter. The fact that it's just dirt being washed off and they're super simple to clean. You just hose off the pleats and that's basically it. There's no need to recharge it with diatomases either, trying to calculate how much DE to put back in. Even when you're backwashing a D filter, you have to recharge it with diatomases earth and that becomes, the filter can become impacted with DE over time. With a cartridge filter, clean all the dirt off of it, put it back in and you're good to go at that point. Would have, not having to worry about anything else after that. And I think one final point is that there's a little bit less maintenance with secondary devices with the cartridge filter.
20:31 Speaker 00 What I mean by this is that with a D filter, you have to maintain the backwash valves. If it's a piston, push-pull piston, you'll have to change the piston every so often, the O-rings. And with a multi-port valve, you have to keep an eye on the spider gasket. With a cartridge filter, since you're not doing any of that, there's no secondary device there to maintain. It's just the cartridge filter, changing the cartridges when you need to and there's no backwash valve to maintain. So another plus, I think, is that there's less on the maintenance side with the cartridge filter. If you're looking for other podcasts that I've recorded, you can find those on my website, swimmingpoollearning.com. On the banner, just click on the podcast icon. That'll take you to a dropdown menu where I have over 1,600 podcasts there.
21:15 Speaker 00 And if you're interested in the coaching program that I offer, you can learn more at poolguycoaching.com. Thanks for listening to this podcast. Have a rest of your week and God bless. This episode is brought to you by Hasa, providing Products that deliver clean, healthy water for every aspect of everyday life. The bottom feeder battery powered vacuum system. Portable, powerful, and only weighs 12 pounds. And Skimmer, Get Skimmer, America's number one pool service software. Podcast listeners can try Skimmer for free at getskimmer.com backslash pool guy.
Previous Aiper Cordless Robotic Pool Cleaners: How Do They Stack Up? Next Frustrating Pool Filter Cleaning Issues Page updated November 15, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated