Pod Insights The Pool Guy Podcast Show Swimming Pool Solar Surface Skimmers – Are They Good? About this episode Send us a textSwimming Pool Solar Powered Surface skimmers are becoming a staple in pool maintenance, but are they as effective as they seem? In this episode, we dive into how pool surface solar-powered skimmers work, their benefits, potential drawbacks, and whether they’re the best option for keeping your pool crystal clear. Tune in as we break down the pros and cons. Support the Pool Guy Podcast Show Sponsors! HASA delivers clean, healthy water solutions. https://bit.ly/HASAhttps://www.orendatech.com/The Bottom Feeder Professional Battery Powered Vacuum System. Save $100 with discount Code: DVB100https://bit.ly/THEBOTTOMFEEDERAnd Skimmer, America’s #1 pool service software! Try Skimmer FREE for 30 days at:https://getskimmer.com/poolguy Thanks for listening and I hope you find the Podcast helpful! For other free resources to further help you:Visit my Website: https://www.swimmingpoollearning.comWatch on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@SPLPodcast Site: https://the-pool-guy-podcast-show.onpodium.com/
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 This episode is brought to you by Hasa. Pool pros, are you using the new Hasa Pro Rewards app? Earn points on Hasa and Orenda purchases, redeem them for gift cards and product rewards. Download the free Hasa Pro Rewards app today and get rewarded by the bottom feeder. With their new cartridge filter assembly, now you can vacuum dirt in a pool down to 10 microns. Don't just vacuum the pool, finish it.
0:27 Speaker 01 This episode is brought to you by Skimmer, the number one pool service software in North America. With Skimmer, you can streamline your schedule, grow your revenue, and keep your customers coming back with five-star service. Whether you're a one-person operation or an established team, Skimmer is your partner in success. Visit getskimmer.com/poolguy to try Skimmer for free for 30 days.
1:05 Speaker 00 Hi, welcome to the Pool Guy Podcast Show. In this episode, I'm going to talk to you about solar surface skimmers for your pool. Are they any good? Are they effective? Should you invest in them? And what is the lifespan of these cleaners? What are some of the drawbacks? I'll cover all of this in this podcast for you. Join my coaching program and take your pool service to the next level. Connect with other pool pros in your area, gain valuable knowledge, and transform your business with personalized, one-on-one advice from me. With over 36 years of experience, I'm here to help you succeed like never before. Learn more at poolguycoaching.com. I'll probably do a follow-up YouTube video where I'll show the different ones that I've tested and reviewed, so that you can get an idea of the different models and their features.
1:49 Speaker 00 So I'll put that out sometime later. But I'll just give you an overview of these surface skimmers and my history with them, which is a long history. In fact, I've been doing reviews of these surface skimmers since they first came on the market. Some of you may remember the SolarBreeze, it was the first solar skimmer that was on the market. It was actually a really good product. Then they came out with the SolarBreeze NX, and I believe there was another model after that. Somewhere in between there, there was the Skim Devil, which I thought was probably the best solar surface skimmer on the market. And then there was the Remington Solar Solar Skimmer, that one didn't last very long. But these solar skimmers have been around for, there was another one too, I'm missing which one that was, I know I reviewed it.
2:34 Speaker 00 But there was a, quite a few of the early generation solar skimmers. I'll give you a rundown of the ones that I've tested recently, or over the last two or three years. The Beta is one that I've tested when it first came out. And it definitely revolutionized these because they're, they, they were able to make him in China at a lower cost than they were being made prior to the Beta coming out. BETTA, the price on these, right now, they're pretty low, they're at, I'm looking right here on Amazon and they're $2.99 right now for, for that particular surface skimmer at this moment.
3:14 Speaker 00 It actually was part of their beta testing for the Beta, and it was one of those tongue twisters. And I was the person that advised them that their motors were insufficient for the pools in America. For some reason, they weren't thinking about saltwater pools. Saltwater is extremely corrosive and they used like these remote control motors when they first came out. And they were not modular, so it was a big mess, the first generation had a lot of failures. They even put out like a bulletin on their sales page saying that these are not made for saltwater pools, which eliminated like a lot of customers. So they're more robust now, of course. And you wouldn't really have a problem with it in a saltwater pool, in my opinion,
4:00 Speaker 00 because they've really fixed that problem. Somewhere in that time period, SolarBreeze kind of sold, or I'm not sure if he sold completely, but Pivot took over, the SolarBreeze company. It did something that I would not advise anyone to do with a product that has a really good branding, and I think SolarBreeze had a great branding. I personally still think some of the early generations of those were the best solar skimmers on the market. They have a very long lifespan. But they went and changed it to the aerial, and I think the color scheme they picked was offsetting to a lot of people. It was like a lime green or bright green and purple mixed together. It just was just flat out ugly, in my opinion.
4:44 Speaker 00 And it had glitches too, because they changed some of the software. So on cloudy days, it would take, after a cloudy day, it would take several days to reboot sometimes. The other controls weren't that great. Sometimes the screen would lock up. So they had some glitches and they had some shipping issues and manufacturing issues also. But the price point was much higher than their competitors, which pretty much put them out of business. They were looking for a buyer. But it's one of those things where, um, maybe someone did buy it and they're waiting to put it out because they also owned the Skimbot. Which I believe was purchased by Dolphin. And let me pull up, let me pull it up here. So I'll give you the, uh, the name of this one here.
5:28 Speaker 00 And so basically the Skimbot was part of Pivot, I believe, and they sold, don't quote me on that. It looks like they sold their design to Matronics. So it's the Dolphin Skimmy Robotic Pool Cleaner. S K I M M I. Now this one here, I think was one of the better designs. I really liked it. One of the problems they had was, that Pivot had was that like a spillway would turn it off because the controller on top was really sensitive. In fact, my son printed these 3D shields that covered the front of these units for them. When they had, when they were the owners of the Skimbot. It actually helped keep the cleaner from turning off from a spillway hitting it. But I really liked the paddles on the side and I think it's a really great cleaner. And when I do my, my comparison video, I'll definitely include
6:14 Speaker 00 the Dolphin Skimmy, but you're gonna see it as kind of the Skimbot version of it, because I don't have the new version. It has a little app control, but I like the, I like how fast it moves and the features of this particular one are really good. So I'm glad that Matronics purchased it and they're keeping that design going. To me, it's a really good solar skimmer. Now there's one on the market that is kind of weird. I can't get my head around it. And I've contacted the company myself as well to get some more details of why it's so expensive for this particular solar skimmer. And it's the Beatbot iSkim Ultra and it sells for fifteen hundred bucks. I mean, that's a pretty steep price for a solar skimmer. It's like, if you do the math,
6:57 Speaker 00 what is that? Five times the cost of one beta? So you can buy five beta units for one. Beatbot, put all five beta units in your pool and you would probably have a pretty clean surface for the cost of this one unit. I'm not sure what makes it superior over the other ones, I haven't tested it yet. It looks pretty robust for sure. And of course, for that kind of price, you're gonna definitely get a good unit. Has a $300 coupon, so I stand corrected, you get one free beta cleaner, I guess, or you only can get four beta cleaners, I should say. Still probably would clean the pool really good, with all those running on the surface. Looking at the reviews on Amazon, let me see if these are all legit.
7:40 Speaker 00 I think they're all verified, some Amazon Vine reviews. So people are actually buying him, there's actually quite a few of the Vine reviews. So the Vine reviews on Amazon, customers get this for free to write a review. It looks like the majority of the reviews here are the Vine reviews. So definitely something to consider, and I don't think many people would be paying for this thing at that price point of $1100 or $1200. It's pretty steep for a solar surface cleaner. I did mention the beta at the beginning, it's a really great unit, I think it's got just about every feature that you're gonna need with these surface cleaners. I really like the ease of getting the debris basket. It also has pretty good tech, there's not a lot of failures.
8:24 Speaker 00 There's a plugin version as well, so if you don't get a lot of sun, you can actually plug it in, and that is a great way to charge it when you don't have a lot of sunlight in your backyard. And they have different colors, white, gray, blue. I kinda like the blue model myself, that's the one that I'm partial towards, but they do have different colored models there. Then you have the iPair Surfer S1, I really like this one too. It's got a sleek design, it's on sale for $299 as well. I think they're competing directly with each other here. There's actually some that are even cheaper or less affordable, I'll cover those as well. I really like this one, the app is kinda useless, so I wouldn't even try working on it, you're gonna have an impossible time installing it, I think.
9:09 Speaker 00 And it does really work well, it has a temperature monitor, but of course you need the app to work for that to work. And it's really made well, I don't really like how the top slides back on it. It just, you need a lot of real estate to open it, and it's not as convenient as just flipping it open. Not sure why they won't with that design. To me, it's not logical, but that's how they went with the design. And it's good. It's just as good, I think, as the Beta. I don't think there's any major difference in the quality of the product. But now they're competing against some that are extremely low priced. And I think I also reviewed the SmoNet. I don't see it here on Amazon. Let me just type it in here. And this is a really good cleaner also. It reminds me more or less
9:54 Speaker 00 of the SolarBreeze cleaner. This is probably the one that looks the most like it, in my opinion, and operates the most like it. And in the center, there's like a little area for a three-inch Trichlor tablet. I didn't mention that in the video. I should have mentioned it. My, my mistake. But there is that thing in the center for a three-inch chlorine tablet like these, uh, the, um, SolarBreeze. I'm getting all mixed up here with all these names of these surface skimmers. It's a little more expensive. It's three hundred and forty or three hundred and thirty. They have a black version. It looks like it has carbon fiber, but I think that's just like a little plastic design. And they have a blue version is the one I reviewed. Pretty good cleaner. It's not too bad. Um, the propellers are just as robust as the other ones.
10:37 Speaker 00 Not a huge fan of the debris tray underneath, but it's, you know, one of those things where I, it wouldn't say it's a deal killer. Any of these would work well. The Beta SC Plus, which is the one you can charge. The Apier Surfer S1 or the SmoNet. To me, they're all pretty good. They're all in that same category of being three hundred dollars surface, surface skimmers. Now, they're competing again, I mentioned, against some that are really inexpensive. I'm not sure of the quality of the other ones because I haven't tested them yet. But definitely there are some that are gonna be a lot cheaper now because the technology is very duplicatable.
11:18 Speaker 00 Here's one. It's called the Solar Powered Automatic Robotic Pool Skimmer Cleaner. It's called, it's the Vita Pool brand. That's just the, kind of the name, description, title. So Vita Pool is forty-one dol- forty-one dollars. I wish it was forty-one dollars. That's forty-one reviews on Amazon. It's one ninety-nine on Amazon, so it's a hundred dollars cheaper than its competitors. It looks pretty good, looks pretty robust. I mean, again, since the technology is something that can be duplicated pretty easily, you're gonna find some pretty low-priced ones. Here's another one for 239. It's got pretty decent reviews. There's even one for 129. I'll click on that one next. I feel like I'm doing an infomercial here, you know? If you order today, you'll get a free set of Ginsu knives. I don't know if you're that old, you remember those things?
12:03 Speaker 00 And this one here is the Bee Gather, Bee Wa Gather. One is 239. So I'll probably stop here, because I'm just like giving you useless leads, I guess. Not really quite useless, because you go on Amazon and see all these cleaners. There are just so many of them, they're just popping up everywhere. It's gotta be a good dozen of them now, out there on the market, competing against each other. Now, are they any good? Well, they do serve a really good purpose. They clean the surface continuously while the sun's hitting them and they're getting a charge. And even afterwards, they have a battery that holds the charge. I like them, because they're gonna keep the pool surface really clean. And, you know, the only time they're gonna not get a leaf or leaf debris is when it's right on the edge
12:46 Speaker 00 of the pool against the tile, because they're not really designed to scrape the side of the pool. It would be logical, although the BeeBot might have that technology, because it looks like it has like these brushes on the side. So that might do that, might like rub the sides and get the debris off the tiles. I always thought SolarBreeze would come out with something like that. And, you know, it would be logical to put like brushes on the side of these cleaners. And I'm probably giving them an idea, but it would be smart to put like a brush on the side so it can brush the tiles as it's going by and kind of scrape off leaf debris. But as far as debris in the center, or there's a little bit outside off of the tile, it's gonna pick it up great. And you're gonna also have the really fine particles being picked up by this.
13:32 Speaker 00 It does a better job than your skimmer, because it actually moves to the debris, where the skimmer has to wait for the debris to get close to it. A lot of pools aren't set up correctly for the debris to be pushed to the skimmer, and the skimmer only gets certain debris. So it does make the pool Look great, I think, in my opinion. There are a few drawbacks. I'll go over those right now. One is the longevity of these things. Since they're in the pool and they're getting hit by the sun all day, you're not going to get a huge amount of life out of these cleaners. In fact, my first Beda model lasted a little over a year and a half. Actually, the very first one lasted less than a year because it had the bad motors.
14:14 Speaker 00 But the second one that I got lasted about a year and a half before the sun wore out the solar panels and it wasn't charging anymore. I think the newer models are more robust. But if you get two years out of this, or two seasons out of one of these things, you're pretty fortunate. I don't think you would want to replace the parts in them because they're really, there's not really much to them. You would just get another one. And if the prices keep dropping like this, it would be pretty affordable to get one of these and just replace it every two years. Another issue that you may run into with these is that they're not really made to work in conjunction with automatic cleaner hoses. If you have suction pool cleaner hoses in the pool, or even a pressure cleaner, but pressure cleaner probably a little bit better. The suction cleaner hoses tend to stop the progress of these
15:00 Speaker 00 and is is one of those things where it can't navigate past the hoses sometimes while it's running. And so it kind of defeats it a little bit, the hoses in the pool. The SolarBreeze is really good about getting around the hoses. That was the one that had, I think, the best technology. But of course, they don't make that anymore. So there's a couple of things you can do. One, you can actually get some hose weights, and I've done this before. Just buy the cleaner hose weights and put them strategically on the hoses so that it sinks down about six inches under the water. Just a few sections of hoses is all you're going to need to weigh down. And that will give this cleaner a path across the pool without hitting those suction hoses. And it's really simple and easy.
15:42 Speaker 00 And you just get the the hose weights from wherever you want to get them, Amazon or your supplier. Put them on the, a few hose sections, and that will sink the automatic cleaner hose down a little bit in the water. It won't really affect the cleaner at all, in my opinion. I've done this with many cleaners and they're perfectly Fine. So a little trick, if you have suction side, if you have a suction side cleaner in the pool while you're operating this. Another thing is that they tend to get pulled into the skimmer. The solar breeze was pretty good because you can add weights to it. And you can use that tablet holder on the side to put rocks in there, which I've done. And that lowers solar breeze down in the water, just enough sometimes to keep it from getting sucked in the skimmer.
16:24 Speaker 00 Or you can raise the water level higher in your pool so that there's no opportunity for this to get stuck in the skimmer. And then, of course, the third thing you can do is get a swimming pool noodle and cut it. And put it in front of the skimmer as like grates on a sewer or maybe jail bars, however you want to look at it. Put one or two noodles in there and that will make the, that will allow the cleaner to bounce off of the front and keep going. I also tie a trichlor tablet holder, even if you're not using trichlor tablets, in front of the skimmer. And that seems to do the trick sometimes to keep it from getting sucked in the skimmer. Or you can run your pool later in the evening and have this thing running in the daytime, however you want to do it.
17:08 Speaker 00 But the skimmer does pose a problem for these cleaners because of the fact that, you know, it's more powerful than the motors on these can pull out of there. And so it may get sucked in there and it'll be sitting there all day inside the skimmer, in the, in the front of the skimmer. And I think the last problem now is that since there's been an explosion of these things, there's just so many of them to choose from. I mean, I'm counting them here on Amazon right now, just looking at them and they're, two, three, four, five. There's, there's 10 of them right here on this page here in the solar skimmer. And there's probably more kind of stuck in there, uh, if you search deeper into Amazon. So, you know, it's one of those things where this is probably the golden age of surface skimmers. And I'm pretty sure that the major manufacturers would be making one.
17:51 Speaker 00 Since Dolphin has one, kind of has one, they bought the rights to it, but it is a Dolphin branded one now, the Skimmy. I would imagine that Polaris is going to make one to compete with it directly. And it'll probably be more robust and a better made machine than these ones, these low priced ones. So if you were thinking About getting a surface skimmer, I think now is your chance to get one because there's just so much choice out there. And this season, going forward into the next season, I think you're gonna have a lot of selection of these things. There was a day where there was really nothing on the market but the Solar Breeze and the Skim Devil. And then you had a few other ones come on the market. And then you had the Ariel pretty much by itself. It had the whole market.
18:35 Speaker 00 It just didn't market it correctly and the color scheme to me was awful. But you as a consumer and as a pool service provider have a great selection of these now. And I would not hesitate to buy the three that I mentioned. The Apeer Surfer S1, the Beta and the SmoNet. I've tested all those myself and I can vouch for them that they're actually really good. And also the Dolphin Skimmy or the Skimbot would be a great choice as well. Looking for other podcasts I've recorded, you can find those on my website. Just click on the podcast icon on the banner. That'll take you to a dropdown menu. Of about sixteen hundred podcasts you'd listen to at your leisure.
19:17 Speaker 00 And if you're interested in the coaching program that I offer, you can learn more at poolguycoaching.com. Thanks for listening to this podcast. Have a great rest of your week and God bless. This episode is brought to you by Hasa, providing products that deliver clean, healthy water for every aspect of everyday life. The Bottom Feeder Battery Powered Vacuum System, portable, powerful, and only weighs 12 pounds. And Skimmer, Get Skimmer America's number one pool service software. Podcast listeners can try Skimmer for free at getskimmer.com backslash pool guy.
Previous Lessons from the Future: What I’d Do Differently in My Pool Business Next Branding Your Pool Business to Dominate Your Market Page updated November 15, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated