Pod Insights The Pool Guy Podcast Show Saltwater vs. Chlorine Pools – Which One is Better? About this episode Send us a textThinking about switching to a saltwater pool, or just wondering which option is better for you? In this episode, I break down the key differences between saltwater and traditional chlorine pools, including maintenance, costs, water feel, and overall performance. I’ll also debunk some common myths and help you determine which system best fits your lifestyle and budget. If you've ever wondered about the pros and cons of salt vs. chlorine, this episode has the answers! Support the Pool Guy Podcast Show Sponsors! HASA delivers clean, healthy water solutions. https://bit.ly/HASAhttps://www.orendatech.com/The Bottom Feeder Professional Battery Powered Vacuum System. Save $100 with discount Code: DVB100https://bit.ly/THEBOTTOMFEEDERAnd Skimmer, America’s #1 pool service software! Try Skimmer FREE for 30 days at:https://getskimmer.com/poolguy Thanks for listening and I hope you find the Podcast helpful! For other free resources to further help you:Visit my Website: https://www.swimmingpoollearning.comWatch on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@SPLPodcast Site: https://the-pool-guy-podcast-show.onpodium.com/
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 This episode is brought to you by Hasa. Pool pros, are you using the new Hasa Pro Rewards app? Earn points on Hasa and Orenda purchases, redeem them for gift cards and product rewards. Download the free Hasa Pro Rewards app today and get rewarded by the bottom feeder. With their new cartridge filter assembly, now you can vacuum dirt in a pool down to 10 microns. Don't just vacuum the pool, finish it.
0:27 Speaker 01 This episode is brought to you by Skimmer, the number one pool service software in North America. With Skimmer, you can streamline your schedule, grow your revenue, and keep your customers coming back with five-star service. Whether you're a one-person operation or an established team, Skimmer is your partner in success. Visit getskimmer.com/poolguy to try Skimmer for free for 30 days.
1:05 Speaker 00 Hi, welcome to the Pool Guy Podcast Show. In this episode, I'm going to compare a saltwater pool or a pool with a saltwater generator to a pool without one if you're going to use chlorine. So I guess this is a saltwater pool versus chlorine pool podcast. I'll go over the pros and cons of both, and you can make an educated decision of which way you want to go with your primary sanitizer, either the saltwater generator or chlorine. Join my coaching program and take your pool service to the next level. Connect with other pool pros in your area, gain valuable knowledge, and transform your business with personalized one-on-one advice from me. With over 36 years of experience, I'm here to help you succeed like never before. Learn more at poolguycoaching.com.
1:48 Speaker 00 Of course, a saltwater generator does produce chlorine and injects it into the pool. So it is technically a chlorine pool. What I'm trying to kind of divide here or give pros and cons of is using chlorine, as in liquid chlorine, Calhypo.
2:07 Speaker 00 Trichlorotubus, dichlor, any kind of chlorine you're gonna manually add to the pool versus a saltwater generator pool, or saltwater pool where the salt is made at the poolside and you're not using these products. So, of course, the first thing is how to kind of define these pools. So I think a chlorine pool should be defined as a traditional system of using chlorine, liquid tablets or granular chlorine, to sanitize the water. Why do you need the water sanitized? Well, there's a lot of stuff that can be in the water that can be harmful if you're swimming in it. If you think about it like this, and logically think about a pool, a pool is an unnatural body of water. If you look at a lake, or a pond,
2:51 Speaker 00 or any kind of body of water that's natural, there's some flow to it, there's of course algae in it, there could be bacteria in it as well. And if you're gonna be swimming in your backyard pool, you wanna make it as free and clean as possible. And so we use sanitizer to kill pathogens, viruses, bacteria, whatever can be found in the natural environment in the water. And that's why backyard pools usually look blue. They can be green, of course, if they're neglected, and they can turn green very quickly as well. And you don't have mosquito larvae swimming in a blue pool, or a clear pool that's sanitized properly. So that's kind of why we need a sanitizer.
3:33 Speaker 00 So back to that, a chlorine pool, I'm gonna say is a traditional system of adding chlorine to the pool, where a saltwater pool basically uses a saltwater chlorine generator, saltwater chlorinator to convert salt into chlorine. It's kind of how they make liquid chlorine at the factory, except it's being made right there in your pool's backyard. So a saltwater pool is not a traditional pool, because you don't have to add the chlorine to the pool, but it is sanitizing the pool with almost the same exact, or I should say, very similar to liquid chlorine if you're going to compare two chlorine types. It's most similar to liquid chlorine than calhypo, or trichlorotubus, or dichlor. So what are the
4:17 Speaker 00 Pros and cons of a saltwater pool versus a traditional chlorine pool. I would say that a saltwater pool, some people say that the water feels softer. And of course, there's lower maintenance with a saltwater pool. And you're not adding the harsh chemicals. You don't have to purchase them, put them in your backyard. Which is nice. You don't have chlorine laying around all over the place. You don't have to go to the pool store. You're not spending money on chlorine during the season. Which is a significant savings, but as I always say with a saltwater generator. It's not going to be cheaper to go with a saltwater generator in the season over a chlorine pool. For a number of reasons, but I'll touch on that maybe later when I talk about the costs and the pros and cons.
5:02 Speaker 00 Now, as far as a chlorine pool, of course, it's going to be a lower initial cost because you're not going to be buying the saltwater generator and having installed. So that's going to save you, you know, fifteen hundred to two thousand dollars to start right there. The maintenance, I think, is something that you're going to, of course, have to manually take care of either through a pool service or yourself adding chemicals to the pool. And this is something that, of course, you're going to have to buy the chemicals if you're doing it yourself. Go to the pool store, bring it back, store it there and use it. These can be pretty harsh chemicals. And a lot of times, people don't want to deal with this. They just hire a pool pro
5:44 Speaker 00 to do either a chemical-only service, which is a good idea, by the way, if you are a do-it-yourself kind of person and you like maintaining the pool, but you don't really want to deal with the chemistry or adding chemicals. Hire a pool service as a chemical-only stop and they can go there, check the chemicals, balance it. Add what's needed and take it in their truck with them. So there's no chemicals in your backyard. So that's a kind of happy medium between a saltwater generator and a traditional chlorine pool. If you have a pool service that can add the chemicals for you. There's no storage in your backyard and it's one of those things where it makes your life easier and it's fairly affordable to have chemical-only service versus a full-service stop for the pool professional. So that's an option.
6:27 Speaker 00 That's kind of in the middle there. Of course, a lot of people don't have time to do their own pool. So they'll just kind of let the pool service company do everything for them, which is perfectly fine as well. Let me focus on one con, I think, with one particular chlorine type, and that is trichlor tablets. And I'm just gonna focus on the odor of the trichlor tablets. Be careful when you're using these or your storm. If any water gets on them, it turns into basically mustard gas because there is cyanatic acid in there. When you have cyanatic acid or acid mixed with chlorine, you're going to have, and water, I should say, that's an important element. Don't want to forget that. In a closed environment, like if you have the lid partially open, it rains and gets wet.
7:10 Speaker 00 And then you close the lid, you open that lid again, you're gonna have similar chemical compound to mustard gas, which can be overpowering, could cause lung damage and, you know, could almost knock you out. I've had, I've had experience with this where I just couldn't catch my breath after being exposed to this. So that's one hazard with a chlorine pool versus a saltwater pool where you wouldn't have that problem. Liquid chlorine is pretty benign. There's not an odor to it and it's pretty safe. Calhypo, the same thing, but any trichlor product, either the trichlor granular, trichlor tablets or trichlor shock, it's going to have a very strong chemical odor. I wouldn't say liquid chlorine and calhypo would have that problem.
7:54 Speaker 00 But of course, trichlor will have that odor problem. And I guess since I'm touching on some side effects, I should also mention this, that every chemical has a byproduct. So for calhypo, you have calcium added to the pool. For trichlor and diachlor, you're adding cyanatic acids to the pool. And for liquid chlorine, you're adding salt to the pool. Of course, the saltwater generator uses salt to make the chlorine. And you're going to have salt as the main byproduct of the saltwater generator. Let's break down some costs here. I'm just gonna use trichlor as my example here so that you can get an idea of some cost breaks down. Let's say you're using trichlor as one of your sanitizers and you get a 50 pound bucket for $200, which is Pretty fair in the market right now.
8:39 Speaker 00 That 50 pound bucket probably should last you at least a season and a half or two seasons based on your pool size. And then you're going to supplement that with either Calhypo or liquid chlorine. I mentioned the byproducts. You don't want to exclusively use Trichlor. Because you're adding way too much cyanatic acid to the water at that point. So you want to do a 50 50, probably half Trichlor. Half liquid chlorine or Calhypo. Liquid chlorine is preferred in my area because of the price and because it's highly effective. It is one of the strongest forms of chlorine out there at 12.5%. If you're getting the Hossa returnables. They're at 12.5%. Um, in their strength, it's kind of hard to compare powder to liquid.
9:21 Speaker 00 But just note that one gallon of liquid chlorine is stronger than one pound of Calhypo. Calhypo used to be really affordable and inexpensive, but the price has of course gone up tremendously. So it's not probably going to be your lowest cost sanitizer. Of course, in Florida. In some states, liquid chlorine definitely is really inexpensive and it's the way to go. So if you're looking at pure costs. Trichlor tablets and liquid chlorine would be my combination to sanitize the pool. And I would say, let's just say you're spending, you know, you spend $200 for the bucket of tablets. Let's just break that in half. So it's a hundred dollars.
10:00 Speaker 00 For that season and then liquid chlorine, let's just say you're spending, I don't know, $30 a month for liquid chlorine. And then you could of course, put that in the pool and use that and. You're, you're spending maybe a hundred, um, let's see, 30 times, let's say five months. So that's $250 for your sanitizer. And then you have the admiric acid. Let's just add another $60 for that. So maybe $300 would be the cost for that season. And let's just take that over five years, just to be fair to the saltwater generator. So. That's $1,500 over five years.
10:40 Speaker 00 Saltwater generator, I think you can probably get one for that price roughly installed. So right there is five years. Worth just for the saltwater generator. Sometimes it's going to be a little more to install depending on the size of the saltwater generator, what it's rated for. And of course, the installation process itself, how complicated it is, which brand you're getting. But I'm just gonna say fifteen hundred, just to be fair. So it would take about five years if you're doing yourself and you have, let's just say, a, you know, fourteen thousand gallon pool. That's a pretty fair amount of chemicals you're using in Southern California for that pool. So five years with the chemicals with the saltwater generator. And then you may want to do this, you may not want to.
11:22 Speaker 00 You may want to add the cost of the replacement cell, depending on the system, it could be anywhere from six hundred to even over a thousand dollars for the cell to replace it after. I would say four years would be fair. So let's just say the saltwater generator after four years costs you, I'm gonna say the cell was eight hundred. So that's twenty, uh, eight hundred, fifteen hundred plus eight hundred, twenty-three hundred dollars. For in a, in a four-year mark with the saltwater generator. You're still above what it would cost for the chlorine pool. And maybe over the course of ten years, it would even out, I'm not sure if that's even gonna, gonna happen at that point.
12:02 Speaker 00 The chemical costs are gonna, of course, go up every year slightly, and the saltwater generator costs will also go up every year as well with inflation. So it's kind of a wash at that point. So there is no initial savings with the saltwater generator. There is maybe a break-even point somewhere down the road. I'm not sure where, if you want to calculate that, you can do that. But the cost of a chlorine, traditional chlorine pool is much less to maintain than a saltwater generator or a salt pool for that reason. Plus you have to add salt occasionally, depending on your area. Sometimes a lot of salt, sometimes a little bit of salt, so there is some cost involved in that with adding salt to the pool.
12:43 Speaker 00 Something that's not talked about often is the corrosiveness of a saltwater pool. Now, the certain salt level, I think, is pretty safe and benign. But when a salt level gets above forty-five hundred parts per million, it Can cause some corrosion of the pool equipment. Specifically, some heater parts, some check valve parts can be corroded. And there are some restrictions on draining a saltwater pool. Ironically, in Los Angeles County, you're not allowed to drain a saltwater pool into the storm drain, which is going into the ocean. I'm not sure why that is, but that's one of their restrictions. And we have something called the Coastal Commission here that kind of supersedes the city.
13:28 Speaker 00 And I think that's kind of weird that you can't drain a saltwater pool into somewhere where it's going into the ocean, which is a body of salt water. Anyway, that's just a little side note. But some cities won't let you drain a saltwater pool. You can drain a saltwater pool into the sewer system in your backyard, so that's perfectly fine, which doesn't make a lot of sense to me either. But basically, you have to check to make sure you can drain a saltwater pool legally in your area. And some people, some areas, some high-end areas may even require you to pump it out with tanks, which would be weird as well. There are some corrosion aspects of saltwater pools, so just be aware of that.
14:09 Speaker 00 As far as a chlorine pool, there really isn't much of a corrosion issue with one exception. If you're using Trichlor tablets as your only sanitizer and you're overusing them, the pH of the tablet is like around two. And if you're using, let's just give this example that you have a fourteen thousand gallon pool and you're putting six tablets in the floater. Can you put six tablets in a floater? You could probably squeeze in five and maybe, you know, wedge the sixth one in there. They do make larger floaters, so you can logically do that. So you can put five or six tablets in a floater, let's just say. And if you're floating those every week, I would imagine the pH in that pool is going to be dropping down significantly
14:54 Speaker 00 to a point where it may even be below seven, six point eight in pH, which could cause corrosion. So you can actually cause corrosion if you overuse. Trichlor is your primary sanitizer. You wouldn't have that problem with liquid chlorine or Calhypo. There really isn't any kind of acid in there. In fact, the pH of Calhypo is around 12. Liquid chlorine pH is higher as well than Trichlor. So be aware that you can actually cause corrosion as well with a chlorine you're manually adding to the pool. It's not just saltwater generator. But I don't think it's going to corrode the deck of the pool, the saltwater generator I'm speaking of, or a lot of equipment unless you're over,
15:35 Speaker 00 you know, 4,500 or 5,000 parts per million of salt in the pool. Let me talk a little bit about convenience factor, which is the primary reason why you wouldn't want to go to a saltwater pool. Now, there, things could happen to saltwater pool that could cause problems as well. And it's not kind of just set it and forget it. You have to adjust the output. You have to make sure the salt cell is clean and you have to make sure everything is running properly and you have the proper runtime of the salt system and the runtime of the pool. So there are these factors that could cause the saltwater system not to produce chlorine, much like you not adding chlorine to a chlorine pool. But in most cases, if the saltwater generator is being maintained by a pool professional
16:17 Speaker 00 or if you're on top of it yourself as a do it yourself homeowner, you're not going to have too many issues where the chlorine is not being produced in the pool or not holding in the pool water. With a chlorine pool, this is where the problems arise. You could have a problem with not adding chlorine when you should add it or need to add it, which causes a multitude of problems to happen very rapidly in the summertime. The water could start developing algae. It could also get cloudy, which requires more and more chlorine to be added to kind of break that effect. And this gets really expensive. So I, I mentioned earlier that if you're just maintaining the pool with Trichlorine, Liquid Chlorine, and the pool is blue and clear
17:02 Speaker 00 and you're doing a great job maintaining it, or if you have a pool service maintaining the pool using just chlorine, that's perfectly fine. You shouldn't have too many issues with the pool having algae or turning green in that case. But if the pool does get cloudy... If it does get chloramines or if it does turn green, then you're spending a lot of money to correct that with chlorine products, algaecides, things of that nature. So the cost of a chlorine pool can compound and get more expensive. I'll give you an example. I took over this account and they were having a lot of trouble maintaining this pool. The first problem was they were overusing trichlorotabol, so of course the cyanic acid level was really high. And to counter that, a partial drain was needed.
17:46 Speaker 00 But the amount of chemicals that were stored at this pool was mind boggling. I wish I took a photo of it. There was at least two 50 pound buckets of trichlor. Then there was a bucket of powdered granular Kyle hypo. They had these Home Depot liquid chlorine cases or boxes scattered about. I would say there was a good, you know, back then it was a little less expensive, but a good 600 or 700 dollars worth of chlorine, which in today's dollars would be over a thousand dollars of chlorine products back there. Just to maintain this pool in the summertime. And it was kind of crazy that they were putting so much chlorine in there. And there was a lot of factors that they weren't aware of. And when I took over the pool, I corrected a lot of that.
18:30 Speaker 00 And got everything back in shape and the chlorine uses dropped dramatically down to about 5% of what they were actually using in their pool every week to try to keep it balanced. So that's kind of the other end of a chlorine pool is that if things get out of hand, which they can rapidly get out of hand, you're spending a lot of money to correct that. Whereas with a salt pool, since it's putting chlorine in there every day, and if you set it correctly, you're going to have a good free chlorine level all the time. You're not going to have these problems where you're adding a ton of chlorine or algaecide products to the pool to bring it back into shape because technically it shouldn't get out of shape and turn green or get cloudy on you. If it's being maintained correctly and the system is working.
19:13 Speaker 00 So the convenience factor is something where the saltwater generator has the definite edge over a chlorine pool. You don't have to worry about adding the chemicals to the pool. All you have to do is set this the generator to produce. Chlorine and they come on and do that. And the chlorine pool is something that requires more maintenance. And of course, if you have a pool pro, they can either take care of your pool with a saltwater generator and make sure it's operating correctly each week. Or add the proper amount of chlorine to the pool to maintain that pool. That's why I mentioned earlier that in the least, a chemical only service would be a great idea. If you're unsure of how to balance your chlorine pool. And I think the saltwater pool does have that convenience factor that wins over
19:57 Speaker 00 a chlorine pool and costs, putting all costs aside, if you are someone who's looking for convenience and want to have your pool swim ready all the time. A saltwater pool would not be a bad choice for you. But if you're budget conscious and if you don't mind adding the chlorine or having a company do it for you. Then a chlorine pool is perfectly fine as well. There's no really, there's nothing that I can say that would say that a saltwater pool is better than a chlorine pool. And I don't think a chlorine pool necessarily is better than a saltwater pool. I think it's all based on your circumstance, your can, your level of convenience. And what you want to actually do and how you want to maintain your pool with the proper sanitizer each week.
20:42 Speaker 00 Looking for other podcasts that I've recorded, you can find those on my website, swimmingforlearning.com. On the banner, click on the podcast icon. There'll be a menu of other podcasts I've recorded. And if you're interested in the coaching program that I offer, you can learn more at poolguycoaching.com. Thanks for listening to this podcast. Have a good rest of your week and God bless. This episode is brought to you by Hasa, providing products that deliver clean, healthy water for every aspect of everyday life. The bottom feeder battery powered vacuum system, portable, powerful, and only weighs 12 pounds. And Skimmer, Get Skimmer, America's number one pool service software. Podcast listeners can try Skimmer for free at getskimmer.com backslash pool guy.
Previous Leaky Equipment Pads? Here’s How to Fix Them! Next Ultimate Pool Tools Titan Aluminum Pole Compared to Other Brand Poles Page updated November 15, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated