Pod Insights The Pool Guy Podcast Show Dead Pool Products About this episode Send us a textDive into a fascinating journey through the history of swimming pool products as I explore the ones that have come and gone over the years. In this video, I’ll uncover the stories behind products that didn’t stand the test of time, examining why they failed to make a lasting impact. From innovative ideas that couldn’t quite deliver to trends that faded away, I’ll break down the challenges and missteps that led to their downfall. Support the Pool Guy Podcast Show Sponsors! HASA delivers clean, healthy water solutions. https://bit.ly/HASAhttps://www.orendatech.com/The Bottom Feeder Professional Battery Powered Vacuum System. Save $100 with discount Code: DVB100https://bit.ly/THEBOTTOMFEEDERAnd Skimmer, America’s #1 pool service software! Try Skimmer FREE for 30 days at:https://getskimmer.com/poolguy Thanks for listening and I hope you find the Podcast helpful! For other free resources to further help you:Visit my Website: https://www.swimmingpoollearning.comWatch on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@SPLPodcast Site: https://the-pool-guy-podcast-show.onpodium.com/
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 This episode is brought to you by Hasa. Pool pros, are you using the new Hasa Pro Rewards app? Earn points on Hasa and Orenda purchases, redeem them for gift cards and product rewards. Download the free Hasa Pro Rewards app today and get rewarded by the bottom feeder. With their new cartridge filter assembly, now you can vacuum dirt in a pool down to 10 microns. Don't just vacuum the pool, finish it.
0:27 Speaker 01 This episode is brought to you by Skimmer, the number one pool service software in North America. With Skimmer, you can streamline your schedule, grow your revenue, and keep your customers coming back with five-star service. Whether you're a one-person operation or an established team, Skimmer is your partner in success. Visit getskimmer.com/poolguy to try Skimmer for free for 30 days.
1:05 Speaker 00 Hi, and welcome to the Pool Guy Podcast Show. In this episode, I'm going to go over some pool products that have died over the last couple of years, or the last few years. I'll touch on some reasons why they died, and some reasons why you may miss these particular products, I guess. And I'll go over, of course, why products fail in general in the pool service industry. Join my coaching program and take your pool service to the next level. Connect with other pool pros in your area, gain valuable knowledge, and transform your business with personalized one-on-one advice from me. With over 36 years of experience, I'm here to help you succeed like never before. Learn more at poolguycoaching.com. The pool service industry is a specialty industry.
1:49 Speaker 00 If you've ever been to Sherman Williams, it's like a paint store. And if you do any painting, you know that Sherman Williams is probably one of the best brands of paint. But if you go in there, you'll see little items there that someone's created. There was one that I saw that was really cool where you could put it on your faucet and hang paint brushes so they dry after you rinse them off. That was pretty nice. Whether that's going to succeed or not, just depends on who buys that product in the store. Since this is a specialty market, people are going to be walking in, they're looking for it. The same goes for pool products. Now, it doesn't seem like a specialty industry because there's, you know, millions of pools out there. But it really is because there are some well-established products that have years of longevity.
2:33 Speaker 00 You know, all the customers call the cleaners creepy crawly still because Pentair had dominated everything back in the 90s and everything is a creepy crawly kind of in a way. The Hayward Navigator has been around forever and is still in pools. So the well-established products have an edge over anything that's trying to break into the market. I'll start with failures by redesign. When something is not broken, you don't want to try to fix it. That's kind of like the golden rule of any business. And the product that I really liked and I thought was highly effective was a product that goes onto the skimmer basket and accelerates the speed of the water being pulled in. Now, there's been several attempts at this product.
3:15 Speaker 00 The best one I thought ever made was the Skim Doctor 2.0. Now, the Skim Doctor 1.0 wasn't too bad, it just wasn't highly adjustable. So if you had a 1.5 horsepower or 2 horsepower single speed pump, there would be just too much vortex or create too much of a vortex and cause air to get into the pump and cause it to decavitate. And this means that the product actually worked highly effectively. So what the Skim Doctor was supposed to do was accelerate the water being pulled into the skimmer. It was highly effective. It's kind of like the Hayward, was it the B37, B38 basket with the float. It's a great way to pull water into the skimmer at a rapid rate and increase the surface skimming.
4:00 Speaker 00 So the Skim Doctor 1.0 wasn't too bad. There was a few things they had to work on. I worked kind of closely with the people that ran that one. It was actually owned by a former NFL player, I believe. Not owned by him, but maybe he partnered with him, put some money into it. Really nice guy. And it was a product that had legs and it was going places. And then they came out with the 2.0 version, which improved the 1.0 version. Because then you can adjust the size of it, close it off to make sure you're not pulling too much water in. It was highly effective even with a higher horsepower pump. And I thought that was perfect. There's no reason to change it. It's working, it's selling, people are buying it, and it was an effective product.
4:44 Speaker 00 It was like a four-star product on Amazon. There was a few things, of course, that people didn't like. The fact you had to put it on the basket. It was not the easiest thing to install. It was a hard thing to kind of put on sometimes. And it was fairly universal, I thought, with all the skimmer baskets. All in all, it was a good product, again, a four-star product. And then, for some reason, not sure why, they redesigned it. And now it's the skim doctor 3.0. And they pretty much ruined the complete design of the 2.0. They made it again without being adjusted. The slits are cut kind of at a weird angle. I'm not sure if an engineer got a hold of it and said this would be better. But there's no way to adjust the tops to let or slow the flow down.
5:29 Speaker 00 And it's now a 2.9-star product, so it's not effective. They basically took a product that was highly effective, worked, actually worked as it was supposed to, and made it back into an ineffective product. Now, why would you do something like that? I'm not sure why they would do something like that. Maybe they were cutting costs and it was cheaper to make this particular model. It doesn't look like it would work anyway, just by the picture that you see there. I haven't tested it because from the reviews, people say it doesn't work. So I don't understand why a company would take a product, go back to the drawing board when things were working. The only thing that I would have, would have liked to have seen with the skim doctor 2.0 is maybe one more slot to adjust.
6:12 Speaker 00 So I would have added another slot on it near the bottom, where you can kind of open it, kind of like the floater for the tablets, where you can like turn the bottom, the three-inch tablet floaters. You can open it and close it to kind of let, you know, let more water in or close off the tablet feeder. That's what I would have liked on the 2.0. I would have liked the slot on the side where you can even open it a little bit more to let more flow in. Because still, for the two-horsepower pump, the 2.0 version, you couldn't adjust it enough sometimes to make it effective. To redesign it and to go away with something that worked perfectly fine is not logical. So I don't recommend the skim doctor and the company took a great product and really went backwards with it.
6:53 Speaker 00 It kind of ruined the whole brand of the skim doctor skimmer product or the, you know, I don't know what they would call it, but the skimming accelerator product. Another skimmer of sorts would be the solar breeze. Now, the solar breeze was the first surface solar powered surface cleaner that was out there. It was actually a pretty well-designed cleaner. Now, there's a few problems with the original solar breeze unit. One, the control panel on top didn't have the greatest water seal. So if it rained really hard in your area or if this, if the solar breeze went underneath a waterfall or water feature, it could cause a short in that control panel on top. They fixed that problem. The other problem was that there were some pretty small components in there.
7:36 Speaker 00 So if you ever took one apart and tried to fix it, there was no way you could fix it yourself. So you have to send the solar breeze into the factory. They would readjust it and put new parts in for it. I think at one point they sold like a rebuild kit for like a hundred and fifty dollars, but it was impossible to put in. The parts were just really hard to work with. You had to, you know, be a former Radio Shack employee to actually do anything with it. And then, of course, they discontinued the solar breeze, which I really thought was a great product in the form that was it was in. And came out with the aerial. I believe the company was merged or sold to a company called Pivot. And then they came out with the aerial. Now, there was nothing really wrong with the aerial itself. Well, there was a few glitches with it. I should state those.
8:22 Speaker 00 One glitch that they had was that sometimes if it was cloudy out for three or four days, the aerial wouldn't charge up or wouldn't turn itself back on. You had to go out there and manually reset it. It was kind of a pain. I think they fixed that. That was not a problem after the first generation. I think the biggest problem was it was just ugly. I mean, they changed the color scheme, had like this neon green color scheme that was really off-putting. I mean, if you have a pool that you spent two hundred thousand dollars on and it's a beautiful blue colored pebble. Tech and you want something in there to clean the surface, you would not put the aerial in there. It just was an ugly looking cleaner, although it was effective. I think the paddle was purple. I think I have one in my backyard. I probably should look at it, see the color scheme.
9:05 Speaker 00 It just was not the greatest design change. I think the solar breeze was perfect. If I was advising them, I would have told them to make it gray or make it pure white or something that's going to be attractive to the consumer. And they didn't ask me for my advice, of course, and the company just was going in the wrong direction. It was really expensive too, like $500 for the unit. They were coming from China and they were like super expensive still. And I think the company just didn't pivot correctly when the betta came on the market. Now, I don't know who chose that name, the betta. I always think beta, like beta testing, but it was called the betta, B E T T A. It was one of the first competitors to the aerial that hit the market and it was a lot less expensive.
9:48 Speaker 00 It probably wasn't as well made at in the first generations. I can tell you that, that there were some failures with the propellers, but it was less expensive and it started cutting into the sales of the aerial. And then I think they tried to sell the aerial, their pivot. I got an email saying they were for sale. If I knew anyone that wanted to buy it, it's just one of those things where it just snowballed out of control and they kept losing money. The unit was too high priced. You had the betta coming out competing and the betta improved and they were able to redesign the propellers and fix that. And then at some point, I think over the last two years, you have the smonet. You also have the A Pier Surfer. Then you have the Beatbot Surface Cleaner. There's a couple of other ones I'm leaving off here. It just kind of flooded the market with the solar power surface cleaners
10:33 Speaker 00 and the aerial cannot get its footing. What's kind of ironic is that they also owned a skimbot, which I thought was a superior surface cleaner to the aerial. And if I was advising the company, I would have scrapped the aerial completely and put all the funding into the skimbot. And I really think that the skimbot was sold to Matronics because they have one, Matronics Dolphin Skimmer Automated Solar Power Robot Skimmer. And I see this for sale on Different sites and it's Matronics, I think, bought the Skinbot, which again was a much superior design than the Aerial, much better color scheme, and they should have put all their money into that particular product, which they didn't.
11:16 Speaker 00 So I think a failure point here would be not seeing the competitors on the horizon, and not going with another product you had that was better. And then really not changing your design so drastically. They went from the SolarBreeze, which looked nice, to the Aerial, which in my opinion was, looks like an 80s product, which is an ugly color scheme, not very well made. I'll touch on another product here, and this is the Hayward Fin Smart Monitor. Now, this actually was a really successful smart monitor. They first came out with it, and I thought it was a pretty good concept. It would do your ORP, which would give you kind of like a chlorine reading. It's kind of confusing.
11:57 Speaker 00 ORP is not something in the US that we use a lot, except for in commercial settings in some cases. Some of the feeders use ORP, the automatic chlorine feeders, but it's not something that is really, that really caught on here. You also have pH, which it did. It also did water temperature. So it was actually a very limited smart monitor. Didn't do alkalinity, not like the WaterGuru Sense 2, where it does, you know, the parameters that are important, chlorine, pH, alkalinity, cyanic acid. This one didn't do all that, but you know, it was like $150. It wasn't terrible to get the ORP, which kind of gives you like the free chlorine reading in a way. And pH, it also had the ability, you could take a picture of a test strip,
12:40 Speaker 00 and then it would give you recommendations for those other readings, the alkalinity, the total hardness, things like that. Wasn't a bad product, and it was actually pretty affordable. I think it was down to like $150 for the unit. And then there was like a $99 subscription fee a year, which I think was probably the deal killer for a lot of people. So Hayward bought the Fin from its parent company for like $25 million or $50 million, something like that. It was an astronomical amount of money. And their advertising or the marketing was all wrong. Marketing was that with the fin, you're going to replace your pool service provider, which I think is something that is going to turn, well, it's something that wasn't true because you're only getting pH and ORP.
13:25 Speaker 00 And you still need someone to maintain the pool for you and balance the water and know how much to add to bring things in line in the water. So it wasn't like the fin with dispense chemicals or do anything for you, except give you the reading. That marketing was all wrong. It also was like really impossible for any homeowner to set it up. You had to connect it to the wifi. Sometimes you had to, you had to type the wifi in manually, which if you ever tried to set up something that way, you know that it's just not going to work. And so the setup was like really difficult for a lot of people and it can only work on, didn't work on 5G, worked on the older um kind of network wifi networks. You had to have two separate wifi kind of
14:07 Speaker 00 lines connected. I'm not describing it correctly here. I know that, but just suffice to say that it wasn't easy to connect. It's a cool looking unit. I mean, it looks was sleek and I still see it for sale for like $290. I'm not sure who would buy it because there's no one who's monitoring it or there's no way you can actually use the fin. But I see here on sale right here at Pool Supply Delivery for $290 and I don't know if you buy it, you can't use it as a brick. And so how Hayward ended the program was really bad as well and gave Hayward a pretty black eye. So what they did is they sent an email out and I also had the fin and I was using it mainly for testing purposes, but the email was just pretty short and it's like, in 30 days, we're no longer going to be providing any support for the fin.
14:51 Speaker 00 And it's going to turn into a brick after that. Basically, that's what they said in the email. The people that just bought it or had it or paid 150 bucks for it who liked it, it was, were using it, we're going to just be kind of left hanging dry. There was no refund issued or credit or anything like that. They just kind of stopped servicing the fin and that was it. So I guess the bottom line here for this product is number one, if you're going to buy a product, maybe have someone in the board meeting that can tell you, hey, maybe if you're going to buy this, market it as a supplement to pool care. Where maybe if you have a pool service provider, they can they can monitor the pH and the ORP for you, or you can do that yourself. It's gonna make it safe to swim all the time. It's gonna be some
15:33 Speaker 00 a device that's gonna help you keep your pool safe. Now, here's another thing that was wrong with the fin. I should touch on this is that it would give you like alerts when the ORP was out of range, which is all the time because ORP is based a lot on the pH of the pool and it fluctuates. And so you would get these alerts saying the pool is unsafe to swim in with the ORP was like below 500 or 600 or something weird like that. And when it said the pool is unsafe, people couldn't use their pool, when in reality, the free chlorine level was perfectly fine and safe, just that the pH was high, giving you a, you know, low ORP reading. So again, if they asked me and I was in the boardroom, I would have said, let's do some testing with this device to see if it's something that we want to purchase for 25 or 50 million. I can't remember what they paid for it. It was crazy.
16:18 Speaker 00 And see if it's something that our consumers, the Hayward brand, could utilize. I mean, builders might be able to utilize this or put it up, put it out there for their customers when they put Hayward equipment in. Who knows if it's gonna be applicable. But you know, if you use the app, you would see the unsafe warnings all the time. You would see that it was not reusable. And it just did two readings, basically, plus the water temperature. So for the amount of money they paid for it, for what it was used for, it just was not a smart investment. And the way they ended it gave them a black eye. So the lesson here, again, don't buy a product or bring a product into your brand unless it fits your brand. And I think the last lesson here is that people just don't like paying a yearly or monthly subscription for anything. That's kind of old school. It's gone out
17:03 Speaker 00 and it's not something that people like to do. And I think that's a problem. If it can be something that you could sell the customer and then make your money on the reagents, like the Water Guru, that's a great product because you're not paying any subscription fee, but you aren't buying the cartridges that are the cassettes that you use to get the readings. And that's a good way to set up your product so that you're not having anyone pay an annual subscription. It just doesn't work. Now, there's a lot of other products that I didn't get to you, and I'll probably touch on them on a follow up. Dead Product Podcast, but this gives you some idea that if you are thinking about making a product, or if you're looking at a product, of course, get a product that has a legacy. You know, hate to say it, Hayward Navigator, not a bad cleaner, been around forever.
17:47 Speaker 00 You're never going to have problems finding parts for it. They're not going to discontinue it. Those legacy products are important. Anything new may not be around three or four years from now. So just be aware of that fact and pick your pool products carefully based on, you know, are they going to be sustainable by this company? And am I investing thousands of dollars or hundreds of dollars in this product? That's not going to be around in a year. I think that's important and stick with the legacy brands or those products that have been in the industry for a long time. And again, another reason why it's hard to break in with a new product because there's been so many products that just have this long legacy in the industry. I mean, the spa wand is still available if you want to use that to clean your spa,
18:29 Speaker 00 but there's a lot better products out there on the market for spa care. Looking for other podcasts that I've recorded? You can find those on my website, slumiprlearning.com. Just go to the banner, click on the podcast icon, and then there'll be a dropdown menu of closest 1600 podcasts for you to listen to. And if you're interested in a coaching program that I offer, you can learn more at poolguycoaching.com. Thanks for listening to this podcast. Have a great rest of your week and God bless. This episode is brought to you by Hasa, providing products that deliver clean, healthy water for every aspect of everyday life. The bottom feeder battery powered vacuum system, portable, powerful, and only weighs 12 pounds. And Skimmer, Get Skimmer, America's number one pool service software.
19:11 Speaker 00 Podcast listeners can try Skimmer for free at getskimmer.com backslash pool guy.
Previous Introducing my New Sponsors, HASA, The Bottom Feeder & Skimmer! Next Swimming Pool Skimmer Basket Tips & Tricks Page updated November 15, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated