Pod Insights The Pool Guy Podcast Show D.E. Filters VS Cartridge Pool Filters About this episode Send us a textWhat is better, a D. E. or a Cartridge filter? I list the pros and cons of each for you here today, and of course, you can decide for yourself. Leslie’s Pro: Pool Service Pro, open a Wholesale account today! Customer referrals, free cleaner repairs, free water testing, open 7-days a week. It is fast and easy to become a Leslie’s Preferred Pool Care Provider. https://lesliespool.com/commercial-services.html/?utm_medium=referral&utm_source=spll&utm_campaign=spllSupport the Pool Guy Podcast Show Sponsors! HASA delivers clean, healthy water solutions. https://bit.ly/HASAhttps://www.orendatech.com/The Bottom Feeder Professional Battery Powered Vacuum System. Save $100 with discount Code: DVB100https://bit.ly/THEBOTTOMFEEDERAnd Skimmer, America’s #1 pool service software! Try Skimmer FREE for 30 days at:https://getskimmer.com/poolguy Thanks for listening and I hope you find the Podcast helpful! For other free resources to further help you:Visit my Website: https://www.swimmingpoollearning.comWatch on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@SPLPodcast Site: https://the-pool-guy-podcast-show.onpodium.com/
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 This episode is brought to you by Hasa. Pool pros, are you using the new Hasa Pro Rewards app? Earn points on Hasa and Orenda purchases, redeem them for gift cards and product rewards. Download the free Hasa Pro Rewards app today and get rewarded by the bottom feeder. With their new cartridge filter assembly, now you can vacuum dirt in a pool down to 10 microns. Don't just vacuum the pool, finish it.
0:27 Speaker 01 This episode is brought to you by Skimmer, the number one pool service software in North America. With Skimmer, you can streamline your schedule, grow your revenue, and keep your customers coming back with five-star service. Whether you're a one-person operation or an established team, Skimmer is your partner in success. Visit getskimmer.com/poolguy to try Skimmer for free for 30 days.
1:05 Speaker 00 And welcome to the Pool Guy Podcast Show. In this episode, I'm going to go over what's better, or actually, I'm just going to compare and contrast DE versus cartridge filters. And you can kind of decide which filter is better. DE filters are diatomaceous earth filters, and cartridge filters use a kind of cloth material like remey. And I'll go over the pros and cons of each, and you can decide if you like DE or cartridge after listening to this. Pool Service Pro, open a Leslie's wholesale account today and receive wholesale pricing on products you use every day. Leslie's pool supply offers convenient locations that are open seven days a week. Another great benefit of opening a Leslie's wholesale account is Leslie's referral program.
1:45 Speaker 00 Get referred to a customer looking for weekly pool service, save time and money, and grow your pool service route and become a Leslie's pro. And there aren't too many of the old-school guys left that, you know, I was at my supplier several years ago, and an old-time pool guy came in and was like, "I hate cartridge filters. DE is the way the cartridge filters are drunk." Not too many of those kind of old codgers still left in the industry. And I would say that most people understand that the newer cartridge filters are extremely well-made. They're very comparable to DE. I would say they're better than DE off the start here. And I was in the industry long enough to where you open a cartridge filter, and if you're an old-timer like me... And you open a cartridge filter and there's thirty or forty tiny cartridges stacked in there,
2:30 Speaker 00 then you are my era kind of pool person. But nowadays, the most common cartridge filters are the quad cartridge filters, which are four cartridges in inside there, which make for the largest square footage. So I'm getting ahead of myself here. Let me just give you a direct category kind of breakdown between diatomaceous earth and cartridge. And you can draw your own conclusion. Like I said, I don't want to be pushing one over the other, so to speak. You could probably decide for yourself based on this. So let's talk about the actual filtration of the pool. I'm going to say diatomaceous earth filters win here. They have better filtration, of course, because they filter down to three microns.
3:15 Speaker 00 And a micron, of course, is a small particle measurement. And the finer the micron, the better. And DE filters definitely win. They filter down to about three microns. Cartridge filters, I've seen literature saying they filter down to twenty, twenty-five microns, fifteen microns. I'm going to say that it's safe to say that a cartridge filter is anywhere between fifteen and twenty-five microns. So you're going to have a little less fine filtration with the cartridge filter, but you're going to make up for it in other categories. So I would say that if you're going for a pure, what level micron you can filter down to, of course, diatomaceous earth filters win. Basically, the reason why they filter down better than a cartridge filter
4:00 Speaker 00 is because of the DE or diatomaceous earth. You have a grid or you have a cartridge, depending on the filter type, or you may have fingers if you have a bump filter. The diatomaceous earth coats that. All the dirt and algae and particles get trapped. In that layer of DE that's on the cloth material that's in the filter. So of course, you're going to have better filtration because the diatomaceous earth acts like a secondary filter, I guess, media where it captures all that dirt and doesn't allow it to pass back in with the clean water. Whereas the cartridge filter is basically just paper. You may have different kinds of paper. Pleco has a thicker kind of paper.
4:41 Speaker 00 Other filters use remey, but essentially it is just paper. And the water is going to pass through and the dirt's going to stick to it. And that's why it doesn't filter quite as well or as fine of a micron as a D filter or filter down to. To me, it's not a major difference. You know, you can't really walk to in the backyard. And I don't think you can tell the difference between filtration by looking at the pool. Except maybe for sand filters, I can kind of tell when someone has a sand filter. But as far as from a D and a cartridge filter, I'll walk back there and I won't even know yet. And a new account, let's say you're getting, you're doing a bid. I wouldn't know if it's D or a cartridge filter. And I couldn't tell by looking at the pool.
5:26 Speaker 00 And when I go back there, sometimes I'm surprised, oh, it's a D filter, or it's a cartridge filter. There's really no way to know because the water quality, in my opinion, is not noticeable. Three microns versus 15 microns, not noticeable because you and I can't even see that small of a particle. And honestly, maybe cartridge filters do a little bit better than 15. I don't know. It's just one of those things where they're rated for these microns. And this is kind of what the manufacturer sticks with. And so there's no big difference there. Next category is square footage or filtration area. And this is where the cartridge filter wins hands down. The largest D filter that's on the market today that I, that I know of in the States at least
6:10 Speaker 00 is the Pentair Quad D Filter, which is 100 square feet. Majority of D filters are going to be 60 square feet. So if you have a large pool, more than likely the builder put on a 60 square foot D filter. Doesn't seem like a lot of square footage and it's really not a lot of square footage. The reason why it works so effectively is because of the diatomaceous earth again on those grids. It gives it more of a filtration ability over cartridge filter. However, the cartridge filter has much more square footage. Because if you look at a cartridge filter, it has what we call pleats. And so the pleats have kind of indentations and then they come back out again. And this is where you get that large square footage.
6:52 Speaker 00 If you have a 450 square foot cartridge filter, that's like seven times greater infiltration square footage than a 60 square foot D filter. And they of course make even larger cartridge filters than that. But I'm just using that kind of as like a median cartridge filter. And this would be four cartridges inside there giving you that square footage. So each cartridge will be about 105 square feet or 110 square feet or 115 square feet. And that gives you the 450 square feet or 420 if you're familiar with the Pentair Cleaning Clear Plus. That's going to give you each cartridge filter 105 square feet. Now, if you have a single cartridge filter, maybe a Hayward or Pentair, you're going to maybe have 150 square foot or 100 square feet.
7:36 Speaker 00 It's still more than the D filter square footage, believe it or not, even in that small little cartridge. So the cartridge filter is going to have more filtration area, more square footage. Now, of course, there is a drawback with the cartridge filter versus D filter. And I should touch on it here because I'm talking about square footage. The cartridge filter will be able to collect more dirt over time because of the square footage. However, the D filter has a slight advantage because you can backwash a D filter, get rid of some of that dirty diatomaceous earth, put in some fresh DE without taking it apart and cleaning it. So there is that advantage, even though the cartridge filter can hold more dirt because it has more square footage.
8:18 Speaker 00 The D filter can be backwashed in between breaking it down and cleaning it, eliminating some of that. You know, equalizing, I should say, some of that square footage that's missing because you can actually do a backwash and get rid of some of the dirt that's in the filter and kind of start fresh again. And I think I'll touch on an exception here too, at the same time, and I don't want to move this to another category. But there is an exception with the cartridge filter, that if you're in an area with a lot of dirt, if you're in a high desert of California, Arizona, you may want to go with a D filter because of the ability to backwash that filter. Because technically a cartridge filter, yes, it can take, hold more dirt with the square footage, but you can't backwash it.
9:02 Speaker 00 So if it is filled with dirt, you have to take it apart and clean it. So that is a slight drawback with the cartridge filter. And the only exception I can think of where you would go with a D filter or a sand filter over the cartridge filter because you can backwash both of those filters and get some of that dirt out in between taking it apart and cleaning it.
9:25 Speaker 00 And the Pool Guy Podcast Show has teamed up with UPA to bring you affordable, reliable liability insurance, starting at just $64 a month. Get up to $2 million in coverage and the members of my coaching group get an even lower rate. Protect your business and your peace of mind. Sign up with UPA today by clicking the link in the podcast description.
9:47 Speaker 00 Next category would be the cost. I would say the costs of both are about the same. This goes over the course of maintenance as well, because the D grids don't last forever. The cartridges don't last forever and I'm really on a three-year timeframe with my cartridge filters. Here in California, we have the four quad type cartridge filters. Now, of course, if you have a single cartridge filter, you're going to replace that much more often because it's taking a heavy load. You only have one cartridge actually working for you. That means that it's taking all that dirt, it's taking all that kind of abuse. Basically that you would spread out between four cartridges and a quad type cartridge filter.
10:29 Speaker 00 So it's going to wear out a lot faster because of that. It's kind of getting more heavy use. You would say versus spreading it out between four cartridges. So the four cartridges last about three years. You're going to replace them. What's the cost of that? Typically, anywhere between $200 and $300 for four new cartridges, depending on which brand you get. You know, what, how, how big they are. Single cartridge filters are of course cheaper and you're going to replace those more often. I would say the single cartridge filter will last six months to nine months. You have to change that out. So that's a little bit different than the four cartridge filters. But the grid and a D filter don't really last more than four years and you're going to be changing those out as well. And each grid is about $30 or $30, $30 to $40. There's eight of them in there.
11:12 Speaker 00 So if they're $40 each, that's going to be $320 every four years. So it's about the same as the price of the cartridges. If you have a quad D filter, I find that those quad DE cartridges last longer, but they're expensive as well, but you're going to get a longer lifespan. So that's kind of the only time you're going to probably save a little bit is with the quad type DE filter. But you're going to be replacing the, what we call elements. And we use that as a general term for cartridges and for the DE grids. We just call them a filter elements. I think it's a pretty good term. It's just a general way of saying the internal parts of the filter, which are either cartridges or grids. So to me, the price is a wash and the price point when you purchase it is about the same.
11:54 Speaker 00 Maybe D filter a little bit more because you're buying a backwash system or backwash valve with it. It's going to raise the cost of the a little bit. But in the end, I think they're about equal as far as cost of the filter initially. And cost to maintain those filters. So you're not going to, you know, have an advantage having one type over the other as far as cost. Let me talk a little bit about ease of use. This is kind of a factor. If you really wanted to get the easiest filter to use, that would be a sand filter. Let's say that you're elderly or you just don't really want to deal with the filter much. I would say the sand filter would be the easiest filter to use because basically it has sand in there.
12:37 Speaker 00 You don't have to do much to it except backwash it whenever the PSI goes up by 10 PSI. And I'll touch on what that means in a second. But if you're looking for ease of use, neither the D or cartridge filter. Fit into that category, the sand filter is of course, the easiest filter that you can purchase and set up and use, where really, nothing you have to do except backwash it when it needs to be backwashed. It's also the least effective filter because it filters down to about forty microns. It also has problems and the pool starts to get ugly if it gets algae or gets a lot of debris in there, the sand filter doesn't do really well. That's why they have a product called aluminum sulfate or FLOC that helps clump things up so the sand filter can work effectively.
13:23 Speaker 00 But ease of use between a cartridge and D filter. I would say, of course, the cartridge filter would be just about as easy to use as the D filter, with the exception of the D filter having the ability to backwash. So you can backwash a D filter, basically reverse the flow of water, knock all the dirt off the grids and some of the diatomaceous earth that's been used up, push it out of the filter and then put fresh diatomaceous earth in there to kind of reset it. I think the cartridge filter does have some advantages though for ease of use that I'll touch on here, that you may not consider as an advantage, but it actually is. So I mentioned the D filter needs to be backwashed. That's kind of a little bit complicated in a way, I mean, it's not rocket science,
14:08 Speaker 00 but there is a layer of, you have to go out there, backwash it, add the diatomaceous earth, so there is a bit more work involved with the D filter. You have to maintain the backwash valve, you know, if it's, if it's a push-pull piston type, you have to replace the O-rings. If it's a multi-port, you have to worry about the spider gasket or the top wearing out, the top handle wearing out, or the valve where you turn it to different ports. And with the cartridge filter, there's none of that, so that's totally eliminated. So I would say, if you're going for ease of use, the cartridge filter, of course, is easy. There's no backwashing necessary. Also, I'll touch on cleaning in a minute, but it is easier to clean a cartridge filter than a D filter in most cases.
14:50 Speaker 00 I did mention I would touch on PSI, filter PSI, and this is what makes cartridge filters a little easier to use than D filters. So the PSI is Basically, the pounds per per square inch in the filter, the pressure builds up. As the filter gets dirty, the water that's being pulled in by the pump can't be returned to the pool at the same rate if it was clean. So when the filter starts to get dirt in there, the PSI starts to rise on the gauge. There's a gauge on top of the filter, and we call this the PSI gauge, basically, or the filter gauge. And in a D filter, let's say you just, it's brand new, you just had it installed,
15:31 Speaker 00 you charge up the filter with DITMA SHS Earth, you have the pump running at full RPM, and this is really important, because if you have a variable speed pump, you need to set it at the maximum 3450 RPM. So you can get an idea of where that full pressure is when it's clean. So let's say that you have a D filter that's brand new, you charge it with DE, turn it on, have it running at full speed 3450 RPMs, or 100% in a VS pump, and the gauge is at 18 PSI. That's pretty much where the D filter is going to sit, usually, 18 or 20 PSI. So if it's at 18 PSI, when that pressure gauge goes up to 28 or 30 PSI, it's time to backwash that D filter, or take it apart and clean it.
16:15 Speaker 00 Same with the sand filter, you don't take apart the sand filter, but you do backwash it when it goes up 10 PSI, as I mentioned earlier. So that is something that you don't really have to deal with, with the four quad type cartridge filter. Because in that case, because it's a large square footage, the PSI gauge does not move very much at all, if at all, on a cartridge filter. And there's not a lot of worry about, okay, the PSI went up by 10, I gotta go out there and backwash it. Or, I backwashed it twice already, I have to take it apart and clean the D filter. With the cartridge filters, since they're larger, and I'm talking specifically about the four cartridge quad type cartridge filters, there's no need to worry about, you don't have a backwash valve, so there's no need to worry about the PSI. Really, the PSI doesn't move too much on that particular filter,
17:00 Speaker 00 unless it's extremely dirty. So that's one other layer you don't have to worry about, backwashing it, or the PSI gauge and a lot of... Situations where it's going to affect the flow. I mentioned the cartridge filter is bigger with the square footage. So it has more flow and this is going to alleviate a lot of the problems you have with high PSI and a D filter. If you ever had a D filter, if you do pool service, you know what I'm talking about. You'll be there in May. Clean the filter in April, let's say, and then by June, you're backwashing it. By July, you're backwashing it again. Maybe you'll get through the season, you get to September, October, where you clean the filter again. But it is something where you're struggling with the flow of the pool because you have 60 square feet.
17:43 Speaker 00 You have a D filter that's going to get constantly dirty and built up. You're going to be backwashing it, lowering down the PSI, which will increase the pool flow and return. And you have to kind of monitor that. Now, it's not something that's a deal breaker of a D filter, but it is something to be aware of when I talk about ease of use. There are more layers to a D filter than there are to a cartridge filter. Whereas a 520 square foot cartridge filter, you clean it in April. All summer long, it's fine. You clean it again in October. There's really no flow issues with the pool because you have such a large square footage area. And you don't have to take it apart in the middle of the season usually. And you just don't need to backwash it because it's such a large square foot as far as filtration area.
18:27 Speaker 00 So it is much easier to use a cartridge filter. Let me talk a little bit about flow and then I'll touch on the cleaning of these filters to give you the last kind of comparison here. Flow, of course, wins hands down with the cartridge filter over just about every filter type, DE and sand filter together. The flow of a cartridge filter is tremendously better because of the larger square footage. It's just kind of, you know, a no brainer that if you have a 500 square foot surface area versus a 60 square foot surface area, or the sand filter is a little bit different. The surface area is calculated a little bit different because you have sand in there and you have water on top.
19:09 Speaker 00 So it's not kind of the same. Sand filters typically don't have the same circulation of a cartridge filter. You have to have a lower horsepower pump on there because of the lack- of flow, whereas a cartridge filter, the fact that the flow is so tremendous. And I'll give you this practical example. I had a pool that was about 20,000 gallons built in the seventies. It had a 36 square foot D filter, believe it or not, for like 40 years it had this filter. It was a Pyrex stainless steel filter and it was just basically a bucket of rust at that point. It was like a, something you would see in a Titanic. It was so old and, you know, coming apart. I'm surprised it never leaked, but it was just the backwash valve and the bottom never worked all the time that I serviced it.
19:55 Speaker 00 Cut that thing out, put a 420 square foot cartridge filter in there. And the flow was so tremendous out of this, out of the return lines. That I actually had to adjust the return so that I would have more return out of the spa return than the pool return. So back when it had the 36 square foot D filter, the spa return, I just had the bypass working and it was trickling in. But because of the increased flow of putting this new filter on, I actually had to turn the return line. So that besides the spa bypass, it had some return going there because it was just tremendous going to the pool. That's what I mean by the flow or circulation of a cartridge filter over a D filter. It's going to be more because of the square footage area.
20:40 Speaker 00 And plus the cartridge filter, as I mentioned just briefly earlier, stays a little bit cleaner because of the square footage. And you're going to have continuously good flow without having to need the backwash to filter like with a sand and D filter. And the last comparison would be in cleaning a D filter and cleaning a cartridge filter. I would say that a cartridge filter, although it may take you a little bit longer to clean because I mentioned the pleats where you have to kind of clean them out because they go in and they come back out again. And this is all the way around the cartridge itself. It'll take you a little bit longer to clean the cartridge filter. However, there's no diatomaceous earth. And so if you ever clean a D filter, and of course, the D filters, most of them are the top manifold type, which the engineer way overdid it with these.
21:25 Speaker 00 They probably could have done a simpler design. But it is difficult to take it out, take all the grids out, put it back together. A lot of people have difficulty putting them back the way they took them out. Plus, you have the added layer of diatomaceous earth, which gets everywhere. And it's really messy and it takes weeks for you to finally clean up all that dust. This is something where the cartridge filter, you hose it off, is just dirt. So it's going into the drain, into the street, whatever, no problem. Diatomaceous earth in a lot of cities and municipalities, they won't let you wash off a D filter into the storm drain. They don't want it going into the sewer. And a lot of builders can't even put D filters in because of a lot of these restrictions. So the diatomaceous earth, of course, makes cleaning a D filter
22:10 Speaker 00 that much more difficult, messier. And it's a layer of mess that you just can't get away from. I really think that if you're looking for an ease of cleaning cartridge filter, you take the top off, you take off this really small top manifold that's holding the four cartridges in place. Take out each cartridge individually, hose it off, put it back in, and you're done. D filter, you can take the top manifold off, which sometimes is hard to do. If, depending on the filter type, you could take it out as a whole, complete grid assembly, and then hose it off in the grass area or another area of the backyard. Keep it intact, but kind of spin it and turn it and then put it back in. It's pretty heavy that way. You could take the top manifold off, take one grid out at a time. You could try to clean it inside the filter tank,
22:55 Speaker 00 which is pretty effective depending on where all that diatomaceous earth is going to. There's a P trap and it's going to the sewer, which of course, they don't really like. But if you have an old setup, they can't stop you. You can just clean inside the tank. But bottom line, the D filter, there's another layer of cleaning it. Plus, you have to add diatomaceous earth back into the skimmer. And there can be all kinds of problems with a D filter leaking diatomaceous earth into the pool. So as far as cleaning and ease of cleaning, the cartridge filter is better. It may take you longer, but it's definitely easier to clean. And I say it wins that category. So you can see from this particular comparison that one filter is definitely superior over another filter type, in my opinion. And you can go through each category and you can, of course, grade it yourself.
23:41 Speaker 00 But you're going to see that one filter type will come out on top, and that's the cartridge filter. Over the diaphragmatic filter, I think just about in everyone's comparison. If they're doing this in a fair and an unbiased way, they're going to come to the same conclusion. And this is something that I've concluded many years ago. That I like cartridge filters better and I'll sell them all day long to my customers. And I'll rarely sell D filter to a customer. And I don't think I've ever sold a sand filter to a single customer here in California. And cartridge filters definitely are number one in my book. If you're looking for other podcasts I've recorded, you can find those on my website, swimmingprolearning.com. On the banner, there's a podcast icon, click on that. There'll be a dropdown menu of other podcasts you can listen to.
24:24 Speaker 00 And if you're interested in the coaching program, you can learn more at poolguycoaching.com. Thanks for listening to this podcast. Have a great rest of your week and God bless. This episode is brought to you by Hasa, providing products that deliver clean, healthy water for every aspect of everyday life. The bottom feeder battery powered vacuum system, portable, powerful, and only weighs 12 pounds. And Skimmer, Get Skimmer, America's number one pool service software. Podcast listeners can try Skimmer for free at getskimmer.com backslash pool guy.
Next Swimming Pool Metal Staining Overview with Joe Laurano Page updated November 15, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated