Skip to content

Century EVO VS NIDEC: The Best Pool Pump Motor Upgrade

The Pool Guy Podcast Show

19m
Transcript

Original podcast

Where to listen

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

This episode covers the pros and cons of retrofitting an existing single-speed pool pump with a variable-speed replacement motor, specifically comparing the Century V-Green Evo and the Nidec VS pump. The host explains that while retrofitting saves money by keeping the existing wet end and avoiding replumbing, it is best suited for pools without automation systems. The core debate between the two motors centers on their control interfaces and features. The Nidec retains a traditional controller and an auxiliary relay for accessories like salt cells or booster pumps, whereas the Century Evo has shifted to a simplified one-button control and dropped the auxiliary relay. This makes the Nidec more appealing to pool professionals who require fine-tuning and control, while the Century appeals to users wanting basic, pre-programmed simplicity.

  • Replace the entire pump with a branded variable-speed model if your pool uses an automation system to ensure proper communication. 10:46
  • Match the replacement motor's total horsepower to the original pump size or go slightly larger to maintain necessary water flow. 12:34
  • Choose the Nidec motor if you need an auxiliary relay to run a salt cell or booster pump directly from the unit. 7:49

Chapters

  1. 0:00
    Episode Introduction and Sponsorship

    The hosts open the episode, introduce sponsors Hasa and Skimmer, and set the stage for the discussion.

  2. 1:05
    Host Intro and Pump Comparison Overview

    The host welcomes listeners and outlines the plan to compare the Century V‑Green and Nidec VS pumps.

  3. 3:26
    Century V‑Green Features and Limitations

    Details on the Century V‑Green’s horsepower options, dual‑voltage capability, and the shift to one‑button control are discussed.

  4. 8:48
    One‑Button Control Drawbacks

    The host critiques the Century’s one‑button system, noting programming challenges and lack of auxiliary relay.

  5. 16:02
    Installation and Wiring Overview

    Step‑by‑step instructions for removing the old motor, installing the new VS motor, and wiring the system are provided.

  6. 17:00
    Manufacturer Background and Production Locations

    The host compares Century/Aosmith, Nidec, and Pentair manufacturing origins and discusses implications for quality and oversight.

  7. 18:06
    Choosing the Right Pump for Your System

    Guidance on selecting between Century and Nidec based on automation needs, auxiliary relay preference, and user simplicity.

  8. 18:57
    Closing Remarks and Additional Resources

    The host wraps up, promotes coaching programs, and provides links to further podcasts and resources.

Highlights

  • 1:07

    Retrofitting vs Replacing Pumpsinsight

    Replacing just the motor saves significant money and avoids replumbing, but a complete pump replacement is better for units eight years or older.

  • 4:17

    Dual Voltage Limitationsdata

    Running a high-horsepower variable-speed motor on 115 volts modulates its power down, rendering motors above 1.65 horsepower unnecessary at that voltage.

  • 5:06

    Century Evo One-Button Controlstrategy

    Century replaced its traditional back controller with a one-button interface on the V-Green Evo to simplify operation and reduce legacy warranty issues.

  • 11:07

    Avoiding Automation Retrofitsinsight

    The host advises against using standalone variable-speed motor retrofits on pools with automated control systems, recommending branded matching pumps instead.

  • 14:43

    Flange Types for Motorsstrategy

    Motors require matching the existing pump's flange type, categorized as either square or round depending on the specific wet end model.

Quotes

  • “For this episode, I'm going to compare the Century V-Green with the Nidec VS pump.”
    Unnamed speaker · 1:07
  • “Now, the Century, their program or their keypad is probably superior to the Nidec,”
    Unnamed speaker · 2:13
  • “So it doesn't do you any good to install any kind of VS pump or standalone motor above 1.65 at 115 volt system because those automatically will regulate the power of the VS pump.”
    Unnamed speaker · 4:39
  • “They've pretty much given the VS replacement motor segment to Nidec by removing their controller on back and also by removing their auxiliary relay.”
    Unnamed speaker · 7:25
  • “Why would you want to go with a VS motor replacement versus a standalone VS pump replacement? Again, it's cost savings, and that's one of the main benefits, I think.”
    Unnamed speaker · 10:16
  • Hasa 0:00–0:24
  • Skimmer 0:27–0:49
  • UPA 9:53–10:11
  • Hasa 18:51–19:18

About this episode

You can save serious money by upgrading to a variable speed pool pump without cutting pipes, but only if you understand what you’re trading off. We put two popular retrofit options side by side: the Century V-Green Evo and the NIDEC variable speed replacement motor. Both let you keep your existing wet end and swap only the motor and drive, but they feel very different to live with day to day. We walk through the details that actually change the outcome: available total horsepower options, du...

Transcript

0:00
19:36

3,237 words · 3 speakers

Topics

  • Pentair
  • Whisper Flow
  • Hayward
  • Century V-Green
  • Jandy
  • Super Flow
  • Nidec VS pump
  • Century Evo
  • Dyna Glass
  • E-Pump

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated