Pod Insights Podcast Business News Network 14185 "WHATS LAW GOT TO DO WITH IT?" with Carol A. Sigmond Partner at Greenspoon Marder LLP and Steve Harper About this episode https://www.gmlaw.com/ Listen to us live on mytuner-radio, onlineradiobox, fmradiofree.com and streema.com (the simpleradio app)https://onlineradiobox.com/search?cs=us.pbnnetwork1&q=podcast%20business%20news%20network&c=ushttps://www.fmradiofree.com/search?q=podcast+business+news+networkhttps://mytuner-radio.com/search/?q=business+news+networkhttps://streema.com/radios/search/?q=podcast+business+news+network
Transcript 0:06 Speaker 00 Broadcasting from the business capital of the world, this is the Podcast Business News Network.
0:13 Speaker 01 Welcome back, everybody. Definitely a hot topic, and it seems like every few days, and I'm not giving opinion here, these are just the facts, there's a new story or situation surrounding ICE. We're going to dig into the latest, some of the legal ramifications of that, and also how it affects even on a state level, because there's lots of, even in the last, literally last 10 hours, more developments on the ICE front. She is a partner at Nassimin, a legal firm in New York City, our friend, great to have her back, our professional of the year, "What's Law Got To Do With It?" is the title of this podcast. She is Carol Sigmund, back on the program. How are you doing today?
0:53 Speaker 02 I'm good, Steve. How are you?
0:55 Speaker 01 Intrigued to hear what you're going to share with us, with all of these latest developments, and I appreciate you taking the time to be with us, even in the last few hours, military-grade weapons being brought to Minnesota by ICE agents. Again, I'm not taking any sides here, I'm just reporting what's going on here. A lot of Democrats demanding new ICE restrictions as another government shutdown looms. I don't even know where to begin, because this is a, no pun intended, a moving target. Where do you think we should start? What's on your mind today with regard to ICE?
1:31 Speaker 02 I think we should start with the Constitution of the United States.
1:35 Speaker 01 Fair enough.
1:36 Speaker 02 I always like to start with foundational documents.
1:42 Speaker 01 Well, you can't dispute them, it's been etched in stone for quite some time. How does the Constitution play into the ICE situation?
1:54 Speaker 02 So I think we should be very clear about one thing. Not all of this is ICE. Some of it is Border Patrol.
2:01 Speaker 01 Fair enough.
2:02 Speaker 02 And Mr. Pratt was killed by the Border Patrol, not ICE. Nonetheless, it's all basically federal agencies. So there are two aspects, two provisions of the Constitution that are extremely important, and everyone needs to sort of understand what they are and then understand how they intersect because we are in somewhat uncharted territory here. The first is the supremacy clause of the Constitution. That basically says in the state and federal governments are in dispute on a matter that is committed to the federal government under the Constitution, the states have to defer.
2:44 Speaker 02 So when you have immigration laws and you have immigration proceedings, the federal government is king. It's on top of the state because immigration is a national federal issue and the states are not supposed to interfere. Now, there are limits on this doctrine. And one of the big limits is that it has to be a bona fide difference of opinion between the state and federal government. And obviously, the federal government can only act within the other authorities that it has. So merely because the supremacy clause exists doesn't mean the federal government can run
3:28 Speaker 02 rampant over the states or run rampant over anyone else. And so let's take one simple example in this area. We have Minnesota considers itself a sanctuary state. And this is something the federal government, the current iteration of the federal government is objecting to. Now, what does it mean to be a sanctuary state? People think it means you can defy the immigration authorities. You don't cooperate with them. You don't coordinate with them. That's only partly true.
4:00 Speaker 02 What normally goes on in a sanctuary situation, and it's true in all the states that I'm aware of, it is a limitation on the authority of the state agencies to cooperate with federal agencies in connection with immigration when they are dealing with what are called administrative warrants. That is to say, warrants issued by the agency itself. If there are judicial warrants, that is, a warrant issued by a judge, it is a different set of facts. And then the supremacy clause governs, and the states cooperate. So if you go to a jail right now in New York City, which is a sanctuary city,
4:43 Speaker 02 and you register as the federal government, a warrant issued by a judge against someone who is currently incarcerated, that warrant will be honored. If it's an administrative warrant, that is to say, not issued by a judge, but issued by an agent, an ICE agent or a Border Patrol agent, it will not be honored. In most cases, it won't be honored. So it's very important to understand there's this distinction in sanctuary cities, and they do cooperate to a degree, but only when they are dealing with judicial orders, not administrative orders. So let's set that off to the side. That's been ruled on repeatedly by the courts,
5:26 Speaker 02 that states can insist on judicial warrants before they cooperate. Now, so there's some limits on the supremacy clause in that regard. The Tenth Amendment is not particularly studied often. We don't talk about it the same way we do about the First, or the Second, or the Fourth, or the Fifth. But it's very important in this context, because this is where the founders said, if we didn't give the authority to the federal government, the state governments retain it. It is a state authority. And let's take a typical situation
6:10 Speaker 02 in which both federal and state authorities have some interest in, say, a shooting. Let's say someone's killed. Let's not say by whom. Let's just say someone's killed. Typically, the federal authorities, even if they are immensely interested in this killing or whatever interests they have, they defer to the state homicide, the state authorized homicide investigators, because homicide is a state crime, not a federal crime. It is, it is therefore, in effect, a reserve power to the states. The only federal homicide statutes are very specific. They're either terrorism or something of that, killing the president or something of that nature.
6:55 Speaker 02 It is not a, there is no general federal homicide statute. General homicide statutes are all state laws. So we have this reserve power to the states, which has only been well-developed in one area. And that area is interesting in this context because it's, it's related to, but not directly in line with what's happening here. It's only in connection with, or it's most developed in connection with, attempts by the federal government to use the state as an arm of the federal government. That they cannot do. To the extent that the federal government is trying to use the police or other public officials in Minnesota as an arm of the federal government, that's prohibited by the 10th Amendment.
7:42 Speaker 02 That is not the argument Minnesota is making. So you have, on the one hand, the supremacy clause, and then you have, on the other hand, this 10th Amendment issue.
7:53 Speaker 02 What the state of Minnesota is arguing is that they have the primary responsibility for policing. They have the primary responsibility for providing library services. They have the responsibility for providing parks and recreation, schooling, all of these services. And they are saying that all of this is being disrupted by the federal government in a way that is impinging on the state's authority. Now, that's, that's the, kind of the basic 10th Amendment dispute. And then we have this supremacy clause question. Now, let's dig into the issue that everyone is talking about, which is the, I don't know any other way to say it, the murder of Andrew Pettit.
8:37 Speaker 02 Fred, there is a horrible, truly horrible, slow-motion video available on the internet.
8:48 Speaker 02 was made by some very intelligent filmmaker, which highlights Pret's hands during this entire incident. And what it shows is that he is holding a phone in one hand. His other hand is not doing anything. He's holding a phone. He's trying to protect a woman who seems to have gotten pushed. All he's doing is holding the phone. And the, and the border agents jump on him and they beat him. They beat him to the ground. One of them finds his lawfully concealed weapon and screams gun. But his hand is nowhere near the gun.
9:32 Speaker 02 His hand is still holding the, the camera, the, the phone camera. Then, um, the agent who takes the gun, apparently, and this is the height of insanity, doesn't check to make sure that the safety is on and it discharges. And this, of course, becomes an excuse for two men to put two shots into this man, who is on the ground, immobile, unarmed, not doing anything.
10:06 Speaker 01 And did not discharge the weapon.
10:08 Speaker 02 And did not discharge the weapon and they kill him. And then that is followed by a total of 10 shots. And that's what the video shows. The New York Times shows that in their, in their reconstruction. This, this, uh, video maker shows it on his. It is frightening. Because essentially what you have is a group of federal agents who beat a guy into submission, disarm him and then shoot him in cold blood.
10:36 Speaker 01 Because the weapon accidentally discharged.
10:40 Speaker 02 In somebody else's hands.
10:43 Speaker 01 A law enforcement individual? And yeah, we're, we're just stating facts here. This is a video you saw.
10:49 Speaker 02 These are just the facts.
10:50 Speaker 01 This is time, uh, dot com reconstructed it, as did other media outlets. And I know there's, there's also AI and games can be played here and there. But it, it appears that a lot of the, uh, material out there is corroborating with the, the same story.
11:09 Speaker 02 So.
11:11 Speaker 02 Now, here comes the question. Can the state charge one or more of these officers with homicide? Without getting into the details of which officer you would charge with what element of the crime, let's just talk about this. Because remember, we have the Tenth Amendment over here. Powers reverse to the state. We have the supremacy clause over here. Now, this is not a novel issue. It has arisen from time to time in the past. And the Supreme Court and the courts have spoken to the question of charging federal officers with state crimes.
11:51 Speaker 02 There are certain instances where a federal officer, in the execution of his duties as a federal officer, has absolute immunity. Consider, if you will, certain events in the South when civil rights, you know, federal officers were trying to enforce civil rights statutes and the states would say, "You're violating our state law on segregation." That would not fly. Federal officer had immunity. He was executing his federal authority. He was doing so in a reasonable manner, and he's got immunity.
12:31 Speaker 02 Similarly, you can't arrest an IRS agent for going on property to serve an IRS notice. He is in the exercise of his lawful duties. He is performing lawfully. He's handing, he's tacking the notice up or handing the notice, whatever he's doing in that modified setting.
12:51 Speaker 01 So I'm going to look at that situation for just a moment. And I got you. I hear you, loud and clear. What if there was a sign that said, "No trespassing," and that IRS agent walked on the property and walked up to the mailbox to drop the IRS notice in the mailbox?
13:08 Speaker 02 It will not affect, he's in the, he's in the proper discharge of his IRS functions, and he is doing so within the scope of his duties.
13:19 Speaker 02 Now, we have Kristi Noem, the Secretary of Homeland Security, maintaining that the officers involved in the shooting of Mr. Pratt were in the discharge of their lawful duties. There is a significant dispute about that, as to whether or not they were actually discharging their duties in a lawful manner. There is a large body of information, studies, expert opinions, you know, serious students of law enforcement who have looked at crowd control and in many contexts. And there are some general rules of thumb in crowd control.
14:01 Speaker 02 You generally speaking, try to keep officers aligned. You try to keep them with their backs protected. And you use, the term is overwhelming force, although that's not the greatest term, that's what they call it. And the idea is to use your presence to control a crowd, not, you know, not clubs. You know, that's why you use defensive weapons. They often have shields. And they'll, and they'll move with behind their shields because the objective is to control the crowd with a large number of officers acting in unison,
14:43 Speaker 02 in unison, under the direction of a supervisor. And there are techniques for safely arresting people, even if they're resisting. And it generally involves three people in a coordinated takedown of the subject that doesn't injure or harm the subject. And we need go no further than Minneapolis and George Floyd to know that if you deviate from that kind of standard, if you're a state police officer, you could be charged criminally. So there are very...
15:20 Speaker 02 Good techniques, they are taught in the police departments. For many years, the Justice Department advocated for these kinds of techniques because they avoided loss of life, they avoided physical injury, and they were the least intrusive, least aggressive way to manage the situation. Experts in the area have been looking at the situation in Minneapolis, including the shooting of Mr. Pratt, but just in general. They are seeing disorganization among the officers, they're seeing poor training, they're not coordinating. The failure to make sure the safety was on on that weapon is one of their points.
16:01 Speaker 01 Basic training.
16:03 Speaker 02 Basic training. So you have a group of people who have been put out in a very stressful situation because they're not doing something that's particularly popular. They are doing so possibly understaffed and undermanned in one regard because they're trying to do too much with too few. They're not particularly well-trained, they're not working in coordination, and they aren't using common sense. I mean, no one, no one can see a person who is down on the ground when you can see their hands, and they don't have a weapon, and they have been beaten, because this man had been beaten.
16:47 Speaker 02 That man is not a threat. He is simply not a threat. And putting two bullets in him, followed by a bunch of other people discharging weapons to a total of 10, as I understand it, that is not reasonable use of force. I don't...
17:04 Speaker 01 I wonder, Carol, Taser, why wouldn't that be used? I'm just wondering.
17:11 Speaker 02 I don't know. So, so that's the situation you have. It's, I think, it is my opinion, only my opinion, the state can charge...
17:26 Speaker 02 Certainly, the two men who fired their weapons initially into Mr. Pratt, when he was on the ground, I believe they can be charged with homicide. And I think the federal government will come in and try to remove the prosecution to federal court, which is one of the things they're entitled to do. And they will try to assert federal immunity for these officers. It is not clear to me that that claim of immunity will be successful. And the reason for that is, I think you're going to have a serious challenge as to whether or not it is ever within the scope of employment of a federal employee to kill someone.
18:09 Speaker 02 The Constitution says we're supposed to be secure in our persons and our property. I don't think you can take essentially a person who has been beaten and poses no threat and shoot him and maintain that you are in the scope of federal law enforcement. I don't believe the experts are going to buy that. I am not at all convinced a jury will buy it, and I'm very interested to see what a federal judge will do with that in light of the fact that they have allowed some of these prosecutions to go forward in the past.
18:44 Speaker 01 And with the time we have left, looking at the repercussions or the aftermath of it, now there's reports that ICE agents are bringing military-grade weapons to Minnesota. Weapons of war. Close-range, I don't want to use the word killing, but designed for close-range combat, if you will. That's alarming for many. And the perception, I believe, of many of the public is this has turned into the Wild West, where whatever's going to happen is going to happen.
19:25 Speaker 01 You know, if agents are deployed because they think that they need to remove individuals under the guidelines of ICE, are these targeted individuals, like you said, with warrants? Or are they just going into neighborhoods and somebody who is profiled to look a certain way? Take him off the street. While we're here, get that one too.
19:46 Speaker 02 Well, there is a decision written by a judge in Minneapolis.
19:54 Speaker 02 He was quite outraged because he has, he was reciting however many of these cases he'd had of people of color who were US citizens who had been grabbed off the street by ICE. And this judge wrote a very blistering six pages, which he said, "This has got to stop", in effect. I don't know in detail what instructions these agents have been given. I can only read the decisions from these judges. I can only read the affidavits that Minnesota has submitted in its litigation against the federal government under the Tenth Amendment.
20:35 Speaker 02 And it appears to me that there are many people being stopped, held, who are US citizens. That is, does not suggest that they are operating with judicial warrants. The President of the United States has indicated repeatedly that he would like to invoke the Insurrection Act. And he may be attempting to provoke an insurrection in Minneapolis. I leave it to the people of Minneapolis to think this through, and how they want to handle this. But there is one other factor that's in this picture, which may seriously undermine the federal position at some later date.
21:15 Speaker 02 And that is a letter from Kristi Noem to Governor Walz, saying that they'll leave, that, you know, they flooded Minnesota with all of these officers and taking all these actions, because they, A, they want the state to give up its sanctuary status, which it can't require, because of the limitations I've explained earlier. And secondly, they want access to voter rolls that they're not entitled to.
21:43 Speaker 01 Got about 30 seconds left. Want to ask this question because it is, in the last, literally, few hours, that Senate Democrats are saying that they're going to block a massive government funding package, i.e., another potential government shutdown. Because of this situation in Minneapolis, they're demanding new restrictions on ICE. What do you think's going to happen there?
22:08 Speaker 02 That's interesting. I think that if Chuck Schumer is being consistent with what I think has been the underlying theme of his activities over the last year or so, he will hold the line on this and he will hold his coalition together for as long as possible. And that is because Schumer seems to be intent on forcing a judicial process forward and he is, he is trying to, to give the American people information and an understanding of what's happened.
22:48 Speaker 02 So he makes an initial decision, the first time there was a potential shutdown to keep the, to keep the government open and in my personal opinion did so in order to keep the courts functioning. He, after the courts were underway and clearly were, had a, a handle on the situation, then he was willing to risk a shutdown of over healthcare. Now he has the courts once again in a major confrontation with the administration over what amounts to the future of the American democracy. I believe that he will hold the line for as long as possible because I think that Chuck Schumer, whatever your criticisms may be, is a man who believes in the Constitution
23:32 Speaker 02 and will do whatever he can to protect it.
23:34 Speaker 01 We're out of time. I would love to keep going here. I mean, there's so many different angles and I truly appreciate your insight and in many ways impartialness. We're, we're stating the facts here. You gave one opinion, but aside from that, this is what's being presented. Let's process that, dissect it, see what we have, look at the Constitution. How can we connect with you, Carol? You're in New York City, somebody's got a question, a comment, what's the best way to reach you?
24:01 Speaker 02 Email. My email address is C Sigmund, C S I G M O N D at Nossman, N O S S M A N dot com.
24:10 Speaker 01 Always great talking with you. Also, [email protected] . Feel free to keep it anonymous, that's okay too. We'd love to hear what's on your mind based on this topic, which is changing by the moment and. Can you come back soon to update everything?
24:29 Speaker 02 Yes, I'll come back soon and maybe the Supreme Court will decide the tariff case.
24:36 Speaker 01 Oh, this, yeah, we've, we've talked about that at length, too. Thank you. I really appreciate it, Carol.
24:43 Speaker 02 Thank you. Be well.
24:50 Speaker 00 Broadcasting from the business capital of the world, this is the Podcast Business News Network.
24:58 Speaker 03 Let's go inside the mind of a 10-year-old.
25:01 Speaker 04 I should have worn those earrings today. I like those earrings. Gabby has those awesome earrings. I need to ask her where she got those, but that's just what she would want me to do. I'll have Michaela ask her for me.
25:13 Speaker 05 Buckle up, Sarah.
25:14 Speaker 04 Yeah, but then Michaela will be like, why don't you just ask her yourself? That's just like Michaela.
25:19 Speaker 05 Sarah, buckle up.
25:20 Speaker 04 Michaela is such a great name. I wish I was called Michaela. There's like a dozen Saras in my class.
25:26 Speaker 05 Hey, we're not hitting the road until you buckle up, honey.
25:28 Speaker 04 Oh, yeah, seatbelt. I forget sometimes because my brain is like busy, you know?
25:36 Speaker 04 I wonder if there's pizza at school today.
25:38 Speaker 03 Sometimes it can be tough to get through to your kids, but it's not impossible. Always make sure they're wearing their seatbelts, even on short drives. Remember, you have the keys, you have the power. Never give up until they buckle up. A message from the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration and the Ad Council. Visit safercar.gov/kidsbuckleup for more information.
Previous 14184 Steve Harper Interviews Dr. Kelly Liius CEO and Founder of Kelly 121 Acupuncture Next 14189 Steve Harper Interviews Allan Philip Gold Retired District Psychologist at Reed Union School District Page updated November 13, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated