Podcast Business News Network
Original podcast
Where to listenCopy share link
3,149 words · 5 speakers
Broadcasting from the business capital of the world, this is the Podcast Business News Network. And welcome back, everybody. He is somebody that has spent his life's work making sure things are better for many others. I'm referring to a gentleman who has worked many years as an urban and regional planner, University of Pittsburgh, and these are the things that we don't realize. We take them for granted, and people in these capacities are working, have worked to improve transportation, irrigation, sanitation, housing, and so much more. Got a lot of listener questions we're going to get to in just a moment with our man of the year, Hall of Famer Richard Goldenbickle Jr.
is back on the program with us. How are you today?
Very good, Steve. Thank you.
Thank you for being here. Lots to talk about, and I want to get in, I want to go right to an interesting question we've got from Daniel, who checks in at [email protected]. He's from Atlanta, and we get a lot of career-related questions. This is not one of them. We're going to get to those in a moment. He says, "What urban planning decision from the last 50 years or so do you believe future generations will look back on and call it a major mistake?" Interesting question.
I didn't know where you were going with that. I thought you were going to say a major success.
You know, I never want to write on the negative side, but that's his question, and it kind of does make you think, well, you know what? How about this? Why don't we look at maybe one successful thing that people will look back on, and then maybe one thing that really didn't pan out the way others thought it might? What do you think?
Well, starting with the positive side, I think congestion pricing has been a real success for New York City and for, as a model for other parts of the country, and I, that's my candidate for a good success story.
And the hard fought battles between the Trump administration's Secretary of Transportation and local officials and the governor. Fortunately, Governor Hochul stood solid for keeping congestion pricing going.
Hmm.
On the negative side, I would say a lot of things that we're doing today are a little bit of a reaction to Robert Moses's era when he was with the Metropolitan Transportation Commission and had the support of Governor Rockefeller. He tried hard to put expressways in many areas that didn't deserve it. And fortunately, he was eventually blocked by citizen opposition in places like Greenwich Village, which was supposed to have an expressway in the middle, and other places.
That's an example. I think there's, I'm sure you'd find many places around the country that would say, this is the worst thing that's ever happened to us. The proliferation of interstate highways and the construction of so-called parkways that also have negative effects will continue until we get a new model for planning, which includes traffic calming and other techniques to reduce the impact of the automobile.
Hmm. You know, we talked about this a while, way back, congestion pricing in New York, and it sounds like you're looking at it differently. I'm not putting words in your mouth, but it looked like you had some apprehension about the way that they were throwing it in there and starting it. And now it seems like you're okay with it. Am I getting that right?
Yeah, I think the initial feeling was that they were gonna go and start something that would be met with such opposition that it might fail. But I think it's been handled very well. And it's responded to some of the concerns that were raised by local elected officials and their neighbors and it's moving along.
Hmm. Got another question here. Let me just pull this up. Mia in Charlotte, and this is a career question. What skills have been most valuable in your career that you didn't expect when you were a student?
I would say, especially since I started as a pre-med student, I would say the focus on public participation, the emphasis on presentations at meetings, which would have frightened the heck out of me when I was a student, and the whole idea of creating coalitions to support a project and get it approved.
What about the other things that come along with the territory as an urban planner? Dealing with the public, dealing with bureaucracy and all those kinds of things. Did you not realize that you would need to? And then, did you realize that, alright, I'm actually more comfortable with this than maybe I thought?
I think that's true. I was not prepared for the amount of meetings you have to go to, whether it's to implement a project or just to coordinate with people at night meetings about studies that are underway at the Regional Planning Commission or at the county. And also, the whole notion of citizen opposition. I guess I should have known that that comes with the territory, but I didn't. I learned it on the job. And it's an important thing to be aware of.
This question lies in with that one and resonates with me because I'm horrible at math. Aiden from Denver is asking, do urban planners need to be good at math and data analysis, or are communication skills equally important?
Oh, I think communication skills are more important, but I think that you need to understand how you can use...
Data and analysis to support the projects that you want to get implemented. And if you, if you just view that stuff as secondary, you're not going to gain the kinds of support that you need to get these projects built or approved. And the notion of planning in a vacuum is just not possible. You've got to be well aware of your environment, what, what the people are most interested in or not interested in, and be willing to work with them to sell a project and implement a project.
When it comes to math, I got to ask, because it was, it was my crutch. Is there a lot of math involved in, in urban planning?
Well, there is at the engineering level. If you're working on a project, you've got to enlist the support of engineers who may do the number crunching and also have the technical background to support heavy infrastructure projects like bridges and highways. But the average planner, I think, needs to be aware of it, but doesn't have to be an expert in, in mathematics.
Gotcha. Yeah, I, it sounds, it sounds like, like any other job, there will be some mathematics involved, but maybe we don't need to put a high focus on it in this line of work. Hannah is in Buffalo and checks in at [email protected] and says, "Roads are often treated as public infrastructure, but parking takes up an enormous amount of valuable land." And her question is, "Why isn't the opportunity cost of parking discussed more often?" So it seems like it's, it's kind of gets lost there and we just, you know, worry about the, the roads themselves.
Well, I think the, the notion of, of the high cost of parking and the impacts of, of parking on neighborhoods has become very important. In Philadelphia, there's a neighborhood that has
Limited parking because the streets are small and and they don't have the capacity for a lot of driving, but at the same time, if cars are jammed into those narrow streets, the whole neighborhood shuts down. And that's the kind of thing that has to be thought about, and the city planning staff, I'm sure, has strategies to deal with it, and the neighbors should work with them and come up with something that's acceptable, similar to how congestion pricing was sold.
You're being from the New York area, you're bringing up memories, in traffic reports, they used to say things like, alternate side of the street parking in effect today.
Yeah, that's a New York classic.
Right, isn't it? And I totally forgot about it until you you mentioned that. You know, that being said, how do you, how does a planner navigate that situation where people oppose more development, right? And, you know, I think this goes back to what you've said before, NIMBY not in my backyard. How do you deal with those situations where the people aren't up for denser development, but then at the same time, they're also complaining about traffic, housing costs, the amount of housing, the long commutes? Like, how do you balance that and work through that?
I think good traffic studies can show people the cost of parking, the impact of parking, and ways to mitigate some of parking's negative on the neighborhoods. But there's no one answer. You've got to deal with situations and neighborhoods that are very diverse and have a character that even within a borough like Queens or Manhattan, you've got places that are appropriate for parking strategies and places that aren't.
And that's that's part of the interaction that occurs in cities and towns.
Before you got into this field deeply, you know, let's, let's say in the, in the beginning, were you, were you surprised once you started and that maybe a couple of years in at the friction, the opposition that, uh, that came along with it?
I, I think in the, uh, early seventies, when I started, uh, there were, there was a lot of opposition everywhere, uh, to the Vietnam War and to other things. And, uh, people were starting to feel that they had a voice in pu- public policy and decisions. And that was one of the things they were concerned about. How, how do you deal with their communities and neighborhoods?
And, uh, the, the idea of just designing a project in a back room or even out in the open and then going to a public meeting and saying, here it is, you gotta buy this. It's the greatest thing that's ever been done. That, that's not the way planning's done these days. You gotta involve people and you have to, uh, respond to their concerns.
So got an interesting question here. Erin is in Denver and says, I appreciate your conversation. This is from the last time we got together. And she says, why does adding lanes frequently fail to reduce congestion long-term? And why is that concept still so difficult to translate into public policy?
Well, adding, adding lanes is a prescription for more traffic because traffic will follow where the easiest, uh, ride is or drive. And if there's a, an area that used to have two lane road and now it's got three or four lanes, uh, including a passing lane, that, that will be an attractor of more traffic. They'll shift from one place to another to, to get a better commute, for example.
What areas do you think are doing well in terms of moving a lot of traffic? Anything come to mind?
Uh, I think parts of New York City are like that. Uh, Atlanta and Denver and other big cities in the central part of the country or the south. And of course, the west coast is another story altogether. They've, they've done a good job initially, but now they're suffering from some of the traffic congestion that we experienced years ago.
I remember, uh, living on Long Island when they put in the HOV lane on the Long Island Expressway. And I want to say that was late eighties, somewhere in that territory where it started. Um, it was mixed feeling about it. I mean, we, we still have them. People are using them, you know, has to be at least two people in the vehicle. Um, but it seems to get the job done, gotta say.
Yeah, uh, when I visited Chicago a couple of years ago, they, they have HOV three, where you have to have three people in the car.
Wow.
And, uh, that wouldn't fly too much in New York.
Yeah.
It, it worked out there and, uh, they, they tied it to the, uh, interstate line that had the tolls. And so they had tolls and they had HOV lanes.
And, uh, when you're on, when you're driving along on a major highway and there's an HOV lane down the middle, the people on the others, on each side can look and see the advantages of having that HOV lane. Doesn't mean they'll change their driving habits, but at least they could see it.
Well, that's a great point you bring up there. I, I, I don't recall seeing an HOV lane in the center.
Oh, yeah, Chicago had that.
Wow. And that actually makes really good sense because on Long Island, it's in the left lane. So if there's a disabled vehicle, an accident in the HOV lane, all right, the whole thing stops. Legally, you can't get out of that lane. You know, I don't know what the jurisdiction is on that. When you get close to the accident, you got to go around it. So you only have one way out to the right. But if it's in the center, that makes more sense because you got the left side and the right side.
Right. Yeah, I'm sure there's a whole science by commuters on how to use and abuse HOV lanes.
Oh, yeah. Well, how many times you see those? It's usually once every two years you see that person that gets busted because they're traveling with a dummy or a mannequin as that, you know, other passenger in the vehicle, just so they can, you know, get to work faster. Brandon has a career question. He's in Tulsa, says that I'm considering a career in urban planning. Is it better to work for a city, a consulting firm, or a regional agency in the beginning?
I would say in the beginning, you should focus on a county level or regional agency rather than a consulting firm, because later on, you might get pigeonholed into a certain kind of job at the consulting firm. And whereas at the county or the regional agency, you might have multiple challenges to deal with.
Yeah, I never thought of it that way. I mean, certainly, there are advantages to working in a city position in terms of benefits and things like that, I would assume, over the consulting firm. How did it start for you? I'm trying to remember back.
I started as a community planner at the Montgomery County PA Planning Commission, and went to a lot of night meetings with local governments and officials. Public meetings were also involved with citizens from the community. And it was a great postgraduate school of planning because You can, you can learn things in school, but you've got to apply that knowledge to real world situations and that's what, that's what the, um, night meetings and the local government meetings resulted in for me.
Have you ever had to in your career compromise on a project because of political pushback or just pushback in, in general? Um, where you had it, you had to go against what you really believed in with that, that, and sometimes you have, I guess you have to, did that ever happen?
Uh, not for me in particular, but I certainly had to realize I wasn't going to implement something if there was such opposition, including from the local elected officials, uh, to what we were trying to do. Uh, there was a train, there's a train station that's being upgraded right now in Ardmore, Pennsylvania, in Lower Marion Township. And when I was accepted in the nineties, I went to a public meeting and tried to push for a parking garage there and also an upgraded station. And it was met with resounding opposition
from the local area because it was in, it was right next to a, a shopping center, uh, in the town. And they felt that there was going to be even more traffic than they had already. And that, that didn't help our sales pitch.
Wow. Uh, it, it is, it comes, I gotta say, to be expected, right? It comes with the territory. You can't make everybody happy, you know?
And, and, and right now, believe it, believe it or not, that, that rail station has almost, uh, been improved and it's going to be a real asset to the Ardmore community.
Wow. Um, we're just about out of time. Thank you for all the insight. This is the stuff that, uh, many of us wonder about how these decisions are made. Um, and even the career side. Want to share? Anybody you have a question about urban planning or even about that career path, you can always reach out to us. Instant feedback, steve at gmail dot com. Uh, Richard, thank you so much for being here again today. Really appreciate all the insight and the, uh, and the feedback. I, I really do.
Broadcasting from the business capital of the world. This is the Podcast Business News Network.
Okay, Simon. What are you wearing right now?
Nothing.
That's right. And what do people normally wear?
Clothes.
Exactly. So now mommy's gonna teach you how to dress yourself. Clothes keep us warm, they look good, and if we go out without them, the neighbors will talk. So it's important to know how to get dressed. Here's how it's done. Underwear always comes first, name tag at the back, then pants, then shirt. Get the first button in the right hole or you have to start all over. If you're wearing a tie, it goes over, round, round, through, and pull tight. Tuck your shirt into your pants and zip up your fly. Socks go in first, then shoes, right on right, left on left. With shoelaces, just take the ends, cross them over, switch the loops. The rabbit goes down the hole, pull tight, and you're left with bunny ears.
I love bunnies.
Good to know. Now remember, spots don't go with stripes, socks don't go with sandals, and if you've tucked in your shirt, wear a bell. Got it? Why are your pants on your head?
Most parenting is hard to do in just two minutes. But spending just two minutes twice a day making sure they brush their teeth is easier and could help save them from a lifetime of tooth pain. For fun two-minute videos to watch while brushing, visit twomin2x.org. That's twomin2x.org. A message from the Partnership for Healthy Miles, Healthy Lives and the Ag Council.
Page updated November 13, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated