Pod Insights The Playbook With David Meltzer Curiosity, Resilience, and the Hard Path to Success with Nirav Tolia About this episode In today’s episode, I sit down with Nirav Tolia, Co-Founder and CEO of Nextdoor, the world’s largest local social network. With over two decades of experience leading pioneering Internet companies, Nirav shares insights from building Nextdoor, stepping away after nine years, and eventually returning as CEO in 2024. He reflects on the resilience required to create meaningful businesses, the importance of curiosity in navigating challenges, and why nobody gets paid to do the easy thing. From his early days at Yahoo to leading a public company, Nirav’s journey offers valuable lessons on leadership, perseverance, and the mindset needed to turn setbacks into success.
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 Welcome to the playbook. I'm David Meltzer and I've waited a long time, even though this is a young executive, I've waited a long time to have Nirav Tolia on the playbook. He's the CEO and co-founder of Nextdoor, but he's always been a trailblazer in the consumer internet space. And over a decade, over 13 years, he's been trawling around technology. And I really appreciate that because I'm an early adopter to the internet. That's how old I am, Nirav. 1992, my first exit was to Thomson Reuters for $3.4 billion in 1995. And everybody laughed at me, scoffed at me and made fun of me when I graduated law school,
0:45 Speaker 00 that I got involved in technology and the internet. But who's laughing now, as I always say. Anyway, as the founder and CEO of Nextdoor, there's so many different things that you've learned as a founder. And I always like to get into the playbook of the mindset. What's been your mentality for over a decade now as a founder to specifically handle the laughing, the scoffing and the making fun of, wow, things are hard. Most people's tendency is to quit.
1:17 Speaker 01 Well, David, it's great to be on the show and I really appreciate you having me. My simple answer is I curl up in fetal position under my desk and try to ignore the pain in my stomach and my head and everywhere else. No, I'm just kidding. But you do feel, you do feel the suffering and the sacrifice and the pain of trying to create something from scratch. And, and you said 13 years. I've been at Nextdoor for more than 13 years. We started the company in 2010 and, and like you. Starting in 1992, I was an undergrad at Stanford those years, and that's when I discovered the internet. And my first job was as one of the first hundred employees at a little
2:01 Speaker 01 company called Yahoo, back when it was not just a little company, but a company that people really loved and destined for greatness, at least temporary greatness. And so I too have been at this for multiple decades, and I've been a CEO three times. I've started three companies. Now, I'll tell you kind of a funny story, which gets into your question. I joined Yahoo in 1996. It was like winning a lottery to be at Yahoo in those days. I wasn't one of the founders. I wasn't even technical. My title was Surfing Yahoo. I was in charge of taking the submissions that were being made to Yahoo, which was a directory
2:41 Speaker 01 of websites, and then categorizing those submissions so that when people visited yahoo.com, they could find the directory of podcasts and the sites that had those podcasts, for example, or whatever other category they were looking for. And after three years of being there and watching the company go from less than 100 people to over 10,000, about $100 million valuation to over 100 billion, and serving probably several million consumers to over 100 million consumers, I thought to myself, boy, this sure seems easy. Maybe I should start a company and maybe I can create my own Yahoo. And so in 1999, I left the company. I was probably the first person to leave Yahoo willingly in those days because
3:25 Speaker 01 the stock was just off the charts, and it was the place everyone wanted to work. And so I remember my goodbye party. Jerry Yang, one of the co-founders of Yahoo, showed up, and he came up to me and he said, I'm kind of curious, you're leaving Yahoo. I mean, no one's leaving Yahoo right now. Why are you walking away? I mean, things are going great. And I said, Jerry, it's been such an honor to be here. And I realized that I won a lottery being at this place, right time, right place. I also realized that if I were run on, if I were run over on the street by a car walking to work one day, no one at Yahoo would even notice. All this success of this company, I haven't had anything to do with it. I've just been a passenger. I've been someone who's been so fortunate
4:08 Speaker 01 and blessed to be here. I want to try to create my own success. And he looked at me, got this look on his face, started shaking his head. He said, you know, You're not nearly as smart as I thought you were. I was taken aback and I said, excuse me? He said, yeah, you have no idea how hard it is to create one of these companies. And that said it all. I mean, I've, I've been an entrepreneur, as I said, three different times. I've had a little bit of success. I've had a lot of failure and it's never been easy. But as I tell the management team at Nextdoor, no one gets paid to do easy things.
4:48 Speaker 01 You get paid to do hard things and no one creates meaningful experiences for the rest of the world, going down an easy path. You have to suffer for your art to some extent and you learn as an entrepreneur that your ability to compartmentalize, to listen and learn from the adversity, but to ultimately move past it and to use it as fuel and learning and strategy to get to the next milestone. That's really the only way to make entrepreneurial success.
5:24 Speaker 00 Yeah, one of my mentors, Bob Parsons, who had a fairly big exit with GoDaddy. He always said, Dave, the superpower that you have is you have the ability to learn to love what other people don't like or love, or what you don't like or love. You're able to, it's not, you know, learn to love. If you love what you do, you don't work a day in your life. It's learn to love what you don't like and don't love. And then life will tell you all its secrets. Now, there's a lot of learning going on and a lot of mistakes. Mistakes will never make you fail, but lack of commitment will. I always enjoy someone that comes back. Obviously, Steve Jobs is probably the most notable of all to come back to something.
6:05 Speaker 00 And to come back as you have and return to Nextdoor as CEO, there must have been some lessons as well, not only leaving Yahoo, leaving Nextdoor, but I've never had the experience of the lessons of coming back. What are some of those learnings that you have had from returning to Nextdoor as CEO?
6:29 Speaker 01 So many and it's still going and I have to say being back has been a blessing and it's a privilege, it truly is to be a public company CEO and to lead the company that I created or helped to create and that I deeply love. But it was quite unexpected for a number of reasons and probably that first reason is when I left Nextdoor the first time after running it for nine years as CEO, it wasn't exactly my choice. I'd kind of topped out. The company was starting to show signs of not growing the same way it had. And when that happens, the flip side of the privilege of leadership is the accountability of leadership.
7:14 Speaker 01 And so when the company is not truly achieving its potential, one of the ways that a board of directors shakes up the deck a little bit is by transitioning leadership. And that's essentially what happened when I left. When I walked away, I had my head held extremely high. I felt great about what I'd done. I felt great about the person that we hired to replace me, a woman named Sarah Fryer, and I felt great about the future prospects of the company. But I was very, very tired. And part of the reason I was tired, part of the reason I was burned out, part of the reason it was actually okay for me to leave is because of exactly what you said at the beginning. The journey was painful. The journey
7:58 Speaker 01 required sacrifice and it had beaten me down and turned me into someone who was really not the best version of myself. And so after five years of slowly but surely rehabilitating myself, my psyche, my point of view, my optimism for doing crazy things, to have the opportunity to come back to Nextdoor, that was something that while, again, it was unexpected and improbable, frankly, it was something that I couldn't resist. And yet, the biggest change, the biggest difference, the biggest learning is that while I was coming back, I could not come back as the same CEO. I could not come back as the same person.
8:42 Speaker 01 I was not coming back because they wanted that person who ran the company from 2010 to 2019. I was coming back because they needed a person who was right in 2024. And so the benefit to me of reflecting on the first nine years of running the company and then reflecting on the five years that I had spent since then outside of Nextdoor. That has given me, I believe, the fresh eyes to come in and be a better leader, be a better CEO, and hopefully have a better outcome at the end. But the lessons are legion and you learn them all the time. In fact, I think if anything, you want to create a mentality that's all about learning. It never ends.
9:27 Speaker 01 It never, ever, ever ends. And the one thing I'll tell you is what makes it worthwhile to me is the people. I've always said I could never start a company by myself. I've started three companies, as I mentioned, but I've always had co-founders. And co-founders and ultimately all of your colleagues, your management team, your board of directors, your investors, everyone, the highs feel so much higher and the lows feel not so low. And in terms of learning, you can only learn so much if you're only listening to yourself. But think about how you can amplify those learnings if you have a set of people around you that you like, respect and trust. And for me, opening my ears and eyes and frankly, my state of mind
10:12 Speaker 01 to all of that learning, that's what I think ultimately will give me a chance to be the CEO that I want to be.
10:21 Speaker 00 And you know, Nirav, as I examine your career, I always admire someone that focuses on the certainty of self by developing skills, knowledge of who and what. And through that pain, the purpose and desire is greater than that pain. When in 1999, I was the head of the data division of a new telecom side of it called Samsung up there. And, you know, I was asked to leave as CEO of the data division because I was a great salesperson. I was not a great CEO. And I was determined to develop those skills instead of staying be the executive vice president of sales, which I had a great acumen
11:02 Speaker 00 for sales, but I wanted to become a leader, a CEO. I was around Kwame and both, you know, just extraordinary leaders in the space up there. And yet, I couldn't get out of my own way ego wise. I still the competitive side of me until Lee Steinberg, which is the irony of my life. I wanted to be in sports when I went to law school and ended up in technology. And instead of being a Silicon Valley investor, I ended up being the CEO of Lee Steinberg Sports Agency because he saw the future of sports in investment and technology. And
11:42 Speaker 00 he didn't care that I wasn't a great lawyer or sports agent. What skill was it that's different today? Obviously, your knowledge is gained, but I'm curious, skill set wise, there's been a great maturation to come back in 2024. Can you pick one of the skills that you see coming back ready for 2024? So you're not the same CEO co-founder that was eight years previous?
12:09 Speaker 01 Yeah, I'd like to think that I am, I am completely different, at least in regards to the weaknesses, right? I want the strengths to stay, but I want the weaknesses to hopefully evolve. But I will follow the sports theme because I recently was in an event listening to Tom Brady, someone who is as good as anyone has ever been at what he does. And he said something that really struck me. He said, be humble in victory, be curious in defeat. And the thing that's really different about me this time around is entrepreneurs are incredibly competitive. I mean, you told the story about how you wouldn't take no for an answer,
12:49 Speaker 01 right? And, and part of the entrepreneurial spirit is one where you just keep getting back up.
12:58 Speaker 02 You know you don't have to wait to shop Black Friday at Lowe's, right? Save up to $150 now on select power tools, equipment, and accessories. Got gifts to get? We've got plenty under $50. Plus, MyLowe's Rewards members get same-day delivery for free. Shop Black Friday deals before the rush at Lowe's. Valid through 11/18. $25 minimum and loyalty membership required. Order eligible items by 2 P.M. Subject to weight and size restrictions and availability. Terms at Lowe's.com/shippingterms.
13:26 Speaker 01 You get knocked down, it's all right, I'm gonna get back up. I'm gonna get back up. I'm still coming, I'm still coming, I'm still coming. And you love to win, but you hate to lose. You absolutely hate to lose. We can say all these great evolved things like, I'm gonna learn from losing, and I'm gonna turn that frown upside down and all that stuff. But in the moment, you hate it. So the thing that Brady said, that I feel like I've tried to put into effect coming back this time is, when you lose, be curious. And losing, when you're building a business, is not binary. But you have many, many, many things that happen almost on a daily basis that don't go exactly the way that you wanted them to go. So at that point, what do you do? Do you get frustrated? Do you ignore them?
14:10 Speaker 01 Do you blame people? Do you think that it was some macro factor that you couldn't control? Or do you get curious? Do you ask questions? This one piece of advice that I have started to embrace is, when someone says something, and this thought goes through my mind, that's wrong, that's not very intelligent, that's not very informed. I mean, this is happening all the time as leaders, right? We are hearing things all the time, and we're having these reactions. I try to force myself to say, why? Not, that's wrong. Not, that person doesn't know what's going on. Not, oh, I need to ignore what I just heard. But why? Asking the question, why?
14:53 Speaker 01 And that is what I've found has not only created... A better working environment because we don't want to build environments where people are afraid to say things because someone will say, oh, that wasn't a very smart thing you just said. We want to build working environments where people are asking questions, where the muscle of the organization, the culture of the organization is around discussion and having a safe space where you can explore things and ultimately come to the right answer. But what I found is in my early days as CEO, I was impatient and that's okay. We want urgency. We want to feel like it hasn't happened fast enough. We're not going fast enough. It needs to happen right now. But within that urgency, we need curiosity.
15:38 Speaker 01 And what Tom said, I mean, I'm sure no one hates losing more than Tom Brady. But for him to lose and then instead of complain or instead of being beaten down when he loses, for him to say why, because why then leads to what can we do better? What can we do to make sure this doesn't happen again? And that is the thing that I've tried to embrace myself and hopefully by doing that, the whole organization can, because the thing about being a leader is you are modeling behavior for the entire organization. And so if you handle adversity well, well, then the organization should be resilient. If you aren't patient, the organization's not going to be patient either, right?
16:21 Speaker 01 If you can show that setbacks make you curious to understand why, so that you can learn how to avoid those setbacks in the future, hopefully the organization will also. And that's what we're trying to build at Nextdoor.
16:33 Speaker 00 That's so beautiful because there's so many times I was in Mexico City with Chicharito, TB12, blessed myself and Tom Bilyeu. We were down in Mexico City. By the way, Chicharito way more famous than Tom Brady in Mexico City. We could not get him anywhere. But they, to this end, Tom Brady, Chicharito, Tom Brady said that as we were on stage and then Chicharito said, but yet remember you're either humble or you're about to be. And which was really interesting. And then I came over the top. My favorite quote, which is- At the end of a lot of these types of interviews is be more interested than interesting. And I think it ties very much into the curiosity of the mistakes and the setbacks,
17:17 Speaker 00 failures that we have in organizations. Now, there is a difference. You hang out with a lot of my friends on Shark Tank. So whether it be Damon or Matt, Kevin, whoever it is, all those guys. And we talk about the difference between being a CEO and being an investor. And even though it's a false facade of investing, in reality, when you're on Shark Tank, a lot of the components of investment are there. And there is a huge difference. You've experienced that in real life, not just on TV, which is why they honor you as a shark, which you're the least amount of shark of sharks because you're such a logical and fair negotiator.
18:01 Speaker 00 From my perception, kind of like Matt Higgins, I love both of you guys and how you do things. But for you, what is the lessons in curiosity that you gained from being on the show itself?
18:13 Speaker 01 It's a great question, and it was a huge honor to be on the show. Interestingly, as you point out, I didn't feel like a shark, even though I was one of the sharks. I felt like I wanted to be one of the people presenting to the sharks because I had my entire career. And the thing that really got me excited about the show was I wanted to support those entrepreneurs. I wanted to be part of helping them achieve their dreams. Like so many people have helped me achieve so many of my dreams. And so just for a second, to take a step back and say, what is the difference really between being a CEO and being an investor, being an operator versus being an advisor?
18:55 Speaker 01 And as I left Nextdoor, I was extremely fortunate because I was able to go to one of the Nextdoor investors, a firm called Heta Sophia, a $7 billion early-stage technology venture capital firm, and be the executive chairman of the firm. And I joined 11 boards and I tried to learn to be an investor, particularly in the areas of consumer technology, fintech, and AI. And it was a very different job. There's no doubt about it. It was a very different job. One difference right off the bat. As an operator or a CEO, your job is to go deep on something that you pick, that you want to make great, and you have to be better at that thing than anyone in the world. As an investor, you have to actually go broad.
19:39 Speaker 01 So it's not depth, it's breadth, because you need to understand an entire industry or set of industries and then be able to predict within that industry, the companies that are starting to emerge, which ones will ultimately be successful. And so this notion that as a CEO, you're working the same problem every single day for years and years and years. But as an investor, you are learning about new companies in completely different fields every single day. Well, those are very different jobs because, you know, I was taught as a CEO to focus. As an investor, you're taught a little bit more to be open minded to the distractions
20:21 Speaker 01 and the illusions that form serendipitously between different things you see where the connection is not obvious. So that's one big difference. The other big difference is as a CEO or an operator, you're doing things with your own hands. You're not just taking advice, you are moving from that advice to execution. And as an investor, it's not your job to do the execution. It is your job to support the person doing the execution. And so you're giving advice. It's a little bit like if you're a CEO, you're driving the car. People may tell you what the destination is. You may have a navigation app or you may have your wife or your husband right next to you saying, take a left, take a right, whatever the case is, right? But you're driving the car.
21:07 Speaker 01 Your feet are pushing the gas pedal and the brake pedal. It's your job, right? As an investor, you try not to be a backseat driver, but you are not the driver. You may tell the driver, you're going too fast, you're going too slow, you need to be aware of that car, we need to take a right here, we're taking the wrong route, we need to stop and get gas. You're giving advice continuously, but ultimately it's not your job to act on the advice. And I found that to be. Both incredibly frustrating because as someone who'd only been a CEO and entrepreneur, I'm used to controlling my own destiny. I mean, I haven't always been successful,
21:47 Speaker 01 but my success or failure has come at my own hand. As an investor, I could tell a fellow CEO something. And if the CEO decided not to listen to me, my role's done at that point. And so it was a very, very different modality. I will say that the real blessing of being an investor for me was that by joining 11 boards and by meeting hundreds of additional CEOs, for the first time, I really was able to experience different styles and different ways of doing things. And so in much the same way as people love to listen to your podcast because they're learning different mechanisms
22:27 Speaker 01 that people have used, I got to observe that with a ringside seat. And some of the things I knew for sure that I would want to incorporate into my own style, even though I never really thought I would be a CEO again, I was thinking, oh yeah, I like the way that that person runs a staff meeting, thinks about strategy, closes a candidate, communicates with the board, thinks about communicating with the company, tells the story externally. And I would say to myself, gosh, that's really something useful. I wish I knew that before I was doing it myself. And then there were lots of other things I saw where I said to myself, that works for that person, but it doesn't work for me. And it kind of refined my sense of self and my authentic
23:10 Speaker 01 way of leading, which I think is critical as a CEO. You have to do what you can do, not what someone else can do. And so the Shark Tank experience, you know, coming back to the question, it was amazing. I did feel at times that I was sitting on the wrong side of the stage, but over the last, call it 10 years or so, I've been lucky enough to spend time on both sides of the stage. And I think even though entrepreneurs and CEOs will look at investors and say, come on, you're not really building the thing. I'm actually probably a little bit more balanced. I think there's tremendous value in both sides. And it's just about understanding what are you good at? What makes you happy? What is authentic to
23:53 Speaker 01 the skills that you have? And it's very clear to me, being back at Nextdoor for nine months. I love being an entrepreneur. I love being a CEO. I love operating. It's just different. I love, I love not just understanding the advice and the learning, but trying to put it into action. And it's not always easy. In fact, I would say in many ways, the good thing about being an investor is you can leave your work in the office and go home. I've never been able to do that as a CEO. As a CEO, there's 10% of my brain, no matter where I am or what I'm doing, that's always trying to work the problem of Nextdoor. As an investor, I could compartmentalize. Okay, I've given the CEO advice.
24:38 Speaker 01 I'll come back in three months and see if it's actually landed. So they're very different. There's a lot of value in both. And you know this because you've been around some great investors. Great investors are just like great CEOs. They're exceptional human beings.
24:51 Speaker 00 Yeah. And you exemplify the number one common denominator. I based the playbook. I think we're on 2,000 episodes of this, but the common denominator has never been greater exemplified than you with the desire that you must be what you can be. And I can feel it through the screen that you have that desire regardless of where you are and what you do. If you're not familiar with Nextdoor, I don't know how, the one thing that I love about it is, to me, it is a great illustration how important community is. And we've never had a greater opportunity to build communities and communities of people that help one another and know people that will help one another.
25:33 Speaker 00 They buy from us and sell for us for life. And there's no better recipe in my 35 years of experience than those people that are able to lead a community of people that are buying from you and selling for you, whether it's your ideas, whether it's product, services, or solution. It's a guaranteed formula of success. And my friend Nirav Tolia has figured out that recipe, whether as it's an investor, a leader, a founder, or a CEO, back on track at Nextdoor. Everybody, please follow him. Follow the company. Nextdoor is an extraordinary community to be a part of. Nirav, make me one promise that we'll get together when I'm up there speaking in San Francisco.
26:17 Speaker 00 I need to learn more from you outside of these amazing 20 minutes. Thank you Nirav Tolia for joining me, the CEO, co-founder of Nextdoor with me, David Meltzer on Entrepreneurs, the playbook.
Previous The Power of Gratitude and Intentional Living Next Why Successful People Ask for More Page updated November 15, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated