You Can Seize Everything (The U.S. is reviving pirate law)
- 24m
- Transcript
Summary
Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.
The Trump administration is exploring the revival of antiquated maritime prize law to quickly auction off seized enemy ships and cargo without going through tedious civil asset forfeiture proceedings. When the U.S. military seizes oil tankers headed from Venezuela or out of Iran, the current legal process under civil asset forfeiture can take months or years and cost millions in maintenance fees, as seen with the oil tanker Majestic X. Historically, prize law operated during 17th and 18th-century wars as a regulated system for state-sanctioned privateers and navies to capture and liquidate enemy vessels. While the Department of Justice and the Navy have worked on modernizing these rules, federal judges drafting the new local court procedures in Texas have pushed back on whether the law applies without a formal congressional declaration of war.
- The government can spend millions in maintenance and custody fees while civil asset forfeiture cases drag on for months. 6:20
- Historically, privateering required a formal government commission and adherence to strict rules to differentiate privateers from pirates. 11:09
- A central legal hurdle for reviving prize law today is that the statute requires a state of war, but Congress has not declared war. 18:25
- Federal courts drafting modern prize rules may decline to include favorable language for the government regarding un-declared conflicts. 25:17
Chapters
- 0:17Intro and Military Seizure Footage
The episode opens with a dramatic DOD video of a U.S. helicopter boarding the Majestic X oil tanker, setting the stage for a discussion on maritime seizures.
- 2:05Resurrecting Prize Law
The conversation turns to the Trump administration’s plan to revive historic prize law to expedite vessel seizures.
- 10:52Maritime Law Expert Explains Prize History
Maritime historian Nathan Pearl Rosenthal details the origins and mechanics of prize law and privateering.
- 17:17Practical Challenges of Reinstating Prize Law
Legal scholars discuss the hurdles of modernizing prize law, including war status and procedural gaps.
- 20:50Judge Randy Crane’s Role and New Rules
Chief Judge Randy Crane outlines the Southern District of Texas’s new prize rules and the potential for swift action on seized vessels.
Highlights
- 1:27
Seizing Tankers Without Immediate Accessstory
The military boards and seizes enormous oil tankers carrying fuel from Venezuela and Iran to disrupt illicit networks, but they do not immediately show what happens inside the control rooms.
- 6:20
Comparing Seizure Systemsinsight
Federal prosecutors currently rely on civil asset forfeiture, treating seized oil tankers and cargo the same way they would seize a drug dealer's car through a lengthy lawsuit.
- 8:58
Maintaining a seized ship is extremely expensive; the U.S. spent $42 million on custody and repairs for the Majestic X in just the first month and a half.
- 11:10
Defining Privateering and Prize Lawinsight
Maritime historians explain that privateering was essentially piracy with official state permission, and prize law provided the rules that kept these acts from being pure crimes.
- 12:09
The Power of a Commissionstrategy
Captain-investors needed a physical piece of paper called a commission from the monarch to legally authorize their cruise and separate them from common pirates.
- 18:25
The Legal Prerequisite of Wardebate
A major hurdle for modern prize law is that legally, prizes can only be taken when a country is formally at war, raising questions about current un-declared conflicts.
- 23:23
Drafting Modern Prize Rulesstory
Chief Judge Randy Crane of the Southern District of Texas assembled a team to write a modern 30-page set of prize rules incorporating tracking systems and perishable cargo carve-outs.
- 25:17
Pushback on War Definitionsdebate
Judges declined to include government-suggested language defining conflict as war, leaving it to future judges to decide if prize law applies without a formal declaration.
Quotes
“Prize law has ancient roots in maritime law and provides the framework to condemn, return, or dispose of maritime property seized in conflict.”
Unnamed speaker · 5:01 “They were trying to use civil asset forfeiture to sell off the ship and the oil inside quickly.”
Unnamed speaker · 7:26 “If you blow the horn, I want to say five times in rapid succession. That is like, that is caution.”
Unnamed speaker · 17:20 “The privateering commission is a piece of paper that says so and so is hereby authorized to cruise.”
Unnamed speaker · 12:16 “They mentioned crude oil immediately, which means they don't have to wait for any court ruling to sell the oil.”
Unnamed speaker · 24:06
Sponsored segments
- The Hartford 0:00–0:15
- Superhuman 3:32–3:57
- The Hartford 3:58–4:28
- Dell 4:29–4:50
- The Hartford 19:47–20:16
- Dell 20:18–20:33
- Capital One 20:34–20:48
- The Hartford 27:16–27:45
- Mint Mobile 27:46–28:15
About this episode
The U. S. is working on bringing back the ancient maritime practice of prize law — which allowed for privateers, or more recently, navies, to seize enemy-linked ships, and quickly sell them off. Why? Well, the U. S. has been seizing lots of big boats — oil tankers linked to Iran and Venezuela — in what the Pentagon calls an effort to disrupt ‘illicit networks.’ But after they seize the big boats, they have a big problem: Boats are very expensive to maintain, and each day the government owns them adds extra costs. So they want to sell off the tankers and the oil inside as soon as possible. On today’s show, pirates, some swashbuckling, and an interview with the federal judge tasked with standing up a modern-day prize court. Read: Our book: Planet Money: A Guide to the Economic Forces That Shape Your Life https://lnk.to/i3AukBdD Our weekly longform Planet Money newsletter https://n.pr/3zrFvUBOur weekly Indicator round-up newsletter https://www.npr.org/newsletter/indicatorFollow: Instagram https://n.pr/3FqLuwsTikTok https://n.pr/3sGZdrqYouTube https://lnk.to/iCVDaW3CFacebook https://n.pr/3h92GwS Support public media with NPR+ and enjoy perks for over 25 podcasts like this one. This show’s perks include bonus episodes and sponsor-free listening. Learn more atplus.npr.org http://plus.npr.org/. This episode of Planet Money was hosted by Nick Fountain. It was produced by Sam Yellowhorse Kesler. It was edited by Marianne McCune. It was fact-checked by Sierra Juarez, engineered by Robert Rodriguez and Jimmy Keeley. Alex Goldmark is Planet Money's executive producer. See pcm.adswizz.com https://pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for sponsorship and to manage your podcast sponsorship preferences. NPR Privacy Policy https://www.npr.org/about-npr/179878450/privacy-policy
Transcript
4,646 words · 8 speakers
Topics
- NPR
- Texas
- Majestic X
- Trump administration
- Southern District of Texas
- Justice Department
- Department of Defense
- Iran
- Venezuela
- University of Florida
Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated