Pod Insights Planet Money When Chicago pawned its parking meters About this episode In 2008, Chicago’s budget was in a bad place. The city needed money. One way to raise money was to increase property taxes, but what politician wants to do that? So instead, Mayor Richard M. Daley’s administration looked around at the resources the city had, and thought, ‘Any of this worth anything?’ They opted to lease out the city’s metered parking system — to privatize all 36,000 of its parking meters.
The plan: have private companies bid on operating the meters, modernizing the system, and keeping the profits for a certain number of years. In exchange, they would give Chicago a big lump sum payment. The winning bid was $1.16 billion dollars for a 75-year lease.
Today’s episode is the story of how that bid got put together, and how it came to be hated. There are kidnapped parking meters https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2010/10/25/130811940/chicago-s-new-parking-meters-go-missing-tears-are-not-shed, foot chases through City Hall, and trash bags filled with secret documents.
Pre-order the Planet Money book and get a free gift https://www.planetmoneybook.com/. / Subscribe to Planet Money+ https://n.pr/3HlREPz
Listen free: Apple Podcasts http://n.pr/PM-digital, Spotify https://n.pr/3gTkQlR, the NPR app https://n.pr/3Bkb17W or anywhere you get podcasts.
Facebook https://n.pr/3h92GwS / Instagram https://n.pr/3FqLuws / TikTok https://n.pr/3sGZdrq / Our weekly Newsletter https://n.pr/3zrFvUB.
This episode was produced by Willa Rubin with help from Luis Gallo and Sam Yellowhorse Kesler. It was edited by Jess Jiang, fact-checked by Vito Emanuel and engineered by Cena Loffredo and Robert Rodriguez. Alex Goldmark is our executive producer.
See pcm.adswizz.com https://pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for sponsorship and to manage your podcast sponsorship preferences.
NPR Privacy Policy https://www.npr.org/about-npr/179878450/privacy-policy
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 This message comes from Apollo. Apollo provides access to long-duration capital and a broad range of financing capabilities, helping companies drive growth at an efficient cost of capital. Learn more at apollo.com/capital.
0:14 Speaker 01 Hey, it's Kenny Malone, and I want to take a quick minute to talk about public media. It was founded to inform, to educate, to expand our perspective. But as of this fall, federal funding for public media, including NPR and local NPR stations, has been eliminated. It was a huge blow on top of an already very busy year here at Planet Money. You know, in 2025, we've raced to publish episodes on the trade war, the Doge chainsaw, the fight over the Federal Reserve, and obviously, we could go on and on. But we've also tried to balance that heavier stuff with stories to entertain and illuminate, even delight, we hope, from time to time, like the story about why it is so hard to
0:57 Speaker 01 find a public toilet, or the mystery behind the website milk.com. We've also taken on some bigger projects this year, like the end of Pax Americana and kicking off our quest to make a board game. So it's been a lot, and we want to be just as ambitious next year to meet whatever the moment calls for, with, of course, your help. So thank you, if you've already gone the extra mile as an NPR Plus supporter. And if not, you can join our Plus community. You can get a bunch of perks, like bonus episodes and more, from across NPR's podcasts, and support public media along the way by signing up for NPR Plus today.
1:42 Speaker 01 You can just go to plus.npr.org. And of course, thank you.
1:51 Speaker 02 This is Planet Money from NPR.
1:56 Speaker 03 Chicago journalist Mick Dumke has an amazing memory. He's the type of person who can look at a map of a new city and then go for a run and not get lost. Or recall exactly where he was on a Tuesday in December of 2008. He was at the gym.
2:15 Speaker 04 I'm a regular weightlifter, Nick, even though you'd never know it from looking at me, because I'm not a very big guy. But I'm pretty sure I was in the weight room at that time.
2:24 Speaker 03 On the floor, on the exercise mat.
2:26 Speaker 04 I was maybe doing sit-ups or stretching and the TV was like above the exercise mat.
2:33 Speaker 03 The TV was playing the news.
2:35 Speaker 05 Well, the city of Chicago has struck a deal with a private company to take over the city's parking meters.
2:39 Speaker 06 The story was about how Chicago's mayor, Mayor Richard M. Daley, had made a deal with some outside investors to sell off the proceeds to Chicago's parking meters for a big upfront payment of $1.16 billion.
2:55 Speaker 05 The proposed 75-year lease has to be approved by council.
2:59 Speaker 03 Now, this wasn't all too surprising to Mick. Mick had covered Daley a lot. And he says the Daley administration at the time had pretty much constant budget issues. But they had found this new tool. They were privatizing stuff all around the city. They were selling off future revenue in exchange for a much-needed, big lump sum payment now.
3:21 Speaker 04 The first one, the groundbreaking one, happened when the city privatized the Chicago Skyway, which is, it's not even a full highway.
3:30 Speaker 03 It's like a shortcut to Indiana.
3:32 Speaker 04 It's a shortcut to Indiana. Thank you.
3:34 Speaker 06 In that one, the city gave up toll revenues for nearly a century in exchange for $1.8 billion upfront. And people were cool with this. The way Mick describes it, Chicagoans barely use the road. It's mostly out-of-towners.
3:48 Speaker 04 And the Chicagoans who do use it are people going to their summer homes in Michigan. And if you don't want to pay the tolls, you just drive on local roads.
3:57 Speaker 03 Honestly, seems ideal to be able to sell off out-of-towners slash rich guys who are going to their vacation. It doesn't seem like there's that much of a downside to that one.
4:08 Speaker 04 That's exactly the way it was received. And Mayor Daley was praised for it. And he remembered that praise and then proceeded to look for other stuff to sell off.
4:19 Speaker 06 Yeah, like the parking lots downtown, under the big parks that run along Lake Michigan. For those, Chicago gave him up for a century and got $560 million upfront.
4:29 Speaker 04 And again, it was another thing that people didn't have to use because the people who used it were in large part tourists, suburbanites.
4:39 Speaker 03 I love that Chicagoans love screwing over the occasional tourist.
4:45 Speaker 04 Oh, absolutely.
4:46 Speaker 06 Mayor Daley, Chicago, they were on a roll with these privatization deals. Each one brought much needed money now at the expense of not only out of towners, but future out of towners.
4:57 Speaker 03 Which brings us back to the map, the gym map. Mick's on the floor, watching this news report.
5:01 Speaker 05 Live from City Hall now with more.
5:03 Speaker 03 And he sees that Chicago has struck another privatization deal.
5:06 Speaker 05 Plug the city's budget gap.
5:07 Speaker 03 Except this time it was for all 36,000 parking meters in the city, which aren't exactly used by out of towners.
5:16 Speaker 07 So if city council approves this lease beginning next year, when you go to feed that meter, you can definitely expect to pay more.
5:24 Speaker 06 And the city seemed to want to get this deal approved as soon as possible. This was December 2008, the depths of the Great Recession, and the mayor was looking to raise revenue without raising taxes.
5:35 Speaker 07 The mayor clearly worried about the economic crisis. He hopes that this will help avert future problems.
5:41 Speaker 03 Now Mick, he had developed a sort of healthy skepticism of the Daley administration and their privatization campaign. But this deal seemed weird. They were selling off the city's parking meters for 75 years in maybe a fire sale?
5:57 Speaker 04 Immediately, my BS antenna went up and I knew that we were going to have to take a closer look at this.
6:04 Speaker 03 But you knew you had a story.
6:05 Speaker 04 I knew I had a story and that started more than 15 years of reporting on this deal for me.
6:13 Speaker 04 Sounds like a sentence, doesn't it? Yeah.
6:16 Speaker 03 Yeah.
6:19 Speaker 06 And it wasn't just Mick who'd been sentenced to 15 years of this parking purgatory parable. This deal that Chicago made would go down as one of the most notorious miscalculations in the history of city government. It would call into question what the government is even supposed to do and become a textbook case on the potential pitfalls of privatization.
6:42 Speaker 03 Hello and welcome to Planet Money. I'm Nick Fautin.
6:44 Speaker 06 And I'm Alexi Horowitz-Ghazi. The word privatization gets thrown around a lot these days. Recently, there have been proposals to privatize all sorts of things that once seemed core to the idea of government. Social Security, air traffic control, the post office. But infrastructure has long been ahead of this curve. Chances are, you've driven on a private toll road in your life, you've flown out of a privatized airport, maybe you've drunk from a privatized water system.
7:11 Speaker 03 And behind those deals, to sell off government-run services and the future fees they collect for an upfront payment, there is a math problem. How much are the future tolls or water profits worth today? How much will they be worth in the future? And when does that trade make sense for the public?
7:30 Speaker 06 Today on the show, the Chicago parking deal. There will be kidnapped parking meters, foot chases through City Hall, and trash bags filled with secret documents.
7:48 Speaker 00 Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors. The 2026 midterm elections are upon us. On November 3rd, voters will determine what the next two years of their local leadership and the balance of national government will look like. Listen to the NPR News Now podcast for all the updates you need ahead of and after November 3rd from NPR News.
8:15 Speaker 00 The countdown to the 2026 midterm elections is here. Voters will determine who controls the Senate, the House, and countless local offices. All the election coverage you need can be found on the NPR app. From big picture political
8:27 Speaker 03 Headlines to local stories that are curated just for you. Plus, live coverage as results come in on election night. Download the NPR app at npr.org/2026election.
8:40 Speaker 03 Midlife brings a lot of changes. Your Turn with Alison Aubrey is a new podcast to help you navigate the twists and turns. From health and relationships to creativity and purpose, we can help steer your next chapter with Your Turn with Alison Aubrey. Find it on the NPR app or wherever you get your podcasts. Support comes from NPR sponsor AARP.
9:03 Speaker 03 We tried to talk to the people from the Daily Administration who negotiated the deal to sell off Chicago's parking meters for 75 years. They did not want to talk. But we did get to talk to somebody on the other side, somebody who wanted to buy them. His name, Sadek Waba.
9:20 Speaker 06 Parking meters is not the most, what's the right word? Help me out here. It's not the most exciting thing, right?
9:29 Speaker 03 You were trying to not say sexy?
9:31 Speaker 06 Sexy? OK, thank you. So it's not the most sexy thing, right?
9:37 Speaker 03 In 2008, Sadek led a firm called Morgan Stanley Infrastructure Partners, where he was tasked with finding new projects to invest in. And when Chicago put out a request for bids on its parking meter system, he was curious. Like, what would this actually look like? No one had done it before in the US, taking over a city's parking meter system. So he flew to Chicago to take a look.
10:00 Speaker 06 We rented a car and went around understanding what it meant to have a parking meter in a particular area.
10:09 Speaker 03 You went to the Loop. You went to neighborhoods like Logan Square.
10:13 Speaker 06 Everywhere. It's this, right? You get statistics that says there are 200 parking meters in this neighborhood. OK, what does that mean? If I have a parking meter where you have storage facilities, no one really parks there after 4 o'clock or whatever, right? Then the usage is going to be very low.
10:31 Speaker 03 And you yourself, the top dog, you were doing this on-the-ground research?
10:36 Speaker 06 Yes.
10:37 Speaker 03 Yourself? That surprises me.
10:39 Speaker 06 No. It doesn't surprise me at all. Of course, he hit the streets. These deals are made on the details. Details like what the future meter rates were going to be.
10:48 Speaker 03 The city's rates have remained very, very low for many decades, like too low, a quarter an hour in many neighborhoods, which meant people would just camp out in those parking spaces all day long. Some city councillors, or aldermen, as they're called in Chicago, wanted to raise rates. But what they didn't want was the political blowback.
11:08 Speaker 06 Sadek wasn't too worried about all that. He was focused on other things, like calculating how much the future profits from these meters were worth.
11:16 Speaker 03 Remember, this deal, it was for 75 years. Trying to figure out like the next 10 years of profits is hard. What if there's another recession? Will people keep driving? Will they even need parking? Now do that every year for 75 years. The math is daunting.
11:31 Speaker 06 Especially because this touches on one of the most important concepts in finance and economics and honestly, daily life. The time value of money.
11:40 Speaker 03 Are we talking about a certain rate? Are we talking about the
11:44 Speaker 06 Yes.
11:44 Speaker 03 Discount rate, perhaps?
11:45 Speaker 06 The discount rate. Ah, the discount rate. Basically, the idea behind a discount rate is that money now is worth more than money later. If someone offers you $100 today, or $100 a couple of years from now, you should almost always take the $100 today. Because if you take it now and stick it in a savings account, you can earn interest. Maybe it'll become $110 in a couple of years. But if you wait to take it, you'll have lost out on that opportunity. And also, $100 will buy less because of inflation.
12:15 Speaker 03 Basically, money in the future is worth less than money today. And remember, Sadek is trying to figure out what money in the future, the profits from the parking meter system for each of the next 75 years, what those are worth in 2008. Because he's going to pay for them upfront in a lump sum.
12:32 Speaker 06 The good news is mathematicians long ago figured out how to take future earnings and calculate their present value. They call this discounting. And the rate at which you discount the future is called the discount rate.
12:45 Speaker 03 And the discount rate you use to calculate what the future is worth today can have huge implications. Also, how far into the future you're going. The longer the timeframe, the bigger the discount.
12:55 Speaker 06 $100 two years from now is very different than the $150 years from now. At some point, the value of what you think that $100 is, that you're going to get Fifty years from now, at a certain discount rate, is very small. So beyond call it-
13:11 Speaker 03 Teeny, right? Fifty years.
13:13 Speaker 06 Yeah, but that value is zero.
13:14 Speaker 03 Effectively zero.
13:15 Speaker 06 Correct. So Sodik and his team, they plug in all the future profits. They discount how much those profits are worth and they try and figure out the present day value of 75 years of profits. The magic number they come up with? 1.16 billion dollars. They submit it to the city and they wait and wait. And then they find out they won. On a Tuesday, Mayor Daley has that press conference we heard about earlier announcing the deal.
13:42 Speaker 05 Well, the city of Chicago has struck a deal with a private company to take over the city's parking meters.
13:47 Speaker 03 Now, as we mentioned, Mayor Daley's administration had already used a privatization tool a couple of times before. But this announcement happened so quickly with so few details that some members of Chicago City Council were taken by surprise. Scott Wagasback was a young alderman at the time, representing the 32nd ward. And he remembers thinking, this deal is weird. We've got to look at it now.
14:11 Speaker 06 We're sitting in the ward office and we were kind of going, you know, past five, past six o'clock. You know, we're sitting here talking it through and I said, okay, guys, this doesn't feel right. This does not feel right. Scott especially didn't like that Mayor Daley's people were trying to strong arm the city council into moving fast. The mayor's people were saying, listen, the economy is in full on meltdown mode. Remember, this was late 2008. We need the money now.
14:40 Speaker 03 Yeah, they said, if you don't approve this, our budget is cooked. Because, surprise, that budget you already passed, it includes $150 million in revenues from this deal. If you spike this, we'll have to raise property taxes.
14:54 Speaker 06 Scott does some back of the envelope calculations on the parking system's worth. And he thinks, this deal is bad. But when he shows up the next day at City Hall to press the mayor's staff on this, he cannot seem to corner them. At one point, I see the CFO and I go, have you read this thing? You know, and he's kind of across the room. And I go, I need to talk to you about this. This, this isn't enough money. We're not getting enough out of this. That guy turns when I start talking to him and literally runs out the door into the hallway, runs down the hallway. And I'm like, wow, this thing's got to be really bad. If he's hoofing it down the hallway. He ducked you. I think he knew what the deal was.
15:39 Speaker 06 On Thursday, just two days after the deal was announced, the whole city council met to deliberate.
15:46 Speaker 06 Council will come to order, please. Call the roll. I was just walking around saying, look, don't vote for this thing. You were literally walking around trying to pick people off, tell them not to vote for this? Yeah. I was getting the brush off from quite a few people because they're like, look, Scott, come on.
16:04 Speaker 03 Yeah, the way Scott and others describe it, the mayor had a lot of influence over the city council at the time.
16:10 Speaker 05 Thank you, Mr. President. I supporting this and I just three good reasons. One, a billion dollars.
16:16 Speaker 06 This deal needs to get done.
16:18 Speaker 05 Who's going to give us a billion dollars? Two, no tax raises.
16:21 Speaker 06 The administration says it's awesome. You know, we need to close the budget gap.
16:25 Speaker 05 And three, we balance the budget. Thank you.
16:28 Speaker 06 Scott convinced a few people on the council, the deal was bad and to vote against it. But speaker after speaker stood up and said, listen, is this the greatest deal ever? Eh, it's a deal and we do need the money now. I think the concession agreement was actually 520 pages. I think the initial contract was like 75. And one of the aldermen next to me, Dick Mel. Thank you, Mr. President. He stood up and he said. How many of us read the stuff when we do get it? That was his quote. Okay. Let's face it. And so I hold it up and I, and I kind of yelled out, I was like, I read it. I read it. All right, we've got it. I know some do and some don't.
17:10 Speaker 03 Scott was flabbergasted that a colleague was saying on mic that they hadn't read the deal. That felt like a dereliction of their duty as elected officials to their current constituents and also for generations to come.
17:25 Speaker 06 But on the other hand, you can see why Chicago city council members would be tempted by this deal, even if they didn't fully understand it. It's a dynamic you see all the time in politics. Because politicians live on the time scale of election cycles, it can be strategic to pass some policy that seems to be addressing a short-term crisis, even if it creates bigger problems down the road. That way they can at least tell voters that they're doing something.
17:52 Speaker 03 And so when it came time to tally the votes for this parking deal, 40 of Scott's colleagues voted for it.
17:59 Speaker 06 And lo and behold, this thing kind of. Got jammed through and the final vote was basically five people voting against it.
18:08 Speaker 03 You were one of the five who voted no.
18:11 Speaker 06 Correct.
18:12 Speaker 03 How do you feel about that vote today?
18:14 Speaker 06 Well, I.
18:17 Speaker 03 After the break, the answer to that. Nah, just kidding. You know the answer.
18:22 Speaker 06 I feel great about it.
18:24 Speaker 03 After the break, why he feels great about it. How his read on the deal was eventually vindicated. And how a string of revelations enraged Chicagoans all across the city.
18:39 Speaker 02 Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors.
18:44 Speaker 03 This week on the NPR Politics Podcast, the midterm elections are wrapping up, and millions of people have already voted. We're taking one final check of the electoral pulse with a new NPR PBS News Marist Poll. It shows Democrats still poised to make gains,
19:01 Speaker 01 but also with some warning signs for just how many. We'll explain on the NPR Politics Podcast. Oh, Kevin, it feels good to be back.
19:09 Speaker 03 It sure does, Casey. And what a time. The world is talking about AI and what's going on in Silicon Valley. And we are here with a new show to tell you all about it.
19:18 Speaker 01 That's right, Kevin. On our new show, Machine Gods, twice a week, we'll be bringing you the biggest news in tech and bring you unmatched access to the real titans of this industry.
19:26 Speaker 03 You can find Machine Gods from NPR on the NPR app or wherever you get your podcasts.
19:32 Speaker 02 This message comes from NPR sponsor CFP, Certified Financial Planner Professionals, committed to acting in their clients' best interests. Learn more at letsmakeaplan.org.
19:44 Speaker 03 The parking deal went through. Chicago got its $1.16 billion in exchange for 75 years of parking revenue. And they put some of it in a rainy day fund.
19:53 Speaker 06 And the folks on the other side of the deal got the parking system. They started by setting up a private company to run the system, Chicago Parking Meters LLC. And they hired people to collect the quarters, to write parking tickets, to service and replace meters.
20:08 Speaker 03 In February of 2009, when the private company took over the system, Things pretty quickly went awry. Meter rates went way up. In some areas, they quadrupled from a quarter an hour to a dollar, which meant meters couldn't handle all the quarters. The company also calibrated some meters wrong, so people were being ripped off. Chicagoans started protesting. Forget nickelled and dimed. These folks are tired of being quartered.
20:34 Speaker 06 The vast majority of the people reject the parking meter deal and reject Margaret Stanley's ownership of the parking meter deal.
20:43 Speaker 03 Other people started disappearing parking meters, kind of Cool Hand Luke style. They've been grabbing these like hotcakes. I don't know who and where. I don't see how you can get away with it. You know what I mean? There were TV debates, like this one time. Mick the journalist got into it with one alderman about what research he did before he voted for the deal.
21:00 Speaker 05 It's not true. How much research did you do into privatization of parking meters? I did a lot of research on it. It's none of your damn business. It is. You're a public official. You're representing the people of the city of Chicago. You're damn right I am, and I do my job.
21:12 Speaker 03 Yes, people were mad about the meter increases and the dysfunction. But Scott Wagasback, the alderman who'd voted against the deal, says as time wore on, another aspect of the deal started to grind people's gears. Scott says the deal had provisions in it that meant the city had to pay anytime they took a meter out of service, like for a street fair. Before, he could just shut off the street. Now, he had to think of the meters. The parking company would calculate the opportunity cost.
21:40 Speaker 05 It was essentially, OK, well, if you take 150, 200 meters out of operation for four days, they came back and said, here's the cost of taking those meters out.
21:55 Speaker 03 It could be in the tens of thousands of dollars. How did you feel when they came back to you with a price tag like that?
22:01 Speaker 05 What the hell? I mean, that's what people would say. Like, what are you talking about?
22:05 Speaker 06 Talking about Alderman. And it wasn't just street fairs. Every time a dumpster needed to be in front of a meter, every time somebody proposed a bike lane or a bus stop or a loading zone in front of their business, Scott had to find a new place for the meters or the city would have to pay up.
22:22 Speaker 03 Do you feel like you've lost control of your streets?
22:25 Speaker 06 Absolutely. One year, Chicago's payments to the parking company topped $26 million. Since 2009, the city has paid more than 160 million. And yes, the city had been paid its 1.16 billion, but it was burning through a chunk of those proceeds and sending them out of the city. Scott says all of this really reached a boiling point for him thanks to an accidental discovery he made. One day, I'm sitting in my office here, right? We were doing the interview and somebody called up and I could hear they were angry. Why? Because of a big pile of trash that was in an alleyway behind a city building in his district. So I jumped in my car and I go over there.
23:08 Speaker 06 So I go into the alley and there are piles and piles of paper and bags and some of it shredded and some is not. And I got kind of angry and I was like, man, who throws all this stuff out here? So I started digging through the piles and I started finding all sorts of meter deal documents.
23:29 Speaker 03 Really?
23:30 Speaker 06 And I thought, what in the heck is this paper? And what is this? And what, wait a minute, what is this? Scott says he'd stumbled upon the motherload of Chicago parking meter deal documents, which had been hidden from city councilors, from Aldermen like him. So I started throwing some of it into my trunk.
23:50 Speaker 03 Uh huh.
23:52 Speaker 06 I'm standing there in the alley and I remember calling up my brother and I said, hey, there's a bunch of acronyms on some of these papers and this looks pretty shady. And I said, what does ADIA stand for? And he said, oh, that's Abu Dhabi Investment Agency. And I said, the meter system has been essentially sold off. They had flipped it over to.
24:20 Speaker 03 Abu Dhabi Investment Agency without telling anyone. We reached out to the Abu Dhabi Investment Authority. That's what it's called to see if they wanted to talk about this story. They declined. So did the city's CFO under Mayor Daley and the CEO of Chicago Parking Meters LLC did not respond to our request.
24:37 Speaker 06 Now, Scott later found out that only about 25% of the company had been sold to the Abu Dhabi Investment Authority. And he wasn't exactly annoyed that they specifically were getting the meter profits. It could have been anyone. He was more upset about the lack of transparency, that he, a city alderman, had no idea what was happening on his streets.
24:57 Speaker 03 But it wasn't clear exactly how bad the deal was until one person spent months actually running the numbers. His name? Aaron Feinstein. Aaron's a wonk. He's not afraid of an Excel formula. In 2008, he started looking into the parking deal when he was working for Chicago's Inspector General. He says the investigation took over his life. One day, he was checking in with his boss.
25:22 Speaker 05 And I remember saying to him just at one point, I was like, I hate parking meters. I've been thinking about parking meters for like four months and I can't, I just don't care. I hate parking meters.
25:33 Speaker 06 Alas, the investigation continued. Aaron's job was to write up a big report, a definitive accounting of the meter deal. He started asking questions of the city and its consultants. And because he worked for the inspector general, they were required to answer him. And some of their answers were kind of shocking.
25:52 Speaker 05 We asked them point blank, hey, what was the value of the city's parking meters to the city if the city had kept the meters for themselves and raised the rates, increased the hours of operation as outlined in the lease? Their response was, we did not do that. We did not consider what the value of the meters would be to the city if we had kept them under city management and raised the rates ourselves.
26:16 Speaker 03 That is the question, no?
26:18 Speaker 05 That's the, to me, that's the question. I couldn't believe that they put in writing that we, that they did not do that.
26:23 Speaker 06 I just, I, yeah, I think I probably very quickly was like, well, that's it. We should, that's it. The report's done. They didn't consider it. Ha, we got them. Let's go.
26:33 Speaker 03 Yeah, right then, Aaron realized the only thing the city calculated was what they could expect to get from the private sector, not what the parking meter profits were worth to citizens, to the city if they kept them.
26:44 Speaker 06 And for Aaron, one of the biggest problems was the discount rate the city used for the deal. He says it was just too high. Basically, the city undervalued the future profits.
26:55 Speaker 03 Aaron wanted to correct this. He did a bunch of research, called up experts across the world to see what discount rate he should use to figure out what the present value of the parking meter system was to Chicago, to its residents. And then he ran his own models, using a conservative estimate of profits and a less aggressive discount rate.
27:12 Speaker 06 We concluded that works out to a value of the city's parking meters in 2008 of 2.1 billion or so, so about $1 billion more than the city ended up selling it for.
27:26 Speaker 03 That's a huge difference.
27:28 Speaker 06 Yeah, that's like, that's like double, just about, just about. Aaron also looked at the length of the deal. He found that Chicago got 93% of the value of the deal out of the first half of the lease, the first 37 years, which means Chicago got pretty much nothing for the last half, the last 38 years. And why would you do that? And I don't know why. We pressed that point and they never responded to the length of the lease, which is, I think, the most egregious part of the, of the transaction is the length of the lease, that you've sort of made this decision for three generations of folks who live in the city of Chicago, and there's very little they can do to undo
28:12 Speaker 06 this decision.
28:14 Speaker 03 Does it make you angry?
28:17 Speaker 06 Uh, yes, I guess. Angry that it was just sort of a, this short-term Band-Aid solution to get through, you know, a single year or two's budget problem. And now the city has lost this asset that it used to have that turns out to be pretty valuable.
28:39 Speaker 03 It's still unclear whether this deal was so long and so bad because of negligence or myopia or just ineptitude. And in fairness to the city, they said that Aaron's estimates were unrealistic because they didn't have the political will to raise meter rates themselves. What is clear is that this deal has been super lucrative for the buyer's side. According to an audit published last year, the company that paid for the meter system has earned back their billion dollar plus investment and earned another $800 million on top of that. And there's still almost 60 years left on the contract.
29:15 Speaker 06 Yeah, Scott Wagasback, the alderman who voted against the deal, he still has a lot of feelings about how this all went down.
29:22 Speaker 05 It is the worst deal, I think, in municipal history in the United States.
29:26 Speaker 03 Wow.
29:27 Speaker 05 Oh, yeah, it's absolutely the worst deal in the history of municipalities.
29:33 Speaker 03 If you're running a postmortem on what makes this the worst deal of all time, it kind of boils down to three things. One, Chicago discounted the future too much. Two, they made the term of the lease too long. And three, they made the decision too quickly during a moment of crisis.
29:51 Speaker 06 All of this feels like kind of a case study about why privatization is such a controversial topic. The case for privatization, of course, is that there are times when the private sector can do things more efficiently or cheaply than the government. Or, as in this case, that it offers the government access to much needed revenue when they need it, instead of having to collect it quarter by quarter over decades. But if you don't actually do the math, actually tally up how much those meters would have paid out if the government kept them, or figure out how much it's worth to keep control over adding new bike lanes or closing off city blocks for a parade, you may just end up selling the farm for a pittance.
30:31 Speaker 03 There is one more reason that I think this deal has continued to piss everyone off. It's kind of a cynical take. I ran it by Scott, the alderman. I have this theory that the reason people really hate this deal is not necessarily because of the economics. It's because they have to feed the meters all the time and they interface with it all the time, right? Like, selling off the proceeds to a toll road used by out-of-towners or parking lots used by tourists is not as viscerally annoying than the parking meters. Do you think-
31:02 Speaker 05 I agree.
31:02 Speaker 03 -my theory holds? Yeah?
31:04 Speaker 05 Yeah, I agree with you. You know, when you're going across a bridge or something and, you know, you kind of put the money in for the easy pass, that's, you know, kind of quick. But when you're having to drive around the city and anywhere you pull up and you're putting money into that box and you're thinking, okay, hardly a dime of this is going to the city, that's money right out of your pocket for the next, you know, what is it, 60 plus years?
31:31 Speaker 03 Several generations.
31:31 Speaker 05 Yeah.
31:34 Speaker 05 Kids and grandkids will be paying for this thing for decades to come.
31:38 Speaker 06 Everyone who's ever visited a big city knows that finding a parking spot remains one of the great pains of modern urban life. But because of this deal, Chicagoans have also felt this additional sting. Now, every time they pop in a quarter, or many quarters, to feed the meter, instead of funding their own city, they are essentially renting back the space that used to belong to all of them, hour by hour, at cutthroat rates, until the meter contractually runs out on February 29th of 2084.
32:11 Speaker 03 Yeah, you heard that right. The contract, this whole situation, ends on a leap day.
32:23 Speaker 03 Hey, just a little reminder on how you can keep our meters running. Planet Money Plus supporters get every episode without any sponsor messages. They get bonus episodes, and, most importantly, they support this journalism that you're hearing right now, directly, which means we can rely less on sponsors or anyone. You can sign up at plus.npr.org/planetmoney.
32:44 Speaker 03 This episode was produced by Willa Rubin, with help from Luis Gallo and Samyala Horst Kessler. It was edited by Jess Jiang, fact-checked by Vito Emanuel, and engineered by Sina Lefredo. Alex Goldmark is our executive producer. Special thanks to Ben Girafsky, Tony Arnold, David Hoffman, and Matt Messbarger from Chicago's Clerk's Office, who found that amazing recording of the city council meeting. Also, big, big thanks to Henry Grabar. I first heard about this story from his terrific book, All About Parking. It's called "Paved Paradise." I really loved it. I'm Nick Fountain.
33:15 Speaker 06 I'm Alexia Horowitz-Gazi. This is NPR. Thanks for listening.
33:27 Speaker 00 Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors.
Previous Strange threadfellows: How the U.S. military shaped what we all wear Next PM does a pop culture draft: 1999 edition Page updated October 31, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated