Pod Insights Planet Money What "Made in China" actually means About this episode Virtually every product brought into the United States must have a so-called "country of origin." Think of it as the official place it comes from. And this is the country that counts for calculating tariffs.
But what does it really mean when something is a "Product of China"? How much of it actually comes from China? And how do customs officials draw the line?
Here in the U. S., the rules are delightfully counterintuitive. A product's country of origin is not necessarily where that product got on the container ship to come here. It's not necessarily where most of its ingredients are from or even where most of the manufacturing happened.
Our system is much stranger. The answers can be surprisingly philosophical — and at times, even poetic.
This episode of Planet Money was produced by James Sneed with help from Sylvie Douglis. It was edited by Jess Jiang, fact-checked by Sierra Juarez, and engineered by Kwesi Lee. Alex Goldmark is our executive producer.
Find more Planet Money: Facebook https://n.pr/3h92GwS / Instagram https://n.pr/3FqLuws / TikTok https://n.pr/3sGZdrq / Our weekly Newsletter https://n.pr/3zrFvUB.
Listen free at these links: Apple Podcasts http://n.pr/PM-digital, Spotify https://n.pr/3gTkQlR, the NPR app https://n.pr/3Bkb17W or anywhere you get podcasts.
Help support Planet Money and hear our bonus episodes by subscribing to Planet Money+ in Apple Podcasts http://n.pr/PM-digital or at plus.npr.org/planetmoney https://n.pr/3HlREPz.
See pcm.adswizz.com https://pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for sponsorship and to manage your podcast sponsorship preferences.
NPR Privacy Policy https://www.npr.org/about-npr/179878450/privacy-policy
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 This episode's sponsor is HubSpot, which offers the following message. What if, instead of updating your CRM, your CRM updated you? HubSpot's self-updating CRM keeps your customer context current, so you can win more deals. Learn more at hubspot.com.
0:17 Speaker 01 A quick note before we start today's show. You may have heard that President Trump has issued an executive order seeking to block all federal funding to NPR. Whatever changes this action brings, NPR's commitment to reporting the news will never change. Even as paywalls rise elsewhere, we offer this vital resource to everyone. Support the news and programming that you and millions rely on by visiting donate.npr.org. And if you already support us via NPR Plus or Planet Money Plus or any other way, thank you. Your support means so much to us, now more than ever.
0:52 Speaker 02 This is Planet Money from NPR.
0:58 Speaker 03 Maureen Thorson is a poet. She's published three books of poems. She's been featured in fancy literary journals, from The Horseless Review to Ploughshares.
1:08 Speaker 02 If you ask poets if they're having fun writing poetry, I think you would get very mixed reactions. I'm not sure we do it for fun in the typical sense of fun.
1:17 Speaker 03 As a poet, Maureen often finds herself puzzling over, you know, the fundamental nature of things. Like, what makes a chair a chair? Or a hat a hat? What makes this this and that that?
1:35 Speaker 04 And asking those questions is kind of her job, but not just because she's a poet. You see, Maureen also happens to be one of the top international trade lawyers in America. Sort of poet by night, trade lawyer by day.
1:48 Speaker 03 So you're like Hannah Montana, basically. Like, but I don't know which part is Miley Cyrus.
1:52 Speaker 02 I don't know either.
1:54 Speaker 03 It's the trade lawyer part, the Hannah Montana part, and then the poet part is the...
1:58 Speaker 02 Yeah, I'm not sure.
2:00 Speaker 04 As an international trade lawyer, Maureen helps companies navigate the complicated world of tariffs, a world that is also full of questions about what makes this this or that that.
2:12 Speaker 02 Pretty famous ones are our X-Men dolls or toys, our...
2:16 Speaker 03 I think we did an episode on that.
2:17 Speaker 02 Our hockey pants, clothing or equipment. Are certain cough drops, are they candy?
2:24 Speaker 03 OK, so the answers, by the way, are that most X-Men are toys, hockey pants are considered sports equipment, and cough drops, well, it actually depends on the ingredients.
2:33 Speaker 02 Some of these questions really get, I mean, you can, it kind of feels like you're staring into the void and it's staring back and whispering at you. Is it?
2:43 Speaker 03 Recently, the questions vexing Maureen have taken an even stranger and more philosophical turn. Maureen's clients, CEOs at companies, big and small, have been asking her about where things come from, their national identity, their country of origin. Like, what makes a Canadian product Canadian? Or a German product, German? Or especially, what makes a Chinese product Chinese? And when does it stop being Chinese?
3:13 Speaker 04 For Maureen's clients, those questions matter now more than ever. On April 2nd, President Donald Trump announced his plan to put big new tariffs on dozens of countries. And we caught up with Maureen just a couple days later.
3:25 Speaker 02 Oh, man. The past 48 hours have been completely bonkers. I am the human equivalent of a computer with 90 browser tabs open. So if I seem a bit dazed. I am dazed. That's why.
3:43 Speaker 03 Maureen's clients have been bombarding her with questions because millions of dollars are at stake. Whether something's a product of Canada, or Germany, or China, could soon mean the difference between no tariffs, or 20% tariffs, or more than 145% tariffs. These tariffs all depend on a product's country of origin.
4:04 Speaker 04 But figuring out something's country of origin is far from simple.
4:09 Speaker 02 So US law is very unique in its approach to country of origin.
4:14 Speaker 03 What's the part that is shocking to people?
4:17 Speaker 02 That there's not a nice, bright line, one-size-fits-all origin test.
4:24 Speaker 04 For example, imagine you take peanuts that were grown in China, ship them to a factory in Brazil, and grind them into peanut butter. Is that peanut butter a product of China, or has it become a product of Brazil?
4:36 Speaker 03 Maureen says people often assume that there must be some logical method, like maybe just compare the costs of the ingredients and the labor that come from each different country or something. And she has to tell them, oh, no. The way we do it in the United States is a lot weirder, a lot more confusing, and a lot more unpredictable. Hello and welcome to Planet Money. I'm Jeff Guo.
5:02 Speaker 04 And I'm Alexei Horowitz-Gazi. Virtually everything that's imported into the United States, by law, must have a so-called country of origin, the place where it officially came from. And figuring out that country of origin matters, because that's what customs goes by when it's enforcing tariffs.
5:19 Speaker 03 Today on the show, when you buy something at the store and it says "Made in China," or "Made in France," or "Made in the USA," what does that actually mean? How much of it actually came from China, or France, or the USA? And in this age of supply chains that crisscross the world, does our system even make sense anymore?
5:41 Speaker 00 Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors.
5:46 Speaker 05 This message comes from BetterHelp. Your brain has limited storage, so why is it still holding on to that embarrassing moment from years ago? BetterHelp is an online therapy platform that gives you space to talk about what's taking up too much of yours. BetterHelp is now in-network with more than 125 health plans, with mini co-pays as low as $15 for eligible members. And if you don't have eligible insurance, you can still get 20% off your first month. Visit betterhelp.com/NPR. Cost and coverage may vary. Discount cannot be combined with insurance. This message comes from LinkedIn. As a small business owner, you wear many hats. You're the owner, the marketer, the seller, the hire. With LinkedIn, you have the tools to help you boost your visibility,
6:31 Speaker 05 find prospective customers, and find the best team for your small business, all in one place. So while LinkedIn can't hang up all of your hats, it makes it easier to wear them all. Learn more at LinkedIn.com/PlanetMoneyShow.
6:47 Speaker 03 Take any object that might be around you. I mean it, like a pencil, a TV remote, a pair of earbuds. Hold it in your hand and look closely. Chances are, you're going to see a little label. Maybe it's engraved, maybe it's printed that says "Made in China," or "Made in Malaysia," or "Made in USA." Maureen says her clients are often surprised to find out that those words can mean very, very different things. There are actually two sets of rules here. One for American products and one for products from the rest of the world.
7:19 Speaker 04 So let's start with the rules for American products. When something says it's "Made in USA," that doesn't just mean that it's manufactured in the United States. It also means that virtually all of the parts and ingredients and labor came from the USA.
7:33 Speaker 02 "Made in USA" means this is pretty much fully USA, down to the soles of its little American shoes. And it doesn't have almost any foreign material in it.
7:48 Speaker 04 There are some exceptions for things like clothing and some types of meat. But basically, if an American product isn't 100% American, it cannot say "Made in the USA."
7:59 Speaker 03 This is why you sometimes see things that say, "Assembled in America with foreign parts." But for American products, there is also the option to just not have a label at all. So when you go to the store, you might notice some products that don't tell you where they come from.
8:15 Speaker 02 I see it a lot with sort of cosmetic-adjacent goods, like shampoos.
8:22 Speaker 03 Oh, interesting.
8:22 Speaker 02 And my assumption is they are actually making the shampoo in the United States, but they're probably importing fragrance from abroad and other things.
8:32 Speaker 03 Yeah, these are American products. They're just not 100% American. So they can't use the "Made in USA" label.
8:40 Speaker 04 The rules are very different for products that are not American. Basically, anything that's imported has to be labeled with the main country it came from, its so-called country of origin. That's been the law since 1890, when Congress wanted consumers to know where their imported products were coming from. So those labels that say product of China or product of France, they are not optional.
9:03 Speaker 03 You can think of country of origin as kind of like a product's citizenship. But in the US, how we determine that country of origin can be wildly counterintuitive. It's not necessarily where that product got on the container ship to come here. It's not necessarily where most of its ingredients are from, or even where most of the manufacturing happened.
9:24 Speaker 02 You can have products, including fairly sophisticated products, where most of the components and the assembly is all happening in China, but the product is not deemed Chinese under US laws.
9:36 Speaker 04 Maureen has helped companies import a lot of different products. She's not allowed to say exactly what she's worked on, but it's things like industrial engines and smartphones, and also flowerpots. She helps companies figure out that product's country of origin, get it labeled right, and declare it to customs.
9:53 Speaker 02 This is something that a lot of importers are confused about. US Customs doesn't have some kind of giant list of all the products in the world with a big chart of their origins and their tariff classifications.
10:06 Speaker 03 Wait, they don't?
10:07 Speaker 02 No, they don't.
10:08 Speaker 03 It seems like that's their job.
10:10 Speaker 02 No, that's your job, Mr. Importer.
10:13 Speaker 03 So you have to self-declare?
10:14 Speaker 02 You do. And then customs can come back and say, hey, so I noticed this particular product was shipped out of Thailand, but you claimed it as Japanese. Prove it.
10:27 Speaker 04 Now, we should say, for many years, companies didn't think too, too hard about country of origin. Most of the time, what you labeled something or what you declared to customs didn't matter that much, because for most countries, tariffs didn't really differ that much.
10:41 Speaker 03 But then, Donald Trump was elected president for his first term, and country of origin suddenly started to matter a lot. Because in 2018, Trump put big tariffs on lots of Chinese products. And how does customs determine what is a Chinese product? Well, it's anything whose country of origin is China. That is when Maureen's phone started ringing off the hook.
11:05 Speaker 02 So suddenly, companies were coming in and saying, well...
11:10 Speaker 02 I do do some manufacturing in China, but a lot of my parts are coming from outside of China. Or I'm really only sending this thing to China for packaging or testing. Do I still have to pay duties on this as a product of China? Even though, I mean, I'm exporting it from China, but am I really making it in China?
11:30 Speaker 04 Other companies were trying to switch up their manufacturing so their products wouldn't count as made in China anymore. They're asking Maureen, how much can I bend the definition of made in China?
11:41 Speaker 02 If I move some or all of my manufacturing operations from China to Malaysia or China to Vietnam, how much do I have to move before the goods will no longer be considered Chinese by US Customs and I don't have to pay duties on Chinese products?
11:58 Speaker 03 And whenever clients ask Maureen questions like this, which they are doing more and more these days, she has to take a deep breath, sit them down, and say, "Okay, here is how we determine a product's country of origin. There's one main rule in the US. It is called the substantial transformation test. And it says a product gets its country of origin from the last place where it went through a substantial transformation."
12:26 Speaker 02 A substantial transformation is processing from which the article emerges with a new name, use, or character.
12:34 Speaker 03 Are you literally quoting this test?
12:36 Speaker 02 I believe I am. I have had to--
12:40 Speaker 03 It sounds like you've memorized it, like word for word.
12:42 Speaker 02 I am intimately familiar with this phrasing.
12:45 Speaker 04 A new name, use, or character. That is the entire rule. And the way it works is if you send something to, say, Vietnam, and there you change it enough that you're basically turning it into a new thing, you're giving it a new name, use, or character, then that thing now counts as a product of Vietnam.
13:04 Speaker 02 A new name, use, or character. Wow, that's super easy to say. But as you try to apply it to everything in the universe, from lawn chairs to fruit salad to a bottle of aspirin, you get into some philosophical questions about the thinginess of things. Where is the fruit salad-ness of a fruit salad imparted to the fruit salad? Oh, OK.
13:30 Speaker 03 Maureen says to really understand the substantial transformation test, you have to understand where it came from and the history of how courts and customs officials have tried to apply it. For that, we called up someone who is an expert in this history. He's kind of a legend of trade law. His name is Larry Friedman, and Maureen actually knows him pretty well.
13:50 Speaker 02 Hey, Larry. I just had emails with Larry today.
13:53 Speaker 03 Did you really?
13:54 Speaker 02 Yeah. He's so nice about answering my emails, and I try to repay that kindness by not emailing him unless I am like, I am so genuinely stumped.
14:04 Speaker 03 Wait, so is Larry like your Yoda?
14:06 Speaker 02 I think he's kind of like a universal Yoda for the customs bar.
14:10 Speaker 06 That's a funny, that is a funny thing. I did tell her the other day, there is no try, there is only do. I did not say that.
14:19 Speaker 03 Larry is a longtime trade lawyer. He's taught trade law at the University of Illinois, and he co-wrote the textbook on customs law.
14:27 Speaker 04 Larry says the origin of the substantial transformation test was this Supreme Court case from 1908 involving corks. A US company was importing corks from Spain, cleaning them up a bit, stamping on a logo, and the Supreme Court said, that is not a substantial transformation because cleaning up the corks did not give them a new name, it didn't change how they were used, and it didn't really even change their character. They started out as corks, and they were still corks here in the US.
14:56 Speaker 03 This Supreme Court cork case created the idea that in order for something to really be transformed, you have to give it a new character or name or use. Is, is that phrase, new character, name, or use? Is that just like tattooed on your heart?
15:15 Speaker 06 It is, it is embedded in my brain. It'll probably be tattooed on me someplace sometime.
15:21 Speaker 03 Or just put it on your tombstone, I don't know.
15:23 Speaker 06 Put that in my will. Here, here lies Larry with a new name, character, and use.
15:28 Speaker 03 Oh, no. I'm sorry, it took us there.
15:31 Speaker 04 To tell the story of how the thinking around name, character, and use has evolved over the decades, we're going to walk through three examples. The first one is from the 1940s, and it involves hairbrushes.
15:43 Speaker 06 A company in the US made brushes. So they imported wooden handles from Japan. The handle had no bristle on it. In the United States, they put the bristles on, and it became a brush.
15:57 Speaker 03 Now, Customs wanted the company to call these hairbrushes "Japanese," because the majority of the brush was the wooden handle, which came from Japan. But the company disagreed. So the question for the court was, did this simple act of adding bristles to that wooden handle transform it into an American hairbrush?
16:17 Speaker 04 That's going to be a big yes for me, Doug. Look, this thing's getting a new name, a character, and a new use. You can't just use some block of wood to brush your hair. Come on.
16:25 Speaker 03 Right. And that is exactly what the judge said. The judge said, "There is a substantial transformation here. What you now have is an American hairbrush." And Larry says this hairbrush case shows you how even a basic manufacturing step, like gluing some bristles on, can change a product's country of origin.
16:44 Speaker 04 But by the 1980s, manufacturing was getting way more complicated. You could argue that any step in the process changed a product's name, character, or use. So where would courts draw the line? All of this came to a head in a fight over... Boachews. That's coming up after the break.
17:08 Speaker 00 Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors.
17:12 Speaker 05 This message comes from LinkedIn. As a small business owner, you wear many hats. You're the owner, the marketer, the seller, the hire. With LinkedIn, you have the tools to help you boost your visibility, find prospective customers, and find the best team for your small business, all in one place. So while LinkedIn can't hang up all of your hats, it makes it easier to wear them all. Learn more at LinkedIn.com/PlanetMoneyShow.
17:39 Speaker 00 This episode's sponsor is HubSpot, which offers the following message: What if instead of updating your CRM, your CRM updated you? No catching up on manual edits, no more guesswork. HubSpot's self-updating CRM keeps your customer context current and helps you understand what to do next. So, marketing builds more demand, sales wins more deals, and customers keep coming back. Learn more at hubspot.com.
18:04 Speaker 05 This message comes from NPR sponsor, Charles Schwab. When is the right time to sell a stock? How do you protect against inflation? Financial decisions can be tricky, and often, your own cognitive and emotional biases can lead you astray. Financial Decoder, an original podcast from Charles Schwab, can help. Join host Mark Reapy as he offers practical solutions to help overcome the cognitive and emotional biases that may affect your investing decisions. Download the latest episode and subscribe at schwab.com/financialdecoder.
18:40 Speaker 03 If you look at how modern manufacturing works these days, it's hard to pinpoint exactly where a thing even becomes a thing, because most things are manufactured in many different steps, scattered across the world.
18:53 Speaker 04 Yeah, a smartphone might be made out of parts from dozens of countries, and those parts themselves are made up of other, smaller parts from dozens of other countries, all of which makes the process of trying to figure out something's country of origin incredibly tricky.
19:07 Speaker 03 In the 1980s, courts were just starting to confront this confusing new reality in a case about boat shoes, specifically Sperry topsiders. You know, those preppy-looking leather shoes with the rubber sole? The company making those shoes, they were getting the upper half from Indonesia.
19:24 Speaker 06 The upper included everything that you see, basically, above the sole of the...
19:30 Speaker 04 Shoe, so it was kind of like a sturdy sock.
19:35 Speaker 03 Like it's a shoe, but without like the rubber part that makes you able to use the shoe as an implement to walk on, basically.
19:41 Speaker 04 Exactly.
19:42 Speaker 03 The company would take those leather uppers and then in the United States glue and stitch on the rubber soles. And the question was, did that count as a substantial transformation? Did the act of attaching soles on to those uppers turn them into American shoes? Or was the finished shoe still a product of Indonesia?
20:02 Speaker 04 Well, based on the hairbrush case we talked about, it seems like you wouldn't have a functioning shoe here until you glued on that sole. Like, that's the step that would create a change in the name and use and character, right?
20:13 Speaker 03 Yes, right? But no. The court said what is happening here in the US is just too simple. They were like, you're just assembling these pre-made parts. The real work to make the shoe, the complicated process of cutting and sewing all this leather, that happened in Indonesia. So this shoe, even though you finished it in the US, has to be labeled as an Indonesian shoe.
20:38 Speaker 04 The name of this big boat shoes case was Uniroil. And Larry says Uniroil spread the idea that a substantial transformation involves more than just giving something a new name or character or use. You might have to change something's essence.
20:52 Speaker 06 According to the judge, the essence of the shoe was not substantially transformed and it remained a product of whatever country that upper came from.
21:03 Speaker 03 Maybe I misunderstand what a shoe really is. And if so, that's on me, that's my bad. But if the shoe doesn't have the sole, if it doesn't have the literal like rubber or whatever that protects your feet from the harsh realities of the ground, then it's not a shoe.
21:27 Speaker 06 Yeah, you're right. I think Uniroil is not a good decision.
21:31 Speaker 03 Yeah, Larry's not the only one who thinks this was not a good decision. But the Boat Shoes case set a really influential precedent. As manufacturing has gotten more complicated, courts and customs officials have focused more and more on what is the essence of a product? And when does that change? And you could see this maybe as a more stringent way of looking at a product's character. So it's no longer enough to just change a product's character. You have to change something essential about its character.
22:02 Speaker 04 These days, you can build an entire laptop in China, where most of the parts and labor come from China. But if the motherboard is from Vietnam, customs might say that laptop is actually Vietnamese. Because the essence of the laptop is in the motherboard.
22:18 Speaker 03 So what is the essence of something? What is the essence of anything? This is the new question at the heart of the substantial transformation test. And it's now creating all kinds of strange puzzles. Like in our final example, which involves sticky notes. You know, like Post-its, those pads of paper. You peel off a sheet and stick it to the wall, stick it to the fridge, stick it to your forehead.
22:41 Speaker 04 Yes, and this sticky sticky note situation happened back in 2020. This was shortly after Trump put a bunch of tariffs on products from China. And Staples, the office supply company, was trying to figure out, what is the country of origin of our sticky notes? Like, do we have to pay the tariffs on China?
23:00 Speaker 03 And Staples was wondering this because they had a whole multinational plan for manufacturing these sticky notes. First, they would start with the paper, a jumbo roll about three feet long. And this would come from either Japan or Indonesia. Then, the sticky stuff, a special patented glue. And this would come from Taiwan. Finally, the assembly. A machine would unspool that giant roll of paper, apply the glue, cut the paper into sheets. And out would come the Post-its. All these final steps would happen in China.
23:32 Speaker 04 And the decision that customs came to about where the sticky notes were last substantially transformed, it really threw us for a loop. So we asked Maureen Thorson to help us make sense of their logic.
23:42 Speaker 02 I'd actually read that ruling before. So I was like, oh, the sticky note one. Okay, okay, yeah, sticky notes.
23:49 Speaker 03 So in this ruling, Customs wrestled with the question of, what is the essence of a sticky note? Is it the paper that you write on? Is it the glue that makes it sticky? Or is a sticky note not really a sticky note until you put the glue and the paper together?
24:07 Speaker 04 Yeah, I'm gonna go out on an obvious limb here and say that it seems like the essence of a sticky note is like the meeting of paper and glue. It's like the moment where the paper and the glue come together.
24:16 Speaker 03 Right, I feel like that is what most people would say. And yet, here's what Customs decided. They said, when you get down to it, we think that the essence of a sticky note is really the paper.
24:30 Speaker 02 A sticky note kind of started its life as paper. It ends its life as paper, and it's not particularly heavily processed paper. And so the underlying material is really what's important here, and that's paper. And the paper is the jumbo roll.
24:44 Speaker 03 Okay, but Maureen.
24:46 Speaker 02 Yeah.
24:47 Speaker 03 I have a piece of paper right here.
24:48 Speaker 02 Yes.
24:49 Speaker 03 I have a piece of paper right here, okay? It's not a sticky note, it's just a piece of paper. And look.
24:56 Speaker 03 It's not sticking. It's not sticking. It's not sticking to the wall.
24:59 Speaker 02 Yeah, that's the goofy bit about the sticky notes ruling is I think it is a perfectly rational point of view to say the sticky noteness of a sticky note is the sticky bit. You know, that's what makes... So putting glue on it should be what's substantially transformative.
25:14 Speaker 04 But Customs did not see it that way. And partly, they were thinking, well, is it that big of a deal to just cut up some paper and add glue to it? We should be focused on the more complicated step of actually making the paper. Because the paper is the essence of a sticky note.
25:30 Speaker 02 So the sticky note ruling is a bit unusual, but if you dig into their logic, I think they were persuaded by the fact that, what do you use a sticky note for? To write on, like paper, because it's made of paper. So it's the paper that is important here. The stickiness is a bell and whistle to the sticky note, not the essence of the sticky note, not the character of the sticky note, even as you're scratching your head and going, but it's sticky, sticky note.
25:57 Speaker 03 So according to customs, the country of origin of these sticky notes would not be Taiwan, where the glue came from. It wouldn't be China, where the roll of paper would, you know, actually get chopped up and glued up and turned into sticky notes. No. Customs said these sticky notes would be considered products of the country where the original paper came from, either Japan or Indonesia. So staples would not have to pay the tariff on Chinese products. The sticky note case really shows you what has happened to the substantial transformation test, how unpredictable it can be nowadays. Because more than ever, courts and customs officials are asking these weird philosophical questions, like, what is the essence of a
26:42 Speaker 03 sticky note? When does a sticky note become its true self? Questions that are hard to answer in any kind of consistent way, which can land you in some pretty absurd places.
26:54 Speaker 04 And there is another way to do this. Whenever we sign individual free trade agreements with other countries, they will often insist on not using our weird loosey-goosey substantial transformation test. For our free trade deal with Canada and Mexico, we had to agree on a new system with a whole compendium of extremely specific rules for determining a product's country of origin. Depending on the product, the rules might have to do with how much labor came from a country, or the value of the parts that came from a country, or even whether a key chemical reaction happened in a given country.
27:29 Speaker 03 Now, there are a few reasons why the substantial transformation test is still, by and large, the law of the land in the US. For one, this is just the way we've always done it. And the test is really flexible. It doesn't require any complicated accounting, or record-keeping, or compendiums of rules.
27:49 Speaker 04 But also, country of origin just didn't matter as much in the past. For decades, our tariffs treated most countries more or less the same. But recently, that has all started to change. Since April, Maureen's been on the phone with her clients at all hours, trying to explain to them our weird and wacky system of determining country of origin.
28:08 Speaker 03 What's the reaction from your clients when they're like, Maureen, can you just tell me, what country of origin is this product? And you're like, oh, hold on, there's a whole... Yes. What is their reaction?
28:21 Speaker 02 It really depends. Everything from stunned disbelief, where the reaction was, it can't possibly work like that. That can't possibly be right. To, OK, let's figure it out.
28:38 Speaker 03 Maureen figures it out by talking to the engineers, asking for design sketches, getting a whole list of materials. And then she sees if she can try to make an argument for whatever country she thinks the country of origin is. For companies trying to avoid China as their country of origin, Maureen might help them figure out how much of their manufacturing they actually have to move out of China. Or maybe they can keep making the product in China, they just have to get a key component, the essence of the product, from a different country. That's kind of the game these days. And lawyers like Maureen are in high demand. Lawyers who can, you know, wax poetic about the real, deep-down essences of things.
29:30 Speaker 03 This episode of Planet Money was produced by James Snead with help from Sylvie Douglas. It was edited by Jess Jang, fact-checked by Sierra Juárez, and engineered by Kwesi Lee. Alex Goldmark is our executive producer.
29:40 Speaker 04 Special thanks to Bill Reinch, Robert Shapiro, and Damon Pike. I'm Alexi Horowitz-Ghazi.
29:45 Speaker 03 And I'm Jeff Guo. This is NPR. Thanks for listening.
29:53 Speaker 05 Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors.
Previous Why it's so hard to find a public toilet Next Is the reign of the dollar over? Page updated November 3, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated