Pod Insights Planet Money The Invention Invention About this episode Book tour tickets and details here https://tix.to/pm-book-tour.
Today, the story of three inventions. The first, the sewing machine, was created by a selfish and ambitious inventor who wanted all the credit and was willing to fight a war for it.
The second, a more modern invention, was made by an Italian inventor who wanted only to connect the world through video, so “evvvvverybody can talk with evvvvverybody else.”
And, a third invention that tied them both together across more than a century. The patent pool.
How do people get motivated to invent, and how do they get rewarded for their ideas? Usually through a patent. And, when the thicket of patents becomes too thick, how do we simplify, and make it so inventors can work together? The answer will involve bitter rivals, a sewing machine war, the nine no-no’s of anti-trust, and something called a gob-feeder.
Subscribe to Planet Money+ https://n.pr/3HlREPz
Listen free: Apple Podcasts http://n.pr/PM-digital, Spotify https://n.pr/3gTkQlR, the NPR app https://n.pr/3Bkb17W or anywhere you get podcasts.
Facebook https://n.pr/3h92GwS / Instagram https://n.pr/3FqLuws / TikTok https://n.pr/3sGZdrq / Our weekly Newsletter https://n.pr/3zrFvUB.
This episode was hosted by Erika Beras and Sam Yellowhorse Kesler. It was produced by Luis Gallo and edited by Marianne McCune. It was fact-checked by Sierra Juarez and engineered by Cena Loffredo. Alex Goldmark is Planet Money's executive producer.
See pcm.adswizz.com https://pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for sponsorship and to manage your podcast sponsorship preferences.
NPR Privacy Policy https://www.npr.org/about-npr/179878450/privacy-policy
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 This message comes from Aura. A data breach may have exposed millions of driver's licenses in the US. Aura alerts you fast if your info shows up in a breach, then locks your credit card and provides US-based fraud support. Visit aura.com/NPR to learn more.
0:18 Speaker 01 Hey, this is Erica Barris. Before we get to the show, I wanted to tell you how excited I am to see you, our listeners, in person on our book tour in Pittsburgh. I may have a news story I want to workshop with you all, and I'm going to be talking with Carnegie Mellon's Kevin Zolman, the author of The Game Theorist's Guide to Parenting. The Planet Money book tour is going to a dozen cities. Every stop will be totally unique with different hosts and guests. And if you get a ticket, you can get a tour-exclusive tote bag with your purchase while supplies last. Find the show nearest to you at the link in the show notes or go to planetmoneybook.com. And thank you.
1:05 Speaker 01 This is Planet Money from NPR.
1:11 Speaker 02 When I think of an inventor, I think of somebody like this guy.
1:14 Speaker 03 My name is Leonardo Caddigione.
1:18 Speaker 01 An Italian inventor named Leonardo? Like, come on. He's very passionate, very smart, and very precise.
1:27 Speaker 02 You speak five languages, is that true?
1:30 Speaker 03 So this means that you have consulted Wikipedia about me?
1:34 Speaker 01 Yes.
1:35 Speaker 03 And that is something that I really hate.
1:38 Speaker 01 Leonardo does actually speak five languages, including Japanese. He just doesn't want some random person on Wikipedia speaking for him.
1:47 Speaker 03 When I will be dead, I mean, people can talk as authoritatively or not about myself, but as long as I'm alive, I am the only one that describes myself.
1:56 Speaker 02 Yeah, he wants to be the one to write his own story, which, for our purposes, is not just a story about Leonardo and his invention. It's a story about how we even think about the nature of invention.
2:08 Speaker 01 It begins back in the 1980s when Leonardo was working at what is now Telecom Italia, and he had a big idea.
2:16 Speaker 03 My dream was, I want a world where everybody can talk with everybody else.
2:22 Speaker 02 The vision Leonardo had is pretty much the one we live with today. It's a world where it's easy to share media, and in particular, video.
2:30 Speaker 03 I want a television that goes everywhere.
2:33 Speaker 01 Leonardo had this idea back in the days of analog television. Video was stored on tape. Think cassettes, VHS. It was fragile and clunky and difficult to store, but also to transmit, like to TVs. So broadcasters were looking to digital video, but that was in its early stages.
2:52 Speaker 02 The problem with the new digital video files was that they were also really big, like both virtually and physically. Like, take, for example, an hour of television. On digital, it would take up a lot of space.
3:03 Speaker 03 Probably something like 100 hard disks.
3:08 Speaker 02 100 disks, just for one hour of television?
3:12 Speaker 03 Yes.
3:13 Speaker 01 These large files were, again, hard to transmit. So if digital video was going to take off across the world, Leonardo realized that broadcasters everywhere would need a smaller, maybe even tiny, file to make transmitting it easier and less expensive. So...
3:27 Speaker 03 I invented the thing called MPEG.
3:30 Speaker 01 MPEG, M-P-E-G. What is an MPEG?
3:36 Speaker 03 What is? Oh, it's many things.
3:38 Speaker 01 Oh.
3:38 Speaker 03 MPEG is the name of a file format.
3:42 Speaker 01 Uh huh.
3:42 Speaker 03 And then MPEG is the name of... I'm sending you an MPEG.
3:46 Speaker 01 Uh huh.
3:48 Speaker 02 Yeah, that is the way most people would know MPEG. MPEG is a kind of file format for video files, kind of like a JPG for pictures or an MP3 for audio. MPEG took huge video files and compressed them, made them way smaller to make it easier and cheaper to store video, to download it and to play it across different old-school electronics.
4:08 Speaker 01 But Leonardo didn't invent the actual technology. He was more like the mastermind, pulling together a bunch of different technological innovations from a bunch of different companies to make a new thing. That's how it got that weird name, MPEG. It stands for Moving Pictures Experts Group.
4:26 Speaker 02 And the reason we called up Leonardo isn't to understand this technology he brought into the world. Rather, it's because of what it took for MPEG to succeed. Because MPEG raised a huge, important question about when inventors can and cannot work together under the eyes of the law.
4:42 Speaker 01 See, MPEG was sort of like a new language for digital video. And in order for his MPEG to succeed as that new language, all the electronics that stored, sent, and received the video, they all had to speak that same language.
4:57 Speaker 02 Which meant the companies making and running those electronics needed to agree, okay, we're all going to use it. We're all going to speak the language of MPEG. What were some of the things that you realized at the outset would cause problems for you?
5:11 Speaker 03 No, simply that people would not care. That is the worst, the worst thing that can happen. So I had the vision, but you know, you have to have that vision accepted.
5:25 Speaker 01 That was the next big hurdle, because there were all these competing digital formats, and people were divided about which language to speak.
5:33 Speaker 02 So for MPEG to succeed, Leonardo and Telecom Italia needed a bunch of companies to all get together and make a collective choice, to say, we're all going to make sure that this digital format will work on our machines. So our machines can all work together, like a signing of contract of sorts.
5:48 Speaker 01 And in fact, a bunch of companies liked MPEG and did want to do that. But there was just one little problem. Was this agreement between these companies to use this new language collaboration? Or was it collusion?
6:05 Speaker 02 Hello and welcome to Planet Money. I'm Sam Yellowhorse Kesler.
6:08 Speaker 01 And I'm Erica Barris. When Leonardo and a bunch of companies and inventors all wanted to collaborate to make the MPEG the new Efficient Language of Digital Video, there was just one big problem. American antitrust law barred companies from making collective decisions to stamp out their competition.
6:28 Speaker 02 So to convince the government that this collaboration was not only legal, but that it would be a boon to people everywhere, they had to look to another invention, one from more than a century earlier, the Singer sewing machine.
6:43 Speaker 01 Today on the show, how the Singer sewing machine laid the groundwork for inventors to collaborate without colluding, and how it created the technological world we live in today.
6:55 Speaker 02 It's the story of the rise and fall and second coming of the patent pool.
7:05 Speaker 00 Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors.
7:09 Speaker 04 This message comes from Avalara Aviator. Aviator is the agent hub for tax and compliance. If you've listened to enough podcasts, you know a confident answer isn't necessarily a correct one. Sources matter. The same goes for AI, tax, and compliance. Aviator is grounded in 20-plus years of Avalara tax intelligence and delivers source-backed, audit-defensible outcomes with human oversight built in. Because the AI said so, won't pass an audit. Visit avalara.com/aviator.
7:40 Speaker 00 This message comes from Mint Mobile. Ditch overpriced wireless and get premium wireless for less. Go to mintmobile.com/switch to see which plan works for you. This message comes from BetterHelp. BetterHelp is in-network with more than 125 health plans, with an average copay for eligible members of just $23 per session. Don't have eligible insurance? You can still get 10% off your first month. Visit betterhelp.com/NPR to explore your payment options. That's better H E L P dot com slash NPR.
8:15 Speaker 01 Okay, so our Italian inventor Leonardo and a bunch of huge companies wanted to make the MPeg a universal language for sharing video. But all those companies needed to figure out a way to collaborate without colluding. And that was a complicated endeavor. How do you make a big, complex technological agreement simple and legal? The answer was hidden in the story of another invention from more than a century earlier. The Singer sewing machine, invented by Isaac Merritt Singer.
8:49 Speaker 02 Your clothes, the ones you may or may not be wearing right now, I don't want to judge how you listen to podcasts. There is a decent chance that they were made using a Singer sewing machine. And the man behind the Singer sewing machine was another one of those colorful, somewhat particular inventors.
9:04 Speaker 05 He was described by some people as an irascible scoundrel. He had a violent temper.
9:11 Speaker 01 Michael Madioli is a law professor at Indiana University, and he's written a ton about patents, including Singer's.
9:17 Speaker 05 He was also married to at least five women under different names.
9:22 Speaker 01 At the same time?
9:24 Speaker 05 At the same time, yes.
9:25 Speaker 02 Okay, we looked it up, and it wasn't five at the same time. Maybe three. Plus, there were a bunch of mistresses.
9:31 Speaker 01 He also had 20 children, and he acknowledged. Michael told us Singer was an actor, but he was better at inventing things. He invented a drill to bore through rocks. He also invented a tool for engraving text into wood.
9:44 Speaker 02 Back in 1850, Singer was in Boston, where he happened upon this sort of rudimentary sewing machine. It was nothing like the one we know today. It had a hand crank and a curved needle, and it kind of moved up and down like a stapler.
9:57 Speaker 05 And the story goes that he saw this machine and said, I could do better.
10:02 Speaker 01 Right off the bat, he saw a few major improvements he could make.
10:06 Speaker 05 He came up with the idea that you could have a straight needle that would be suspended from an arm overhead.
10:11 Speaker 01 Singer started toiling away, working day and night.
10:15 Speaker 05 Someone would hold the lamp for him, actually, while he would try to make the machine work.
10:20 Speaker 01 In accounts of his life, Singer says that late one night, he and that lamp holder guy were doing their inventor thing, racking their brains, trying to get the machine to sew tighter stitches. They kept testing it, but something just wasn't right.
10:33 Speaker 02 So, feeling dejected, they headed back for the night. But on their way around 1 a.m., this guy turns to Singer and he says, "Hey, did you notice those funny little loops of thread on the seam?" And Singer says, "By God." He actually said that. The lamp holder guy wrote it down because he didn't like that Singer curses so much. He said, "By God, we need to add tension to the thread."
10:51 Speaker 05 So they ran back to the machine shop, adjusted the tension, and tried the machine. And they got at least five perfect stitches. The thread snapped, but that was enough to see that the secret was all in the tension of the string.
11:07 Speaker 01 Singer made some adjustments, so the thread didn't snap. And there it was, his invention, the Singer sewing machine. He got his patent in 1851.
11:17 Speaker 02 And for Singer, this patent was government-issued proof that he was the inventor and owner of this technology, his machine. It meant only he could profit off of it. And that's what patents do. They are basically like little government-granted monopolies that incentivize innovation.
11:33 Speaker 01 And Singer's patent was a huge success. Within a couple of years, the Singer Corporation was making hundreds of sewing machines. His machine won a prize at the 1855 World's Fair, and Singer became wealthy.
11:47 Speaker 02 But with that wealth came enemies. A sewing machine war was brewing. Because what you have to keep in mind is this was the Industrial Revolution, a time in history when lots of people were inventing lots of things. And some were standing on each other's shoulders and others were stepping on each other's toes.
12:03 Speaker 01 So Singer was making his name in the sewing machine world. Someone else was sitting on the sidelines, seething. Another inventor who'd already made another sewing machine similar to that janky one, Singer faced his machine on.
12:20 Speaker 05 Elias Howe Jr. fired the first legal shots in the war.
12:25 Speaker 01 Elias Howe had also patented part of his sewing machine. And in fact, Singer had used a part of Howe's invention in his machine. But he never made any money off of it. He did not get wealthy. So when Howe saw Singer's growing fortune, he saw an opportunity, and he sued Singer.
12:48 Speaker 05 That was sort of the battle, and it led to the war.
12:52 Speaker 02 The two of them took out ads in newspapers, each saying they were the proper inventor of the sewing machine. Howe wrote, "You that want sewing machines, be cautious how you purchase them." Singer retorted, "Machines made according to Howe's patent are of no practical use."
13:07 Speaker 01 Singer fought back. He made threats.
13:09 Speaker 05 He threatened to kick Howe down a flight of stairs.
13:13 Speaker 01 He didn't. At least, we don't think he did. Eventually, Singer agreed to pay Howe 15,000 old-timey dollars, plus royalties on every sewing machine sold. So a compromise.
13:25 Speaker 02 But the fight brought all this attention to the new sewing machine. All these other inventors with less successful sewing machine patents turned up out of the woodwork and sued. Grover and Baker and Wheeler and Wilson. Singer sued Grover and Baker. Grover and Baker sued Wheeler and Wilson. Wheeler and Wilson sued Singer. This was the sewing machine war. They all said that some component of the sewing machine was invented by them.
13:50 Speaker 05 Singer had to make a closet to store all of his legal files.
13:54 Speaker 01 This could not go on. All of these competing patents claiming ownership over some part of the sewing machine. It wasn't only bad for Singer, but it seemed bad for industry, for inventors of all kinds. Like, why would anyone invent anything if they would then be sued by everyone who ever had a similar idea?
14:13 Speaker 02 Yeah, Singer had done something that hadn't been done before. He made a functioning sewing machine, one that improved on everyone else's designs. In other words, he innovated. And all these lawsuits and petty inventors, they were bad for innovation. They were creating what is known as a patent thicket.
14:28 Speaker 01 Like a thicket of patented ideas that you gotta machete your way through before you can even go about making something new.
14:35 Speaker 02 To solve this patent thicket problem, a new idea was needed. And this time, it didn't come from an inventor. It came from a lawyer. His name was Orlando B. Potter.
14:45 Speaker 01 And he thought, what if all these competitors could stop fighting each other and put their patents together into one big pool? Take all their best ideas for different parts of the machine and make it so any of the companies could use them.
15:00 Speaker 05 So he pointed out all of these rivals were harming themselves. He was the first to suggest that they could all benefit just by cooperating.
15:09 Speaker 02 And by God, Grover and Baker, Wheeler and Wilson, and Singer, and Howe, they all agreed in 1856, they all signed an agreement and created one big collective patent pool. So now every time one of the companies made a sewing machine, they would pay $15 and that would be divided among the members of the pool.
15:27 Speaker 01 Millions of machines would end up being sold. It opened up an entire world of manufacturing and it all started with this agreement.
15:33 Speaker 05 They called it the sewing machine combination. And this was the first patent pool in America.
15:39 Speaker 01 And it became a groundbreaking idea. The key was patent pools didn't just combine similar inventions. Only complementary inventions could go into the pool. As in the inventions work together to form a larger invention, but they don't overlap.
15:56 Speaker 05 So like a patent for grinding coffee and a patent for making a coffee filter.
16:03 Speaker 01 Beautiful. It's like peanut butter and jelly.
16:05 Speaker 05 Exactly. Yeah.
16:07 Speaker 02 And this patent pool idea became a model because in an ever more technologically advanced world, it allowed people to build on each other's inventions, to stand on each other's shoulders without stepping on each other's toes. And importantly, to make sure everyone got credit for their ideas.
16:24 Speaker 01 And for consumers, the hope was patent pools would bring better, more affordable inventions to the market. And patent pools hit it big. They started cropping up in all these major inventions of the 19th and 20th centuries.
16:38 Speaker 05 There were so many. So I'm looking through my list here. 1856, sewing machines. 1877, steel making. 1890, farm tools.
16:47 Speaker 01 1899, footwear. 1900, this little contraption that would take the seed out of a raisin. Very important.
16:53 Speaker 02 Maybe just as important, 1903 automobiles. 1908, motion pictures.
16:58 Speaker 05 1917, aircraft. 1919, Radio Corporation of America, RCA was.
17:05 Speaker 01 Sorry, couldn't help it, couldn't help it. Sorry, keep going.
17:07 Speaker 02 1921 oil refining.
17:09 Speaker 05 1930s through 38, we've got heavy industry like high tension cables, hydraulic oil pumps, Phillips screws.
17:17 Speaker 01 Really?
17:18 Speaker 05 Which are used in all kinds of products around our houses.
17:21 Speaker 01 The government even pushed for patent pools in certain situations, like when they needed a lot of airplanes for the First World War. They asked the Wright brothers to form a pool. But from the very beginning, there were also concerns about the very idea of patent pools, that companies that were supposed to compete with each other were instead getting together to cooperate and that they might even be colluding.
17:48 Speaker 05 There was a lot of skepticism and outrage about the possibility that we're looking at a cartel.
17:55 Speaker 02 Yeah, pooling your ideas together, setting prices, trying to dominate a market. These are all things that a cartel does. It's a little like kneecapping your competitors.
18:05 Speaker 01 And all these concerns came to a head in the 1940s with this one super complicated machine that made glass jars, like mason jars.
18:14 Speaker 05 The key invention was called a gob feeder, G O B. And they had control of over 94% of US glass containers.
18:27 Speaker 01 Can I tell you, I am looking at an image of the gob feeder right now and it looks like there's more than 1,000 components.
18:33 Speaker 02 The gob feeder was like this big machine with a bunch of moving parts and it takes a hot rod of molten glass, that's the gob, and it spits it out into a mold for jars and bottles and such.
18:44 Speaker 01 And this gob feeder was part of a big glassware patent pool that included four different companies. And over time, the pool allowed these glassmakers to dominate an overwhelming majority of the market. They controlled the gobs.
18:57 Speaker 05 They were basically like the gob father.
19:00 Speaker 01 Yes, the gob father.
19:01 Speaker 05 Yeah, essentially, they were operating like a cartel.
19:03 Speaker 01 Like if you were part of the pool, you had to promise in a contract that you wouldn't make glassware that competed with anyone else in the pool. They had divided up the market.
19:14 Speaker 02 So the US government sued the glass manufacturers. They said the pool had overreached.
19:19 Speaker 05 The primary purpose of this pool was to restrict output, to fix prices, and also to make sure that competitors weren't going to enter the industry.
19:29 Speaker 01 The government said, you guys cannot own this industry. And the case went all the way up to the Supreme Court. And in 1945, the court said, yep, this behavior violates the Sherman Antitrust Act. You cannot kneecap your competition.
19:42 Speaker 05 Justice Hugo Black wrote that it's the most completely successful economic tyranny over any field of industry.
19:50 Speaker 02 The court said, in essence, the glass companies just had to play fair, set reasonable prices, and you can't cut off your clients who don't do what you want. You know, put that crowbar away.
19:59 Speaker 01 And this case laid the foundation for a new rule that in order to collaborate with other companies, share your inventions and pool your patents, you have to be, quote, "fair, reasonable, and non-discriminatory." The acronym, FRAND. You gotta be friendly.
20:16 Speaker 02 Why can't we be friends? This glassware case and the friendliness of it all laid out a roadmap for patent pools with yield signs along the way. But the world of industry saw them more like stop signs.
20:29 Speaker 01 And by the 1970s, the mood had changed from what you can do to what you can't do. A new antitrust sentiment had taken hold in the country. The Department of Justice wanted to break up anything that even resembled a monopoly. The Justice Department actually laid out a list of don'ts.
20:47 Speaker 05 The nine no-no's.
20:50 Speaker 01 The nine no-no's? Was this written for other adults?
20:54 Speaker 05 This was written for adults.
20:56 Speaker 01 Wow. The nine no-no's were a list of things that were big no-no's, like tying. Tying is essentially telling your customers, if you buy a car from me, you also have to buy my tires. The thing is, when inventors saw this list of nine no-no's, combined with FRAND, all this guidance seemed to deeply discourage anyone looking to collaborate with other companies. People basically stopped forming patent pools.
21:24 Speaker 02 In the 1970s, Michael's research found that not a single notable patent pool was formed. Patent pools were essentially dead.
21:32 Speaker 01 And they would basically stay dead until the 1990s, when our Italian inventor Leonardo showed up on the scene with M-Peg.
21:42 Speaker 02 After the break, the valiant Impeg takes on the nine knowns.
21:46 Speaker 01 And clears the way for inventors to collaborate again.
21:59 Speaker 00 Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors.
22:03 Speaker 04 This message comes from Avalara Aviator. Aviator is the agent hub for tax and compliance. If you've listened to enough podcasts, you know a confident answer isn't necessarily a correct one. Sources matter. The same goes for AI, tax, and compliance. Aviator is grounded in 20-plus years of Avalara tax intelligence and delivers source-backed, audit-defensible outcomes with human oversight built in. Because the AI said so, won't pass an audit. Visit avalara.com/aviator.
22:34 Speaker 00 This message comes from Mint Mobile. Ditch overpriced wireless and get premium wireless for less. Go to mintmobile.com/switch to see which plan works for you.
22:46 Speaker 04 This message comes from EasyCater, the workplace food platform. EasyCater helps organizations order food from favorite restaurants, meet dietary needs, and stay on budget. With employee meal programs, flexible payment options, and 24/7 customer support, all on one platform. Learn more at easycater.com.
23:06 Speaker 02 So we've told you the story of the rise of patent pools, how Isaac Singer brought all his would-be competitors into a collaborative pool to avoid endless lawsuits for stealing their ideas, to work as a team instead of rivals.
23:20 Speaker 01 And we've told you the story of the fall of patent pools, how some pools grew too powerful, and how a Supreme Court case and rising antitrust sentiment brought patent pools pretty much to a grinding halt. And now for the rebirth of the patent pool.
23:37 Speaker 02 The 80s was, once again, this crucial moment in technological history. It wasn't the Industrial Revolution, but something new was on the rise that would spawn millions of tiny new inventions, each dependent on the next. That thing that was on the rise? Computers, tech. These inventions would necessitate more collaboration than ever. A lot of it, tons of it.
23:57 Speaker 01 Gobs of it. Take, for example, Leonardo, our Italian inventor, and his dream of connecting the world through MPEG, this new language for digital video.
24:07 Speaker 03 We want to make people happy and to make industry happy. And it is this magic formula.
24:14 Speaker 01 It was this magic formula, but only if everyone uses it. Because there were all these other formats for video. And if one company is using one language and another is using another, then none of the machines can talk to each other. It'd be like if you bought a lamp, but you couldn't get a light bulb to fit in it.
24:31 Speaker 02 Yeah, these things needed to be interoperable, to be able to talk to each other. It was in the interest of consumers and manufacturers to pick one standard, like a standard file format for these tiny, adorable compressed video files.
24:44 Speaker 01 Standards are like an agreement across an entire industry for technical specs and norms. There are actually international organizations that exist just to set standards and maintain them.
24:55 Speaker 02 So that's what Leonardo was hoping MPEG could become, a big international standard.
25:00 Speaker 01 So Leonardo partnered with a handful of other companies and this major international standards organization. And they hired a bunch of lawyers to help them turn MPEG into a standard. One of those lawyers was a guy from Queens named Ken Rubenstein.
25:15 Speaker 06 I was one of the fathers, let's say.
25:18 Speaker 02 Would you say you're one of the founding fathers?
25:19 Speaker 06 I think I'm one of the founding fathers, yes.
25:23 Speaker 01 It was Ken's job to help figure out how to create this international collaboration without running afoul of American antitrust laws.
25:32 Speaker 01 So the first hurdle was to figure out what shape this would even take.
25:37 Speaker 02 They were sitting in conference rooms, asking themselves, how do we make MPEG the new standard? How do we collectively and legally choose what language all of our technology is going to speak? The tool they landed on was the patent pool. They actually thought back to another time, a group of competitors wanted to pool their inventions. They thought of the sewing machine and all the patent pools that came after it.
25:59 Speaker 01 But with patent pools came those pesky concerns.
26:03 Speaker 02 Like, who's gonna stop you?
26:04 Speaker 06 Well, the US government, for example, could intervene and sue us. Because a patent pool is inherently a joint activity, a cooperating activity of companies that normally are supposed to be competing.
26:22 Speaker 02 Yeah, they thought the Department of Justice's antitrust division would have too many issues with a patent pool. That from the jump, they would flag it for being too much like a cartel.
26:31 Speaker 01 So they would need to address the issues of the past, friend and the nine no-nos. That was the second hurdle. How do you go about making sure, in this massive negotiation between heavy hitters like Sony and Mitsubishi, that every company was treated fairly, you know, friendly?
26:48 Speaker 02 Friend means fair, reasonable, and non-discriminatory. So they would need to be fair and reasonable about who gets to be part of the pool. Because a lot of companies wanted in. They could be paid every time somebody bought a product that was part of it. And they had to be non-discriminatory. Ken and the other lawyers knew you can't just exclude people willy-nilly.
27:06 Speaker 01 Ken's job was to make sure that every patent included was essential to the pool. And he was supposed to be impartial, to make these choices based on merit and fairness.
27:16 Speaker 06 So I evolved into the umpire, who got called the balls and strikes on essential, not essential for patents.
27:25 Speaker 02 You know, anyone could submit a patent for the pool, and Ken had to sort through all of them.
27:30 Speaker 06 I seem to recall tons and tons and tons of paper.
27:35 Speaker 01 They sorted through abstracts of patents and they had criteria. And the criteria boiled down to, is this patent necessary for the larger standard? Is it complementary and not a substitute?
27:48 Speaker 02 So, you know, if we go back to our PB and J example, you don't have 18 different kinds of peanut butter when you only need one. You have one patent for peanut butter and one for jelly. These are the criteria that Ken is looking for, the patents that are essential to the standard. And once they found those essential patents, there was one final tiny step, one little hurdle, just convincing the Department of Justice that this wasn't all collusion.
28:11 Speaker 01 This was their final battle in their fight for the fate of MPEG, for DVDs and HD television and eventually video calls and TikToks. And one of their key moves, they didn't want to wait around and get sued by the Department of Justice like those infamous patent pools of the past. So they acted first by directly asking for permission.
28:32 Speaker 02 So they talked to the Justice Department, learned from their conversations what the department's concerns were. And then, using what they learned, they crafted a weapon of sorts, a weapon to finally win the fight for MPEG.
28:46 Speaker 01 They used the best, the sharpest, the mostest tool they had, a letter. They wrote a letter to the Department of Justice.
28:53 Speaker 02 And that letter basically promised that the MPEG patent pool would not edge out competitors and would not make anyone sign coercive contracts. It would all be above board, you know, friendly. And this was crucial. It made the case that all of these companies could and should collaborate, not just for the company's sake, but for the sake of consumers everywhere.
29:12 Speaker 01 And it helped that this coincided with a loosening of antitrust laws, an argument that was gaining momentum, that if it was good for consumers, let it be.
29:23 Speaker 06 And we got the letter approved. I think it was in 1997.
29:29 Speaker 02 Yeah, in 1997, the DOJ granted permission for the patent pool. And that patent pool allowed MPeg to become a standard for storing and sharing video files.
29:41 Speaker 01 But the real power of the letter was that it became a template. Now, all these other companies were able to write their own letters to model their own patent pools off of MPeg's methods. They were able to successfully argue that companies could and should collaborate, not just for the company's sake, but for the sake of consumers everywhere.
30:02 Speaker 02 Now you started to see patent pools crop up everywhere again.
30:06 Speaker 05 1997, Bluetooth. 1998, DVDs.
30:10 Speaker 01 Michael Mediole again, law professor and patent pool enthusiast.
30:14 Speaker 05 1999, there's another pool for DVDs. 2001, 3G mobile phones.
30:19 Speaker 02 Today, we still use various standards that patent pools allow for, like Bluetooth and 5G. Some people even still use CDs and DVDs.
30:28 Speaker 01 Yes, I do. Whatever.
30:30 Speaker 02 Erica might be one of those people.
30:32 Speaker 01 I'm proud of it.
30:33 Speaker 02 How many things would you say today you have touched that have involved a patent pool in some way?
30:40 Speaker 05 Oh, my gosh. Well, just in the course of setting up this call, I touched at least five things that involved a patent pool. My smartphone, the tablet that I'm using, the desktop. So, yeah, we're surrounded by patents that are parts of pools.
31:00 Speaker 01 And those pools, the saga of Singer and the sewing machine, kind of paint a different story of the world we live in than the one we're often told. This idea that a singular inventor, one great person, has an idea, and they have to fight to have it realized, like Edison versus Tesla, Jobs versus Gates.
31:19 Speaker 05 I think America has always loved the story of the individual. And I think that the notion of individuals who have overcome obstacles and done great things, it is naturally compelling to us. So, the Singer story and the stories of other patent pools, they're stories about the power of cooperation.
31:43 Speaker 05 Over the ambition of an individual. To me, that's really, it's kind of hopeful, actually, to think that sometimes it's possible for competitors to realize that the best thing for all of them is to cooperate.
31:57 Speaker 01 When patent pools are working, they're sort of this line in the sand that separates collaboration and collusion.
32:04 Speaker 02 A way for self-interested inventors like Singer to serve their own needs, as well as the needs of other inventors and consumers, so that we can all have glassware and airplanes and streaming video.
32:16 Speaker 01 And sewing machines.
32:24 Speaker 02 Thanks to everyone who supports this show by spreading the word. More and more people are finding podcasts through algorithms, but word of mouth is still the best way we reach new listeners. If you can think of someone in your life, a colleague, a friend, a lover of sewing machines, who might enjoy this episode, send them a link and tell them why.
32:41 Speaker 01 This episode was produced by Luis Gallo with help from Willa Rubin. It was edited by Mary Ann McCune. It was fact-checked by Sierra Juarez and engineered by Sina LaFredo. Alex Goldmark is our executive producer.
32:53 Speaker 02 Special thanks to Sophie Tannhauser, whose book, Called Worn, is where we first heard about the story of the sewing machine and its impact on the world of antitrust. And thanks also to Ruth Brandon, author of the book Singer and the Sewing Machine. Special thanks as well to Lori Fitzgerald and Garrett Beany. I'm Samuel Horst Kessler.
33:10 Speaker 01 And I'm Erica Barris. This is NPR. Thanks for listening.
33:16 Speaker 04 Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors.
Previous Iran, protests, and sanctions Next Betty Boop, Excel Olympics, Penny-isms: Our 2026 Valentines Page updated October 31, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated