Pod Insights Planet Money Summer School 3: How government decides what to spend our money on About this episode Although it seems like the government can spend an endless amount of money, it cannot actually do all the things it wants to do. So the big question in this week's lesson is: How do we decide? Why does the government spend so much money on some things and not on others? And honestly, is there any limit? Get tickets to our August 18th live show and graduation ceremony at The Bell House, in Brooklyn. (Planet Money+ supporters get a 10 percent discount off their tickets. Listen to the July 8th bonus episode to get the discount code!)The series is hosted by Robert Smith and produced by Eric Mennel. Our project manager is Devin Mellor. This episode was edited by Planet Money Executive Producer Alex Goldmark and fact-checked by Emily Crawford. Help support Planet Money and hear our bonus episodes by subscribing to Planet Money+ in Apple Podcasts or at plus.npr.org/planetmoney. Always free at these links: Apple Podcasts, Spotify, the NPR app or anywhere you get podcasts. Find more Planet Money: Facebook / Instagram / TikTok / Our weekly Newsletter.
See pcm.adswizz.com https://pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for sponsorship and to manage your podcast sponsorship preferences.
NPR Privacy Policy https://www.npr.org/about-npr/179878450/privacy-policy
Transcript 7,038 words · 24 speakers
0:00 Speaker 00 This message comes from Avalara Aviator. Aviator is the agent hub for tax and compliance. Purpose-built AI agents work around the clock and across business systems to help execute the work. Visit avalara.com/aviator.
0:14 Speaker 01 Hey, everyone. Just a quick message before class gets started. Planet Money Summer School is having a live graduation ceremony and party in New York City on August 18th. It's going to be great. So get your tickets now before the show sells out. Planet Money Plus supporters get a 10% discount and get early access to summer school episodes all summer long. Check out the show notes for a link to buy tickets and to subscribe to Planet Money Plus.
0:40 Speaker 02 This is Planet Money from NPR.
0:47 Speaker 01 Welcome back, class, to Planet Money Summer School, the only economics degree you can get just by listening. No tuition, no textbooks, no frustrating group projects. I'm all right. I'm Robert Smith, and this season, we are tackling power and money, the profound ways that the government influences business and the economy. This is class number three. You are what you pay for. Last week, we talked taxes, how the government raises money. This week, we get to decide what to spend it on. Woo, government shopping spree. But, reality check, although it seems like the government can spend an endless amount of money, it cannot do all the things it wants to do. So the big question in this week's lesson is, how do we decide? Why does the government spend so much money
1:31 Speaker 01 on some things and not other things? And honestly, is there any limit? The United States is at, let me check here, more than $36 trillion in debt. Is that too much? God, it feels like too much. Every week, we have a couple of case studies and a guest professor to teach us the big lessons. Welcome today to Aviva Erindine, Director of the Hamilton Project at the Brookings Institution. What exactly does the Hamilton Project do? It's not based on the musical, right?
2:03 Speaker 03 It's not based on the musical, though it's funny. It gets its name from sort of the same rehabilitation of Hamilton that is embodied in the musical.
2:13 Speaker 01 I guess it is hard to make a rhyme based on the Hamilton Project, but of course, I'm going to try. It makes multimodal proposals on quality fiscal policies. Yeah, not ready for Broadway. Moving on. For our purposes here at summer school, we should say that Aviva has, in the past, been inside the very government we are going to talk about, at the Treasury Department and at the Office of Management and Budget. So, Aviva, you have been there for the taxing, you have been there for the spending, and the cloud hanging over all those discussions must be the national debt. Now, of course, like, as an individual, I have to pay my debts eventually. Why doesn't the government ever balance its budget?
2:55 Speaker 03 So, government is different fundamentally because it has a tax base. And there are, in fact, some very good reasons that a government might not balance its budget every year.
3:06 Speaker 01 Yeah, I mean, we might be at war. That often sends up the deficits. The country could be in recession, where it makes sense to spend a ton of money to perk up the economy and help people. But there's not always an emergency reason, right?
3:22 Speaker 03 Yeah, even outside a recession, it can make sense for the government to borrow to invest. The concern, and I would say we do have this concern now, particularly as we look out 10, 20 years, the concern is when your debt is growing too rapidly relative to your economy. And that's what projections would say is going to happen in this country going forward if we don't do something that changes our fiscal trajectory.
3:47 Speaker 01 So, to put it in terms of my own life, if the money I owe to the bank is growing faster than the money I make, my salary... Then I'm getting deeper and deeper into this hole. And for and for governments, they're already in a hole and they might want to, you know, stop digging at some point.
4:03 Speaker 03 And the reason for that is that the size of your debt and the growth rate of your debt relative to your economy is sort of telling you what would you need to do if you abruptly needed to reduce your debt? Is that a manageable proposition where you have lots of policies you could plausibly pursue to do that? Or is it an unmanageable proposition?
4:22 Speaker 01 OK, so you seem to be saying if there's some huge thing the government has to spend money on, like a crisis, or perhaps the financial system starts to worry about lending the government money, we could always theoretically increase taxes as a country to stabilize the debt. But it makes a difference if you have to theoretically increase taxes by 3%, which may be manageable, or if you have to increase taxes by 10%, which is definitely going to get you in trouble. Like, a 3% tax hike is easier to sell.
4:53 Speaker 03 And, you know, we're a big country. We're a wealthy country. We absolutely have policy tools with which we could do that. But the more the debt grows as a share of the economy and the more it's rapidly it's growing, the harder it is to to make that stabilization.
5:08 Speaker 01 So on today's show, we are going to peer inside the budget and see what we can do to slow this roll a bit. It's easy to rant about big government, but what if everything inside the budget is actually there for a good reason? Then how do you make the hard choices? Get your calculator out for after the break.
5:33 Speaker 04 Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors. This message comes from Apollo. Whether it's funding growth, modernizing operations, or strengthening their balance sheet, CEOs and CFOs need more than capital. They need a financing partner with the scale, flexibility, and certainty to help them execute. Apollo provides access to long-duration capital and a broad range of financing capabilities, helping companies develop customized financing solutions designed at an efficient cost of capital. Learn more at apollo.com/capital.
6:09 Speaker 00 This message comes from Bowlin Branch. Change the way you sleep with soft 100% organic cotton sheets from Bowlin Branch. Designed to help you fall asleep faster with airy blankets, cloud-like duvets, and breathable sheets. Experience pure comfort on night one and feel your sheets get softer with every wash. Discover the difference with 15% off your first order at bowlinbranch.com with code NPR. Exclusions apply. See site for details.
6:37 Speaker 01 Planet Money Summer School, back in session and doing math on the radio, which is always fun. Pay attention, everyone. We are going to go over everything our government spends money on in exactly 10 minutes. This is from an episode we did back in 2017. Professor Aviva Erandine, what should the students listen for in this episode?
6:57 Speaker 03 I think the question is, what are all these programs doing? What do these policies and programs accomplish?
7:02 Speaker 01 This episode was hosted by Jacob Goldstein and Stacy Vanek Smith. And even though it was made eight years ago, the percentages of the government budget are roughly the same. One thing to mention, though, when we talk in this episode about President Trump and the Republicans trying to make budget cuts in things like Medicaid, we are referring to his first term and not the current moves in his second term to make those cuts. The more things change.
7:26 Speaker 05 OK, here is how it's going to work. We're going to put 10 minutes on the clock and we're going to cover the entire federal budget.
7:32 Speaker 06 Every second of that 10 minutes will be worth $6.4 billion.
7:37 Speaker 05 So the small programs, they're going to go super fast.
7:39 Speaker 06 Big programs, nothing but time.
7:41 Speaker 05 And we're going to bring in a bunch of people from Planet Money to help us out. So the first piece in our show today, Robert Smith, is going to talk about Medicare and Medicaid. That is 29% of the federal budget. So they will get 29% of our 10 minutes.
7:55 Speaker 06 Start the clock now.
7:57 Speaker 01 You know how there's always this debate about whether the federal government should have a responsibility to pay for health care? Well, I've got news for you. It already does. The federal government pays for the health care of 120 million Americans, people over the age of 65, families with low income, people with long-term disabilities. They are all covered by Medicare and Medicaid. Medicaid and Medicare. Although I always mix them up. Everyone does.
8:23 Speaker 07 I had some embarrassing errors when I was a new health policy reporter, where I would mistake these in stories and lots of people would send me angry emails.
8:30 Speaker 01 This is Sarah Cliff, a writer for vox.com. She co-hosts the Weeds podcast.
8:35 Speaker 07 I heard a terrible way to remember it.
8:37 Speaker 01 Oh, I want to hear it.
8:38 Speaker 07 Ages ago, someone told me, "You care for the old and aid the sick," or no, "Aid the poor." That's what it-- see, it's a terrible one.
8:46 Speaker 01 Okay, I have a better one. Silver hair, Medicare. Underpaid, Medicaid. If we live long enough, we all get Medicare. But even if you don't consider yourself poor, you might also find yourself on Medicaid.
9:02 Speaker 07 It actually finances a lot of long-term nursing home stays. So a lot of middle, upper-class Americans eventually do end up on Medicaid when they need that kind of coverage and they've kind of whittled away their savings.
9:14 Speaker 01 And there you have it. Hey, Stacy, how much time do I have left?
9:18 Speaker 07 You've got about a minute and a half.
9:20 Speaker 01 Minute and a half.
9:21 Speaker 07 Yeah, you got it. This is the big-- this is the biggest part of the budget. You've got some time.
9:25 Speaker 01 Okay, let's go get some coffee.
9:28 Speaker 01 We got time.
9:29 Speaker 07 We have some time.
9:31 Speaker 01 And I can explain one more thing about Medicaid.
9:35 Speaker 01 Okay, so we've all heard about Obamacare. We've all heard about how in Congress right now, the Republicans are undoing Obamacare. But what the fight is really about is the future of these programs we're talking about, the future of Medicaid.
9:49 Speaker 07 Underpaid.
9:50 Speaker 01 Underpaid. You want-- should I get you a cup?
9:52 Speaker 07 A black coffee, please.
9:54 Speaker 01 One of the big ways that Barack Obama got people insured was to expand Medicaid. Medicaid costs are shared between the federal government and the states. The states run the programs. And Obama essentially said, "We are going to give you more federal money, a larger share of our budget, if you just cover more people." And so this, this part of the budget pie I'm talking my way through, this got larger. So when the Republicans are thinking, "God, how do we undo Obamacare?" What they thought is, "Let's put some caps on the growth of Medicaid." And what that means in sort of real-world terms is that if the Republican plan passes, 15 million fewer people covered by Medicaid. So if we're going to do this show again in 10 years, there might be slightly less time for government healthcare, perhaps.
10:38 Speaker 07 No coffee break?
10:39 Speaker 01 Maybe time for a short coffee break.
10:41 Speaker 07 You gonna drink that, by the way?
10:44 Speaker 06 No. Transportation, 2% of the budget, Kenny Malone.
10:48 Speaker 08 We asked former Secretary Ray Lohood to write us a haiku. He declined, so I made one for him, using words from his old speeches.
10:56 Speaker 09 A highway crumbles beneath our wheels. One big pothole. It spreads across the roads. Thank you all very much. Thank you very much.
11:06 Speaker 05 Next up, social security. It accounts for 24% of federal spending. Jacob, take it away.
11:11 Speaker 06 Social Security is really big because almost everybody gets it. In particular, almost every American over the age of 66, including billionaires. You know, if Warren Buffett wants social security, he can get it. I called up Ted Marmer to ask about this. He's an emeritus professor at Yale, expert on social security. Why does Warren Buffett get social security checks?
11:35 Speaker 10 That's a classic dumbbell formulation.
11:39 Speaker 06 Okay. Marmer says billionaires getting social security is not a bug, it's a feature. When social security was created back in the 30s, some Democrats did want to create a version of the program where the money just went to poor people. But President Roosevelt was like, no, a program like that just won't survive politically. What we need is something that almost all working people are eligible for. And, he said, we should fund it with a special tax that almost all working people pay. That way, people will say, I paid into social security. I deserve social security when I retire. And I will vote out of office any politician who tries to take it away from me.
12:15 Speaker 10 His terms in which he expressed it was, goddammit, I'm going to be sure to have a program that no damn Congress is going to mess with because people are going to feel entitled.
12:28 Speaker 06 But I do think this leads to a lot of confusion. You know, people seem to think, oh, I contributed to social security. They're holding on to my money in a special box. This is not how it works. My money is paying for retired people right now. And I'm crossing my fingers that in 30 years, when I'm retired, there will be 40-year-olds who are paying me.
12:47 Speaker 10 Jacob.
12:48 Speaker 06 Yes.
12:49 Speaker 10 I'll bet you any money, and I want you to pay me off by putting it in my grave.
12:53 Speaker 06 Okay.
12:54 Speaker 10 The probability that you will receive social security benefits for retirement is so high.
13:02 Speaker 10 That you should be declared irrational for believing so.
13:06 Speaker 06 Really? Why are you so confident?
13:09 Speaker 10 Why am I so confident? Because I understand the political economy of the United States.
13:12 Speaker 06 Because Roosevelt was right.
13:14 Speaker 10 Correct.
13:15 Speaker 06 Because almost everybody pays in and gets paid out, including billionaires, Marmer says Social Security is politically bulletproof.
13:24 Speaker 05 Social services and education, 3%. And for this segment, we wanted to get someone who is currently a beneficiary of public education, AKA Jacob's kid.
13:34 Speaker 11 Most spending in this area comes from state and local governments.
13:40 Speaker 06 The federal government's biggest-
13:42 Speaker 11 The federal government's biggest education line item is grants for low-income college students.
13:51 Speaker 06 National defense is 15% of federal spending. Stacy.
13:56 Speaker 05 We spend $1.5 billion every day on defense. And this is famously one of the most controversial parts of the budget. I mean, Democrats often come in and they want to cut defense spending. Then Republicans come in and they want to raise defense spending. But somehow, in spite of all of this, if you look back over the last 20 years, the share of the budget devoted to defense has not really changed that much. And actually, that is pretty much true for most of the federal budget. It stays pretty steady. And I was totally shocked by this. So I talked to this guy, Bill Valdez, about it. He worked for the Energy Department for more than 20 years. He wrote a lot of budgets. And he told me his theory of what's going on here.
14:35 Speaker 12 You know, the real thing that keeps the budget stable is that there are all these special interest groups.
14:41 Speaker 05 Hundreds of lobbyists battling for government funds, hammering out deals with different states and different politicians. Bill says the budget status quo is really this hard-earned equilibrium. And he thinks this is a good thing, ultimately. It creates stability. So we actually have lobbyists to thank for our stable budget?
15:00 Speaker 12 Yeah, in many respects, yeah.
15:03 Speaker 05 It's like a little shout out to the lobbyists.
15:06 Speaker 12 Well, I mean-
15:07 Speaker 05 They get so little love. I feel like that's OK. Right? Don't you think that maybe the budget should be their Valentine? President Trump has proposed increasing defense spending by cutting other parts of the budget. Bill says he will have to get through the lobbyists first.
15:22 Speaker 06 Next up, income security. 13% of the budget. Here is Noel King.
15:27 Speaker 13 Yes, income security. So think of this as programs for poor people. It includes a bunch of different things, like the earned income tax credit, housing assistance, unemployment. Foster care is a small part of it. I'm going to talk about food stamps, which are officially known as SNAP for two reasons. Number one, food stamps are a really big program. Usage spiked during the recession. If you look at graphs, it's basically like a straight line going up. And it has stayed pretty high. More than 40 million people are getting food stamps right now. And I think there is a lot of confusion over who gets them. So let's clear that up. Two out of every three people on food stamps are kids, the elderly, or they are disabled. Of the rest, it's roughly split between people who are
16:12 Speaker 13 working but making very low wages, low enough to qualify for food stamps, and people who are not working but should be working soon. Because SNAP comes with work requirements. For the most part, if you are able-bodied and you don't have a job, you get cut off from food stamps after a couple of months. There you go.
16:31 Speaker 05 Interest on the national debt, 6% of the budget.
16:35 Speaker 06 And you can look at this in two ways. One, interest rates are really low right now. So the government was able to borrow money, spend it on goods and services for Americans. Great.
16:45 Speaker 05 But you could also say this whole chunk of the budget is just the interest on all the money we owe. And what we get in return for all this money is nothing.
17:00 Speaker 06 Four more seconds.
17:05 Speaker 05 This is feeling awkward.
17:07 Speaker 06 Veterans Affairs, 5%. Sally Helm, go.
17:11 Speaker 14 Yes, they provide things like healthcare and disability benefits for vets. President Trump wants to boost funding for the VA, but is proposing some cuts, including one for disabled vets, once they're old enough to get social security. President Eisenhower tried to do something kind of like this in the 50s. He was a five-star general, so maybe he thought he could get away with it, but he got totally shut down by Congress. We'll see how Trump does.
17:33 Speaker 05 International Affairs, 1%. Nick Fountain, go.
17:35 Speaker 15 Yeah, this goes to operating US embassies and consulates throughout the world, providing military assistance to allies, aiding developing nations.
17:44 Speaker 06 Everything else makes up about 3% of the budget. Let's bring it home.
17:47 Speaker 05 Justice, that's FBI, DEA, prisons, homeland security.
17:49 Speaker 06 Natural resources and environment.
17:51 Speaker 05 Science, space, and technology.
17:52 Speaker 06 General government, that's like mowing the White House lawn and paying congressional salaries.
17:54 Speaker 05 Community and regional development.
17:56 Speaker 06 Agriculture.
17:56 Speaker 05 Energy.
17:57 Speaker 06 Done!
17:57 Speaker 05 Woo! We did it!
18:01 Speaker 05 So we made it through the whole budget in 10 minutes. And I have to say, the thing that strikes me about the budget is that half of it, more than half of it, is just made up by three programs: Medicare, Medicaid, and social security.
18:14 Speaker 06 And then, in the rest, overwhelmingly, the biggest chunk is defense. And so there is this old line that I still love, which is, "The federal government is basically a big insurance company backed by a large standing army."
18:32 Speaker 01 Jacob Goldstein and Stacy Vanik Smith from 2017. And the percentages you heard there are still roughly the same, with a couple of notable exceptions. If we were doing this show again today, Nick Fountain would barely have time to speak. If the current plans hold, the budget for international aid and embassies will be cut to far less than 1%. And the interest on the national debt. The debt is now bigger, the interest rates are now higher, the interest on the national debt is now double what it was. 13% of the budget, twice as much time. Ouch, indeed. Let's bring back in our professor, Aviva Arindain, from the Brookings Institution. As we listen to those 10 minutes of the budget, I kept thinking, why?
19:17 Speaker 01 Why does the government do these things and not other things? What's the big way to think about this?
19:24 Speaker 03 So I think you can put most of the things government does into one of two buckets. One is addressing a market failure, a case where there's something that prevents the private market from functioning well. And the other is redistributing incomes. So addressing a case where the private market is not giving us the distribution of resources that we, as a society, want.
19:47 Speaker 01 Why don't we start with market failure? What do you mean by market failure?
19:50 Speaker 03 Yeah. So this is a case where, but there are lots of cases where markets work pretty well. If you want to buy a pair of shoes, a market economy is going to do a pretty good job of offering you a range of shoes to buy of different kinds, lots of different characteristics. They're going to be priced pretty close to what it costs to make them. It's going to work great.
20:10 Speaker 01 This is why we don't have government shoes.
20:12 Speaker 03 Right. And anyone who suggests we should have government shoes, right, you'd have some questions. There are other things that the market is definitely not going to provide. So, classic example, national defense. It's what economists call a true, a sort of pretty pure public good. We usually define this in technical terms as non-rivalrous, which means that the fact that you and I both get protection from the US national defense apparatus doesn't really increase the cost of providing national defense. And non-exclusive, which means you can't really say to anyone living here, we're going to carve you out of our national defense protection because you didn't pay for it, right? So the market is just never going to provide something like that.
20:57 Speaker 03 And then there are lots of things that aren't pure public goods, but they have some characteristics and qualities of public goods. So this is a lot of things that the federal government does, like education, scientific research, infrastructure, national parks. In theory, could you imagine those being privately provided? Sure. But I think most people have a pretty strong instinct that there are reasons that those are treated as public goods, that we want to provide those on a common basis.
21:22 Speaker 01 So that is one reason why government would spend money, for a market failure. The other one you said was redistribution. Which parts of the budget are redistribution and why are we doing it?
21:34 Speaker 03 Sure. So a good example of a part of the budget that is principally redistribution is the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program, or SNAP, or what used to be called food stamps, that provides food assistance to people who have low incomes, whether elderly people who have low incomes, kids who have low incomes, people of working age who just lost their jobs and have low income. And that's a pretty pure case of, in a market economy, if you just left the market outcome alone, many of those people would really struggle to put food on the table. And in fact, we have evidence that when you cut SNAP, people have more trouble affording food. When you increase SNAP, fewer people struggle to get food. And we've decided that that's a valuable thing to do.
22:17 Speaker 03 It's not addressing a market failure, per se, but it's addressing a failure of the market to achieve the distributional outcome, in this case, lower poverty, lower rates of people who can't feed themselves than we want.
22:34 Speaker 01 So that is the theory of how government budgets should be decided. Coming up after the break, we look at the messy reality. I don't want to spoil it, but let's just say that maybe, maybe, the politicians who decide how to spend our money have some personal interests of their own.
22:53 Speaker 00 Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors.
22:58 Speaker 04 This message comes from LinkedIn. Owning a small business comes with a lot of challenges and means juggling multiple things at once. It's even harder to do it efficiently. But with LinkedIn, you get all the tools you need to grow in one place. With LinkedIn, simplify your sales, marketing, and hiring so that you can actually run your small business. Learn more at LinkedIn.com/PlanetMoneyShow. This message comes from NPR sponsor Charles Schwab. When is the right time to sell a stock? How do you protect against inflation? Financial decisions can be tricky, and often, your own cognitive and emotional biases can lead you astray. Financial Decoder, an original podcast from Charles Schwab, can help.
23:39 Speaker 04 Join host Mark Reapy as he offers practical solutions to help overcome the cognitive and emotional biases that may affect your investing decisions. Download the latest episode and subscribe at schwab.com/financialdecoder.
23:56 Speaker 00 This episode's sponsor is HubSpot, which offers the following message. What if, instead of updating your CRM, your CRM updated you? No catching up on manual edits, no more guesswork. HubSpot's self-updating CRM keeps your customer context current and helps you understand what to do next. So, marketing builds more demand, sales wins more deals, and customers keep coming back. Learn more at hubspot.com.
24:24 Speaker 01 OK, class. In our next case study, we peer behind the curtain of the US Congress and find out that there are forces at work that might keep them from doing the most fiscally responsible thing. One reality is that senators and representatives want to keep their jobs and get reelected. And that takes donations. Listen now to Illinois Senator Dick Durbin.
24:45 Speaker 16 I think most Americans would be shocked, not surprised, but shocked, if they knew how much time a United States senator spends raising money and how much time we spend talking about raising money and thinking about raising money and planning to raise money.
25:01 Speaker 01 In 2012, Planet Money and This American Life collaborated on a series of stories about how money and lobbyists influence politics. Alex Blumberg and Andrea Seabrook began by tracking down a list of dozens of fundraisers that happen in Washington DC every single week.
25:17 Speaker 17 The money changes hands in very specific places all over DC. There are townhouses whose sole function is to be rented out as venues for this. Dozens of restaurants do a booming business catering small parties in private rooms.
25:30 Speaker 18 And there's one thing driving all this activity, a gnawing, relentless, voracious need for cash. To understand that need, consider Walt Minnick.
25:39 Speaker 17 Minnick is a conservative Democrat who represented a Republican-leaning district in Idaho. He was first elected in 2008, and after he won, he took just five days off from fundraising. Then, two months before he was sworn in as a congressman, he was back raising money for the next election, two years away.
25:58 Speaker 19 I needed to raise $10,000 to $15,000 a day, and you only do it by elbow grease.
26:04 Speaker 18 Let's stop and dwell on that statement for a second, shall we, Andrea? $10,000 to $15,000 a day. The typical cost of a congressional race is about $1 million, although if you're challenging an incumbent, you need more. Minnick's goal was even more than that, $2.5 million, because he was in such a competitive district.
26:20 Speaker 19 I would spend two or three hours a day as a congressman trying to raise money.
26:26 Speaker 17 That's typical for a member of Congress, and most of those hours are spent across the street from the Capitol in special offices set up by the parties specifically for this purpose.
26:37 Speaker 18 Special offices because federal law prohibits lawmakers from making fundraising calls from their own congressional offices. Neither party is eager to let reporters into these call centers, but we got a couple Democrats to describe what it's like in there. This is Oregon Congressman Peter DeFazio.
26:51 Speaker 20 If you walked in there, you would say, boy, this is about the worst-looking, most abusive call center situation I've seen in my life. These people don't have any workspace. The other person is virtually touching them, just like counters on the wall with telephones and people eight inches away from you talking on the telephone.
27:09 Speaker 16 We sit at these desks with stacks of names in front of us and short bios and histories of giving.
27:17 Speaker 18 This is Senator Dick Durbin, who says that on the Senate side, they'll have these things called power hours several times a week, where a bunch of senators will go into the call center.
27:24 Speaker 16 And make these calls to people who are our faithful friends and ask them to give money or have a fundraiser. And then, if we're fortunate enough, we end up attending those fundraisers that we beg people to do for us. I mean, that is part of the conversation, and this goes on and on and on.
27:46 Speaker 18 Where did the names come from? How do you decide who to call?
27:50 Speaker 16 The names come from a history of giving, and many of them, it's hard for most listeners to believe, really aren't looking for much. They want their team to win, in this case, the Democratic team. They don't ask for special favors, but there are exceptions. There are some who won't waste any time to tell you what they think is the most important issue in Washington as they talk about their donation. I mean, it is part of the reality of the life that I live.
28:15 Speaker 18 Now, there is an easier way to relieve some of that pressure and raise money faster, a way that doesn't involve tapping out your friends. Just go to the people who already have big stacks of money set aside to give to politicians: lobbyists.
28:26 Speaker 17 A lobbyist can throw you a fundraiser, a lunch at Johnny's Half Shell, or a cocktail reception at Bullfeathers. And so every week, lawmakers and their staffs work the phones, trying to find lobbyists to organize these events. Jimmy Williams used to get those calls. He was a lobbyist for the real estate industry for many years.
28:44 Speaker 21 A lot of them would call and say, hey, can you host an event for me? And you never want to say no. Actually, no, you always want to say no. In fact, you always want to say no. But you can look on your phone with these caller IDs, and you would be like, really? I'm not taking that call.
29:03 Speaker 18 Oh, so you would dodge calls for funds?
29:05 Speaker 21 Oh, yeah. Every lobbyist does it. Are you kidding? You spend most of your time dodging phone calls. Oh, yeah.
29:11 Speaker 18 This was one of the most surprising things I learned about this whole process. The way most of us generally think about it is absolutely backwards. We imagine the lobbyists stalking the halls of Congress, trying to influence members with cash. But more often than not, it's the reverse. The member is stalking the lobbyist, saying, hey, can I have some of that money?
29:28 Speaker 17 And it's hard to say no, Jimmy says, especially to a congressman whose work and votes he cared about. So he'd say yes, and then he'd have to round up a bunch of guests.
29:39 Speaker 21 So I call up my buddies down on K Street, from my buddy over at the credit unions, or my buddy over at the insurance company, or my buddy over wherever, at the home builders. And I say, hey, dude, I'm going to do this event for this guy, and he sits on the House Financial Services Committee. And do you guys have any money for this person? Is he in your budget? And the answer was usually, yeah, yeah, I got money for that guy. And so, all right, so cool. So we'll come up with a date, and then we have this fundraiser. And it's a breakfast, or it's a lunch, or it's a dinner, or a cocktail reception. And everyone comes, and they bring their checks, or they mail their checks in, and then you have it.
30:13 Speaker 17 We're talking thousands of dollars that the congressman will make in just an hour.
30:18 Speaker 18 And this brings us to the big question. What does the money buy? What are corporations and special interests getting in return for the billions of dollars they spend lobbying each year?
30:27 Speaker 17 There tend to be two views on this. If you're cynical, you think money buys votes, pure and simple. Washington is owned. Money drives everything.
30:37 Speaker 18 But lobbyists and politicians will sometimes tell you the opposite. Money has no effect. After all, they say, there's always two sides, and both are giving. Exporters versus importers, bankers versus realtors, businesses versus unions. The money cancels itself out.
30:51 Speaker 17 When we asked Congressman Barney Frank about this, he said both of those positions are caricatures.
30:56 Speaker 22 People say, oh, it doesn't have any effect on me. Look, if that were the case, we would be the only human beings in the history of the world who, on a regular basis, took significant amounts of money from perfect strangers and made sure it had no effect on our behavior. That is not human nature.
31:12 Speaker 17 On the other hand, he says, there are things that influence a politician besides money.
31:17 Speaker 22 If the voters have a position, the votes will kick money's rear end any time.
31:24 Speaker 17 But the fact is, most legislation your district doesn't care about. The stuff that makes the news is a tiny fraction of what Congress actually does. They're deep in the weeds of tax law and business code and replacing the "and" in subsection B of Title I with an "or," things most voters have no opinions on. The only people who do care, or who even understand what that small print means, are the lobbyists and the industries and interests they represent.
31:53 Speaker 18 Consider the American Jobs Creation Act of 2004. This was a piece of legislation that lots of multinational corporations spent a lot of time lobbying for because it got them a huge, one-time tax break. Some of the profits, the profits they made overseas, would be taxed at just 5% instead of the normal rate of 35%, a massive windfall.
32:11 Speaker 17 This law caught the attention of a tax professor at the University of Kansas, Raquel Alexander. She thought it might help her understand a pretty difficult question she and her colleagues had been considering.
32:22 Speaker 23 We know that people lobby for a reason, but we haven't really been able to quantify what's the return on their lobbying investment.
32:29 Speaker 17 With the American Jobs Creation Act, Alexander and her colleagues finally got something that could help them add up the lobbying costs and benefits.
32:37 Speaker 18 They simply compared the amount that companies spent lobbying with the amount they saved on their taxes, came up with a figure, a figure they called the return on investment for lobbying. Now, for some perspective, money in a regular old savings account, you'd be lucky to get a 1% return on your investment. On the other end of the spectrum, Bernie Madoff advertised annual returns of just over 10%. If you want to come up with a big, impressive sounding lie, a 10% return on investment is what you say. The return on investment to lobbying in the case of Alexander's study?
33:07 Speaker 23 22,000%. So for every dollar, on average, that these firms spent on tax lobbying, they received $220 in tax benefits from this repatriation provision.
33:18 Speaker 18 Were you expecting it to be that big?
33:21 Speaker 23 I was not. I was not expecting it to be that big at all. I thought I needed to go back and check my math again.
33:29 Speaker 18 So after the fifth or sixth time checking, you were like, oh, this is the number?
33:32 Speaker 23 After the 20th time of checking.
33:35 Speaker 17 In 2010, there was a total of $3.5 billion spent on lobbying. $3.5 billion. It's hard to imagine that every one of those dollars got a 22,000% return. There are certainly companies out there that spend a lot of money and don't get what they want. They've just lost money.
33:52 Speaker 18 And it's not to say that the things they're lobbying for are bad public policy. There are lots of people, President Obama included, who think a lower corporate tax rate would benefit the country.
34:02 Speaker 17 Barney Frank and lots of others told us straight up, a lot of times, the lobbyist knows much more about your subject than you do as a congressman. You depend on their expertise, and so you listen to their arguments.
34:12 Speaker 18 The problem is, those arguments are accompanied by a large check. The other side of the issue, you don't always hear from them.
34:23 Speaker 01 Alex Blumberg and Andrea Seabrook from Planet Money and This American Life in 2012. Just last year, the amount of money spent on lobbying hit a new record, $4.4 billion. Big thanks to This American Life for letting us rerun that piece. If somehow you are just hearing about This American Life for the first time, check it out. It's available wherever you listen to podcasts. After the break, we'll invite our professor back to talk about an economic principle that explains why special interests often get exactly what they want.
34:59 Speaker 04 Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors. This message comes from LinkedIn. As a small business owner, you wear many hats. You're the owner, the marketer, the seller, the hire. With LinkedIn, you have the tools to help you boost your visibility, find prospective customers, and find the best team for your small business, all in one place. So while LinkedIn can't hang up all of your hats, it makes it easier to wear them all. Learn more at LinkedIn.com/PlanetMoneyShow. This message comes from NPR sponsor Charles Schwab. Financial decisions can be tricky. Your biases can lead you astray. Financial Decoder, an original podcast from Charles Schwab, can help.
35:41 Speaker 04 Download the latest episode and subscribe at schwab.com/financialdecoder.
35:49 Speaker 01 We are back with our professor, Aviva Arindain.
35:51 Speaker 03 You're back.
35:54 Speaker 01 So in a democracy, we are essentially hiring these politicians to run our country in a responsible way. But there are all these pressures on them, right? To bring back more money to their districts and the national interest, of course. And as we hear in the story, to listen to what lobbyists want. And so politicians really have to weigh competing interests over taxation and spending.
36:16 Speaker 03 Yeah, I mean, I think another economics concept that comes into play here is the problem of concentrated versus diffuse benefits. And so let's take an example. If I were looking for a place to save money in the federal budget, to save a significant amount of money, one of the things I would look at is reforming the way we pay hospitals versus doctors in Medicare. We sometimes pay more for the exact same health service if you get it at a hospital than if you get it at a doctor's office. It costs us a lot of money, causes all kinds of problems, probably makes care worse.
36:52 Speaker 01 But who would want that?
36:53 Speaker 03 Right. The challenge is when ever anybody suggests changing it, and many people have, you get a lot of pushback from hospitals. And they push back quite publicly. And they say Congressman so and so is proposing to cause your local hospital to close. And a lot of people find that credible. Some voters may find that more credible than what their congressperson is telling them. And even more than that, the balance of interests is just very different. The hospital cares a ton about this payment reform. At best, the average citizen is going to save a little bit of money on their health bill, and they're going to see the national debt go down by a very little bit.
37:38 Speaker 03 And so they're just never going to care as much as the local hospital does. And I do think there are a bunch of problems in federal budgeting that have this quality, that you have concentrated interests on one side and diffuse benefits on the other.
37:52 Speaker 01 Yikes, the school bell is about to ring. Professor, perhaps we could go over some vocabulary, words and concepts, so that students can think about it when they hear about Congress debating the budget. Does a government program solve a market failure? What's a market failure?
38:07 Speaker 03 A case where the private market doesn't function effectively. For example, a case where the private market just won't provide a certain kind of service or good.
38:16 Speaker 01 And the government could step in.
38:18 Speaker 03 That's right.
38:19 Speaker 01 Redistribution.
38:21 Speaker 03 When we, as a society, say that we're not happy with the distribution of resources that results from just letting the market operate, and so we step in to achieve a different distribution of resources.
38:34 Speaker 01 When we talked about the problems of trying to balance the budget, we talked about concentrated versus diffuse costs and benefits.
38:44 Speaker 03 Yeah, there are a lot of problems in public policy where there are some stakeholders that benefit a lot from a particular policy, and there's a much larger number of stakeholders who would benefit a little bit from changing it. And those are circumstances where it's often hard to make changes.
39:03 Speaker 01 Aviva Erindine from the Hamilton Project, which is part of the Brookings Institution. Thank you so much for coming to class today.
39:11 Speaker 03 Thank you.
39:13 Speaker 01 Man, the time flies when we are in class. But if you're eager to hear more episodes now before everyone else get a head start on studying, well, you can. If you're signed up for Planet Money Plus, we're giving our Plus supporters early access to every episode of Summer School this season. You can brag, you can show it off. You'll also get sponsor-free versions of regular Planet Money episodes and The Indicator. Joining Planet Money Plus is one of the best things you can do right now to show your support for our journalism and the work of NPR. Go to plus.npr.org/planetmoney to join. Summer School is produced by Eric Mantle and edited by Alex Goldmark. It was fact-checked by Emily Crawford and Sierra Whitehouse.
39:56 Speaker 01 Devin Mellor is our project manager, and the show was engineered by Robert Rodriguez. I'm Robert Smith. This is NPR. Thank you for listening.
Previous Why are we so obsessed with manufacturing? Next The President's Golden Share in U.S. Steel Page updated November 1, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated