Pod Insights Planet Money Reese’s heir vs. chocolate skimpflation About this episode Live event info and tickets here. https://tix.to/pm-book-tour
When ingredient costs skyrocket, companies have three basic options: They can raise their prices (a sort of product-specific inflation), shrink the size of the products (often called “shrinkflation”), or, sometimes, find more creative ways to reduce costs by degrading the quality of their products - which our very own Greg Rosalsky has dubbed https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2021/10/26/1048892388/meet-skimpflation-a-reason-inflation-is-worse-than-the-government-says-it-is as “skimpflation.” The latest alleged culprit? Hershey’s.
The Hershey Company is using ingredients in some of their Reese’s candies that — legally — they cannot call milk chocolate or peanut butter. This has infuriated Brad Reese, a grandson of H. B. Reese, the inventor of the Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup.
On today’s show, why chocolate makers might be skimping on chocolate and peanut butter, what else might explain these ingredients, and how Brad Reese has launched a skimp-shaming campaign to get Hershey’s to go back to using classic Reese’s ingredients.
And – EXCLUSIVE – you’ll hear Planet Money break some big news to third-generation peanut butter cup scion Brad Reese.
Pre-order the Planet Money book and get a free gift https://www.planetmoneybook.com/. / Subscribe to Planet Money+ https://n.pr/3HlREPz
Listen free: Apple Podcasts http://n.pr/PM-digital, Spotify https://n.pr/3gTkQlR, the NPR app https://n.pr/3Bkb17W or anywhere you get podcasts.
Facebook https://n.pr/3h92GwS / Instagram https://n.pr/3FqLuws / TikTok https://n.pr/3sGZdrq / Our weekly Newsletter https://n.pr/3zrFvUB.
This episode was hosted by Greg Rosalsky and Sarah Gonzalez. It was produced by James Sneed. It was edited by Kenny Malone, fact-checked by Sierra Juarez, and engineered by Cena Loffredo. Alex Goldmark is Planet Money’s executive producer.
See pcm.adswizz.com https://pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for sponsorship and to manage your podcast sponsorship preferences.
NPR Privacy Policy https://www.npr.org/about-npr/179878450/privacy-policy
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 This message comes from Edward Jones, where they believe rich is about taking care of what gives your life meaning. That's why your financial advisor personalizes your plan to help you preserve your progress and create something that lasts. Let's find your rich. Edward Jones. Member SIPC.
0:20 Speaker 01 This is Planet Money from NPR.
0:25 Speaker 02 Brad would rather be spending his time singing karaoke right now.
0:30 Speaker 03 I do Rolling Stones. I do Depeche Mode. I just have fun.
0:39 Speaker 01 Brad is 70, retired in West Palm Beach, Florida.
0:43 Speaker 02 And when we first talked to him, he showed up wearing a bright orange, I guess Hawaiian shirt, but with a bunch of Reese's Peanut Butter Cups all over it. Honestly, pretty snazzy.
0:53 Speaker 03 I mean, I guess you could call me a big Reese's fan.
0:57 Speaker 02 And it's his love of Reese's that is keeping him from his beloved karaoke right now.
1:02 Speaker 01 Yeah, because a little while ago, he heard that the Hershey Company had released a new Reese's chocolate.
1:10 Speaker 03 It was Reese's Peanut Butter Mini Hearts Unwrapped. Okay? And of course, then I went out and bought one, bought a pouch.
1:18 Speaker 02 Brad opens the bag and pops some mini hearts in his mouth.
1:22 Speaker 03 And I took two bites and it was not recognizable. It was just nasty. It was not edible.
1:32 Speaker 02 Brad spits out the mini hearts and then he dumps them in the trash. But then he's like, wait, what was so off about those chocolate hearts?
1:40 Speaker 03 I retrieved the pouch wrapper and looked carefully at the front and the back. And there was no milk chocolate and there was no real peanut butter. So it wasn't even, I don't know what I, Greg, I have no idea what I was eating or what I was tasting.
1:55 Speaker 01 Brad is like, what is even in here? No milk chocolate, no peanut butter in a chocolate Reese's Peanut Butter Cup like product?
2:04 Speaker 03 I went to the store and just investigated everything I could.
2:10 Speaker 01 Brad starts scanning the candy aisles, looking at the wrappers of other Reese's and Hershey's products.
2:16 Speaker 03 Are you familiar with the Reese's Fast Break?
2:18 Speaker 02 I am.
2:18 Speaker 03 Okay. One of my favorites. No longer milk chocolate.
2:23 Speaker 02 Wow.
2:24 Speaker 03 The Reese's sticks, have you had those?
2:26 Speaker 02 I have not had the Reese's.
2:27 Speaker 03 They're similar to a Kit Kat, but peanut butter. And those came out in 1998, very good, I love them. And it came out as the crisp, you can't resist. That used to be milk chocolate, again, taken off, no milk chocolate.
2:40 Speaker 02 Yeah, the wrappers on these Reese's candies have changed. They used to say milk chocolate. And on some other Reese's candies, they used to say peanut butter. Now they say something else.
2:51 Speaker 03 Chocolate candy. They replaced milk chocolate with chocolate candy. And they replaced the peanut butter with peanut butter cream.
3:00 Speaker 01 And these words, chocolate candy, peanut butter, cream. They may sound like the real deal, milk chocolate and peanut butter, but they are not.
3:10 Speaker 03 It's fake, it's it's compound coating. It it's betrayal. I felt betrayed, I mean, it's like somebody took a dagger and stabbed it in my heart.
3:20 Speaker 02 It'd be one thing if Brad were just like some random Reese's super fan. But Brad, he's the grandson of H.B. Reese. The inventor of the Reese's Peanut Butter Cup.
3:32 Speaker 01 Brad's name is Brad Reese.
3:36 Speaker 03 And then I just said, wait a second. I can do something about this.
3:41 Speaker 02 Hello and welcome to Planet Money, I'm Greg Rosalsky.
3:44 Speaker 01 And I'm Sarah Gonzalez. The Hershey Company is using ingredients in their candies that legally they cannot label milk chocolate or peanut butter.
3:54 Speaker 02 And an heir to a chocolate and peanut butter dynasty is now going after the brand that bears his family name.
4:03 Speaker 01 Today on the show, why chocolate makers might be skimping on the chocolate and the peanut butter.
4:15 Speaker 04 Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors. This message comes from Odoo. Running a business shouldn't feel like surviving a software group project. Start managing your business with one unified system. Odoo is the all-in-one business management software. Try for free today at odoo.com/planetmoney.
4:36 Speaker 00 This message comes from LinkedIn. Owning a small business comes with a lot of challenges and means juggling multiple things at once. It's even harder to do it efficiently. But with LinkedIn, you get all the tools you need to grow in one place. With LinkedIn, simplify your sales, marketing, and hiring so that you can actually run your small business. Learn more at LinkedIn.com/planetmoneyshow.
5:00 Speaker 04 This message comes from NPR sponsor Charles Schwab. Financial decisions can be tricky. Your biases can lead you astray. Financial Decoder, an original podcast from Charles Schwab, can help. Download the latest episode and subscribe at schwab.com/financialdecoder.
5:17 Speaker 02 All right. Obviously, we reached out to the Hershey Company to weigh in on the chocolate allegations made by Brad Reese, angry grandson of the Reese's Peanut Butter Cup inventor. Hershey's did not give us an interview, but they did tell us via email that their, quote, "iconic" Reese's Peanut Butter Cups are, quote, "made the same way they always have been."
5:40 Speaker 01 Which prompted a thorough investigation by Planet Money at various stores.
5:45 Speaker 02 Incredibly thorough.
5:50 Speaker 02 Wow.
5:51 Speaker 01 We have purchased $70 worth of Reese's products.
5:56 Speaker 02 Oh, look at that CVS receipt. Jeez.
5:59 Speaker 01 You can just hear it from a mile away.
6:03 Speaker 02 Honestly Reese's Peanut Butter Cups, my number one. Since, since maybe I was like four or five years old. I'm like, I don't even think there's like, I can't even think of my number two.
6:11 Speaker 01 Number one chocolate, Reese's, Reese's.
6:13 Speaker 02 It's Reese's.
6:15 Speaker 01 Reese's.
6:15 Speaker 02 This would like rock my world if it, if we're not pronounced Reese's.
6:20 Speaker 01 You're giving me Brad vibes, Greg.
6:22 Speaker 02 It would be devastating.
6:25 Speaker 01 All right, when we go through this assortment of chocolate that we have assembled here, here's what we found. The original Reese's Peanut Butter Cups, as Hershey said, do still say that they are made with real milk chocolate and real peanut butter. That formula has not changed.
6:43 Speaker 02 Same with the mini cups and even some of the Easter related egg shaped ones. They also still say milk chocolate and peanut butter.
6:51 Speaker 01 But on some of the other products that we have here, Brad is right. Those do say chocolate candy or peanut butter cream or both.
7:02 Speaker 02 Yeah, for example, on these mini eggs that are unwrapped. Also a more normal sized egg one that is wrapped.
7:10 Speaker 01 Some flat eggs, some chocolate bunnies. On those, it is chocolate candy or peanut butter cream.
7:16 Speaker 02 Brad thinks Hershey's is skimping on their ingredients so much that they can't even call their stuff milk chocolate or peanut butter anymore. So they use workaround words.
7:27 Speaker 03 Key words are chocolate candy, chocolatey, covered in chocolate, made with chocolate. If you don't see the words milk chocolate, then it's fake.
7:37 Speaker 02 Fake is kind of a mean way of saying these candies are using what's known as a chocolate compound. Chocolate compound uses some chocolate ingredients, but not enough to legally be called milk chocolate.
7:50 Speaker 01 Similar story with the peanut cream, not enough peanuts to be called peanut butter. And for Brad Reese, using fewer peanuts, using fewer chocolate ingredients, this is in poor taste.
8:02 Speaker 02 That is a bit of an understatement. Brad is basically accusing Hershey's of chocolate skimflation. Skimpflation. This is a term that we at Planet Money coined a few years ago.
8:16 Speaker 01 Well, Greg, you, you are fantastic newsletter writer. You coined this and now like the Federal Reserve is saying skimflation.
8:24 Speaker 02 NPR, you cannot ever let me go. This is like, I'm the skimflation guy. I'm the skimflation, I'm the skimflation guy. You can't skimp on me. Uh, anyway, yeah, so skimflation, it's a business practice in which companies degrade their goods and services. You know, like skimp on their quality, often in response to inflationary pressures like higher ingredient costs or, you know, higher labor costs. It's a sneaky form of inflation where instead of simply raising prices, companies skimp on the quality of their goods and services.
8:59 Speaker 01 On the quality. Now, for the record, some Reese's products may have always been made with chocolate compound and were never made with real milk chocolate or real peanut butter. But other products do seem to have actually switched ingredients or some might say skimmed on the ingredients. They skimflated.
9:20 Speaker 02 And Brad Reese, he's not happy with any of this. He says Hershey's is degrading his family legacy.
9:28 Speaker 03 Yeah, so to understand where I fit in, okay, my grandfather, H.B. Reese, was born in 1879 and my father was the youngest of his 16 children.
9:41 Speaker 02 16?
9:42 Speaker 03 Yes.
9:43 Speaker 02 So, yeah, H.B. Reese, he had a lot of mouths to feed. In 1916, probably amidst the screams of a ton of crying babies, H.B. Reese read in the newspaper that Milton Hershey, the founder of the Hershey Chocolate Company, needed more help on his dairy farms, which, you know, supplied milk for his, his milk chocolate.
10:04 Speaker 01 Brad's grandpa, H.B., got the job. It was the start of a long-term business relationship and friendship between Grandpa Reese and Mr. Hershey. And then in 1923, H.B. formed his own company, the H.B. Reese Candy Company.
10:18 Speaker 03 He had peanut clusters, he had caramel, he had coconut.
10:22 Speaker 02 At the time, there was this chocolate peanut butter product on the market in Pennsylvania. It was a ball, peanut butter ball wrapped in chocolate. And H.B. Reese, he has an idea.
10:35 Speaker 03 So what my grandfather did is he put it in a cup.
10:39 Speaker 01 Oh, it's in a cup now, guys. Innovation.
10:44 Speaker 02 All right, it was also, there was also, there was something else. It was one part of the innovation.
10:49 Speaker 03 My grandfather's genius was to perfect the peanut butter. The key has always been the peanut butter.
10:57 Speaker 02 He builds a chocolate and peanut butter empire. In the 50s, he hands control over to his six sons. And in 1963, those sons, they sell to Hershey. Okay, technically, it's a merger. Brad's dad and the other siblings, they get stock and a big payday.
11:14 Speaker 03 I was only seven years old. I didn't even know my family owned a candy company. I thought he worked there like everybody else. So I had no say, you know, didn't know what that was, that transaction was all about. Other than we moved from a normal house into a big mansion.
11:31 Speaker 01 Brad wishes his family never sold the company and I guess stayed in a normal house, didn't move to imagine.
11:37 Speaker 02 Yeah, he wishes he had some control over the Reese's brand, especially right now. After he tasted those Reese's Peanut Butter Mini Hearts unwrapped back in February and hated them.
11:49 Speaker 03 I just had to spit it out. I, I, I, I mean, slap me in the face, wake me up.
11:53 Speaker 01 After first tasting those mini hearts, Brad did what any third generation chocolate royal with no power over the family company because it was sold over a half century ago could do. He wrote an open letter on LinkedIn.
12:07 Speaker 03 That's why I'm writing to you publicly today.
12:10 Speaker 02 This is Brad reading his open letter.
12:13 Speaker 03 My grandfather, H.B. Reese, who invented Reese's, built Reese's on a simple, enduring architecture.
12:20 Speaker 03 Milk chocolate plus peanut butter.
12:23 Speaker 02 Brad's basic thing is you're damaging the Reese's brand. But, you know, written with the seriousness of the Declaration of Independence.
12:31 Speaker 03 Not a flavor idea, not a marketing construct, a real tangible product identity that consumers have trusted for a century.
12:42 Speaker 01 But honestly, can anyone but Brad Reese even really taste the difference between milk chocolate and chocolate candy or peanut butter versus peanut butter cream? Because in response to Brad's open letter, other Reese's descendants wrote their own letter or statement or whatever, being like, "The products are fine. Grandpa Reese would be fine with the current Reese's products."
13:06 Speaker 02 I mean, Sarah, it wouldn't be a great American candy company without, you know, some family drama.
13:11 Speaker 01 A little family drama, totally.
13:14 Speaker 02 So, yeah, like, in our continued thorough investigation, hello Pulitzer Committee, we moved to this, you know, taste test phase. Should we start with the OG?
13:25 Speaker 01 To set our palate?
13:26 Speaker 02 Here we go.
13:27 Speaker 01 We begin with the classic Reese's Peanut Butter Cup that is still labeled milk, chocolate, and peanut butter.
13:32 Speaker 02 Oh, my God. How iconic. I love how they have the little wrap around it, too. Like, you open it and there's that little film.
13:43 Speaker 02 It's neat. It's like unwrapping a gift.
13:47 Speaker 02 Fantastic. I'm sorry. Like, it doesn't get better.
13:50 Speaker 01 So I sometimes nibble at the edges.
13:56 Speaker 02 You're like a little gerbil, just like...
13:59 Speaker 01 Okay, two bites. Two bites and it's done.
14:00 Speaker 02 No, you gotta do two bites. The classic Reese's Peanut Butter Cup, it's as scrumptious as ever.
14:06 Speaker 01 Now we gotta taste the one labeled chocolate candy and peanut butter cream. This is where the investigation really picks at people, okay?
14:13 Speaker 02 I found Reese's Peanut Butter Mini Eggs unwrapped.
14:17 Speaker 01 You do?
14:17 Speaker 02 So it's... You got that? All right, great.
14:20 Speaker 01 This is the same thing that Brad Reese had that he spit out, except these are the eggs. He had the hearts because it was around Valentine's Day.
14:29 Speaker 02 This is what broke Brad Reese's heart. All right, we're gonna open this up.
14:33 Speaker 01 Little mini egg.
14:34 Speaker 02 Look at this. They're a little tiny. Oh, yeah, I see. They're unwrapped. Honestly, I'm just gonna be honest. It doesn't smell the same.
14:42 Speaker 01 I think it does.
14:44 Speaker 02 No.
14:44 Speaker 01 Bite it in half or pop it?
14:46 Speaker 02 Yeah, I think just pop it in.
14:51 Speaker 01 No.
14:52 Speaker 02 I'm not joking.
14:53 Speaker 01 No.
14:54 Speaker 02 I'm not just saying this, it's not right.
14:55 Speaker 01 Totally.
14:56 Speaker 02 It's not right.
14:56 Speaker 01 I mean, I can get on board with the peanut butter cream, but I give no allowances on the skimping of the chocolate. I like the peanut butter cream. I'm just gonna say it.
15:06 Speaker 02 Do you?
15:07 Speaker 01 It's like saltier.
15:08 Speaker 02 I, I like the OG peanut butter. Um, call me old fashioned, but um, I don't like a mystery. I don't, what is the cream? What does that mean?
15:17 Speaker 01 I.
15:18 Speaker 02 See, I'm, I, I feel, I, I feel very passionate about peanut butter. So I, I, I, I don't want this. I don't want anything skimmed on. It was a disappointing experience for me. I mean, listen, I love Reese's Peanut Butter Cups as much as the next guy.
15:31 Speaker 01 Well, not as much as Brad.
15:32 Speaker 02 Not as much as Brad and Reese.
15:33 Speaker 01 Yeah, sure, not as much as Brad.
15:34 Speaker 02 Obviously, I don't think, I don't think anybody likes it as much as him. But still, it stirred something in me. Was it anger? Was it desperation and, and existential crisis? Or was it yearning? To understand why a storied chocolate company would use less chocolate in peanut butter.
15:56 Speaker 01 It has to do with the global chocolate supply chain, the shapes our fun chocolate comes in, and the less discerning consumers who somehow may not even notice. That's after the break.
16:08 Speaker 02 Break me off a piece of that podcast underwriting.
16:12 Speaker 01 Oh, baritone. I like it.
16:18 Speaker 00 Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors.
16:22 Speaker 04 This message comes from Odoo, the all-in-one business management software platform. Whether you're a small or large business, Odoo gives you one flexible platform built to grow with you. Try today for free at Odoo.com/planetmoney.
16:37 Speaker 00 This message comes from Rula. World Mental Health Day takes place in October, making it a great time to take that next step in getting support if you need it. Rula makes accessing quality mental health care affordable with sessions costing an average of $15 with insurance. So turn off the talk track that's keeping you from progress and head to rula.com. That's R U L A dot com to find a therapist the easy way. This message comes from LinkedIn. As a small business owner, you wear many hats. You're the owner, the marketer, the seller, the hire. With LinkedIn, you have the tools to help you boost your visibility, find prospective customers, and find the best team for your small business, all in one place.
17:21 Speaker 00 So while LinkedIn can't hang up all of your hats, it makes it easier to wear them all. Learn more at LinkedIn.com/PlanetMoneyShow.
17:31 Speaker 01 To understand why chocolate makers are skimping on the milk chocolate right now, we called up someone who knows the ins and outs of the chocolate industry and somehow seems to be as passionate about chocolate as Brad Reese.
17:45 Speaker 05 You know, I travel a ton and in my luggage, I always, always, always, 100% carry with me Valrona unsweetened cocoa powder.
17:57 Speaker 02 This is Judy Gaines and honestly, we had to look up Valrona. I'd never heard of it. And apparently this is like the Gucci or Lamborghini of cocoa powder because this stuff is like expensive.
18:08 Speaker 01 Super high end.
18:09 Speaker 05 It's a three kilo box.
18:11 Speaker 02 You're buying kilos of cocoa powder? And you're like sprinkling it on things? Like what do you do with it?
18:18 Speaker 05 I actually make hot chocolate with it and sometimes it gets nailed by security as to what it is.
18:27 Speaker 01 And you're like, I'm in chocolate. I'm in chocolate. I work in chocolate. It's cocoa powder.
18:31 Speaker 02 They're like frisking you and I just love it because you're a chocolate expert and that's just like so wonderful.
18:38 Speaker 01 Judy has a consulting firm that focuses on soft commodities.
18:43 Speaker 05 So sugar, coffee, cocoa, cotton, orange juice.
18:46 Speaker 01 So a hard commodity would be like crude oil, coal, gold, diamonds. Basically, hard commodities are mined or drilled. Soft commodities are typically grown. And Judy? Trudy is a soft commodity gal, particularly.
19:03 Speaker 05 Cocoa, yeah, definitely.
19:06 Speaker 02 Before we get into chocolate economics, coconomics, if you will, you gotta know how we even get this miracle of nature and human ingenuity we call chocolate. Chocolate comes from chocolate liqueur. It sounds like something that would give you like a really bad hangover, but it doesn't contain any alcohol.
19:28 Speaker 01 Chocolate liqueur is what you get when you take the cocoa pod, like the whole fruit, take the cocoa beans out, ferment them, roast them, grind them up. The result is that chocolate liqueur, which is part cocoa butter, part cocoa powder.
19:41 Speaker 05 So it's sort of like having a jar of peanut butter that the oil rises to the top.
19:46 Speaker 02 Trudy says the cocoa butter part is kind of essential for the texture and silkiness of chocolate. The cocoa powder, it's more essential for the flavor.
19:54 Speaker 01 And as we've mentioned, if you wanna call something milk chocolate, the Food and Drug Administration doesn't mess around. They have strict, strict rules.
20:04 Speaker 05 In milk chocolate, as per the FDA, it has to be, in the US, 10% chocolate liqueur.
20:13 Speaker 01 At least 10%.
20:15 Speaker 02 10%, let's say together, let's harmonize. At least 10%.
20:20 Speaker 01 10% chocolate liqueur.
20:23 Speaker 05 That little catch on the FDA is that for whatever cocoa butter is in that milk chocolate, it must be 100% cocoa butter. You can't substitute any vegetable oil or palm oil.
20:41 Speaker 02 It has to be pure cocoa butter, people.
20:43 Speaker 01 I mean, come on, if there's vegetable oil in there.
20:46 Speaker 02 That's the weak stuff. We don't want that. That's not chocolate.
20:49 Speaker 05 Then it's not chocolate.
20:51 Speaker 01 That's what I'm saying.
20:52 Speaker 02 That's what I said, Trudy.
20:56 Speaker 02 We need to go back to the investigation.
20:58 Speaker 01 Cue the sound, James.
21:02 Speaker 01 All right, when you flip over some of these Reese's products that we have in our hands right here, you will see in the ingredients, first sugar, then vegetable oil.
21:13 Speaker 02 The smoking skimflation gun, it's right there.
21:16 Speaker 01 Well.
21:16 Speaker 02 Right in front of our face the whole time, Sarah.
21:20 Speaker 01 Well, hold on, because do we know for sure that the motivation here is to skim? Like, could there be other reasons to swap out the ingredients? Because in March, when we first heard from Hershey's, they suggested that their use of chocolate compound and peanut butter cream was not skimflation, that it was innovation, that this was about new shapes and sizes, new products, and serving consumer preferences.
21:44 Speaker 02 Yeah, yeah, yeah. We'll dive into more of that in a second. But I'm just gonna say it, like, it's not this consumer's preference.
21:51 Speaker 01 We know, we know, we know. Okay, we are going to start with the evidence that this is actually skimflation.
21:58 Speaker 02 Okay, hear me out, guys. The case for skimflation, here we go. First of all, for years, big American chocolate companies, including Hershey's, have actually lobbied the federal government to let them switch in vegetable oil for cocoa butter and still call their products milk chocolate.
22:18 Speaker 05 The industry is like, please, please, please, you gotta help us out. And the FDA says, no.
22:23 Speaker 02 If you skim on the cocoa, you cannot call it milk chocolate.
22:27 Speaker 01 So why would you skim? Like, surely chocolate makers don't want to have to call their stuff chocolate candy or chocolate compound, so why even do it? Well, to understand that, we need to dive into the global chocolate supply chain.
22:42 Speaker 05 So there's been a dependency on the Ivory Coast and Ghana to supply a massive percent of the world's chocolate.
22:52 Speaker 01 Yeah, most of the world's cocoa comes from the Ivory Coast and Ghana in West Africa.
22:56 Speaker 02 And a few years ago, there was this funky weather. We're talking long droughts and extreme heat and also excessive rainfall, and that smothered cocoa production. And in April of 2024, the global price of cocoa went cuckoo.
23:12 Speaker 05 The price of cocoa butter. Rather than being $3,000 a ton, went to $25,000 a ton.
23:19 Speaker 01 Holy moly.
23:20 Speaker 05 Yeah.
23:21 Speaker 01 That's a big difference.
23:22 Speaker 05 Okay.
23:23 Speaker 02 This was record highs.
23:25 Speaker 05 So the last time cocoa prices were high, you know, at like nosebleed levels, was in 1977. And now you have prices that are triple that level.
23:37 Speaker 01 And then President Trump also slapped high tariffs on Ghana and the Ivory Coast on top of the already cuckoo for cocoa prices. And Judy says, like, put yourself in the shoes of a chocolate manufacturer here.
23:50 Speaker 05 I mean, it's impossible.
23:52 Speaker 02 Now, when ingredient costs go through the roof, companies have three basic options.
23:57 Speaker 01 They can raise prices, you know, kind of like inflation on a product. But of course, consumers do not love it when prices go up.
24:06 Speaker 02 Or they can shrink the amount of stuff they provide in their packages, which is known as shrinkflation. But consumers also don't love it when, you know, the chip bag is now smaller or half empty.
24:17 Speaker 01 Or they can skimp on the quality of their product, what we at Planet Money, really Greg, our newsletter writer, have dubbed skimpflation.
24:24 Speaker 02 Skimping on the ingredients, uh, it's all pretty sneaky. It's all subtle. Some consumers, you know, with less refined chocolate and peanut butter palettes and, you know, you, Sarah, or me, or Brad Reese, they might not even notice, you know? And this recent cocoa shortage was so extreme that Judy says chocolate makers, they pulled all the levers.
24:49 Speaker 05 They did raise prices, they did shrink the packaging, and they had to reformulate.
24:54 Speaker 01 We got skimpflation, we got shrinkflation, we got inflation, they hit us on all fronts.
25:01 Speaker 02 Which like, okay, understandable, but wait just right there. Cause okay, right? Like, yeah, drought and rainfall, West Africa, production problems with the cocoa global supply chain and yada, yada, yada, you know, affected chocolate.
25:15 Speaker 01 What about the peanut butter, though? Because peanuts are grown in the United States for the most part. Like, why are they skimping on the peanut butter? Why do we have peanut butter cream right now? Like, what is the argument for that? Come on.
25:29 Speaker 05 Okay, okay. So. It's not only about the price.
25:33 Speaker 02 Yeah, it's not just about the price. Judy says maybe they changed the peanut butter so it works with the new chocolate formula.
25:40 Speaker 05 A product that's made with vegetable oil that doesn't have the same texture. Is there going to be seepage and, you know, how does it stand up in packaging?
25:51 Speaker 02 And Hershey's actually told us a version of this too. And this is bringing us to the rest of Hershey's case that this is not skinflation. Okay, they said, quote, "Different shapes simply require a different recipe to hold their form. And for labeling purposes, that's referred to as a cream."
26:10 Speaker 01 As a cream, but they did say that even when they create different Reese's shapes and forms, that they still start with, quote, "fresh ground peanuts," which is an important distinction. Because to be clear here, peanut butter cream just means that Reese's is using less than 90% peanuts, which is the FDA rule for calling yourself peanut butter. So I don't know, maybe they're using 80% peanuts or 50% peanuts. So when we say that they are not using real peanut butter or real milk chocolate, it's not like they're using fake peanuts or fake cocoa. It's more like they're using less peanuts and less cocoa.
26:49 Speaker 02 Hershey's told us, as we've grown and expanded the Reese's product line, we make product recipe adjustments that allow us to make new shapes, sizes, and innovations that Reese's fans have come to love and ask for.
27:04 Speaker 01 Yeah, and Judy says maybe there's a broader business strategy going on here too. Okay, because Reese's consumers aren't all the same. And she says Hershey's is like differentiating their products for different segments of the market.
27:18 Speaker 05 I would say, look at designer clothing.
27:21 Speaker 01 Think of like a luxury clothing brand.
27:23 Speaker 05 They have their haute couture.
27:26 Speaker 01 Their fanciest clothesline.
27:28 Speaker 02 For Reese's, that's the classic peanut butter cup. Silky, smooth, luxurious. Still legally, milk chocolate and peanut butter.
27:36 Speaker 01 Then they have more like middle of the road clothes.
27:39 Speaker 05 That are selling mid-market.
27:42 Speaker 01 You know, like out of Macy's or something.
27:44 Speaker 02 Okay, like mid-market Reese's, uh, that's probably like the Reese's sticks or something. I mean, they're pretty good, but they're kind of just like an imposter Kit Kat. I mean, like, what are we doing?
27:54 Speaker 05 And then they have. Offshoots for like the discount stores.
28:00 Speaker 01 You know, the stuff you'd find at like a Ross.
28:02 Speaker 02 And maybe for Reese's, that would be like the mini eggs unwrapped. And for those eggs, Reese's can use the chocolate compounds or the peanut butter cream because those mini eggs, they're just not for me, the Reese's purist. They're more of like a down market product.
28:19 Speaker 01 Yeah, Judy says these products may be more meant for kids. And kids, they don't care.
28:25 Speaker 02 I'd like to think my son would notice.
28:28 Speaker 01 I would like to think that we are raising children to notice the difference. Same.
28:32 Speaker 02 I definitely taste the difference. I'm still trying to get it off my tongue.
28:36 Speaker 01 All right, so maybe some of this is the result of trying to make new products and shapes for different kinds of consumers. But if it has been about skimping in response to sky high cocoa prices, there's a chance that our national skimpy chocolate nightmare might soon be over.
28:54 Speaker 02 Because cost pressures have partly subsided over the last year. In November, the Trump administration citing affordability concerns exempted cocoa beans from tariffs. And the production problems in West Africa seem to at least have been partially resolved. Since its peak in early 2025, the global price of cocoa has fallen more than 60%.
29:18 Speaker 01 So maybe, maybe chocolate companies will go back to the real deal milk chocolate, right Judy?
29:25 Speaker 05 I'm gonna throw something at you, okay?
29:27 Speaker 01 Okay. In the eighties.
29:29 Speaker 05 The major soft drink manufacturers, Pepsi, switched from 100% sugar to high fructose corn syrup.
29:40 Speaker 02 That was in response to high sugar prices, but soda makers, they never looked back.
29:45 Speaker 01 Judy, it sounds like you're saying you don't think these chocolate manufacturers are going to go back to the original milk chocolate formula. But that's what that example is telling me, like.
29:57 Speaker 05 Some will not. It really depends on the economics and what their sales are. And if consumers are buying it.
30:06 Speaker 01 Yeah, are consumers buying it? Are they even noticing it? I mean, certainly you would not want someone announcing to the world like, "Hey, this isn't real milk chocolate anymore." But that is what Brad Reese is doing. He has mounted what you might call a skimp shaming campaign against Hershey's.
30:26 Speaker 03 I think I'm having an impact. I really do. They're on notice. Are they not on notice?
30:31 Speaker 02 Yeah, it seems like they're on notice. This was not on my radar and I actually love Reese's. And now, and to be honest now that because of you, when I go to the store, I do look at the ingredients. Brad's been writing these open letters. He's making media appearances. He's documenting Hershey's ingredient lists and their changes. And he's been updating his website and his LinkedIn. But he's hoping his skimp shaming tour can end soon. So he can go back and enjoy retired life.
31:04 Speaker 03 I can go, I can do my karaoke at Wednesdays at Benny's on the beach.
31:10 Speaker 03 That's what I want to get back to. I don't know where this is going to lead because it is a lot of work. And, and I'm not against doing a lot of work, but also I need to take my naps. And I need to, I want to have a simple, enjoyable life. And, but Reese's is no longer the enjoyable part of my life anymore. It's now just, I'll just go out and just be a normal person, wearing a normal shirt. And, uh, and we'll be talking about Reese's.
31:39 Speaker 02 Brad's hope is that consumers notice the new formula and that they won't settle for skimpy chocolate. And that Hershey's is forced to go back. Oh my gosh, I just got an alert, Sarah. We're working on this story right now. This is breaking news for us. Hershey, this is from Bloomberg Business. Hershey will change the chocolate in a small portion of its Reese's and Hershey's products. The latest twist in a squabble over its ingredients initiated by a grandson of the Reese's Peanut Butter Cup creator.
32:15 Speaker 01 Brad did it?
32:16 Speaker 02 Brad did it. Okay, so let's put a pin in whether Brad did it or not. But yeah, Hershey's, it announced it will stop using chocolate compound coating in all of its products.
32:29 Speaker 01 The moment the news broke, we of course called up Brad Reese.
32:32 Speaker 02 I have some news.
32:34 Speaker 06 What news? What are you talking about? What's going on?
32:35 Speaker 01 Brad was out on the town. We were talking to him on the phone on speaker and he had not yet heard the news.
32:41 Speaker 06 I already, I already got my computer to sleep. Yeah. So I'm, I'm out partying right now. So yeah.
32:47 Speaker 02 Um, this is today, this just came out. The company said, this is Hershey's, it will swap out a chocolate compound coating as part of a return to using, quote, "classic milk and dark chocolate recipes," end quote, "in all Reese's and Hershey's products by 2027."
33:07 Speaker 06 What? Wait a second. They're giving themselves two years?
33:13 Speaker 02 Wait, so you're not happy, Brad?
33:15 Speaker 06 I mean, come on, the brand will be ruined by that.
33:18 Speaker 01 We did tell Hershey's that this recent ingredient change by them seemed like a pretty big contradiction to what they told us before. That the compound stuff and the cream stuff was all about innovation that consumers love. They suggested it was not a contradiction. They said, quote, "As consumer preferences continue to change about ingredients and tastes, we continue to evolve to meet these needs."
33:42 Speaker 02 Now, as to whether Brad caused this to happen, in the Bloomberg article, it does seem that Hershey, it says, "The Hershey chief executive officer Kirk Tanner said he made the decision to change the ingredients shortly after he took the role last summer and well before Brad Reese aired his complaints." So I don't think.
34:05 Speaker 06 Oh, that's hilarious. Okay, all right.
34:09 Speaker 01 Wait, where are you?
34:10 Speaker 06 Johnny Brown's in Delray Beach.
34:12 Speaker 02 Are you, are you singing karaoke?
34:13 Speaker 06 Well, no, that's later tonight, Ten Roof at nine o'clock.
34:16 Speaker 01 What are you gonna sing?
34:18 Speaker 06 I'll probably be singing Nightlife by Willie Nelson.
34:22 Speaker 01 You wanna give us a little?
34:25 Speaker 06 Oh, the nightlife, it's not a good life, but it's my life. Listen to what the blues are saying.
34:39 Speaker 01 Do you love the banter between your Planet Money co-hosts?
34:43 Speaker 02 Oh, Sam.
34:43 Speaker 01 The chemistry?
34:44 Speaker 02 Just bantering back and forth. It's like, it's like tennis. We're going back and forth, just bantering away.
34:51 Speaker 01 Wanna see this all happen live on a stage as we do a live taping of a brand new episode? Great, you are in luck. You should come see us on the Planet Money Book Tour. I'm gonna be in Santa Monica on April 16th with Jack Horbit from our famous, famous Planet Money TikTok. You can see him doing his thing live on stage.
35:10 Speaker 02 Yeah, we're gonna be so many places. DC, Seattle, Boulder, the South.
35:17 Speaker 01 San Francisco, Toronto. We're going international, baby.
35:19 Speaker 02 We're going to the moon. We're going all over the place, baby. Let's get wild.
35:25 Speaker 01 The book is called Planet Money, A Guide to the Economic Forces That Shape Your Life. And every stop is gonna be unique and different with different hosts, different guests. If you get a ticket to one of our live events, you will also get a book tour exclusive tote bag. We know you love a tote bag, listeners. Okay. Find the show nearest to you at the link in our show notes or go to planetmoneybook.com. And thanks for supporting us.
35:50 Speaker 02 This episode of Planet Money was produced by the wonderful James Snead.
35:55 Speaker 01 Cue the chocolate investigation sound again, one more time for the people.
35:59 Speaker 02 It was edited by Kenny Malone, fact-checked by Sierra Juarez, and engineered by Sina LaFredo. Alex Golmark is our executive producer.
36:08 Speaker 01 I'm Sarah Gonzalez.
36:10 Speaker 02 And I'm Greg Wazowski. This is NPR. Thanks for listening.
36:15 Speaker 00 Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors.
36:19 Speaker 04 This message comes from Edward Jones, where they believe rich means opening yourself to new possibilities. That's why your dedicated financial advisor meets you where you are, helping you move forward with confidence. Let's find you're rich. Edward Jones. Member SIPC.
36:37 Speaker 00 This message comes from Google Workspace with Gemini. One subscription that does it all. Personalized AI and premium business versions of Gmail, Google Docs, Drive, and more. Try it free for 14 days at goo.gle/workspacewithGemini.
Previous Dark times for Cuba’s economic experiment Next A pro-worker experiment in private equity Page updated October 30, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated