Pod Insights Planet Money Planet Money vs. the NBA’s tanking problem About this episode What do we want from sports? The very best athletes competing as hard as they know how, putting all their effort and training and natural ability to the test against their opponents. But this time of year, that’s not the product the NBA is putting on the court. Instead, teams at the bottom of the league are competing … to lose, because it could help them get a top pick in next year’s draft. It’s called tanking — it’s bad for fans, and it’s bad for the league.
Tanking has gotten especially egregious this year. Even NBA Adam Silver has called out teams for tanking https://www.nba.com/watch/video/adam-silver-press-conference-v2. He recently announced that league bigwigs are considering “every possible remedy” to “align incentives.”
Today on the show — Planet Money fixes the NBA’s tanking problem by … fixing the NBA draft. We get solutions from Hockey Hall of Famer Jayna Hefford https://www.hhof.com/induction_archives/ind18Hefford.shtml, World Cup Champion Sam Mewis https://www.meninblazers.com/the-women-s-game, and long-time NBA analyst Zach Lowe https://www.theringer.com/podcasts/the-zach-lowe-show.
Handles for the NBA fans in the episode: thevoiceofevan https://www.tiktok.com/@thevoiceofevan/video/7604256573078113566?_r=1&_t=ZT-93mTp0nKiZq, fullcourtblitz https://www.tiktok.com/@fullcourtblitz/video/7604210050353188109, ashleynevel https://www.tiktok.com/@ashleynevel/video/7604556955096599821?q=nba%20tank%20ashley%20nevel&t=1772636454584, igotnxtpodcast https://www.tiktok.com/@igotnxtpodcast/video/7605276905276820767, finesse.wes https://www.tiktok.com/@finesse.wes/video/7609457324943527181, basketballsavant https://www.tiktok.com/@basketballsavant/video/7595383074884504863, and mikedaddino__ https://www.instagram.com/reel/DUe22nhjl4A/.
Live event info and tickets here https://tix.to/pm-book-tour / Pre-order the Planet Money book and get a free gift https://www.planetmoneybook.com/. / Subscribe to Planet Money+ https://n.pr/3HlREPz
Listen free: Apple Podcasts http://n.pr/PM-digital, Spotify https://n.pr/3gTkQlR, or the NPR app https://n.pr/3Bkb17W
Facebook https://n.pr/3h92GwS / Instagram https://n.pr/3FqLuws / TikTok https://n.pr/3sGZdrq / Our weekly Newsletter https://n.pr/3zrFvUB
This episode was hosted by Keith Romer and Erika Beras. It was produced by James Sneed with an assist from Sam Yellowhorse Kesler. It was edited by Jess Jiang and fact-checked by Sierra Juarez. Alex Goldmark is our executive producer.
See pcm.adswizz.com https://pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for sponsorship and to manage your podcast sponsorship preferences.
NPR Privacy Policy https://www.npr.org/about-npr/179878450/privacy-policy
Transcript 5,929 words · 14 speakers
0:00 Speaker 00 This message comes from University of Buffalo, where five decades of AI research is producing advancements that put people first. Tackling real-world problems for progress, not profit. Empowering, not replacing. Learn how the University of Buffalo is using AI responsibly to create a better, brighter future for all at buffalo.edu/NPR.
0:23 Speaker 01 This is Planet Money from NPR.
0:28 Speaker 02 Every year, as winter starts to turn to spring, this very weird thing starts to happen in the NBA. Diehard fans begin rooting against their favorite teams.
0:40 Speaker 03 This is the only time in recorded human history where I'm not even the slightest bit mad that we're losing to the Brooklyn Nets.
0:47 Speaker 04 You can bet every loss means so much more for these teams, and they're not hiding it at all.
0:54 Speaker 01 That's right. It is tanking season.
0:57 Speaker 03 Somebody gonna see this score and wonder if we even tried. No, good sir. No, we did not.
1:02 Speaker 01 Right now, some of the greatest athletes in the history of the world are being paid millions of dollars to lose.
1:12 Speaker 05 So the Utah Jazz are not even trying to hide the fact that they're tanking. They were up by as much as 17 points last night against the Magic.
1:21 Speaker 03 Will Hardy then, in the fourth quarter, pulls the entire rotation out and throws in a bunch of G League dudes to completely give that game away back to the Magic.
1:31 Speaker 02 Now, this is so normal in the NBA that if you're a sports fan, you're like, yeah, of course they're losing games on purpose. The league gives the teams with the worst records the best chance of getting one of the top picks in the next NBA draft. So teams have this real incentive to be as bad as possible.
1:48 Speaker 01 So yeah, tanking is rational. But if you are a fan of one of these tanking teams... It can be rough.
1:57 Speaker 06 And I watched that Pacers game last night, and it was the most disgusting thing I've ever seen.
2:01 Speaker 07 Like I said, something smells fishy here.
2:04 Speaker 08 What about teams like the Kings, who are flat out benching everybody? No Levine, no Zabonis, no Westbrook, no no one!
2:14 Speaker 01 If you're curious, we will share the social media handles for all the voices of fans we used in our credits.
2:19 Speaker 02 And it's not just fans who feel this way. Here is the most powerful man in the NBA, Commissioner Adam Silver.
2:26 Speaker 09 Are we seeing behavior that is worse this year than we've seen in recent memory? Yes, is my view.
2:33 Speaker 01 Adam Silver also said the league is considering every possible remedy to fix tanking.
2:38 Speaker 09 There have been lots of different ideas out there over the years, looking at whether there's a better system here to try to align incentives.
2:46 Speaker 02 So, Adam Silver, you are saying you have an incentives problem and you need some creative solutions? I mean, you might as well shine a giant Planet Money sign up into the sky.
2:59 Speaker 01 Yeah, yeah, we got you, Adam Silver.
3:01 Speaker 02 Hello and welcome to Planet Money. I'm Keith Romer.
3:03 Speaker 01 And I'm Erica Barris. Every system of rules creates incentives. This is true whether you're talking about CEO stock options or regulating greenhouse gases, or yes, the NBA draft. So if you want to change the behavior of the people operating within a system, change the rules that govern that system.
3:24 Speaker 02 Today on the show, Planet Money fixes the NBA's tanking problem by fixing the NBA draft. We will look at three radical proposals for changing the draft and talk to an Olympic gold medalist and a World Cup champion.
3:44 Speaker 00 Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors. This message comes from University at Buffalo, where five decades of AI research is producing advancements that put people first. Tackling real world problems for progress, not profit. Empowering, not replacing. Learn how the University of Buffalo is using AI responsibly to create a better, brighter future for all at buffalo.edu/NPR.
4:11 Speaker 10 This message comes from LinkedIn. As a small business owner, you wear many hats. You're the owner, the marketer, the seller, the hire. With LinkedIn, you have the tools to help you boost your visibility, find prospective customers, and find the best team for your small business, all in one place. So while LinkedIn can't hang up all of your hats, it makes it easier to wear them all. Learn more at LinkedIn.com/PlanetMoneyShow.
4:38 Speaker 00 This message comes from NPR sponsor Charles Schwab. Financial decisions can be tricky. Your biases can lead you astray. Financial Decoder, an original podcast from Charles Schwab, can help. Download the latest episode and subscribe at schwab.com/financialdecoder.
4:55 Speaker 02 Let us just consider for a moment the majesty of sports. The very best athletes competing as hard as they know how, putting all their effort and training and natural ability to the test against their opponents.
5:10 Speaker 01 Yeah, this time of year, that's not what you see when you turn on a random NBA game.
5:14 Speaker 02 No, no, it's not.
5:15 Speaker 01 Because of tanking, a lot of NBA games are basically not even worth watching right now. It's bad for fans and it's bad for the league. So to help us think through what to do about this pox on the game of basketball, we reached out to someone who lives and breathes this stuff.
5:33 Speaker 02 How much time in your life do you think you have spent watching basketball games?
5:38 Speaker 04 Can I just pass? I don't, I don't, I don't want to actually sit down and do the math. So my religion is two games a night at a minimum. It's, it's, I don't know. I don't even want to venture, I guess. It's too much.
5:50 Speaker 02 I mean, I think it's, it must be years, right? At this point?
5:55 Speaker 04 That's a depressing, that's a depressing thought. I mean, it's fun. I love watching basketball, but it, years is, we only have so many years. That's a lot of time.
6:05 Speaker 02 That is Zach Lowe, host of the podcast, The Zach Lowe Show, longtime NBA reporter and commentator for Sports Illustrated and ESPN, and now The Ringer.
6:15 Speaker 01 Yep, important member of my household. My husband listens to Zach Lowe just about every single day.
6:20 Speaker 02 Shout out to Andy and his fandom. Okay, so Zach says the whole tanking problem basically boils down to incentives. Teams are trying to lose to get a higher slot in the NBA draft. So we are going to start with kind of a history of the different incentives the league has offered teams in the draft over the years.
6:39 Speaker 01 Back in the 1960s and 70s, the NBA draft system was pretty simple. Teams got to pick which young players coming out of college would come and play for them. And to try to keep the league as competitive as possible, those picks were distributed in a very intentional way.
6:55 Speaker 04 The league decided, as many leagues do, that the draft should more or less go in reverse order, with the worst teams picking high and the best teams picking low. And so that's what the draft is designed to do.
7:08 Speaker 02 Every year, the worst team from the Western Conference and the worst team in the Eastern Conference would flip a coin to see who got the number one pick. And from there, draft picks were assigned to the next worst team, and then the next worst team, and so on.
7:22 Speaker 01 And you can see the logic of a reverse order draft. Let's give hope to the bad teams. Maybe they won't stay bad forever because they can get the next great star coming out of college.
7:32 Speaker 04 But as long as that general incentive structure exists, teams are going to exploit it in whatever ways are advantageous for them.
7:41 Speaker 01 This famously came to a head back in 1984. That year, the draft featured a couple of players that were so good that teams had a big incentive to exploit the rules a little.
7:52 Speaker 02 Yeah, Hakeem Olajuwon, and another guy you might have heard of, Michael Jordan, they were going to be in the draft that year. And the Houston Rockets were like, if we got one of those players, this could change everything. So maybe, you know, we lose this year so that we can win next year, and the year after that, and the year after that, and the year after that.
8:12 Speaker 01 So to make sure they got a shot at a top pick, the Rockets started sitting their best players, giving worst-washed-up players big minutes. They managed to lose 14 of their last 17 games. And it worked. They ended up with the first overall pick.
8:28 Speaker 02 The Houston Rockets.
8:30 Speaker 07 Who are represented here by owner Charlie Thomas and his daughter Tracy, select Hakeem Olajuwon of the University of Houston.
8:40 Speaker 02 The Rockets got their star, and they ended up winning two NBA championships with Olajuwon.
8:46 Speaker 01 1984. It was an important year in the history of tanking because it launched this decades-long game of cat and mouse between NBA teams tanking and the league trying to stop them from tanking.
8:59 Speaker 02 For the league, teams intentionally losing games was a terrible look. So to try to avoid a repeat of the whole Rockets tanking fiasco, the league remade the rules for the draft. Now there was going to be a lottery. Every team that missed the playoffs would get their name thrown into a big drum.
9:16 Speaker 11 As soon as the drum is closed, it will be turned to mix the envelopes.
9:21 Speaker 02 Then they would draw to see who got the top picks.
9:25 Speaker 11 The envelopes will now be selected from the drum by the representatives of the participating teams.
9:31 Speaker 01 It stopped mattering whether you finished dead last or just missed the playoffs. The league added some randomness to their draft that is still there today.
9:40 Speaker 02 What's the randomization trying to maximize?
9:43 Speaker 04 It's trying to discourage abject, obvious, horrible tanking. It's trying to remove the incentives or decrease the incentives for being a 15-win team, just a terrible team that's intentionally bottoming out.
10:00 Speaker 02 And the change worked, at least as far as making tanking less attractive. But every new set of rules contains new trade-offs. And while the lottery lowered the incentives for teams to full-on tank, it also made it way harder for some not at all tanking, just genuinely bad teams to ever get better. Now, instead of getting a top pick that could have made them relevant again, the worst teams sometimes ended up picking fourth, or fifth, or seventh. So some bad teams just stayed bad.
10:32 Speaker 01 Over the years, the league has tried all these different tweaks. In 1987, they made it so only the first three picks were determined by a lottery.
10:39 Speaker 02 Then in 1990, they weighted the lottery so that the worse your team was, the better chance you had of getting a top pick, you know, giving bad teams more hope.
10:48 Speaker 01 Then in 1994, they increased the odds for the worst teams even more, so even more hope. In 1996, they went the other way and decreased the odds a little for some of the worst teams.
11:02 Speaker 02 And the league stuck with that version of things for a few decades until in 2019, they went back in the direction of randomness. They increased the number of picks in the lottery from three to four, and they flattened the odds again by kind of a lot.
11:16 Speaker 04 You used to have a 25% chance of getting the number one pick if you were the worst team in the league.
11:20 Speaker 01 Now, it was going to be just 14%.
11:23 Speaker 04 The whole point of it was to discourage teams from being the absolute worst teams in the league.
11:27 Speaker 02 But this year, there are a few players coming out of college that people think could be really good. So even with those lower odds, a lot of teams have decided that it's still worth it to throw away the rest of the season, to tank for a shot at a better draft pick.
11:41 Speaker 01 Yeah, Zach says teams are maybe more motivated to tank in the NBA than in other sports because of just how valuable a single great player can be.
11:52 Speaker 04 There are only five players on the court at a time for a team. The best players can have the ball on every single possession, and so a superstar is uniquely valuable in basketball.
12:02 Speaker 01 Now, Zach has heard all sorts of ideas about how to fix this tanking problem.
12:09 Speaker 04 Everyone has their favorite solution. I mean, the number of emails and tweets and suggestions, everyone has a fix that is, they think is the silver bullet.
12:17 Speaker 02 He's heard the one about making it so that no team can have a top four draft pick two years in a row, and the one that says if you make it deep enough into the playoffs, you can't get a top pick the following year.
12:27 Speaker 01 But Zach says if your only goal is to stop teams from losing games to get a better draft pick, there is a pretty straightforward solution.
12:37 Speaker 04 I think you can eradicate tanking. It just requires none of these Band-Aids, none of these like mini fixes on top of mini fixes that might open holes everywhere else. It requires you have to snap the connection between a team's record and where it picks in the draft.
12:53 Speaker 02 Yeah, if your draft pick had nothing to do with how bad your record was, there would be no reason to intentionally lose games.
13:01 Speaker 01 One of the more elegant proposals for how to snap that connection between losing and draft picks is something called the draft wheel.
13:10 Speaker 04 I think I first learned about it in the summer of 2013. I learned about it at a bar in Las Vegas, as many people learn things at bars in Las Vegas.
13:19 Speaker 02 I feel like NBA draft reforms is low on the list of things that people learn in bars in Las Vegas.
13:24 Speaker 04 Not during NBA Summer League. NBA Summer League, the NBA takes over Las Vegas, the season's over, free agency is over, the draft is over. This is when people have these kind of conversations because there's nothing else going on.
13:34 Speaker 02 So at that bar there in Vegas, Zach finds himself talking to someone he knows from the front office of the Boston Celtics, an executive named Mike Zarin. And Mike starts explaining to Zach his elaborate draft wheel idea.
13:47 Speaker 04 The wheel has 30 spokes, one for each first round selection. So there's a spoke for pick one, pick six, pick 10, pick 20, whatever. And then over 30 years, you just cycle like you're ticking around a clock, kind of, through all 30 picks in a predetermined order.
14:06 Speaker 02 And Mike Zarin's draft wheel is going to be the first of our proposals for how to fix tanking in the NBA. So imagine a wheel. All 30 teams in the NBA get assigned to one of the 30 spokes of the wheel. And then each year, they advance one spoke around the wheel.
14:23 Speaker 01 The spokes don't go first pick, second pick, third pick. Instead, the order looks kind of random. There were a few versions of the wheel over the years, but in the first version, after pick number one, the next spoke was the 30th pick, then the 19th, the 18th, the 7th, the 6th.
14:35 Speaker 04 The idea was very simple, like it doesn't matter what your record is in this particular year, you pick where the wheel says you pick. And so there's no benefit to you being bad in this particular year or good in this particular year because the wheel sets the order for you.
14:49 Speaker 02 And mathematically, the design of the wheel is a thing of beauty. Every five years, you're guaranteed one top six pick and one pick seven through 12.
14:59 Speaker 04 Hope was always at least somewhere on the horizon. So it's not like you'd ever go through a series of five picks that were like 27, 22, 29, 30.
15:08 Speaker 01 After 30 years, every team will have moved through all 30 picks and then they start another trip around the wheel.
15:16 Speaker 02 Zach says the league did talk about the draft wheel some, and a lot of teams were really resistant for a couple of pretty fundamental reasons.
15:23 Speaker 04 Number one is just a general principle of are bad teams going to get trapped into badness for longer? Like if I, if my team just stinks and the next three picks on the wheel are 11, 29, and 16, and I'm a fan of that team, am I just like checking out for three years until the wheel spits me out somewhere else?
15:45 Speaker 01 Under the current system, if you're bad, you get help right away in the draft. But with the draft wheel, no matter how crappy your team is, you are still just gonna get whatever pick the draft wheel says is on the next book.
15:59 Speaker 04 And connected to that, there's always some contingent of small market owners, front office executives who will say, hey, wait a second, we lose to the glamorous markets in free agency. No player is going to pick us in Midwest City X over Los Angeles or New York or Miami. And so our best and most secure vehicle to getting a superstar player is being bad in the right draft and getting lucky in the lottery. And if you take that away from us, is it going to increase the disparity between big market teams and small market teams? But it is, those are the two main sort of quibbles that come up.
16:42 Speaker 01 Too many of these smaller market teams were worried that the draft wheel would take too much hope away from bad teams. And that's partly why the wheel never really got serious traction.
16:52 Speaker 02 Yeah, big changes like this, they are not done top down by the league. It would take a vote of all 30 teams and would require three fourths of the teams to say yes. So a lot of teams would need to change their minds for this to become a reality.
17:05 Speaker 01 So for our next option for fixing the NBA's tanking problem, we went looking for a plan that could limit tanking without completely doing away with the whole hope element of things. And we found it in women's hockey.
17:20 Speaker 02 I don't always get to start interviews this way, and so I'm going to take the opportunity today because I have it. How many Olympic medals do you have?
17:29 Speaker 12 I have five Olympic medals, four Olympic gold medals, and one Olympic silver medal.
17:34 Speaker 02 That is Hockey Hall of Famer Jayna Hefford, arguably the greatest athlete we've ever had on the show.
17:40 Speaker 12 Second greatest. Thank you very much.
17:42 Speaker 02 Second greatest to you. Jayna won her five medals across five different Olympics as one of the stars of the Canadian women's hockey team.
17:49 Speaker 01 These days, Jayna is in charge of hockey operations for the PWHL, the Professional Women's Hockey League.
17:57 Speaker 12 The PWHL, first of all, was established in 2024. Well, established in 2023, but dropped the puck in 2024. So still a fairly young league.
18:06 Speaker 02 Jayna helped launch the league. And she says one of the benefits of being a young league was that they had the ability to experiment, to not just do things the way they've always been done.
18:15 Speaker 12 As we were setting up the entire league, really, we had, I guess, a culture, a mindset that said, you know, we want to think outside the box. We want to be creative. We want to do things differently.
18:27 Speaker 01 One of the things they did differently was their draft.
18:31 Speaker 02 Yeah, Jayna and her colleagues, they could see how just giving the best draft picks to the teams that lost the most games was hurting other leagues, how bad tanking was, especially for fans.
18:42 Speaker 12 There's many people that maybe only get to one NHL or NBA or NFL game a year. And if you get to bring your child there once a year and then see a team that isn't putting their best team on the ice, on the court, on the field, you know, I think that's a really tough place to be as a fan.
19:03 Speaker 01 So to try to limit tanking, but still give bad teams some hope, the PWHL adopted this idea that had been floating around for over a decade, something called the Gold Plan.
19:12 Speaker 12 So the Gold Plan was developed by a gentleman by the name of Adam Gold. And what it does is it ensures that there is no tanking with teams, that they don't just play lesser players to try to earn or get their way to the first draft pick by losing.
19:27 Speaker 01 Once you're eliminated from playoffs, you actually have to be the highest performing team to get the first overall pick.
19:33 Speaker 02 Yeah, the goal plan takes the standard reverse order draft and adds this twist. So to take the PWHL right now as an example, currently, the two teams with the worst records in the league are the Seattle Torrent and the Vancouver Golden Eyes. Let's say Vancouver gets mathematically eliminated from the playoffs first. From that day forward, every game they win works for them instead of against them.
19:59 Speaker 01 Then, say a couple of weeks later, Seattle gets eliminated. Now, Seattle is also incentivized to try as hard as they can to win games, to compete with Vancouver and whoever else might get eliminated from playoff contention.
20:15 Speaker 02 Whichever team ends up racking up the most points after they're eliminated from the playoffs, that team gets the highest pick.
20:22 Speaker 12 For the fans of a team that gets eliminated early, they have reason to continue to show up and to continue to cheer for their team, to win games and earn points so that they can earn the top draft pick.
20:33 Speaker 02 Like, imagine that it comes down to the very last game of the season, and Vancouver and Seattle are playing head to head. Both teams, they've had this rough year, they've lost a lot of games. But now their fans are going wild because they know if their team wins, they will get the better pick in the next year's draft. Like, that would be amazing sports theater.
20:52 Speaker 01 But every new system comes with new trade offs. Sure, the goal plan increases a bad team's incentives to keep trying hard, but Jayne acknowledges it could also limit their chances to get better.
21:05 Speaker 12 You know, if I had to see one downside, I think it would be that, you know, if you did have a team that got eliminated very early and they still didn't get the number one draft pick, it would be challenging for them, you know, to continue to get better without top young talent.
21:21 Speaker 02 Right. If a team is just perpetually really, really bad, and they're so bad that they can't even win with this new incentive, then, yeah.
21:28 Speaker 01 It's still early days for the P W H L. The league is in the process of adding teams. So this is the first year that the goal plan might really shake up the draft order in a dramatic way. But Jayna is pretty confident that the pros of the goal plan are going to outweigh any possible cons.
21:45 Speaker 02 So would it work in the NBA? Well, it's obviously not apples to apples. For one thing, there's a lot more money at stake in the NBA. It can be worth potentially as much as $1 billion for a team to be able to draft the next LeBron James. And the same bottom line cynicism that leads NBA teams to tank now, that would still be there.
22:05 Speaker 01 Yeah, if teams wanted to tank under the goal plan, they still could. They just have to tank at the beginning of the season, then turn it on once they're eliminated from the playoffs.
22:15 Speaker 02 For me, though, I like, I still kind of like the goal plan because it's like a dare, right? Would NBA teams actually be willing to be that cynical and just intentionally lose their first 20 or 30 games of a season?
22:28 Speaker 01 No.
22:29 Speaker 02 I kind of think mostly no, but it's hard to say.
22:32 Speaker 01 No. So in the event that NBA front offices really might sink that low, we're going to consider one final plan for how to get rid of tanking. Let's call it the Milton Friedman approach. And this plan is already being used right now in a different U.S. sports league. That's after the break.
23:03 Speaker 00 Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors. This message comes from University of Buffalo, where scientists are working to protect the Great Lakes and freshwater supplies around the world from harmful contamination. Learn more about their research at buffalo.edu/NPR.
23:21 Speaker 10 This message comes from LinkedIn. Owning a small business comes with a lot of challenges and means juggling multiple things at once. It's even harder to do it efficiently. But with LinkedIn, you get all the tools you need to grow in one place. With LinkedIn, simplify your sales, marketing, and hiring so that you can actually run your small business. Learn more at LinkedIn.com/PlanetMoneyShow. This message comes from NPR sponsor Charles Schwab. Is there a right time to sell a stock? Are you taking the right risks with your portfolio? Financial decisions can be tricky, and often your own cognitive and emotional biases can lead you astray. Financial Decoder, an original podcast from Charles Schwab, can help.
24:02 Speaker 10 Join host Mark Reapy as he offers practical solutions to help overcome the biases that may affect your investing decisions. Download the latest episode and subscribe at schwab.com/financialdecoder.
24:16 Speaker 01 Okay, how to fix the NBA's tanking problem. Well, you could do something like the draft wheel and just completely break the connection between losing and getting a high draft pick. But then you're risking bad teams just staying bad for years and years and years.
24:31 Speaker 02 Or you could use the gold plan. Incentivize teams to keep winning games even after they've been eliminated from the playoffs. But, like we said, teams might still be willing to game the system.
24:42 Speaker 01 So for our third and final proposal, we wanted to go a little bigger, a little more radical, and we brought in another big shot.
24:51 Speaker 02 Let's start this way. How do you like to be introduced? World Cup champion Sam Mewes? Editor in chief of the women's game Sam Mewis?
24:58 Speaker 01 Wow. Both, ideally.
25:06 Speaker 02 In case your household is a less religious follower of the US women's national team than mine is, Sam Mewis, legendary midfielder, former professional soccer player, and now host of a kajillion podcasts about women's soccer for the women's game.
25:20 Speaker 01 For most of her professional career, Sam played in the NWSL, the National Women's Soccer League. And in the NWSL, there is no tanking at all, because in 2024, they decided to get rid of their draft entirely.
25:37 Speaker 13 Players who want to enter the league can just enter into conversations with... Teams that they're interested in that are interested in them back. And they can negotiate a contract just as individuals, um, kind of on their own accord.
25:50 Speaker 02 Now, if every team wants to sign the same young phenom, they have to compete for her on the open market. Try to outbid each other on salary or who can provide the best place to develop as a player.
26:02 Speaker 13 Now, the clubs are competing to have the best facilities, the best coach, the best environment, the best culture, the best fans. They have to make sure that their, their team situation is an appealing place for these young players to go play.
26:15 Speaker 01 There is a salary cap in the NWSL, so it's not just full-on free market anarchy. But without a draft, teams have to decide way more precisely how much a young player is worth to them and then pay them.
26:28 Speaker 02 Interestingly, Sam says she thinks the primary motivation for eliminating the draft was not actually trying to fight tanking. Instead, she says the NWSL was trying to deal with two pretty idiosyncratic problems.
26:41 Speaker 01 The first problem was that at a certain point, the NWSL got some competition. In the UK, the WSL, the Women's Super League, started bringing together really strong teams who were willing to pay top dollar for elite players.
26:57 Speaker 13 You could play for a team like Chelsea, Manchester City, Manchester United, Arsenal.
27:01 Speaker 02 Top players who didn't like where they were drafted could just go play overseas.
27:06 Speaker 01 The second problem. The NWSL, like a lot of soccer leagues, allowed teams to sign some pretty young players. But the league didn't want a situation where a 16-year-old had to move thousands of miles because she got drafted by a team across the country. So players under the age of 18 were exempted from the draft. And that created another problem.
27:27 Speaker 13 The really great youngest talent was skipping the draft and they were choosing teams that have great environments, probably a good amount of money, um, and were really good places for a teenager to go play instead of going to college.
27:41 Speaker 02 So the NWSL got rid of their draft for a bunch of reasons that had nothing at all to do with tanking. But it's not hard to see how not having a draft changes the incentives for teams.
27:52 Speaker 01 Yeah, without a draft, there is precisely zero reward for a team losing more games.
27:58 Speaker 02 We're a year into this experiment. How do you think it's working out?
28:04 Speaker 13 Super interesting. Obviously, one year is not a ton of data. I definitely don't think it was a problem. I think that, you know, just anecdotally and feelings-wise, the rookies did great.
28:15 Speaker 02 And Sam says, even without a draft, small-market franchises could still build strong teams.
28:21 Speaker 13 There is still this opportunity for smaller-market teams to carve out
28:28 Speaker 13 an environment for their players that is appealing, even if they aren't paying top dollar. Having other things as a part of your club environment that are really, really important to you could still allow these smaller-market teams to be successful.
28:43 Speaker 01 But she also recognizes that with no draft, owners with deeper pockets might be able to build powerhouse teams year after year after year.
28:52 Speaker 13 I think generally, the wealthiest owners who are the most dedicated and the most committed are gonna win. And the top four teams are probably gonna keep getting better.
28:59 Speaker 02 This whole time, though, we've been approaching this problem of drafts and tanking from basically two perspectives. On the one hand, the leagues and the fans, and on the other hand, the teams themselves.
29:09 Speaker 01 But Sam says it's also worth thinking about how all of these systems work from a third perspective: the players.
29:16 Speaker 13 There are several reasons why it was specifically important in this league to have players have more of a say where they get to go.
29:25 Speaker 13 Part of that is like a history of abuse in the league, or, you know, different states have different laws about women's rights and different levels of friendliness towards LGBTQ plus people. I also like to think that player autonomy and seeing these players as like human beings who have a say in where they're going leads to better performance, better engagement with fans, better relationship with the club. That, I think, is the lesson to take from the NWSL eliminating the draft.
29:56 Speaker 02 So it's complicated. Like, how do you craft a system that perfectly balances the needs of the league, the teams, the players, the fans? It's trade-offs all the way down.
30:05 Speaker 01 We reached out to the NBA. They didn't want to do a recorded interview, but they told us that fixing the incentives around tanking was very much on the league's radar. And that the NBA Board of Governors was set to meet later this month and would be discussing a bunch of different possible solutions.
30:20 Speaker 02 Okay, Erica. I want you to imagine that you are the NBA commissioner for a day.
30:26 Speaker 01 Finally.
30:26 Speaker 02 What's your move? Are you going to keep things the same? Do the draft, do the gold plan, get rid of the draft?
30:31 Speaker 01 I am getting rid of the draft. I'm done with it. It's over.
30:33 Speaker 02 Whoa, I personally, I'm team gold plan, but like this stuff is super hard.
30:38 Speaker 01 It is. It's hard to like, figure out what's going to end up working in the long run.
30:42 Speaker 02 Our NBA expert, Zach Lowe, he also doesn't know what the league is going to do, but he's very confident they're going to do something.
30:50 Speaker 04 I think change is 100% coming. I mean, like the outcry.
30:55 Speaker 02 Planet Money is doing a podcast about it.
30:57 Speaker 04 Well, yeah, Planet Money is doing a podcast, the public shaming. I mean, Adam Silver just more or less came out and said, we're looking at everything. And they are looking at everything. And I don't know how sweeping and dramatic, like, I don't think the draft is going to be abolished in two years. I don't think we're going to a 30-team lottery in two years or something like that. But I do think changes are definitely coming.
31:19 Speaker 02 Zach told us, he has always been pretty opposed to just getting rid of the reverse order draft. He wants bad teams to have hope, but after all the tanking this year, he's at least opening his mind to other possible systems.
31:34 Speaker 04 I've come to just sort of think more about what does the world look like when everyone has to try every year?
31:42 Speaker 01 And that's all we want from NBA teams. Just try.
31:44 Speaker 02 Just try.
31:45 Speaker 01 Give a little.
31:45 Speaker 02 Just try.
31:46 Speaker 01 Play the game. Just play the game.
31:53 Speaker 01 Planet Money is going on tour and I'm sitting here looking at this brand new tote bag. It's amazing. It's like those shirts that fans make for their tours with a list of all the cities they visit. And these bags were made for people who come see us live. Our tour starts in April. We're celebrating the release of the Planet Money book. If you buy a ticket at planetmoneybook.com, you can also get this bag while supplies last. Each stop on the tour will have a Planet Money host and a special guest. And all of the stops will have the book's main author, Alex Miasse. That's planetmoneybook.com or click the link in the show notes.
32:31 Speaker 02 This episode was produced by James Snead with an assist from Sam Yellowhorse Kessler. It was edited by Jess Jiang. It was fact-checked by Sierra Juarez. Alex Goldmark is our executive producer. Special thanks to Ryan Nantel, Abdullah Ayubi, and Evan Johnson.
32:46 Speaker 01 The fans we heard from at the top of the show go by the handles TheVoiceOfEvan, FullCourtBlitz, Ashley Neville, IGotNextPod, Finesse dot West, Basketball Savant, and Mike Daddino. We'll add links to their videos in our show notes.
32:58 Speaker 02 I'm Keith Romer.
32:59 Speaker 01 And I'm Erica Bears. This is NPR. Thanks for listening.
33:05 Speaker 00 Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors. This message comes from University at Buffalo, where five decades of AI research is producing advancements that put people first. Tackling real-world problems for progress, not profit. Empowering, not replacing. Learn how the University of Buffalo is using AI responsibly to create a better, brighter future for all at buffalo.edu/NPR. This message comes from NPR sponsor Charles Schwab. Financial decisions can be tricky. Your biases can lead you astray. Financial Decoder, an original podcast from Charles Schwab, can help. Download the latest episode and subscribe at schwab.com/financialdecoder.
Previous The Business of Heated Rivalry Next The laws of the office revisited Page updated October 31, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated