Pod Insights Planet Money Piles of cash and a town of solutions in Kenya, Nigeria (Summer School) About this episode Let’s head to a small town in Kenya that’s become globally famous for helping economists answer some of the biggest questions facing humanity.
In Kenya and Nigeria, economics isn’t just theory, it’s real life. We’ll look at some radical experiments that turned out to be enormously successful.
What are the building blocks of health, education and prosperity for all? How does a nation grow rich? What is the most effective way to spend a dollar to fight poverty? We find answers in a town that became the laboratory for new concepts in economic research that netted some researchers the most prestigious prize in economics.
Featured Episodes:
How randomized trials and the town of Busia, Kenya changed economics (2023) https://www.npr.org/2023/06/09/1181448838/busia-kenya-nobel-prize-randomized-control-trialsNigeria, You Win! (2016) https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2016/05/20/478883658/episode-702-nigeria-you-win
Featured Terms:
Randomized controlled trialHuman capitalMissing middleSupport:
Planet Money+ https://n.pr/3HlREPz
Read:
Our book: Planet Money: A Guide to the Economic Forces That Shape Your Life https://lnk.to/i3AukBdD (Audiobook here https://open.spotify.com/show/509P7k1QPcwgzOSCqVCDCZ) Our weekly longform Planet Money newsletter https://n.pr/3zrFvUBOur weekly Indicator link round-up newsletter https://www.npr.org/newsletter/indicatorFollow:
Instagram https://n.pr/3FqLuwsTikTok https://n.pr/3sGZdrqYouTube https://lnk.to/iCVDaW3CFacebook https://n.pr/3h92GwS
The series is hosted by Robert Smith and produced by Sophia Paliza-Carre. This episode was edited by Planet Money Executive Producer Alex Goldmark. This episode was fact-checked by Leyla Doss, with engineering by Annlie Huang.
See pcm.adswizz.com https://pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for sponsorship and to manage your podcast sponsorship preferences.
NPR Privacy Policy https://www.npr.org/about-npr/179878450/privacy-policy
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 This message comes from Insperity. Because how you HR matters. From payroll and benefits to HR compliance and talent development, helping your business move forward with confidence. Learn more at insperity.com/hrmatters.
0:16 Speaker 01 This is Planet Money from NPR.
0:29 Speaker 02 Welcome back, everyone, to Planet Money Summer School World Tour, the only international economics degree where the invisible hand points to the departure gate. It's the final boarding call. Better run. I'm Robert Smith. This summer, we are on a quest to find lessons we can learn from other countries that just might work back here, where we live. In each episode, we'll have fascinating case studies and a hometown tour guide that also happens to have a degree in economics. Our destination today? Kenya, specifically a small town that taught the world a better way to do economics. We'll also have a stopover in Nigeria, where they've come up with a novel way to grow small businesses. Free money. It works. Just make sure you take notes along the way.
1:13 Speaker 02 Anything we mention might appear on the final exam, which will allow you, traveler extraordinaire, to get a souvenir diploma festooned with all the passport stamps.
1:27 Speaker 02 Helping us through customs in Nairobi is Tavni Suri, a professor at MIT's Sloan School of Management.
1:34 Speaker 03 Hi, it's nice to be here. Thanks for having me.
1:36 Speaker 02 You are fifth generation Kenyan?
1:38 Speaker 03 Technically fourth. It depends how you count. You know, my family moved from India in the late 1800s with the British, and the British took a bunch of people to build roads and railways in that part of the world. Always amazes me that when they got done with roads and railways, they asked them, do you want to go back? And they said, no, we'll just stay.
1:57 Speaker 02 Well, I mean, I I've been there. It is a lovely place. It's understandable. But but that is not why summer school is stopping in Nigeria and in Kenya. It's stopping there because this is a place where economics isn't just theory. It's real life. There is commerce everywhere, hundreds of people on each block selling different things. And you must appreciate this as a business school professor. There are so many case studies around.
2:24 Speaker 03 You know, I love being back in almost any African city. I always feel there's a vibe to them that's quite different. There's people on the streets. There's people trying to sell something. There's people trying to jump on a bus, go somewhere, do something. You can kind of see the entrepreneurship of all of this right in front of you, right?
2:43 Speaker 02 And this becomes so much more important when you realize that unlike most of the world, places like Nigeria are still rapidly growing in population. I I think by 2050, Nigeria will have more people than the United States. So you have this vibrant, growing country with with lots of young people that could become a lot larger part of the global economy.
3:07 Speaker 03 Absolutely. And with their demographics, sort of the number of youth on the African continent is extremely large. By 2050, 35% of the youth, think 18 to 25 year olds, is going to be in Africa. Right? And so it will be a place where there'll be a large labor force at some point.
3:28 Speaker 02 In other words, the perfect place to stop for economic students on a tour. Not only the future of the global economy, but an incubator for new ideas. That's what we're going to hear about today. Ways to have a richer, healthier population with more businesses and more jobs. Sounds great.
3:46 Speaker 02 First up, we will take a look at a program in Nigeria that tries to solve that business part of the equation by creating a mashup of Shark Tank and the lottery. And we'll have our business school professor break it all down for us after our break.
4:08 Speaker 04 Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors.
4:12 Speaker 00 This message comes from Bilt. Rent and mortgages keep getting more expensive. That's why Bilt created three credit cards designed to offer rich rewards on everything you spend on. You can earn up to 1.25 X points on every housing payment with no transaction fee, which can be redeemed for flights, hotels, a future housing payment, and more. Apply at join B I L T dot com slash money. Terms apply. Subject to approval and eligibility. Bilt cards are issued by Column N A, Member F D I C, pursuant to license from Mastercard International, Incorporated. This message comes from Insperity. Because how you HR matters. From payroll and benefits to HR compliance and talent development, helping your business move forward with confidence.
4:58 Speaker 00 Learn more at insperity dot com slash H R matters.
5:02 Speaker 04 This message comes from Odoo. Running a business shouldn't feel like surviving a software group project. Start managing your business with one unified system. Odoo is the all-in-one business management software. Try for free today at Odoo dot com slash Planet Money.
5:19 Speaker 02 Okay, students, stay together on this tour. That's why I have this big Planet Money flag. We are back with Planet Money Summer School on our way to Kenya, but with a stopover in Abuja, Nigeria. Professor Tavnit Suri is along for the ride. Professor, what should our students think about as they listen to this very first case study?
5:39 Speaker 03 Okay, imagine you're a small business and imagine you have great ideas.
5:42 Speaker 02 Of course.
5:43 Speaker 03 But you need a bunch of money to sort of build out these ideas. Who would you go to for that money? Would you go to a bank? Would you go to a venture capital fund? Would you go try and raise money through some other means? How would you get that money?
5:59 Speaker 02 Great question, and the same question faced by small businesses in Nigeria, where the government came up with a very clever solution. As one economist said, quote, "Is this the best development program in history?" As a student, you decide. Planet Money's Alex Goldmark and Noel King tell us the story.
6:19 Speaker 05 In 2011, Lariat Alhassan had a paint business in Abuja, Nigeria. She sold house paint, she sold industrial paint, she sold textured paint, she sold paint that fills in the cracks in your wall. The paint company was called Lark Lux Paint, and it was really, really small.
6:35 Speaker 06 The employee I had was just me. I was the production manager, I was the marketer, I was the delivery person. I was everything, except the security.
6:50 Speaker 05 That was the whole company, her and a security guard.
6:53 Speaker 04 And being so small was a problem because customers would try out her paint and they would say, "This seems great. I want to place a big order. How about I come down to your office and we'll sign the papers?"
7:03 Speaker 05 Which is where things would get awkward because she didn't have an office.
7:07 Speaker 06 And I kept telling them, "No, no, no, you call me whenever you want. I will just be there, I will be there."
7:13 Speaker 05 She just had her car. And when clients would see that, they would say, "Mm, I'm sorry." And that's when they would back out. She needed the office to keep the clients, but she needed the clients to be able to afford the office. She felt trapped, stuck.
7:28 Speaker 04 And then one day, she was at home, listening to a little music.
7:31 Speaker 06 Music has a way of helping me a lot. So I had this little radio in my room then that I would always listen to to help me get over my emotions. It was at my bedside, so I was listening to it. And there was this announcement.
7:51 Speaker 05 This ad comes on, and it was like the radio was talking right to her.
7:55 Speaker 04 It was an ad for what seemed to be some sort of program to help small businesses grow big.
8:01 Speaker 07 It may be small today, but it will be after you win. The youth enterprise and innovation competition, You Win, is a nationwide jobs creation project organized by the federal government to empower young Nigerians.
8:14 Speaker 05 The government was having a nationwide contest where it would be giving away millions of dollars to people trying to start businesses. No experience necessary, no strings attached. Just go to the website and sign up.
8:26 Speaker 04 Lariat heard this ad, and she knew immediately what it was: a scam.
8:34 Speaker 05 OK, so that ad, not a scam. I met the person behind it.
8:38 Speaker 06 My name is Ngos.
8:39 Speaker 01 Oconjo Iwala.
8:41 Speaker 05 She goes by Dr. Ungosi, and she was the Finance Minister for Nigeria at the time. And she looked out, and she was facing this big problem: unemployment.
8:49 Speaker 04 There are 8 million young people in Nigeria who need jobs. That's like a quarter of all youth.
8:54 Speaker 05 But the thing about those young people is they are super go-getters, right?
8:57 Speaker 01 Everybody wants to run something, and they want to expand their businesses. Some want to create new businesses but don't know how.
9:03 Speaker 05 They're hitting this wall: money. They need more of it. But the thing is, it's really hard to get a small business loan in Nigeria.
9:11 Speaker 04 Maybe you go to a bank and you try. But think about it from the point of view of the bank. Most of these businesses are one person. They're really small, and it's hard for a bank to tell a good one-person paint company from a bad one-person paint company.
9:27 Speaker 05 She thought, since what these entrepreneurs need is money, why don't we just give them money? Just find tiny businesses and then hand them piles of cash.
9:35 Speaker 04 What if you gave Lariat, the woman who sells paint, $50,000? That's a lot of money. That's about 10 times what Lariat would normally make in a year.
9:44 Speaker 05 So Dr. Ungosi takes this idea, and she starts shopping it around within the Nigerian government. And right away, some questions come up.
9:51 Speaker 01 How will we monitor these people? How will we make sure they don't fall by the wayside? They just get the money and divert it to some other use?
9:58 Speaker 05 If banks have a tough time handing out the money to small businesses, how is the government going to decide which are the right people to hand it out to?
10:06 Speaker 04 Dr. Ungosi says, "Don't worry, don't worry. Here's how we're going to do it. We're going to have a contest, a massive nationwide contest."
10:14 Speaker 05 Anyone who wants to can submit a business plan, a few sheets of paper with an idea, a budget, a chart or two.
10:20 Speaker 04 And we'll read them. We'll pick out the best ones, and we'll hand out those piles of cash.
10:25 Speaker 05 The president of Nigeria, good luck, Jonathan, he liked the idea. And he said, "Go figure it out."
10:30 Speaker 04 There were a lot of challenges. First off, this is a country where the government has a hard time even keeping the electricity on. And now they're going to vet tens of thousands of business plans? Even people within the Nigerian government were thinking, "How are we going to pull this off?"
10:45 Speaker 05 The logistics were going to be one problem, but then there was this other problem: corruption.
10:50 Speaker 04 Corruption is not unheard of in Nigeria. So how do you make sure that the officials running the contest don't just give the money to their connections, to their friends and family?
11:00 Speaker 01 That only people who are connected get a chance.
11:03 Speaker 05 And ordinary people will not. That was the even bigger skepticism. They had to figure out a fair way to give out the money and a way that looked fair, too.
11:11 Speaker 04 They found judges outside of the government and outside of Nigeria to do the grading. And they decided also to take the names off of the application so the judges wouldn't know who was who.
11:21 Speaker 05 But that still left the question, how do you predict which business will succeed? Who do you give the money to?
11:27 Speaker 04 And this is where they brought in David Mackenzie. My, my job, I work in the research group at the World Bank and so sort of I typically come in when
11:35 Speaker 05 there are people have got an idea and they want to know, does it work? Mackenzie had an interesting idea for how to pick the winners. Just do it randomly. Sure, he said, you can look at their business plans, maybe pick out the few that seem great, throw out the terrible ones, but after that, just pick at random.
11:53 Speaker 04 So, OK, they decide they're going to pick a lot of the winners at random.
11:57 Speaker 05 They gave the contest a name, the You Win Competition.
12:00 Speaker 04 You Win, exclamation point.
12:01 Speaker 05 And they started to get the word out with ads.
12:04 Speaker 04 They blanketed the country with radio and TV ads.
12:07 Speaker 07 I'm like most entrepreneurs. I dream big, big, but reality, reality. But you know what? A youth enterprise with innovation in Nigeria, You Win, changed my story.
12:24 Speaker 05 So those ads are all over the country. And Lariat Al Hassan, that woman we met earlier who was selling paint out of her car, she's listening to the radio, she's in her bedroom, and she is hearing those ads over and over and over again.
12:37 Speaker 06 I heard it for the first time. I ignored it. I heard it the second time. I ignored it. But the third time, something in me said, Lariat, why don't you pick up this opportunity? Try, try and see. It could work out for you.
12:53 Speaker 05 She took out her old laptop, she plugged in her modem, and she went online and she applied. So did 24,000 other people. And Lariat, she made the first cut. So she and 6,000 other people, they get invited to the next phase. This is where she would have to write that real, proper business plan.
13:10 Speaker 01 Lariet got some help with this part. The government called all of the semifinalists together and they put them through these business trainings. Lariet says hers was like this big, packed concert hall. There were all kinds of applicants. There was a baker who didn't have the right kind of equipment.
13:25 Speaker 05 A chicken farmer who said he wanted to expand into catfish and snail farming.
13:30 Speaker 01 There was a guy running a computer school.
13:32 Speaker 05 There were musicians, dentists, all kinds of people with ideas for all kinds of businesses.
13:36 Speaker 06 Boy, it was intense from morning till evening.
13:40 Speaker 01 Afterward, Lariet went home. She drafted a budget. She made some sales projections. This was a full, comprehensive business plan, just like she learned in the training.
13:49 Speaker 05 And yep, she is the likable character at the start of her show. You knew it had to be coming. She won.
13:53 Speaker 06 I felt I couldn't even control my emotions and I went jumping on my bed.
14:03 Speaker 06 Until my sister would say, what's wrong with you? Have you won? Have you won a lottery? And I said, yes, yes, yes.
14:14 Speaker 01 Lariet got 10 million naira. That is about $65,000. And this is a huge amount of money. It's like more than 10 times what she would earn in a year.
14:23 Speaker 05 She used it to hire some people. She got some salespeople. She got some marketing people.
14:28 Speaker 01 And she rented a proper showroom. She tricked it out with some furniture she was really proud of. No doubt about it, this changed her business.
14:36 Speaker 06 Yes, yes, because I can confidently say now, please come to my office. Oh, we are in so, so place. Oh, you can come here. Oh, what time? Oh, yes, I'll be ready for you. Oh, I'll be waiting for you.
14:49 Speaker 01 Now, you can look at this and say, of course, she was able to do this. She was given $65,000.
14:56 Speaker 05 Not even alone, just gave her a pot of money.
14:59 Speaker 01 The real question is, how is her business doing a year from now, two years from now?
15:04 Speaker 05 How do all the others do? The dentist and the chicken farmer who wants to expand into catfish.
15:09 Speaker 01 And the World Bank looked at this. Because some of the winners had been chosen randomly, they could evaluate it like a real experiment. They could compare people who got the money to people who didn't.
15:18 Speaker 05 The results were published, and they're pretty remarkable. Chris Blatman is an economist at Columbia University who studies how to get people out of poverty in the developing world.
15:27 Speaker 00 I remember reading it, and my eyes kind of popping out of my head, and then reading it a little bit more in-depth because I thought, no, no, no, this isn't possibly true, and getting into the details. And getting so excited, I just shot off a blog post right away.
15:39 Speaker 05 That's how he deals with unexpected joy. Here's what the report said. It looked at Lariat and the 1,200 other winners of the You Win competition, and it found they had created 7,000 jobs, real jobs that stuck around for years. So the whole thing costs $60 million, and that, do the math, comes out to a cost of $8,500 per job created, which may mean nothing to anybody else, but to people who look at these things and study them, like Chris Blatman, he says that is really impressive. And that is why he picked this as the title of his blog post.
16:10 Speaker 00 Is this the most effective development program in history? Question mark.
16:14 Speaker 05 Blatman said the thing that stood out to him is that the winners, as a group, used the money pretty well, even though a lot of them were these one-person businesses, and they got more money than they'd probably ever seen in their whole life. Even though a lot of them were picked kind of at random, he just expected that a lot more of them would fail.
16:31 Speaker 00 I guess I have this idea that entrepreneurship is a little bit more rare. And yes, they screened people for business by competitions, and there were all these stages, but even so, they, there wasn't this magical X-factor that is really, really rare. It might be something that's a lot more common. So it just struck me that this could apply in a lot of places, possibly.
16:54 Speaker 05 That you could do this kind of program somewhere else.
16:57 Speaker 00 Right.
17:02 Speaker 02 That story was from 2016, hosted by Alex Goldmark and Noel King. The You Win contest was eventually shut down in Nigeria. The country changed presidents and you know how that goes. But the program was copied in Kenya and Senegal. The woman who came up with the idea, Dr. Ngozi, is now the Director General of the World Trade Organization, the WTO, and Lariat's paint business, still running. Although she tells us she still struggles to find financing to grow even bigger. We have our professor back now with us, Tavneet Suri. Hey, Tavneet.
17:36 Speaker 03 Hi, Robert.
17:37 Speaker 02 One of the things I learned from this case study is that Nigeria and a lot of the other countries in Africa have what is called the missing middle of businesses. There are a lot of entrepreneurs, one-person companies. And then on the other side of the spectrum, there's a lot of large corporations. But there aren't enough mid-sized businesses. That's the missing middle. Why is this gap happening? And what's holding back entrepreneurs like Lariat from growing?
18:01 Speaker 03 Yeah, it's a good question. You know, one piece is skills, right? Do you actually know how to run a business? Do you, you know, are you an entrepreneur? Have you thought of all the pieces? You know, a second is, of course, actual capital, right? If I want to start a business, I need a bunch of money. Where do I get that money?
18:23 Speaker 02 The You Win program was tackling the money problem, one big lottery winning at a time. But I kept thinking, how does this program get bigger? Where are the VC firms or banks that are willing to step in and provide the startup capital that the government is trying to do with this program?
18:42 Speaker 03 You know, if we think of the mid-sized businesses that we think of elsewhere in the world, a lot of banks do something we call cash flow lending. You show me your cash flow in your business. I see your cash flow and go, okay, I can lend you this much based on your cash flow. In Africa, a lot of businesses don't have a way of showing cash flow. Right? I don't keep track. I don't have electronic records. I don't have an Excel spreadsheet to show you my cash flow. A lot of them are informal, so they're not filing taxes. I don't have a tax return to show you my cash flow. So some of it is maybe because banks feel like I would have to come out and visit the business to figure this out, and it's very costly to do that process.
19:20 Speaker 02 Hmm. This goes back to a big thing that we talked about a lot in last year's summer school season, the value of institutions to help businesses. You need a system in place with property rights, accountants, you know, a trusted legal system before you can even start to think about giving loans out as a bank.
19:40 Speaker 03 Yeah, absolutely. So this was kind of a very creative, kind of a little crazy thing to do, right? Where had I wanted to structure that as a loan, I would never give out that amount as a first time loan to a business, right? So that's the other piece. Like, you know, if you're gonna try and do something really big, it's not clear you can even recoup when the legal system doesn't work for you and there's not clear property rights around what's owned and what's not owned and by who.
20:08 Speaker 02 Which is essential, right? I always say that land surveyors and title insurance companies may seem like the most boring things in the world, but they are in fact the foundation of a successful economy, figuring out who owns what.
20:22 Speaker 02 Up next, we travel halfway across the continent of Africa to a small town in Kenya that has really become the center of economic research for the world. What are the building blocks of health, education, and prosperity for all? We'll figure that out along with The Economist after the break.
20:43 Speaker 00 Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors.
20:48 Speaker 04 This message comes from Odoo, the all-in-one business management software platform. Whether you're a small or large business, Odoo gives you one flexible platform built to grow with you. Try today for free at Odoo.com/planetmoney.
21:03 Speaker 00 This message comes from Capital One. With the Spark Cash Plus card from Capital One, you earn unlimited 2% cash back on every purchase and get big purchasing power so your business can spend more and earn more. Stephen, Brandon and Bruno, the business owners of SandCloud, reinvested their 2% cash back to help build the company's retail presence. Capital One, what's in your wallet? Find out more at CapitalOne.com/SparkCashPlus. Terms apply. This message comes from Capella University. You know that feeling when there's a spark building inside you? That you were meant for more? That's your own drive pushing you towards what's next. Capella University gets that. With their FlexPath learning format,
21:47 Speaker 00 you can set the pace and earn your degree without putting life on pause. You've built experience and know what you're capable of. Now, this is your time to turn that momentum into more. The only real question is, what can't you do? Learn more at Capella.edu.
22:07 Speaker 02 All right, everyone. Stay together. Remember the buddy system. We don't want any of the students getting lost here on the border of Uganda and Kenya. This is the location for our second case study, and it gets to the very core question in economics, and all of science, really. How do we know what we know? What really works and what doesn't? The show was hosted by Erica Beras and Alex Mayasi.
22:32 Speaker 03 The place where Carol Nakasa grew up, she says it's not a place she ever expected the rest of the world to care about. I was born and raised in a small town in western Kenya called Busia.
22:44 Speaker 01 Busia, Kenya. It's right on Kenya's border with Uganda, so it's a busy international crossing point. There is lots of truck traffic hauling things back and forth. It made getting around Busia kind of treacherous when Carol was a kid.
22:58 Speaker 03 We would ride at the back of bicycles, they're called boda bodas, and all the Time we freaked out whenever there was a truck coming because, you know, they're not very safe.
23:08 Speaker 01 Carol eventually left Busia. She studied computers in Nairobi, but her family wanted her to return home. And her father helped her get a computer-related job back in the small town. A group of economists were doing some sort of study and they needed someone to help with data entry. So Carol finds herself sitting at a desk and entering the answers to some strange survey questions.
23:30 Speaker 03 How many goats you have? How many TVs? How many bicycles? So all these questions started nagging me and I was wondering like, why would you ask someone these types of questions?
23:42 Speaker 04 Carol Takessa eventually met the man who wanted to know how many goats and bicycles people in Busia had. Michael Creamer, a soft-spoken American with glasses. So I taught high school not far away from Busia. After that, he went off to get his PhD in economics. He focused on development economics, which deals with all the factors that keep poor countries from growing. So everything from a lack of infrastructure to public health problems.
24:09 Speaker 01 Michael gets his degree and his thoughts are never far from Kenya. He advises a friend with a project to help kids in Busia, paying school fees, funding school. And Michael suggests that maybe they could do a sort of experiment to see if the project really helped people. It ends up being too small to draw any conclusions, but the money seemed to help a bit.
24:30 Speaker 04 A couple of years later, Michael's friend's nonprofit is trying to take on a bigger project. They want to give textbooks to students at 100 schools in the region. And Michael, he's ready to try out his experiment idea in a bigger way. He wants to do a randomized controlled trial.
24:46 Speaker 01 Now randomized trials have been the gold standard in medicine for decades. It's how we tested the treatment for tuberculosis back in the 1940s, the polio vaccine in the 1950s. You have two statistically identical groups and you randomly choose one of them to get the treatment and the other one doesn't. In medicine, it's one of the best ways we have of understanding whether an intervention works.
25:11 Speaker 04 In economics in the early 90s, there had been a few studies based on randomized trials, but it wasn't. That wasn't really how things were done. Randomized trials are expensive. They take a lot of time.
25:21 Speaker 01 So when Michael sets out to measure the effects of giving out textbooks to schoolkids in Busia, he's not only trying to help his friend's nonprofit spend its money effectively. He's also trying out a different way of drawing conclusions in economics. The study he designs takes place over four years, and it includes 100 schools around Busia. Michael and his colleagues randomly assigned the schools to different groups. This was often listing the schools in alphabetical order and then going, you know, counting off, 123, 123, 123.
25:56 Speaker 04 They want to be sure that these groups are all pretty much the same, that one group isn't an outlier in some way. One way they do this is by surveying the families. And this is around the time Carol McCassow was hired. All those questions about goats and TVs and bikes that she was puzzled by, they were meant to check whether some of the students' families were much wealthier than the others.
26:15 Speaker 01 So the study gets up and running. The first year, only one group of schools gets textbooks. The next year, a second group gets them, until all the groups have gotten them.
26:24 Speaker 04 This goes on for four years. And then Michael gets the results. And there is a big surprise. He expected that as each group received the textbooks, their test scores would go up. But instead, he didn't see any difference in average test scores. No difference at all, even though all these kids now had textbooks.
26:43 Speaker 01 Yeah, first I was shocked. That wasn't what I was expecting. Second, I was disappointed. Yeah, I wanted this to work. And I thought it would work. Michael reflects on what he knows about schools in rural Kenya. He knows that many kids fall behind for a whole bunch of reasons. School is taught in English, but most kids don't speak English at home. There are public health problems like malaria and HIV, which can keep kids out of school. And kids miss school to work or help their families.
27:14 Speaker 04 And as he's thinking about that and looking back at the data, he notices something that didn't initially stand out. The textbooks did help one group, students who had high test scores to begin with. Their scores improved significantly. Eventually, this study led to an important insight. Governments and aid groups were spending millions of dollars on textbooks. But a lot of that money was wasted. And so education reformers Start focusing more on the kids who weren't doing well. They start emphasizing remedial education.
27:43 Speaker 01 For Michael and for Busia, the textbook study is a turning point. Michael is like, I want to do more studies like this. Randomized trials that can help solve real problems that people face. And other economists got interested, too. Some of them were students of Michael's. They'd help out as research assistants, then go on to develop their own projects. And very, very often, that meant working in Busia. Because it was a good place to do research.
28:14 Speaker 04 When all of these economists start coming to Busia, Carol Nakesa has a front row seat.
28:19 Speaker 03 So first, we had one expert house, which was rented specifically for the experts. And then the experts, you know, they continued to increase. So we rented a second expert house. So maybe four, five in a house.
28:33 Speaker 01 Oh, wow.
28:34 Speaker 03 You know, especially the summer, the office would be full of so many white people. I think it got to the point where any white person in town would be affiliated to us.
28:47 Speaker 04 By 2010, the studies that are happening in Busia are starting to remake development economics.
28:53 Speaker 01 One of Michael's students from Harvard, Ted Miguel, evaluated the benefits of giving schoolchildren medicine for parasitic worms for free, when a lot of groups were charging for it.
29:04 Speaker 04 It winds up showing that kids are far more likely to attend school if they've been treated. A follow-up study shows that led to better jobs and higher incomes later in life. Treatment is now standard across Kenya.
29:16 Speaker 01 And the Kenyan staffers who helped run studies in Busia, some of them realized, this can be my career. Carol was one of them. She started out by just making suggestions to the researchers.
29:29 Speaker 03 Like if I read a proposal and then I think about it, I'm like, oh, how about this? How about this? I feel. Like it just came naturally.
29:37 Speaker 04 After all, she'd been working on randomized trials for years, pretty much as long as they'd been happening in Busia.
29:42 Speaker 03 And so the moment someone accepts your suggestion, it's also something that makes you to feel like sharing more suggestions in future.
29:54 Speaker 01 Of course, yeah. Like Carol tells an economist that there are lots of girls having sex with older men in return for money, which raises their risk for HIV. The economist Pascaline Dupat is like, do they know about the risk? Could we change this behavior?
30:10 Speaker 04 So Pascaline created a curriculum to teach girls that older men have higher rates of HIV. The curriculum went out to dozens of schools, and there was a randomized trial to test the results.
30:20 Speaker 03 For me, her study was awesome in so many ways because that was a big problem then.
30:28 Speaker 04 Yeah. Did you feel like you could see it in the data from the study that that fewer girls had gone into that kind of dangerous work as a result?
30:37 Speaker 03 Yes, I did.
30:38 Speaker 01 Pascaline's study found that in the schools that got the teaching, fewer girls got pregnant, suggesting there was less unprotected sex. And so the curriculum started to be used more widely.
30:50 Speaker 04 In 2014, almost 20 years after Carol first started working on Michael Kriemer's textbook study, she left Busia to get a master's degree at Harvard.
31:00 Speaker 01 And when she graduated, she went right back to Kenya, to Busia, and founded her own research organization, a kind of one-stop shop for any researcher who wants to run a randomized trial in Kenya. Carol Nakessa says she knows this approach to economics has changed lives in developing countries all over the world.
31:21 Speaker 03 When you see something being practiced in other countries and they
31:26 Speaker 04 It was also as a result of the study that was conducted in Kenya. And when not only Kenya, but in a small town where you come from. Isn't that not nice?
31:43 Speaker 02 It is indeed nice. That case study was from 2023 and was hosted by Erica Beras and Alex Mayasi. And a notable follow up here. Michael Kramer won the Nobel Prize in Economics alongside some of the other researchers who worked in Busia, Abarjeet Benari and Esther Duflo. They won for the idea of using randomized control trials to effectively alleviate global poverty. We return with our Kenyan economist, also a business school professor, after the break.
32:17 Speaker 00 Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors.
32:22 Speaker 04 This message comes from Odoo, the all in one business management software platform. Whether you're a small or large business, Odoo gives you one flexible platform built to grow with you. Try today for free at Odoo.com/planetmoney.
32:37 Speaker 00 This message comes from NPR sponsor, the Capital One Venture X Business Card. Every business owner needs a serious business travel card that can keep up with their needs. With the Capital One Venture X Business Card, you earn unlimited double miles on every purchase, no matter where your business may take you. Plus, big purchasing power means you can spend more and earn more. The Capital One Venture X Business Card. What's in your wallet? Terms apply. See CapitalOne.com for details.
33:07 Speaker 02 We are back with our Kenyan economist, Tavne Suri, who is currently at the MIT Sloan School of Management. Hey, Tavne.
33:15 Speaker 03 Hi, Robert.
33:16 Speaker 02 So in Kenya, do people know this about Busia? That it is this town of economists beloved around the world?
33:25 Speaker 03 No, my guess would be no. My parents, my parents know, but partly because some of those economists have traipsed to our house for dinner.
33:33 Speaker 02 You cannot keep an economist away from free food. When people who are not your parents talk about Busia, are they proud that Kenya was the center of this randomized control trial revolution? Or does it feel a little, I don't know, icky to be the world's experimental lab?
33:52 Speaker 03 Yeah, I guess that's a great question, Robert. I think you'll probably get flavors of both people. Some people who think it's cool that there's been knowledge generated. I think others who think this is weird and they don't really think we should be part of experiments. I do think, you know, the one question that a lot of people do ask me is, how does this help all of us, right? Does it change policy? Does it get implemented? Do we learn stuff that will come back to benefit everybody in some way? And that's a harder question to answer, of course, because we can do the research. Whether the government listens to the results and reacts is a whole other separate kind of question.
34:36 Speaker 02 So what do you say when they ask this? Is it helping real people in Kenya?
34:42 Speaker 03 I sort of say the direct effect of Kenyan policy might not be huge on any given day, but the effect on our global knowledge and how that affects policy more broadly, I think, is quite large.
34:54 Speaker 02 If you can have policies that encourage less disease, more education, less poverty on a local level, does that build up to make the whole country richer? Or does that not necessarily follow?
35:09 Speaker 03 I think from what we know, it absolutely follows. I do think that core to the growth of an economy is this thing we call human capital, which is about the education and the health of your population. It's the sort of, in quotes, capital that a human brings to the table.
35:27 Speaker 02 How do you figure out what the return on the investment in human capital is? What's your, what's your variable there?
35:32 Speaker 03 Yeah, so we look at returns to education for Example, there's a large literature on the returns to education. In fact, there's some recent work showing that the growth miracle in Southeast Asia, a chunk of that was education, but an important part of that was was higher education, actually, less so primary education. So that's the education piece. And then the health piece, again, we measure the returns to health investments. One of the podcast talked about a deworming study that Michael Kramer and Ted Miguel ran. That was an investment in health. And there it actually also resulted in more education. Because the kids were healthier and went to school more. And so these two things are actually tied.
36:14 Speaker 02 We call that a positive externality in economics. Why don't you define that for the class?
36:21 Speaker 03 Positive externality is where if I invest in something, it benefits other people. So an example is if I'm more educated and I am working, the people around me are more productive because I have more education than they would be otherwise. And the same for them on me. If they're more educated, we can do more stuff together and I become more productive.
36:44 Speaker 02 As an economist, do you ever get frustrated seeing that we know something? We know something from the randomized control trials. But either no one will listen or a government chooses to do something different. Do you ever just bang your head against the wall?
36:57 Speaker 03 Oh, absolutely. Every day, Robert. Would we like people to use research and knowledge more in their decision making? Absolutely. But you can't just bang your head against a wall. You have to say, well, what can we do about it? Right? And so the same academics have been trying to build sort of, you know, policy relationships to try and change that.
37:20 Speaker 02 And I guess a Nobel Prize doesn't hurt when it comes to convincing governments that they maybe just maybe want to look at the data. Tavneet, we're asking all of our professors this season one final question. If there is something in the Kenyan economy that we could take back here to the United States that would be useful, what would that thing be?
37:44 Speaker 03 Well, it's not finance or economics, Robert, but you know.
37:49 Speaker 03 Everybody loves to vote and everybody shows up to vote.
37:53 Speaker 02 In Kenya, really?
37:53 Speaker 03 Not everybody, not everybody 100%, but voter turnout rates are extremely high. And as you can imagine, people stand in line for hours and hours on end to vote.
38:04 Speaker 02 That enthusiasm is similar to how everyone seems to have their own business. People like to get involved in the civic and business life of the country.
38:12 Speaker 03 I think in general, that's one thing that's true is everybody wants to participate in the economy. Think of even young people, as I said, right? They're not getting into university and they're frustrated because they want to participate in the economy. The entrepreneurship piece we saw, there's this sort of wanting to participate in the social and economic life in a very deep way, I think. And that's through voting and politics. You see it in that entrepreneurial spirit we talked about. So that piece I find very inspiring and I think it's up to us to figure out how to deliver on that, right?
38:47 Speaker 02 I think that's a good mission statement for economists everywhere. Tagnit, there will be a test at the end of the semester of summer school. Maybe you could help us with defining some of the concepts from today's episode.
38:59 Speaker 03 Sure, with one caveat, I don't have to do any of the grading.
39:02 Speaker 02 No, it's all automatic. Everybody passes.
39:05 Speaker 03 Oh, great.
39:06 Speaker 02 Okay. What is this randomized control trial, I should say Nobel Prize winning randomized control trial that everyone's talking about?
39:14 Speaker 03 A randomized control trial is a way of studying the impact of something, where you basically split a population, a study population into two groups randomly and one group gets the intervention and one doesn't. It allows you to sort of estimate the impact of that program very cleanly.
39:32 Speaker 02 A lot of the randomized control trials we talked about in this episode involved human capital. What is human capital?
39:40 Speaker 03 Human capital is education and health. So think of it as the capital embodied in our, in humans, in people.
39:49 Speaker 02 It's investing in humans instead of investing money, although it does cost money.
39:52 Speaker 03 Correct.
39:53 Speaker 02 Yes.
39:53 Speaker 03 It does cost a lot of money.
39:55 Speaker 02 Finally, we talked about the missing middle as a problem faced by businesses in countries in Africa. What is the missing middle?
40:04 Speaker 03 So the missing middle is where I don't have businesses that are middle sized in terms of their employees. I have lots of very small businesses with, you know, one or two employees. I have a bunch of big businesses that are in the hundreds of employees, but I'm missing this middle set of businesses that have kind of 5, 10, 15, 20 employees.
40:27 Speaker 02 Tavneet Suri from the MIT Sloan School of Management. Thank you so much for coming in and for talking with us.
40:34 Speaker 03 You're very welcome. It's been a pleasure. I had fun talking with you, too.
40:38 Speaker 02 When are you next going to Kenya? Your parents want to know.
40:41 Speaker 03 August.
40:42 Speaker 02 Nice. As you travel with us around the world for summer school, you might want to bring along a guidebook to the economy. Luckily, we wrote one. Planet Money, A Guide to the Economic Forces That Shape Your Life. It's like a podcast, but with beautiful, full color illustrations. It's always in my carry on. And hey, if you have lived in some country with a smart economic idea the rest of the world should know about, please tell us and you might be featured in our graduation episode. Perhaps you know a different way to do taxes, a mega project that came in under budget, somewhere where rent is cheap. Huh, get in touch now. Email us at [email protected] and put summer school in the subject.
41:25 Speaker 02 Summer School is produced by Sophia Palisacar and edited by Alex Goldman. It's fact checked by Leila Das. This show is engineered by Anli Huang. I'm Robert Smith. When I'm not summer schooling, I'm also the host of the new podcast, Business History. It's a show about the history of business. This is NPR. Thanks for listening.
41:49 Speaker 03 We have now started boarding our Planet Money flight, Group One Business Premium Elite, which of course includes all Planet Money listeners. Get over to our gate for early boarding and a glass of champagne. Our flight to Oslo, Norway, is now boarding. Get ready to learn how Norway beat the resource curse, AKA the paradox of plenty. Take off as usual next Wednesday.
42:14 Speaker 00 Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors. This message comes from Google Workspace with Gemini. One subscription that does it all. Personalized AI and premium business versions of Gmail, Google Docs, Drive, and more. Try it free for 14 days at g o o dot g l e slash Workspace with Gemini. This message comes from NPR sponsor Charles Schwab. Is there a right time to sell a stock? Are you taking the right risks with your portfolio? Financial decisions can be tricky, and often your own cognitive and emotional biases can lead you astray. Financial Decoder, an original podcast from Charles Schwab, can help. Join host Mark Reapy as he offers practical solutions to help overcome the biases that
42:59 Speaker 00 may affect your investing decisions. Download the latest episode and subscribe at schwab.com/financialdecoder.
Previous Big Lettuce meets Small Intestine Next How to beat the resource curse in Norway (Summer School) Page updated October 29, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated