Pod Insights Planet Money Do prediction market bettors make anything better? About this episode Have you noticed a lot of young people getting into antenna-maxxing as alpha? Or, maybe searching for any bit of copium after they fat-fingered and got rinsed? Or maybe they farmed during a yes-fest on Mention Markets resulting in some serious printing?
If none of that made sense to you, then we have the perfect episode for you.
Prediction markets have taken off in the past few years, using the same legal loopholes as the crypto market to essentially claim they are a “swap,” or “futures market,” similar to that of the totally legal grain and pork belly markets, and less like the state-regulated sports gambling market.
And they are great for the bondsharps who print on the regular (or, in English, “well known market makers who often make a lot of money”).
These prediction market companies exist because they’ve convinced regulators that they’re also great for the rest of us. They're adding new knowledge to the world. Making us more informed about the future.
On today’s episode, the case Kalshi has been making to regulators, the courts and the public as to why what looks like gambling and seems like gambling … is not. Why that argument’s kinda been working. And – if no one stops them – what prediction markets could do to our future.
For more, listen to former CFTC Commissioner Kristin Johnson on The Indicator from Planet Money https://www.npr.org/2026/04/20/nx-s1-5789071/is-anyone-gonna-do-anything-about-these-iran-war-trades.
Live show tour and book info. https://www.planetmoneybook.com / Subscribe to Planet Money+ https://n.pr/3HlREPz
Listen free: Apple Podcasts http://n.pr/PM-digital, Spotify https://n.pr/3gTkQlR, the NPR app https://n.pr/3Bkb17W or anywhere you get podcasts.
Facebook https://n.pr/3h92GwS / Instagram https://n.pr/3FqLuws / TikTok https://n.pr/3sGZdrq / Our weekly Newsletter https://n.pr/3zrFvUB.
This episode of Planet Money was hosted by Bobby Allyn and Mary Childs. It was produced by Sam Yellowhorse Kesler. It was edited by Marianne McCune, fact-checked by Sierra Juarez, and engineered by Cena Loffredo. Alex Goldmark is Planet Money’s executive producer.
See pcm.adswizz.com https://pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for sponsorship and to manage your podcast sponsorship preferences.
NPR Privacy Policy https://www.npr.org/about-npr/179878450/privacy-policy
Transcript 6,619 words · 18 speakers
0:00 Speaker 00 This message comes from Avalara Aviator. Aviator is the agent hub for tax and compliance. Purpose-built AI agents work around the clock and across business systems to help execute the work. Visit avalara.com/aviator.
0:16 Speaker 01 So figured out a way to pitch this?
0:18 Speaker 02 We know books aren't exactly a new medium.
0:21 Speaker 03 You know, a friend of mine once told me about a deeper bond with the product. Nostalgia. It's delicate but potent.
0:28 Speaker 02 Sure, but let's not overthink this.
0:30 Speaker 03 He told me that in Greek, nostalgia literally means the pain from an old wound. It's a twinge in your heart far more powerful than memory alone. Books aren't a spaceship, but a time machine.
0:42 Speaker 01 Spaceships? Listen, why don't we just tell listeners straight that it is called The Planet Money Book? It has a collection of some of our favorite stories with updates and tons of new original reporting. Plus, it's available in bookstores now.
0:56 Speaker 03 Back home again, to a place we know we are loved.
1:04 Speaker 01 This is Planet Money from NPR.
1:09 Speaker 04 My friend and colleague Bobby Allen has been covering the banana-less growth of prediction markets for NPR. You know, the ones where you can bet on everything from Taylor Swift's wedding date to the war in Iran. And Bobby says this craze has kind of come out of nowhere. Like, a few years ago, when the CEO of one of the biggest prediction markets in the world reached out to Bobby.
1:28 Speaker 05 Like, hey, FYI, might be worth incorporating like some Kalshi prediction markets into your coverage. And I was like, a prediction what? Like, Kalshi? Isn't that a cereal?
1:37 Speaker 04 The first thing that made Bobby think, wait, this may be a really big deal, happened last December. First, he saw Kalshi was partnering with CNN, meaning that CNN would be telling people the news and also telling them what people were betting on that news. And around the same time, people were actually betting on whether a famine would be declared in Gaza.
1:56 Speaker 05 Those two things colliding made me think like, what is this company all about? Who's using it? Why does CNN care about it? I guess WTF, how is this a thing?
2:05 Speaker 04 Ever since, Bobby has been listening to Kalshi's proponents and its detractors and trying to sort out exactly what this company is doing, either for us or to us. And we at Planet Money, we asked Bobby to take us along on the ride he's been on, starting with the Kalshi traders he met when he went looking for them, where they hang out, in chats on Discord.
2:24 Speaker 05 My account, it's like Bobby176539, and there's like no photo, like I look like a bot. But it's fine.
2:30 Speaker 04 Definitely not a narc. Bobby was thinking that these prediction market apps might be the next frontier of online gambling addiction. So when he first got on the Discord, he was asking around for stories of financial ruin.
2:42 Speaker 05 And I got absolutely savage for this, like absolutely savage. Here walks in an NPR reporter who announces himself as NPR reporter and asks, hey, I'm looking for someone who's like addicted to Kalshi and who like lost a lot of money. And they just utterly dragged me and were just like, who is this guy? You're calling us D gens, which is like slang for like degenerate trader. Like you're just, you're just looking for a DJ. You just want to ruin this industry, like what's wrong with you, blah, blah, blah, blah.
3:08 Speaker 04 Bobby is actually learning all of this vocabulary as he goes. He starts keeping a glossary.
3:12 Speaker 05 Degenerate traders don't know what they're doing and will lose their life savings.
3:16 Speaker 04 So Bobby's like, okay, this is not a therapy group for losers. I get it. This is where the winners brag, where the whales are, what they call the sharps. No, not sharks, sharps with a P, doing what they call printing.
3:28 Speaker 05 The very active ones are extremely savvy and they love putting in their Twitter bio, like from 10,000 to 900,000 on Kalshi, right?
3:35 Speaker 04 So Bobby's like, how are they winning so big? He starts asking people about what they call alpha, how they're getting an edge so they can predict the future better. Like some people are buying powerful antennas so they can have a millisecond advantage listening to a press conference. And Bobby's trying to get them to talk by speaking to them in their own language.
3:55 Speaker 05 I go, well, here's my proposed headline. Kalshi bond sharps turn to antenna maxing in search of market alpha.
4:04 Speaker 05 Which is something that would never appear on NPR.org, but was a nod to like the way they speak. And one guy says, "Defo a hit." Another guy says, "LOL, I think I like this guy. I hope somebody talks to him. He actually seems cool." Another guy says, "I just DM'd him."
4:20 Speaker 04 He's in.
4:21 Speaker 06 What's your job history been like? Yeah, so I graduated a little over two years ago.
4:25 Speaker 04 So now Bobby is madly typing notes in his interviews, and he meets a guy named Logan Suddeth, who is 25 and last year quit his job at a private credit firm to do prediction markets full-time.
4:36 Speaker 06 Why did you leave? Did you get a new job? Are you doing trading full-time? Yeah, I was making more from trading on CallShee after work than I was from my job. You're kidding.
4:45 Speaker 04 Like more every month than he was earning all year at his old job, he says.
4:49 Speaker 06 Amazing, dude. Wow.
4:51 Speaker 04 Logan's alpha is just research, research, research. He made more than $40,000, for example, on predicting Time Magazine's Person of the Year by analyzing what they were covering the most.
5:01 Speaker 05 I can't, what's your last name?
5:03 Speaker 07 Booth.
5:03 Speaker 04 Bobby found a guy posting about his alpha on a bet about how long it would take Charlie Puth to sing the National Anthem at the Super Bowl.
5:11 Speaker 07 I saw that Charlie Puth was in San Francisco like three days before. So I flew out there immediately, went outside the stadium.
5:20 Speaker 05 And I was like, oh, this guy's a perfect example of someone who's willing to literally go the extra mile, to have an edge that people would think would be unfathomable.
5:28 Speaker 04 Kayden Booth bought a stopwatch and this device used for listening to bird sounds and hung out on the sidewalk outside of the stadium waiting for the rehearsal to start so he could time it.
5:37 Speaker 07 I thought I was gonna show up here, and there would be 500 people sitting outside. I really thought there'd be 500 people in lawn chairs all trying to make easy money. To me, I was like, this is just common sense.
5:49 Speaker 04 And Kayden did win many thousands of dollars. But where did that come from? And what is all of this predicting doing to us?
6:00 Speaker 04 Hello and welcome to Planet Money. I'm Mary Childs here with NPR's Bobby Allen.
6:04 Speaker 05 Hey, Mary. What's up?
6:05 Speaker 04 Hi, Bobby.
6:06 Speaker 05 Never would have predicted we'd be doing an episode together, but here we are.
6:09 Speaker 04 OK. I also didn't predict it. The future's so strange.
6:12 Speaker 05 Prediction markets are obviously great for the Cadence and Logans of the world, who are making a bag, and great for the companies that run these prediction markets, who are also making a bag. These companies exist, though, because they have convinced regulators that they're also great for the rest of us, that they're adding new knowledge to the world, making us more informed about the future.
6:33 Speaker 04 And Bobby has been asking, is that right? Today on the show, the case Kalshi has been making to regulators, to the courts, and to the public, as to why what looks like gambling and seems like gambling is not. We will hear why that argument has been kind of working, and, if no one stops them, what prediction markets could do to our future.
7:01 Speaker 00 Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors. This message comes from Capella University. That spark you feel? That's your drive for more. Capella University's FlexPath learning format lets you earn your degree at your pace without putting life on pause. Learn more at capella.edu.
7:20 Speaker 08 This election season, let the NPR Politics podcast save your time and your sanity. We'll help you understand key races, which polls you can safely ignore, and what might happen if power shifts in Congress. Our short, daily episodes come out every afternoon, so you can spend less time scrolling through each chaotic news cycle. Make NPR Politics your hub for midterm election coverage. Follow our podcast on the NPR app or wherever you get your podcasts.
7:44 Speaker 09 American journalist Austin Teich vanished in Syria over a decade ago. For years, we've been searching for him, and now we finally have some answers.
7:55 Speaker 00 This is the prison that Austin was in.
7:57 Speaker 09 Oh, my god.
7:59 Speaker 10 We found Austin's file.
8:00 Speaker 09 Listen to Where Is Austin Tice from NPR's Embedded and BBC Radio 4, on the NPR app or wherever you get your podcasts.
8:09 Speaker 04 So as Bobby enters this world of people who are saying prediction markets are the next big thing, a route to prosperity, it's becoming richer, smarter, happier, he's like, the first step towards understanding all this hype is to try it.
8:22 Speaker 05 Most people are downloading these apps right now because of sports. It's the only place you can bet on sports in all 50 states. So that's about 80% of what's happening on Cowshoe. But then there's all this other stuff, like questions about what will happen in the world and pop culture and politics, whether a world leader will be toppled. Plus, something called mention markets, capital M, capital M, where people bet on whether someone will or won't say something.
8:46 Speaker 04 Bobby gave me a little tour through betting on mention markets, capital M, capital M. And I did get clearance from Mary Ann and Alex to do this. That's our process at Planet Money. I'm not allowed to do a lot.
8:58 Speaker 05 All right, so under 20K. The day we tried it, President Trump was about to give a very important speech that lots of people were watching about the war in Iran. So we decided to bet on which words he would say in the speech.
9:10 Speaker 04 Okay, fund your account. How much did I put? 50?
9:13 Speaker 05 Oh, you're gonna make some money or lose some money. The app is very brightly colored and super engaging. There's charts all over the place. You kind of can't stop looking at the thing.
9:22 Speaker 04 Okay, deposit now. I'm gonna push the button. Ready?
9:25 Speaker 05 You can literally see trades just flowing all over the screen in real time.
9:29 Speaker 04 I feel like I'm in an arcade.
9:30 Speaker 05 I mean, that's, that's exactly the point. Yeah, you see the probability of whether a word will be said or not. You're seeing like a lot of, you know, numbers going up, going down, depending on how traders are betting.
9:41 Speaker 04 Oh, wow. 95 for Epic Fury. Is he, I don't know, nuclear? People, 98% odds, nuclear. That's pretty good. Let's root for tariff. Do you think that's a good one?
9:53 Speaker 05 A yes or a no on tariff?
9:54 Speaker 04 Yes, tariff.
9:56 Speaker 05 Okay.
9:57 Speaker 04 I'm a yes on tariff. It's a low odds one. It's 17% only.
10:00 Speaker 05 That's not great, but let's, let's see.
10:02 Speaker 04 But I think I'm right. I think he's gonna say it.
10:04 Speaker 11 As we speak this evening, it's been just one month.
10:07 Speaker 05 Can you hear that?
10:08 Speaker 04 I'm hearing it. After Trump started talking, he immediately said like 15 of the words on the list.
10:13 Speaker 05 And all these words on the list, by the way, they're, they're known as strikes.
10:15 Speaker 04 And he even said words that I had thought were pretty improbable, like Barack Hussein Obama.
10:21 Speaker 05 Someone just, someone just said on Discord, holy yes fest.
10:25 Speaker 04 It's a yes fest. Oh, should we just put more money down?
10:27 Speaker 05 As we were watching, the odds of every word were jumping all around and we just really locked in like the world stopped. We felt like we were looking at this through a soda straw. Did he say our word? Will he? It becomes all your brain can think about. So when Trump starts talking about the economy, Mary's basically trying to goad him into saying the word tariff.
10:47 Speaker 11 Our economy is strong and improving by the day and it will soon be roaring back like.
10:52 Speaker 04 Because of?
10:53 Speaker 05 We are experiencing a very special kind of prediction market pain known as weaving.
10:59 Speaker 04 Well, he really almost said tariff twice. This is crazy. I'm so nervous.
11:03 Speaker 05 He's really playing footsie with tariff over here.
11:05 Speaker 04 He's really like just flirting with it. He's walking around it. Listeners, thank you for your faith in me, but I did lose $5 on my yes tariff bet. He never said it. Meanwhile, Bobby is a centimillionaire after months of betting on these markets just to figure him out.
11:21 Speaker 05 Yes, and I'm speaking to you now from my PJ. It's very palatial.
11:24 Speaker 04 And your first takeaway, Bobby, on your reporting journey is this feels a lot like gambling.
11:30 Speaker 05 It does. Uh, it's a game, right? You get this dopamine rush every time you win. If you're losing, you want to chase your losses and it's absolutely maddening. And there's always another market, Mary, the next hour. It just goes and goes and goes and goes and goes.
11:43 Speaker 04 And this feels like gambling experience? Bobby is definitely not alone. As he's following the story, he's reporting on all these lawsuits where lots of states are also accusing Calci of being gambling. Some of them are trotting out a very basic definition, which in Merriam-Webster is the practice of risking money or other stakes in a game or bet.
12:04 Speaker 05 In their early ads, Calci even portrayed itself like gambling. They were kind of cute about it, how they phrased it. They were basically like, bet on the NFL, legal in all 50 states.
12:13 Speaker 04 And important note, all the existing online sports betting apps are currently categorized as gambling.
12:20 Speaker 04 And as Bobby gets deeper into this giant fight with the states over whether Kalshi is gambling or not, he realizes the whole existence of these prediction apps depends on the courts agreeing with Kalshi, that these yes or no questions about the future are like derivatives, like swaps, a regular, degular financial instrument in which two parties with opposite views on the direction of some price or level agree to bet against each other.
12:45 Speaker 05 So I started digging into that. I really wanted to understand the argument that Kalshi's CEO and co-founder has been making from the start in defense of these prediction markets. And that means I finally write him back and say, hey, hey, Tarek, sorry I missed your message two years ago, but here I am. I think I'm ready to talk now.
13:02 Speaker 12 Can you hear me well? I mean, I guess you can. Yeah.
13:05 Speaker 05 Yeah, that works. Actually.
13:06 Speaker 04 The first thing Tarek Muntur always says about why Kalshi's not gambling, at least not like a casino, is that there is no house. He says Kalshi doesn't win when bettors lose. Instead, it makes money every time people bet, a little percentage of every bet. So their incentive is to have as many bets as possible.
13:23 Speaker 05 Chaching.
13:24 Speaker 04 And then the next thing he's always claiming is just because you're speculating about the future doesn't mean you're gambling.
13:29 Speaker 12 I always say this, speculation is not equal to gambling. Because if speculation is equal to gambling, then our entire financial market is gambling.
13:38 Speaker 05 Yeah, but I mean, if the comments section on NPR stories is any indication, Tarek, I mean, many people think this is gambling. I mean, they say you're putting up money. You might win some, you might lose some. It's an uncertain outcome. That's gambling.
13:52 Speaker 12 To me, I know my customers and I know what they're trading. And why are they excited about this? Is because at the end of the day, they're trading the same way they trade in the stock market. But in this case, they're trading on things that they care about and they can relate to.
14:02 Speaker 04 And Tarek is always saying that it's better than regular financial markets. He says on Kalshi, your average individual trader is on a more even playing field with all the seasoned professionals.
14:13 Speaker 12 Like the hedge funds and all these guys have all the information and, you know, there's no way to really beat the market in those places. But people have opinions about politics. They have an opinion about culture. They follow and track. The economy, they fall on track, sports, and this is a mechanism for them to express those opinions.
14:29 Speaker 05 The idea that prediction markets are basically democratizing the world of trading is a talking point Tarek has honed over the years. Because from the start, he had to convince the federal government that betting on all sorts of crazy stuff on Calci was not gambling, but something else, technically swaps. But Tarek often compares it to futures trading because, well, people are betting on future events.
14:50 Speaker 04 Right. Oil futures have a ton in common with betting on the Rotten Tomato score for the Devil Wears Prada, too.
14:55 Speaker 05 That's currently at 87%. Interesting. What's really helped me understand Tarek's argument was to go back in time and look at all the ways Tarek has made his case that Calci should exist. It started way back when he was an intern at Goldman Sachs, around 2016, when he says he kept hearing about customers who wanted to bet on big world events.
15:15 Speaker 12 They were all trying to figure out what was going to happen to simple questions about the future. It was basically, will Brexit happen or not? And will Trump win the election or not?
15:24 Speaker 04 The answers to those kinds of questions, like will Brexit happen, mattered to them because they affect the market and the price of assets. And investors wanted to be able to bet on which way things would go. So Tarek thought.
15:36 Speaker 12 Okay, we have a market to price companies. We have a market to price commodities, like physical things that you can touch that are important to the economy, currencies, interest rates, like debt. And what if we built one to price simple questions about the future? Okay, well, what is the simplest way of creating that is like, let's just make it a yes or no questions, where you can buy yes if you think an event is going to happen and no if you think it's not.
16:01 Speaker 05 Right. So, you know, Tarek in his past life was, you know, a buttoned up Wall Street type, not exactly Gordon Gekko, but you know what I'm talking about. And so he really wants to make betting markets the next thing in the long line of futures, starting with grain futures, the very first futures to be traded almost two centuries ago.
16:18 Speaker 04 Which, by the way, people also thought was gambling at first.
16:21 Speaker 05 So Tarek goes to the regulator of the futures market, the Commodity Futures Trading Commission, the CFTC, to ask permission to be able to run an exchange, a marketplace.
16:31 Speaker 04 The whole idea of futures for farmers, for instance, is to avoid feast or famine cycles, to smooth it out. So you can buy futures to lock in future prices. In case there's like a drought that knocks out all your crops. It's a way of hedging against something that might threaten your business, like an insurance policy on your crop.
16:50 Speaker 05 And also, when they're doing what they're supposed to do, futures help everyone figure out how much things should cost. Or if you ask Tarek, they can help predict the future more accurately, like they could be a tip sheet about what's gonna happen.
17:02 Speaker 12 Instead of people guessing whether Brexit was gonna happen or not, now you have a more objective source of, like, more objective unbiased source of signal on whether Brexit was gonna happen or not.
17:12 Speaker 04 And more noise. But Tarek is trying to turn his idea into a marketplace. And in order to get designated as just another futures or swaps market in the long line of them, the CFTC says Kalshi has to check a bunch of boxes, like the market cannot be easily rigged. No insider trading.
17:31 Speaker 05 Insider trading, bad. Kalshi submits lots of paperwork about this. And in November 2020, at the very end of President Trump's first term, Kalshi gets a call from the CFTC informing them that they have won regulators over. In Kalshi's press release, they wrote that it was, quote, "the next natural step in the evolution of trading on future events."
17:49 Speaker 04 But that was just a first step. Once Kalshi was allowed to exist as a marketplace, the company also needed to get approval for every new market it wanted to list. Meaning if Kalshi wanted to put up a market for people to bet on how much rain will fall in Chicago next week, they had to get permission.
18:06 Speaker 05 And this was just as President Trump was ending his first term and the much more skeptical Biden administration was taking over.
18:14 Speaker 04 So during these first few years, Kalshi was hearing a lot of this one word, no. Because the CFTC had rules. Any market on its exchange had to be insider trading proof, and it had to have what they called "public interest value," like the way a market on oil futures or employment data or inflation might inform how corporations make decisions over travel or hiring or firing. And also, the law strictly prohibited any markets to do with terrorism, assassination, war, and gaming. And that last one, gaming, that one ended up being important for Kalshi. Because at first, that was a real issue for Tarek. Like, back then, this gaming restriction meant that he couldn't list sports.
18:55 Speaker 05 And also, lots of other events that seemed to the CFTC to be like games. And this was frustrating to Kalshi's traders. So Tarek decided to fight it.
19:04 Speaker 04 In 2023, Tarek proposed Kalshi's first election market, a market for betting on what party would take control of Congress. Regulators blocked it, as expected. They said election betting is gaming, it's not allowed, and that it would open up elections to interference, among other things.
19:20 Speaker 05 But this time, Tarek sued. His lawyers argued there's no rule specifically against betting on elections, and this market would do what futures do best. You know, hedge against harmful outcomes and provide more predictive data.
19:34 Speaker 04 In their court papers, Kalshi referenced a whole academic experiment from the 1980s, where economists at the University of Iowa accepted bets on the 1988 presidential race. And it was more accurate than polls at the time. The wisdom of the crowds prevailed.
19:50 Speaker 05 And Kalshi's lawsuit prevailed, too.
19:52 Speaker 12 The courts did weigh in, you know, and they agreed our legal position that these markets are legal. They are allowed.
19:57 Speaker 05 And that was a rocket booster for you guys, when you guys sued your regulator and won. Yes, that was huge for you guys. That really opened the floodgates.
20:04 Speaker 04 Yes, it opened the floodgates, it majorly boosted the rocket, all of that.
20:07 Speaker 05 And here's the thing, once Kalshi got permission to list election markets, they interpreted that approval to mean they could list all kinds of markets. Not just who will win a political race, but sports, the Golden Globes. Will Ariana Grande's streams be up on Spotify next week?
20:22 Speaker 04 And it isn't just that ruling that opens the floodgates, it's the huge political shift that comes next.
20:28 Speaker 05 Because the Trump family actually joins in on the love fest. Donald Trump Jr. becomes an advisor to Kalshi. The CFTC's default setting changes. They go from default rejecting to default accepting, no matter how outlandish the market is.
20:42 Speaker 04 So that's basically where we are now. This is the reality that Bobby has sorted out during all these months on Discord chats and on calls with CEOs and following all the court battles.
20:52 Speaker 05 Prediction markets are ascendant. Caucay is out there trying to pull in as many people into prediction markets as it can, recruiting on college campuses, advertising all over subways. But I mean, every time I log on to work, I see my inbox absolutely full with lawmakers really incensed. Many people are trying to tear all of this down.
21:11 Speaker 04 That's after the break.
21:22 Speaker 00 Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors.
21:26 Speaker 10 This message comes from Capella University. You know that feeling when there's a spark building inside you? That you were meant for more? That's your own drive, pushing you towards what's next. Capella University gets that. With their FlexPath learning format, you can set the pace and earn your degree without putting life on pause. You've built experience and know what you're capable of. Now, this is your time to turn that momentum into more. The only real question is, what can't you do? Learn more at capella.edu.
22:00 Speaker 13 The 2026 midterm elections are upon us. On November 3rd, voters will determine what the next two years of their local leadership and the balance of national government will look like. Listen to the NPR News Now podcast for all the updates you need ahead of and after November 3rd from NPR News.
22:23 Speaker 14 Midlife brings a lot of changes. Your Turn with Alison Aubrey is a new podcast to help you navigate the twists and turns. From health and relationships to creativity and purpose, we can help steer your next chapter with Your Turn with Alison Aubrey. Find it on the NPR app or wherever you get your podcasts.
22:41 Speaker 00 Support comes from NPR sponsor AARP.
22:46 Speaker 05 Over the last month, Tarek's team of PR handlers has been pushing him into the spotlight. He's making the rounds as the public face of Calci and all these prediction markets. And he's essentially saying, yeah, yeah, there's this big legal debate happening, but listen to me for a second. These prediction markets are actually really important to society.
23:02 Speaker 04 Like Tarek keeps saying, at a time when no one seems to trust anything, these markets can be an accurate crystal ball, a truth machine. And, he says, they are better than polls. Betting, having skin in the game, makes the wisdom of the crowd even wiser. And, he says, prediction markets even make people better, more engaged citizens, like the opposite of social media.
23:23 Speaker 12 If somebody is very careful about their belief, they will make more money and do better on prediction markets than someone who has bad takes and extreme beliefs, right? Whereas that's not true for social media. Like, in social media, someone who has a very nuanced, smart take gets five likes. Someone who says something crazy on social media or racist will get 300,000 likes.
23:43 Speaker 05 I know, all of my most brilliant tweets get no likes, so I totally relate.
23:46 Speaker 12 So that's how you should be on prediction markets.
23:48 Speaker 04 Oh, trust me, he is.
23:49 Speaker 05 Yeah, it's all for the sake of journalism, I swear.
23:51 Speaker 12 I actually think prediction markets are a force for good because the incentive structure for prediction markets is rewarding the nuanced, the unbiased, the well-calibrated takes.
24:03 Speaker 04 In my little mention market betting experiment with Bobby, though, that is not what we found. Like, were we more engaged citizens when we were listening to that speech on Iran?
24:15 Speaker 11 The Korean War lasted for three years, one month.
24:18 Speaker 04 Duration of worse. Did not have that in my bingo card. Oh, this is the bingo card.
24:24 Speaker 04 This feels pretty gross, Bobby, I will say.
24:27 Speaker 05 You stop absorbing the content and you're just literally just like hearing the words as like, as like a cherry in the slot machine. Like, are you gonna line up three cherries? Are you gonna hit the jackpot?
24:38 Speaker 04 And he's over here talking about obliterating and decapitating an entire country which is full of people.
24:44 Speaker 05 Yeah, it's pretty unsettling.
24:49 Speaker 04 Now, how we feel about all of this is immaterial. It has nothing to do with whether or not Calci is legal. And after months of Bobby talking to all these people involved in Calci, not involved in Calci, watching it, worrying about it, he has basically concluded that Calci is working this legal loophole of being governed by derivatives law instead of gambling law. Like, this is gambling, it's just buttoned up and in a suit.
25:16 Speaker 05 And having covered tech startups for years now, this whole like, we're not this, we're that argument is something you hear over and over. Airbnb isn't a hotel, it's a people-to-people marketplace. Uber is not a taxi, but a transportation network company. And now Calci is saying, we're not gambling, we're this other thing.
25:31 Speaker 15 I think that they followed the playbook of many in the tech industry.
25:34 Speaker 04 That's Amanda Fisher, former chief of staff at the SEC.
25:37 Speaker 15 I would say crypto paved the way for this, which is that the disruption-
25:41 Speaker 05 Sorry, Amanda, sorry, Amanda, sorry, my dog's barking, sorry.
25:44 Speaker 04 And this is Bobby's dog, Cammy. He's a good dog.
25:47 Speaker 05 I first came across Amanda dragging the prediction market bros on the app formerly known as Twitter. She's now at a very pro-regulation advocacy group called Better Markets. Amanda says Calci's path to success has taken a page from another financial sector that bobbed and weaved its way through complicated legal obstacles.
26:03 Speaker 15 They use the playbook that the crypto industry, I think, started and perfected during the Biden administration, which is framing their disruption of industries as a technological disruption, when I would characterize it more as just a legal disruption. They are willing to take more legal risk and break the laws and essentially take the approach of catch me if you can.
26:25 Speaker 04 But Amanda's take is that prediction markets are not doing the things futures markets are supposed to do.
26:30 Speaker 15 Which is to facilitate corporations in the real economy, fostering price discovery and creating jobs and creating stable markets and not for just gambling and speculation.
26:43 Speaker 04 Amanda says the fact that these prediction markets are getting rubber stamped by the federal government as basically futures trading, that's giving sports gambling apps ideas.
26:52 Speaker 05 Some of the sports gambling apps are themselves launching their own prediction markets, trying to get approval as futures marketplaces. Their execs are publicly admitting it's a way to get sports betting into states where it is not legal. So Amanda posted this week, at least they're being honest.
27:08 Speaker 04 One of the things Amanda is out there warning people about all the time is how understaffed and uninterested the current CFTC is when it comes to monitoring whether these apps are following any of the official rules, like insider trading. In the stock market, which is regulated by the SEC, where Amanda used to work- She says it's pretty easy to get caught using insider access to WinVic. The SEC has like eight times the staff of the CFTC.
27:34 Speaker 15 I would highly advise people do not insider trade in the stock market. There are a lot of, there are a lot of surveillance tools and cops on the beat, at least during an administration that is predisposed to enforcing the law. I do not have similar confidence in prediction markets.
27:53 Speaker 05 Because prediction markets are partly responsible for policing their own services.
27:58 Speaker 04 There is a self policing mechanism that was written into the rules back when futures markets were all focused on grains and soybean prices and such.
28:05 Speaker 05 It is fascinating to me, the degree to which the CFTC sort of outsources regulation to self regulation, right? What's up with that?
28:14 Speaker 15 That's absolutely right. So in the past, markets were pretty simple. It wasn't every day that a financial intermediary would try to list a new type of grain future or soybean contract.
28:28 Speaker 05 You're saying they didn't, they didn't envision markets on whether the Supreme Leader of Iran would be ousted.
28:32 Speaker 15 Exactly. They were basic markets in pretty boring commodities. So when Congress and the agency set up this market, that self policing structure maybe made sense.
28:45 Speaker 04 Now, Amanda says, you have prediction markets like Calci applying the same self certification tool to all kinds of markets that it was not intended for. They're also supposed to be policing their own traders to make sure that they're not manipulating markets. But Amanda says she's not seeing any serious enforcement. What she hears instead is executives at these prediction markets talking about enforcement when big fishy looking wins make the news.
29:10 Speaker 15 So the capture of Maduro in Venezuela, or the Iran strikes, or any other policy announcement related to tariffs.
29:20 Speaker 04 People have been making suspiciously well timed bets on these kinds of events, but they are very hard to pin down as insider trading.
29:28 Speaker 05 Yeah, they really are. I mean, just this week I was reporting on these French sleuths who figured out that there was probably an insider trader on Polymarket who made a ton of money on President Biden's pardons in like the final hours he was in office. But it took them weeks to untangle all of this and we still don't know exactly who was behind the bets.
29:45 Speaker 04 Now Bobby was a philosophy major in college and he says he hasn't read Simone de Beauvoir or Kant in a long time, but during these whirlwind months reporting on prediction markets, he has found himself falling into a big existential wondering about these prediction markets.
29:59 Speaker 05 We, we, we, as I stroke my chin, I've been wondering, how much are these bets on future events changing the future?
30:07 Speaker 04 When parties acting in their self-interest maximize their own gain over that of the public, in philosophy and economics, this is known as sinister interest, attributed to philosopher Jeremy Bentham in the late 1700s, and you can already see this happening.
30:20 Speaker 05 Yeah, I saw what some might call sinister interest in the real world recently. I was watching a mention market where people were betting on what words a Federal Reserve official was going to say in a meeting about the crypto industry. It was on Zoom. And when the officials were taking questions from that Zoom, I saw Kalshi traders submitting questions as if they were just regular humans, trying really hard to get the official to say something they were betting on.
30:44 Speaker 04 And it can get way more ick. Perhaps the most stark example, prediction market betters threatened a journalist over his reporting on the Iran war, saying that they would kill him if he didn't change what he'd written about a military strike.
30:55 Speaker 05 Now, Tarek has told me he's aware of the dangers and there are markets he would never list.
31:01 Speaker 12 Yes, I mean, there are limits, right? Like, I always say, taken to the extreme, things can be bad. But like, any markets that can create a perverse incentive, we avoid.
31:09 Speaker 05 What's a perverse incentive, you might be wondering? Well, maybe a bet on California wildfires. Like, how far will this fire spread that could encourage someone to set a fire?
31:19 Speaker 04 But the problem is, in practice, the prediction market companies themselves are the ones deciding what markets may have perverse incentives. And Polymarket, they did have markets on the LA fires last year.
31:32 Speaker 05 So I've actually gone back and talked to all those big time prediction market sharps in the Discord chats to ask them if they were worried about all the potential reality warping and insider betting on almost any future event. And some of them are like, eh, we're not that worried about it. But others are like, I don't really see how Kalshi's claim that this is a net plus for humanity really checks out at all.
31:54 Speaker 16 They try to say like, oh, you know, it's, it's really important to have like, these numbers from prediction markets to like accurately gauge things.
32:02 Speaker 04 This is Evan Semet, who told Bobby he's been making close to $100,000 a month on Kalshi. So you might think he would be pretty game. But.
32:10 Speaker 16 You know, does the general public really need something that's like 1% more accurate on like the, I don't know, like whether or not someone's gonna score like over a certain number of points in a football game? Like, like, what, what value does that actually add? I would say like none. Like, like literally none.
32:28 Speaker 05 I talked to one trader, um, yesterday who said, uh, you know, basically like they have so much on the line financially in terms of prediction markets sticking around that whatever party, whatever candidate wants to let them thrive, they're gonna back. Is that like your number one thing or is it a top thing or?
32:43 Speaker 16 No. So I like, okay, maybe this is like bad for me to admit or whatever, but like, I don't think prediction markets are like a good thing socially. I, I think that there is like an actual like pretty real dark side to prediction markets. These markets are only profitable for people like me because there are people just throwing away money. I think that's probably pretty bad, to be honest.
33:09 Speaker 04 Evan's bad vibes, though, are not stopping this industry.
33:12 Speaker 05 It seems like every day there's a new lawsuit or court ruling over the future of Kalshi. Nevada has recently banned Kalshi. In New Jersey, meanwhile, a court struck down a ban. It'll all probably end up before the Supreme Court one day. But in the meantime, the rocket ship that is the prediction market industry keeps soaring. This past year alone, 70 new prediction market companies have started, and the industry is projected to be a trillion dollar industry in the next four years.
33:41 Speaker 04 Bobby, uh, should we make a bet on it?
33:46 Speaker 05 Hey, Mary? Mary Childs?
33:48 Speaker 04 Yeah.
33:49 Speaker 05 We want to play something for you.
33:50 Speaker 17 Hi, Mary. It's Dilip Singh, currently vice chair at PGM, former deputy national security advisor for international economics under the Biden administration, former head of the markets group at the Fed, blah, blah, blah. Well, um, I'm calling because I heard you're leaving Planet Money.
34:07 Speaker 05 Oh, my God, Mary, you're leaving.
34:08 Speaker 17 That's really too bad because I was just about to cave to that interview you've been chasing me on for months.
34:12 Speaker 04 I literally have been pounding this guy.
34:15 Speaker 17 Well, onwards and upwards for you. Congratulations, and please don't forget about the rest of us.
34:20 Speaker 04 This is the meanest thing.
34:24 Speaker 05 Congrats, Mary. We all love you.
34:26 Speaker 04 Thank you. It's true. I am leaving Planet Money for a new project. Details to come. Joke's on Dilip, though, because I'm absolutely going to be following up.
34:37 Speaker 04 This episode of Planet Money was produced by Samuel Horsecassler. It was edited by Marian McCune, fact-checked by Sierra Guarez, and engineered by Sina Lefredo. Alex Goldmark is our executive producer.
34:46 Speaker 05 Special thanks to all the Kelsey traders. I have been hounding for months. Speaking of hounds, thank you to Kami the dog.
34:52 Speaker 04 Good dog.
34:53 Speaker 05 I'm Bobby Allen.
34:55 Speaker 04 And I'm Mary Childs. This is NPR. Thanks for listening.
35:11 Speaker 00 Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors.
35:15 Speaker 10 This message comes from Mint Mobile. Ditch overpriced wireless and get premium wireless for less. Go to mintmobile.com/switch to see which plan works for you.
35:27 Speaker 13 This week on the NPR Politics Podcast, the midterm elections are wrapping up and millions of people have already voted. We're taking one final check of the electoral pulse with a new NPR PBS News Marist Poll. It shows Democrats still poised to make gains, but also with some warning signs for just how many. We'll explain on the NPR Politics Podcast.
Previous How to get through the Strait of Hormuz Next Live: Anthropic co-founder on AI and jobs Page updated October 30, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated