Pod Insights Planet Money Can the president override Congress on spending? About this episode So the president can't spend more money than Congress has agreed and voted to spend. But can the president spend less money than Congress wants?
It all comes down to something called "impoundment" and the Impoundment Control Act of 1974, which controls when and how a president can take away money Congress has appropriated.
President Trump followed the Impoundment Control Act rules back in 2018. But now, in his second term, he's saying he thinks that law is unconstitutional.
On this episode: the history of impoundment, from Thomas Jefferson to Richard Nixon and Bill Clinton. And what constitutional scholars and judges are saying after Trump attempted to dismantle a federal agency and freeze trillions in federal funding that goes to states for everything from new school buses to public health research.
We've got more about impoundment in the latest Planet Money newsletter https://www.npr.org/sections/planet-money/2025/02/18/g-s1-49220/trump-ignore-congress-spending-laws-impoundment.
Check out The Indicator's episodes on the gutting of USAID https://open.spotify.com/episode/6lDAKGI7RUT0j8g9NTE0lJ?si=_SkG6Un9TjioEg_vY0FfpA and how American farmers are affected in USAID cuts https://open.spotify.com/episode/7B0gf7hDzrZ3dCFVxOXRoc?si=Zju9nPdmSs6P0pZbUHKlMA. And, our previous episode on the big government money pipe https://open.spotify.com/episode/4WePEAx3C2wXYDVsr4aBwq?si=vcMxo_qESq-2yzjo5HpgcQ that's being closely watched right now.
Find more Planet Money: Facebook https://n.pr/3h92GwS / Instagram https://n.pr/3FqLuws / TikTok https://n.pr/3sGZdrq / Our weekly Newsletter https://n.pr/3zrFvUB.
Listen free at these links: Apple Podcasts http://n.pr/PM-digital, Spotify https://n.pr/3gTkQlR, the NPR app https://n.pr/3Bkb17W or anywhere you get podcasts.
Help support Planet Money and hear our bonus episodes by subscribing to Planet Money+ in Apple Podcasts http://n.pr/PM-digital or at plus.npr.org/planetmoney https://n.pr/3HlREPz.
See pcm.adswizz.com https://pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for sponsorship and to manage your podcast sponsorship preferences.
NPR Privacy Policy https://www.npr.org/about-npr/179878450/privacy-policy
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 This episode's sponsor is HubSpot, which offers the following message: What if, instead of updating your CRM, your CRM updated you? HubSpot's self-updating CRM keeps your customer context current, so you can win more deals. Learn more at hubspot.com.
0:17 Speaker 01 This is Planet Money from NPR.
0:23 Speaker 01 President Donald Trump has attempted to dismantle a federal agency, USAID, the Agency for International Development. He's attempted to freeze billions of dollars in grant money that goes to states for everything from new school buses to paying for the health benefits of childcare workers, wildfire prevention. He's attempted to freeze federal funds for medical and public health research. And now, whether Trump has the power to cut off money that has been appropriated by Congress is being litigated by the courts. Several judges have blocked big parts of Trump's efforts, ordered the administration to release the funds they froze, though there have been many examples
1:08 Speaker 01 of funds not being released. And, you know, the Constitution is pretty clear that Congress has the power of the purse. Congress decides how much money the US spends. So generally, it's been understood that the president cannot spend more money than Congress has agreed and voted to spend. But can the president spend less money than Congress wants?
1:35 Speaker 01 Hello and welcome to Planet Money. I'm Sarah Gonzalez, and that is the thing being debated right now. Whether a president can spend less than Congress wants comes down to something called impoundment and the Impoundment Control Act. Basically, when and how a president can impound funds, like take money away that have already been appropriated. Today on the show, what is impoundment? How has it been used in the past? And what do the judges and legal scholars who study the Constitution and impoundments in particular have to say about the legality of what the Trump administration is trying to do?
2:19 Speaker 02 Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors. This message comes from LinkedIn. Owning a small business comes with a lot of challenges and means juggling multiple things at once. It's even harder to do it efficiently. But with LinkedIn, you get all the tools you need to grow in one place. With LinkedIn, simplify your sales, marketing, and hiring so that you can actually run your small business. Learn more at LinkedIn.com/PlanetMoneyShow.
2:47 Speaker 00 This episode's sponsor is HubSpot, which offers the following message. What if instead of updating your CRM, your CRM updated you? No catching up on manual edits, no more guesswork. HubSpot's self-updating CRM keeps your customer context current and helps you understand what to do next. So, marketing builds more demand, sales wins more deals, and customers keep coming back. Learn more at HubSpot.com.
3:12 Speaker 02 This message comes from Capital One. Capital One offers checking accounts with no fees or minimums. What's in your wallet? Terms apply. See CapitalOne.com/BankGuide for details. Capital One, N.A., Member FDIC.
3:27 Speaker 01 When the Trump administration ordered all of the funding freezes, it upended thousands of contracts, including with US businesses and nonprofits. For example, US farmers grow a lot of the corn and soy and food that the agency USAID sends to other countries. Last week, the USAID Office of Inspector General released a report that said that half a billion dollars' worth of food was at risk of just spoiling in warehouses, at ports, in transit. The USAID Inspector General was fired the day after that report came out.
4:06 Speaker 01 Now, the US Constitution says that the president has a duty to "take care that laws be faithfully executed." And when Congress debates and decides to fund something, that's a law. But before Trump was re-elected, he was saying that he didn't think Congress had the final say here. In a campaign video, Trump said that, as president, he should have the power to not spend money that Congress has appropriated.
4:36 Speaker 03 For 200 years under our system of government... It was undisputed that the president had the constitutional power to stop unnecessary spending through what is known as impoundment.
4:49 Speaker 01 Impoundment. Trump was saying that he should be able to impound the money.
4:54 Speaker 03 Very simply, this meant that if Congress provided more funding than was needed to run the government, the president could refuse to waste the extra funds and instead return the money to the general treasury.
5:07 Speaker 01 Okay, we should note that the system kind of already allows for this, according to a legal scholar we spoke to, who said that, you know, if the government can like get the job done with less money than Congress appropriates, that's totally okay sometimes. So like, if Congress appropriates $15 billion to build a new aircraft carrier, but the contractor can get it done for, I don't know, $14 billion, that's fine. The federal government is not going to be like, oh, no, no, no, you, you must charge us the full $15 billion, right? The important thing is that the aircraft carrier that Congress wanted just has to get built. A president cannot override Congress and say, well, you know, I as president don't
5:52 Speaker 01 think we should even have an aircraft carrier at all. At least, that is what the Impoundment Control Act of 1974 says. It's the law that controls the president's impoundment power. But Trump thinks that law is unconstitutional.
6:08 Speaker 03 This disaster of a law is clearly unconstitutional, a blatant violation of the separation of powers.
6:15 Speaker 01 President Trump and his team, including the person who is now general counsel at the Office of Management and Budget, which is the agency that oversees the release of federal funds, say that impoundment is an inherent power of the president because, they say, presidents have historically exercised this power. They have been pointing out what they call hundreds of years of examples of presidents impounding funds before Congress, like, reined in the practice. Basically, they're saying that impoundment was like, kind of chill in the early days.
6:49 Speaker 04 Well, I'm not sure I'd say chill, but I, but I, um...
6:52 Speaker 01 You wouldn't? You sound like that's like definitely something you would say. Zachary Price is a law professor at the University of California College of Law in San Francisco, who has written about historical empowerment practices, including examples that Trump's team has been citing. So we will start with what is likely the most high-profile instance of empowerment in 1803 with Thomas Jefferson. Congress had appropriated up to $50,000 to build 15 gunboats in the Mississippi, because the US thought that it might have to fight France over the Mississippi River. But after Congress appropriated the gunboat money, things took a turn with France.
7:37 Speaker 04 Jefferson thought the threat that had warranted this project had disappeared. So he didn't spend the money, didn't build the ships, always didn't build all of them, and then just told Congress in his annual message when they came back, you know, here's what I did, and, you know, this is why.
7:51 Speaker 01 Was Congress just meeting a lot less often in the 1800s? And so they went away for like months and months, and he was like, I don't know what to tell you, like, things are different and we don't need all these gunboats anymore?
8:01 Speaker 04 Yeah, certainly in the very early republic, Congress would come for a session, and then everyone would go home, back to their states.
8:09 Speaker 01 Yeah, it's 1803. Congress was meeting once a year. And after Congress voted for the gunboats and then went home, this big thing happened. The US bought Louisiana from France and a bunch of other land, the Louisiana Purchase. So France was no longer going to be near US territory, no longer on the Mississippi. And we were cool with France now. We weren't gonna go to war with them anymore. So Jefferson is like, okay, well, I'm not gonna build those gunboats in the Mississippi then. Trump's team has specifically pointed to this gunboat funding example to say, see, the president does have the power to not spend money. But...
8:50 Speaker 01 Here's the thing about this Thomas Jefferson gunboat example. Zachary says Congress never told the president he had to spend $50,000 on 15 gunboats.
9:03 Speaker 04 Right. So that one, the law just said you can spend up to X amount on this purpose. But the law didn't say you must spend at least this much. It said no more than.
9:14 Speaker 01 Yeah, the actual law said Thomas Jefferson could order, quote, "a number not exceeding 15 gunboats" using, quote, "a sum not exceeding $50,000." So baked into the law, it was always optional.
9:30 Speaker 04 So a lot of examples have that sort of character. And that's not really, Jefferson would say, "I'm just faithfully executing the statute." Or at least you can understand what he's doing that way.
9:39 Speaker 01 So you're saying that all the examples of times that presidents used impoundment, there was always some little language that was like a little bit more like, "You don't have to spend all this money. You just can spend up to this amount."
9:51 Speaker 04 It's not always quite as clear as Jefferson.
9:53 Speaker 01 Okay.
9:54 Speaker 04 But you know, you do have a pattern of examples sort of like that.
9:57 Speaker 01 Historically, Zachary says, presidents weren't making the argument that they have the constitutional power to override Congress and impound funds.
10:07 Speaker 04 Generally, presidents weren't really making that argument. They're instead involved in a kind of back and forth with Congress.
10:13 Speaker 01 Zachary says presidents would just kind of be like, "Come on, Congress. Let me do this." And then Congress would give in. Like, there was spending for rivers and harbors that Ulysses S. Grant thought was wasteful. There was money for a weapons program that John F. Kennedy didn't want to spend after World War II. But in both cases, after some controversy, Congress just gave in to the presidents. So in that way, yeah, Zachary says, there was this like tacit approval by Congress to sometimes not spend money. But it's not like there was a place where all the rules were spelled out around this one way or another. That didn't happen until Richard Nixon became president. Because Richard Nixon took impoundments to a whole new level.
10:58 Speaker 05 Well, the distinction with Nixon is also the frequency and the scope at which he impounded funds. I mean, in 1973, he impounded nearly one-third of all discretionary spending.
11:08 Speaker 01 Rachel Snyderman is the Managing Director of Economic Policy at the Bipartisan Policy Center. And days before Trump's second inauguration, she published this big Empowerments 101 explainer.
11:21 Speaker 05 And really refresher of, you know, what are the real checks and balances when it comes to the federal budget process as we head into a very busy year for fiscal policy and of course, a new administration.
11:33 Speaker 01 The thing that made Richard Nixon's empowerment practice so distinct was really the scale and the scope. Nixon wasn't using empowerment like here and there. He was using empowerment to subvert Congress's will. Like Congress had approved billions of dollars to send to states to build sewage treatment plants. Nixon didn't want that, so he withheld the money. Nixon impounded housing assistance money, community development money, disaster assistance, and eventually, the people and states who were entitled to the money that Nixon was withholding sued Nixon in a bunch of courts.
12:11 Speaker 05 When he impounded funds, there were several court challenges that went all the way up to the Supreme Court. And the courts were repeatedly upholding the fact that the president did not have the authority to unilaterally make decisions about spending.
12:25 Speaker 01 The Supreme Court case was specifically about the sewage treatment plant money that states were supposed to receive from the federal government. The Supreme Court said that the total amount that Congress had appropriated for this had to be spent, not just any amount, the total amount, because that was the language of the law. All nine justices agreed. Meanwhile, while all this is playing out, Congress is like, all right, I think we gotta get some real ground rules for empowerment now. And they passed the Empowerment Control Act of 1974, which, you know, controls how presidents can impound money. You can impound funds.
13:01 Speaker 05 Yeah.
13:02 Speaker 01 But it's not that like impoundment is not allowed act, right? It's just like it's allowed, but like in this controlled way.
13:09 Speaker 05 Yeah, so they cannot do it alone. The president must, they must go through the process and work with Congress.
13:17 Speaker 01 Under the Impoundment Control Act post Nixon, there are now two ways a president can withhold money that Congress has appropriated. Just two ways. The first way is called the deferral process. The president can temporarily defer payments, but with a catch.
13:34 Speaker 05 The president can choose to defer, temporarily delay certain spending. If they have the explicit intent that they are going to spend all of that funding within the fiscal year, they just don't quite know when.
13:47 Speaker 01 One example of spending that can get deferred is disaster assistance money. So we know that hurricane season tends to be towards the end of the fiscal year in September. So maybe you want to hold off on spending too much disaster money early on so that you have some leftover around hurricane season when you might need it, right? That's a deferral. The second way a president can withhold funds post Nixon is through something called the rescissions process. They're rescinding the money. Basically, a president goes to Congress and says, here's all the money I don't want to spend that you find people already approved. Congress then has 45 days to look over the president's proposal.
14:29 Speaker 05 If Congress chooses to do nothing or does not approve that package as a whole or in part, that funding must then be released to federal agencies and spent.
14:41 Speaker 01 So Congress decides still.
14:42 Speaker 05 Congress decides, yes. And throughout this entire time, the Government Accountability Office is kind of serving as the external watchdog to make sure that this is happening.
14:52 Speaker 01 And Trump knows how this process is supposed to work, says Rachel, because he followed this exact process. In 2018, when Trump wanted to rescind billions of dollars, he notified Congress. Congress reviewed it all, but then chose not to approve it. And many presidents have impounded funds this way through this process.
15:13 Speaker 05 President Trump is not alone in exercising this authority. George H. W. Bush utilized this authority. President Clinton, President Reagan did too. So there really is precedent.
15:23 Speaker 01 This time around, though. Trump did not notify Congress. There was no rescissions proposal. So to some legal scholars, the fact that Trump is not following the normal process is about something bigger.
15:40 Speaker 06 He's clearly after something more than just restraining this funding. He's seeking to make a point about inherent presidential authority.
15:52 Speaker 01 After the break, how Trump is testing the limits of presidential power and what constitutional scholars and the courts are saying about it.
16:04 Speaker 00 Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors.
16:08 Speaker 02 This message comes from LinkedIn. As a small business owner, you wear many hats. You're the owner, the marketer, the seller, the hire. With LinkedIn, you have the tools to help you boost your visibility, find prospective customers, and find the best team for your small business, all in one place. So while LinkedIn can't hang up all of your hats, it makes it easier to wear them all. Learn more at LinkedIn.com/PlanetMoneyShow.
16:35 Speaker 00 This episode's sponsor is HubSpot, which offers the following message. What if instead of updating your CRM, your CRM updated you? No catching up on manual edits, no more guesswork. HubSpot's self-updating CRM keeps your customer context current and helps you understand what to do next. So, marketing builds more demand, sales wins more deals, and customers keep coming back. Learn more at hubspot.com.
17:01 Speaker 02 This message comes from Apollo. Whether it's funding growth, modernizing operations, or strengthening their balance sheet, CEOs and CFOs need more than capital. They need a financing partner with the scale, flexibility, and certainty to help them execute. Apollo provides access to long-duration capital and a broad range of financing capabilities, helping companies develop customized financing solutions designed at an efficient cost of capital. Learn more at Apollo.com/capital.
17:32 Speaker 01 You may remember that in 2019, President Trump withheld money meant for Ukraine without going through Congress. This was when Trump was trying to get the Ukrainian president to investigate the Biden family. Trump was found to have violated the Empowerment Control Act back then, and the money was eventually released. Now, in his second term, Trump is saying, "Yeah, that whole Empowerment Control Act thing, I think it's unconstitutional." Days into Trump's second term, his administration announced that they were temporarily going to not spend billions and billions and up to trillions of dollars on a bunch of stuff that, you know,
18:14 Speaker 01 Democrats and Republicans agreed together to fund. He announced the funding freeze without ever submitting a proposal to Congress, and a bunch of lawsuits followed. Nonprofits have sued, states have sued. States have sued specifically over just the medical research funding. Health organizations that receive funding for USAID programs sued. So to some, this was not like a Thomas Jefferson-style, saving money on some Mississippi gunboats kind of empowerment. This was more like what Nixon tried to do, using empowerments as a broader policy tool, withholding money for policies he disagreed with. Now, a lot of the Trump funding freezes have been paused
18:58 Speaker 01 while the courts sort everything out, just like how it went down when Nixon used empowerments this way. But what Trump's team is arguing that Nixon's team did not argue in court is that the president should have this special power to not spend. They're saying, yes, there's a ceiling on spending. The president cannot spend more than Congress appropriates, but they don't think there's a floor. For this, I called up a law and economics professor. Do your students call you Professor Super?
19:30 Speaker 06 Uh, yes.
19:31 Speaker 01 Nice. Wade, say your name and title.
19:33 Speaker 06 Uh, I'm David Super and I teach law at Georgetown.
19:37 Speaker 01 David Super studies the Constitution, teaches legislation, and he actually had the Empowerment Control Act on his syllabus when all the funding freezes happened.
19:47 Speaker 06 So, as a teacher, I couldn't be more grateful for their timing with this. As a lawyer and a citizen, I'm troubled by it.
19:56 Speaker 01 So, okay, what about this constitutional claim that the Trump team is making? Is there a place in the Constitution that says, like, "Yeah, yeah, you can't spend more, but like, yeah, you could spend less"? Or is there a place in the Constitution that says, like, "You cannot spend more and you also cannot spend less"? Like, is there validity to their claims? That like, it doesn't say in the Constitution that there's a floor, which is like what the argument is, right? Like, the ceiling is there, don't spend more, but is the floor there?
20:25 Speaker 06 Yeah, the floor's there. The floor's there in the laws that say you must spend this money. And in the Constitution, it says you must take care that the laws be faithfully executed. You're not taking care that the laws be faithfully executed if the law says, "Spend a million dollars," and you refuse to do so.
20:41 Speaker 01 David, and a long, long line of legal scholars and judges appointed by Republicans, by Richard Nixon and Donald Trump, have said that the Constitution does give Congress the power to set even a spending floor. Supreme Court Justice Brett Kavanaugh, who Trump appointed, back when he was an appellate judge, he wrote that, quote, "Even the president does not have unilateral authority to refuse to spend." But Trump's legal team has said that the Supreme Court hasn't provided the final word on whether a president has constitutional empowerment power, like inherent empowerment power just because he's the president.
21:24 Speaker 01 They say that even that one Nixon ruling was more specific to like, the particulars of Nixon's case. And David Super agrees that the Supreme Court did not rule on overall empowerment power, but only because, again, Nixon's team wasn't making that argument in court. So, that's the legal stuff. In terms of the money stuff, like the money that the Trump administration has frozen or attempted to freeze, here's what's happening there. Several judges have at least temporarily blocked just about all of those actions. Some of these judges are Trump-appointed judges, judges, at least one of the judges.
22:04 Speaker 06 Yes, he's been losing in front of Trump judges, Biden judges. It really hasn't mattered.
22:12 Speaker 01 These judges have said that the Trump administration needed to unfreeze the money, at least for now. So the money is supposed to be released. The White House even rescinded their initial memo declaring the pause on federal grants and loans. But there are a lot of reports that money is still being held up. One judge said that the Trump administration was still not releasing the funds, which violated a court order.
22:37 Speaker 06 The judge in Rhode Island found that they had violated his order in numerous respects and has issued a supplemental order admonishing them to start complying right away and specifically condemning some of the actions they've taken and some of the arguments they've made to defend their actions.
22:58 Speaker 01 State agencies in Pennsylvania still, as of today, have not been able to access $2.1 billion in grant funding that was suspended or restricted. This is according to the governor's office, even though, as they pointed out, multiple federal judges have ordered the Trump administration to unfreeze this funding. Several nonprofits across the country also have tried to access their federal funding, only to find out it's not there.
23:27 Speaker 06 Indeed, I talk to people all the time who tell me their funding is frozen still. Indeed, some people whose funding was frozen after the orders were issued against that. So if the administration is trying to comply, they're not trying very hard and they're not trying very effectively.
23:45 Speaker 01 David Super says that these actions, for him, rise to the level of a constitutional crisis. We did reach out to the White House and to the Office of Management and Budget to ask why some federal funding is still not being released and to get their response to what David Super and Zachary Price had to say about the history of impoundments. The White House and OMB did not respond. But the White House Press Secretary has said that it's actually the courts and the judges stopping Trump's executive actions that are the ones causing the constitutional crisis.
24:32 Speaker 01 If you want even more history and legal arguments around impoundments, check out our latest newsletter. There's a link in our show notes, and you can subscribe at npr.org/planetmoneynewsletter. This episode was produced by Willa Rubin and edited by Meg Kramer. It was fact-checked by Sam Yellowhorse Kessler and engineered by Robert Rodriguez. Alex Goldmark is our executive producer. I'm Sarah Gonzalez. This is NPR. Thanks for listening.
25:06 Speaker 02 Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors.
Previous The Big Government Money Pipe Freeze Next The rise and fall of Long Term Capital Management Page updated November 3, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated