Pod Insights Pharmacy Podcast Network Herbal Support for Chronic Lyme Disease with Richard Mandelbaum | Holistic Pharmacy Podcast About this episode Today I am back with one of my herbal teachers to talk about herbal and holistic approaches to managing Lyme disease. It is a topic that is becoming ever more relevant as the medical community has been coming to the realization that there is such a thing as chronic Lyme, where acute measures such as antibiotics fall short. This is where herbal support can really shine in helping to peel back the layers that are causing disharmony and reestablish a healthy foundation for health. Richard Mandelbaum RH is a clinical herbalist with a private practice, offering personalized health consultations, online and in person in the southern Catskills, NY. Richard has been an avid student of our native flora for close to forty years, and in addition to seeing clients he teaches classes in clinical herbal medicine, field botany, and phytochemistry. He is a co-founder and core instructor at the ArborVitae School of Traditional Herbalism and is on the faculty at David Winston’s Center for Herbal Studies and the Won Institute of Graduate Studies. Richard has been a Registered Herbalist since 2003 and was a member of the American Herbalists Guild board of directors from 2012 to 2018. He lives with his wife Gabrielle and his daughter Rose in their straw bale home in Forestburgh, NY. You can learn more about Richard, including articles, podcast interviews, etc. at Richard Mandelbaum RH. See our past episode about whole planet care and Gaia theory here and my episode with Dr. Christine Arseneau on this topic here. Connect with Richard via:Email: [email protected] Website: Richard Mandelbaum RH
Transcript 0:05 Speaker 00 You are listening to the global network of podcasters dedicated to the pharmacy profession. Welcome to the Pharmacy Podcast Network.
0:27 Speaker 01 Hello and welcome to the Holistic Pharmacy Podcast. I'm your host Marina Books of and I'm a functional medicine pharmacist in New York. I'm also a clinical herbalist and an integrative health coach specializing in mindfulness and empowerment. I'm on a mission to transform the way we approach healthcare by bridging the wisdom of traditional medicine with modern practice. And in this podcast, I will be highlighting guests who do just that. I'm constantly inspired by them and I know you will be as well. Hi, everybody. Welcome back to the Holistic Pharmacy Podcast and I have a returning guest today.
1:08 Speaker 01 His name is Richard Mandelbaum and he was my teacher at Arbor Vite. He's a clinical herbalist with a private practice offering personalized health consultation online and in person in the Southern Catskills, New York. He has been an avid student of our need of flora for close to 40 years. And in addition to seeing clients, he teaches classes in clinical herbal medicine, field botany and phytochemistry. He's a co-founder and co-instructor at the Arbor Vite School of Traditional Herbalism and is on the faculty at David Winston's Center for Herbal Studies and the ONE Institute of Graduate Studies.
1:46 Speaker 01 He has been a registered herbalist since 2003 and was a member of the American Herbalist Guild Board of Directors from 2012 to 2018. He lives with his wife Aprilia and his daughter Rose in their Straw Bale home in Forestburg, New York. And I will have all the links of how to get in touch with Rich later on in the show notes. And without further ado, welcome back, Richard.
2:08 Speaker 02 Thank you. Thank you, Marina. Happy to talk to you today.
2:12 Speaker 01 Yeah, so today we wanted to tackle some of the topics that we ran out of time from last time, and I think one of the big ones that we had wanted to discuss was Lyme, Lyme disease, right? It's kind of a biggie, more and more people are talking about chronic Lyme, the literature is there, the cases are there, conventional medicine is finally starting, I think, to see that it's there and it needs to be treated and addressed. So, um, let's talk about it. What, what did, you know, what kind of got you into this work of working with Lyme?
2:46 Speaker 02 Yeah, um, thanks for that. Um, so for me personally, uh, I've had Lyme twice myself, um, the second time more recently and caught it pretty quickly. Actually, in both cases, I was fortunate to catch it pretty quickly, but the first time, which goes back, oh, uh, over, over 20 years now, um, uh, I got a particularly bad case, particularly of facial palsy from the Lyme that took a long time to improve and like a pretty aggressive approach.
3:27 Speaker 02 So that's kind of a secondary outcome sometimes that's not uncommon with Lyme and some of the co-infections. As we talk about Lyme, sometimes I use Lyme kind of as a shorthand to include the whole spectrum of other tick-borne illnesses, so-called co-infections, Anaplasma, Lichea, Bartonella, Babesia, the ones most common in, in our part of the world. But in any event, um, sometimes people think, oh, I dealt with it myself, I had to address it with my own health, therefore I wanted to like reach out and help other people. And that's a nice story, but that's not what happened. Really, it came to me. And maybe that was part of it. And certainly, some people
4:10 Speaker 02 sometimes ask if I've ever dealt with it personally, because they find that meaningful, that they want someone to understand and is compassionate. And I don't think you have to have gone through something yourself for that to be the case. But, but really, it was no conscious choice of my own to focus on working with Lyme. It just started, and I kept working with people. And we don't have enough practitioners who are both knowledgeable and affordable. That's sort of threading that needle is tough out there, who work with Lyme and chronic Lyme, and eventually just started working with it enough that
4:52 Speaker 02 got a little bit of a reputation, if we can call it that, for working with it, kind of known for that. I work with all sorts of things in my practice, not limited to Lyme at all. But it's a pretty high percentage, I would say, of what I work with. And of course, you know, you have to address, and I'm sure this is what we'll get into, you have to address the whole person with chronic Lyme. And so, in some cases, the Lyme is central to that approach. And honestly, in other cases, it's not, and needs to be de-emphasized over other things to address, or anything in between. But individualizing is key. Anyway,
5:34 Speaker 02 it was accidental, or at least not conscious on my part. But now, I'm in it and work with it pretty regularly.
5:45 Speaker 01 Yeah, definitely. I completely agree with something that befalls yourself, or your family, or a loved one, that gets you to have an experience, or research it, or understand certain aspects, and go down rabbit holes. So it can certainly be very helpful to speak to people and go to a practitioner that has had success, personal success, and a story to share, and also can relate and empathize and understand what people are going through. So I think that's important. So what do you feel like is the most challenging aspect of working through Lyme, you know, both personally and professionally?
6:26 Speaker 02 Oh, can I give maybe two or three?
6:30 Speaker 01 Yes, please.
6:32 Speaker 02 One is what I was alluding to already. It has to be individualized and there are so many cookie cutter approaches. Oh, you have Lyme, do this. And as you know, as other holistic practitioners know, and holistic and alternative are not the same thing. Just want to say that off the bat. And you can use herbs or supplements or other alternative approaches in a way that's holistic or in a way that's not holistic. And for me, a fundamental part of being holistic in my approach is individualizing things. You have to pay attention to the individual. Certain herbs, for example, that work with 80% of people cause adverse reactions in the other 20%.
7:13 Speaker 02 And sometimes people are told to power through it, which is, can be a mistake. We could talk about Herx reactions and things like that. The, so individualizing, crucial in terms of one of the challenges. Another challenge is once someone has chronic Lyme, so we're not talking about, oops, I got bitten by a tick two weeks ago or yesterday, but, but this has become deep seated now and chronic. So in that context, another challenge is it's a slog.
7:49 Speaker 02 It is like you have to be ready to dedicate time and as difficult as this is, I don't say this easily, be patient that it's going to take time to pull yourself up out of that hole. And improvement within months, sometimes quicker, but sometimes I'll work with people for a year or two, or then, you know, gradually less and less as time goes on. But there's no quick fix here. And along with that,
8:25 Speaker 02 A need to reexamine and deconstruct the ideological perspective on what it is we're trying to accomplish in the first place, and that can be a real challenge. So if, and again, we're talking about chronic Lyme as opposed to something more recent as an infection, if we only view that, or primarily view that as an infection that needs to be killed off, what we end up doing is using a very depleting approach, even
9:06 Speaker 02 if it's herbal, a very depleting approach that never really pulls somebody out of the hole they're in, and you get into this vicious cycle of symptomatic relief, followed by relapse, followed by more symptomatic relief, followed by relapse, without ever breaking free of that cycle. And the need for nourishment is huge. The need to support a healthy, balanced immune system function, nervous system function, nutritional support, gut health support, making sure sleep is there, emotional and
9:47 Speaker 02 mental health, all of these things are actually what pull you out of it eventually. And attacking the infection is only a part of it. And so sometimes, whether it's alternative or conventional, I find there's 90% focus on attacking, and people never really improve in a deeper, more substantive way. So, anyway, you asked for one challenge, I gave you half a dozen, but those are some of the ones I would think of.
10:25 Speaker 01 Yeah, I think that last point is really important because you see Western medicine, conventional medicine, really go on the attack a lot of the times on any disease, right, like war on cancer and let's, you know, use antibiotics for everything and let's just kill the germ, but they often miss the terrain, right, the germ versus terrain theory that we always talk about in holistic approaches. So how does this concept play a role when you try to create a treatment plan for somebody with chronic Lyme?
11:00 Speaker 02 Yeah, and I'm so glad you brought up germ versus terrain and I sometimes think we should just call it germ and terrain, right, because they're both true. So we can sometimes swing the pendulum too far in another direction as a, as a reaction. And there are times which are vitally important where you view Lyme and the other tick-borne illnesses as infections, that you do want to use approaches that are a little more attacking, if you will, in their activity, more antimicrobial activity, for example. But a lot of those herbs, and again, it includes herbs, so we can talk about antibiotics and there's a
11:44 Speaker 02 place for that, but there's a place to be deliberate and careful about that, too. But even some of the herbs, like let's take Japanese knotweed, for example. A lot of people are just taking Japanese knotweed or Andrographis, or we could Decatsclaw, every day for months and months, if not longer, to address their Lyme. And those herbs are depleting. Traditionally, Japanese knotweed in Eastern Asian medicine, as an example, is a depleting herb. You actually
12:24 Speaker 02 have to be careful using it if someone's overall vitality, their overall qi is depleted and deficient. And so even within an herbal context, we have to be really careful not to overdo that part of the approach. That said, I'm absolutely not rejecting that part of the approach. That part of the approach is vital as well, but it needs to be deliberate, cycled in and out. And at the same time, like we're saying, more nourishing approaches to just get you out of that, out of that cycle. It's interesting because there are some people
13:08 Speaker 02 who come to me and where a chronic Lyme might be one of the main things or the principal thing they want me to work with them on addressing. And in some cases, we dive right in and and use some of the Lyme protocols, if you will, which, you know, I mentioned a couple herbs just now, but we can talk, there's a lot more to it. In other cases, honestly, I have had some people in my practice where we end up never doing that because they end up feeling better gradually over time without it. It's like, well, should we use those Lyme
13:49 Speaker 02 herbs, quote unquote? It's like, well, actually, you're feeling well. So I don't think so. And so we kind of are circling back to the need to really individualize. If somebody's very depleted when they come to me, I usually don't go for the stronger Lyme herbs immediately. I like to nourish and build someone's strength back up a little bit first for a couple of months. I mean, it depends on the person, but let's just say before we even consider that. But these are judgment calls. Working with Lyme is about judgment calls from beginning
14:31 Speaker 02 to end all the time and paying, like I said, paying close attention to the person and being willing to step back and say, oops, no, that's a dead end for you. That wasn't the right choice for you. Let's go that way instead. And and being very responsive that way to how someone is doing is is really important, too, I find. So approaching it with humility, I think, is really important, too.
14:58 Speaker 01 Yeah, you bring up really great points around that holistic approach and being responsive. And it really doesn't differ than treating anything else. Not that this is medical advice, right? And we're not saying that we are treating or diagnosing anything. But when we have that diagnosis of Lyme, right? It may make us think that there's some protocol that we need to be following that takes care of the Lyme. But what you're saying is that you still have to look at it in context of the person and everything else that they have going on. And then figure out what's the step by step approach? What's the order of operation, et cetera? So I completely get that it's individualized.
15:38 Speaker 01 My question to you is, is there ever a role for, you know, the more aggressive, perhaps prescription antimicrobial regimen approach when somebody gets diagnosed with Lyme, let's say?
15:52 Speaker 02 Hundred percent. And of course, with Lyme, you'll get every opinion under the sun. And my joke is, you get 10 herbalists in a room and you get 11 different opinions. But absolutely, there's a place for that. Particularly when Lyme is caught early. And you use the word diagnosis, Marina, just to say, that's a whole other can of worms. There's a lot of Lyme that goes underdiagnosed or undiagnosed because of the fallibility of the blood work and labs we use. That's a discussion in and of itself. But it is important for people to know that those tests are not infallible.
16:37 Speaker 02 And just to briefly say this, and then I'll answer your question more or address that more. The, what I like to say about the labs that are used for diagnosis, for diagnostic purposes, is that they never actually tell you if you have Lyme or not. What they tell you is the probability of whether you have Lyme or not. And I think that's an important reframing. That said, back to the point you brought up, which is really important. Absolutely, there's a place for more aggressive antimicrobial protocols. So let's take antibiotics, for instance, and doxycycline is the standard,
17:19 Speaker 02 but others come into play for different reasons, different times, different co-infections, etc. Certainly, I fully believe that for the vast majority of people, the if you have, if you have been infected or have a good suspicion that you have been, right? All the clues are adding up and it's fairly recent. You absolutely should have four weeks of doxycycline. Now, there are herbs and supplements, vitamins, nutritional support, other things that I think you should be doing probiotics at the same time, continued
17:59 Speaker 02 afterwards. So it doesn't end there. But I, I, I think, and again, there's always exceptions. There are people very sensitive to antibiotics. Of course, maybe switch to a different one. But there are always exceptions. But for most people, honestly, that would always be my advice. And that would be, it's a personal choice, but that would be what I would do for myself, my own family, is if you think you've caught it early like that. And herbally, in terms of the herbs that have a stronger antimicrobial activity, there's absolutely a crucial place for them in the protocol, too. But what I like to do is cycle those
18:44 Speaker 02 in and out. So you're doing, let's say, six weeks of a stronger kind of attack mode.
18:52 Speaker 02 And then you pause and you see how the person's doing and you're nourishing along the way. And you may need to keep going with that a bit longer, or you may a couple of months later need to repeat that. That varies individually. But that, that's an incredibly important part of the protocol. And again, herbs like Japanese knotweed, like Endrographis, like cat's claw. Isatis, bone set, different herbs come into play teasel. But then there are herbs that are more nourishing, like sarsaparilla, which is a key herb when it comes to Lyme. And interestingly, it lives on both sides of that equation of attack and
19:36 Speaker 02 nourish, which makes it really useful. So the point is, what I would, what I think is, you absolutely, the vast majority of people do benefit from and do need, in fact, some of those stronger remedies. But they should be used judiciously and deliberately and not in an ongoing, continuous way. If you need those in an ongoing, continuous way, there's some deeper work that needs to be done that hasn't been done yet. And you'll, you'll never dig yourself out doing that. So both sides equally important. We don't have to reject
20:15 Speaker 02 either one. It's, it's about tailoring it to the person and, and, and managing all of it in a balanced way.
20:26 Speaker 01 Yeah, thank you for that. And a quick follow up to that, I have heard of alternative or naturopathic doctors doing IV antibiotics over periods of time and also apotherapy. So what are your thoughts on that?
20:42 Speaker 02 Yeah, so interesting. Where I start to get a bit more wary of antibiotic therapy, when it becomes IV, when it becomes three or four different antibiotics, when it's like six months, eight months, nine months of it, you're starting to talk about a lot of damage to the microbiome at that point. You know, four weeks of doxy could do that too. But for most people, it's okay, you know, compared to the possibility of having a Lyme infection that's not being addressed, right? If you weigh those two against each
21:21 Speaker 02 other. I, I get a lot more wary when it's continued, ongoing approach that's that strong. And I'm not as convinced that it's a good idea. I do, for, for some people, it's very clear they get symptomatic relief from it. But my question is, is it really helping them to dig out of that hole over the longer term? So it's, it's, there's kind of ironic twists with Lyme. You can have a Lyme literate doctor practitioner, but that doesn't mean they're more holistic. It means they're more knowledgeable about Lyme, which is crucial, but it doesn't, you know, you can have a Lyme
22:06 Speaker 02 literate doctor who just pummels somebody with antibiotics for three years. So that's something to, it's really important for someone with one of these challenges like chronic Lyme, to find a practitioner who matches their own perspective and viewpoint. Of course, results are what matter ultimately, but there are so many even just thoughts about it. And again, if somebody feels like they're certain of what to do in every case out of the gate, that would be enough to make me wary, to be honest. I think we have to be humble and
22:43 Speaker 02 recognize how little we understand about Lyme. And in terms of other therapies, there's ozone therapy, there's apotherapy, like you're saying, apotherapy can be quite helpful for rheumatic and arthritic conditions. I don't know that it's addressing the underlying Lyme, but addressing someone's pain, someone's discomfort, someone's lack of mobility is all crucial to helping them recover as well. So certainly I'm in favor. And there was a, an interesting study published a few years ago that showed that there are
23:31 Speaker 02 Genetic fragments, DNA fragments of Borrelia burgdorferi, which is the primary species of spirochete that causes Lyme. There's actually a few others in the mix, but that that you can actually detect in the joints of people with chronic arthritic symptoms from having had Lyme disease. So there, there's now definitive scientific evidence that this is real. I think anyone who, at this point, is still saying chronic Lyme is not real is ignoring the science on it.
24:14 Speaker 02 But another interesting irony in all this is if you go to the CDC, which does not recognize chronic Lyme, they also are wary of long-term IV antibiotic therapy. So in some strange twist, I'm more in agreement with that specific part of their opinion, despite the fact that it's based on a denial of reality. But then also, one of the things they point out
24:43 Speaker 02 is that you might have like a post-disease syndrome where you're experiencing inflammation, other, which is immune-mediated, other neurological symptoms that may not actually be an active infection. And I actually think there's some truth to that, too, which is why some people never need actually that attack mood to get better. They actually need their immune system reminded how to calm itself down.
25:15 Speaker 02 So as in all things, it gets complicated, but there's, there's, there's a place for all of this. But, but some of it can get to extreme levels, I think. And I would say continued, ongoing antibiotic therapy is one of the things that I, I'm pretty wary of personally.
25:39 Speaker 01 Yeah, I completely agree with that too, because even like you said, short dosing courses and interventions can do a lot of harm, a lot of damage. And it's very hard to rebuild what you have lost once there's damage there in the microbiome. And you know, even like through lineages of the human that all the species that we have probably lost over the couple last generations as we were doing, you know, no longer breastfeeding as much, no longer having vaginal delivery as much. So the biome has been changing and probably not in a good way.
26:22 Speaker 01 And now antibiotics are just routinely used. And each course that you have to take or a tool that you have to take can potentially throw you over the edge. And so it's, it's very, it's something to really keep in mind. I think the pros versus the cons and also trying to be on the more like preventative side of not having to take antibiotics, not getting to a point where there's this need or this question. And that's difficult to do, right? But let's, let's talk a little bit about the prevention. Like what would be your best tips about not having Lyme infections or other co-infections, how to avoid that? And then also, if you do see a tick, what should you do?
27:07 Speaker 02 Yes, let's talk about that. And also, if there's any time, I'd love to share a little more about mental health aspects of chronic Lyme, because it gets sometimes not discussed and it can be quite traumatic for people going through that. But yeah, in terms of prevention, I so much agree. And one of the interesting things about Lyme is that we don't actually know.
27:36 Speaker 02 What percentage, even vaguely, of people who are infected with Lyme, infected with Borrelia burgdorferi, actually ever get symptomatic or sick? In other words, it might be a strong majority of people infected who get sick, or it might be very low. And the reason we don't know that is, first of all, the tests are fallible, like we said earlier, but then also on top of that, you generally only get tested for Lyme if you have a suspicion that it might be the case. And so, we actually don't even know, for example, back to germ and terrain,
28:17 Speaker 02 it may be that only a very small percentage of people, quote unquote, infected, ever get sick. So, prevention, so key that you brought up, nourish your terrain. Now, we're all in different places. We don't get to always choose when something tragic or traumatic or stressful happens to us, right? Some of us are more fortunate than others, so we don't want to create like an illusion that we're always in control of how we're doing health-wise. People have different access financially and otherwise to healthy food. And so, but we do the best we can. And so, the best we can do with food, with sleep, with immune system health, with nervous system health,
29:01 Speaker 02 with microbiome health, as you're pointing out, the better we're gonna do. And one of the interesting things that I've started really paying attention to with chronic Lyme is that it's very often a one-two or one-two-three punch, meaning, most people that I talk to, who are suffering from chronic Lyme, lingering Lyme, "Oh, maybe there's mold toxicity, maybe there's long COVID, maybe there is heavy metal, a heavy metal load." Something that, very frequently, something emotionally stressful
29:45 Speaker 02 or challenging or traumatic happened, leading up to this. Not always, none of those things are always true, but very often. So, it changes our perspective on, like, preventing Lyme. It's addressing, just like we were both saying earlier, Our health as a whole and not just like, oh, how do we prevent this bacterium from getting in our bloodstream? There's a, there's a, there's a value to that, but that's missing a lot, I think, if we just kind of laser focus on that. That said, how do we prevent? How do we reduce the likelihood of the bacterium during our bloodstream?
30:25 Speaker 02 First of all, there are natural tick repellents, natural-based repellents, you have to keep in mind, have a very short efficacy window. So if you have a very effective essential oil-based repellent, which they can be very effective, and even the CDC recognizes that some of the essential oils are as effective as D, but their efficacy only lasts about a half hour. So you have to keep reapplying throughout the day to really keep up the efficacy. And then, the biggest, most important thing, hands down, in my opinion, the most important thing, is a full-body tick check at the end of every day.
31:07 Speaker 02 And even if you haven't been outside that day, if you live in a Lyme area, and what is a Lyme area? Increasingly, it's anywhere on the planet. I mean, I've had clients in parts of the US or other countries where there's not supposed to be Lyme, and it turns out they have it. We get on planes, we carry ticks all over the planet, so, so you have to keep it in mind. But that full-body tick check, if you have someone who can help look the places you can't readily see, even better, crucial, because the statistical likelihood of the infection having been passed to you is very, very low if you catch the tick the same day. It's, it's the ones that we missed, and oops, this has been on me for a day or two or three,
31:52 Speaker 02 then, then we're more likely to be in trouble. Not every tick is infected. If you catch it, if you, if you find a tick and you think you missed it and it's been on you a while, you can send it to a lab to be tested. You can take a single day's worth of doxy, which has been shown to help prevent it if you catch it that early. Or you can jump on herbs as well. And vitamin D is crucial. B vitamins are often helpful.
32:23 Speaker 02 Golden seal can be helpful. So there's a number of things to do. But that tick check at the end of the day, and they can be quite small when they're in the nymph stage, to look really carefully, I think is actually the best. And of course, keeping our immune system strong. So to name an herb, for instance, astragalus, wonderful herb, along with medicinal mushrooms, shiitake, reishi, things like that, turkey tail, to keep our immune system as strong as we can. Again, nutritionally, vitamin C, vitamin D, zinc, is going to be really helpful. That said, just a note about astragalus, because a lot of the functional medicine world gets this wrong. And there are a lot of Lyme products and formulas out there.
33:08 Speaker 02 And even not just functional medicine, some in the herbal world get this wrong. Astragalus is, should not be used when you're actively fighting off an infection. So if you're, if you're using Japanese knotweed and cat's claw and et cetera, astragalus should not be in the mix at that stage. It's a nourishing herb. So it should be used both before preventively and then in the rebuilding, strengthening stages of a protocol. And I'm amazed that just is all over the place right now. There are Lyme formulas mixing those herbs together. And so, no, those, those should be used at different stages, actually. Anyway, I'm digressing a little bit, but those are some thoughts on, on prevention.
33:53 Speaker 01 Yeah. And then if you do spot a tick, you're supposed to take it out with tweezers so you get the whole thing out. And it's pretty tough to kill, right? So you either have to light it on fire. But now the new sort of strategy is to put it in a little Ziploc baggie and send it out for testing. So that is the most surefire way to kind of see if there's any risk at all that it passed something on to you. Is that correct?
34:20 Speaker 02 Yeah, and some people mistakenly say, oh, all the ticks have Lyme or one of the co-infections. It's not true. I forget if the exact number is closer to 50%, but it's not true that they all are. And so, yeah, you know, if you spend a lot of time outdoors like I do, you can't send every tick away that you find on yourself. It's really about, oh, I think I missed this one. It's a little engorged. This might have been on me for over 24 hours, something like that. Then, then it is definitely useful to send those away and see what the, if they are in fact infected, absolutely.
35:01 Speaker 01 Yeah. So because we mentioned that it's kind of tricky to understand the diagnosis or get an accurate diagnosis of Lyme, because our ways of testing that are flawed. And again, even if you test the tick, it's unclear whether it got a chance to pass it on to you, et cetera. So when we're working with somebody that may suspect Lyme, or maybe you suspect it as a differential diagnosis, what are some of the things that you look for, some symptoms that would kind of ring off to you that, okay, maybe I should suspect Lyme?
35:37 Speaker 02 Yes, thank you for that. So Lyme is almost always a wind disharmony. That's how it would be described in Chinese medicine. It's erratic, it's unpredictable, it's moving. So for instance, arthritic symptoms, if somebody tells me, oh, yeah, this really hurts. Is it always that joint? Yeah, it's not suddenly your hip or your left knee, or then switches to your right knee. No, not really. It's like, okay, lower likelihood, we're talking about Lyme. Lyme is like, it's here, and then it's here, and then it's my hip, and then I have a good two weeks, and then it's horrible again. So very windy symptoms. Not
36:20 Speaker 02 everyone has arthritic symptoms, but that's just as an example. Sometimes people know the story, like this all started with a tick bite, but they told Me based on the blood tests, I don't have it, but I was fine beforehand. I wasn't chronically fatigued like I am now. I wasn't depressed. I, you know, mentally, so I mentioned mental health. This isn't true for everyone. Some people don't experience this. But lime can send you to dark places, nightmares, feeling like you're being overtaken, being feeling like you're not yourself anymore, having thoughts that don't feel like your own. Cognitively health, a word recall in particular, just like not being able to
37:05 Speaker 02 kind of get to the words you're thinking of. So there are definitely clues in there. And again, some people, the, the, the, creating the timeline is so crucial because some people already know, or again, you know, you can recreate that with somebody. At the same time, it's important for practitioners, I think, to always check themselves and not see something everywhere. So there are people who come to me initially thinking, oh, lime's a thing. I think we need to address and I might come to a different conclusion. I had one client, just as an example, Marina, who was experiencing all sorts of arthritic rheumatic condition
37:45 Speaker 02 symptoms, had a history of Lyme back in the past, just assumed like, oh, this is still the Lyme. I looked at her, her blood work and her uric acid levels were sky high. Well, that's not lime. You could have both. But uric acid alone will cause all sorts of red, painful, gout-like inflammation in the body and a very different approach. So we also, it's also important to kind of check ourselves and not see lime everywhere. But those are, those are some of the things that, that I would look for.
38:22 Speaker 01 Yeah, that's really helpful. Thank you, Richard. And let's also throw this question in there. This might be a big one, but let's try to keep it succinct. If you had unlimited resources and somebody came to you and you both decided and agreed based on the whole holistic picture that the person's presenting with, that Lyme is definitely part of the problem that needs to be prioritized, then what would you create as a sort of plan in order of priority for this person, including herbs or maybe like heat therapy and sweat therapy? We haven't talked about that yet. You mentioned ozone. Like, what would be the things that you would want to have on board
39:05 Speaker 01 without, again, overwhelming the person with the amount of treatment that is being thrown at them?
39:12 Speaker 02 Yeah, no, it's a good point.
39:16 Speaker 02 And I think it's important that it's practical and affordable to somebody. At the same time, I think you do have to be a little aggressive with this. You can't just sort of, you know, drink one herb in a tea per day and expect a big shift, right? So it is work, which is harder because of the society we're in. We really should have a community around us that's bringing us food and bringing us herbs. And like, you know, but instead we feeling sick have to do this for ourselves often, which is not the way it should be. That said, you mentioned heat therapy. So saunas, I think, are the best, better than hot baths or hot tubs, although that can still be helpful.
40:00 Speaker 02 But taking some diaphoretic herbs that help release to the exterior, induce healthy sweating, Yaro, BoneSet. And if someone has access to a sauna, so you said, without limitations, right? So sauna, best case scenario, as much as you can, but not to depletion, right? Not, you should not feel horrible coming in. That means you overdid it. And I think mindfulness. Practices, addressing gut health and digestion if it needs to be, making sure the person is sleeping enough. That's crucial. And when we're recovering from illness, sometimes we need to sleep more.
40:45 Speaker 02 So forget eight hours, that's hard enough, but someone might need nine or 10 for several months. Sometimes I'll recommend to people, just try getting nine a night. Now, of course, they might need help getting nine a night, right, with herbs or other things. But even if we don't need the help, sometimes we don't allow ourselves to sleep. Our culture's attitude towards sleep is incredibly dysfunctional. And so giving someone permission to sleep enough to start to recover is huge. And then I would say gentle immune system support.
41:24 Speaker 02 The medicinal mushrooms, reishi, cordyceps, which is also adaptogenic, so helping with adrenal response and stress response.
41:33 Speaker 02 Sarperilla, I mentioned as an adaptogenic herb that helps with recovery. And vitamin D, often a B complex if it's indicated, which it often is. Vitamin C, in terms of nutritional support, microbiome support, so pre and probiotic foods. Anti-inflammatory foods that are rich in sollicylates, for example, and healthy fats, moving away from the unhealthy fats. So all of that's important. And then what I would say in addition, besides just, of course, paying attention to the, this person might need this, this person might need that.
42:15 Speaker 02 Like I said, mental health is huge for some people, not there for other people, cognitive health, et cetera. But other than that, what I tend to do is I have a six-week protocol that often gets amended for the individual, but that has a series of different herbs. It's three different formulas that I rotate people through for six weeks. They're doing other stuff at the same time. And and then we pause and we reassess and sometimes we repeat that. Or sometimes, no, let's focus on nourishing.
42:54 Speaker 02 And we might return to that in a month or three months or six months or a year. Sometimes I'll get a call from someone, you know, two years later after they stopped working with me. And they're like, I'm having a relapse. Almost always something stressful happened to trigger that something happened. But but then we we address it as needed. And my goal is always to give somebody the tools they need to address it themselves as much as possible. And then other things can come up like chronic Lyme can be a can a little bit morph into a certain degree of autoimmunity. When the immune system is revved up and then doesn't know how to calm itself back down.
43:40 Speaker 02 So anti inflammatory herbs that are kind of, I'm being a little metaphorical here, like reminding the immune system how to calm itself back down. Sometimes more important or as important as like fighting an infection. Bicol, skullcap is one herb that can be really helpful for that. So anyway, those are, those are some things that often come in the mix. But any one of those might be inappropriate for a specific person.
44:09 Speaker 01 Wow, thank you so much for sharing all of that. You've mentioned so many herbs and I think whoever is listening to this podcast, you know, will will get a lot of gold from this episode, especially if you're dealing with Lyme or wanting to get exposed to new approaches for it. But I want to end with this, Richard. We kind of started this episode by talking about managing expectations as related to healing and somebody's goals. And so I'm wondering, is the goal to completely eradicate Lyme and get back to life the way it was before somebody got Lyme? Is that even possible? Or is it about finding a way to coexist?
44:54 Speaker 01 Like, how do you manage somebody's reframes around this?
44:59 Speaker 02 Yeah, thank you for that Marina and it is a good place to to to end on and it's an important topic and again you'll get all sorts of opinions. I think that that sort of idea that you mentioned earlier of you know six months or nine months or 12 months of IV antibiotic therapy, the idea is just to kill, kill it, get it out, eradicate it. I, what I like to remind myself of and talk to people about is this goes back to the testing, we have no way to even prove that it's gone. Like we literally do not. Anyone who says we do is ignoring the limitations of our scientific knowledge. We cannot ever
45:44 Speaker 02 say that definitively. And and again, we also don't know how many people have Lyme in their in their systems but are fine and asymptomatic. So you kind of put those two together and for me, it does not make sense. And again, we're talking chronic Lyme, we're not talking about a recent infection. That's different. Go get the doxy in my opinion, get it out, right? I think that's possible and it's in your rearview mirror, you're good in in a lot of those scenarios. But chronic Lyme, very different. I do not think the goal is to kill something off and eradicate it. The metaphor I use is you've got a roommate
46:26 Speaker 02 now and it's kind of like a roommate or a housemate, you know, are they doing their dishes? Are they paying their share of the rent on time? Or are they making messes and keeping up all night with noise and right? So there is a place for like getting things under control with stronger remedies. But then it's really about coexistence, which is not, I was just talking to a client recently about this. This does not in any way mean giving in to the fact that you're gonna feel sick. I do not mean that. I do not believe that. It's about feeling well, but with this new context for your
47:08 Speaker 02 And it may very well be that you need to keep it in mind in the future and you need to remind yours, oh yeah, I'm feeling unwell because maybe this is a flare up. So I know what to do about it now so that it doesn't spiral out of control and I regain feeling well, right? So, but it's about it no longer interfering with your wellness emotionally, physically and otherwise. And that's, that's really the goal, I think.
47:41 Speaker 01 All right. Yeah. Thank you so much for your wisdom. Everything that you've shared today again is, is really, really useful information and really applicable. So I want to end with a very quick rapid fire round. And the first question I'm going to ask is, if you could share something with a person struggling with Lyme, chronic Lyme in particular, right now, what would be the number one tip that you can give them so they could improve their quality of life right now?
48:15 Speaker 02 Oh, I know you said rapid fire. I mean, find a practitioner who believes you and who respects you. I think that's, that's what I would say.
48:28 Speaker 01 Love that. So important. Okay. Second question is, what would you say to somebody, whether or not they had Lyme or some other issue that they're sort of losing faith and hope in ever, you know, overcoming or crossing a particularly challenging hurdle? What could you tell that person right now?
48:51 Speaker 02 I have worked with a number of people. I'd never counted the numbers, but with, with a fair number of people at this point who have had chronic Lyme for five years, 10 years, 15 years. And like I said earlier, I don't want to paint it as easy. It's a slog. It's a lot of work. It will take time. But if you do it, if you really address what you need to, you get better. You do.
49:21 Speaker 01 All right. Awesome message, Richard. Thank you again. And I'd love for you to finish off by sharing with folks how they can get in touch and maybe something that you're looking forward to, maybe this summer, or just in general, any events or things that you're having or you're excited about.
49:38 Speaker 02 Oh, thank you for that, Marina. So the best place is to go to my website, which is my full name, richardmandelbaum.com. I'm not on social media, so you won't find me there. It's a conscious choice just to reduce my screen time. But for folks in the area, so again, I'm in the southern Catskills, like you mentioned, I do offer classes and workshops through the summer. Most of my teaching is within established programs, but in the summer, I offer stuff for folks who are nearby. And in terms of something I'm looking forward
50:15 Speaker 02 to, one thing I need for myself every summer is a little bit of wilderness camping. And I like to do that with friends and family, but I also make it a point every year to disappear for several days, at least by myself, to reset. That's kind of my own silent retreat out there. And where I'm going to go this year was one of my absolute favorite places in the world, which is the Adirondacks up in northern New York, and just this treasure
50:56 Speaker 02 of wilderness. And sometimes I go backpacking, sometimes I take my kayak and just go out onto some of the lakes and ponds and disappear for a bit. So I'm really looking forward to that.
51:14 Speaker 01 Yeah, that sounds so good and an awesome reminder too for everybody. Just get off your screen once in a while and lose yourself in nature. So, so important for healing and mental health and everything that we talked about, even Lyme, you know, don't, don't let limes scare you away from nature is I think another message too. And just wear long clothing, cover yourself, protect yourself, tick check, et cetera, but don't let it scare you away. All right. Thank you so much, Richard, and enjoy every, everything that you have mentioned, and I hope to see you again soon. Bye.
51:49 Speaker 02 Thanks Marina. Yeah, take care.
51:51 Speaker 01 Thank you for tuning into another episode of the Holistic Pharmacy Podcast, and I truly hope you enjoyed the show. If you learned something useful in this episode, please consider giving the show a five-star rating and a sincere review so that more people can find it or share it with a friend directly. To get in touch with me, you can find me on social media by looking up my name, Marina Booksov, or email me at [email protected] . Take good care and see you soon.
Previous From Innovation and Integration to Impact: Advancing Health System Specialty Pharmacy at UC Davis Health | NASP Specialty Pharmacy Podcast Next Valentine’s Day Special 2026 | TWIRx Page updated November 14, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated