Skip to content

The women trying to make it in the manosphere

Panic World

Hosted by Ryan Broderick

1h 3m
Transcript

Original podcast

Where to listen

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

Ryan Broderick and Grant Irving are joined by guest Kat Tembarch to examine the women trying to build careers inside the right-wing manosphere and legacy conservative media. The discussion analyzes figures such as Wall Street Journal newsletter editor Emma Camp, influencer Amy Dangerfield, and diaper-toting activist Caitlin Bennett, unpacking how they perform traditional womanhood and contrarianism to appeal to older male audiences or radical online factions. The hosts and guest explore the deep ironies, class dynamics, and ultimate limitations of these career paths, arguing that conservative female pundits often act as disposable mouthpieces for a fundamentally misogynistic movement.

What makes the episode worth listening to are the specific deep dives into bizarre internet lore—such as Caitlin Bennett's attendance at the 2025 Warp Tour to see controversial musician Ronnie Radke, and Amy Dangerfield's groyper wedding theme. The conversation goes beyond simple mockery to dissect the transactional nature of the right-wing media apparatus, contrasting institutional columnists with independent creators and explaining why female pundits frequently find themselves trapped in a system that ultimately devalues them.

  • Aspiring conservative media figures often write pieces explicitly designed as job applications to appeal to boomer editors and wealthy donors. 18:04
  • Extreme online political movements rely heavily on traditional gender hierarchies that ultimately limit female participants. 31:23
  • Succeeding in institutional right-wing media requires wrapping controversial rhetoric in a veneer of sophisticated, reasonable-sounding nuance. 54:45

Chapters

  1. 0:00
    Show Introduction and Podcast Setup

    Hosts introduce the episode, sponsors, and the podcast format.

  2. 0:30
    Emma Camp Overview and Content Strategy

    The hosts discuss Emma Camp’s background, her content style, and her appeal to conservative audiences.

  3. 21:35
    Amy Dangerfield’s Rise in the Manosphere

    The conversation shifts to Amy Dangerfield, her transition from finance influencer to right‑wing content creator and her engagement with the manosphere.

  4. 36:11
    Caitlin Bennett’s Diaper Protest and Media Persona

    The hosts explore Caitlin Bennett’s controversial campus activism and her evolution into a right‑wing media figure.

  5. 42:21
    Tommy Lahren’s Career Path and Ideological Challenges

    The discussion turns to Tommy Lahren, examining her early career, ideological contradictions, and the broader dynamics of young women in right‑wing media.

  6. 45:39
    Closing Reflections and Episode Wrap‑Up

    The hosts conclude the episode, reflecting on the themes discussed and previewing future content.

  7. 49:47
    Ring Light vs. Professional Set

    The hosts compare the low‑budget production of a woman on Rumble to the high‑production, studio‑quality setup of Megyn Kelly.

  8. 50:48
    Misogyny, Class Dynamics, and Media Gatekeeping

    They explore how misogyny and class privilege shape mainstream journalism and the conservative media landscape.

  9. 51:39
    Sharecropping and Lack of Female Leadership

    The hosts argue that women can build lucrative careers but ultimately remain sharecroppers within a male‑led movement.

  10. 54:13
    Institutional Media vs. Independent Extremism

    The conversation contrasts women pursuing traditional media careers with those who go independent and embrace extremism for mass appeal.

  11. 55:11
    Future of Women in the Right‑Wing and Barry Weiss Analogy

    The hosts speculate on whether women can ever lead the Trump‑era movement, using Barry Weiss as a cautionary example.

  12. 1:01:22
    Closing Remarks and Guest Information

    The episode wraps up with a thank‑you to the guest, a preview of her wedding vlog, and promotional details.

Highlights

  • 0:30

    Right-Wing Grift Premiseinsight

    The host and guest humorously brainstorm what their hypothetical right-wing media grifts would entail, joking about launching anti-women harassment campaigns and libertarian AI platforms.

  • 5:53

    Performance for Boomer Readersinsight

    The guest and host analyze Wall Street Journal videos about grocery stores, arguing they represent old conservative men's fantasies of what young women should say.

  • 12:46

    College Free Speech Op-Edstory

    The hosts discuss Emma Camp's 2022 New York Times op-ed about self-censorship in college, noting how it mirrors the career trajectory of Barry Weiss.

  • 23:13

    Manosphere Collaboration Strategystrategy

    The conversation examines how finance influencer Amy Dangerfield pivoted into the manosphere by appearing on red-pill podcasts and engaging with extreme online figures.

  • 28:33

    Nick Fuentes Marriage Advicestory

    The hosts recount how Nick Fuentes advised Amy Dangerfield offstage to get married and pump out babies instead of having a public career.

  • 38:41

    Caitlin Bennett at Warp Tourdata

    The hosts discover that conservative activist Caitlin Bennett attended the 2025 Warp Tour to see controversial artist Ronnie Radke.

  • 51:04

    Lucrative SiriusXM Payoutsdata

    The guest and host discuss the multi-million dollar contracts commanded by mainstream conservative commentators like Megyn Kelly.

Quotes

  • “I think it's probably time we pull back the rock and see what's underneath.”
    Ryan Broderick · 0:33
  • “I feel like determining my conservative grift would be like antagonistic journaling of what I already do.”
    Unnamed speaker · 1:21
  • “I think that's really where it is.”
    Ryan Broderick · 2:02
  • “Megyn Kelly, like, she's really, she has the good studio, good lighting, probably gets a lot of work done, Ann Coulter may also do the same thing”
    Unnamed speaker · 50:33
  • “And Megyn Kelly is, is very good at that, like, her Sirius XM deal, I think, was somewhere between eight and 15 million dollars a year”
    Unnamed speaker · 50:59
  • “I think also, like, Megyn Kelly, like, she's really, she has the good studio, good lighting, probably gets a lot of work done”
    Unnamed speaker · 50:33
  • NoCD 20:23–20:47
  • Warp Tour 39:23–41:05
  • MintMobile 1:01:27–1:01:45

About this episode

We, and the broader culture, unfortunately can’t stop talking about the manosphere. But what’s going on with right-wing women? Today, we’re diving into the effort being led by a handful of young, conservative women who are trying to create some kind of a post-Dimes Square movement to rebuild 2010s hipsterdom but this time from the right. Our story starts with Emma Camp, a WSJ reporter who makes early BuzzFeed Video-style content shilling the virtues of capitalism; before moving onto other fresh voices in the quasi-conservative revolution — like Amy Dangerfield, who also started as a financial reporter and then fully immersed herself in the manosphere. Kat Tenbarge joins us once again, this time to explore questions like: What kind of content are these right-wing women making? Who is it for? And will they be successful in creating their own “womanosphere” (sorry) or reduced to being bit players in the larger manosphere? Our guest Kat Tenbarge is an independent journalist and creator of Spitfire News. Subscribe to Spitfire News at https://spitfirenews.com/, and follow her on Instagram, Bluesky, and TikTok @kattenbarge. Buy tickets to Panic World’s FIRST-EVER LIVE SHOW on November 28 in NYC! Along with Katie Notopoulos, the Garbage Media team will inflict the worst things on the internet in 2026 upon an unsuspecting Grant. Tickets: https://caveat.nyc/events/garbage-day-worst-things-on-the-internet-2026-2026-11-28 Want even more Panic World content? Like ad-free episodes, bonuses & exclusives, and access to our members-only Discord? Sign up for a membership for just $6.66 a month at https://www.patreon.com/PanicWorld. Sponsors If you’re struggling with OCD or unrelenting intrusive thoughts, NOCD can help. Book a free 15-minute call to get started at https://learn.nocd.com/panic Credits - Host: Ryan Broderick - Producer: Grant Irving - Production Coordinator: Josh Fjelstad - Researcher: Adam Bumas Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Transcript

0:00
1:03:26

11,243 words · 7 speakers

Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.

Topics

  • Instagram
  • The Wall Street Journal
  • Substack
  • Fox News
  • SpitfireNews.com
  • YouTube
  • Blue Sky
  • The Atlantic
  • NBC News

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated