Pod Insights Order of Man Men Have Lost Initiation | FRIDAY FIELD NOTES About this episode Men have lost initiation.
There was a time when boys were tested before becoming men. They faced hardship. They endured pain. They returned changed - recognized as men.
Today, that process is gone.
In this episode of Friday Field Notes, Ryan Michler breaks down:
Why modern men feel lost The three elements of ancient initiation Why pain is necessary How comfort culture is weakening men Why nobody is coming to initiate you How to initiate yourself If you feel stuck, drifting, or chasing validation - this episode is for you.
SHOW HIGHLIGHTS
00:00 Men Have Lost Initiation
00:26 When Boys Knew They Became Men
02:50 The Cost of Extended Adolescence
05:10 Comfort Culture Is Weakening Men
07:25 "Where Have All the Real Men Gone?"
08:05 The Three Elements of Initiation
08:30 Removed From Comfort
09:24 The Benefit of Pain
11:15 The Trial: Facing Fear
12:56 Recognition and Acknowledgment
14:49 Drifting, Chasing, and the Integrity Gap
16:35 Nobody Is Coming to Initiate You
17:14 Voluntary Hardship
18:45 What Initiation Looks Like Today
19:45 Brotherhood Is Modern Initiation
20:51 The World Needs Grounded Men
21:15 Questions Every Man Must Ask Himself
22:21 Do Something Difficult This Week
23:47 Steadiness Over Loudness
24:35 Choose the Fire
25:00 Join the Iron Council
25:20 The Men's Forge Event
26:00 Final Challenge
Battle Planners: Pick yours up today! https://store.orderofman.com/products/order-of-man-annual-battle-planner
Order Ryan's new book, The Masculinity Manifesto https://www.amazon.com/Masculinity-Manifesto-Establishes-Influence-Credibility/dp/1684513316/ref=tmm_hrd_swatch_0?_encoding=UTF8&qid=1665048672&sr=8-1.
For more information on the Iron Council brotherhood https://orderofman.link/iron-council.
Want maximum health, wealth, relationships, and abundance in your life? Sign up for our free course, 30 Days to Battle Ready https://orderofman.link/battle-ready-0
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 And here's the hard truth, nobody is coming to initiate you. Nobody's going to step up and do this for you. Not your dad, not your coach, not the government, not society at large, not your wife. If you missed the boat, and many of us did, I did, then you have to initiate yourself. So what does that actually look like? Well, it looks like stepping into voluntary hardship. It looks like working out, it looks like pursuing things, it looks like taking risks, it looks like taking on challenge. It looks like discipline when nobody around you is watching. What time do you get up? It looks like choosing responsibility before you feel ready.
0:33 Speaker 00 Man, there was a time when a boy knew when he became a man. It really wasn't ambiguous. It wasn't self-declared like Michael Scott screaming, "I declare bankruptcy." It wasn't based on his age alone, it was earned. And across all cultures, whether it was the Spartan warriors, or Native American tribes, or African tribes, or even the early American frontier, boys were tested before they became quote unquote "men." They were taken to the wilderness, they endured hardship, they faced fear, they carried responsibility,
1:15 Speaker 00 and when they came back, they were changed. They were welcomed to the seat at the table of men. They weren't boys anymore. They were initiated. But today, we don't have any of that. Outside of military or sports, all of that has gone away. There's no clear line between boyhood and manhood. There's no trial, there's no rites of passages, no older men calling younger men forward, and instead, we have extended adolescence. And that's the best way to describe it.
1:54 Speaker 00 We have taken our youthful years of boys, and we have just extended it perpetually. And this is why you have 30, 35, 40, 50-year-old men who don't act like men. They're grown, but they're not men. They're acting like boys. They're 35-year-old boys, 40-year-old boys, 50-year-old boys. I know you know people like this, I know plenty of women who know men like this. They're, they're, they're guys with beards and mortgages, but no internal initiation. And I hear from men just about every single day who tell me and express that they do not feel like men.
2:37 Speaker 00 They feel inferior, they feel inadequate, they feel unqualified to step up into the role that the world and their families and society demands. And there's a cost associated with this fact at this point that men are not being initiated. Because when that disappears, when we have stripped that away from society, then the responsibility that we as men have, it gets delayed, it gets pushed back. And that's why you see a lot of guys who are victims and perpetually blaming all of their woes on somebody else.
3:15 Speaker 00 Discipline becomes optional because there's no consequence to not being disciplined. Uh, commitment that you have for other people and yourself feels like it might just be negotiable.
3:28 Speaker 00 Hardship that you might face in life feels unfair. I mean, how many guys have you heard complain about it's my right, my right, my right, my right to a fair and decent wage, my, my right to housing, my right to healthcare. What, what right are you talking about? Who, who, who gave you that right that you're talking about? You look at the animal kingdom, there's no rights. And it's the same for us. There's no rights that you have other than what is given to us by God. And God hasn't given us a right to food and housing. He hasn't given us a right to healthcare. He hasn't given us a right to decent, livable wages.
4:11 Speaker 00 But our founders decided that we wanted to protect the right to life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness. And that's biblical. God has given us agency. He's given us freedom to make our own choices for better or worse. And then our right, if anything, is to suffer the consequences, positive or negative, of the choices that we make.
4:33 Speaker 00 And the problem is that nobody has ever told a man that this is the weight of manhood, so carry it.
4:41 Speaker 00 There's a legion of young men and old men who are walking around thinking that they are owed something from everybody. I heard an interview with a guy who is on SNAP benefits just earlier today. And he said, you know, these, these benefits are expiring and they're going away. And I don't know how I'm going to make my living and I don't know how I'm going to make my food. And if I'm going to be required to work 20 hours a week, then what other benefits am I going to get? And this is a pathetic loser. There's no other way to say it. This is a pathetic man who never learned what it means to be a man. And it's easy to spot in those moments, but you're probably doing it too, to some degree. We're waiting on big daddy government, or mommy and daddy,
5:23 Speaker 00 or our wife, or whoever, to solve all of our problems. Well, what do I get out of it? I don't know. What are you going to create? Because what culture tells people, men specifically, to do, and there's a clear and deliberate reason for this, and we can talk about it, is to stay comfortable, is to avoid any sort of risk, to protect your feelings, to search after happiness, to not offend anybody. Don't lead too assertively or too boldly. It might come across as aggressive. I just had a woman message me on Instagram because I had said something clear and decisively. I wasn't a jerk about it. I just said what I believed. And she said,
6:05 Speaker 00 you're being aggressive. Why? I'm not being aggressive. She probably just doesn't know, or isn't familiar with the way a assertive, bold, masculine man communicates. And she interprets it as aggressiveness. And what most men will do is they'll cower, and they'll buckle, and they'll fold, because a woman said, you're being too aggressive. I don't care about that. And you shouldn't care either. Now, should we determine for ourselves whether we're being aggressive or not? Sure. But we can be assertive. But if anybody says to us that we're being aggressive because they've never seen it before, that's not my problem. That's somebody else's problem. And then we wonder, as we're crying about men being too aggressive, or too assertive,
6:48 Speaker 00 or too bold, or too confrontational, or too assertive, that we wonder why we don't feel like men, and why we feel lost.
7:02 Speaker 00 You cannot expect a man to act like a man if he was never forged into one. And it's ironic when you hear women and culture in general, who will blast and chastise and mock and criticize and ridicule men for being bold and assertive and courageous and taking risks and stepping into the fire when nobody else will. And then at the same time, as you mock them and they cower and they buckle, then you'll say, where have all the real men gone?
7:36 Speaker 00 You don't, you don't have the right, if we're talking about rights, to say that.
7:41 Speaker 00 You don't get to undermine masculinity at every step and then ask where all the masculine men are. You turn them mothers, single mothers, society, teachers, schoolteachers, the medical community, entertainment. You don't get to undermine men and then complain about men not showing up the way that you would want them to. You did this to yourself. Guys, there's a missing fire within men. And initiation into manhood has always involved three very, very specific things. And up until the relative ease of modernity, have we stepped away from these things? So let's talk about it, all right? Number one, when it comes to initiation.
8:24 Speaker 00 Throughout all of culture and all of human history, and there's no exception to this rule, literally zero exception. A boy was removed from the comfort of his situation. He was removed from his mother. He was removed from his tribe. He was removed from the village. He was removed from resources that he didn't provide himself. He was literally ripped away. He was kidnapped and pulled out of that environment. We removed his comfort.
8:53 Speaker 00 Okay, we've done that. There's no level of discomfort that people have anymore. We've removed physical challenge. There's no real risk in life. There's no testing. And without that testing, there's no transformation. I made this analogy the other day that if you have kids, you understand that kids just want to touch the stove top, right? They want to put their hand on the stove top. It glows and it's red and it's enticing. And you tell them, no, no, no, no. And still, they want to put their hand on that stove. And once they do, they realize that hurts. I'm not doing that again. And sometimes it takes being burned to learn. But let me run something past you. Imagine that you had no nerve endings.
9:35 Speaker 00 Imagine that if you put or your child put their hand on the stove
9:41 Speaker 00 and they couldn't feel that it hurt, would that mean that the stove top was less dangerous? No, because even if you couldn't feel it, it would still do damage to your hand.
9:57 Speaker 00 So the point that I'm making is that the
10:03 Speaker 00 the consequence, the sting, the hurt, the burn, the pain, that's the benefit. What that's doing is telling you, it's training you not to touch the stove top anymore. Without that, you'd still do it, but you wouldn't feel it, but you'd still get burned.
10:19 Speaker 00 You'd still damage your skin and your body.
10:22 Speaker 00 And so as men, oftentimes we think, well, I don't want to feel that way. I don't want to experience that. I don't want to go through that hardship. I want to ease that suffering. And so we have big daddy government and social institutions that come in and rescue us. But you know what? The benefit of pain
10:39 Speaker 00 is undeniable. You have to feel pain. Without it, you would never learn. You would never grow. So if you're sad or sorry, or angry, or mad, or frustrated, or contentious, good, good to steal a quote from Jaco. Good. You should be in pain. You should feel sorry. You should feel sad. You should feel mad. You should feel angry. Now, the way we express that is up for Conversation, but if you're not feeling that, then it doesn't matter enough to you. And the pain has to be there. It's part of initiation. Too many young men have never been initiated that way. Okay, number two is there has to be trial. Now, there was a task.
11:23 Speaker 00 Typically, what happened in ancient villages and tribes and, and culture is that the boy was stripped away. Just talked about that. And then he was put into an environment where he had a trial. There was a task. There was a hunt. There was a fast, maybe, uh, maybe it was a battle. It was a, a journey in the wilderness. Something that forced a young man to confront the fear. But today, we numb all of that fear. We scroll, we doom scroll, right? We game. Uh, we watch porn. We get into alcohol and substance abuse. We distract ourselves from the reality of our lives and you don't become a man by avoiding fear.
12:06 Speaker 00 You become a man by walking directly into it in the face of fear. It's not that you shouldn't have fear. Of course, we all are fearful at times, but you're going to walk forward in spite of it. And that's what helps you become a man. And then number three, and this is the last, like, main component. There's a lot to it, but, and I've studied this for 10 years. There's some sort of recognition. Okay. When a young man was stripped away from all that he knew. And he was put into some sort of obstacle, trial or adversity. The third component is that there was recognition of who he became. When he returned, the older men said, you're now one of us.
12:48 Speaker 00 And then what they traditionally did is they marked that individual tattoo. Um, they, they, they burned him, maybe even circumcision or pierced him. And there was some sort of recognition that he has now become a man. And that acknowledgement matters. It matters. Okay. Today, men are either criticized or they're completely ignored. But there's very little affirmation earned strength. How amazing would it feel if your wife came to you tonight when you got home and said, hey babe?
13:19 Speaker 00 I just want to tell you, I appreciate you going to work. I appreciate you battling what you battle. I appreciate you sacrificing for our family. And I want to acknowledge that we recognize your effort, your sacrifice, your commitment, your dedication. That's recognition. Ladies, if you're listening and you're not doing that for your husband, you should start doing that for your husband. Not without warrant, but when he actually does something good, you should acknowledge it because I'm telling you flat out, women are praised. They're pedestalized, they're complimented, they're flirted with all the time. You don't know what it's like to be a man
14:01 Speaker 00 who doesn't receive that acknowledgement and recognition. You think because through your own lens that that just happens because of who you are. It doesn't happen for men. And it's your job as your husband's wife to acknowledge what he's doing. Now, guys, that's not to say that we do things for acknowledgement. Two things can exist at once. She should acknowledge you and recognize your sacrifices, and you should need it. You should do it because it's intrinsically who you are. But acknowledgement and recognition is huge. So what happens as a result of us not having initiation?
14:46 Speaker 00 Ask yourself this. Consider this. Do you feel like you're drifting? Do you feel like you're chasing comfort? Do you feel like you're chasing validation from your woman? Or from your clients, or your boss, or whoever, your kids, whoever it might be? Do you chase women around hoping that they'll choose you? Do you chase money? Do you chase status? But even though in spite of those pursuits, you don't feel grounded. I've been there. I've chased money, I've chased women, I've chased validation, I've chased comfort. I do all of these things daily, actually. And I have to fight against that.
15:30 Speaker 00 And I have been initiated the way that I'm talking about today.
15:36 Speaker 00 But I can tell you when I don't pursue those things, I don't, well, pursue, pursuit is one thing, but chase is different. We can talk about that another time. If I don't chase those things, I feel more grounded because internally,
15:51 Speaker 00 I feel like I've proven my worth to myself. I don't need to prove it to a woman. I don't need to prove it to a client, or a colleague, or a coworker, or a boss, or my kids. I don't need to prove it to anybody. I feel internally like I've tested myself.
16:10 Speaker 00 An untested man is always, always seeking proof. He's always seeking validation because he's always lacking. There's a gap between, I call this the integrity gap. There's a gap between what he knows or wants himself to be and who he actually is. And because that gap exists, instead of working towards bridging that gap, he reaches out to other people and says, will you do this for me? Will you build this bridge for me? And nobody can build it for you.
16:38 Speaker 00 They might try because they love you and care about you. They might try to pull you along, or rescue you, or throw you a rope, or do whatever they can. And they, they try diligently. But guys, they can't build your bridge. You have to build that bridge.
16:53 Speaker 00 You have to.
16:55 Speaker 00 And here's the hard truth. Nobody is coming to initiate you. Nobody's going to step up and do this for you. Not your dad, not your coach, not the government, not society at large, not your wife. If you missed the boat, and many of us did, I did, then you have to initiate yourself. So what does that actually look like? Well, it looks like stepping into voluntary hardship.
17:17 Speaker 00 It looks like working out. It looks like pursuing things. It looks like taking risks. It looks like taking on challenge.
17:25 Speaker 00 It looks like discipline when nobody around you is watching. What time do you get up? Even though nobody's going to ask you what time you got up?
17:33 Speaker 00 It looks like choosing responsibility before you feel ready. How many guys will say, well, that's above my pay grade when it comes to an opportunity at work? Okay, then stay stuck. That's fine. But don't cry when somebody else gets chosen for the opportunity that you complained about you not getting. You didn't do the work. It looks like telling the truth when it costs you.
17:57 Speaker 00 You know, even in the dating world, you think about it's like, how many dates have we gone on? Where, you know, maybe there wasn't a connection instead of just talking to the person and being honest and respectful. You just ghost. Don't do that. Just talk to the person. Hey, there wasn't a connection.
18:12 Speaker 00 Or maybe your wife is doing something and it bothers you and you're like, no, I'm fine. I'm good. I'm fine. And then one day you blow up. That's not leadership. It's not initiation. Initiation is saying, hey babe, I've got a problem with the way that you talked to me last night. And here's why it bothered me and here's why it frustrates me and here's how I would like to be talked to. She would actually appreciate that, by the way, ironically.
18:36 Speaker 00 Lack of initiation looks like staying when it's easier to leave.
18:48 Speaker 00 It looks like lifting heavy objects physically and metaphorically. It looks like walking into the arena, the battlefield of life.
19:00 Speaker 00 And being exposed to critique and risk and frustration and all of these things that you're going to inevitably face. But if you want initiation, then you need to commit to your marriage fully and you need to do hard things. You need to raise your children deliberately. You need to go out and build something. How many of you have ideas and thoughts and insights and things that you want to accomplish? You need to build something from nothing.
19:31 Speaker 00 You need to step up and lead when others hesitate and shrink away and pull away and hide and cower. You need to step up. You need to train your body when you don't feel like it. Go to the gym. Hey, I woke up this morning and I didn't feel like it. I don't care what you felt like. Go to the gym. Go get it done. You need to join a band of men who are going to hold you accountable. Brotherhood is actually modern initiation. You didn't go to the military. You didn't maybe play sports after high school. Having a brotherhood of men who will hold you accountable is initiation. The hardship that you choose, if it's done voluntarily, and voluntarily is important, that's modern initiation. So if you're a man who's listening to this podcast,
20:13 Speaker 00 you're like, man, I don't, I don't feel like a man. I didn't have a dad around. I didn't have anybody to teach me these things. Good. So what? You're, you're 25 years old, you're 30 years old, you're 40 years old, you're 50 years old. What, like you're still waiting for daddy to come save you? Volunteer. Step up. And this matters because culture is confused about men right now. It really is. You know, some people will say masculinity is toxic. A lot of people will say it's under attack. Some will say even masculinity is outdated or unnecessary. But the real issue isn't masculinity. It's the absence of masculinity. Disciplined, dangerous,
20:58 Speaker 00 grounded. These are the type of men who aren't toxic. They're stabilizing. They protect. They're steady. They step up. And a culture, despite what social media might tell you, desperately needs you to be initiated. So I've got a challenge for you today. I want you, I want to ask you a couple of questions. I want you to write these down if you can, if you're in a place where you can write it down. Number one, where have I avoided initiation?
21:33 Speaker 00 Number two. Where am I still acting like a boy?
21:40 Speaker 00 Is it in your marriage, your business, your life, your fatherhood? Where am I still acting like a boy? Number three. Where am I willing to be chosen instead of choosing? Where am I be, where am I willing to be chosen instead of choosing?
21:56 Speaker 00 And then the second part of that is to do something difficult this week. Not reckless, okay, not, not dangerous, not performative, but, but something difficult. A hard conversation, a hard decision, waking up when the alarm goes off. Having some discipline, joining a brotherhood, going to an event, starting that new project, asking for a raise, starting a business, asking for a promotion. There's an endless list of things that I know are on your minds and too many men aren't doing them because they're little boys.
22:35 Speaker 00 They're, they're little children where they don't think they can ask out of life what they want. Life, and I heard this quote a long time ago, will give you exactly what you ask of it. So if you're not happy with where you are, then maybe you ought to start asking some better questions. Life is giving you exactly what you ask for. Guys, initiation isn't about ego. It's about integrating your entire life and becoming more of the man that you want to be and more of the man that the people in your life need you to be. It's about becoming someone who can carry the burden and the mantle of masculinity without buckling, without folding, without crumbling. Think about that metaphor for a minute. You've got a pack on you and it's 100 pounds. How long can you carry that pack?
23:20 Speaker 00 Are you going to buckle? Are you going to fold? Are you going to collapse because that weight is too much? Or are you just going to soldier on?
23:29 Speaker 00 Or are you going to carry that weight diligently and do your job and have responsibility? That's what people need of you. The world doesn't need louder men. It's a bit ironic because I'm on social media trying to be as loud as I can be to share these concepts and insights, but it doesn't need louder men. It needs steadier men to step up in a very powerful way.
23:51 Speaker 00 The steadiness that you need to have in your life, it's forged. It's not just gifted to you. It's built through initiation. So I want you to choose the fire. And when you walk through it, you don't need somebody else to declare that you're a man. You don't need somebody else to say what a man is. Even me, you don't need me to say a real man should. You won't need any of that. You'll just know. You'll know I'm a man. You'll know you're a man. And you'll have confidence and boldness and courage as you lead your family, yourself and your business and your life, your community, every aspect of it. Guys, I want all of us to be initiated. All of that has been stripped away.
24:31 Speaker 00 Some of this self-imposed, some of it externally imposed, but we need to initiate each other. We need to initiate ourselves and we need to be men in a world that is critically, critically lacking men. If you want to know more about this, you can head to orderofman.com and learn. You could subscribe to the podcast or if you're really ready to initiate yourself, then join the Iron Council at orderofman.com/ironcouncil. If you're not ready for that commitment, then come out and meet with us in April for three days and we'll tell you what you need and we'll show you a way to be initiated into manhood with hundreds of other guys. You can go to themensforge.com and check that out, April 23rd through the 26th. So you've got your marching orders.
25:16 Speaker 00 You need to initiate yourself because nobody else is going to do it. Join us at orderofman.com/ironcouncil or join us at themensforge.com. Guys, I hope that helps. I hope that serves you. We will be back for our interview next week. So go out there, take action and become a man, you.
25:35 Speaker 01 Thank you for listening to the Order of Man Podcast. You're ready to take charge of your life and be more of the man you were meant to be? We invite you to join the order at orderofman.com.
Previous Signal to Noise Ratio, Protecting Leadership Standards, and Why Curiosity Wins | ASK ME ANYTHING Next RICHARD RYAN | Guarding Your Mind in a Digital World Page updated November 6, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated