Pod Insights On with Kara Swisher High Stakes with HRC: The AI vs. Democracy Episode About this episode Welcome back to another episode of High Stakes, with co-hosts Kara Swisher and Hillary Clinton. This week, Madam Secretary tunes in from Belfast (she wasn’t grounded in the FAA debacle), and she and Kara discuss the latest on the NVIDIA saga, Jensen Huang, and all the White House briefings Trump probably ignored. They cover the rare FAA grounding last weekend, the populist data center backlash, and the big one: is Congress really ready to regulate AI? Plus, the two bring in a special guest to talk about the dangers of our technological moment: Nobel Peace Prize laureate, Maria Ressa.
We’re off next week for Thanksgiving! Enjoy your turkeys. Tune back in at the top of December for more Kara and HRC.
Questions? Comments? Email us at [email protected] or find us on YouTube, Instagram, TikTok, Threads, and Bluesky @onwithkaraswisher.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 13,446 words · 7 speakers
0:01 Speaker 00 Support for the show comes from Alloy Health. If you're dealing with menopause alone, no, it's not just you. Alloy was built by women who have dealt with all of it. It's an all in one platform that connects you with board certified menopause specialized physicians and proven effective treatments. Find relief that works for you. Head to myalloy.com and use the code ONWITHKARA. Your menopause specialized doctor will tailor your treatment to your exact needs. Plus you'll get unlimited messaging with your doctor. That's M Y A L L O Y dot com using the code ONWITHKARA to get 20% off your first order. This code is valid on products only.
0:43 Speaker 01 I'm Josh Muccio, host of The Pitch, where startup founders raise millions and listeners can invest. For our sweet season 16, we're giving you more of what you love and less of what you don't. Software is out. Actual cool stuff is in. We've got consumer brands, deep tech that changes the weather.
1:02 Speaker 02 Our big vision is to make it rain and snow on demand.
1:05 Speaker 01 We've got hardware that helps blind people see and dairy. I never imagined my life journey would be milk. Season 16 of The Pitch is out now. Listen wherever you get your podcasts. This season is presented by Engine.
1:20 Speaker 03 Support for the show comes from Engine. Running a small business means every dollar has to work hard. But if your team is still booking travel the old way, it's costing you more than you think. Engine is the fastest growing travel and spend platform in the country, built specifically for businesses like yours. Book a trip in as little as two and a half minutes, earn up to 10% back on hotels. And in 2025, Engine customers save more than $300 million on travel with zero booking fees, no contracts, and no BS. More than 1,000 businesses join Engine every month. Join them and get $500 when your business signs up and starts traveling at engine.com/vox.
2:04 Speaker 00 Trump was blaming Biden immediately.
2:06 Speaker 04 Oh, he blames Biden for everything, you know? If he, you know, has, is constipated, he probably blames Biden.
2:21 Speaker 00 Hi, everyone. I'm Kara Swisher.
2:23 Speaker 04 And I'm Hillary Clinton.
2:24 Speaker 00 And this is High Stakes from the Vox Media Podcast Network. How you doing, Hillary?
2:30 Speaker 04 I'm doing good. I'm in Belfast, Northern Ireland.
2:33 Speaker 00 What's going on there? Is that a little incident?
2:37 Speaker 04 I'm the chancellor of Queens University Belfast. And so I come and do events and remind people about the Good Friday Agreement and try to make sure we're still on track and work with universities.
2:51 Speaker 00 Explain this week to me for you. You've been all over the place. I keep seeing you pop up everywhere.
2:57 Speaker 04 Honestly, until I went to Belfast, I was in New York because I had to, as you did, interview Rachel Maddow about her great book, which we talked about on the podcast. And then I had to have a bunch of meetings with incoming Democratic elected officials and offer encouragement and support and then came to Belfast.
3:19 Speaker 00 Wow.
3:19 Speaker 04 And of course, had to wait many hours because of the
3:22 Speaker 00 Oh, the planes.
3:24 Speaker 04 Were you stuck? Yeah, I was, but I got out because they let international flights out.
3:30 Speaker 00 Why? Why did they let international versus? I don't understand any of it, Hillary.
3:33 Speaker 04 Because once we got out of US airspace, they didn't have to worry about us.
3:37 Speaker 00 All right, we're going to get to that in a second, but it's a couple of weeks after the election and two weeks ago, AI looked unstoppable, the AI industry at least. Now Nvidia's CEO is out, which we've discussed. Voters rejected data centers almost everywhere and Democrats are coming for big tech in January. So today we're going to ask, who controls AI before it controls us? And later, Nobel laureate Maria Ressa joins us. But let's, let's, let's start with the big news because things have changed rather dramatically, even though there's a real retrograde attack back already. First, the Nvidia mess. Treasury Secretary Scott Besant said that Nvidia needs an outside CEO and questioned whether the company pushed illicit chip sales to China to boost its earnings.
4:19 Speaker 00 He's also pointing the finger at Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick, who The Times reports pushed weaker chip rules that could benefit clients of his firm his sons now run. Talk a little bit about this because at the same time, there's a real push by some of the worst people in tech is Elon, Travis Kalanick, who have their own issues, which I think it's more about them than it is about anything else. But is Besant trying to clean up the mess or just making sure he's not the one who takes the fall when Trump needs someone to blame? So how do you look at what's happening, including certain tech leaders? And again, as I say, the most toxic of them, who had their own issues, pushing back on this?
4:58 Speaker 04 You know, this is really fascinating, Kara, because this has moved from just what we originally thought a sex and spy scandal into a big financial question mark. And I think they're also worried about the circular financing that has been going on, where you're OpenAI, you're Anthropic, whoever you are, you're trying to build some data centers, you're trying to buy, you know?
5:24 Speaker 00 The hyperscalers, right.
5:25 Speaker 04 Yeah, hyperscalers, Nvidia's GPUs. I think this is going to get messier before it gets at all clarified. And your question about some of the big tech names signing petitions and speaking out, saying, hire back Jensen Huang. Some of it is just ego and displacement, like, oh, my gosh, there but for the grace of God go I and what would happen to me. But some of it may well be an understanding that they're going to be facing a big set of financial issues within the industry because of the intertwining of Nvidia's financing with everybody else's. So stay tuned.
6:05 Speaker 00 So to talk about the inside, I'm fascinated with Besant because it looks like both Rubio, Marco Rubio, the Secretary of State, and Besant are the ones to start this in motion. It feels like they leaked everything or people close to them did. Talk about you were on the inside. If something like this was happening, how does that work? I mean, what happens between, say, the president and Marco Rubio and Scott Besant? And then you have Howard Lutnick over here. Give us a little color what happens inside. Now, this was not something you ever faced, but I'm sure you had beefs among and between each other, the Treasury Secretary, the Secretary of State.
6:39 Speaker 04 100%. You know, there are often different institutional views and sometimes personal views. And I can only speak from looking from the outside in, but it seems as though Rubio's efforts to warn Trump were really institutional and personal. I mean, this was important to him because until he became, you know, Trump's Secretary of State, he was pretty much a China hawk and raised all kinds of issues. He was a Russia hawk as well and then had to recede with those views because of Trump's cozy relationships. So when it became clear to Rubio that Trump was shrugging off warnings about the intel
7:20 Speaker 04 linking Jensen to Alice Wang, he then wrote a highly classified memo and got it to Trump directly.
7:27 Speaker 00 How are those done? I really, you were the person I can ask that.
7:31 Speaker 04 Yeah, no, it can happen a couple of different ways. Very coincidentally, the Secretary of State might start by giving it to the National Security Advisor. Well, Rubio is also the National Security Advisor. So my bet is in a regularly scheduled or maybe a requested meeting, Rubio gave this to Trump directly and said, you know, Mr. President, this is a problem. We have this intelligence. And I'm sure Rubio couched it like this. We want to protect you, Mr. President. You probably should keep your distance from Jensen until we figure out what's really going on. Well, Trump had both, I think, a dismissive attitude, like, oh, who cares if he's having an affair? I mean, that wouldn't bother Trump anyway. But I think, secondly, he's never believed American intelligence.
8:16 Speaker 04 He has rejected it time and again. And he also didn't want to stop the trade relationship with China that included advanced chips.
8:28 Speaker 00 And, and the kickback 25%? Whatever.
8:30 Speaker 04 The kickback to the country and who knows? Maybe we'll unearth kickbacks to companies that he's involved in, the way we are now learning about the companies that Lutnick's firm is involved with.
8:41 Speaker 00 So who writes those memos? How did it, how does it get started? This Signal intelligence rises to who? And where's the CIA chief? Ratcliffe in here? Oh, he must be involved.
8:52 Speaker 04 The Signal's intelligence would go, especially
8:56 Speaker 04 As this one raised serious questions to the National Director of Intelligence, but it would also be coming from the National Security Agency that does the, what we call, technical intelligence, signals intelligence. You know, they're not running agents, they're picking up emails and phone calls and all of that. And once more than one person knows about it, it will spread. And then somebody, and I'm not sure who this somebody was in the, from the reporting, somebody said, okay, you've got a signals intercept which says they're talking about an American, we need to, quote, unmask that American. We need to know who that is, right?
9:38 Speaker 00 Yeah.
9:39 Speaker 04 So when they unmask the American, because we're not spying on Americans, but we pick up information about Americans, then it was determined it was Jensen Wong. And that's when the internal debate started, like, oh, my God, Jensen Wong, most, you know, prominent, biggest market company in the world, da-da-da-da.
9:58 Speaker 00 Best friend of Trump.
9:59 Speaker 04 All of that, and a friend of Trump, and someone who we're very close to. And so then the wheels started spinning. And I imagine that people in the intelligence community, maybe even Rubio, approached people in the White House.
10:14 Speaker 00 The trade representative was also concerned.
10:16 Speaker 04 Yeah, the trade representative, and Lutnik knew about it, but at the moment, when all this was breaking, it looked like he was unwitting. It looked like he'd been, you know, honey-trapped, honey-potted, and therefore, he should be warned away. And Trump would not warn him. Now, Trump loves having
10:35 Speaker 00 Information on people.
10:36 Speaker 04 Information. So if he needed to put the arm on Jensen down the road and get something out of him, maybe personally something out of him, he could say, well, you know, Jensen, I protected you. So he had his usual nefarious purpose, but he also just didn't think it was that important, and he didn't think that he wanted to call a halt to this cutout operation that was going on, where the chips were being sent to mega-speed or whomever.
11:06 Speaker 00 So I'm going to ask you more internal questions, because I'm really interested in internal. So then Besen gets involved, and he's being rather explicit. One, in really throwing Howard Lutnik deservedly under the bus, that's one. We tried to warn them, which is CYA, which is fine, it's a good CYA.
11:20 Speaker 04 Right.
11:21 Speaker 00 But he's also explicitly saying, we cannot, as these tech leaders, that, again, they're not, you're not hearing from Sundar Pichai, you're not hearing from Mark Zuckerberg on this, you haven't heard from Sam Altman, which to me says a lot. He must know, why is he saying it so explicitly? It needs an outside CEO, something's, you know, something's, something's bad in Denmark right now, you know, that kind of thing.
11:44 Speaker 04 Well, again, what I have heard is that oftentimes Besen, in the room on economic issues, is fighting an uphill battle, like, you know, wait a minute, think of the consequences, maybe we don't want to do that. And he often has used other people rather than himself to send some signals, make public comments about what's happening. He's also had, I've been told, a very contentious relationship with Lutnik. And at the Treasury Department, they are often responsible for imposing and implementing sanctions, but there are some carve-outs that end up in the jurisdiction of the Commerce Department, and this apparently is one.
12:26 Speaker 04 So everybody's trying to stop Lutnik from going forward with allowing these chips to be exported in the face of this intelligence, which now is known at the highest levels of the US government. And Lutnik is basically just giving them the head nod.
12:45 Speaker 00 But why is he saying publicly, get another CEO, like, an outside CEO, something, it's quite a step.
12:49 Speaker 04 If I'm guessing, Karen, you know much more about this, I think, and remember, the woman now, the CFO, who's been put into place as a temporary head of Nvidia, was apparently trying to figure out how to rein in this loaning money to other companies to buy their products, their chips. And so at some point, when does that look like a Ponzi scheme?
13:15 Speaker 00 Yeah, 100%. So that's, that's why he's doing it, but it's really something, he's saying it so publicly and going against.
13:21 Speaker 04 And they're both on the plane to China.
13:22 Speaker 00 They're both on the plane. So talk about that. So Trump has, just to be clear, one of the things, the reason, it's odd that the tech leaders are doing it, to me, everyone, they're sort of thinking it's a normal thing. But one of the people that's doing it is Travis Kalanick, who himself was removed for behaviors, right? Even if he created and pushed Uber to the forefront, it's doing better under a different CEO by far, by Dara Khosrowshahi. So he doesn't, he's seeing, he's playing out his own personal drama, that he got ousted, essentially. But meanwhile, Trump heads to China to meet with Xi and says he won't raise the Nvidia scandal. Incredibly, as of the taping, Nvidia's lost more than $1.2 trillion in value since the scandal broke. It is, as Hillary was noting, very locked into the rest of the internet economy.
14:07 Speaker 00 It's sort of the linchpin, in a, in a way, that's really frightening to a lot of people, I think. So what is China taking away when the American president won't raise matters of national security? And, you know, if you were Secretary of State and the president said this, what would you say? Like, are you kidding me? Or what?
14:24 Speaker 04 Yeah, are you kidding me? Yeah. I think that's the right way to ask the questions, because what China will, once again, just pocket, is Trump could care less about US national security in the way we usually define national security. And I don't say that lightly, Kara. I mean, he won't raise human rights issues, which we used to raise, in order, not just to raise the questions about Americans and others being persecuted inside China, and denial of Chinese dissidence, their human rights, but to lay a marker down, like, you know what, we're watching you. And if you want to be a big leader in the international community, you got to treat your people right.
15:06 Speaker 04 And let's talk about Tibet, and let's talk about, you know, the Uighurs and all of that. Trump could care less. But the more important issue is, I think these chips go right to Trump's very faulty view of economic power. He thinks tariffs make America powerful. He thinks totally eliminating the efforts that had been put into place to build a clean energy economy in America, not only for climate, but also to compete with China, are minor league stuff. All he cares about, the best I can tell, is looking like he belongs in the company
15:50 Speaker 04 of Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin, both of whom he's going to meet with together. I mean, these two men play him like a child's guitar. It is pathetic.
16:02 Speaker 00 A child's guitar, not a Stradivarius.
16:04 Speaker 04 A child's guitar. Oh, my God, it's disgusting. And, you know, when he came out of the meeting with Xi and the United States, there was nothing to report. He will fulminate, he'll bluster, he'll make these ridiculous claims. We will get nothing of importance to our national security or economic security.
16:23 Speaker 00 And this is a big deal, the three of them together.
16:25 Speaker 04 It's a huge deal.
16:26 Speaker 00 Right, right.
16:27 Speaker 04 It's a huge deal. And what he says is he's going to go talk about nuclear weapons. Okay, great. I mean, we need to get
16:32 Speaker 00 He's Reagan at Reykjavik, I guess.
16:34 Speaker 04 Yeah, we need to get China into, you know, nuclear weapons agreements. Like, we used to have Russia, we no longer have agreements with Russia. Okay, I'm all for that, but that's, you know.
16:45 Speaker 00 What is one good thing if you, that should come out of this? If you were, you think nothing, he'll do the same thing that happened in the last two meetings with these people.
16:53 Speaker 04 I think, I don't think he's capable of understanding what's in America's best interests, either through security or the economy. He lives in the world of slogans. He lives in the world of unformed ideas, like tariffs. And he doesn't, I don't think, really understand the way the economy actually is operating in 2026.
17:18 Speaker 00 So a nothing burger from this? It doesn't seem like it.
17:20 Speaker 04 Nothing, well, I think it will weaken us. It will give Putin and Xi more control over him. It will do nothing to deal with the, what I think is going to be a growing scandal about Nvidia and their exporting of advanced chips to China. And it will do nothing to help Ukraine, because China is basically Russia's manufacturing base for a lot of the high-tech technology. And Trump also said he's going to talk about Iran. Well, you know, China helps Iran, and Iran helps Russia, and Russia helps Iran, and Iran is killing American service members, in part because of help from China and Russia.
18:02 Speaker 04 So on any rational basis of what's in our interest to try to engage on and try to be tough on and push through some kind of understanding, even an agreement, we're not going to see it. You're not going to see Trump say to China, let's convene an international forum to figure out how we're going to regulate AI.
18:21 Speaker 00 Yeah, not going to happen. All right. Well, speaking of incompetence, as it goes through the air, traffic is returning to normal, following Friday's nationwide ground stop. Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy is so far refusing to apologize for the overall chaos. Here he is on Meet the Press.
18:37 Speaker 05 Listen, it happened on my watch, but we have to be clear. I am moving at an incredible speed that no one has done at the FAA or the DOT in decades. And I'm proud of the work we're doing, the attention we're bringing to this issue. But I can't apologize for what was passed off to us. And I can't blame Republicans or Democrats because it's all of them. Goes back 20, 25, 30 years of a lack of investment, a lack of waving the flag to say, hey, this is a problem, let's fix it. Why they didn't do that, I don't know.
19:10 Speaker 00 So we're talking about transpo, a joke from Saturday Night Live. Duffy is demanding $50 billion from Congress, but Democrats say Congress already gave him 12.5 billion and he only spent about a billion of it. Experts say modernizing the FAA will take over a decade and Thanksgiving travel, of course, starts next week. Talk a little bit of this because he does have a point, even though he seems feckless and incompetent, but can anything get actually fixed before 2028 or should travelers just brace for more of it? And if our most critical system, one of them is fragile and AI is making it easier than ever to attack them, this could be really problematic, including in terms of people's actual safety and lives. So he has a point that no one's really done anything, but neither Trump has been in office
19:54 Speaker 00 in those two sandwich times, right? In between, if you want to blame some of the last 10 years, Trump has had a lot of control over the situation.
20:02 Speaker 04 Yeah, no, look, I think, I think there's enough blame to go around and I think it's unseemly for him not to take responsibility for his part of the last two years because, as you said, on the big so-called beautiful bill, Congress, Republican Congress appropriated 12 and a half billion dollars. They've only spent a billion. I thought the initial explanation from him and Mark Wayne Mullen were incomprehensible, incoherent.
20:28 Speaker 00 You know, they called it dumb and plumber, but go ahead.
20:30 Speaker 04 I had no idea what they were saying. And I was basically sitting at the airport trying to get out on my flight to Ireland.
20:39 Speaker 00 Where do you sit at an airport? I need to take a moment. Where do you sit, like in the regular?
20:42 Speaker 04 Well, mostly I'll sit in the car because if I get there in a timely way, then I want to just get out and go walk to the gate. Otherwise, you know, I might go to a lounge, I might hang out at the gate, I might go to a bookstore, but it kind of depends on the timing.
20:57 Speaker 00 You have security implications.
20:59 Speaker 04 Yeah, the security and all of that.
21:00 Speaker 00 You're not at the Chipotle.
21:01 Speaker 04 No, not yet, anyway. So part of what I think is missing is an understanding that, starting with Doge, we had a lot of people who knew things pushed out of the government. We are losing expertise in both the public and the private sector to do things that really matter, but they're not as sexy as let's go build data centers, let's invest in AI. We ought to figure out how to do basic things first and have the people who know what needs to be done on the payroll. And I think with Duffy, the guy spent seven months filming his own reality TV show. He was not on the phone saying, let me visit what you're doing, let me bring experts.
21:44 Speaker 00 Let's figure out how to upgrade.
21:45 Speaker 04 Let me figure out how we're going to make it work. I hope that they're going to be able to put it together with duct tape and baling wire. I don't want anything terrible to happen to anybody. But this is a moment for all hands on deck.
21:57 Speaker 00 Or a bipartisan effort.
21:59 Speaker 04 And a bipartisan effort.
22:00 Speaker 00 Because Trump was blaming Biden immediately.
22:02 Speaker 04 Oh, he blames Biden for everything, you know? If he is constipated, he probably blames Biden. Whatever it is, he blames Biden. And, you know, it's getting old. It's really, really old.
22:12 Speaker 00 Well, he's getting old.
22:13 Speaker 04 And he needs to stop. Well, he is old and he's just saying the same thing over and over again. But anyway, I would like to see the Congress actually do a good job, a bipartisan good job, in holding their feet to the fire, demanding, we want to, we want to see the contract. We want to know who's working on it. We want to know if you have enough people at the FAA. If you don't, we want you to take some of that 11 and a half billion that is left and hire those people. We're not going to give you 50 billion more dollars until you give us a plan. Because the other question, Kara, which I also don't know the answer to, but needs to be asked, where is that money? Is part of it in the ballroom? Is part of it in the arch? Is part of it on ICE enforcement?
22:55 Speaker 04 The way that Trump treats the federal budget is like it's all in his checking account. He doesn't follow the law. He doesn't care what it's for. He doesn't really pay any attention to it.
23:06 Speaker 00 And there are some AI elements here. It's not really clear what happened, but one of the things I want to just stress is when they're like, we were trying to upgrade it and the old system didn't work. Well, you never blame the old system if the new system doesn't work. It's the new system's problem. And so they need to find out exactly what happened, which they will not do, but it's...
23:24 Speaker 04 But they have to be forced to do it. That's my point, Kara. This Congress, I really want them to be tough and disciplined, and I think some of this can be bipartisan. We depend upon our air traffic control system. We depend upon aviation in this country.
23:39 Speaker 00 Well, look what's happening to meat. What about meat and food?
23:42 Speaker 04 Oh, forget it. Well, they cut the number of inspections. They are poisoning us, they are endangering us, and the Congress needs to be our protectors and go after this administration.
23:55 Speaker 00 So, speaking of that, Democrats, now that they have the Senate, in January, they're fighting over who leads it. Very quickly, Maryland Senator Chris Van Hollen is challenging Chuck Schumer for Majority Leader. You said you're Team Chuck, but voters just made pretty clear that they want something new. And Van Hollen, there's back and forth between them, which is rather typical, I think. I mean, you've been in the Senate. You have said keeping him in charge at least until 2028 is important, but does that send a message that nothing's changed? And how do you assess what's happening here? I personally think it's healthy, but how do you look at it?
24:25 Speaker 04 Look, I think anybody has a right to challenge the leadership of their party. I mean, it should be an open process. And I know Chris and have worked with him, but at this point, from my perspective, the Majority Leader is not the messenger. How many times did you see John Thune on television defending or expousing a message? Their job is different. Their job is to push the committees, to mark up legislation, get it on the floor, get it passed, get it to the House, get it to the White House. I want somebody who knows how the ins and outs of the Senate, and just because you've
25:06 Speaker 04 been in the Senate, doesn't mean that you have the hands-on experience or the team in place to really pull those parliamentary levers. So at least for now, I think what voters were voting for were changes in their own life. I don't think half a percent of voters thought, oh, who's going to be the leader of the Democrats if I vote for a Democrat? What they thought of, I'm going to vote for the Democrats because they need to fix my cost of living and they need to fix the corruption, they need to end the war in Iran. So this leadership battle, to me, is kind of performance in a way because if you think that the Majority Leader of the Senate is going to replace the voices of people like
25:48 Speaker 04 James Talarico or Abdul El Sayed or Annie Andrews, you don't know what is going to happen in the Senate. The Majority Leader will work to get legislation up and he'll say, okay, Abdul, you want to put in Medicare for All and Adam Hamilton, that's not your preferred approach. You work with the legislative team here to come up with your, and let's figure out how we're going to get something passed.
26:13 Speaker 00 Right. So you think it's a lot of performative, like, do you, do you think he'll survive Schumer?
26:18 Speaker 04 Yeah, I do. I do. But who knows? I'm not there. I don't know.
26:23 Speaker 00 They work on you, like when you're a senator like that, like very quickly, what are they doing? What is Van Hollen doing versus Schumer?
26:28 Speaker 04 Chris is calling people and saying, we need to change, we need to show a different face to the electorate, the Democratic base is calling for this. I haven't been in leadership, I'm going to be a new voice. And Chuck is calling and saying, I raised X millions of dollars for you.
26:44 Speaker 00 All right, what are you doing? I have for you.
26:46 Speaker 04 Yeah, I helped you pass that piece of legislation that you wanted two years ago. And remember what we did when Biden was president and we didn't have the majority and we got all this stuff done and your name was on one of it. So, look, it's typical politics. Like, is sticking with the guy who brought you to the dance the best way to go forward? Or do you like the guy across the room who's giving you the eye? And people have to make up their own minds.
27:11 Speaker 00 Oh, my. Oh, dear, we're not on that. All right, Madam Secretary, let's go on a quick break. When we come back, we'll talk about whether anyone... Can actually regulate AI.
27:25 Speaker 00 Support for this show comes from Alloy Health. Shorter lashes, thinner brows, a hair part that keeps getting wider and more strands in the shower then seems possible. A lot of women don't connect this loss to their hormones, nor do they know it's actually treatable. If you're looking for a solution, you can find the treatment you need from Alloy. Almost 40% of women experience hair loss in menopause, so Alloy offers oral medications to treat female hair loss. You can start seeing thicker, fuller hair within three to six months. It's a complete solution for your scalp, lashes and brows, and is prescribed by doctors who specialize in exactly this. And you can get it delivered to your door, no insurance calls or trips to the pharmacy. With Alloy, your best hair isn't behind you.
28:07 Speaker 00 Visit myalloy.com and use the code ONWITHKARA to get 20% off your first order. Your menopause specialized doctor will tailor your care to your needs, plus you get $0 unlimited messaging with your doctor. That's M Y A L L O Y dot com with the code ONWITHKARA to get 20% off your first order. This code is valid on products only.
28:34 Speaker 00 Support for this show comes from the Freedom From Religion Foundation. On high stakes, Hillary and I talk about the choices shaping our democracy. Here's a fundamental one: who should hold power in America, the people, or religion? Our founders created a constitution that bars religious tests for public office, and the First Amendment protects your freedom to believe or not believe. Yet we're seeing a growing efforts to blur the line between religion and government, from public schools to public policy. When the government takes sides on religion, everyone's freedom is at risk. The Freedom From Religion Foundation works to keep state and church separate. F F R F also stands up for free thinkers, atheists, agnostics, and millions of nonreligious Americans whose voices deserve to be heard.
29:17 Speaker 00 Visit F F R F dot U S slash Kara or text K A R A to 511 511 to learn more or to join. Because protecting democracy means protecting freedom for everyone. Text Kara to 511 511 or go to F F R F dot U S slash Kara. Text fees may apply.
29:41 Speaker 01 I'm Josh Muccio, host of The Pitch, where startup founders raise millions and listeners can invest. For our sweet season 16, we're giving you more of what you love and less of what you don't. I definitely start to blank out when we're talking about like middleware AI wrappers. Software is out. Actual cool stuff is in. We've got consumer brands. We're building 8Sleep for daytime. Hardware that helps blind people see.
30:07 Speaker 06 They kept asking for middle finger. Next thing we knew, we had like 10 students running around flipping each other off.
30:13 Speaker 01 We've got deep tech to change the weather.
30:15 Speaker 02 Our big vision is to make it rain and snow on demand. What if you wanted to not make it rain somewhere else?
30:22 Speaker 01 Like, one day, we're just like, screw Arizona.
30:26 Speaker 01 And dairy? I never imagined my life journey would be milk. Season 16 of The Pitch is out now. Listen wherever you get your podcasts. This season is presented by Engine.
30:42 Speaker 00 Madam Secretary, we're back. For two years, the AI industry has operated with almost no oversight. Now Democrats are taking over Congress with a wave of AI bills and investigations of the industry's cozy ties to Trump. I want to talk about the regulation and whether anyone can actually rein these companies in. Let's start with the idea of this crash and a mortgage crisis and Too Big to Fail. That's, I think, the thing that's hanging over all of this.
31:05 Speaker 04 Well, and it should be. And I don't want to scare anybody listening or watching us because we're not there yet. But I have to ask you, Kara, you talk to lawmakers about AI. Do any of them understand the technology well enough to legislate it?
31:19 Speaker 00 Yes, I mean, they legislate planes, they legislate from, you know, I don't think that's the case. I think there's a lot of staffers that know what's going on. They're very up on this. They had the experience of social media where they didn't do anything, you know? Now, look, Amy Klobuchar is probably the most up to speed on it, and she's leaving. But I think they do. I think this idea, I think what happened is Orrin Hatch said something stupid. Remember when he said, essentially, how do you turn it on? And I think people have this idea. I get this all the time whenever I go places. I'm like, no, they do understand it. What they also understand is the money that tech companies put into campaigns now, right? And that's worrisome to them on some level.
31:56 Speaker 04 But I take a slightly different angle on this.
31:59 Speaker 00 Okay.
32:00 Speaker 04 I think they might understand the big strokes of what's at stake, and they might have some staff members who do. But what happens when somebody comes into your office, and this used to happen in my office all the time, an executive comes in, often with their lobbyists, their Washington representatives, and they basically say that what you think you understand, you don't understand. And here are all the reasons why, if you do what you're talking about doing, this will have the following terrible impact on the economy. So I don't think it's as much the campaign contributions, because most of those, frankly, have gone to the Republicans. I think it's more like, oh, my gosh, I don't want to do something that's going to crash
32:45 Speaker 04 the economy, and my staff is telling me one thing, and the companies and the experts they're bringing in are telling me something else. So maybe the safest thing is to do nothing. So part of what we have to figure out is how to get enough experience and expertise on the side of the lawmakers in both the Senate and the House, so they've got their own people, not just the usual staffers.
33:10 Speaker 00 But isn't that the age-old thing? You're going to, whether it's planes, whether it's cars, you're going to, don't do anything to carmakers because it's going to hurt us.
33:19 Speaker 04 Yeah, but there was enough experience over enough time. AI came out of, you know, Zeus's head five years ago. And all of a sudden, yeah, if you'd been in the tech world like you had been, you knew it was coming, you knew that it was around the corner, you knew that it was rooted in research that went back decades, you understood all of that. But that is not the way most Americans, including most lawmakers, thought about it. All of a sudden, oh, my gosh, there's this new technology. And they were just coming to grips with the fact that they hadn't done anything to protect kids and adults from social media, and that we had basically given up our data for free and been manipulated in return by the companies.
33:59 Speaker 04 And so I think that they don't yet have the confidence that comes by having experience. So they need to substitute that by having a team of experts that they can trust.
34:13 Speaker 00 I think that is in place more than you think. I don't.
34:16 Speaker 04 Well, I'm glad to hear that.
34:17 Speaker 00 I think the bloom is off the rose. And I think one of the things that'll be helpful is bringing them in to testify under real oath, not a Trump meeting.
34:26 Speaker 04 Yes, I agree with that.
34:27 Speaker 00 And it depends on which ones come. And it can't be a performative kind of thing that's happening here.
34:33 Speaker 04 Right.
34:33 Speaker 00 And if I had to pick, you obviously want to bring in Musk, but that'll just be a performative show, and he'll act like an asshole. My worry is that it gets, that they don't do serious looks at what's happening here, right? And that's the hard part, is that it becomes this performative hand-waving.
34:48 Speaker 04 But I think they should do closed-door hearings to start.
34:51 Speaker 00 Oh, interesting.
34:52 Speaker 04 Deprive, you know, somebody like Musk of the audience. Have them behind closed doors. This is a good way to get started. You do this behind closed doors, then you go into public. When you have an idea where these tech guys stand, who's going to be cooperative, who could be a partner. I mean, it wasn't so long ago that Sam Altman and Dario Amade were saying, regulate us, please, regulate us.
35:17 Speaker 00 But that's always, they do that because.
35:19 Speaker 04 But get them into a series of meetings, and whoever's representing them, say, okay, we're here, and we're now ready. Let's figure out, here's what we think needs to be done. You give us your response. I mean, this needs to be the hard work of legislating, and you're not going to get it done in a public hearing. The public hearing is to either hold people accountable or educate people about what is.
35:43 Speaker 00 Yeah, I think hearings on Doge are one thing, but this is not, this isn't how, I think you're right. We need a government that's very educated about AI, but it's very difficult when Trump is this coin-operated, takes money from them. Nobody learns anything anymore, right?
35:56 Speaker 04 That's right.
35:56 Speaker 00 Like, how to do it. And I think, I do think at their heart, most of the tech people do want sensible legislation. I think they want none, and if they want some, they want sensible legislation. I think personally, Congress is the one that hasn't done its work, right? Ultimately, it's their own fault, and they are scared of the money. They really are. Amy Klobuchar can tell you a story, you know, she had things almost passed, and then suddenly she'll get a call.
36:21 Speaker 04 From a senator, I can't do it because, you know, they're killing me in the state. And that's the difficulty. I just want to clarify, you're not talking about the money that they only would get for themselves. You're talking about the money that the tech companies spend against them, which is scary. You know, you're, they're running ads. They're, they're, they're calling, you know, CEOs in the company saying, your senator, your congressman is going to crater the AI market. And there goes the S and P. You better be careful. So it is, it is not always the, the, the sort of easy caricature, like, oh, they've got their hands out. No, it's also like, you're getting pummeled. You're going to get primary.
37:03 Speaker 00 Yes, that's what she said. Like, there was two or three senators with her that were against her. Now, on a much larger scale, as Secretary of State, you negotiate with adversaries over nuclear weapons. But with AI weapons, the companies building them are moving faster than a government can. And they're the ones doing negotiation. Has that regulation window passed? Are you worried? Like, when you, when you think about this, you would think this is something like, I can see that Besen and Rubio are very concerned about the chips, right? Essentially, they're screaming in public, from what I can tell. But has the regulation window passed? Or we have two more years of Trump. And if they can't convince him and someone else can, if Lutnick comes out on top, which is frightening, what, what do you do as a, in Congress, for example?
37:47 Speaker 00 Or, or if you're Marco Rubio, if you're Marco Rubio?
37:50 Speaker 04 I don't think the regulation window has passed, but I agree that unless we have a systematic effort to really figure out what the regulation will be, number one, in our own country, and then try to figure out how to work with the rest of the world, most particularly China, it could pass. Now, I do think that there can be a strategy. If you could persuade, like you said, there are tech leaders who know better, who would go for, quote, sensible, smart regulation. If we could focus on them, and there's, there's a handful of them, I think, if we could focus on them and get them on some kind of agreed pathway,
38:34 Speaker 04 then you could go to Trump. And you could say to Trump, look, a majority of the major companies are on board with doing something. We can either try to do it despite you or around you. This could be something that could be passed, you know, with a veto proof majority, if it's done right. But we don't want to do that. We'd love to have the president on board. And so we've got these guys who've given to your ballroom. They show up at your dinners. They ride on your plane, all of that. So why don't you join with us on that? And you know what? We'll do our best to bring in the outliers, and you can help there, too. There's an argument to be made, but you got to do the work to figure out what is the argument, number one.
39:17 Speaker 04 But number two, how many Republicans can you get on board? And the one thing, you remember, like, I think it was two years ago, there was a big move to preempt state regulation of social media and AI.
39:30 Speaker 00 Yeah.
39:31 Speaker 04 And it came after I and others worked with Kathy Hochul in New York, and then we, you know, had-
39:36 Speaker 00 California, yeah.
39:37 Speaker 04 California. And there was a big reaction by the tech companies. I can understand their argument, which is like, we don't want 50 different rules will then help us get one. But nevertheless, they were responding negatively. And the Senate blocked a bill about preemption. It was totally bipartisan. And it was pretty amazing because everybody thought, well, Ted Cruz is, you know, bulldozing it through. They've got a majority of Republicans. But it was a bipartisan blockage. I think there are enough Republicans who see that this has got such national security and economic threats attached to it.
40:15 Speaker 00 And public, and public interest.
40:16 Speaker 04 Yeah. And so I, I don't think the time has passed.
40:19 Speaker 00 Okay. All right. All right, Madam Secretary, one more quick break. We'll be back to talk about the data centers no one seems to want in their backyard.
40:29 Speaker 00 Support for this show comes from Airwallex. Can your business keep up with the gigantic speed? Airwallex powers automated financial operations that help optimize how your company receives, spends, and manages its money. Take an e-commerce startup whose product just went viral. Orders pour in overnight from London in pounds and Tokyo in yen, collected in local currency through Airwallex without the friction of international wires. Then the startup pays its factory in Toronto and its packaging supplier in Mexico City. It uses Airwallex to pay in local currency at bank beating FX rates to more than 200 countries and regions, and Airwallex flags anything over a startup's spending limit. The startup ships their orders. Airwallex handles the money behind them.
41:12 Speaker 00 That's Airwallex' Agentic Global Business Account in action. More than 675,000 businesses already trust Airwallex directly or through their platform customers. Head to airwallex.com/go-global to get started. That's airwallex, with an X, dot com slash go global. Airwallex U.S. LLC is a licensed money transmitter in most states and not a bank. Terms and conditions apply.
41:42 Speaker 00 Support for this show comes from Hers. Losing weight on your own can feel like an uphill battle. Weight loss by Hers offers access to the FDA-approved Wegovy pill and the Wegovy pen. People lost an average of 14% of their body weight at 64 weeks in a clinical trial of Wegovy alongside diet and exercise. To get started with Wegovy, just go to forhers.com and complete an online consultation with a licensed provider who will determine if a prescription is appropriate. And with Hers, nutrition and lifestyle guidance are part of the plan, along with access to 24/7 messaging with your care team. Ready to reach your goals? Visit forhers.com/kara to access personalized, affordable care for weight loss, hair, menopause, and more. Individual results may vary,
42:26 Speaker 00 and stopping treatment may result in weight regain. Weight loss by Hers is not available in all 50 states. Wegovy is a registered trademark of Novo Nordisk AS. To get started and learn more, including important safety information, Wegovy clinical study information, and restrictions, visit forhers.com.
42:49 Speaker 00 Running a business shouldn't feel like surviving a software group project. One app for accounting, another for inventory, another for sales, and somehow, none of them talk to each other. That's where Odoo comes in, an all-in-one business management software that brings every part of your business together. From sales and accounting to inventory and marketing, all in one powerful platform. No messy integrations, no bouncing between tabs, and best of all, no spreadsheets. Stop managing software and start managing your business with one unified system. Try for free today at Odoo.com/vox. That's O-D-O-O dot com slash vox.
43:27 Speaker 00 Madam Secretary, we're back. That dovetails perfectly. In this election, 56% of voters said data centers were a crucial and major factor in how they voted. Three out of four said they oppose building one in their own community. That said, Wall Street analysis estimates only 2% to 4% of planned data centers will actually be canceled. So talk about, you know, what happens in this situation with these newly elected candidates who have, when these projects break ground, new governor, Democrat Amy Acton of Ohio, supports conditional data center moratorium. She wants data centers to pay all their own utility costs and use union labor. There's all manner of people that are sort of shifting slightly, I've noticed, right? They're not anti-data center. Talarico is another one. And obviously, the AI industry poured millions of dollars into super PACs and dark money groups this cycle
44:11 Speaker 00 and still lost, but it still has money. So I perceive it changing, like, especially in the messaging that Democrats are doing and moving slightly back to the center a little bit. And I'm not so sure the people are with them in that regard because they're so angry. How do you look at that? Because we do have to build, we can't not, it's like every, living causes environmental damage, everyone being here. How do you shift that idea in a safer way?
44:40 Speaker 04 Look, I think part of what I'm hearing from people like Amy and Gina Hinahosa is there have already been contracts let. There have already been agreements provided, like it or not, which I don't, by county commissioners and city council members. And so there are some data centers that have already been, quote, approved, right? And to undo that approval process will be a very lengthy litigation, unlikely to win, because the data center folks can come in and say, we did everything we were supposed to do. Now, it wasn't enough, and it was too much in bed with the data centers, there's no doubt about that.
45:25 Speaker 04 But, you know, we went to the county commission. We went to the city council. We did the zoning. We da, da, da. So I think what Gina Hinahosa has said is in Texas, which has more than any state right now, she's not going to fight the ones that have already been approved, but she's going to take a hard look at any new approvals. I can understand that. I think that is like a way of trying to split the baby, so to speak. I think what Amy Acton has said in Ohio is, we are not going to allow it to move forward unless they make these provisions to protect water, pay for electricity, union labor, all of that. I think that these are decisions, kind of looking at the reality of where we are.
46:09 Speaker 04 So nothing is going to move forward until there's changes.
46:13 Speaker 00 Right. And I think Abbott was declaring that, like, that they want to figure out, which is really interesting. I do think, one of the things, I guess fascinating, listening to their language, they understand these things have to move forward on some level because we do need them in this country. It's just a question of how we do it. And I think when you have the face of it being an Elon Musk or, or Kevin O'Leary, who it seems so like the Monopoly Man, right? You know, I mean, he looks like a Monopoly Man. Like, it becomes very offensive to voters. But I do think, at their heart, people are furious. They still are. I get letter after letter. They, they feel used, they feel angry, whether it's an environmental issue. Sometimes it's environmental with people. Sometimes it's, why are my rates higher? Sometimes it's, why do these guys get everything? Right?
46:58 Speaker 00 That kind of thing that they want. And so it's super complex.
47:01 Speaker 04 But Kara, if we had a real government, which we don't have, we would have a process with really tough standards. And we could get money out of these companies. And it's not just the usual suspects. It's the hyperscalers, it's companies you've never heard of that are building these data centers. We could get money to fix our grid. We could get money to lower electric rates by changing utility law that they would be forced to support. There's so much we could have gotten. So it's not just that people feel rightly, they always get what they want. We haven't put up a fight. We haven't stood there and said, okay, we may need X number of data centers, but here's what you're going to have to give us.
47:41 Speaker 00 Well, it's not a dialogue. And I think that's what bothers people, is that it's just imposed upon them. And, and then it's very easy then. For the media, which I think has done a pretty good job covering this, honestly. But it's, you know, that picture of the thing making noise, right? Here I am in my home, trying to enjoy my dinner, and this thing is humming away, right? Which was also annoying to people.
48:02 Speaker 04 Well, you know, the spinning of a windmill sometime does the same thing.
48:06 Speaker 00 That scares Donald Trump, you know, the windmills.
48:08 Speaker 04 Well, apparently so, but.
48:10 Speaker 00 Are you scared of windmills? I need to know.
48:13 Speaker 04 I'm not, I'm not scared. I actually like windmills. But I, I think, just to kind of wrap this part of our conversation up, it does seem to me that people feel like their representatives just basically gave in. The big guys showed up. They didn't know how to negotiate. They didn't know what to ask for. They just got it, got run over. We don't have, in many places, they didn't have a governor. It was all done at the local level. So there was no backup power that could have come in to make a better deal. And we had no federal government that cared about it.
48:44 Speaker 00 They have spoken.
48:45 Speaker 04 So it's all one sided. It's so unfair.
48:47 Speaker 00 Well, what they're trying to do now, instead of trying to work with the people, they want to do, move data centers offshore into the ocean, on the moon, like just, they just can't stop these people.
48:58 Speaker 04 They can't stop, and that, and so we need a law.
49:00 Speaker 00 This is Peter Thiel, who's investing in things like that.
49:02 Speaker 04 You can't do that unless we approve either.
49:04 Speaker 00 Right, that's right. Not the moon? You don't want it on the moon?
49:07 Speaker 04 I don't want it on the moon.
49:08 Speaker 00 You know what's going to happen? They're going to put it up there and somehow they're going to break the moon apart or blow it up. And then it's going to, we're going to be in moonfall. That Halle Berry movie.
49:16 Speaker 04 Oh, my God, and all the green cheese will float away.
49:19 Speaker 00 Don't you see it? This is exactly, this is like such a.
49:21 Speaker 04 Oh, but they're also talking about data centers on platforms, not just on the moon, but circulating around up there, being hit by asteroids or meteors. I mean, this is crazy talk. Half the time, it's just, it's like you, you imagine these guys sitting around, I don't know if they drink or they, you know, smoke weed or whatever they do.
49:42 Speaker 00 They don't drink enough. That's what I say.
49:44 Speaker 04 They don't drink enough, you know?
49:45 Speaker 00 They do other things enough, and they need to shift to a good whiskey. Anyway, let's go on a quick break. When we come back, Nobel Peace Prize winner Maria Ressa joins us with her take on AI.
50:00 Speaker 00 Life can be messy and complicated, especially during the holidays. One thing that isn't, switching to the Simplicity Plan from Verizon. It's one plan, one price. Just $30 a line per month, for you or the whole family. Make the simple choice this season. Switch to Verizon and shop their best holiday deals today.
50:22 Speaker 00 When the holidays start to feel a bit repetitive, reach for a Sprite Winter Spiced Cranberry. And put your twist on tradition. A bold cranberry and winter spice flavor fusion? Sprite Winter Spiced Cranberry is a refreshing way to shake things up this sipping season. And only for a limited time. Sprite, obey your thirst. Get unlimited access to Bloomberg.com for global business news, expert analysis, and market insights. For a limited time, save 65% on your first year during our best offer of 2026. That's 65% off your first year. Subscribe now at Bloomberg.com.
51:04 Speaker 00 Madam Secretary, we're back. Nobel Prize winning journalist Maria Ressa was among the first to warn that the algorithms behind social media could be weaponized against democracy. And now she's sounding the same alarm about AI. She co-chairs a global panel on AI's risks and is the author of a new book, The Fight Back: A Citizen's Guide to Standing Up to Dictators. That is quite a title, Maria. How you doing? I'm tired of the standing up to dictators part. I bet. I'm doing, hey! You like to sit down to dictators.
51:33 Speaker 04 Yeah, she's standing up, she's fighting back, she's trying to get all of us to understand what's going on with the developments in AI. Because as you said, Cara, Maria was really one of the very first, along with you, who recognized the threats. And she saw it from the angle of what was happening, number one, with the radicalization of young men by Islamist jihadists, ideology through technology, mostly through social media. She wrote a book about that. And then she saw it firsthand in the Philippines, which became kind of ground zero for Facebook experimentation about how to influence and manipulate people.
52:14 Speaker 04 So I wanted to ask, here we are, 2026, 10 years ago. What did Manila show you in 2016 that frankly, Washington and America refused to see?
52:27 Speaker 00 I mean, so first, for the two of you, you know, one of the first, after all of the law cases, Hillary, you were one of the first to sound the alarm, and we felt we weren't alone. But Cara, you know, I had, at a certain point, by 2016, 2017, I had spoken to maybe 50 people simultaneously in different ways in Facebook. So I had just come from San Jose, and I realized I had spoken to both Mark Zuckerberg and Sheryl Sandberg and a bunch of other folks, many of them gone now. Nick Ren, a former CNNer, also was there, you know? And I realized nobody was really taking it seriously. They were not. And I thought, if I spoke with you, that maybe you could actually help me sound the alarm.
53:10 Speaker 00 And that was so many years ago. I feel you've both have heard me say Cassandra and Sisyphus, and I hate the fact that now we're coming up and we just keep going to the same place. The two dictators, for, at least for me, right? At least I've gotten rid of one. Well, not me, my country. Now you have to handle it. But the other dictator has absolute impunity. But I turned to both of you for help at the time when I thought I could have gone to jail or worse, right?
53:41 Speaker 04 Explain for our audience, Maria, what you were seeing and, and what was happening in the Philippines? Because many Americans don't know. And it really was the first place in the world that so clearly was being manipulated. But give us some background, why you were alarmed, why you reached out to me, why you reached out to Cara and sought her help?
54:00 Speaker 00 Because I was getting an average in 2016, by August 2016, an average of 90, 9-0, 8 messages per hour. And at that point, I felt like we were fighting two dictators.
54:14 Speaker 04 And who were they? Who were those two dictators?
54:16 Speaker 00 Rodrigo Duterte was starting a brutal drug war. And he, he basically took Facebook and came bottom up with these 98 messages per hour. The other dictator was Mark Zuckerberg, because I had appealed to them repeatedly about how the platform was being used. We could see it. You know, when you're the target, you know what's happening. Everyone else can kind of turn a blind eye. And when I was both the target, I was running our business, and I was building our tech. And I realized, this is a design thing. And that's when I realized that Duterte gave cover to the platforms. They weaponized the law. While the platforms, the tech oligarchy, so they're
55:01 Speaker 00 both oligarchs in many ways, right? The tech oligarchy then actually spread the message. It was a matter of spreading fear, anger, hate. It was insidious manipulation in the service of Duterte in my country. So we began working against both. We took a look at all the data, because it's coming at me, I didn't have to ask Facebook. And we then began to map and chart it. And I think, Cara, that's when I went to you. Yeah, so what was the reaction? What was the, Duterte is, you know, a singular figure. He's like your real life dictator, so he's not going to respond to you. But at the time, Facebook's just a company. What was their response to you? Because they told me I was overreacting. That's what I recall hearing from them.
55:44 Speaker 00 What was your, what was your experience with them? They told me to report it. You know, 98 messages per hour, there weren't enough hours in the day to keep reporting it. Over time, what wound up happening was I pulled the data, I showed it to them. Most of the people outside of Silicon Valley, outside of Menlo Park, are salespeople. They're the ones selling the product to us. So finally, we began doing stories on it. And we began showing the data. And that was when it really, it really started. I would say that time period when Chris Cox resigned temporarily before he came back in, right? I was at that meeting. It's way past the non-exposure for that. Thank God!
56:27 Speaker 00 But by the time Cambridge Analytica came around, the whistleblower and Cambridge Analytica itself only verified what we were living through. And so I was really surprised by America kind of fudging it. And for us here, the whistleblower told us, he was specific, he called us the Petri dish, that they tested tactics of mass manipulation in the Philippines. And if it worked here, they then. Ported it over to you, the target. That was the 2016 election.
56:58 Speaker 04 Meaning you were the canary in the coal mine of this kind of thing. I think that's what I called it at the time. Maria, we have learned a lot of lessons about what has happened the last 10 years. I'm not sure enough people have learned them and we haven't implemented the kind of regulatory framework that we still need, although we're chipping away in the United States on the state level. But now we're in the world of AI. And we have seen a big collapse in the trust people have for AI, which is even faster than when they finally woke up about social media. But we're not taking it seriously the way we need to in terms of national and international
57:42 Speaker 04 efforts to put some guardrails up here. So what are we about to get wrong again? Because, you know, we allowed this mass experiment with social media to manipulate not just children, but adults as well. And now we've got an even more powerful form of technology. So how do you want us to think about it? Because it has to be driven from the United States. That's other than China, where the major platforms reside. And also, how's it playing out in the Philippines with AI, with this current dictatorship?
58:14 Speaker 00 Of course, when OpenAI came out, right? We were in the top five countries in terms of use, of adoption.
58:20 Speaker 04 The Philippines.
58:22 Speaker 00 Yeah, the Philippines. In the fight back, I literally come at what we need to do, right? We need top down, so the leaders. That's part of the reason I do the United Nations Independent International Scientific Panel on AI. Joshua Benjo and I co-chair that. But there are 40 of us from 37 different countries. And we come down with, like, here are the facts. That's what the UN mandated for us. But below that, in order to help the leaders who are trying to put these laws in place, you need to have people come bottom up. And that's part of why, you know, I spend the first three part. It is understand, the first part. The second part is defend. And the last part is build. Those are the three things we need to do. Understand, defend, build.
59:07 Speaker 00 And we need to actually look at this as an entire artificial intelligence from social media, which hacked our attention to chatbots, right? The end goal was to keep you chatting. So what did they do? This isn't Star Trek, you know, where you say, computer, turn this on or give me the data. Here, they pretend to be real people.
59:31 Speaker 04 Well, they do on Star Trek a little bit. A lot of the sci-fi has that, right? That they're having a relationship with you.
59:37 Speaker 00 Oh, the later ones, but I'm talking the James Bliss one. That was me.
59:41 Speaker 04 Yeah.
59:42 Speaker 00 But in terms of, you know, Captain Kirk, Mr. Spock, it is, computer, give me this data. And I think that's part of what's wrong with the chatbots now is that when you pretend to be human, it then acts as a caregiver. It acts as your psychologist. It is sycophantic by design, just like social media was designed to keep you scrolling. This is designed to keep you chatting. And of course, we've had the first cases against the chatbots. And we haven't gone to the last one, which is really what we're all concerned about because it's moved so fast, the agentic. So if the first one hacked our attention, this one hacked intimacy, the chatbots. The very last one hacks agency itself.
1:00:27 Speaker 00 We, it acts for us. And yet, from the panel in July.
1:00:31 Speaker 04 The UN panel, right?
1:00:32 Speaker 00 The UN panel. We stated that no one, not any of the people who are making this, can control what they're making. And there's absolutely no accountability for the harms that it's causing at the UNGA with the Security Council. From the scientific panel, Joshua Benjo stated that if a human did what the agents did, it would be criminal. Right? So that's, our biggest problem is that we now have some system of, of laws to stop the impunity. Look at where my former president, Is Rodrigo Duterte, has been arrested. He's at The Hague.
1:01:13 Speaker 00 His trial for crimes against humanity begins November 30th. But the other dictator, Mark Zuckerberg, has just become more powerful, richer. In Brazil, which just had elections, they were fighting, their two dictators were Donald Trump and Mark Zuckerberg. Different name, no longer Facebook, now Meta.
1:01:36 Speaker 04 So can I ask you, you're using a really loaded word dictator, right? There's a lot of words running around the world right now that I would say genocide is one of them. Why do you use the term dictator? Now, I use the term monarch, you know, because you have to, I don't want to be careful. You know I don't. But talk about why you think it's a dictatorship over, you know, these, these people who have impunity. I think they are post-government. You're seeing it play out right now with the firing or the departure of Jensen Huang at Nvidia. They can't tolerate that he got removed for good reason. Why the word dictator?
1:02:09 Speaker 00 I mean, I'll start from what I know, which is that when I was going to Facebook, I could convince people inside to realize the harms that were happening. But inevitably, over the years, I was always told it goes all the way up to Mark Zuckerberg. And he's not elected, and yet he decides what my country of 110 million people at that point in time, what we were subjected to. It turned the incentive structure upside down of people, of governments, of, of the, how many billions, right? 3.2 billion people at that time. And then the other reason I say dictator is that he also isn't alone. And this I say in Chapter 2, the Unholy Alliance is the chapter title.
1:02:54 Speaker 00 Because when you put Mark Zuckerberg with Elon Musk, with Peter Thiel, right? And you look at the authoritarian stack. Authoritarian is a nicer way to take dictator.
1:03:05 Speaker 04 Oligarch.
1:03:05 Speaker 00 Oligarch. When you look at this, right? It's so familiar to me. I live in the Philippines and what I see, and here's a perfect example of it. Peter Thiel funds the campaigns of JD Vance, of Donald Trump. They get elected. Their large numbers, right? For JD Vance, it was the first time that $15 million was spent by one person in a senatorial election. Once they get elected, we begin to see contracts coming out. You see this, you see the revolving door of the CEOs walking into Pcast. But what happens after they get the contracts? When they get the contracts, someone like Peter Thiel said as early as 2009, that democracy
1:03:50 Speaker 00 is only a thin skin. And that once they have the contracts, have the data, and are the ones operating these systems, who really does have the power?
1:04:01 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:04:02 Speaker 00 You know, it's funny because Silicon Valley says, this is innovation.
1:04:06 Speaker 04 Right.
1:04:06 Speaker 00 This is very familiar to me in the Philippines. We call this corruption.
1:04:10 Speaker 04 Hillary, what do you think of that word?
1:04:12 Speaker 00 Dictator.
1:04:13 Speaker 04 I understand why Maria is using it because it is descriptive for the experience that, as she said, she lived in the Philippines. Because the way that Duterte used Facebook to manipulate the population was really on a big scale the first time. I mean, we had the problems with Facebook and the terrible attacks on the Rohingya, and there were a few other examples. But the cozy relationship between how Duterte saw Facebook as a tool of his dictatorship
1:04:53 Speaker 04 and despite warnings and pleas to Facebook at the time, that was ignored. And you can say, well, they were not believing it. They didn't understand the implications. They just wanted to make money. And Facebook at the time had its largest per capita audience in the Philippines. It was stunning. Not only how many people of all ages in the Philippines were on Facebook. It was their news source, it was their community source, and it was the manipulative tool of the dictatorship. So I think after a certain time, you have to kind of say, people are like the company they keep. And if you're running a big company that is being used to facilitate the dictatorship
1:05:38 Speaker 04 of a country, maybe of more in common than not. We can call authoritarian, we can call a lot of other things, but it's really the unaccountable power. But I want to really drill down on something with Maria because you're in the Philippines, you know Asia well. The response anytime any of us, whether it's Cara, me, or somebody else, says, we need to have sensible, smart regulation of AI, just like we needed of social media. The answer is, oh, my God, then China's going to win. What are you? I mean, you're, you're clearly naive or you're complicitous in letting, you know, China win the AI race. How do you respond to that, Maria? Because that is the argument that everybody, and if the Democratic Congress tries to
1:06:23 Speaker 04 regulate, starting in January, that's what they're going to run up against. So give us your analysis, but also your response.
1:06:30 Speaker 00 Yeah, so I think that's the boogeyman in a huge tech lobby. Yes, it's been used repeatedly. I would say there's two other words that have been used by the tech lobby that I almost ban in, at least we don't use it in Rapppler. We use disinformation because of narrative warfare, because of information warfare. We don't use misinformation because when people get misled, not as much of a problem as the way people are bombarded with narrative warfare, right? Because when that narrative warfare splinters reality, that then leads to that next phase, which happened in our country, happened in yours. It's the hollowing out of institutions that leads to the bottom of the funnel, which we live with.
1:07:14 Speaker 00 It's strategic corruption and kleptocracy. So for me, China as a boogeyman, well, you know what? Like, we've done work with China. And when you look at the regulations and the safety measures they put for their own people, there are certainly far more safety measures there, except they keep saying, Maria, you should say that more often. And I'm like, if you add Tiananmen Square into your AI, it would be really good. I may say it more often. But you know, TikTok, right? That the Chinese version of TikTok has safety measures for teenagers. These safety measures are just being introduced in the States right now, maybe, right? The UK is just starting to do that. But that's been there for years already.
1:07:56 Speaker 04 We only have a few more minutes, but a couple of things you want to do, strip out a dictator.
1:08:00 Speaker 00 Features for everyone, not only teens. And is there any AI tool you can trust? Because one of the things I got, you hate AI. I'm like, I absolutely do not. Well, so the first one is every single person that is watching or listening or using any of the technology, everyone feels like they have learned helplessness. They're not enough. But you have to realize that when you are the target, when it is your data that is being taken by a predatory and extractive industry, that you do have power. And that's part of it. This is the first step in the two dictators. Chapter one, count how many hours you spend on screens in the first seven days while you're reading the book. And the second one, delete one app, the one hopefully that makes you angry. So that's bottom up.
1:08:44 Speaker 00 There's a lot more, 100 tactical steps. Top down, let's start with frontier models, right? The very first thing is the, and I hope we do this through the United Nations. There are several countries that are putting this together. Democracia siempre, Lula will play a huge role in this. He was one of the folks. How did they win in Serbia, in Brazil, in Hungary? They moved out of the virtual world, from the design of that tech into the physical world. And they organized and mobilized. Oh, yeah, that's also what happened in the US. But what do they need to do? The frontier model. Mandatory reporting, huge fines, not little 1% of their annual revenue, but huge fines if they don't.
1:09:28 Speaker 00 Every single escape, every single hack that the agents have done has been reported by the victim, not the company that knows it's happening. So mandatory reporting. I think a second one, and this is me, not as part of the panel, because we're not supposed to give you the solutions. But the other part is a mandatory kill switch, right? Where will it go? Which is difficult technologically. It is. But Kara, you know this. If they were held accountable, instead of having sheer impunity, they would find ways. Right, right. Hillary, last question.
1:10:02 Speaker 04 Well, Maria, when the UN comes out with its report, which I guess is toward the end of this year.
1:10:07 Speaker 00 It's the final one in May, but this year we will come out with, we just did the hugging face thematic brief on agents.
1:10:15 Speaker 04 And will you be going around the world, briefing governments, briefing our new Congress, trying to brief the Trump administration, brief some of the big states like New York, Illinois, California, that have passed some legislation anyway to try to restrain AI, to try to give everybody a big push, starting right after the first of the year to get
1:10:35 Speaker 00 Yeah.
1:10:35 Speaker 04 going with some kind of effort at a regulatory framework. And then the second part of that is, will you be urging that the United States and China, unlike what Trump is doing on his way to China, and not going to mention Nvidia, he's not going to mention AI, that we need an international framework as well as national frameworks?
1:10:55 Speaker 00 With China? Absolutely, absolutely on both, right? So on November 23, there's a safety summit that's being held in Barbados. It'll probably be one of the last acts of Secretary General Gutierrez, along with Mia Motley. And they're bringing together not just tech guys, but also the panel and also the civil society, right? So many discussions don't have the people who are the ones that are not just the products, but also the ones that are where the harms happen. So the first is the safety becomes important, is an imperative by design. I think we can begin to do this.
1:11:37 Speaker 00 And call me optimistic, but I hope that the UN plays a massive role on a multilateral solution, because one country alone can't do that. And then Hillary, in terms of what the US government wants, we've been trying forever. And I think now with the scientific panel, if you look at the July preliminary report, the facts are clear. Lesson I learned when we were actually briefing the member countries in Geneva in July, most of them had only spoken to the men, largely men, who were selling them the products, selling them the tech. That's what all the advisory panels are made up of.
1:12:14 Speaker 04 Yeah, that's why we need you, Maria.
1:12:15 Speaker 00 I have one more suggestion. Can you give Trump your Nobel Peace Prize? And maybe, and have him do what you want? Just give it to him. Like, it's okay.
1:12:28 Speaker 04 But drive a harder bargain.
1:12:30 Speaker 00 Yeah, what do you think? What do you think? I mean, you'll save humanity. I mean, you don't need that medal, right? You're so funny. You know, the hard part in all of it is how the words have been turned upside down. Yeah. And how we would even have to deal with something like this. Can we restore? I'm thinking of a short term solution, Maria. I know. You don't need that medal. It's very gaudy. I don't know what to tell you. Anyway, Maria's, it's heavy. He can handle it. Maria's new book, and maybe he'll fall over when he's wearing it. Maria's new book is called The Fight Back: A Citizen's Guide to Standing Up to Dictators. Maria, thank you so much.
1:13:07 Speaker 04 Thank you, Maria.
1:13:09 Speaker 00 Thank you both for everything. Anyway, I appreciate your thoughts. That's really important to be talking about these issues. But now we have to go.
1:13:18 Speaker 04 Oh.
1:13:19 Speaker 00 Are we going to be back, Hillary?
1:13:20 Speaker 04 I'll be back, no matter where we are.
1:13:22 Speaker 00 Okay. This is a beautiful friendship, I think, and relationship. And I think people really appreciate it. So I'm very excited to keep talking to you.
1:13:29 Speaker 04 Me too.
1:13:30 Speaker 00 Me too. Thanks for everything and thanks for everyone for listening. Today's show was produced by Lara Naaman, Madeline LaPlante-Douby. Our editors are Manolo Moreno and Brandon McFarlane. Rosemarie Ho provided fact checking. Nick Merrill was in charge of more cowbell. Thanks also to Art Chung, Abby Krynsky, Joe Nebrous, Renee Betterson, and Anna Casey. Nishat Kurwaz, Vox Media's executive producer of podcasts. Make sure to follow us on your favorite podcast platform. Thanks for listening to High Stakes from Vox Media. Hillary, I can't wait to talk to you again.
1:14:04 Speaker 04 Thanks.
1:14:22 Speaker 00 Support for this show comes from Alloy Health. Skin changes are a part of life. One way to treat them is to address your hormones, specifically estrogen loss. Alloy's M4 Skincare, made specifically for women in perimenopause and beyond, can help. Try M4 Skincare from Alloy and see results in as little as eight weeks. Head to myalloy.com and use the code ONWITHKARA to get 20% off your first order. Your menopause specialized doctor will help you build a skincare plan for your needs. Plus, you get $0 unlimited messaging with your doctor. That's M Y A L L O Y dot com using code ONWITHKARA to get 20% off your first order. The code is valid on products only.
1:15:06 Speaker 00 These are compounded products, not subject to FDA approval.
1:15:11 Speaker 01 I'm Josh Mucio, host of The Pitch, where startup founders raise millions and listeners can invest. For our sweet season 16, we're giving you more of what you love and less of what you don't.
1:15:23 Speaker 00 I definitely start to blank out when we're talking about like middleware AI wrappers.
1:15:28 Speaker 01 Software is out. Actual cool stuff is in. We've got consumer brands. We're building 8Sleep for daytime. Hardware that helps blind people see.
1:15:38 Speaker 06 They kept asking for middle finger. Next thing we knew, we had like 10 students running around flipping each other off.
1:15:43 Speaker 01 We've got deep tech to change the weather.
1:15:45 Speaker 02 Our big vision is to make it rain and snow on demand.
1:15:49 Speaker 06 What if you wanted to not make it rain somewhere else? Like, one day, we're just like, screw Arizona.
1:15:56 Speaker 01 And dairy? I never imagined my life journey would be milk. Season 16 of The Pitch is out now. Listen wherever you get your podcasts. This season is presented by Engine.
1:16:09 Speaker 00 Running a business shouldn't feel like surviving a software group project. One app for accounting, another for inventory, another for sales, and somehow, none of them talk to each other. That's where Odoo comes in, an all-in-one business management software that brings every part of your business together. From sales and accounting to inventory and marketing, all in one powerful platform. No messy integrations, no bouncing between tabs, and best of all, no spreadsheets. Stop managing software and start managing your business with one unified system. Try for free today at Odoo.com/vox. That's O D O O dot com slash vox.
Previous Priya Parker on Family Friction, Holiday Tension and Better Conflict Page updated November 19, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated