Pod Insights Office Ladies Is Toby the Scranton Strangler? With Paul Lieberstein About this episode Is Toby is the Scranton Strangler?? This week on Office Ladies 6.0 the ladies discuss this very popular fan theory! In old school debate style, they each take a side and present their case. Angela vs Jenna. Angela says that Toby IS the Scranton Strangler and Jenna argues that he is NOT. With the help of many “Office Ladies” fans writing in with their theories and the ladies' own deep-divey research, this debate gets heated! Sam becomes the impromptu judge and Cassi serves as the debate expert but ultimately we needed to hear from Paul Lieberstein aka Toby Flenderson himself. He joins the ladies in the studio to answer this fan theory once and for all! Is Toby the Scranton Strangler? We want to hear your thoughts! We hope you enjoy this episode, we never knew we could have so much fun talking about Toby.
Check out Paul Liberstein’s Audible show “Middlespace: The Rebels Attack, And Then Other Side Attacks as Well” https://www.audible.com/podcast/Middlespace-The-Rebels-Attack-And-Then-The-Other-Side-Attacks-As-Well/B09L37JVBC
Check out Office Ladies Merch at Podswag:https://www.podswag.com/collections/office-ladies
Office Ladies Website - Submit a fan question:https://officeladies.com/submitaquestion
Follow Us on Instagram:OfficeLadiesPod https://www.instagram.com/officeladiespod/
Transcript 10,539 words · 6 speakers
0:04 Speaker 00 I'm Jenna Fischer.
0:05 Speaker 01 And I'm Angela Kinsey.
0:06 Speaker 00 We were on The Office together.
0:08 Speaker 01 And we're best friends.
0:09 Speaker 00 And now we're doing the ultimate Office Lovers podcast just for you. Each week, we will dive deeper into the world of The Office with exclusive interviews, behind the scenes details, and lots of BFF stories. We're the Office Lady 6.0.
0:25 Speaker 00 Hello.
0:26 Speaker 01 Hi.
0:27 Speaker 00 Happy New Year.
0:28 Speaker 01 It's 2025.
0:30 Speaker 00 Woohoo.
0:31 Speaker 01 We did it. We all made it through the holidays.
0:36 Speaker 00 We have a fun episode today.
0:39 Speaker 01 I was so excited in prepping this. I got really excited, lady. I even stood up. I paced. I said things out loud.
0:46 Speaker 00 Really? Oh, should we tell people what we're doing?
0:49 Speaker 01 Yes. All right, the inspiration for today's episode comes straight from the Office fandom. You know, we have been digging online and we have found a lot of Office fan theories. You name it. You guys all have an origin idea about something on the show. So, based on one of the most popular fan theories that you shared with us, we're gonna do a little detective work. A little mom detective work.
1:16 Speaker 00 Mm-hmm.
1:17 Speaker 01 Jenna, what are we mom detective-ing?
1:21 Speaker 00 Detective-ing?
1:22 Speaker 01 There it is.
1:22 Speaker 00 Yeah. Today, we are finally tackling the question, is Toby the Scranton strangler? Yes, and we asked you to write in and give us your theories and opinions. Thank you so much, by the way. They were amazing.
1:40 Speaker 01 Detailed. I mean, really good stuff.
1:44 Speaker 00 Our producer Ainsley divided your letters into two sections. Those of you who think Toby is the Scranton strangler and those of you who think he isn't. So here's what we're gonna do. We are gonna have a good old fashioned debate using your letters to support our arguments.
2:00 Speaker 01 Our version of a debate for you hardcore debaters out there.
2:04 Speaker 00 We're gonna mess it up.
2:05 Speaker 01 We're not gonna, it's not gonna be like the, the debate, but it's gonna be a debate.
2:09 Speaker 00 It's gonna be a debate.
2:10 Speaker 01 It's gonna be a conversation.
2:11 Speaker 00 A mom detectives debate.
2:12 Speaker 01 Thank you. And then after we debate, is Toby the Scranton strangler? Paul Lieberstein is gonna join us in the studio and tell us what he thinks.
2:22 Speaker 00 And by the way, I say Toby is not the Scranton Strangler.
2:27 Speaker 01 And I say Toby is the Scranton Strangler.
2:30 Speaker 00 And we have not seen each other's arguments. We have not seen each other's evidence. This is gonna be interesting.
2:37 Speaker 01 Mm-hmm. But before we get into our debate, I thought it might be helpful to give a brief history of the Scranton Strangler.
2:44 Speaker 00 Angela?
2:44 Speaker 01 Mm-hmm.
2:46 Speaker 00 You are doing a summary. This is my favorite day.
2:50 Speaker 01 Jenna's doing like a little shoulder shimmy. She got excited about that. Yes, Jenna, you suggested I do this and I thought, you know what? I'm gonna take a stab at it. Ooh, I said stab.
3:00 Speaker 00 Oh.
3:01 Speaker 01 Not strangle. Okay. You know, I'm doing, I guess, my version of a summary. I'm calling it an overview.
3:08 Speaker 00 An overview?
3:09 Speaker 01 Mm-hmm.
3:10 Speaker 00 I like it.
3:10 Speaker 01 Okay.
3:11 Speaker 00 Please proceed.
3:12 Speaker 01 Here is my Scranton Strangler overview. So, the first time the Scranton Strangler is featured is in the sixth season. It was the episode, "The Delivery."
3:20 Speaker 00 Mm-hmm.
3:21 Speaker 01 Now, if you remember, everyone is at the hospital waiting for Pam to give birth, and Andy arrives with a gift. He has gotten the newspaper from the day Cece was supposed to be born framed. This is a very thoughtful gift.
3:34 Speaker 00 It really is. I don't know if we ever talked about how thoughtful that was of him.
3:38 Speaker 01 I know. But then, he is annoyed because she wasn't born on the day of the newspaper that he framed. So, Andy says, "I decided to give baby helper to newspaper from the day she was born. This frame sent me back 55 bones."
3:53 Speaker 00 Yeah.
3:54 Speaker 01 And then Andy shows the camera the framed newspaper and goes on to say, "But she decided to take her sweet time, so now I have to switch it with today's paper." And he holds up the day's paper. Now, look, the original newspaper he framed had the headline as, "Spring Has Sprung." But that day's newspaper, the headline is, "Scranton Strangler Strikes Again."
4:17 Speaker 00 Yeah.
4:18 Speaker 01 This is the first time the audience learns about the Scranton Strangler. It would become a running storyline for the remaining seasons of the show. Besides "The Delivery", it is mentioned in the following episodes: Viewing Party, Happy Hour, Body Language, Costume Contest, Classy Christmas Part 1, Michael's Last Dundee's, Doomsday, Jury Duty, The Boat, Dwight's Christmas, and Moving On. And although several other characters reference the Scranton Strangler throughout the series, it is Toby who seems particularly obsessed with this news headline.
4:50 Speaker 00 Mm-hmm.
4:51 Speaker 01 And ironically, once the Strangler is apprehended, it is Toby who ends up on the jury that finds the Strangler guilty. After the trial, Toby remains obsessed with the case, and finally, he goes to the prison to confront the man he thinks he wrongly imprisoned.
5:07 Speaker 00 Well, Angela, that was an excellent overview.
5:11 Speaker 01 Thank you.
5:12 Speaker 00 Guess what I have? I'm gonna take on a little bit of like, your thing. I have some digital clutter.
5:20 Speaker 01 Is today Freaky Friday?
5:22 Speaker 00 What is happening in this new year?
5:24 Speaker 01 Are we trading bodies?
5:25 Speaker 00 I don't know.
5:26 Speaker 01 Oh, my gosh, I did a summary, you're doing digital clutter?
5:30 Speaker 00 All right, so we once shared that Mindy famously said that the Scranton Strangler was the most pitched storyline in the writers' room. They loved this.
5:41 Speaker 01 I mean, I bet it was fun.
5:42 Speaker 00 And like you said, we were first introduced to the Scranton Strangler in season six, The Delivery. Well, I found three Strangler storylines that were pitched but not produced for season seven.
5:56 Speaker 01 Oh, my gosh.
5:57 Speaker 00 Are you ready?
5:58 Speaker 01 Treasure. What?
6:00 Speaker 00 Okay, so I guess over the summer between season six and seven, the writers had this big pitch session. They all had to come back from the break with multiple storyline ideas. And here are the three that involved the Scranton Strangler.
6:14 Speaker 01 Okay.
6:15 Speaker 00 First of all, BJ pitched a storyline that Dwight was gonna try to lay a trap for the Scranton Strangler. This was the card. Dwight lays a trap for Scranton Strangler. But there were no other details. Carrie Kemper pitched a storyline similar. You're gonna see a similarity between all three of these pitches. Carrie Kemper pitched a storyline that would be part of our Halloween episode.
6:41 Speaker 01 Okay.
6:42 Speaker 00 Which is that the Scranton Strangler had called the Scranton Times and issued a warning. That he was gonna strangle on Halloween night.
6:52 Speaker 01 Oh, this guy's got a lot of attitude.
6:54 Speaker 00 Yeah, this was gonna make everyone really scared to go trick or treating.
6:58 Speaker 01 Okay.
6:58 Speaker 00 So Dwight, here's the common theme, decides to take things into his own hands and he's gonna take Erin to a park and tell her to fall asleep on a park bench and he's gonna like lay in wait.
7:13 Speaker 01 Use her as bait?
7:14 Speaker 00 Yeah, that she's the bait.
7:16 Speaker 01 Oh Erin, don't go.
7:17 Speaker 00 But the strangler never strikes.
7:19 Speaker 01 Okay.
7:19 Speaker 00 Was a false alarm all around. No strangling on Halloween after all.
7:23 Speaker 01 Okay.
7:24 Speaker 00 Okay?
7:25 Speaker 01 He's playing games.
7:27 Speaker 00 Yeah.
7:27 Speaker 01 Yeah.
7:28 Speaker 00 This is maybe-
7:28 Speaker 01 Messing with everybody.
7:29 Speaker 00 Maybe some insight into the strangler.
7:32 Speaker 01 I'm just adding to the card.
7:34 Speaker 00 Oh, that's how our session works, right?
7:36 Speaker 01 Yeah.
7:37 Speaker 00 Then Robert Padnik pitched this story. It was a card that said, "Extra security because of Scranton Strangler."
7:45 Speaker 01 Hmm.
7:46 Speaker 00 And in this pitch, as the building manager, Dwight was going to really buckle down to protect everyone from the strangler. He was gonna put up barbed wire and metal detectors. He was gonna get a Doberman. The problem is that this scary dog that was supposed to protect everyone ends up being just like a complete love bug and then everybody just falls in love with this dog and then I don't know where that was gonna go if we were just gonna have a dog. But these were the three pitches that I was able to dig out of my producer's digital clutter.
8:21 Speaker 01 You know, here's the one flaw with that Robert Padnik card.
8:25 Speaker 00 Yeah.
8:25 Speaker 01 Which is that if Dwight put up metal detectors, he'd never be able to come into the office with all of this stuff.
8:30 Speaker 00 This is so true. I'm sure he had an alternate entrance for himself.
8:35 Speaker 01 That's really fun. We're gonna have to ask Paul about all of that when he joins the show.
8:40 Speaker 00 I have so many questions for Paul.
8:41 Speaker 01 I know.
8:43 Speaker 00 All right, well, are we ready for our opening statements? Angela, would you like to go first?
8:50 Speaker 01 Yes, I just wanna put this out there. I have never debated anything and I tried to follow the little outline you sent me Jenna, so I'm not sure this qualifies as an opening statement, but here it is. Are you ready? Hello.
9:06 Speaker 00 That's a good start.
9:07 Speaker 01 Welcome Cassie, Sam, Jenna, and all of you listening out there in the world. Welcome to the first ever Office Ladies Debate. I, Angela Kinsey, am taking the position that Toby Flenderson is indeed the Scranton Strangler. Today, I will prove the true nature of Toby Flenderson and the crimes he most certainly committed. Now, you might say, shy, mild-natured Toby? The sometimes helpful HR rep who sat quietly in the corner of the annex? Could he really be capable of this type of violent crime? But ladies and gentlemen, I really don't have to say much. Toby will tell you in his own words that he, in fact,
9:50 Speaker 01 has a very sinister nature. Furthermore, I will provide hard evidence that reveals that Toby is the Scranton Strangler.
10:01 Speaker 00 Wow.
10:03 Speaker 02 I'll allow it, but watch yourself, Counselor.
10:07 Speaker 01 May I approach the bench?
10:08 Speaker 02 Yes.
10:09 Speaker 00 Okay.
10:11 Speaker 00 All right. That was great. I will start by saying I've also never done this. I was not in debate in school.
10:17 Speaker 01 Me either.
10:18 Speaker 00 I think I did one debate and one history class once in high school.
10:22 Speaker 01 My closest thing to debate is watching, um, what was that Tom Cruise movie? You Can't Handle the Truths!
10:29 Speaker 00 Oh.
10:29 Speaker 02 A Few Good Men?
10:30 Speaker 00 A Few Good Men.
10:30 Speaker 01 A Few Good Men.
10:31 Speaker 00 I rewatched that this past year.
10:34 Speaker 01 Well, that's the closest I've come to debate.
10:36 Speaker 00 Really great.
10:36 Speaker 01 Really good.
10:37 Speaker 00 Yeah. All right, here's my opening statement.
10:39 Speaker 01 Okay.
10:41 Speaker 00 Sam, Cassie, esteemed listeners, Angela.
10:46 Speaker 01 Thank you.
10:48 Speaker 00 It is my position that Toby is not the Scranton Strangler. I will present evidence, or rather, point out the lack of evidence that shows Toby is not a criminal. And while I personally believe that George Howard Scub is the real Scranton Strangler, I will also offer alternate suspects, all of whom are more likely than Toby Flenderson to have committed these crimes. I believe that Toby believes he convicted the wrong man. I believe he might start a podcast to try to find the real killer. But this is not out of guilt for being the true Scranton Strangler, but rather because Toby's life lacks excitement.
11:33 Speaker 00 And the Scranton Strangler trial was perhaps the happiest we've ever seen Toby. His face lights up when given the chance to talk about it. I believe he's grasping at this one moment of excitement. I would like to conclude my opening statement with these words from Celia S. in Plymouth, Minnesota. George Howard Scub is the Scranton Strangler. And Toby is just a weird man who's obsessed with murder mysteries, probably because his own life is actually so boring. I'm not a Toby hater or a Toby defender. I'm neutral.
12:13 Speaker 00 Toby is just Toby, not the Scranton Strangler. Just Toby. And that's all he needs to be. Toby is Toby. Thank you.
12:33 Speaker 01 Well, I mean, I know we're on opposite sides, but I thought that was really well done.
12:37 Speaker 00 I mean, I thought yours was great, too. Well, listen, why don't we take a break? And when we come back, we will each give our constructive speeches.
12:47 Speaker 01 All right.
12:48 Speaker 00 On our positions.
12:50 Speaker 01 Okay.
13:03 Speaker 00 All right, we're back. So when I sent us the little debate structure, it said, opening statements, and then we each give a constructive speech, and then we have rebuttal time.
13:14 Speaker 01 Yeah.
13:14 Speaker 00 I don't totally know how that works, but I'm getting out a pen. And paper.
13:21 Speaker 01 Oh, you're gonna write notes to rebut?
13:23 Speaker 00 For my rebuttal.
13:24 Speaker 01 Okay.
13:24 Speaker 00 Because I think my rebuttal is in real time, right?
13:27 Speaker 01 I thought rebuttal-
13:28 Speaker 00 Did you write a rebuttal?
13:30 Speaker 01 I thought, I thought they came at the end.
13:32 Speaker 00 They come at the end?
13:33 Speaker 03 I did speech and debate in high school.
13:34 Speaker 00 Oh, Kathy! Oh, my gosh, please, get in here!
13:38 Speaker 03 So, you have to listen to each other's arguments, and you can be writing while they're making the arguments, but you want to have a rebuttal against whatever they say and make your argument stronger.
13:49 Speaker 00 At the end.
13:50 Speaker 03 Yeah, so it'll be argument, argument, rebuttal, rebuttal, in conclusion.
13:54 Speaker 00 Yeah.
13:55 Speaker 01 Oh.
13:55 Speaker 00 All right, so now, while Angela's talking, I'm just writing, but am I allowed to do things like, "Mmm..."
14:02 Speaker 01 Oh!
14:03 Speaker 00 Am I allowed to do stuff like that, or no?
14:05 Speaker 03 No.
14:05 Speaker 00 Probably not.
14:05 Speaker 03 But, but for the sake of the podcast, I think you can.
14:08 Speaker 00 Okay. Just want to know our rules.
14:10 Speaker 01 I did not write an "in conclusion," so I'll have to wing that one.
14:13 Speaker 00 Well, I'm winging it because I want to hear what Paul has to say.
14:17 Speaker 01 Oh, our in conclusions come after Paul. All right. Okay. Okay. Here we go.
14:23 Speaker 00 Angela, you're up.
14:24 Speaker 01 Okay, here I go.
14:27 Speaker 01 I feel like I'm in front of, like, a high school classroom. I have all of those feelings. I'm like, "Oh, no." Okay. I am ready to present my case that Toby is the Scranton Strangler. First of all, let's ask the question. Does Toby fit the profile of a serial killer? The evidence says he does. According to the US Department of Justice, 85% of serial killers are male, and 82% are white. Check, check, Toby.
14:59 Speaker 01 According to the FBI, serial murders often seem normal, have families, or a steady job. Hmm. A human resources rep at a paper company. Again, check Toby.
15:12 Speaker 01 Studies have found that a significant percentage of serial killers come from broken homes. As a result of their trauma, they may suppress their emotional response and may have difficulty empathizing with others. They often suffer from a variety of personality disorders, psychopathy, and antisocial personality. Let's see if Toby checks that box off. Hmm. In the episode "The Deposition," we learn that Toby's parents divorced when he was a child. Both of them wanted custody and both asked him to testify against the other in court. He was unsure what to do because he loved both of his parents and didn't want them to get divorced in the first place. That was certainly traumatic for Toby.
15:55 Speaker 01 And we learn Toby himself goes through a bitter divorce. Check Toby. Next up, studies also find that serial killers find comfort in their fantasies and dreams that take them into a realm that only they can control. Hmm. Let's see, does Toby fit that profile? His wife left him, he feels alone. He loved Pam, but she didn't love him back. He has a boss that hates him and bullies him. He can't control his real life, so he creates a fantasy life through a character he made up, Chad Flenderson. That is where he can be in control. In fact, one of Toby's mystery novels is titled "A Murder for Framing."
16:38 Speaker 01 Toby is sharing his knowledge of how to frame someone for murder. It's literally the title of his book. In the episode "Christmas Wishes," Toby, through his cover of being this mystery writer, reveals how you could put someone else's fingerprints on a crime scene. It happens when Dwight gets quilled by the porcupine. Andy says to Jim, "This has your fingerprints all over it." Jim turns to Andy and says, "Andy, you've got to be kidding me." And then Toby pipes up and says, "fingerprints can be planted." You know, with like a severed hand or... What is happening here? Toby is describing how to frame someone in front of everyone.
17:27 Speaker 01 Toby goes on to further say Chad is a character is a very complex individual and he deals with a lot of personal issues. So Toby checks all the boxes here, folks. And ladies and gentlemen, Sam, Cassie, and Jenna, now that we have established that Toby fits the profile of a violent criminal, let's look at some hard evidence that further proves Toby is the Scranton Strangler. Are you ready?
17:54 Speaker 00 Mm-hmm. You're not doing poorly.
17:56 Speaker 01 You've written three notes. I can't see what they say. I'm not going to look at her papers, okay? Here we go on to my next part. It all started with rejection. Becca N. from Berwyn, Illinois writes in to say Toby is absolutely the Scranton Strangler. Let me lay out the evidence. Becca, you do a fantastic job, by the way, sidebar. Becca says Toby turned his back on his initial passions, the seminary, to get into a relationship with a woman. And it's implied that she ended up leaving him. And now he's stuck in a dead-end job where he doesn't get to use his brain, he's very undervalued, not just by Michael, but everyone else.
18:39 Speaker 01 He's constantly bullied and generally mocked and ridiculed. And of course, he was deeply upset by the thought of the police going into his desk because he's hiding something. The killing starts being mentioned after Pam got married. He had an obsession with Pam and is disappointed at losing her to Jim, and that is manifested into a murderous rage. Pam is having another man's baby! And someone dies the same day? Then there is the part where the baby is christened. Toby goes to the church and he can't go in. Later, he asks God, "Why are you always so mean to me?" Someone else agrees. Sam K. from Los Angeles.
19:26 Speaker 01 In our Office Ladies episode, Break Down the Christening, Sam said, you know, who wouldn't want to enter a church because they have a problem with God? And then Sam answers himself, a strangler.
19:37 Speaker 00 Okay, I feel like that's a little pandering to the jury. Using our jury's own words.
19:44 Speaker 01 Bringing. Wait, is this, is this allowed? Is this like, are you, is this approach the bench moment?
19:51 Speaker 03 No, this is absolutely not allowed. And if, if Sam is the judge, he needs to like leave.
19:58 Speaker 02 I need to recuse myself.
19:59 Speaker 03 Yes. Sam clearly needs to recuse. Cassie is now our only judge.
20:03 Speaker 01 Okay, sorry, Sam. You're part of the argument, sorry. All right. Now, let's point out some of Toby's strange behavior that is prone to being irrational, aggressive, suspicious, and sinister. That is further evidence that he is the Scranton Strangler. Number one, irrational behavior, like out of nowhere, saying he is going to Costa Rica. Fan theory from Angela Kay, also on this podcast, also in the Christening episode quoted as saying, if you were the Scranton Strangler, you would need to have a place to go and hide. He clearly has set up a second residence or even a different identity in Costa Rica.
20:45 Speaker 01 Liv from Vancouver writes in with this excellent point. What are your thoughts on the fact that Toby always keeps his passport with him? Mentioned when he's having a conversation with Mrs. California. My theory is that he needs it in case he ever has to flee the country.
21:03 Speaker 00 Who said that?
21:04 Speaker 01 Liv.
21:05 Speaker 00 Liv.
21:06 Speaker 01 From Vancouver.
21:07 Speaker 00 Okay. I have some words for Liv later.
21:10 Speaker 01 Oh, okay. Well, Liv, get ready. Next up are things that Toby hides. He's actually quite athletic. Proof of this is in Night Out. We also had a fan theory that we shared on this very own podcast from Carolyn G. She said, since Toby jumps the fence with such apparent ease, it shows that he's someone who might be able to escape the police. Is this evidence that Toby is the Scranton Strangler? Jenna, Jenna F. from Los Angeles said she asked Paul about this and Paul's response was, sounds smart.
21:43 Speaker 00 Okay, all right. Judge, judge, are we allowed to use Paul and hear what is happening?
21:51 Speaker 02 You were playing fast and loose with this.
21:55 Speaker 01 Why can't I quote?
21:56 Speaker 02 Like a cop who's two days from retirement.
21:59 Speaker 01 Why can't I quote the person who plays the character who also was a writer?
22:04 Speaker 00 Oh, boy.
22:05 Speaker 01 All right. Next up.
22:06 Speaker 02 On thin ice.
22:08 Speaker 01 You have been recused.
22:10 Speaker 02 This whole thing's about to go out the window.
22:12 Speaker 01 Oh, gosh. It's going to be blown out the window. Next up, Toby's aggressive behavior. Like this moment when Clark interrupts Toby and Jim talking. Let's hear it.
22:24 Speaker 04 Hey, Toby. Wanted to ask you a question. Oh, sure. It's a little personal. Let's do it. Let's get personal. I wanted to talk to you about your divorce. Whoa.
22:36 Speaker 04 Sorry. I don't know what I meant. What I meant actually was... It's OK. I can handle it.
22:42 Speaker 04 So you guys obviously went through some tough times leading up to this.
22:47 Speaker 04 OK. I was wondering if you ever did any couples counseling? Oh, sure. Lots of times, yeah.
22:55 Speaker 04 Wait, you and Pam aren't in couples counseling, are you? Oh, God. No, no, no. We're just starting couples counseling.
23:05 Speaker 04 Which doesn't sound any better.
23:09 Speaker 04 And you guys. Kelly called it 2013.
23:15 Speaker 04 Hey, hey, hey. No, no. Get out of here. Clark, get out of here. My mistake. Yes, it is your mistake. He's lingering. So annoying. Going to kill him.
23:26 Speaker 01 "I'm going to kill him."
23:29 Speaker 01 That's what Toby said when Clark interrupts him. "I'm going to kill him."
23:35 Speaker 01 For more suspicious behavior, we have in viewing party. Everyone is gathered around Toby's desk watching the police pursuit of the Scranton Strangler. Fans have pointed out a few important things. Number one, where is Toby? Everyone else at Dunder Mifflin is there. We have a fan theory from Angela Kay in Los Angeles. Might the documentary film crew have suspected it was Toby all along? And is this why they purposely included this footage in the documentary film? They wanted to highlight the fact that Toby was not at work the day the strangler was fleeing, and there's also something else. A letter from Taylor C. in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. The staff is seated at Toby's desk when his phone rings on the day that the police are
24:19 Speaker 01 pursuing the falsely accused strangler. In addition to attempting to contact him, the caller must have known Toby's extension directly, because Aaron was not at reception forwarding the calls. Given he has few acquaintances and hardly ever gets direct calls, this is extremely suspicious and suggests that Toby might be framing George Howard Scub. Doug Y. from Spokane, Washington. Noticed that the car the strangler used during the chase was previously seen in the background shots of the parking lot of the office. Did Toby provide George with the car? Further part of How to Frame a Murderer. And then there's Toby's obsession with being on the jury for the case. Jenna, you mentioned this.
25:04 Speaker 01 He seemed delighted. He seemed so happy. Well, many people wrote in and noted that Toby is happy to be on the jury because he knows he got away with it. Someone else is going to pay for his crime and he's going to help make sure of it. He is going to convict an innocent person to cover his tracks as the Scranton strangler, as he planned all along, by framing George. And several people wrote in and noted, including Jennifer G. from Tampa, Florida, saying that they believe that when Toby went to see George in prison, he was going to say to him, "I know you're innocent, because I did it." He is sinister. He is evil. He has a dark nature.
25:48 Speaker 01 He was proud of this crime. He was taunting him, and George strangled him as a response. But lastly, to really show Toby's true sinister nature, let's just hear it from Toby himself.
26:04 Speaker 04 We should really have the office's air quality tested. We have radon coming from below. We have asbestos in the ceilings. These are silent killers.
26:12 Speaker 05 You are the silent killer. Go back to the annex.
26:14 Speaker 04 You'll see.
26:16 Speaker 01 You'll see. You'll see who the silent killer is, Michael.
26:22 Speaker 01 This is a person who was bitter, unhappy, jealous, rejected, a loner who had the motive to kill, the ability to kill, and the arrogance to brag about it in front of a camera crew. They knew he did it. Toby tells us he did it. Believe him. Toby Flenderson is the Scranton Strangler. Wow. Wow. Okay. That's as far as I got, guys.
26:53 Speaker 00 I'm gonna say, I'm a little surprised to hear that you were not in debate, because I thought that was excellent.
26:58 Speaker 01 Oh, thank you.
26:59 Speaker 00 Yes. Kathy, are debates usually this friendly?
27:02 Speaker 03 No, but I love how friendly this one is.
27:06 Speaker 00 We will continue.
27:08 Speaker 01 Okay.
27:09 Speaker 00 Well, I guess it's my turn.
27:10 Speaker 01 Well, let me just tell you, the jury is feisty in there.
27:14 Speaker 00 Oh.
27:15 Speaker 01 The judge has a lot of comments.
27:18 Speaker 03 We lost a judge.
27:19 Speaker 01 We lost a judge, but he's still very chatty. So, anyway, I wish you luck.
27:24 Speaker 00 Thank you. Thank you so much. Ladies and gentlemen, I'm gonna present three very strong reasons why Toby is not the Scranton Strangler. Starting with, a lack of direct evidence. There is simply no concrete evidence linking Toby to these murders. Now, I will admit, there's not a lot of evidence or details of the Strangler's crimes, but we do know a few things. Number one, we know that there was a car chase that led to the arrest of George Howard Scub. And I would ask this question, why did George Howard Scub run from police and barricade
28:08 Speaker 00 himself inside of an apartment complex if he was not guilty of this crime? Some people have suggested that Toby was driving the car since he is not in the scene where everyone is watching the chase. Maybe Toby ran into the apartment complex and then escaped, leaving George Howard Scub to take the fall. But here's the thing. Where did Toby get this Mercury Cougar? This is not Toby's car. Angela, you yourself pointed out that in season one, Toby has a photo of a Jeep at his desk. In season two-
28:40 Speaker 01 You're doing what I did. You're quoting from our own podcast. Judge!
28:45 Speaker 02 Slight objection, but I'll allow it.
28:47 Speaker 00 Thank you. In season two, episode "Take Your Daughter to Work Day," Toby drives a Silver Saab. And then in season eight, "The Garden Party," he's driving a Subaru Impreza. None of the Dunder Mifflin staff are ever seen driving this Mercury Cougar that is at the center of the Strangler case. This would mean that Toby, our underpaid HR rep, somehow has two cars? A Strangler car and another car? I doubt that is the case. In "Dwight's Christmas," Toby is recounting his theories about the Scranton Strangler
29:28 Speaker 00 Tenelli. He mentions that they found fingerprints, presumably linked to George Howard Scub. How did George Howard Scub's fingerprints get on coins found at one of the crime scenes if he's not the Scranton Strangler?
29:45 Speaker 01 Hmm?
29:45 Speaker 00 Oh!
29:46 Speaker 01 Hmm hmm.
29:47 Speaker 00 Okay. You might notice that none of Toby's fingerprints were found at any of the crime scenes, and if they were, we would know about it because he has traveled abroad, and it is customary to provide fingerprints in order to obtain a passport. So clearly, Toby's fingerprints have been cleared. And while Toby might doubt the validity of these fingerprints as being accurate, there have been many cases of police being able to lift fingerprints from money and get convictions, just like they did in this case, because criminals often think to wear gloves while committing a crime, but not when handling their own money.
30:29 Speaker 00 And finally, I would say that the fact that George Howard Scub tries to strangle Toby during his visit to the prison is pretty clear evidence that George Howard Scub is the strangler. But now, I'd like to go to character consistency. Per the FBI, psychopaths who commit serial murder do not value human life and are extremely callous in their interactions with their victims. One strategy to assess whether a person is a psychopath is to look at four dimensions: deviance, distress, dysfunction, and danger, collectively known as the four Ds.
31:12 Speaker 00 Toby's character is largely depicted as mild-mannered and empathetic, making it difficult to believe that he is a serial killer. Ellen Kay from Robinson, Illinois said, "I don't think serial killers participate in Movember." I would also like to quote Jenna F. from Los Angeles, who said, "Why would Toby be so worried about us all dying of radon poisoning if he was the Scranton strangler? Wouldn't he want us all to slowly suffocate?" That sounds like the perfect crime. Finally, I'd like to point to some other suspects. Sure, you don't believe it's George Howard Scub?
31:57 Speaker 00 How about Creed Bratton? Madison S. from Covington, Kentucky said, "Everyone thinks it's Toby who could be the Scranton strangler? Why does no one suspect Creed? He came into the office during the murder mystery episode and freaked out when Michael, quote, blamed him for murder, and he also had blood on himself in the Halloween episode." Seems pretty viable that it could be Creed. Amber C. from Oregon said, "It is definitely Creed." Not to mention Creed's impromptu talking head when the police were searching for weed, and he says, "Just keep talking until the cops leave." Also, why was Creed in the middle of nowhere on the side of the road hitchhiking to work
32:41 Speaker 00 during work bus? Not to mention the "wanted" posters in the finale. And Jessica J. from Sweden said, "Creed has stolen an identity, and he's up to so many funky businesses, why wouldn't he be the Strangler 2?" And in "Viewing Party," Jim has a line when they're watching the car trace that says, "Huh, I guess the Scranton Strangler isn't who I thought he was." Pam says, "Why?" And Jim says, "Because the person I thought it was just showed up to work." And then we see Creed walking in. But fine, you don't think it's Creed? How about Gabe?
33:24 Speaker 00 Alexis L. from Staten Island, New York said, "I think it's far more likely Gabe is the Strangler. It's well-established that he enjoys violence and horror. He travels between Scranton and Florida, which makes it easy to elude police, and he's super creepy." Phil C. from Oklahoma said, "Notice that the killings not only stop after the trial, but also after Gabe goes back to Florida." But not only do they stop when Gabe leaves, they didn't start until Gabe arrived in Scranton. I would definitely be investigating Gabe if I were the Scranton police. But I'm not done.
34:08 Speaker 00 How about David Wallace? Hmm. Izzy S. from Surrey, England said, "I recently found out some people believe David Wallace might be the Scranton Strangler. Apparently, he sent Holly away just as she was getting close to figuring it out."
34:24 Speaker 01 Approached the bench. What? When was Holly investigating the Scranton Strangler?
34:29 Speaker 00 I don't know. Never mind. Objection sustained.
34:37 Speaker 00 Sorry Izzy, I liked your argument. Alright Tyson H. from Salt Lake City, Utah said this. At the writer's block panel at the wrap party in Scranton Greg Daniels, Greg Daniels said, wait, we can quote Greg Daniels, but we can't quote Paul Lieberstein, your honor?
35:00 Speaker 02 Continue.
35:00 Speaker 00 Well, I think this is biased. I got fast and loose. She gets continue.
35:05 Speaker 02 You're looking at contempt of court here. Calm down.
35:08 Speaker 00 Greg Daniels said, if the Scranton strangler was anyone else, it would be none other than Robert California. And my friends, if anyone possesses the four D's of deviance, distress, dysfunction, and danger, is it not Robert California? I have given you three very good other suspects and one that maybe we're gonna throw out, but I still have one more. Jacqueline R. from Orange County, California wrote in to say that she believes Mose is the Scranton strangler. The evidence, though circumstantial,
35:50 Speaker 00 forms a chilling mosaic of behavior, opportunity, and motive.
35:55 Speaker 01 It's very well written.
35:57 Speaker 00 Yeah, Jacqueline really maybe should have written my whole thing. She was great.
36:00 Speaker 01 It's nice.
36:01 Speaker 00 I know. Jacqueline goes on to say, first, Moses peculiar and antisocial behavior places him outside of societal norms where many criminal profiles of serial offenders begin. He is almost entirely isolated from society, living on a remote beef farm with limited human interaction, except for his cousin Dwight.
36:22 Speaker 01 And a scarecrow.
36:24 Speaker 00 Thank you for making my point, Angela. Mose demonstrates signs of emotional instability, extreme awkwardness, and a lack of understanding of social boundaries, traits commonly associated with individuals capable of heinous crimes.
36:39 Speaker 01 I was meaning he loved a scarecrow, like he did her and stuff.
36:44 Speaker 00 Oh, I know what you meant. And I think Jacqueline knows what you meant, Angela. Is this your argument? You think someone who
36:50 Speaker 02 Is this an objection?
36:51 Speaker 00 Does a scarecrow? Also, I'm so sorry. Who quietly took notes while the other person was talking? And who is breaking in every four sentences?
37:01 Speaker 01 I am sorry. There was a long period where I listened and then I decided to break in. You had a few things.
37:08 Speaker 00 Okay, I'm going on. Mose has odd erratic behavior, which has been well documented, such as his proclivity for running alongside moving vehicles, screaming without provocation, and displaying an unnatural interest in physical conflict as seen during his wrestling of farm animals and coworkers. Second, Moses' physicality and access to tools of strangulation make him a credible suspect. The tools he uses daily on the farm, ropes, chains, other implements, are eerily similar to the potential instruments used in strangulations.
37:45 Speaker 01 Jacqueline, you are doing a fantastic job.
37:48 Speaker 00 Right, right. You see why I'm ending with Jacqueline here. Third, and most damning, Mose had both the opportunity and proximity to carry out these crimes. Scranton is not far from Shrewd Farms, and the rural locations offers the perfect hideout for someone evading suspicion. While the documentary crew focused on Dwight's activities, Mose's whereabouts were often unaccounted for, giving him ample opportunity to commit these heinous acts without raising suspicion. His ability to blend into the background as a peculiar but harmless farmhand works to his advantage, allowing him to operate unnoticed.
38:30 Speaker 00 In conclusion, I'd like to quote Ali W. from Moor Park, California, who says, "Ladies, no. Toby is not the Strangler. His only crime is being pathetic and uninteresting and throwing out his Baba Ganoush in the office trash." Thank you for your time.
38:51 Speaker 01 That was very good. That was very good.
38:53 Speaker 00 Thank you. Now, how do we rebuttal, Cassie? Who goes first on the rebuttal?
38:58 Speaker 03 See, you just went, so you should rebuttal Angela and then vice versa.
39:04 Speaker 00 So I have to go first now?
39:05 Speaker 03 Yeah, and basically like if there was any points she made that you want to like take down, or you have evidence, that would be what you would focus on.
39:14 Speaker 00 Okay, then I will say this.
39:16 Speaker 01 Okay.
39:17 Speaker 00 Here is my rebuttal Angela to your argument.
39:21 Speaker 01 Okay.
39:22 Speaker 00 You paint an entertaining picture.
39:25 Speaker 01 Why does that sound judgy?
39:28 Speaker 00 Toby is the Scranton strangler, but it's all based on circumstantial evidence. And I believe I proved in my argument that we could paint a number of people in the world of Dunder Mifflin with that same brush if we wanted. But none of your arguments really hold up in court. Divorce, trauma, happens to a lot of us. Are we all serial killers? Angela Kay, you love fantasy. Are you a serial killer? Hmm. Also, Liv in Vancouver, you mentioned the passport. I mentioned that Toby's fingerprints would be on record for said passport.
40:12 Speaker 00 We know that fingerprints were left behind and they do not match Toby, but they do match George Howard Scub. And I know Angela, you mentioned that you believe perhaps in addition to strangling everyone while living a life mostly documented by a documentary crew, Toby had time to murder people and frame another man. You're suggesting that maybe Toby provided George Howard Scub with this car? Really? George Howard Scub didn't want to mention that? He didn't want to say, I got this car from someone else? Or anything like that when he was being interrogated by police?
40:59 Speaker 00 I think we all need to just admit the police caught the right person. And that person is George Howard Scub. Thank you.
41:11 Speaker 01 Well, fantastic rebuttal. Here's my rebuttal. I will start with this. You mentioned, according to the FBI, serial killers do not value human life. I would say to you, Toby has a personality where he can compartmentalize people and have no value at all to people who should have value. I will cite the moment when he is willing to ditch his daughter, who he barely sees, to go to Pam's art show. I will cite the moment where he decides to leave his daughter to go to Costa Rica. Toby can compartmentalize. You brought up the radon poisoning. Wouldn't that be the way Toby would finally get us all?
41:57 Speaker 01 I would like to point out that people that have these type of personalities, one of the main things they have in common is extreme obsessions with things. Radon, Pam.
42:10 Speaker 01 Being on this jury, they lock into something and they get into a loop and it manifests itself in very dark ways. You mentioned the fingerprints, that Toby's fingerprints are on his passport, that they couldn't be at the scene of the crime, that George's fingerprints are there. But we learn from Toby himself that he has studied how you can use other people's fingerprints to implement them in a crime. He literally shared that he studied on how to do this and wrote about it in one of his books. You make compelling arguments, along with Jacqueline, about who else could have done these crimes, but none of them had the motive that Toby had.
42:54 Speaker 01 None of them had the rejection, the bitterness, the jealousy, the bullying. Toby's rage is simmering quietly in the annex and it comes out in the form of the Scranton Strangler. Toby is the Scranton Strangler. Don't doubt it. Because if you do, he will have fooled you too.
43:20 Speaker 01 That's my rebuttal.
43:22 Speaker 00 I think all that's left is for us to take a break and come back and talk with Paul Lieberstein all about it.
43:28 Speaker 01 Yeah, this was really fun.
43:31 Speaker 00 I agree.
43:45 Speaker 00 All right, we are back. Paul Lieberstein, AKA Toby, is here.
43:51 Speaker 04 Hello.
43:51 Speaker 01 Welcome to the courtroom, Toby.
43:53 Speaker 04 Oh, wow.
43:55 Speaker 00 You should know that we have entered into quite a hot debate here. We are very excited to get your perspective. Can we start with a little backstory?
44:03 Speaker 04 We can, sure.
44:04 Speaker 00 All right.
44:05 Speaker 04 Yeah.
44:06 Speaker 00 First question for you, Paul, from Kelly W. in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. Oh, this is a formal debate, sir.
44:13 Speaker 01 This is a serious debate, Paul.
44:16 Speaker 04 All right, well, I apologize for my attitude.
44:20 Speaker 00 Your honor?
44:20 Speaker 04 Going forward.
44:21 Speaker 01 Can his attitude be noted?
44:23 Speaker 02 It's on the books.
44:24 Speaker 00 Yes, I hope you aren't a hostile witness.
44:27 Speaker 04 I may be treated like a hostile witness.
44:29 Speaker 00 All right. Okay, all right.
44:31 Speaker 04 I'm used to it, too.
44:32 Speaker 01 Aww.
44:33 Speaker 04 Toby, that's the Toby in me.
44:34 Speaker 01 That's the Toby.
44:37 Speaker 00 Well, here's your first question. Kelly W. from Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, said, "Who originally had the idea for the Scranton Strangler? Was he always going to be a recurring character or storyline? Or was this something that became a continuous joke through the series just sort of organically? Give us the background."
44:56 Speaker 04 So, it's difficult to trace this.
45:01 Speaker 04 And I have tried.
45:02 Speaker 01 It's a mystery.
45:03 Speaker 04 No, it's... So, there's a decent chance it was my idea, but I can't say for sure. And I've been contacting people. So, it first appeared in Charlie's episode. It was like a background joke, the baby episode.
45:15 Speaker 00 Yes.
45:16 Speaker 04 But he didn't remember writing it.
45:20 Speaker 01 The newspaper headline.
45:21 Speaker 04 Yeah, exactly. And we just wanted something, you know, because people always get that gift for a baby. So, we just wanted like an inappropriate.
45:29 Speaker 01 Right. It went from "Spring has sprung" to "Scranton Strangler strikes again."
45:35 Speaker 04 So I asked Greg if it was his, because I know that he got very involved in the rewrite of that episode. And he thought it was mine.
45:44 Speaker 00 How?
45:46 Speaker 04 And then I asked a bunch of other people who seemed to like it and who were around at the time, including a couple of writer assistants, and Danny and BJ and Halsted. And they seemed to think it was mine.
46:00 Speaker 00 Okay. This one joke was your idea.
46:04 Speaker 01 And Warren said he thought it was yours as well.
46:06 Speaker 04 Yeah. But I can't say for sure. And I would hate to be taking credit for someone else's pitch.
46:14 Speaker 01 You're so kind, Paul. I mean, the majority of the writers think it was you.
46:18 Speaker 04 Okay.
46:19 Speaker 01 But you're still like, it might not be me.
46:21 Speaker 04 So it kind of sounds like me. Also sounds like Mindy, too.
46:25 Speaker 00 But this was intended to be, originally, a one-off joke gag in the delivery.
46:35 Speaker 04 Yeah, it hadn't been for more than that.
46:37 Speaker 00 Okay.
46:38 Speaker 04 But it kind of grew as things, as things do.
46:42 Speaker 00 Yes. But I would like to note, for the record, again, for the record.
46:49 Speaker 04 Yes.
46:50 Speaker 00 When conceived, this was simply a newspaper joke. Thank you. Committed to record. Angela, would you like to ask question number two?
47:03 Speaker 01 I would. And I don't think what you're commending to record proves anything. But okay. Paul?
47:08 Speaker 04 Yes, Angela.
47:09 Speaker 01 You are aware that people think Toby is the Scranton Strangler?
47:13 Speaker 04 Yes.
47:14 Speaker 01 So Aiden B. from the UK says, did Paul purposely write or play the role or plan for it to be as ambiguous as it is? Like, is Toby the Scranton Strangler?
47:24 Speaker 00 Yeah, I'm curious about that, too. When did you all become aware that fans were keying into Toby being the Scranton Strangler? Was it while we were still on the air?
47:36 Speaker 04 No, it was after we wrapped. So I watched that YouTube video about, you know, putting together the very first one that said it might be Toby. And that kind of blew my mind.
47:46 Speaker 01 There are many now.
47:47 Speaker 04 Yeah, there are a lot. And I watched a bunch for this podcast. And they were long.
47:55 Speaker 01 Because there's a lot of evidence to prove that he is.
47:59 Speaker 04 Yeah, or and for other characters too, right?
48:02 Speaker 01 Yeah.
48:03 Speaker 04 Yeah.
48:04 Speaker 00 Yes, for other characters that could be the Scranton Strangler.
48:08 Speaker 01 There's a lot of YouTube out there.
48:10 Speaker 00 Mm hmm. Pointing that out again.
48:15 Speaker 04 No, it had not crossed my mind that it could be, that it would be me. We may have joked that it could be Creed. We might have joked around like that.
48:27 Speaker 01 Creed definitely had a lot of different lives that he led.
48:31 Speaker 04 Yes. Yeah, which came out really strongly in season nine, I guess.
48:36 Speaker 00 Yes.
48:38 Speaker 04 But that's the only, that's the kind of thing you could do in the very end. Right? I guess.
48:43 Speaker 01 Yeah.
48:43 Speaker 04 And Creed, I don't know, he existed on a whole different plane. And he loves the idea. He loves the idea that he was the Scranton Strangler.
48:51 Speaker 01 And that Toby is the one everyone would pin it on, maybe, if not for George.
48:56 Speaker 01 Well, our next question is this. Mindy said that the Scranton Strangler was one of the most pitched things in the writer's room. She said that if you compiled all the notes, you would have an epic and terrifying mini series. Do you remember any of the pitches that you guys had?
49:14 Speaker 04 No, I think it was a lot of just this person gets strangled. You know, you're looking for, we're looking for twists in the story. So like, we have this list up on the board, right? Of like, after we write things, like, did we include an inciting incident? Oh, no.
49:35 Speaker 04 You know, and it's like, the simple things in stories. And so one of them was a twist. You know, is it a straight line to the end? Or, you know, do we go somewhere up with this? So I think a twist or like second act break commonly could be somebody gets strangled. When we're really stretching.
49:57 Speaker 00 All right, next question, sir. We also received a letter from Maria H. in Atlanta, Georgia, who said, "Have you heard the theory that the Scranton strangler isn't a murderer?" Paul Lieberstein famously posted a video on Instagram a few years ago saying that the writers of The Office always intended to include that the Scranton strangler would just strangle his victims till they passed out, but never actually killed any of them.
50:25 Speaker 04 Now, I loved that. I thought that was super fun. I'm not sure everybody was on board for that, but I loved it, just like strangled and left them there.
50:36 Speaker 01 Such a weird, like passive, violent crime, but very, like, I could kill you, but I'm not going to.
50:43 Speaker 04 It's weirder, and then it becomes less of a, like, crazy thing. I mean, it gets crazier, but in a way, it's just like, it's not a serial killer.
50:55 Speaker 01 Right. It's just a serial strangler.
50:57 Speaker 04 It's just like, oh, that was a really bad night when I got strangled and passed out.
51:03 Speaker 01 And then woke up later.
51:04 Speaker 04 And then you live your life. Live the rest of your life.
51:08 Speaker 01 And he knows, he knows, like, I'm gonna take you to the edge.
51:10 Speaker 04 Yeah, yeah, take you to the edge, yeah.
51:12 Speaker 01 But then for George-
51:13 Speaker 04 And it's like, okay, sure, that's traumatic. I'm not saying there wouldn't be some therapy, but it's like, it's, it's just so much smaller.
51:20 Speaker 00 So this was just an idea in the writers' room? This never, this fact never shows up on the show?
51:25 Speaker 04 It never shows up on the show.
51:26 Speaker 00 This idea?
51:26 Speaker 04 No.
51:27 Speaker 01 Right, because-
51:28 Speaker 04 Which means it's not officially in the lore, yes.
51:30 Speaker 01 And then also, too, that would contradict George Howard Scub getting the death penalty and life in prison, right?
51:38 Speaker 04 You're right, you're right.
51:39 Speaker 01 Because you don't strangle someone, your string of crimes, just stringing to passing out doesn't get you death penalty.
51:47 Speaker 04 Yeah, you're right.
51:49 Speaker 00 Wow, Angela. I feel like that is maybe-
51:54 Speaker 04 Unless-
51:55 Speaker 00 What?
51:56 Speaker 04 The Aleutians accidentally went too far one night and killed someone.
52:00 Speaker 01 Right.
52:02 Speaker 00 Okay, so maybe that happened.
52:03 Speaker 04 You don't know with that.
52:05 Speaker 00 Yeah. Well, this leads us to one of our last questions, Paul, in our evidence gathering here. If you could go back and add one additional storyline for the Scranton strangler, knowing everything you know now about all of the fan interest, maybe it would wrap things up. Would you do it? And if so, what would that thing be?
52:26 Speaker 04 No, I probably wouldn't wrap it up for the audience. But SCUB getting out of prison, like, say we had gone another 10 years.
52:31 Speaker 00 Okay.
52:33 Speaker 04 With SCUB maybe getting out of prison and...
52:36 Speaker 01 Would SCUB become Toby's friend that he'd always hoped for?
52:40 Speaker 04 Or Toby could be very, very scared.
52:44 Speaker 04 You know, or members of the jury could be very scared. Or there could be another strangling while SCUB was in prison.
52:53 Speaker 01 Well, that would definitely fuel the fire.
52:56 Speaker 04 Yeah. And was it a copycat? Or did they get the wrong guy?
53:01 Speaker 00 Interesting questions. Yeah.
53:03 Speaker 04 We would do something like that.
53:05 Speaker 00 Yeah. It would have continued.
53:07 Speaker 04 Yeah, for sure.
53:07 Speaker 00 If we had continued. The Scranton strangler case was not over.
53:12 Speaker 04 No, something like that isn't over, ever. We're still talking about the Menendez Brothers.
53:18 Speaker 00 True.
53:19 Speaker 01 True.
53:19 Speaker 04 Yeah.
53:20 Speaker 01 Yeah. No, that would be the lore of the town for as long as we documented that town and that community.
53:26 Speaker 04 Yeah, it's a big deal in the town. It's Scranton size.
53:29 Speaker 00 Yeah. Angela, do you have any more questions for Paul before we get to the question?
53:36 Speaker 04 This is so serious.
53:37 Speaker 01 No, I don't. I think, you know, we learned a lot about Toby today. We learned about his athleticism, how he could just hop a fence with no problem. I would also say that Toby has big hands. I noted.
53:52 Speaker 00 I'm so sorry. What is this? This is, this is not the time for you to present more evidence. You're just throwing out evidence right now. What is this?
54:00 Speaker 01 You said to me, "Do you have anything else?"
54:02 Speaker 00 I said, "Do you have any more questions for Paul?"
54:05 Speaker 01 Okay.
54:05 Speaker 00 Not, "Do you want to give a speech about why Toby is the Scranton strangler?"
54:10 Speaker 01 Okay. I will just simply say this, then. Paul?
54:14 Speaker 04 Yes.
54:15 Speaker 01 Is Toby the Scranton strangler?
54:19 Speaker 00 Oh my gosh, I don't even have to win. I don't even have to win because I won.
54:25 Speaker 01 This is one person's opinion.
54:27 Speaker 00 One person's opinion, it's Toby. And by the way, one of the showrunners of The Office.
54:34 Speaker 04 So here's why he's not the Scranton Strangler.
54:35 Speaker 00 Oh, give it to us.
54:37 Speaker 01 All right, all right.
54:39 Speaker 04 Because we wouldn't do that. We're about like relatable.
54:42 Speaker 01 This fan theory doesn't exist in the realm of what would we normally do?
54:47 Speaker 04 I'm saying this should be part of the theory.
54:50 Speaker 00 Part of the reason why he is not.
54:52 Speaker 04 Yes.
54:53 Speaker 01 Is you have to break the fourth wall and say, the writers wouldn't do that.
54:59 Speaker 04 Well, okay, if you weren't breaking the fourth wall, then you would just, you say it's too unlikely. This is like an Occam's razor kind of thing. Like, no, the most likely thing is generally the truth, where the guy convicted is guilty of the thing.
55:15 Speaker 01 Okay.
55:16 Speaker 04 You know, there was a trial. But yeah, if you're willing to break the fourth wall, and I've been thinking about this a lot over the last.
55:22 Speaker 01 Let's hear it.
55:23 Speaker 04 24 hours of watching all those videos, it's just, well, you know, we always search for like, the thing that people were experiencing, which sometimes is like a proximity to a big story, but not an actual part of it. So I feel like that would have been something we would have probably pitched, broken, we would have had a version of it, and ultimately decided like, no, this is not our show.
55:48 Speaker 01 Right, this is not.
55:49 Speaker 04 We're like, we shouldn't do this. This is a.
55:52 Speaker 01 This would be jumping the shark moment.
55:54 Speaker 04 Yeah, for sure.
55:54 Speaker 01 If Dunder Mifflin had an employee that was a serial killer.
55:59 Speaker 04 Yes.
56:00 Speaker 00 Okay, so I guess that's my next question. Toby is not the Scranton Strangler. Does that mean that Creed, Robert California, Gabe?
56:10 Speaker 04 Yeah.
56:11 Speaker 00 David Wallace, nobody is the Scranton Strangler?
56:13 Speaker 04 No one from our show.
56:14 Speaker 00 George Howard Scub?
56:16 Speaker 01 No one in the world.
56:16 Speaker 00 Is the Scranton Strangler? Or was he wrongfully convicted? That maybe we don't know. Is the Strangler still out there?
56:23 Speaker 04 Hmm.
56:24 Speaker 00 That's a whole other question.
56:25 Speaker 04 Yeah, yeah. I mean, people are wrongly convicted, right? Every once in a while? Once in a while.
56:33 Speaker 00 Okay.
56:34 Speaker 04 But generally, generally not. I don't know.
56:37 Speaker 00 Okay. Well, maybe the cliffhanger here is, is George Howard Scub, the Scranton strangler, or not?
56:45 Speaker 01 We may never know.
56:46 Speaker 00 We may never know.
56:47 Speaker 01 We officially mom detected of it.
56:49 Speaker 00 What?
56:50 Speaker 04 No, definitely never.
56:51 Speaker 00 Cassie's raising her hand.
56:52 Speaker 03 Angela, I want to give you props for like your debate, even though you lost. There was something you brought up that I kept thinking about, and you said that when George is driving the getaway car, that car had been parked in the Dunder Mifflin parking lot before.
57:09 Speaker 01 Yes.
57:09 Speaker 03 Of course, that's a production thing, but in the world of Scranton, I think that would be grounds for him to have an appeal. Because what is that about?
57:19 Speaker 01 Mm-hmm. And then I also wondered of all of Scranton.
57:22 Speaker 04 Wait, that could have been, he could have worked in the office park.
57:25 Speaker 00 But wouldn't we have known him then? Wouldn't we have known, wouldn't we, I mean, we got so excited when the car chase went past our building, which is interesting because he clearly knows our street.
57:37 Speaker 01 Well, that's what I was going to say. Of all of Scranton, you know, there is some statistic, and I had it, but I don't have it with me now, that a lot of times crimes are committed nearest where people live. And that's why a lot of times when people commit a crime near, close to where they live or work, they do a much harder job at trying to hide it because it will, it's very close to their circle of where they live. So the fact that he drives down the street where his car is also parked, and while he's driving down the street, of all of Scranton, that is where Dunder Mifflin is, and then Toby's phone rings as he's driving
58:16 Speaker 01 in that area, I think that did cause some suspicion about how is this person connected to the world of Dunder Mifflin?
58:24 Speaker 04 Yeah. The phone ring, I don't get. I don't get how that points to Toby.
58:29 Speaker 00 I don't get how that points to Toby either.
58:31 Speaker 04 Yeah. And then so maybe he stole a car from the office park since he lives in the area.
58:36 Speaker 01 So he definitely lives in the area, I think.
58:39 Speaker 00 So that car could-
58:40 Speaker 04 But we know he lives in Scranton, so he's gotta live somewhere.
58:43 Speaker 00 Yes. And that car could belong to someone at Vance Refrigeration or any number of other people who work in the building. And so maybe he did steal the car. But I feel like we would have talked about that in the office.
58:55 Speaker 04 Yeah.
58:56 Speaker 00 And maybe we did and the documentary crew didn't get it. But I think we would be like, oh, my gosh, did you hear that such and such Leo's car from Vance Refrigeration was the one that the Scranton Strangler stole and drove down the street?
59:08 Speaker 04 Yeah, you'd think that would get around.
59:10 Speaker 00 That would get around, yeah.
59:11 Speaker 01 But, or, or-
59:13 Speaker 00 What?
59:14 Speaker 01 Maybe it was Bob Vance.
59:17 Speaker 00 Oh, no. Don't reopen this can of worms.
59:21 Speaker 01 Maybe it was Bob Vance.
59:22 Speaker 00 Don't go there.
59:23 Speaker 01 He looks a little shady, like he could have some other things happening on the side.
59:28 Speaker 04 Shady, but, but that's different.
59:30 Speaker 01 I know.
59:31 Speaker 04 Yeah, I don't see it as Vance.
59:32 Speaker 01 I know, I know. I was just playing.
59:35 Speaker 04 I know you're playing.
59:38 Speaker 04 I know you're playing.
59:40 Speaker 00 Well, um-
59:42 Speaker 04 You don't think this is a real court of law?
59:47 Speaker 01 Toby, I did it. Toby, I called you.
59:50 Speaker 04 Where's the jury? Look around. Look around.
59:52 Speaker 01 Paul, I took an online course. I'm certified now. I am certified.
59:56 Speaker 04 Do you see a jury in this room?
59:57 Speaker 01 I do. Sam and Cassie.
1:00:01 Speaker 00 Yeah, Cassie, I am curious. Before Paul gave us the definitive answer and I won because I picked the right side, who were you gonna award the win to, based on our debating?
1:00:16 Speaker 03 Yeah, you both had great arguments and everything. I do think Angela had the hardest job. But yeah, I would have given it to you, Jenna, because-
1:00:24 Speaker 00 To me? Oh!
1:00:25 Speaker 03 I don't think Toby is the Scranton Strangler.
1:00:28 Speaker 01 I will also say this. Jenna proudly said, because I picked the right argument. We just said we both have to pick one. What do you want to do? And Jenna was like, I'll say that he isn't. I said, okay, fine. I'll say he is.
1:00:41 Speaker 00 Well, and I want to say I might have been awarded the win by both Paul and Cassie, but I would have awarded you the win because I thought your debate was just fantastic today. I really, really did. I was like, oh, no. I was sweating it when it was my turn. So I feel like we both won today. And you know who I really think won? The office ladies community.
1:01:06 Speaker 04 Oh, yeah, for sure.
1:01:07 Speaker 00 Really, really.
1:01:09 Speaker 01 And Paul, you're in studio with us. This is so fun.
1:01:12 Speaker 04 I know. This is so great.
1:01:13 Speaker 00 And before you go, can you tell us about your project with Audible, your show, Middle Space?
1:01:20 Speaker 04 Oh, yeah. I love this thing so much.
1:01:21 Speaker 00 I want people to listen to it.
1:01:22 Speaker 04 I want people to as well. Middle Space, all one word, but the full title is Middle Space: The Rebels Attack and Then the Other Side Attacks As Well. And it is one of the funnest, silliest things I've ever done.
1:01:37 Speaker 01 Will you tell us sort of the world of it?
1:01:40 Speaker 04 Yes. So we're in space.
1:01:42 Speaker 01 Okay.
1:01:43 Speaker 04 Let's call it the future, I guess. And Will Forte stars as this captain.
1:01:49 Speaker 01 He's so funny.
1:01:50 Speaker 04 Who starts off very early that they get a distress call and he decides not to go.
1:01:57 Speaker 01 Oh, not to take the distress call?
1:01:59 Speaker 04 Not to go. And it, he doesn't feel like it. He doesn't want to.
1:02:04 Speaker 01 Okay.
1:02:05 Speaker 04 And that's his reason. He just doesn't want. And he's that kind of captain. And he just kind of wants to float around in space and is very interested in getting out of the space business, captaining business. He'd like to get into fast food and goes around interviewing a manager of an intergalactic burger chain. But it is, you know, four and a half hours of not a single mission. It's just life in space.
1:02:38 Speaker 04 And it's very like anti sci fi.
1:02:42 Speaker 01 Oh Jenna, you might like it.
1:02:44 Speaker 00 I I'm not a sci fi fan, but I love this comedy spin on sci fi. Like it's a satirical take on sci fi adventure.
1:02:55 Speaker 01 I have a question.
1:02:55 Speaker 04 It was really fun. It's a great cast. John Malkovich narrated.
1:02:59 Speaker 01 Oh, my gosh.
1:03:00 Speaker 04 And and we had a lot of great people in there.
1:03:03 Speaker 01 I have one question.
1:03:04 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:03:05 Speaker 01 Throughout the whole time where he's looking at how to become a fast food worker.
1:03:11 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:03:12 Speaker 01 Are there more distress calls that come through that he just continues to ignore?
1:03:16 Speaker 04 Yes, he ignores all work. Go.
1:03:21 Speaker 04 They would like to mutiny, but they're not quite capable of pulling that off because that takes a lot.
1:03:26 Speaker 01 Takes a lot of effort.
1:03:27 Speaker 04 Yeah. I mean, you got to kill someone. I don't want to do that in the end.
1:03:34 Speaker 00 He might listen to Mel Robbins, who likes to remind us all the time that I don't want to is a perfectly acceptable reason to not do something.
1:03:43 Speaker 04 To not do something. And Rain's in it and he plays a the rebel leader.
1:03:49 Speaker 01 Oh, great.
1:03:51 Speaker 04 And he has, he calls up, one of the people on the ship is in contact with the rebel leader, Clark. Clark too.
1:03:57 Speaker 01 Oh, Clark is in it.
1:03:59 Speaker 04 And Clark plays the someone on the bridge who's who's very upset that we're not.
1:04:04 Speaker 01 Taking the distress calls?
1:04:05 Speaker 04 Taking the distress calls or really doing anything, you know, which doesn't know what his life's about if he's not doing something. So he gets in contact with the rebel leader and he calls him up and his son answers. And and they have a great conversation and it's played by Henry, my son.
1:04:24 Speaker 01 Oh.
1:04:25 Speaker 04 And we did it kind of like word by word. He was really young at the time. And it's so cute and so funny.
1:04:33 Speaker 01 I can't wait to hear that.
1:04:34 Speaker 00 Oh, I love that.
1:04:36 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:04:37 Speaker 01 Well, we'll include all the information in our Insta stories and our website with links so you guys can go and listen.
1:04:43 Speaker 00 That is so cool. And then Paul, just one last thing, you know, I we've put a period at the end of the sentence of one fan theory.
1:04:52 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:04:52 Speaker 00 And I I hate to. Open a window here on another.
1:04:58 Speaker 01 Oh, I see what you did there.
1:05:00 Speaker 00 But the last time we saw you, we discussed your particular pet peeve, which is that the windows of the Dunder Mifflin Building, the interior and exterior windows do not match.
1:05:14 Speaker 04 Yes.
1:05:14 Speaker 00 Would you like a moment to speak to that?
1:05:16 Speaker 04 Yeah, yeah, yeah.
1:05:16 Speaker 01 Because you're very passionate about this.
1:05:18 Speaker 04 I am. This bugged me so much and no one seemed to care at all.
1:05:23 Speaker 00 Let's, well, here's your, this is your radon. This is your radon. What radon was to Toby, these windows are to you.
1:05:31 Speaker 04 So we set the windows, obviously in Culver City, right? When we were down there, we moved to the valley in, in season two.
1:05:38 Speaker 00 Right.
1:05:39 Speaker 04 Outside of that building had those big, wide glass things. And then the inside of our windows were these very small, kind of like three, three by six rectangular windows. There's no way they match. I mean, it's startling.
1:05:58 Speaker 04 And then the view from anybody's, any one window, we would change all the time depending on what we wanted to see.
1:06:06 Speaker 01 That's true.
1:06:07 Speaker 04 And, and that pissed me off so much too. It's just like, no, out that window has to be this one thing.
1:06:13 Speaker 01 And they're like, nope, it doesn't matter.
1:06:15 Speaker 04 And it doesn't matter. And then I broke, I broke it too. And we needed to kind of like, see Michael hop a train. I picked that window to be outside, you know?
1:06:26 Speaker 01 Great.
1:06:28 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:06:29 Speaker 00 You're part of the problem.
1:06:30 Speaker 04 Part of the problem.
1:06:32 Speaker 00 Well, do you feel any better now that you've at least gotten to speak to it?
1:06:36 Speaker 04 I think at one point I was like, let's not, don't point the camera up. Don't see this building. Just keep it low. If people are gonna freak out, it's not gonna be okay.
1:06:46 Speaker 00 It's not the same windows. And so clearly not the same windows.
1:06:50 Speaker 04 And then no one cared. They pointed up.
1:06:53 Speaker 01 I hope today there's someone listening out there, Paul, that was like, I always wondered about the windows.
1:06:59 Speaker 04 I just probably ruined the show for somebody.
1:07:03 Speaker 00 Well, Paul, thank you so much for joining us today.
1:07:06 Speaker 04 Thank you for hanging me on. It's so good to see you guys.
1:07:09 Speaker 01 So good to see you too. And we have settled the fan theory is Toby the Scranton Strangler. Toby is not.
1:07:15 Speaker 04 Not.
1:07:16 Speaker 01 But we don't know who really is. Is it George? We don't know. We don't know.
1:07:21 Speaker 04 We can assume.
1:07:25 Speaker 00 Thank you, everyone, for listening to Office Ladies this week. We will see you next week with our superfan breakdown of the fire.
1:07:33 Speaker 01 Yes, and you guys be sure and check out Paul's audible show, Middle Space, and we'll see you next week. See you then. Bye, everyone. That was very Barry White.
1:07:51 Speaker 00 Thank you for listening to Office Ladies.
1:07:53 Speaker 01 Office Ladies is a presentation of Odyssey and is produced by Jenna Fisher and Angela Kinsey.
1:07:59 Speaker 00 Our executive producer is Cassie Jerkins. Our audio engineer is Sam Kiefer, and our associate producer is Ainsley Bubaco.
1:08:06 Speaker 01 Odyssey's executive producers are Jenna Weiss-Berman and Leah Reese-Dennis.
1:08:11 Speaker 00 Office Ladies is mixed and mastered by Chris Basil.
1:08:14 Speaker 01 Our theme song is Rubber Tree by Creed Bratton.
Previous Second Drink: Office Olympics with Paul Feig Next Second Drink: Halloween with Creed Bratton Page updated November 7, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated