Pod Insights Negotiate Anything The Hidden Pressure of Being in Charge About this episode In this episode, we break down the hidden pressure of leadership—the stress people don’t see, the isolation leaders feel, and why many leaders struggle with mental health while everyone assumes they’re “fine.” We also talk about how leadership can become dehumanizing, and what it looks like to rebuild compassion (for leaders and for ourselves).
Negotiate Anything:
Take your personal data back with Incogni! Use code ANYTHING at the link below and get 60% off an annual plan:
https://incogni.com/anything
incogni.com
Personal Information Removal Service | Incogni | Incogni
Data brokers are collecting, aggregating and trading your personal data without you knowing anything about it. We make them remove it.
Connect with Melissa Doman
www.melissadoman.com
Buy the book: Cornered Office: Why We Need To Talk About Leadership Mental Health
Contact ANI
Request A Customized Workshop For Your Company
Follow Kwame Christian on LinkedIn
negotiateanything.com
Click here to buy your copy of Finding Confidence in Conflict: How to Negotiate Anything and Live Your Best Life!
Transcript 10,007 words · 3 speakers
0:00 Speaker 00 Today's episode is brought to you by Shopify, Granola AI, Quince, and the Anxious Achiever Podcast. Stay present in your meetings. Get three months of Granola free at granola.ai/Quami. For your gift list, shopquince.com for free shipping and 365-day returns, and make sure to tell them that Quami with big swings only sent you. Subscribe to the Anxious Achiever today on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen to podcasts. Do you have an idea that you want live for the holidays? Launch before Black Friday at Shopify.com/Quami. Hey, everyone. Quami Christian here, and today's episode is going to challenge the way that you think about leadership, power, and mental health. If you are an aspiring
0:43 Speaker 00 leader or someone who works closely with leaders, this conversation is for you. I'm joined by my good friend and returning guest, Mel Doman, organizational psychologist and author of the groundbreaking new book, Cornered Office: Why We Need to Talk About Leadership Mental Health. Mel pulls back the curtain on the emotional toll that leadership can take, why society often strips leaders of their humanity, and how we can start building cultures that make space for the mental health of those at the top of our organizations. By the end of this conversation, you'll walk away with a deeper understanding of the hidden struggles that leaders face, and more importantly, how to lead with more empathy, self-awareness, and resilience. Let's get into it.
1:27 Speaker 00 When I, oftentimes when I read other friends' books, I'm like, this is their intellect, but it's not necessarily them. But as soon as I started reading, I could read your book, oh, it was strong. I was like, this is, there's, it's indistinguishable, even from, from how you actually speak. I loved that.
1:46 Speaker 01 I'm gonna be honest, I was being a real asshole to myself.
1:51 Speaker 01 I was not being nice to myself. Asked my husband, he would be like, I don't understand why she is the way she is. But I, I was really, really hard on myself and I even like processed it with my therapist. I was like, Whitney, what am I doing? And through a couple sessions with her, she was like, you're being so hard on yourself because you're taking the task very seriously. You want to do it really well because unlike your last book, you're not just informing people about a topic. You're not just teaching them how to talk about it. You're taking a well
2:30 Speaker 01 hold, well held notion and you're trying to break it. And you're trying to rebuild it into something different and that is no small task and no one's done it yet. So I was being really hard on myself because not, not just that, but also I work with leaders constantly when it comes to talking about mental health, intentional communication, team dynamics, but I don't specifically talk about leadership. So I was getting caught up in the fact that it was a book for leaders and I was like, am I the right person? Am I qualified? But then Whitney was like, but it's not about leadership. It's about the mental health of leaders and you know what that is?
3:09 Speaker 01 And I was like, you're fucking right, I do. So I, I was really torturing myself so much so that that's how I started the preface. I was like, I was freaking out, y'all, about writing this.
3:23 Speaker 00 And I like that. I, I think especially for somebody who, I know you as a friend, but also I admire you as a thought leader in mental health and psychology in general. And I think it's, it's, thank you. And I think it's
3:39 Speaker 00 and I think it's really, um, not just endearing, but validating to see that somebody of your stature who focuses on psychology and mental health can still fall into that trap of beating yourself up in the process. You know, we all struggle in that type of way. And I think it's important to be able to be vulnerable enough to share that and confident enough in yourself to share that because then it helps other people who look up to you say, well, you know what? If she feels this way and she still did something amazing, then maybe I could do, do that too.
4:10 Speaker 01 Oh Kwame, can I talk to you every day and have you just be like my hype man on Speed Dial? I, I really appreciate that. I, listen, you know as well as I do that anybody and everybody can struggle with imposter syndrome. Michelle Obama said she struggled with imposter syndrome. Mike Myers, the former head of the World Health Organization, like it's, it's, it's anywhere. And I truly feel that nobody should act as though they are a faultless oracle on any topic. And I think that you can be confident in, in something that you talk about while showing people that you are a flawless human, just like the rest of us, just like the rest of them.
4:56 Speaker 01 And so I think that both can and should coexist. So I think I can be confident in what I am saying and also saying I am not the only voice.
5:06 Speaker 00 Right.
5:07 Speaker 01 And I think that there are too many authors that would bow down to, bow down to themselves if they could. And I'm just allergic to that disingenuous nonsense. So I'm happy it came across that I was trying to be confident and aware of me just being one mind at the same time.
5:30 Speaker 00 Yes. And you know, just in the spirit of melancholy vibing. It's funny, as you were, as you were saying, you know, some authors, you looked down and there was a little smirk. It was very clear there were authors in your mind that we will not mention. But I want you to know, I saw that. I saw it.
5:48 Speaker 01 We're not gonna talk shit.
5:49 Speaker 00 We are not.
5:50 Speaker 01 We're not gonna talk shit.
5:51 Speaker 00 They're not. I'm just, I am, I am, I'm telling you, I saw, I saw.
5:56 Speaker 01 I just, I get the like throw up in my mouth vibes when people act like that. And I'm like. I would love to remember a time before I had to talk to you. But it's a, it's not, it's not my thing. I can't deal with more ultra crepidarians in this world. That's word of the week, ultra crepidarian.
6:19 Speaker 00 Googling ultra capidarians.
6:22 Speaker 01 Insolipsus. Insolipsus. Those are my two, two words of the week.
6:27 Speaker 00 That's awesome. I might need to download Word with Friends again and start playing. But I, I think a couple of things though. I think from a persuasive perspective and like a trust building perspective, being willing to admit a flaw is very, very powerful. Because if you're saying, it's essentially like a statement against your interests. So it's like, hey, listen, I don't know everything. These are the things that I am good at. These are the things that I'm not. And so I'm going to focus on the things that I'm good at. That builds trust because people say, you know what, if she's going to stay in her lane and I can trust her. And then when it comes into this, you're technically taking a foray into leadership, but you're taking a foray into leadership based on your thought leadership in psychology.
7:10 Speaker 01 Yes.
7:11 Speaker 00 We're talking about mental health of leaders. So again, you're extending your brand while still being true to your brand. And I think a lot of people could gain from that when it comes to the persuasive power of humility and authenticity. Staying in your lane while at a certain time, just recognizing, you know what, let me stipulate that I, these are things I do know. These are things I don't, so I'm going to stay in my lane.
7:34 Speaker 01 A hundred percent. And I, I don't know if I ever told you this, but uh, when I minored in communications in undergrad, I wanted to major in it, but at the time, the comms program at GW was the most competitive to get into in the country. And so I, I didn't have the cumulative 3.7 GPA again. I was like, I guess I'll minor in it. But my two favorite classes were persuasion, shocker, and interpersonal communication, shocker. And I remember learning about ethos, pathos, logos, you know, all the, all the old school stuff. And I have found in, in my experience, and I'm, I'm sure it's very similar in yours,
8:20 Speaker 01 that it is so much easier to trust people who.
8:25 Speaker 01 Stake their credibility on what they know and what they don't.
8:31 Speaker 00 Hmm.
8:32 Speaker 01 So I'm very clear about that. And when I'm talking about leadership, mental health, that's why I made it so clear in the book. This is not about how to lead. This is not about leadership. This is about the mental health of the humans in those roles that are stripped of their humanity based on those titles. Very, very clear about the function of what the book is and what it's not. And I think that anybody who is trying to make an argument should be that clear.
9:02 Speaker 00 Agreed. And for me, as a lawyer, it was very clear that you made your argument in a very uh logical and systematic way because
9:11 Speaker 01 What a compliment. Oh, my God.
9:15 Speaker 00 You said it very clearly, too. You're like, I'm going to state my case objectively and using logic. I'm like, oh, my goodness. I'm so excited. And I think it's important, too, to recognize, because as you, as you started off the book and you were very clear about your lane, it became readily apparent to me that this is maybe the only or one of very few books that focuses on this topic. Why do you think it's so rare to have conversations on this topic from the angle you took?
9:46 Speaker 01 That's a good question. And there's no shortage, for example, and I, I did the research. Uh, when I kicked off with my publicist for this campaign, I said, list competitive titles. And I looked and I looked and I looked and I was like, I cannot be the only one. Like, how is that possible? And yet, somehow, in the history of ever, my, my book is seemingly the only one that, that's talking about this specific niche of leadership. Now, there are lots of books about, you know, mindfulness in leadership and servant leadership and, and, you know, building trust in leadership and all these things
10:32 Speaker 01 to enhance leadership capabilities. There are even some that are dedicated to, we'll say, self-care in leadership, well-being in leadership.
10:44 Speaker 01 I was shocked that I could not find a single title other than my own that explored the dehumanization of leaders and exploring the neglected mental health of leaders based on the sociological assignment of power and the psychosocial biases that that creates. I was like, I don't, I don't understand how I could be the first. Now, I'm sure of the eight billion people on the planet, there are some other title buried in the annals of the internet that I didn't find. But I think it's so rare to talk about it because we're not supposed to. We're not supposed to talk about the humans behind the titles.
11:28 Speaker 01 We're not supposed to talk about the struggles of the people we put in charge because then should we trust them to be in charge? We, did you see Air? The film about the, about
11:42 Speaker 01 building of the company of Nike and, and Michael Jordan, you know, before it became super famous?
11:47 Speaker 00 I did not, but I was saying to myself, man, I was reading something recently where the person talked about it. Yeah, it was you.
11:54 Speaker 01 It was me. It was me. I, listen, I am not like a sports buff by any means, but I love that movie because it talks so much about, you know, leadership and trust and team building and, and all these things. And there was a monologue from a real person who's portrayed in the film, Sonny Vaccaro, who basically revolutionized Nike. And he was sitting down, talking to the, you know, pre-famous Michael Jordan, basically saying, you know, we're going to build you up into something that doesn't even exist.
12:33 Speaker 01 And then we're going to tear you down because that's the predictability of human nature. And I was like, that's it. Because that's what we do. We build leaders into these things as if they are a different species. But they are just people, let my teeny tiny nihilist come out for a moment, with made up job titles and made up industries with made up services and made up products. And they are held to a different standard because of the position they hold. And yes, there comes power with responsibility. There's visibility, there's influence, you are held to a different metric. I'm not an idiot, of course, this is true. However, why?
13:18 Speaker 01 Why, based on that, would we not then want to normalize the struggles of being put in said position?
13:28 Speaker 01 And the amount of support required to survive said position? I'll wait.
13:36 Speaker 00 It's a great question. It is a great question.
13:40 Speaker 01 Yeah, and so I was like, I cannot be the only person seeing this, but apparently I was. So there have been lots of articles, lots, there's lots of stuff floating around on the interwebs, but not a single book about that. And it's because we're not supposed to, because it breaks down this perception we create of leaders and creates a kind of a sense of unwelcome chaos. Because we as a species, we want to trust leaders, we want to believe they're, they're, they're stronger than us, better than us, they know the answer is they'll protect us. But when we talk about the silent struggles behind the veil of leadership, it, it can freak people out because then they realize, oh, they just don't, they don't know any better than me.
14:25 Speaker 01 They're the same as me, they just know something different, they're responsible for something different. We treat them differently because it breaks down the illusion of leadership and that makes people really uncomfortable.
14:37 Speaker 00 Yeah, and, and I agree, I think that's a big part of it. And I know this is something that you've explored in the book and we've, we've talked offline about it too. Um, it seems like there is a, um, I'll say it softly, a reluctance to uh, acknowledge the, the struggles of leaders or even care about it. I think there's a deficiency of compassion when it comes to the struggles of leadership too, where we say, we look at the leader and it seems as though they have everything that we do not have. And therefore it doesn't seem like they have the right to feel the negative things that we also feel too. And so it's almost like you, they have.
15:15 Speaker 00 Got into a level in stature where for some it feels inappropriate to give them compassion.
15:21 Speaker 01 Oh, yeah. A hundred percent. I liked how you put a deficiency of compassion and that's for two reasons backed in research. Would you like to know what they are?
15:31 Speaker 00 Let's hear it.
15:33 Speaker 01 So I found a couple of things that number one Sally didn't shock me, but also corroborated what we're talking about. So there is this one piece where people really, just like you said, because someone is in a leadership position, we should, we don't feel that we should need to support them because they're in a quote naturally more advantageous position than us. So that's one piece. The second piece, and this is a real thing. And I, I, I mentioned it several times throughout the book because I was like, don't forget about this.
16:15 Speaker 01 There was a, a large study conducted where it talked about, and I quote, something called the leadership wellbeing prototypes and the leadership mental illness prototypes, which literally showed that people assume purely based on the leadership position, that people quote naturally enjoy better mental health. I know. And experience less mental illness. That is the assumption that people make based on made up job titles that these human beings, based on more responsibility and more money,
17:01 Speaker 01 have better mental health and less mental illness. And I was like, did they miss the memo that world leaders tend to be sociopaths? Like I, I don't know. I kind of missed that, but that is what people think based on the veil of, of leadership that because they have more control in certain circumstances, they are paid more money. They are, you know, maybe get away with more. Unfortunately, in, in many cases, they have naturally better mental health and less mental illness.
17:38 Speaker 01 Yeah, breathe, just breathe.
17:40 Speaker 00 So clearly, that is inaccurate. And I also wonder if this is, and this is just hypothesizing, I'm sure you've given this a lot of thought. I'm wondering how much of that is some kind of version of projection? Where they say, I have certain mental challenges, or I feel these emotions that I would rather not feel. And if I had what they had, then I would not feel what I feel. And so then, when a person in that position feels those things, then they say, you're, I am not giving you any compassion. You shouldn't feel that way. Look at everything that you have.
18:15 Speaker 01 Yeah, there, that, that piece in itself could be its own podcast, really. Uh, and the, the lack of, and listen,
18:29 Speaker 01 there's a lot of leaders out there doing and have done
18:36 Speaker 01 a lot of bad shit. A lot. So if we look at social identity theory, for example,
18:46 Speaker 01 when individuals are representative from a group, it is so easy for people to say leaders are bad because of the badly behaved leaders in those, in that group. Where good leaders get torn down based on the group they represent. So it's very easy and understandable to get upset at people who have power over others. Because throughout history, people who have had power over others have done a lot of bad things. That doesn't make it any less true
19:29 Speaker 01 that mental health and leadership is important just because of some of the badly behaved people in that group. However, most people don't want to hear that. I have talked to several people who got very, very triggered by the fact that I wrote a book about the mental health of leaders because of the leaders who have screwed them over. In their career and those experiences are valid for God sakes. I had a manager who actively sabotaged my work and made sure that I knew that they didn't like me. They didn't want me to succeed.
20:07 Speaker 01 They didn't want me to stay around, but that doesn't give me the right to villainize all leaders and people in positions of power.
20:17 Speaker 00 Hmm. You're right. You're right. Essentially, this is the, we have the halo effect where we inappropriately extrapolate positive attributes to somebody that we see favorably. But then we also have the other side, which is the horn effect where we extrapolate inappropriately. But also, we're seeing how the bias is created. So there's a strong emotional attachment to a negative, a negative situation. And we say, the leader did this. Therefore, I'm skeptical of all leaders.
20:47 Speaker 01 There's actually an article that I cited in the book talking, I think it was from a psychoanalyst or psychiatrist. I don't remember. We're shocking no one. The mental representations that we make of leaders are built on previous representations of power from our past. Now, this can be parental figures. This can be previous leaders. It can be a hodgepodge of all of the above, where in some cases, people seek out leaders that remind them of positive representations from the past. Or alternatively, they will rally against leaders that give them negative reminders of other people in power positions from their past.
21:33 Speaker 00 That's so interesting. It's so much of who we become and what we believe just is formulated at such an impressionable age, you know?
21:41 Speaker 01 We are, I, we're kind of like those nesting Russian Matryoshka dolls.
21:47 Speaker 00 Mm hmm.
21:47 Speaker 01 And we get that we have layers within layers, within layers, within layers. And people don't like to be slowed down and reminded of that because it is so much easier to use mental heuristics or fancy word for shortcut, uh, to make snap judgments about people who have power over us. And I get it. I really do. And in the book, I say, listen, I understand. I completely understand. And that doesn't mean that this group of people that we put so much on their shoulders, demanding they do, asking that they do, that they don't deserve the support to be able to survive
22:26 Speaker 01 that role, to not then crack and have those cascading effects impact a company and its people.
22:34 Speaker 00 Right. Yeah. And I think that this is a perfect segue into the why this matters part, right? Because it sounds like hypothetically, I'm framing this in a Kwame way and you can reject it in a Mel way too. But it's almost like, let's say you listen to this and you're like, Mel, Kwame, I don't care. I don't like my leaders. I don't like leaders in generals, in general. But it sounds like even if they don't care at all about the leader, they should still care about the mental health of their leader. Because if the mental health is off, then it has, like you said, cascading effects that impact everybody. So if your leader is not in the best mental state, then it is likely to have a negative impact on you. So really, at the end of the day, even if you don't care about the person, you should care about yourself
23:19 Speaker 00 enough to care about their mental health.
23:22 Speaker 01 Yes. And that's the thing. If people need to be super dispassionate about it, transactional, listen, supporting leadership mental health is good for business. Supporting leadership mental health is good for team culture. Supporting leadership mental health is good for the bottom line. These are non-negotiable statements that supported leaders are more likely to support an organization and support their team. I'm not saying that supporting all leaders is going to make some leaders stop being assholes. Of course, I'm not saying that. Some people are just dicks. But there's so many expletives you're gonna have to beep out.
24:07 Speaker 01 There's your promo.
24:10 Speaker 01 But the odds are that if leaders feel it is socially acceptable to talk about their struggle so they can get support, so they can improve, wouldn't logic dictate that that is going to slightly change outcomes about how they behave within an organization? So they don't have to do shady things to cover their ass, so they don't take things out on their team who don't deserve it and destroy morale and psychological safety? So they get help sooner? I'm, I'm pretty sure these are reasonable things I'm talking about.
24:51 Speaker 01 But if people want to be dispassionate about it, don't, don't take the human case, don't take the bleeding heart case. If you want leaders to do better, support them better. That's it.
25:03 Speaker 00 Yep. Yeah. And I, I love this approach too, because if you care about people, you should care about this topic. If you don't care about them, but you care about you, you should care about this topic. It's the, the logical answer is to care and want to do something. Now, the question is, what do we do? Because now that we have this information, what would you say if people read the book? What is the change that you want to see as a result of reading it?
25:31 Speaker 01 So that is what the entire second part of the book is dedicated to, because I would have not been very nice if I built this whole case and then didn't give people a different way to approach it. So there, those changes fall into two buckets. Now we have what companies can do, and we also have what individual leaders can do. Now, the irony is not lost on me, that the people who need to benefit from this change are the ones who will be driving it. Now, leaders have enough to do, so we're putting more on their shoulders. But we can't ask individual contributors and other people not in those positions
26:14 Speaker 01 to drive a change that they may not even understand, they may not be bought into, they aren't the primary beneficiaries of it. We can't ask them to do that. So the people who need the change will be the ones that will drive it. It will be leaders themselves. Now, within organizations, there's a lot of different things that can be done. You and I have talked a lot about the power of storytelling.
26:42 Speaker 01 It takes a long time to establish a narrative and it takes a long time to change it. Now, we need, it's kind of like, we need a lot of people to normalize leadership mental health struggles, to make the people who don't normalize it like the weird ones in the corner. That's kind of what we're going for, because you can't get every single person to buy into any idea. That's not how human beings work. So, we need to have as many companies as possible and as many people within those companies as possible, normalizing the coexistence of mental health struggles and effective leadership. Now, there are a lot of different ways to do that. Whether that is in day-to-day conversations, whether it is through company town halls,
27:27 Speaker 01 whether it's through highlights and newsletters, whether, there are lots of different channels to do this. But when leaders are talking about their struggles and talking about the resources they use to manage it, people can sniff out if it's performative or disingenuous. So if a company is going to try and change that narrative, you better be ready to stand behind it. So what I mean by that is not just talking about and highlighting leaders who struggle to normalize conversations about mental health. Everybody's already doing that. The way you back that up is by then saying, this is how we're actually supporting leadership mental health and making it a part of critical leadership development. Here's where those impact points are.
28:12 Speaker 01 It's in onboarding. It's an ongoing leadership training. It's in leadership, mental health peer support networks that we're creating within our company. You can't just say leadership, mental health is important, but then not show the structures that are going to support it in an ongoing basis, not just from a support position, but an accountability position. Because leadership, mental health has to be treated as a core leadership professional competency. So, so companies need to show how they're supporting that in an ongoing endeavor, not just through support, but also education. This is another one of the reasons I created the, I know, very sexy title, Mental Health That Work: Conversational Literacy For Leaders.
28:58 Speaker 01 Because you, you have to equip them with the skill set to talk about their mental health, support their peers' mental health, to support their team's mental health, in between the moments of encouraging them to call the EAP or to go to therapy or to do all these, these support moments, because it, it has to be in tandem. You have to show how you're encouraging leaders to use mental health resources and in between those moments, how you are educating them about the function of mental health within their own leadership.
29:31 Speaker 01 I, I, I feel crazy sometimes when I'm explaining these things because this is what's done for employees and for other people. So why the hell is it not being done for leaders in the same way? Because they get concerned that, oh, if we're supporting leadership, mental health, and people will doubt our leaders. No. It is quite the app opposite where you are supporting their mental health proactively. You are encouraging to use mental health resources proactively so they can be healthier leaders for the organization.
30:03 Speaker 00 Right.
30:04 Speaker 01 Ta-da.
30:06 Speaker 01 The the other piece I was gonna say is individual leaders who are taking part in that system, who are using the resources, because you know, if you're gonna build it, they have to come. So they have to be engaging in the education, engaging in the consistent, you know, me- mental health, which honestly is the is a part of emotional intelligence. Making sure they practice their mental well being, non negotiables, you know, one of my favorite terms I've trademarked, that they're they're communicating their capacity to people, that they there are so many things individually they have to do, and taking part in the support system that's made for them.
30:44 Speaker 00 Yes. Yeah. And and for me, it makes me think about how much of the the reason why we haven't done this yet, across the board, just as a an industry norm, is because of and things that you we've touched on, it's like politics and posturing, where the the leader.
31:02 Speaker 01 Love the alliteration.
31:03 Speaker 00 Yes. Where they're saying to themselves, you know what, I do have these struggles, but I don't want to share, because if I'm vulnerable in this way, then people might question the leadership. Because it's it's funny where we're kind of ironic where we're saying the people who need this are also the people who have the the political capital and authority within the company to create this, and yet they have not done that for themselves. It reminds me kind of like with sports psychologists back in the day, it used to be stigmatized as like, ooh, this this athlete needs a sports psychologist, they are mentally broken. And now it's kind of like, you don't have a mental.
31:38 Speaker 01 Expected.
31:39 Speaker 00 Like, what?
31:40 Speaker 01 Yes.
31:40 Speaker 00 Yeah.
31:42 Speaker 01 Uh, you know, it's funny you mention this, which actually, one of the people who endorsed my book is a former NBA player and is now an NBA optimization mindset coach.
31:54 Speaker 00 Hmm. Oh, nice.
31:55 Speaker 01 Uh, and last and last night, I was watching the series on Netflix, Death by Lightning.
32:03 Speaker 01 It's about the assassination of President Garfield, who really like, no one really talks about him because he was assass- he was shot three months into his presidency. But what I found so interesting about the show, and it has Nick Offerman in it. He plays the, who was Vice President Arthur, who then became President Arthur, another president a lot of folks don't know about. Even though he apparently reformed civil service in ways that is still effective today. I'm, I'm not a politico by any means, so you just heard the entirety of my knowledge about this entire, you know, chapter in history.
32:46 Speaker 01 Where Garfield seemed to be a very, very, very humble man. And he didn't even want the job. He just because they had like ranked choice voting back then was like thrust into, into being the nominee for president. And he was like, I don't want it, but okay. So he kept trying to humanize himself to people. That he's not this oracle and that the man who actually sought counsel from him, who ultimately assassinated him was like, how do I become? Like you, like, how do I be like you, setting him up into this image? And Garfield was like, I'm, I'm just a man like you. You know, this is the, the path.
33:27 Speaker 01 That I've been led towards. And he was a religious man. So he said, you know, God made this plan for me. And he really was trying to normalize. He's like, I'm just a man. And his wife was like, you are more than just a man to these people. You have to be better. You are a leader. They look to you for guidance. They look up to you. And again, just placing the leadership veil on him, saying, it doesn't matter that you're trying to be just a human to these people because to them you are more.
33:56 Speaker 01 So this, this is a narrative that, that is as old as civilization itself.
34:01 Speaker 00 Mm hmm.
34:02 Speaker 01 How do we change that with a lot of fucking effort?
34:06 Speaker 00 Right, right. Let's, let's talk about that effort. And I think this is an important opportunity to shout out your last book and we'll link to your last episode on the podcast too, about how you can talk about mental health at work, because this sounds like one of those types of negotiations that you have to have within the company to create this. But I think the first negotiation they have to have is internally, because the leader needs to say, okay, now I need to have enough confidence to share that I might have a struggle, or there are other people who might have a struggle. How do they, how do they have that conversation internally to become more comfortable to have the conversation externally?
34:45 Speaker 01 Well, that's where they have to start. And, and you know that in both of my books, that I'm, I'm always like, don't just, don't just jump in, don't just cannonball into this conversation. You know, have a little conversation with yourself about where did my beliefs come from? Who did I learn them from? Why do I feel like I need to hide this to begin with? Where did I learn these lessons? So I think the first thing to do is to have that internal dialogue and maybe in an, an internal debate, basically saying, do I want to talk about this? What am I trying to achieve? Is not talking about this serving me in, in any positive way. Would talking about it serve me differently?
35:29 Speaker 01 And what is my goal for trying to change these conversations? Because if you're not aligned on that, before you have these conversations, people will eat you alive.
35:39 Speaker 00 Right.
35:39 Speaker 01 Because if you don't give statement of intention, if you don't talk about why you're talking about something, what you're trying to achieve. Human beings are pattern creating creatures. We will fill in the blanks unless someone tells us otherwise. So that's where it needs to start, you know, map out where your influences come from, what your obstacles are, what your concerns are, what you're trying to achieve and.
36:04 Speaker 01 The one liners you're gonna say when people challenge the validity of what you're saying, because it will happen. It will happen. And then it comes down to sentiments like, just because I'm a VP doesn't mean that I don't struggle and that I can't struggle. And me talking about how I struggle and what I plan to do about it is actually a sign of emotional intelligence and is pretty good in leadership. And I'd like to understand why you don't agree.
36:34 Speaker 00 Well, that's a bar.
36:37 Speaker 01 Your butt just tightened a little bit because I, because what did I say that's wrong? What did I say that's, that's rude? What did I say that's not based in logic or fact? That didn't invite a conversation?
36:51 Speaker 00 Yeah. And I think just another strategic note here, when you drop a question that is, that has that much weight, there's no way for somebody to respond quickly. Don't let them off.
37:03 Speaker 01 No, no, because they're gonna be like, oh, this is uncomfortable. And, and the thing, the thing is that when you really just boil it down to logic,
37:16 Speaker 01 typically speaking, you're gonna get a, a pretty uncomfortable person sitting in front of you, or they may kind of, just kind of, usually when I, when I ask questions like that, I get one of two responses, either, well, I didn't think about it like that. Or then they pull something called DARVO. Deny, attack, reverse victim offender.
37:45 Speaker 01 It's a lot of people in politics who do this. We're not gonna name names. But usually when someone's attacking you and you explain why their approach is illogical and not based in reason, and you explain it calmly, they then get triggered and they attack you. So if you're gonna say stuff like that, and people start to try to turn it around on you, then it turns into, I'm sorry that my logic and reason make you uncomfortable, but that doesn't make it any less valid.
38:20 Speaker 00 Every year, I swear that I'm going to get ahead of holiday shopping. This year, it started with a Quince cashmere sweater that I bought for myself. It was so soft, so well-made, and my first thought was, who else on my list needs one? Quince makes high-quality staples with 100% Mongolian cashmere and Italian leather, and their cashmere sweaters start at just $60. All of it is 50% to 80% less than similar brands because they work directly with ethical factories and cut out the middleman. As a negotiator, I know a great deal when I see one. This is luxury quality without the luxury price tag. I use Quince, and you should too. Give the gift of quality this season. Download the Quince app for app-exclusive offers, or just go to quince.com.
39:04 Speaker 00 Get free shipping on your order and 365-day returns, now available in Canada and the UK too. And when Quince asks where you heard about them, let them know it was Kwame with Big Swings only. That's the best way to support the show. If you were going to take a big swing this holiday season and start a business, what would you build? Maybe it's that one idea that you can't stop thinking about. I've built a business from the ground up, and I can tell you that the hard part isn't the idea, it's getting it live. That's where Shopify comes in. You can sell everywhere people shop: online, in person, across social media, even in AI chats. And Shopify Checkout with Shop Pay converts up to 36% higher than the competition,
39:47 Speaker 00 so more of the people who show up actually buy. Plus, Black Friday is when more people are already shopping and ready to buy, so the sooner you're live, the better. If you're ready to launch your business before Black Friday, go to Shopify.com/Kwame to start your free trial. That's Shopify.com/Kwame. Go to Shopify.com/Kwame to hear your first
40:14 Speaker 00 My goodness.
40:15 Speaker 01 I know, I know. I know it's uncomfortable. We're all gonna get through it. We're all gonna get through it. And listen, I am fully aware that what I am saying in many cases is gonna create conflict. But rallying against ideas always does.
40:32 Speaker 00 It's true. And, and that's the thing, but conflict is not a bad thing. It's, it's if we have unproductive, unproductive, toxic conflict, that's not bad. That's, that's not good. But if we have productive, constructive conflict, then that's a good thing and it's necessary. And I think that's, it's a requirement for change and that, and people don't appreciate that enough.
40:54 Speaker 01 And that's the thing, there needs to be productive conflict surrounding this topic because we can't just be like, leadership mental health matters. And people go, okay. No, they're gonna push back and they're gonna get confused and they're gonna get angry and they can get resentful. And then you explore those feelings. Try to see where they come from because then you have to insert logic and reason and the case for why this is reasonable and why organizations should care about it and what the, the positive ricochet effects are of doing it and the negative ricochet effects of not doing it. It's supposed to be a conversation. We should have productive conflict
41:37 Speaker 01 where leaders humanize themselves and then explore the discomfort that creates for people.
41:42 Speaker 00 Yep.
41:43 Speaker 01 Talk about it.
41:44 Speaker 00 And what's beautiful is that you've already made those arguments. You laid it out. Like I said, you made the case like a lawyer at the beginning. And so if
41:53 Speaker 01 Thank you.
41:54 Speaker 00 If this is resonating with you, then get the book so you can make these arguments because you've essentially done the work for them when it comes to building the case. What would you say are some really, if, if somebody is saying, all right, I'm gonna do this journey, Mel, I'm gonna have these conversations, I'm gonna push for this. And there's somebody who is skeptical, they're, they're kind of blocking, they're uncomfortable as we described before. And you've already given us a lot of talking points, but I want to talk about specific questions. What are some other really powerful questions that we could ask them to get them to shift their perspectives and be more open to this?
42:32 Speaker 01 So I think if we're talking to a skeptic, now there would be two categories. There would be an individual contributor and there would also be a leader. Because let's keep in mind that there are plenty of leaders
42:46 Speaker 01 who also rally against what I am talking about.
42:51 Speaker 01 Because they like the veil of leadership. They, they like what it creates and they don't want to put any, you know, proverbial cracks in it. So let's look at, let's look at the leader first, who may be a bit skeptical. My question would be,
43:10 Speaker 01 I understand that this image serves a purpose for you.
43:17 Speaker 01 Help me understand why maintaining that image for other leaders who don't want that is a helpful thing for leaders overall. Help me understand. If you want to maintain this your way for yourself, I understand. I'm certainly not going to tell you what to do. But why put that on other leaders who don't want to function that way?
43:43 Speaker 01 Does opening up help for them? Change something for you?
43:50 Speaker 01 That, that's the conversation I would want to have. Because there is kind of this herd mentality that we need to all, you know, be uniform. And you see this in companies all the time. United Front, United Leadership Group. I, I get that. That should not apply to supporting mental health. If some leaders don't want to talk about their mental health, they don't want to go there. Fine, no one's forcing you legally. We can't, can't force anybody to talk about mental health in the workplace.
44:19 Speaker 01 But if other leaders want to, because it helps them to be a better leader, why are you trying to stop them? Help me understand. That's the conversation I would want to have. Because they put this united front framework on leadership mental health where it doesn't belong.
44:37 Speaker 00 Right.
44:39 Speaker 01 Now, individual contributors, going back to what you and I were talking about earlier, I would say, what scares you about supporting leadership mental health? What scares you? What are you concerned about might happen? Talk me through it. And I think that's the main question. What makes you angry about supporting leadership mental? What makes you angry? What makes you resentful about supporting leadership mental health? I don't want to shy away from those feelings. I want to understand where they come from. There is always a source. There's always a reason. And they're valid because these people have probably been seriously screwed over by emotionally constipated leaders throughout their career.
45:23 Speaker 01 Like, I get it. Those experiences are valid. And that doesn't make the premise any less true. That supporting leadership mental health creates better business outcomes, creates better team experience, creates better employee engagement. All the data's there. I am not by myself in this. So those are the questions I'd want to explore because the questions and the pushback is valid. So let's talk about where it comes from. And then I'm going to dump this big case on you that you can't argue against.
45:53 Speaker 00 Yes, I love it. I love this. And I think one of the biggest challenges people might face is the idea of, I suffered, so you must suffer too. And
46:04 Speaker 01 Oh, yeah.
46:05 Speaker 00 For me, I think about the bar exam. I'm like, why are we doing the bar exam this way? And then I hear, you know, how many of her years out? But then I hear they might change it to make it a little bit easier. I'm like, what? I had to suffer? And then I'm like, oh, no, I'm doing what other people do, you know? And I'm wondering how much of that mentality kind of applies here? Where somebody's like, listen, I've been suffering for 30 years and nobody cared about me and I still got it done. So when you run into that, how do you approach that challenge?
46:40 Speaker 01 So, as I'm sure you'll recall, because chapter five was a behemoth, and I'm sorry for that.
46:49 Speaker 01 Uh, I was talking about the kind of intergenerational tug of war about talking about mental health at work. And we, we consciously know that finger pointing at each other doesn't work and doesn't create commonality, but we keep doing it. So I'm not going to be able to stop that, but I'm still going to comment on it. So you see five generations in the workplace and you see leaders within each of those generations and how they're each saying, I'm right, no, I'm right, no, I'm right, no, you're wrong.
47:28 Speaker 01 But the problem is that they're just reflections on when they were born in the space-time continuum. Okay? They each have access to different kinds of social permission, nomenclature, social rules to talk about something or not talk about something. And the thing is, what they all share in common is not only are they the same species, but they all have struggles. Every single one of them. They just have a different social permission structure. That's it.
48:08 Speaker 01 So for me, it's not even talking about how I was raised, or what's right, or how I came up. None of that matters. The only thing we have in common, every person struggles in some way. Every leader, every leader struggles in some way. You cannot argue with that. So instead of pointing to different points of the space-time continuum of what's socially acceptable, why don't we just connect on that? And trying to find some form of in the middle method to support each other in leadership, regardless of when you came up or how.
48:54 Speaker 01 That's it.
48:56 Speaker 01 I'm, I want to strip all of it away, strip it down to bare bones. There each. A human being in a leadership role that will struggle. So why not just connect on the strain of leadership? The emotional struggles it can create.
49:17 Speaker 01 Even if everything else is stripped away.
49:19 Speaker 00 Right.
49:20 Speaker 01 That should be something that, e- even if you don't talk to individual contributors. If anybody else can understand, it's other leaders, talk to other leaders who will get it. You and I have talked about this. The safest container is other people who understand. So why, why get caught up in the different generations when you all are in that same? Again, social identity theory, you're all in that same group. So why not support each other within the group?
49:48 Speaker 00 Right. Makes a lot of sense. And I want.
49:52 Speaker 01 So too.
49:54 Speaker 00 I want to make sure we, we leave some time for Simone to get in. Simone, what, what thoughts are coming to mind? Any questions?
50:01 Speaker 02 Is there anything employees can do to support leaders? Because it's like a taboo and it's very difficult for an employee to go and, and talk to the leader and say, hey, you should see a doctor, you know? It's, it's not easy. So how?
50:16 Speaker 01 Well, I definitely wouldn't say that. I definitely wouldn't say to the leader, you need to go see a doctor.
50:22 Speaker 01 Definitely big no. But I under, I understand the point.
50:28 Speaker 01 Yeah, def, I definitely don't do that. But yes, employees need to be able to support leaders too, because everybody is a chronologically aged adult. I say chronologically aged, not mentally aged, because those are not often the same. But everybody is an adult in the workplace. There is no rule against supporting leaders because they are a leader. Now, we are taught not to do that. We are taught that the support framework is, is one direction. It, it can be actually bidirectional. So that doesn't mean.
51:07 Speaker 01 Wholly disrupting power dynamics. That's not what we're trying to do. Power dynamics exist for a reason and in lots of different situations. However, there is nothing wrong with just asking a leader how they are doing. You know, you don't seem yourself the last couple of weeks. I hope it's okay. I'm asking, is, is everything okay? Like, do you, do you want to have a coffee or something? There is nothing wrong with that. And you can even acknowledge the elephant in the room. You can be like, I, I understand you're my manager, but like, you're still a person. You know, is, is everything okay? There is nothing wrong with doing that. Now, it depends on the rapport you have with your, with your manager.
51:51 Speaker 01 If you don't have that kind of relationship, little tougher to navigate. If you want to have that kind of relationship, but you don't, acknowledge that. Hey, I, I know we haven't talked about this before, but I, it seems like you've been really stressed the last month. Is it okay? I'm asking how you're doing. Ask permission. Acknowledge the dynamic. Acknowledge it's a new, a new conversation that you don't have any nefarious intention. I'm not trying to make you uncomfortable. I'm, I'm just checking in. I hope that's okay. That is how simple it can be, but, but definitely don't say you gotta go see a doctor.
52:29 Speaker 00 We.
52:30 Speaker 01 And. Don't say that.
52:33 Speaker 00 It's a great point, and that's very helpful too, because for all the things that, the reasons we described, discussed already. And then also the things that you talked about in the book, it can be scary as a leader to, to be vulnerable.
52:45 Speaker 01 Yeah.
52:45 Speaker 00 And I think also there's a lot of modeling from, from me as a man, what masculinity, the nexus between masculinity and neck and, um, leadership should look like. But also I know my family's coming from the Caribbean. There's a level of stoicism that the, the males should always have in the, uh, relationship and the family structure too. And so a lot of times as a leader, if I'm struggling, I project to the team, everything's fine. We're good. And then I'll call Mel, I'm like, I am freaking out. Okay, so this is what's happening. Um, what it, am I, what, what's wrong? Am I the problem? What's happening? You know, and so it, it goes to what you're, you're saying too about the importance of having leaders having a network that they could confide into. Because sometimes vulnerability can be really scary.
53:30 Speaker 01 But also, that's why I was talking so much about intersectionality in chapter five, because it's not just the veil of leadership. It's also gender and sexual orientation and culture of origin and ethnicity and country of origin and all these other things that give messages about identity intersecting with leadership and mental health. Do you remember the harangue I went on about Barbie? Not just for women, but also for men. So you have, you have all of these complex things that are not, you're not just trying
54:11 Speaker 01 to portray yourself as a leader, but in your case, someone who identifies as male, who is, you know, your history is from the Caribbean, like these are additional messages that you have. And so there's so much that goes into it that puts those leadership prototypes on steroids.
54:32 Speaker 00 Right. You're so right. And I think there's an added layer too. If you are a compassionate leader who wants to be there and empathize for, with their team, right? So you're always emotionally, you're available to them, being supportive to them, and it can feel really hard. And this, I think, extends out from just leadership within companies, but also leadership within families too. There's somebody who often plays the role of the strong one, you know? And if, it can almost feel as though when you are constantly there for other people emotionally, you feel like the structure of strength, the foundation will fall out
55:14 Speaker 00 if you say, by the way, I'm strong for you, but I need somebody to be strong for me too.
55:19 Speaker 01 Oh yeah, there was a study done by a variety of universities where they were taking a look at Latino males and those who identify as male.
55:33 Speaker 01 And the leadership lessons they get culturally from within Latin America, and how that shows up within how they believe they should act as leaders. And they explored the concept of felicimo, which is exactly what you're describing. And then for Latina women and those who identify as female, they're often governed by, I'm probably saying this wrong, personalisimo, where it's having, you know, shared harmony and care and nurturing and building trust, whereas for Latino male and those who identify as male, felicimo is having, you know, strength, dependability, consistency,
56:18 Speaker 01 you know, all these things that you're describing. So you tend to see a lot of this, especially in collectivistic cultures.
56:24 Speaker 00 So this is, it's so fascinating because when you bring in gender, you bring in socioeconomic status, you bring in history, culture, all of these things, it'll have a modifying effect on
56:37 Speaker 01 Oh, yeah.
56:37 Speaker 00 on all of this, which is is true in all communication too. You know, so it's just interesting to see how it's everywhere. And we need to be mindful of it so we can make more accurate assessments and understand ourselves and others on a deeper, deeper level.
56:53 Speaker 01 Oh, yeah. I mean, the self-assessment that I'm asking people to do in this book before they have these conversations is pretty significant because you have to understand how you became this baked cake and where you get these messages from before you even attempt to have these conversations with others.
57:12 Speaker 00 Right, right. Let's and let's let's wrap with this, Mel, because I'm wondering, hypothetically, if everyone in the working world were to read this book, what change would you hope to see?
57:28 Speaker 01 Oh, that's not a loaded question at all. God.
57:33 Speaker 01 What would I hope to see, the one thing?
57:38 Speaker 00 If you were going to take a big swing this holiday season and start a business, what would you build? Maybe it's that one idea that you can't stop thinking about. I've built a business from the ground up and I can tell you that the hard part isn't the idea, it's getting it live. That's where Shopify comes in. You can sell everywhere people shop, online, in person, across social media, even in AI chats. And Shopify checkout with Shop Pay converts up to 36% higher than the competition. So more of the people who show up actually buy. Plus, Black Friday is when more people are already shopping and ready to buy. So the sooner you're live, the better. If you're ready to launch your business before Black Friday, go to Shopify.com/Quami to start your free trial.
58:23 Speaker 00 That's Shopify.com/Quami. Go to Shopify.com/Quami to hear your first...
58:31 Speaker 00 Try this. Pull up your notes from a meeting last week. Do they still make sense? Or do they just seem like random notes that only the old version of you could decode? That used to be me. And as a negotiator, that's a real problem. Because my job is to listen, not type or write notes. That's why Granola has been one of my favorite tools, period. It's an AI-powered notepad. I jot my usual rough notes, and then Granola securely transcribes the meeting in the background. And when it ends, I get clean, structured notes that still make sense a week later. Decisions, owners, next steps, everything that I would need to feel good about going forward. And it works through your device's audio too. So there's no additional setup or any annoying AI joining your call. Just your normal meeting, but with superpowers.
59:16 Speaker 00 If meetings are eating up your day, Granola is a no-brainer. You can try it totally free for three months. Just go to granola.ai/Quami. That's granola.ai/Quami to get your time back. Get three months free at granola.ai/Quami.
59:35 Speaker 01 When people would see a leader struggling in their company, that the first reaction isn't anger and disdain,
59:51 Speaker 01 but rather curiosity. I would like to see people be curious.
59:58 Speaker 01 I'm not saying to excuse, no, no, no. You know that I have no patience for people who put bad behavior towards others when they're not managing it themselves. That's a big, hard no.
1:00:12 Speaker 01 But I think that a sign of change and success is when a leader is showing signs of distress or is acting out,
1:00:25 Speaker 01 that one, one of the first reactions is curiosity. I wonder why, as opposed to immediately saying, well, they're the fucking devil. So, and, and granted, you know, some are, there are some bad people out there. Not, not everybody is good. Some people are bad,
1:00:46 Speaker 01 but not everybody is bad. And so I think that having one of the first reactions be curiosity, that alone, I think, is sign of change and success because curiosity can lead to really good conversations.
1:01:01 Speaker 00 That's powerful. That is great, Mel. Thank you so much for coming on the show. Before you go, again, just remind the listeners about the book and how they can work with you too.
1:01:11 Speaker 01 So, uh, my second book, Cornered Office, Why We Need to Talk About Leadership Mental Health, uh, comes out February 24th, 2026, currently available for preorder across, uh, all platforms and anybody who sells books. And, um, I'm just so, so looking forward to it coming out. And if you would like me to come into your company or conference or summit and, uh, crack some heads talking about leadership, mental health, uh, please feel free to get in touch. At Melissa Doman dot com. You can also connect with me on LinkedIn or on Instagram
1:01:49 Speaker 01 at the wandering Mel. I do firesides, keynotes, trainings, consulting, anything to do with mental health at work, communication and team dynamics. And I would love to come in and provide actual realistic interventions that will produce results.
1:02:10 Speaker 00 Amazing. Mel, thank you so much for joining us. Really appreciate it.
1:02:14 Speaker 01 Ah, thanks for having me. Always good to come on the show.
1:02:16 Speaker 00 Hey, everyone. I want to tell you about a podcast I'm really excited about. It's called The Anxious Achiever, and it's hosted by my good friend, Maura Aronsmele, and it's part of the Yap Media Network. Here on Big Swings Only, we're all about going after the big stuff. But anyone who's taken a real swing knows anxiety usually comes along for the ride. And honestly, nobody handles that better than Maura. Since 2019, her show has helped millions of listeners navigate stress, mental health, and the search for meaning through work. With personal stories, expert insights, and evidence-based tools, she tackles anxiety, perfectionism, ADHD, and psychological safety at work with guests ranging from the US Surgeon
1:02:56 Speaker 00 General to NFL and NBA stars. It's a top 10 management podcast and a Signal Award winner for Best Commute Podcast. And she's been a guest on our show, too. If you're ready to take control of your anxiety and your life, you definitely want to check out The Anxious Achiever. Subscribe to The Anxious Achiever today on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever
Previous What No One Tells You About the Future (AI, Uncertainty & Staying Grounded) Next Inside the Mind of Exceptional Negotiators: What They Know — and You Don’t Page updated November 6, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated