Pod Insights Negotiate Anything How to Give Feedback Without Triggering Defensiveness — Backed by Science About this episode Most feedback fails not because it’s wrong — but because it triggers defensiveness. Buy the book Let's Talk: Make Effective Feedback Your Superpower by Therese Huston In this episode, cognitive scientist and author Therese Huston joins Kwame Christian to reveal the brain science behind effective, non-threatening feedback. You’ll learn why even well-meaning feedback can backfire, how to prevent emotional resistance before it starts, and what most managers get completely wrong when delivering hard truths. Whether you're a leader avoiding uncomfortable conversations or someone who wants to build a culture of trust, this episode gives you practical, research-backed tools to speak up without sparking conflict. Discover the subtle shifts — from leading with listening to stating your intentions — that make feedback land with clarity and care. 🔍 You’ll learn: Why your brain sees feedback as a threat — and how to override it The “Jedi” feedback move that instantly lowers defenses What to say before criticism to avoid sounding like an enemy Why silence makes things worse — and how to break it safely Connect with Dr. Therese Huston theresehuston.com Buy the Book - Sharp - 14 Simple Ways to Improve Your Life with Brain Science Follow Therese on LinkedIn Contact ANI Request A Customized Workshop For Your Company Follow Kwame Christian on LinkedIn negotiateanything.com Click here to buy your copy of Finding Confidence in Conflict: How to Negotiate Anything and Live Your Best Life!
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 If you listen to this show, you're probably one of two people. You're someone who's trying to improve their communication skills and learn how to resolve conflict, or you're a dealmaker who's trying to learn how to get an edge in their next negotiation so you can either make more or save more. The American Negotiation Institute is built for both. We have keynotes for conferences, workshops for teams, and courses for everyone because the best things in life are on the other side of difficult conversations. Hey, I'm Kwame Christian, and you are about to step into the world of Negotiate Anything, the number one negotiation podcast in the world where we teach you how to make difficult conversations easier while getting more of what you want in the process. Each episode is packed with practical tips and strategies from the experts.
0:45 Speaker 00 We delve into negotiation, conflict resolution, and leadership skills that are crucial in both business and in life. Whether you're closing a deal, managing a team, or navigating personal relationships, Negotiate Anything provides you with the tools you need to succeed. Our conversations are real, relatable, and most importantly, rooted in practicality. So if you're ready to transform your conversations and elevate your negotiation skills, join me on Negotiate Anything. Subscribe and listen on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you love to listen. Let's make every conversation a winning negotiation.
1:25 Speaker 00 Therese, thanks for joining us today.
1:27 Speaker 01 Thanks, Kwame. It's so good to be here.
1:29 Speaker 00 Yes, it's great having you. So how about you get us started by telling us a little bit about yourself and what you do?
1:34 Speaker 01 Sure. I'm a cognitive scientist at Seattle University, and I try to help smart people be smarter at work. It's that simple. And what that means in terms of my actual, the ways that I do that, I give talks, I write books, I do consulting, I'm basically trying to take smart research and turn it into great practice. And people are hungry for what is better practice and what does the research have to say? And I try to package that in a way that people can really use at work.
2:03 Speaker 00 That's fantastic, and I respect that because I my undergrad degree is in psych. And I can um I can get really lost in the studies and then afterwards I say, well, what do I do with this? And so it's it's great to see that you're actually taking that literature and and turning it into practical advice that people can put into to use.
2:21 Speaker 01 Yeah, I I'm I'm with you. It's fun to read, but then you step away and you forget the studies because you can't actually make it actionable. So I really tried to to take the best research that's out there and say, okay, if you were going to use this at work, what would you do? And and I try to put it in practice in my own work, not just proselytize, but actually, what does it look like when I try it?
2:39 Speaker 00 Yeah, this is great. Well, fantastic. Well, listeners, the the three things we're going to focus on today. First, we're going to talk about common mistakes that managers make when they're giving feedback. Then we're going to move on to talk about how to truly give helpful feedback instead. Then lastly, how to solicit better feedback from your manager. So let's start off with the juicy stuff, mistakes, share stories, tell us about it.
3:02 Speaker 01 Oh, there are so many mistakes that we make when we're giving feedback. Most of us aren't trained. You know, I know you have a law degree, Kwame. Um, plenty of people get law degrees and MBAs and and advanced degrees. And yet they still like, nobody ever trains them how to give feedback. I'm doing a program right now at Oxford in their business school. And all the different things we talk about, we never talk about how to give feedback. So it's really common that this is overlooked. So uh my book talks about a bunch of different mistakes that are all avoidable, but I'll just talk about three here today that are are really common. So one common mistake in giving feedback is you don't do it. You just don't give the feedback.
3:40 Speaker 01 Um, there's a a recent study showing that in the United States, approximately twenty one percent of managers admit that they just don't give the uncomfortable feedback. They avoid the conversations altogether. So that's a disaster if you're a CEO or a president, right? Think about that. You've got one hundred managers, twenty one of them are just skipping the hard conversations. Twenty one teams, right? That means twenty one teams are just crossing their fingers and hope they improve, you know? They're they're being robbed of the opportunity for feedback. And so I want to change that. I want to and I and I understand people don't have the training. People want to be the nice guy. They they don't want to be the one who has to say the hard thing.
4:23 Speaker 01 There's so many reasons why people will skip the hard conversation. You might not want to crush someone's spirit, spirit, especially during COVID, right? People don't want to reduce morale and motivation. It happened to me last fall. I had hired a freelance designer and she provided her initial designs and they were really off the mark, right? Kwame, they were they were not what I wanted. And my first thought was like, oh, you know what? I need to hire somebody else. And I got back online. I'm like, oh, I need to hire a new designer. And I was like, wait a second, give her the feedback, give her the chance to improve. It's so easy to write it off as this person can't do this. I need to turn to someone else or need to give the job to someone else. So that would be that would be one of the biggest mistakes is simply that people don't give the feedback.
5:06 Speaker 00 This is really, it it makes so much sense, but it's so scary too, right? Just how many professionals out there are not getting that aren't getting the the proper feedback. And you're you're a psychology nerd, just like me. And so let's let's play with this for a little bit. Because of course, there's there's going to be the side of they were never taught how to do it, right? But there there might be that thing in the back of their head saying, hey, I should probably talk to them about their performance. But there's something holding them back. So for the people who have some kind of emotional or psychological barrier to having these conversations, what advice would you have? Would you give them?
5:43 Speaker 01 So put picture yourself in the in the other side of the conversation. You're the person who's who's not being given the feedback. If if you knew your manager had something to say to you that they saw a place that you could improve and they didn't say anything, what would be running through your mind? You'd be thinking, you know, don't they believe in me? Do they think I'm too sensitive? Do they think I can't take it? Have have other people noticed that I'm underperforming in this way? Maybe they're not the only one who's noticed, right? So if you can flip, if you can take the other perspective, you would be mortified to find out that your manager has some great piece of advice or concern. And they're skipping it. So one of the things you can do is try to imagine yourself in the other side of the equation. What would, how would I feel if my manager didn't do
6:26 Speaker 01 this? So that can be helpful to get you there. Um, I, I think part of the problem is our own discomfort with how the other person is going to react, right? Um, there's a great episode of The Office. I don't know if you're a fan of The Office, but there's a great episode. You are. Okay, good. There's a great episode of The Office where Michael needs to tell one of his employees that, um, his fiance Angela is having an affair with someone and Michael thinks about it. He thinks about it all day, right? When am I going to tell this person? And what he ends up doing is they're walking to the parking lot together and Michael, as he drives away, unrolls his window and says, Angela's having an affair. As he drives away so that there's no further conversation. You know, it's not work feedback,
7:10 Speaker 01 but there, but, but that just illustrates like the discomfort that someone can have with giving bad news. And, and then that gets mingled with, we think the other person's going to have a terrible reaction. So we over, over, over hypothesize as to how they're going to react. The honesty is, most people are silent in the face of critical feedback. You know, they're surprised by it, or they're, they realize, oh, you know, I knew that was coming. I knew that didn't go as well. And they're embarrassed. But most people don't have a really strong reaction. Um, they're, they're usually looking for guidance. So a good thing to know is people are probably going to be much more passive than you expect. Um, so, so don't, don't hold back for that reason. You, you know, you can help that person improve. They want to improve. And like I said, put yourself in that other person's
7:55 Speaker 01 shoes and it'll help you get past whatever obstacles you're running into, your, your own discomfort.
8:00 Speaker 00 That's great. I love this. And I love The Office. So that is a great, great example. So yes, so tell us more. So we had the one mistake, people just don't give feedback. What else?
8:14 Speaker 01 So another one, and okay, let's say, let's say you're in that eighty percent. You're like, Therese, I do give feedback. I'm gonna go. I've got, in fact, a feedback conversation tomorrow. A common step that people skip is they don't say their good intentions out loud. This is something I talk about in my book, but I haven't read in any other feedback books. But it's, it is, it's the Jedi maneuver is to say your good intentions out loud. So first, let's talk about why don't people say their good intentions out loud? So what's really interesting here is we do, we assume the other person believes we have good intentions. But what the research shows, study after study, is that when someone brings them bad news,
8:54 Speaker 01 we assume the bearer of bad news has malevolent intentions, right? And maybe you've had this experience. So you go to the doctor's office and your doctor, you know, you go because you have what you think is a small problem. And your doctor says, oh, this could be serious. You know, we need to do a bunch of tests. I need you to come in for two follow-ups. We'll do the first test. You come in in two weeks and I'll have you come in in two months. Then I'll have you come in at six months. And what do you think? You're like, oh, my gosh, my doctor just wants a whole bunch of visits, a whole bunch of copays, right? Instead of thinking, this person's trying to take care of me. They're trying to catch this problem early before it becomes huge, you know, before I have to go on medication.
9:35 Speaker 01 It's just a perfect example of how we assume negative intentions, even when that person is literally trying to take care of us, right? I, I don't know if you can relate to that example, but I sure can. You know, I've had that experience with doctors before. And there's plenty of research showing when, when, when somebody brings us bad news, we shoot the messenger. We assume negative intentions on their part. And research, there's a great study by Leslie John. She's a management professor at Harvard. And one of the things that she did, she made it completely random. She had people draw a little slip of paper. Her research assistant would draw a little slip of paper out of a bag. And the person ahead of time, the person in the experiment would say, I want you to draw a one, two, or a three. So let's say they said, I want you to draw a one. And you draw out a three instead.
10:19 Speaker 01 It's totally random what number you draw out of the bag. And when you say out loud, oh, you know what? I drew a three. And that person doesn't get money? That person assumes that you tried to draw the wrong number. Can you believe this? It's totally random, all they're doing. And you get to see them. You're, they're, they're in front of you. They're drawing it out of the bag. And yet you somehow assume negative intentions on their part. Even though it's random, it's just remarkable how how we fill in the blank, we scribble in negative intentions for people. And so this is a mistake that managers make. We don't realize that people are going to assume the worst when we have bad news for them. They're going to going to assume that we like the power or that we want to make them feel bad, or that we're just, we're not paying attention to how hard they're working. There's just so many negative intentions that we'll scribble in.
11:04 Speaker 01 So that's one of the big problems is that we don't say our good intentions out loud.
11:08 Speaker 00 Well, this is great. So let's do a little bit of a mini role play.
11:11 Speaker 01 Okay, great.
11:12 Speaker 00 A mini role play.
11:13 Speaker 01 I like it.
11:13 Speaker 00 So I will be me and you can be you. And so I'm going to give you some feedback. So Therese, I've really enjoyed having you on the podcast thus far. On a scale of one to 10, you have been a 10 out of 10 thus far. But there's been one thing that you've overlooked, and I think it's really important. You have not said the name of your book yet.
11:38 Speaker 00 You refer to it a lot. You haven't said the name. So there's your feedback.
11:43 Speaker 01 There's my feedback. That's great. Yes. So here's my book. Woo, let's talk. It it just came out. Thank you. That's great feedback. Okay, so what might be the negative intentions that I would describe? Right? So I could jump to negative intentions like I might assume like,
11:59 Speaker 01 oh, he's he's more concerned about his listeners' comfort than he is with my comfort. Right? But but I'm assuming positive intentions. You want me to promote my book, right? Because I'm I'm an I I know you're in my camp, right? But it would be really easy for me to jump to negative like, oh, he's he's more, like I said, he's more worried about his listeners than he is about me. Right? Yeah. And and and and we we go there. We go there very quickly.
12:27 Speaker 00 Hello, my friends. Before we get back to today's episode, I want to ask you a question. Have you ever wondered how to elevate your team's negotiation game? And how you can help the folks on your team have better, difficult conversations? At the American Negotiation Institute, we offer transformative keynotes and workshops tailored to empower professionals with top-tier negotiation and conflict resolution skills. Whether it's a keynote for your next event or hands-on training for your team, we've got you covered. Don't just negotiate. Master the art with the American Negotiation Institute. Click the link in the description to find out more. Elevate, negotiate, and succeed.
13:09 Speaker 00 This is great. And again, it's something so simple in like to understand and to execute on. But if you don't know, you don't know, right? Exactly. And so people just don't do it.
13:21 Speaker 01 And it feels, and I've got to tell you, so and I'll, you know, someone might be listening like, I'm gonna try this, I'm gonna try this, I'm gonna try to say positive intentions. It's gonna feel awkward. Okay? It feels a little artificial. I'm gonna admit that right up front. I am, I did it last week with someone where he was, he was gonna start working with a really high-profile new client, and he had done so much research that I thought the client was gonna be intimidated in the first meeting, right? Because he, he had done so much homework, he seemed like more of an expert than the client did, right? And I was concerned that he was gonna create a bad impression, like that he was a little overzealous. So what I, what I said to this colleague, instead of just going right to, you know,
14:01 Speaker 01 I'm afraid you're gonna look overzealous and obsessive, I said, I really want you to make a good impression on this, this new client, right? And it's clear you've done so much research, you've worked so hard on this. I want to make sure that they see this in a positive light, all this extra research that you did. And then he was so curious about what I had to say next, right? Now, he was really invested, and it felt kind of artificial to say those things out loud. But I've got to tell you, I, I turned what could have been a high-conflict conversation into he was super eager to hear like, oh, good, yeah, I did do all that research. Okay, how could I frame this so that they don't misinterpret it? And it, and it became a really positive conversation. So if it feels a little awkward, it's not surprising. Just try it. You'll be, it's a Jedi maneuver, it works.
14:46 Speaker 00 I love this. And, and let's actually, I want to operationalize this deeper too, because I think, let's think about our, our own biases from our own perspective. Because we might go ahead and say, yes, this is, this is the positive intention, right?
15:02 Speaker 00 Would it be at all beneficial to kind of anticipate the possible negative assumptions that they have and intentionally frame your message to counter those specific negative assumptions they might have?
15:19 Speaker 01 Yeah, you could definitely do that. So let's say you're concerned, you know, so you know, there would be things I wouldn't say. So you know,
15:29 Speaker 01 one of the, one of the common negative perceptions that employees can have is that this is a power move. So I might not say that. I might not say this isn't a power move, right? Right? So there are some, there are some that you probably wouldn't want to say, but let's say you are asking for someone to turn something in sooner than you'd originally agreed upon. So let's say that originally you were saying, you know, I need a draft of those designs by next Friday, and now you're coming to them saying, you know what? Actually, could I, could I get a draft by Wednesday? Right?
15:59 Speaker 00 Try this. Pull up your notes from a meeting last week. Do they still make sense? Or do they just seem like random notes that only the old version of you could decode? That used to be me. And as a negotiator, that's a real problem because my job is to listen, not type or write notes. That's why Granola has been one of my favorite tools, period. It's an AI-powered notepad. I jot my usual rough notes and then Granola securely transcribes the meeting in the background. And when it ends, I get clean, structured notes that still make sense a week later. Decisions, owners, next steps, everything that I would need to feel good about going forward. And it works through your device's audio too. So there's no additional setup or any annoying AI joining your call. Just your normal meeting, but with superpowers.
16:44 Speaker 00 If meetings are eating up your day, Granola is a no-brainer. You can try it totally free for three months. Just go to granola.ai/Quami. That's granola.ai/Quami to get your time back. Get three months free at granola.ai/Quami. Every year, I swear that I'm going to get ahead of holiday shopping. This year, it started with a Quince Casimir sweater that I bought for myself. It was so soft, so well-made, and my first thought was, who else? On my list needs one. Quince makes high quality staples with one hundred percent Mongolian cashmere and Italian leather. And their cashmere sweaters start at just sixty dollars. All of it is fifty to eighty percent less than similar brands because they work directly with ethical factories and cut out the middlemen.
17:29 Speaker 00 As a negotiator, I know a great deal when I see one. This is luxury quality without the luxury price tag. I use Quince and you should too. Give the gift of quality this season. Download the Quince app for app exclusive offers or just go to quince.com. Get free shipping on your order and three hundred and sixty five day returns. Now available in Canada and the UK too. And when Quince asks where you heard about them, let them know it was Kwame with big swings only. That's the best way to support the show.
17:57 Speaker 01 To frame it, you know, you know, I'm. To frame that as positive intentions to say, this isn't that I'm questioning your work. I know that you're an expert and you're very detail oriented, so this isn't about the quality of your work. It's just to ease my own anxiety. And I want to make sure that we're on the same page because I'm going to have some other meetings that day. So I do like if you can anticipate, here's how they might see it. I want to clarify, it's not X, it's actually Y. I think that is a nice way to go. But like I said, if you think that they think that the whole system is broken. Don't say it that way. Don't say that the system is broken and.
18:37 Speaker 01 So I would, I would think a little bit about how you want to frame it.
18:41 Speaker 00 Perfect. That makes sense. Well, what is the third thing that people often do?
18:46 Speaker 01 So the third thing that people do is that they lead with talking, not with listening. And I think partly this, this arises out of a model that a lot of us, if you have been trained in feedback, or if you do a quick Google search, you'll come up with something called the situation behavior impact model or the SBI model. And that model, if you're familiar with it, is to say like, you know, here's the situation, here's when something happened, here's what you did, and here's the negative impact that it had. And this is a common model that people will, will go to, and it offers a lot of clarity. So that's what's good about this model. The problem is you're leading with, I'm doing all the talking. As a feedback giver, I'm doing all the talking. And what I find is much more that that puts people on their back heel, right?
19:31 Speaker 01 They're immediately in defensive position. What I find is much more effective is to lead with listening, to lead with asking questions. There's a, there's a great study by Zenger and Folkman where they were asking employees to rate how good their manager was at giving feedback. And there was one thing that predicted employees' perceptions that their manager was a great feedback giver. You know what it was? It, it was simply that their manager asked for their perception first. So before the manager gave any feedback, they simply said, you know, how do you see it? You know, how do you think that went? You know, how did yesterday's presentations go? How did yesterday's presentation go? What did you think? What were you pleased with?
20:13 Speaker 01 If the employee gets to control the conversation first and you're just listening, that employee thinks you're so much, so much more brilliant as a feedback giver. They think you're better at giving feedback, even if you're going to say the same thing, whatever you were going to say, it doesn't change a bit. If you listen first, that person thinks you're now a better feedback giver. So it's a really simple thing that most of us, it's very easy to skip. If you've got feedback to give, you feel like you should launch right into it. Um, and instead, if you can hold off just a little bit longer and listen first, that other person's going to feel like whatever you've just delivered them is gold. I think another way to think about it is that people think that feedback is about honesty, when really it's about empathy. And by listening first, you're showing more empathy.
20:58 Speaker 00 That makes a lot of sense. And it's, it's so funny because it tracks really perfectly with, with our methodology for difficult conversations and negotiations. And, and really what this is, is it's a negotiation of sorts because we're, we recognize that there is some behavior or an outcome that we would rather not be happening at this time, and we want to persuade them to change their behavior, right?
21:22 Speaker 01 Exactly. It is. It's, it's, it's, it's an art of persuasion, right? And you may not think, you know, even the language we use, giving feedback, right? It's as though it's like. I got to, I've got to say my thing and now I've given it to you. Now it's your problem, right? A much better way to think about this is that we're navigating the feedback conversation, right? We are, we are having this together. We're on a little journey. I'm going to say some things. You're going to say some things. I'm going to be listening to the things you say. And if you think about it as navigating feedback, instead of giving feedback, you're already on the journey to, to having a better conversation.
21:56 Speaker 00 This is great. Well, fantastic. Let's, let's move on to the second point. And that is how to give truly helpful feedback instead. And I know we've probably touched on this a little bit, but what are the key points that we need to keep in mind when it comes to actually giving good feedback?
22:11 Speaker 01 So we have to, so just a couple that we've already touched on. So one would be, you need to lead with listening, not with talking. I can give a quick example of that. I had an experience recently where a colleague got a really important detail wrong in an email to a client and I happened to be CC'd on that email and we're talking a really important detail, like something that needed to be corrected right away. So I corrected it. I, you know, I wrote an email to both of them saying, oh, actually it's this, right? And let, and then I thought, how do I give the feedback to my colleague? Because what I'm concerned about is that she's perhaps is creating the impression that she's bad at details with, with the client, which she's not, but I'm concerned that maybe that's,
22:53 Speaker 01 that's the perception the client's going to have is that she's bad with details. And I thought about saying that. And instead, what I did is I reached out to my colleague and I said, hey, is everything okay? And she said, fine. Just very abruptly. And I said, oh, okay. I'm glad to hear it's fine, but that's not like you, you know, that, that, that mistake on that email is you're usually very detail oriented. So I just wanted to check, is everything okay? And she launched into how overwhelmed she was that her dad was sick and that she was juggling his medical issues along with her own work. And I'm so glad that I went there because not only did we connect, which allowed me to understand better where she was at, but she raised her game over the next several days. I've got
23:38 Speaker 01 to tell you, Kwame, she was amazing over email. Over the next several days, she was, she was really looking out for me. And, and that was because I led with listening, right? I, I asked questions and instead of just leading with my here or my concerns, here's the impact I'm afraid you're having. I held off on that and I'm really glad that I did because she knew she'd made a mistake. She, she, she knew it was a problem. So anyway, so the, the first tip would be to lead with listening, um, not with talking. Um, secondly, clarify your intentions. You know, your good intentions will do a lot more good if you voice them. So just get them out there and they can be as simple as I want good things for you. I want this to be your, your best podcast ever, right? Whatever it might be, right?
24:22 Speaker 01 You would be surprised how happy the other person will be to hear your good intentions. And, and then, then we get to the issue of, um, what if you're someone who avoids giving feedback? What if you're, what if you're reluctantly admitting you're one of those 20%? Um, a really helpful mindset is to take a growth mindset. Have you, have you talked about growth and fixed mindset on your podcast?
24:44 Speaker 00 Yes, but let's do a, let's do a quick revision for the audience.
24:47 Speaker 01 Sure. So Carol Dweck is this, uh, researcher at Stanford, developmental psychologist, and she has a great book called Mindset. Um, what mindset, what she's looking at and captures so beautifully is when we think about ourselves and other people, we can either have a fixed mindset or a growth mindset. A fixed mindset is assuming that someone's states or traits are stable and unchanging. And a growth mindset is assuming people are always improving and growing. And we often think about, do we have a fixed or growth mindset about ourselves? But we also have a fixed or growth mindset about other people. You know, when I, when I work with you, Kwame, am I thinking he's someone who's always learning and growing? You know, he's by the end of our conversation, he's a different person than when we started. Or am I assuming he is who he is, right?
25:32 Speaker 01 And researchers at the University of Texas at Austin found that when they encouraged managers to take a growth mindset about their employees, when they thought of their employees as constantly improving. They were more sixty-three percent more likely to give that employee feedback than if they had a fixed mindset about their employees. So simply believing that people will grow and improve and change leads you to have the conversation. And it makes perfect sense, right? Because if you think people are willing to change, then you're willing to tell them the thing that points them in the right direction.
26:05 Speaker 00 Right. So essentially, it's a self fulfilling prophecy, right? Either you believe they can change, then you'll help to change them. If you don't, you you won't, right?
26:14 Speaker 01 Exactly. It is. It's a beautiful way of framing it. It's a self fulfilling prophecy. If you don't say the thing that could help them, you're robbing them of the opportunity to change. And sure enough, you're stuck with someone who probably isn't going to improve in the way that you're hoping.
26:28 Speaker 00 Exactly. Fantastic. Is there anything else we should know about helpful feedback?
26:34 Speaker 01 There are so many good pieces of advice in my book, Let's Talk.
26:39 Speaker 00 I like it.
26:40 Speaker 01 You like it? Um, the the one thing that I would say is is another good motto to or, you know, mindset is make your motto no surprises. Um, a really common pattern I heard and I interviewed sixty people for my book, Let's Talk, and a really common pattern was that managers would kind of sit on feedback. They they wouldn't avoid it, but they would just wait until the end of the year conversation. Um, when it was performance review time, I interviewed one person who said that a year went by and he hadn't heard any critical feedback. He thought he was great and review time came and his manager reached behind and pulled a binder off of her shelf and opened it up and said, well, in February, you did this. Turn the page. And in March, you said this in a meeting.
27:25 Speaker 01 And he's like, what? Where where did this binder come from?
27:30 Speaker 01 So painful, right? And and you probably are thinking, I would never sit on feedback that long, but all too often, we do sit on it longer than we mean to. We notice something and we don't say something right away. But instead, we're beginning to think, oh, you know, Debbie Debbie just is too introverted. She's not going to make good management material. And we begin to. To to make up this list of like, yeah, no, you know what? Debbie isn't going to make a good manager after all. That's too bad. And we're not saying to Debbie, Debbie, I need you to speak up more in meetings. How can we work on that with you? What would make it easier for you to speak up in meetings? Because you have such great ideas, right? So we need to mention things. Don't make it a surprise for Debbie at at review time that there's bad news. She's not being promoted.
28:12 Speaker 00 Yeah. Oh, this is great. This is great. And listeners, there will be a link to the book in the description, too, because this this is really helpful. And I think there are going to be listeners out there who are saying to themselves, wow, I have one of those managers who is not giving me feedback. So let's wrap up the conversation by addressing that issue. So what can people do to solicit better feedback from their own managers?
28:39 Speaker 01 So this is such a common problem. One of the things I heard most often from people throughout organizations, from entry level employees to VPs, that they don't get feedback from their manager. What they're told is, Kwame, keep doing what you're doing. It's great. I love it. No, no news is good news, right? That this is literally things that managers will tell employees. And I think it's probably gotten worse during COVID. There was a great study done by Microsoft this summer. They found that managers on average are putting in an extra eight hours a week in interactions on top of their normal workload because of COVID, that they need to be communicating more. So I think to add to the problem, you've got managers are so busy, they're not noticing, right? They're they're they're
29:20 Speaker 01 not taking the time to give you the feedback you need. So three strategies for trying to help your manager acknowledge, you know, you're acknowledging they're busy, you acknowledge that they may not notice everything, but you want you need better feedback than you're getting, right? This vague praise is not helping you. So three strategies, and I'll go from the least aggressive to the most aggressive. Okay. So the easiest one, make it super easy for your manager. Create a list of three or four things you're willing to work on. Let's say your manager says, you know, Kwame, just keep doing what you're doing. You'd say, great. I've got a list of three, you know, but I, but I've got a growth mindset. I want to improve. I want to be better at my job three months from now than I am today. So here are three things I could work on and you show your manager the list.
30:03 Speaker 01 And then you say, which, which of these would you prioritize? And now your manager will be like, oh, you are serious. All right. Um, and chances are your manager will come up with a fourth thing that you didn't even think of. Right. But you're giving your manager permission to get really specific. You're allowing your manager to say, actually, what I would prioritize would be X. Or they may pick something from your list, but now you're at least you're on the same page. You're aligned as to where you should be putting your extra energy. And I've talked with managers who, when they hear this piece of advice, they're like, I want my direct reports to do this. I wish more of them would make it easy for me. So that's, that's, that's the, that's kind of the simplest one. Um, the second one, if you are at a company where there's a, a rating system, a lot of companies have a one to five.
30:48 Speaker 01 That employees are rated at the end of the year on one to five or one to three, where one is below expectations, two is meets expectations and three is exceeds expectations. The strategy is what is a five doing, right? So basically if your manager says, everything's great, you know, you know, don't worry, everything's fine. Just keep doing what you're doing. Say, okay, that's great, but last time I was a four and I want to be a five. So tell me, what's a five doing differently, right? And, and now your manager may not have an answer in that moment, but it gets your manager thinking like, I have seen fives before. What are they doing differently? So this is a really nice way to, like I said, it may take a couple of conversations, but you're showing your manager. You really are looking to move up in terms of your performance.
31:32 Speaker 01 And then the most aggressive, and I have, I've interviewed two managers who've taken this approach. And that is to say, am I promotion material? All right. And what I've seen, these two managers at least have told me that they've done is they've gone to their manager and said, I want to be promoted by the end of the year. What do you need to see from me to, to put my name up for promotion? And then they asked every month. Every month, they came back to their manager and said, am I, are you seeing what you need to see to put me up for promotion? Am I doing what you need me to do? Is there something I'm missing? And they kept coming back to it. And as a result, they were, they were able to get feedback to pivot and pivot and pivot.
32:15 Speaker 01 And both of these, both of these employees got promoted at the end of the year.
32:19 Speaker 00 Wow, that is fantastic. That's really, really good. I wish I knew this while I was working for somebody else.
32:27 Speaker 01 Exactly. I wish I had been given that advice. I had, I had a boss. I went to her two months before it was promotion time. And I asked, are you seeing what you need to be seeing? Or, you know, I use slightly different language, but I said, can you make a case for me to put me up for promotion? And she was like, oh, no, I can't. And I won't, you know, there's not enough time for you to do the things you need to do for me to put you up for, for me to make a case in two months. Right? She needed, she needed a longer runway. Right? And so, um, I wish I'd, I wish I'd gotten this advice sooner. You know, just start, start asking a year out and it will show your manager you're committed. Plus your manager is now in a position where they can't surprise you. Right? They, they need to be, they need to be letting you know.
33:09 Speaker 00 Exactly. Wow, Therese, this has been fantastic. Um, let the listeners know again about the book and how they can get in touch with you.
33:16 Speaker 01 Sure. So my new book is called, Let's Talk, Make Effective Feedback Your Superpower. And it was just published by Penguin Random House, um, here in January, 2021. And, um, you can look me up on my website, theresehuston.com, or you can email me. My email is on my website and I, I'd love to hear from people.
33:34 Speaker 00 Fantastic. Thank you so much. This was really, really helpful.
33:37 Speaker 01 It was a lot of fun, Kwame. Thank you.
33:41 Speaker 00 Congratulations. You've just joined an elite club. By listening to a full episode, you're now officially on the Negotiate Anything team. So welcome aboard. What most team members do is they subscribe to the podcast because that allows them to automatically get the latest episodes of the show. The best things in life lie on the other side of difficult conversations. Keep learning, keep practicing and keep getting better. Your relationships will improve, your career will soar, and you'll have the confidence you need to get the most out of these crucial conversations. Again, thank you for joining the team. We're excited to have you and I will see you in the next episode. I'll catch you later.
34:25 Speaker 00 Hey everyone. I want to tell you about a podcast I'm really excited about. It's called The Anxious Achiever and it's hosted by my good friend Maura Aron Smale and it's part of the Yap Media Network. Here on Big Swings Only, we're all about going after the big stuff. But anyone who's taken a real swing knows anxiety usually comes along for the ride. And honestly, nobody handles that better than Maura. Since 2019, her show has helped millions of listeners navigate stress, mental health, and the search for meaning through work. With personal stories, expert insights, and evidence-based tools, she tackles anxiety, perfectionism, ADHD, and psychological safety at work with guests ranging from the US Surgeon General to NFL and NBA stars.
35:07 Speaker 00 It's a top 10 management podcast and a Signal Award winner for Best Commute Podcast. And she's been a guest on our show, too. If you're ready to take control of your anxiety and your life, you definitely want to check out The Anxious Achiever. Subscribe to The Anxious Achiever today on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen.
Previous How to Persuade Without Pressure — The Magic Question That Changes Everything Next The Real Way to Stand Out — No Shouting Required Page updated November 7, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated