Mohnish Pabrai: This will save you 10 years of bad investments

Get Mohnish's 9 investment principles: https://clickhubspot.com/kwdo Episode 827: Shaan Puri ( https://x.com/ShaanVP ) sits down with Mohnish Pabrai to break down the mental models that made him a billionaire value investor. — Show Notes: (0:00) Intro (1:25) Mental models of the top 1% (3:38) The mistress is always hotter than the wife (6:37) Introduce Randomness in your life (10:47)  Humans are poor at copying (20:13) Take a simple idea seriously (23:02)  Be and inch wide and a mile deep (30:29)  Never use Excel (35:03) Wait for fat pitches (39:38) the stock market is like a church with a casino (44:01) Paying $650,000 to have lunch with Warren Buffett (45:43) The cautionary tale of Rick Guerin (47:22) The inner score card (49:25) The future of Berkshire Hathaway (51:29) Mohnish’s best investment (1:02:39) The hardest question (1:06:16) How to beat the index (1:11:25) Mohnish's stock picks for 2026 (1:22:26)  S&P 500 (1:24:57) life advice disguised as investing advice (1:29:32)  Studying the greatest investors (1:37:51) if you remember nothing else, remember this — Links: Mohnish Part 1: This Guy Copy-Pasted Warren Buffett’s Strategy (And Became A Billionaire) Mohnish Part 2: Go from $10,000 to $1M in just 3 years The Dhando Investor - https://a.co/d/0hkx1t8g — Check Out Sam's Stuff: • Hampton (joinhampton.com): My community for founders. Average member does $25m/year. Many of the guests are members. Get after it...apply: http://joinhampton.com/mfm — Check Out Shaan's Stuff: • Shaan's weekly email - https://www.shaanpuri.com • Visit https://www.somewhere.com/mfm to hire worldwide talent like Shaan and get $500 off for being an MFM listener. Hire developers, assistants, marketing pros, sales teams and more for 80% less than US equivalents. • Mercury - Need a bank for your company? Go check out Mercury (mercury.com). Shaan uses it for all of his companies! Mercury is a financial technology company, not an FDIC-insured bank. Banking services provided by Choice Financial Group, Column, N. A., and Evolve Bank & Trust, Members FDIC • I run all my newsletters on Beehiiv and you should too + we're giving away $10k to our favorite newsletter, check it out: beehiiv.com/mfm-challenge My First Million is a HubSpot Original Podcast // Brought to you by HubSpot Media // Production by Arie Desormeaux // Editing by Ezra Bakker Trupiano /

Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.

• 0:00Shaan Puri?

  What percentage of Americans who invest in stocks do you believe are good investors?

• 0:04Mohnish Pabrai?

  Well, under 1%. The game we are playing is transfer wealth from the active to the inactive. If you have that type of a temperament, it is orgasmic activity. Okay, if you are even a slightly above average investor, you can't help but get rich over a lifetime.

• 0:22Shaan Puri?

  What's the mistake that smart people are making?

• 0:24Mohnish Pabrai?

  Many people die at 25 and are buried at 75. I saw Charlie make investments six days before he died.

• 0:33Shaan Puri?

  This is like life advice disguised as investing advice.

• 0:36Mohnish Pabrai?

  Yeah.

• 0:37Shaan Puri?

  Just quick reaction, bullish bearish on the S and P index right now.

• 0:41Mohnish Pabrai?

  Bearish.

• 0:42Shaan Puri?

  AI, how do you think about it as an investor?

• 0:44Mohnish Pabrai?

  Invest in the pickaxe makers because the alphabets and metas of the world are playing a game they haven't played before.

• 0:50Shaan Puri?

  So I want to ask you the hardest question, which is.

• 1:03Shaan Puri?

  Mohnish, round three. Here we are, elevated as always, we're on the pitch. What percentage of Americans who invest in stocks do you believe are good investors?

• 1:14Mohnish Pabrai?

  Well, under 1%.

• 1:16Shaan Puri?

  And why is that?

• 1:18Mohnish Pabrai?

  But the good news is, so a large number of investors invest in index funds.

• 1:23Shaan Puri?

  Right.

• 1:25Mohnish Pabrai?

  And index funds give you a great return without doing any work. So you don't need to be a rocket scientist or understand businesses or any of that. And you get a pretty good outcome.

• 1:38Shaan Puri?

  Are you counting them in the 1% or are you saying that's a separate?

• 1:41Mohnish Pabrai?

  No, I'm talking about the ones who are actually picking stocks, right? And so I'm just saying that you can take the approach of buying an index fund and you're going to be ahead of 90 plus percent of the crowd.

• 1:52Shaan Puri?

  Right.

• 1:53Mohnish Pabrai?

  Which is awesome, right? I mean, just think about doing some activity, which takes no more brain cells and getting ahead of being in the top 10%.

• 1:59Shaan Puri?

  Right.

• 2:00Mohnish Pabrai?

  But if you decide that you want to actually study businesses and then invest in them after studying them.

• 2:09Mohnish Pabrai?

  In that universe of people doing that, there'll be a very small sliver who would do well with that.

• 2:15Shaan Puri?

  Yeah. What's the mistake that smart people are making when it comes to investing?

• 2:18Mohnish Pabrai?

  It's not a mistake, it's the lack of patience. So, most of the nuances that would lead to a great investment result have to do with temperament. They're not related to IQ or other things, but they have to do with temperament. So, it all comes back to watching paint dry, right? So, when we make an investment in a company, nothing may happen for three years or five years. You know, it's just the nature of the beast is that it may, it may not do a whole lot for a while. And also, sometimes you've made, in fact, many times you've made an investment, it's a mistake. And you need to, at some point, reverse that mistake.

• 3:02Mohnish Pabrai?

  So, so there is the activity needed appropriately. But basically, the less the activity, the better the outcomes.

• 3:14Shaan Puri?

  You gave me one of the commandments, one of the truths about investing, which is, thou shall enjoy watching paint dry.

• 3:21Mohnish Pabrai?

  Yes.

• 3:22Shaan Puri?

  I called your daughter in research for this podcast, because I knew you were very into mental models and these frameworks of ways of thinking.

• 3:28Mohnish Pabrai?

  Yeah.

• 3:29Shaan Puri?

  That produce benefits. I said, what's one that he loves? And he said, she said, the mistress is always hotter than the wife. So, explain.

• 3:36Mohnish Pabrai?

  I didn't want to say that in front of my daughter, but unfortunately I did.

• 3:41Shaan Puri?

  That was the first one she mentioned.

• 3:43Mohnish Pabrai?

  Yeah, so, what we own is the wife. We live with her every day. And what we don't own is the mistress.

• 3:54Shaan Puri?

  Right.

• 3:55Mohnish Pabrai?

  And the unknown has exciting attributes. And so, one of the things we have to keep in mind is

• 4:07Mohnish Pabrai?

  The wife is someone we know extremely well. And we may be discounting some great attribute she has. The mistress is someone we don't know very well. She just looks hot.

• 4:20Shaan Puri?

  Right.

• 4:20Mohnish Pabrai?

  We don't know all the other nuances about her, you know, temperament and other things and whatever else. It's very tempting for an investor to say, I own this company, but I think this other company, which I don't own, is better and I should make a swap. My friend Guy Speer says that he's very reluctant to take any actions on his portfolio. And not being interested in taking action can give you a huge leg up. So sometimes we do need to take action, but in general, you have to really be convinced pretty unequivocally.

• 5:01Shaan Puri?

  Right.

• 5:02Mohnish Pabrai?

  That the mistress is truly hotter.

• 5:04Shaan Puri?

  Right.

• 5:04Mohnish Pabrai?

  Right, and not just an appearance of being hotter. That is a difficult nuance to actually master in real life.

• 5:15Shaan Puri?

  The idea of the wife versus the mistress is you have to have a very high bar for action. It's not that there is no action.

• 5:21Mohnish Pabrai?

  Yeah.

• 5:21Shaan Puri?

  It's that the bar needs to be very high to have the conviction level. You need to become comfortable passing on everything below that bar.

• 5:28Mohnish Pabrai?

  Yes.

• 5:28Shaan Puri?

  And I think in general, most of us would do well to raise our standards about all things in life. The people that we're around, the investments that we make.

• 5:34Mohnish Pabrai?

  Exactly.

• 5:35Shaan Puri?

  This is actually like life advice disguised as investing advice.

• 5:38Mohnish Pabrai?

  Yeah.

• 5:39Shaan Puri?

  Right?

• 5:40Mohnish Pabrai?

  My dad used to say that to have a great life, you need one good wife and one good friend. And so less is more. Buffett says that if you hang out with people better than you, you get better. And if you hang out with people worse than you, you get worse. There's a gravitational pull either way. So the good news is we don't need many of these. But what we should be doing is we should be trying to make sure that our relationships are ones with people we have deep admiration for, people that can make us rise.

• 6:14Shaan Puri?

  Right.

• 6:15Mohnish Pabrai?

  And I, I feel that, you know, I randomly stumbled onto investing. I'd never been in this field, et cetera. And I remember, so there's another mental model, which is a very powerful model.

• 6:29Shaan Puri?

  All right, let's take a quick break because I got a little freebie for you. So if you're listening to this episode and you like what Manisha is talking about, you might be like me, you're trying to take notes, you're trying to remember these principles that he's talking about because the dude is just a wealth of knowledge when it comes to investing. Well, the fine folks at HubSpot listened to this episode, they took the transcript, they put down the nine principles that he talks about, as well as the examples that he have, and they put it all in a PDF for you, so you don't need to take notes, they did it all for you. You can read that, learn from it, that's a much better way to get more value out of these episodes. It's in the show notes below, just go download that and enjoy.

• 7:00Mohnish Pabrai?

  Charlie used to talk to me about introduce randomness in your life.

• 7:03Shaan Puri?

  Introduce randomness.

• 7:04Mohnish Pabrai?

  Randomness in your life, and just to tell you the impact that had, which I didn't even understand this when it had the impact. In 94, I'm at Heathrow Airport with my wife and I'm looking for something to read on the flight back. And I pick up one of Peter Lynch's books, One Up on Wall Street. And I'm never invested in a stock, not really interested in investing, don't even know much about it. I read the book and loved it. Okay, I'm an engineer running an IT company, right? I said, oh, I want to kind of read more of this, right? So there was another Peter Lynch book, Beating the Street, I read that, and I loved that too. And then there's no more Peter Lynch books. But in those two books, in one of the two books, he talks about Buffett, right? And I'd never heard about Buffett.

• 7:48Mohnish Pabrai?

  So then I said, let me find out about this guy. And I was very lucky, the first couple of biographies on him had just come out the year before. And then I read those, then that led me to the Berkshire Letters, the Partnership Letters. Huge world opened up, right? And then I started to invest using that approach. So I'd been doing the Buffett investing and all that, and really kind of overdosed on it. And in 97, the thought came to me, should I go to the annual meeting? And I was saying, you know, the transcripts get published and all of that, and I don't know anyone, and I have young kids and all of that. So I was very much on the fence whether to go to the annual meeting or not, right?

• 8:32Mohnish Pabrai?

  And I decided in the end, let's go. Okay, let's see what the hoopla is all about. The annual meeting opened up another big world, right? And now, some of my best friends.

• 8:46Mohnish Pabrai?

  Are folks I met in Omaha. Right. So, reading the Peter Lynch book introduced randomness. And one thing I I came to realize, I tell people when they go into the annual meeting, that when you're flying to Omaha on a Friday, the two people sitting next to you are both going to Omaha for the meeting as well. And they're both above-average humans. So just start talking to them. Right. Right? Because it's not the average humans going there, right? Pre-filtered. And so when I look back now on my life, so much of it has come from the whole Buffett orbit, right? And the Buffett orbit, what I realized is, when I got to know Charlie Munger and I started playing bridge with him, I got to know Charlie's friends.

• 9:31Mohnish Pabrai?

  I used to have dinner with him and I, one by one, I met a bunch of his friends. Charlie's friends were some of the highest-quality people I've ever met. They were much older, but I worked on, you know, building those friendships. And that was such an awesome thing. Right. And literally, every time I talk to some of these guys, and the way the conversation goes, I say, wow, you know, hang out with people better than you, introduce randomness. So this is what Munger calls the lattice work of mental model. So when you start putting these things together and you start using them all at the same time, that's when one plus one becomes eleven. Or if you put four models together,

• 10:16Mohnish Pabrai?

  it's one plus one plus one plus one is over one thousand. That's when you start getting what Charlie calls Lulap loser effects. And so then that's when you get a huge leg up on humanity. There are other people who may be a lot smarter, other people who may work a lot harder. Let's take Elon, for example. So I forget what he calls it, the idiot factor or something. Idiot index. Idiot, yeah, the idiot index, right? That's right. So what he says is, they look at some part that they need. And they'll say, oh, this part is, you know, five thousand dollars. So Elon says to them, what are the materials that go into this part? Raw material. Raw materials.

• 10:56Mohnish Pabrai?

  And what is the price of the raw materials on the London Metals Exchange? Right. Okay? And they'll calculate that and say, it's two hundred and seventy bucks. So they said, then they'll say, we're gonna make it ourselves. And we're gonna make it for five hundred bucks.

• 11:16Shaan Puri?

  Right.

• 11:16Mohnish Pabrai?

  Right. And so the thing is that none of his competitors think like that, right? None of them have this idiot index. Without that, there's no Tesla. There's no SpaceX. There's nothing. There's no boring company, any of that. So it's one of those core foundational models, right? But the other thing about humans is that Boeing is aware of this model. And all the car companies are aware of this model. It's not in their DNA.

• 11:43Shaan Puri?

  Right.

• 11:44Mohnish Pabrai?

  This is not how they think. They're not going to adopt it. So the other thing, another mental model to understand is humans are very poor at cloning. They all understand that Elon has kicked their ass. They also understand why he kicked their ass.

• 11:59Shaan Puri?

  Yeah.

• 12:00Mohnish Pabrai?

  They know everything. He's an open book. Okay, you've talked to people.

• 12:03Shaan Puri?

  He literally published the book.

• 12:05Mohnish Pabrai?

  Right. And what you need to do is also known, but after knowing all of that, there is no movement towards that, right? There's no movement.

• 12:16Shaan Puri?

  By the way, we wouldn't be here right now if not for cloning. So the story of this set right now is that my friend Chris, Chris Williams said he did a podcast here. He sent us a video like, oh, I'm doing this crazy shoot. LED wall, three D, I've got this film crew here, blah, blah, blah. He sent us a video of it and I was like, wow, that looks cool. But my first reaction was buddy, it's a podcast. What do we do? What are we doing? Why, why do you, does anyone really care if it's in IMAX four K? Like, does that really make a difference? And, you know, that seems like a lot of effort and a lot of cost. I sort of wrote it off. So then it comes out. First time I clicked, and then I see, not even before I clicked the video, I see the thumbnail. I'm like, wow, that looks different.

• 12:58Shaan Puri?

  So I click because I'm a lizard brain human. And if something is different, interesting, I click it before I even think. And then I'm looking at it and I'm watching this thing and it's interesting and it's entertaining. And so immediately I recognized, oh, a mistake on my part. Like I thought, I thought this was not important. Turns out actually this is important.

• 13:16Mohnish Pabrai?

  So you had to travel a little bit in the sense that your first reaction was stay in your comfort zone.

• 13:24Shaan Puri?

  Right.

• 13:24Mohnish Pabrai?

  Right. But the second leap you made, which is after seeing it. You acted. Right. So from admiring it to acting it is a huge leap. Right. It's like ninety percent of humans will not do that. Right. So Sam Walton, not that smart a guy, okay? Founder of Walmart. Yeah, very hardworking, all American, but not that smart, okay? And no original ideas, okay? Every single thing at Walmart came from somewhere else, okay? Everything was copied. He goes to meet Sol Price, who was the founder of Price Club, which is the predecessor to Costco.

• 14:07Mohnish Pabrai?

  And he meets Sol Price and he looks at Price Club and he says, no brainer. He sets up Sam's Club, okay? And Price eventually sells to Costco and so now we have Costco and Sam's, right? And Sam Walton would tell you, in ten lifetimes, he could never come up with the concept of a Sam's Club. Right. He could not come up with the concept of a Walmart. Walmart came from Kmart. Sam Walton said, there is no human who has come before me, who has stepped into more retail stores of my competitors than I have. Right. And no human after me will ever beat that record.

• 14:51Mohnish Pabrai?

  Okay, so anytime he traveled anywhere, he was going on vacation with his family and saw his passing some retail store. He'd stop his fam, stop the car, tell them, hang on here, go do his fifteen, twenty minute tour of the place and come back and make notes of what he saw, right? One time, he takes a bunch of his managers into one of the neighboring competitor stores. And they come out of the store and one of the managers says to him, Sam, that was such a poorly run operation because they could just see it was just a mess compared to where Walmart was. And then Sam says to him, yes, but did you see the candle display? The candle display was fantastic. Finding the one golden nugget. So Sam said. You can learn from anyone. You can learn from the biggest idiot operator.

• 15:36Mohnish Pabrai?

  Sam would go early morning at like five thirty in the morning to the Walmart distribution center with donuts, okay? And he'd sit down with the drivers because the drivers were going to the stores every day. And he'd tell them, what do you see when you go in? And then there's the drivers will tell them, well, such and such store, I saw the garbage. There was stuff thrown out that shouldn't be thrown out, Sam. Okay, and Sam's making notes of this, right? And then he'd go and, you know, fix all the so. But what I'm saying is that everything at Walmart came from somewhere else.

• 16:07Shaan Puri?

  Right.

• 16:08Mohnish Pabrai?

  The reason cloning works so well is no one's willing to do it. Look at Tesla's market cap and look at the market cap of the next car company.

• 16:18Shaan Puri?

  I believe it's more than the next fifteen car companies combined.

• 16:21Mohnish Pabrai?

  All of them combined. You can take the whole industry combined. You know, they won't, they won't get there. And on SpaceX, so if you look at Blue Origin and you look at SpaceX, they have completely different approaches to how they do things. SpaceX wants to blow up rockets. Their focus is to blow up rockets. Blue Origin focuses on not blowing up rockets. And he's miles ahead.

• 16:44Shaan Puri?

  Right.

• 16:45Mohnish Pabrai?

  And in fact, he's clobbered the industry, you know, the whole landing, landing these things backwards and, you know, reusing them and all of them. People laughed at him at that and he got it done.

• 16:55Shaan Puri?

  I'll give you a story of two of your models combined, as you said. So introduce randomness. There was a period of time after I sold my first company, I was thinking about what to do next. I kept shuffling through ideas, couldn't figure out which one to do. And I realized I'm sitting here in San Francisco and I'm meeting the same people, talking about the same things, going to the same tech events over and over and over again. And I've had this gut instinct of I need to introduce more randomness to my life. So I hear about this event called FarmCon, a farmers conference in Kansas City. Sign me up. I'm going. So I go and I'm the only tech guy. You know, I look out of like a literally fish out of water dresses. I'm dressing wrong. I don't know anything about farming. I even get there and I'm like, I don't know what the hell I got myself into.

• 17:38Shaan Puri?

  I took Ben with me and we're sitting there, they're talking about soybean futures. I don't even know what soybeans are. And so I were completely out of water, but it was a great way to just shake up the snow globe a little bit. Introduce randomness and serendipity. When we're there, we meet this guy. And his name's Kevin Van Trump, and he was the guy who owned this conference. I was, how'd you get all these people to, how'd you get so many farmers to come? There's 4,000 farmers here and they all love you. How do they even know you? And he said, well, I've been writing this newsletter for 20 years for farmers. Half of the thing is just memes, just funny jokes. Because the farmers just want to laugh in the morning and then half of it is his letter about like, what's going on in the markets today for farmers? And so we're sitting there and we, we've essentially leave one of the conference rooms.

• 18:21Shaan Puri?

  And we decide to clone because I met with you for the podcast and you had this great analogy of, who's the dumbest guy in the world? And we decided that the dumbest guy in the world is the guy with the gas station across the street from the more successful gas station. And it's like, you can be unsuccessful, but if you're staring at the gas station across the street and he's winning and he's doing everything right and you're just not doing those things. That's on you.

• 18:44Mohnish Pabrai?

  Yeah.

• 18:44Shaan Puri?

  And so I'm sitting here, I'm watching Kevin Van Trump and he's got his newsletter for farmers. And at this time crypto had just started becoming very interesting. I said, you know, Ben, what if we created a newsletter for crypto? Just like this guy's done for farming. We'll do it for people who want to keep up with the crypto news. It'll be half memes, it'll be half news.

• 19:01Mohnish Pabrai?

  Yeah.

• 19:01Shaan Puri?

  And let's do this, it was just write the first edition tonight. So we wrote the first edition while we were there and we named it something that was themed after the conference. It was called the Milk Road, like a dairy name. And in one year, we built the largest crypto newsletter in the world.

• 19:16Mohnish Pabrai?

  Oh, great.

• 19:16Shaan Puri?

  And we sold it for millions of dollars and never hired an employee. We had one employee. It's like the best business I ever did at the time, just in simplicity.

• 19:24Mohnish Pabrai?

  Yeah.

• 19:25Shaan Puri?

  And it was all because we strung together two of these models, just introducing randomness and then cloning on top of that.

• 19:31Mohnish Pabrai?

  I think that humans complicate things a lot, but I think that if you.

• 19:37Shaan Puri?

  All right, let's take a quick break and I got a question for you. When a buyer asks AI for a solution like yours, does your business come up? Most companies have no idea. And by the time they found out, they've already lost the deal to another company that did. HubSpot has AEO, which helps you show up in the moments when the right buyers are looking for a company like yours. Before the first click, before they fill in the form, that is the moment HubSpot AEO is built for. Check out hubspot.com, the agentic customer platform for growing businesses.

• 20:04Mohnish Pabrai?

  McDonald's had this whole big department on figuring out where to put the next McDonald's, right? Location is very important. Burger King had two guys, they just looked at where's the McDonald's going? And they would look at where McDonald's are going, they'd put it across the street.

• 20:18Shaan Puri?

  Right.

• 20:19Mohnish Pabrai?

  Right? And that was their model. Phenomenal, because all the work's already done.

• 20:23Shaan Puri?

  Right.

• 20:24Mohnish Pabrai?

  You know, cloning gives you a huge advantage. Now, another bedrock model, I think no mental models work without this model, which is take a simple idea and take it seriously. Right? This is, to me, none of the other models, cloning or not using Excel or anything else, works unless you buy into this first model. So you have to go all in, right? I made my first trip to Turkey purely on a limb, kind of like you going to the farmer's conference. Just because it was screening cheap, I just want to take a look at this market, which is screening so cheap. And that was in 2018. What I learned is that the average Turkish company, public company, cycles through its

• 21:08Mohnish Pabrai?

  float every 17 days, which means like, let's say, a founder owns 40% of the company, the other 60%-

• 21:16Shaan Puri?

  The shareholder base will just turn over.

• 21:17Mohnish Pabrai?

  Literally about 4% of the shares are trading every day. Okay? And every 17 days, you've got a new set of shareholders. Okay? Buffett has a quote that the stock market is a mechanism to transfer wealth from the active to the inactive. Okay? This is hyperactive. Okay? Now, if you look at something like Berkshire Hathaway. And you look at how frequently its shareholder base changes. It might be the slowest in the world. It might be like ten years or something or more for the float, right? And here you have seventeen days, okay? And then I even looked at places like India, right? So I actually compared Turkey and India.

• 22:01Mohnish Pabrai?

  And what I realized is in Turkey, almost all the investors are gamblers and speculators. They want to buy at ten o'clock, they want to sell at three o'clock and they want to make ten percent. That's their model, okay? Whereas in India, what I found is that out of five thousand public companies, there's maybe hundred, hundred and fifty companies with good governance that are investable. And a lot of research has been done on those by a lot of smart people in India. And they've pounded into those companies and they trade at stratospheric valuations, very expensive. I would look at a Coke bottler in India and I'd look at a Pepsi bottler in India

• 22:44Mohnish Pabrai?

  and I look at a Coke bottler in Turkey. And the valuation differentials were massive, same business. And I'd look at an airport operator in Turkey, airport operator in India, huge valuation differences. Again, because here everyone was looking for long term and all of that.

• 23:02Shaan Puri?

  So you're picking like poker tables to sit at?

• 23:04Mohnish Pabrai?

  So when you take the first model, take a simple idea and take it seriously. I said, India, zero, we're not interested, okay? Even though I'm Indian, Turkey, I'm going all in. And so what I decided is to be an inch wide and a mile deep. And so I said, I understand the nuances of the Turkish market. I want to study everything in here. I want to be the person who's, this is my Moody's manual, right? Go through every single thing, right? And what I found is whether it's a useless company in Turkey or a great company in Turkey, they're all cheap.

• 23:44Mohnish Pabrai?

  So this is great. We'll focus on great, right? And no one's interested. You've got all these people like buying and selling shares. And so we were able to make some investments which we couldn't have made anywhere else in the world. At valuations, we couldn't have made, you know, just the simple thing of the take the first model and it gives you an edge. So I think the the mental model just carries so much weight that it makes your journey very light.

• 24:12Shaan Puri?

  Right.

• 24:13Mohnish Pabrai?

  Because they just carry the, they do the heavy lifting.

• 24:15Shaan Puri?

  Right.

• 24:15Mohnish Pabrai?

  And all you have to do is not violate them.

• 24:18Shaan Puri?

  So I wanted to ask you about violating them because sometimes I could see a world where they clash.

• 24:23Mohnish Pabrai?

  Yeah.

• 24:23Shaan Puri?

  Or that the definitions get fuzzy. So for example, one idea is invest in your circle of competence. But like with Turkey, it wasn't your circle of competence. You sort of made it your circle of competence. So in that sense, like, how do you think about that? Like, because it sounds like some of the best bets for you and others have been where you decide to go get smart about a space. But you were a complete beginner in that space, maybe six months prior.

• 24:49Mohnish Pabrai?

  Well, so like, for example, before I went to Turkey, I had already studied Coke and Pepsi bottlers. I'd studied the Coke and Pepsi business quite a bit, just because Buffett had made the investment. And the Coke concentrate syrup business is phenomenal. It's a software company, you know, it's just eighty percent margin. It's a great business. And the the bottlers, not as good a business as Coke, but they are oligopolies. And most of them do really well as well. I mean, they have more CapEx and all that, but it's a good business. So when I'm looking at a Coke or Pepsi bottler anywhere in the world,

• 25:31Mohnish Pabrai?

  one of the things to keep in mind is they had to be approved. To become a Coke or Pepsi bottler and Coke and Pepsi are very anal about who they're going to allow, especially at this stage because they've got global brands and all that. So to me, it was relatively easy that so when I went into, for example, the Coke bottler in Turkey, it wasn't surprising to me that the management team was super high quality. The management team was multinational. They weren't Turks, like the CFO is from Ukraine.

• 26:02Shaan Puri?

  Right.

• 26:03Mohnish Pabrai?

  And he had worked in Delhi before that and all of that. So you could just see that this was a global team running this business and all of that. So similar to the airport operator, I looked at other airport operators. So I started by using guardrails.

• 26:18Shaan Puri?

  Right.

• 26:19Mohnish Pabrai?

  And I focused on the the simplest businesses, which were ones that were the easiest to understand. And and one of the things about investing to also understand, the businesses that you spend the least amount of time studying tend to be the ones that make you the most money because they tend to be the simplest, they're obvious and all of that. But yes, you have to couple the circle of competence with the introduction of randomness.

• 26:50Shaan Puri?

  Right.

• 26:50Mohnish Pabrai?

  And so those two are not in conflict with each other. The introduction of randomness is how you grow. And that's how you may actually, the circle is going to expand over time, naturally going to expand, but you don't need to focus on expanding it.

• 27:08Shaan Puri?

  In your book, you have some great stories. The one I remember is the American Express.

• 27:13Mohnish Pabrai?

  The salad oil crisis.

• 27:14Shaan Puri?

  Salad oil crisis. I didn't know about this. It's a little bit before my time. Tell this story. It's an amazing story.

• 27:19Mohnish Pabrai?

  American Express at that time had, they've always had a number of different businesses that we don't think about. One of their businesses was asset based lending business. And there was kind of a crooked guy. He basically got them to finance his inventory of salad oil, where he said, I've got these warehouses filled with salad oil.

• 27:40Shaan Puri?

  This is not a finance, a literal salad oil.

• 27:43Mohnish Pabrai?

  Yeah, salad oil, right.

• 27:43Shaan Puri?

  In barrels.

• 27:44Mohnish Pabrai?

  Yeah. And so they financed it and there wasn't any salad oil. It was seawater. Okay.

• 27:50Shaan Puri?

  So somebody figured this out. How did they know this was, there was just seawater in the barrels?

• 27:54Mohnish Pabrai?

  Well, later it came out because basically when they went to collect, you know, the guy's already taken the money. He's a, he's a crook. It's gone. And when they went and got the asset and looked at it, they found that they, they got nothing. Like they basically had been duped. Right. And it was a very significant loss for Amex where a big dent of the balance sheet. So obviously, when they, when they reported it, the stock collapsed. And Warren felt that the big value of Amex was in its brand. His question was, is confidence shaken in the credit cards? So for example, if, if I'm a restaurant owner and I accept the Amex card,

• 28:38Mohnish Pabrai?

  in effect, Amex owes me money, right? So what he did is he went to a number of different restaurants in Omaha and just stood by the cash register and just wanted to see whether the restaurants had any concern about accepting the Amex card. And he saw zero, zero concern of any kind. So he felt that the moat of Amex was unaffected and the trust and confidence in the brand wasn't affected. And the stock, on the other hand, had collapsed, right? So he, he actually put forty percent of his fund into Amex. Forty. Forty, forty percent of the single stock. It may have been about forty million, thirty, forty million of capital. Right. Uh, so maybe like ten, fifteen million or something went in.

• 29:24Mohnish Pabrai?

  The crisis abated, you know, Amex started to kind of get their balance sheet kind of straightened out and all of that. And of course, the stock eventually, because these businesses are fantastic and their credit card business at that time was growing gangbusters. You know, it was just on, on a rocket ship. Eventually the stock and, you know, the interesting thing is he met Walt Disney once, just before Disney died. And then he, he, he felt funny. He went to see Snow White. He said, I went to see Snow White with my briefcase because he said, everyone else is there with their kids. I went to actually study the business. Okay, study what Snow White, Snow White's all about. I think he owned like 5% of Disney. And of course, for him at that time, there was no buy and hold.

• 30:07Mohnish Pabrai?

  It was just, you know, look for the next cheap thing. So he, he had a significant ownership in Amex, significant ownership in Disney. He sold all of these at a good profit.

• 30:17Shaan Puri?

  Right.

• 30:17Mohnish Pabrai?

  But he could have just carried them on. If he had kept them for 20, 30 years, they would have done extremely well.

• 30:23Shaan Puri?

  I'm trying to piece together this puzzle of what are some of the, the traits or some of the behaviors that can lead to great investing? When I think of investor, I think of finance, strategy, numbers, Excel, spreadsheets. That's where my brain goes. That's the mental model, the picture I had in my brain.

• 30:42Mohnish Pabrai?

  Yeah.

• 30:42Shaan Puri?

  When you're describing, it's like, he goes to the movie theater to observe. He stands outside the restaurant. He asks the guy a question and it's, these are not spreadsheet. This is like journalism. It's a research, it's firsthand research, it's maybe gut. I guess for you, do you do the same? Uh, teach me about that.

• 31:00Mohnish Pabrai?

  One of my 10 commandments of mental models is thou shall not use Excel. Right? And another model is that if you cannot explain your investing thesis to a 10 year old in about four sentences, so the 10 year old can understand it, it's a pass.

• 31:17Shaan Puri?

  Right.

• 31:18Mohnish Pabrai?

  Right? So basically, at the end of the day, every investment has to be very simple. It starts off being this complex thing, but when you've, you know, understood it, it needs to get down to those four sentences.

• 31:31Shaan Puri?

  Right.

• 31:31Mohnish Pabrai?

  That to me is one of the most interesting parts of investing. So I think the way it works is that we have 50,000 stocks around the world. If you're just investing in public markets, the data set is too large. No one is ever going to know 50,000 companies. A large number of those businesses, something like 90 or 95% or 98% of them should go into the too hard pile. So Buffett has a box on his desk. Which has too hard written on it, right? And I think one time when I visited his office, I told him, Warren, the too hard box is empty, right? And he always said ninety-eight percent goes in the too hard box. Right.

• 32:14Mohnish Pabrai?

  And he immediately took a bunch of papers and put it there, like, oh, it's full, it's all full. In in his case, he made the metaphor real, right? With the too hard pile. So most businesses that we would encounter or look at, usually there'd be two problems with it. One is it's either outside my circle of competence or it's too hard. And this is an exercise in honesty in our scorecard and all of that, where you have to be honest with yourself and not be delusional that you know everything about everything. So exercise in humility. Peter Lynch used to say that when you're looking at businesses to invest in, he said,

• 32:56Mohnish Pabrai?

  make a list of everything you use, right? What shoes do you wear? Right. What clothes do you wear? You know, what brands, where do you go to eat? So make a list of everything that you consume and study those companies. Because many of those companies are publicly traded. Because it's very difficult for a company to get even a dollar from you. All of us as humans are very discerning about how we want to spend our money and we make our choices. And those choices are very specific. So if you are already a consumer of the product, you understand the product. That gives you a basis to try to understand the business because you are a consumer of the product. And then you can kind of go from there.

• 33:41Mohnish Pabrai?

  We are in a business which Buffett says has no called strikes. So if you're a baseball player, three strikes, you're out. Which means if the ball is within the strike zone, you have to swing at it. Even if it's like not in the sweet spot, you have to swing at it. In investing, we can let ten thousand balls go. So it's only when we get the fairest pitch in the center of our sweet spot do we need to act? And if those conditions are not satisfied. Just let it go. What you mentioned is entrepreneurs are all about action. Investors are also all about action.

• 34:25Mohnish Pabrai?

  The action is below the surface. So basically, a person like Warren is spending all his time studying businesses. Now, usually not much comes out of it, right? Because we only see the whale when it surfaces, the whale is swimming all the time. And the activity that investors need to enjoy, if they're going to, you know, be good at this field, is just turning the pages, one after the other, after the other. So there used to be a racetrack in Nebraska called Axarben, which is Nebraska spelled backwards, okay? When I first go for the Berkshire meeting in the nineties, early two thousands,

• 35:09Mohnish Pabrai?

  the meeting used to be at the Axarben racetrack, about ten thousand people. But Buffett used to go to that racetrack when he was eleven or twelve years old. And what he used to do was he used to gather all the tickets that were lying on the floor or the trashcans that people had thrown away. And he'd go home and study each ticket one by one. And some drunk may have thrown away a winning ticket, right? They may not have looked at it carefully. Some things in horse racing are difficult, you know, win, place, show. It could be a place or a show and could have still won and that sort of thing. So he'd gather up the few tickets that he'd find, after sifting through this whole mess, that are actually winning tickets.

• 35:53Mohnish Pabrai?

  Because he was twelve, he couldn't go to the window to claim them because you had to be over eighteen. He'd give it to his aunt, Aunt Alice. His Aunt Alice would go to the racetrack and collect on those tickets and then give him the cash. And when he was in his early twenties, he went through the Moody's manuals. And on eBay, I bought one of these Moody's manuals because they don't publish them anymore. But they are on very thin paper, very small text. And they have some financials about three or four companies on one page. He went through all of them in the early fifties, two or three times.

• 36:32Mohnish Pabrai?

  Turning one page at a time and what he was looking for is he was looking for anomalies. And Ajit Jain made a comment this time at the Berkshire meeting. He says that, you know, when we hire these people in the insurance business, the instructions I give them is whenever someone comes to you for any deal, always say no. Say no to every single thing presented to you. And then he says, you'll see a deal that hits you in the head like a two by four and you can't believe the deal. Right. That's when you bring it to me and then we'll look at it. Okay. And investing is the same way. So when he was going through Moody's manuals,

• 37:17Mohnish Pabrai?

  he's looking to get hit in the head by the two with a two by four. And he found this company, for example, Western Insurance. The stock is at fifteen dollars. They made twenty five dollars last year. And they forty dollars of cash on the balance sheet. Okay. That's hitting you in the head with a two by four, right? So he pulls that out, invests in it, you know, looks at it, goes and understands more of the company and all of that. And then the next thousand companies, nothing. Then he again finds something. Recently, last four or five years, he made the bet in the Japanese trading companies, five Japanese trading companies. Those came out of something like the Moody's manual called the Japan Company Handbook, which is an English publication, updated once a quarter.

• 38:02Mohnish Pabrai?

  Two public Japanese companies on every page is a thick book, right? He's been going through the Japan Company Handbook for at least twenty years. Okay. This is the first time after twenty years of going through it that he made these these bets. But it was a huge home run because again hit with a two by four. So these Japanese trading companies, in this case, what he did was all of them had a dividend of eight or nine percent. He borrowed the entire five billion that he put into these companies in Japanese yen. So it's hundred percent levered at half a percent a year. The companies are paying eight or nine percent a year. So he's getting seven and a half percent cash.

• 38:42Shaan Puri?

  Right.

• 38:43Mohnish Pabrai?

  Just for holding these investments. Then in the next three, four years, they doubled their dividends. So now it's sixteen percent and the stocks doubled. So the five billion became ten billion and the ten billion is paying eight hundred million a year. Okay. And it was almost fully risk free.

• 39:05Shaan Puri?

  Right.

• 39:05Mohnish Pabrai?

  Right. So basically, that is the nature of investing is that the game we are playing is there is continuous activity of a different kind than the way an entrepreneur. But it is orgasmic activity. Okay. If you have that type of a temperament.

• 39:24Shaan Puri?

  Right.

• 39:24Mohnish Pabrai?

  Right. If you really enjoy looking for needles in haystacks.

• 39:29Shaan Puri?

  Right.

• 39:29Mohnish Pabrai?

  Then the payoffs are huge.

• 39:31Shaan Puri?

  At the Berkshire meeting, Buffett had this line that I loved. He said, the stock market is like a church with a casino attached to it. And he said, seems like a lot of people, that casino is getting crowded. Seems like a lot of people are visiting that casino, you know, nowadays. And I'm curious what you think about that. And especially in the context of you've got prediction markets and Robin Hood and options and two day options and you know, leverage and there's so many ways to play the casino.

• 40:00Mohnish Pabrai?

  And I think all of that, from my point of view, makes it better for me.

• 40:05Shaan Puri?

  The wealth transfer.

• 40:06Mohnish Pabrai?

  Well, exactly. I mean, the thing is, the more hyperactive people get, the better it is for me. And I mean, it is, it is unfortunate because the stock market serves a very important function of allowing gifted leaders and entrepreneurs to get the capital to pursue their dreams. I mean, that's really the reason why we have capital markets, right? Is basically to funnel capital to the best uses, best uses of the capital. And of course, the side effect of that is that you have all the casino activity that comes with the church. And the interesting thing is that after the, there was a big bubble in the, in the UK,

• 40:50Mohnish Pabrai?

  the South Sea Bubble, where there was a big speculation orgy and prices went crazy. And then eventually. A lot of people lost money. The British government's response to that was to ban public markets for 200 years. So interestingly, like even when there were no public markets, a number of great businesses got created in the UK and capital still found its way to them. So it doesn't always need to be through an auction-driven market. But the main purpose of the New York Stock Exchange and the Hong Kong Stock Exchange and so on is to funnel and allow the capital to go into the Teslas of the world, go into

• 41:33Mohnish Pabrai?

  the SpaceX of the world, and allow those businesses to improve a lot of humanity, right? And of course, the side effect of that is there's all the casino activity going on. And as we've seen with Robin Hood and so on. And so it's a negative for humanity. And the more that becomes prevalent, that's more negative it is. But I, when I look at it from an individual point of view, like from my own self-centered, self-interested point of view, the more the merrier. You know, that's just going to be more helpful to someone like me.

• 42:05Shaan Puri?

  I don't know if this is fully accurate, but this New York Times said this on Polly Market, 0.1% of the users have 60% of the profits right now. And so they said some number like 2,000 traders had made like half a billion dollars this year, just 2,000. So it was an immense wealth transfer from the casual gambler to what's likely an insider, just sitting there who has more knowledge or a bit of a sharp, who's being more selective.

• 42:31Mohnish Pabrai?

  Well, the simple, the simple thing is, so if you, if you look at something like horse racing, the track takes 21% of every dollar, because you know, physically paying for horses to run is expensive. Whereas let's say if I go play blackjack at a great game in Vegas, the house has a 0.2%, a 0.3%, a 0.4%.

• 42:59Mohnish Pabrai?

  So every time a gambler bets forty nine point five percent or more is coming back to them, right? It's a forty nine point five percent odds that they will win that bet. It's a pretty decent, whereas in horse racing, you've already lost the twenty percent is gone already. But the thing is that there are people who make a livelihood only betting on horses. And the way they make the money is the same as what's happening in polymarkets, which is they watch all the horses and all the races. And they pick the one where the odds make no sense, right?

• 43:39Mohnish Pabrai?

  So they they know the horses, they know the races, and because the odds are set based on how much is being bet.

• 43:45Shaan Puri?

  Right.

• 43:46Mohnish Pabrai?

  Just like the stock market or or the way.

• 43:48Shaan Puri?

  You're betting against the other betters.

• 43:49Mohnish Pabrai?

  Yeah, we're betting against the other bettors, right? And and that's what's happening in polymarkets as well.

• 43:54Shaan Puri?

  Right. I was looking through all the stories you've done. And one of the craziest ones is that you paid six hundred and fifty thousand dollars to have lunch with Warren Buffett. Was it worth it?

• 44:04Mohnish Pabrai?

  So what happened is in two thousand and seven, my net worth hit, I think, eighty four million. And most of it was because of the intellectual property of Warren Buffett, which I had paid nothing for.

• 44:18Shaan Puri?

  Right.

• 44:18Mohnish Pabrai?

  Right? And I felt like I wanted to thank him and just look him in the eye and just say how grateful I was. Now, when Buffett does these lunches, his agenda is that whatever someone paid, they should feel like they got a bargain. And so from his point of view, he just wants to make sure that there's tremendous value delivered, right? So before we met for the lunch, there was about a kind of one year gap between the time I won and we actually sat down for lunch. So his assistant had asked for bios of everyone who was attending, and he'd studied all of those. So when he got there, he basically told us, my entire afternoon is free.

• 45:02Mohnish Pabrai?

  So whenever you guys get sick and tired of me, just let me know and I'll leave.

• 45:07Shaan Puri?

  What was the one thing you took away now, twenty years later?

• 45:11Mohnish Pabrai?

  Yeah, I made some notes after the lunch, and I think we had a total between everyone about. Over fifty questions that we asked him. And of course, you know, Warren has this great skill of taking lemon questions and converting them to lemonade. So sometimes I asked him questions which were just innocuous questions, just an update. Like I asked him, for example, what happened to Rick Goran? Explain who Rick is. So Warren and Charlie, Charlie Bunker were partners for decades, several decades. Originally, there were three of them. There was Warren, Charlie and Rick Goran. And in the sixties, they did a bunch of stuff together, early seventies. And then Rick Goran disappeared off the radar.

• 45:55Mohnish Pabrai?

  I mean, we never heard from him. So I, I just wanted to know what happened to Rick, you know? So I asked Warren and he converted that question. So he said, Charlie and I always knew we were going to be rich, but we were not in a hurry. And Rick was in a hurry. So then he talked about how Rick was always levered. He always had margin loans. And when the downturn of seventy-three and seventy-four came, seventy-three, seventy-four were the very severe stock market correction, was a crash in slow motion. Basically, the markets went down more than fifty percent over that two-year period. Rick got a number of margin calls.

• 46:37Mohnish Pabrai?

  And Warren said that he bought Rick's Berkshire shares from him for forty bucks a share. I mean, those shares are over seven hundred thousand now, right? And he then said, if you are even a slightly above-average investor and spend less than you earn and do not use leverage, you can't help but get rich over a lifetime, right? So he wanted to communicate the message about the ills and follies of leverage. But I, I felt there were, there were so many lessons. There was another important thing he talked about. He said that there are two ways you can live your life.

• 47:21Mohnish Pabrai?

  You can live your life with an outer scorecard, which is what people think of you and react to that. Or you can live your life with an inner scorecard, which is you measure yourself with internal metrics, not with external metrics. And he said that, would you prefer to be the greatest lover in the world, but known as the worst? Or the worst lover in the world, but known as the greatest. So he said, if you know how to answer that question, you've got it made. So I think this inner and outer scorecard is a really, to me, it's a really fundamental mental model. You have to be true to yourself.

• 48:04Shaan Puri?

  Right.

• 48:04Mohnish Pabrai?

  Because we can be swayed, easily swayed by external inputs, external stimuli. So to keep it centered is awesome.

• 48:13Shaan Puri?

  I've thought about that one a lot. I think I read in his biography, I think he called that the most important lesson his father taught him was to live life with the inner scorecard. How does one do that? How do you go from going from the outer scorecard to inner?

• 48:26Mohnish Pabrai?

  You've got critics who are very harsh, right? Who want to pull you down and taking you below where you know reality is. So one of the things I frequently run into is I've, I've met people who criticize Gandhi a lot. Criticize Buffett a lot. Criticize some folks that I think have lived remarkable lives, right? And they nitpick at, oh, what about this? What about that? And so the way I look at it is I say, okay, if they can criticize Gandhi, then I'm fair game. Okay. So, you know, just understand that the Gandhis of the world being criticized. And so.

• 49:10Shaan Puri?

  Don't be shocked when you are too.

• 49:12Mohnish Pabrai?

  Anytime you have any kind of a public presence or anything else, you are going to get all of the above.

• 49:19Shaan Puri?

  Berkshire has something like almost what 400 billion in cash?

• 49:23Mohnish Pabrai?

  Yeah, 380, yeah.

• 49:25Shaan Puri?

  What are they doing? What are they waiting for?

• 49:27Mohnish Pabrai?

  Well, I mean, I think that this has been the history of Berkshire where the cash will build up and then they'll find opportunities and they'll put it to work. They're not suffering right now because treasuries are playing pretty well. So they're, they're making decent money. But the second is that we get dislocations and we don't know when these dislocations come. We had dislocations during COVID. We had dislocations in the financial crisis. If I were to make a guess, I would say that five years from now, the cash may be half or less of what it is today. Berkshire used to be run by a great capital allocator.

• 50:07Mohnish Pabrai?

  Now it is run by a great operator and a pretty good capital allocator. Berkshire is going to get phone calls. And Warren used to say that when they call you on a Saturday, that's when you know you're going to make a great deal. He said the Saturday calls are the best.

• 50:25Shaan Puri?

  Because it's the most desperate call.

• 50:27Mohnish Pabrai?

  Because usually they need, they need the deal done before Tokyo opens on Sunday night, US time. So when there is a crisis and Berkshire is a little better known now than it used to be, Greg will get the call. And you know, the investing game is interesting because you need extreme patience with extreme decisiveness. Charlie used to say, it's like standing by a stream with a spear, looking for salmon going by. And he says, you know, you might be there for a while, but then suddenly a juicy salmon comes in. And when a juicy salmon is passing by, you have to act fast. You can't start contemplating your navel at that point.

• 51:10Shaan Puri?

  Right.

• 51:10Mohnish Pabrai?

  Right. So you have to be very patient where you have the spear. And you don't know whether it happens in the next five minutes or the next five hours or the next 12 hours. But you're ready.

• 51:21Shaan Puri?

  Right. In your whole investing career, what one investment has been the best for you?

• 51:27Mohnish Pabrai?

  So I, I had two more than hundred bagger investments, which went up more than a hundred X. Before I started the funds. So I started investing on my own in 94 or 95. And then by the time I got to 2000, I had two businesses. The one went up 140 X and the other went up about 100 X. And in one case, I had invested about 10 million, no 10,000. I had a million dollars in about in 94. So I invested just 10,001 business. It became 1.4 million.

• 52:09Mohnish Pabrai?

  But there was another business I invested in which became more than 10 million. And so these two were the outliers. So the original million became like 14 million or something. But it was driven by these two investments. More recently, the company in Turkey that we bought at 3% liquidation value, it's just about hitting 100x now.

• 52:38Shaan Puri?

  Which one is that?

• 52:39Mohnish Pabrai?

  That's Rezas.

• 52:40Shaan Puri?

  Rezas, that's the warehouse?

• 52:42Mohnish Pabrai?

  Yeah, the warehouse operator.

• 52:43Shaan Puri?

  Okay.

• 52:44Mohnish Pabrai?

  I mean, so what happened there is that we were buying a company, I think when we first started buying it, with a 15, 16 million dollar market cap, liquidation value was about 800 million.

• 52:55Shaan Puri?

  And what was the big misunderstanding? Like, you know, you've told me these words before. I look for what's hated and unloved, or where people have confused risk with uncertainty. Or was it something else in the Turkish market? Why was it trading? When you say 3% of liquidation value, that means the price of the business, there's 30x that in just the assets that it owns if it had to liquidate everything. So, you know, 33% or whatever.

• 53:19Mohnish Pabrai?

  Turkey was, and even still is, in such a weird state that it's hard to believe. So, for example, at that time, the company was trading at, what should have happened with a company like that was that the owners should have taken it private.

• 53:37Shaan Puri?

  Right.

• 53:38Mohnish Pabrai?

  And the owners of the business did not have a good understanding of buybacks and taking it private. They are very good operators and they went to the public markets to raise capital so they could grow.

• 53:53Shaan Puri?

  Right.

• 53:53Mohnish Pabrai?

  They got the capital, they were growing, they never cared about the stock price. They've actually never, even now, even today, they don't really calculate their kind of wealth by the stock price. They calculate it based on what they think the business is worth. They don't really care about the stock price, which is actually a good way to.

• 54:10Shaan Puri?

  Inter-score, Craig.

• 54:10Mohnish Pabrai?

  Yeah, a great way to run, but actually you really want the business to trade near the stock price, near the value, so that anyone entering or exiting is getting a fair deal. That's what Buffett tries to do. He wants to make sure that Berkshire's value is always around what it's worth. But there were other businesses, like I remember the first company I visited in Turkey was trading at a P of 0.1. Never heard of that. Not, not one, zero point one, which means that the market cap was equal to one month's earnings. Okay. And I remember my friend had sent me a list of the businesses we were going to visit. And I did no work on these companies. I said, I'm going to do work on them after I visit them because I don't want to waste time if I don't like them or whatever else.

• 54:54Mohnish Pabrai?

  So as we were driving to the company, I start asking him questions. So I'm just somewhat intelligent in the meeting. So I said, okay, so what's going on here? He said, well, Mohnish, it's a P of zero point one. I said, zero point one, and it's one of the largest banks in Turkey. I said, what's going on? He said, are they violated some UN sanctions? They were doing some wire transfers with Iran that we're not supposed to do. And what happened with that company was that the CFO of the business, who didn't have anything to do with this craziness, went to the US to vacation with his family at Disney World.

• 55:33Mohnish Pabrai?

  And when he landed in New York, the Southern District of New York folks picked him up at the airport and put him in Rikers Prison in violation of the sanctions. And they told him the rest of the family can continue on to. Enjoy Disneyland. So, so when that news hit the street, I mean, that's like, you know, they, you'll be cut off of the SWIFT SWIFT system. The US can put sanctions on you. I mean, you could just, you know, kneecap the bank. And Erdogan at that time was calling Trump in his first term, saying, can you please release the guy? Yeah. And he didn't do anything. And Trump said, it's New York State.

• 56:17Mohnish Pabrai?

  And so all of this was playing out while I'm going to see the company. And actually, the, the business was a well-run bank. And I told my friend, it's too much hair even for me. I'm not going there. Okay. So Turkey. Then and even now, has some crazily priced assets, which is why I decided, take a simple idea, take it seriously. I said, okay, this is the situation where half the winners of the Saban racetrack have thrown away, William, winning tickets, right? Instead of one in a thousand or one in 500, it's 50 out of 100 have thrown away winning tickets. So basically, it's going back to the mental model. You take a simple idea, you take it seriously.

• 57:01Mohnish Pabrai?

  You know, I remember when this company was 15 million, Turkish stocks are allowed to go up 10% a day. They were limited in a day, company. So I was concerned how much stock I can buy. So I told the broker, buy every share available. Don't worry about the volumes. Take out all the asks, you know, the stocks at 15, someone's willing to buy, sell at 16 or 17, whatever. I said, all the asks up to 10%, just take them all out. If anything more shows up, take it out. I said, just take everything you can get, right? So the guy calls me, the broker calls me and says, I have 5% of the company being offered by Templeton Fund, this is a US fund in Turkey.

• 57:43Mohnish Pabrai?

  Templeton Fund is offering 5% of the company for a million dollars. Okay? So 20 million market cap, basically 1 million. I said, why are you calling me? Take it, right? And so now, this is not a Turkish investor. Right. These are not people who are day traders. Right. Somebody in New York made a decision, I'm out of Turkey. And the reason they were going out of Turkey is the currency was very unstable and inflation was rampant and they were right about that. So two things that were bothering investors a lot, which can be very detrimental to making an investment is an unstable currency and high inflation. And other mental models came in to help me.

• 58:26Mohnish Pabrai?

  So one of the things that I think I discussed with Charlie is, let's say, there's a thermonuclear event, global thermonuclear event, 99% of humans are dead. So we've gone to 70 million humans left out of 7 or 8 billion and everything's destroyed.

• 58:48Mohnish Pabrai?

  The seventy million humans that are left, someone is going to start producing Coke concentrate. And someone is going to resurrect a Coke bottling plant. Because there's seventy million humans. And there's no currencies anymore. But humans will be willing to trade fifteen minutes labor for a Coke. So a company like Coke is not dependent on inflation. It's not dependent on exchange rates. It's not dependent on anything. There is a benefit it gives. So it doesn't matter whether you're trading Coke cans in seashells or dollars or lira or whatever.

• 59:33Mohnish Pabrai?

  There is an exchange that would take place. So I said to myself, when I was looking at this warehouse company, I said, what is a warehouse? It's land, paint, cement, and steel. Okay? All four are inflation indexed. If the currency goes crazy, all of these prices are going to go up. So I don't care about the currency. And then the exchange rate also didn't matter because these are prime assets in a prime city. People need those assets just like they need to have a Coke. So I only looked at investments in Turkey, which were naturally immune to the whole inflation

• 1:00:18Mohnish Pabrai?

  or whatever was also going on. And what happened in Turkey is when we were buying this company, it was five lira to the dollar. Okay, that was the exchange rate. Seven years later, it's forty-five lira to the dollar. Okay, the lira has collapsed by ninety percent. In dollars, I'm up ninety X. Okay, in dollars. In lira, I'm up infinity. Right. Who cares? Okay, I don't care about that. I'm just looking at it in dollars. And the reason we went up in dollars ninety X is exactly... So there was another mental model where I said...

• 1:00:55Shaan Puri?

  All right, big news. We just hit three hundred thousand subscribers on Spotify. Thank you to everybody who subscribed. If you're not, go there and watch on Spotify. It's the best place to watch our podcast.

• 1:01:06Mohnish Pabrai?

  There are many businesses in Turkey that will get hurt by inflation. We're not interested in those. So there was another company there called Tav Airports. All their revenue is in euros. Everything is in euros.

• 1:01:20Shaan Puri?

  Right.

• 1:01:20Mohnish Pabrai?

  Okay, they're listed on the Istanbul Stock Exchange with all the gamblers. Okay. Now, airport operators, these are phenomenal businesses. And normally you look at an airport operator, like you look at one in India, the trailing P E L sell at is 70 times, 50 times.

• 1:01:37Shaan Puri?

  It's like a natural monopoly, right?

• 1:01:39Mohnish Pabrai?

  Natural monopoly, very desirable. Everyone wants in and so it's just overinflated and all of that. In, in Turkey, it's sitting at like four times, three times. You know, it's sitting at nothing, like basically. So, and in this case, in the case of Tav Airport, the currency is not relevant. They're not even, in fact, what is happening is their revenue was in lira, in euros, and their costs are in lira. So in fact, what's happening is the employees are getting poorer every year.

• 1:02:11Shaan Puri?

  Right.

• 1:02:11Mohnish Pabrai?

  And so basically, it was just using a few models. Take a simple idea, take it seriously, active versus passive, understanding that thermonuclear event, people want coke. And let's look at assets where the currency is not relevant. Right? And when I was able to look at those four things, there was no one else on the planet applying those four models at that same time in that market.

• 1:02:40Shaan Puri?

  Right.

• 1:02:40Mohnish Pabrai?

  That's it. How, how difficult was that?

• 1:02:43Shaan Puri?

  So I want to ask you the hardest question, I think. I think the hardest question, let me tell you how I arrived here. I love the idea of studying businesses because I love business and I love studying. Put them together, I'm happy. I enjoy it. I think it's a great intellectual sport and I do it. I pick some stocks and I have some index and, you know, I combine the two. At the same time, it seems like most people lose money doing this. Even smart people lose money doing this. And for example, I had Kathy Wood on the podcast. I said, Kathy, you know, she's super popular. I think she's really smart. I even agree with her about many of her theories and thesis about where the world is going. At the same time, I told her, I was like, look, if I look at the last one year, two years,

• 1:03:25Shaan Puri?

  five years, you haven't beat the S and P, but you're taking huge fees on your money. The way her model works is that, and I said, look, I think you're an honest person. Like, would, I asked her the question, I said, would you invest in someone with your track record? And she said, you know, she had a great answer, like, actually, I really appreciate you giving me the chance to answer that. And so she gave me a good answer, but I'm curious, you know, same thing. How hard is it to beat the market, really? And how do you feel? Cause in some years you do and some you don't. I don't know exactly because your funds and you have the ETFs. It's hard to even piece together fully.

• 1:03:56Mohnish Pabrai?

  Yeah.

• 1:03:56Shaan Puri?

  But I guess, give me two answers. One is, what is your track record? You manage something like a billion dollars. So what is your track record compared to just blindly put in the index? And secondly, how do you feel about that? You know, as a sort of smart, honest person who's studied this game and trying their best to do the best they can?

• 1:04:14Mohnish Pabrai?

  Yeah, so the, the track record, it depends on the fund because we've, we've got different funds and so on. But if you look at our oldest fund, which is now, um, uh, what it's a 20, more than 27 years old. Every dollar is turned into about $30. So dollars become about $30 in the oldest fund. And I think the S and P is, uh, every dollar is less than seven, approximately six or seven dollars. That fund has done, done well. If I take the newest one, which is our ETF, for example, which is, uh, got about two and a half years of history. If you, if I look at the entire two and a half years, we are behind the S and P.

• 1:04:58Mohnish Pabrai?

  Because I think the S and P has done like 19% since, uh, on average per year. In the last two and a half years, then we've done like 15, 16%. But, uh, this year we are ahead. So if you look at three months, we are ahead, six months, one year, and even 18 months, we are ahead. And I think in the last one year, for example, we are, uh, beating the S and P by more than 20 points. Pretty significant. So in this, in the ETF case, I think it took us some time to get properly invested because I only can find like a couple of things in a year. And I would, I would say that I would expect that in the fullness of time, if we look at after five or 10 years. Uh, we should be ahead of the S and P.

• 1:05:43Shaan Puri?

  Right.

• 1:05:43Mohnish Pabrai?

  Also, the S and P has, um, it's a handicap situation for the S and P because it's overvalued. You know, it's sitting kind of elevated in, in valuations and such. And so at some point, the stock market becomes a weighing machine. And so I, I think that in general, the index, broad index of the S and P may not do that well for the next decade. Just because there's been so much growth.

• 1:06:09Shaan Puri?

  Yeah.

• 1:06:09Mohnish Pabrai?

  Into the future in the last decade. So, uh, I think we'll be fine.

• 1:06:14Shaan Puri?

  Yeah.

• 1:06:15Mohnish Pabrai?

  Yeah.

• 1:06:15Shaan Puri?

  I guess, do, do you feel like, uh, the question I think I'm trying to ask is more like, how hard is it to beat the index?

• 1:06:22Mohnish Pabrai?

  Well, so, yeah, so, so if you look at the entire US stock market over the last 90 years, 4% of companies have basically delivered the market return. So the, the return we're getting in the market has come from 4% of businesses. The other 96% have just treaded water. And if you look at Warren Buffett, for example, and he said this himself, that 12 investments he made over 60 years is what has created Berkshire Hathaway. He has made more than three or 400 investments. So again, his success rate is 3 to 4%. And this is the reason why indices do well.

• 1:07:05Mohnish Pabrai?

  Because the index is too dumb to know that it owns Nvidia and it's too dumb to sell it. Okay. It's too dumb to know that it owns TSMC and it's too dumb to sell it. Whereas an individual investor or, or a portfolio manager will look at it and say, oh, it's overvalued or this and that, or whatever else. Or the mistress looks hot or whatever else and make that change. So this is the reason why index investing does well, because it includes that 4%. So you don't need to think about it. You have captured the 4%.

• 1:07:36Shaan Puri?

  Right.

• 1:07:37Mohnish Pabrai?

  And you will get a market return, which is very good. When I look at what I'm doing, I don't think I would have the wealth I have had. And I don't think my investors would have had what they have done if we had indexed. We've done better than the index. The way I look at it is that every year that goes by, I'm getting to be a better investor. So I think that if I were playing a game like basketball, I would start declining, right? And when I get to my 30s and 40s, I'm gone, basically. But investing is a game where you can keep getting better. And you keep seeing more patterns, you expand your circle, you get better at looking at different things.

• 1:08:20Mohnish Pabrai?

  So experience is a huge plus. And all of this accumulates and also you get to ride the winners, if you will. So the important thing in investing is not the mistakes you make. It's not selling the winners. The 4% bets of Berkshire that worked, the other 96%, whatever Buffett did with them did not matter. It didn't matter whether he sold them, bought them, liquidated them, whatever else. That didn't really move the needle. What mattered was not selling Coke, not selling Apple, having Greg Abel run Mid-American Energy, having Ajit Jain run the insurance and not firing Ajit and not getting rid of him. Those were the important things.

• 1:09:05Shaan Puri?

  This is your circle the wagons concept.

• 1:09:07Mohnish Pabrai?

  Circle the wagon. So the thing is that we have to understand that capitalism is brutal. And almost every business will eventually go to zero because of the competitive destruction forces. But there's a sliver of businesses that what happens is that a brand gets built or tastes happen, like a business like McDonald's. It starts off with no moat.

• 1:09:35Shaan Puri?

  Right.

• 1:09:35Mohnish Pabrai?

  But now it has a brand, you know, there'll be a sign on the highway saying McDonald's eight miles ahead.

• 1:09:43Shaan Puri?

  Right.

• 1:09:43Mohnish Pabrai?

  You see that sign and say, that's where I'm going.

• 1:09:46Shaan Puri?

  Right.

• 1:09:46Mohnish Pabrai?

  Right?

• 1:09:46Shaan Puri?

  Even if Sean's Burger Shack is one mile away.

• 1:09:49Mohnish Pabrai?

  Exactly. And that's the moat, that's the moat, right? And so it's actually accidental, for the most part, how and when moats get built. But once a moat gets built. Some of these moats become enduring for a very long time. Like if you look at something like FICO, for example, the FICO scores. I mean, that business just prints cash, right? But it started off with no mode, then as more and more people start using that score. And now there's some movement where people are talking about other things, but people don't want to move away from FICO. It's too entrenched, right? And so we as investors have the advantage of buying into existing modes, right?

• 1:10:32Mohnish Pabrai?

  And so if I look at, for example, the largest bet we have, which is a Turkish warehouse operator. They have prime warehouses, extremely well built in prime parts of Istanbul. Okay. And that's a very important city. It's a big city, it needs it, it's fundamental. I don't think that's going away. In fact, the demand for warehouses increases in an e-commerce world, right? Because you need, in fact, what they were building, a quarter million square foot warehouses are now becoming million square foot warehouses because all the nuance is happening with e-commerce.

• 1:11:12Mohnish Pabrai?

  So we, we want to look at businesses where the moats have staying power for a long time. An airport operator, a coke bottler, you know, gonna go on, right? So we want to look at these enduring moats. Eventually, we want to own parts of those enduring moats.

• 1:11:29Shaan Puri?

  I want to ask you about some new things. So, you know, it's very interesting to look at the kind of investments of maybe early days Buffett and just things that are around for a hundred years. But then there's new things that might be around for a hundred years from now or might not. I'm curious your opinion on these. So I'm going to throw four kind of topics at you that you can rapid fire. Give me just your kind of where you're at mentally on these different things. So first is AI. I don't think you could be an investor in the world and not have AI thoughts, whether you think it's going to disrupt certain businesses or create new industries or really be huge tailwinds or headwinds.

• 1:12:04Mohnish Pabrai?

  Invest in the pickaxe makers. So I think I think that the alphabets and metas of the world are playing a game they haven't played before, which is having businesses with very high capex. May work, may want work, I don't know. But what I do know is they have to pass through some toll bridges. They all have to pass through TSMC. They have to pass through ASML. They probably have to pass through Micron.

• 1:12:30Shaan Puri?

  Right.

• 1:12:31Mohnish Pabrai?

  So I have no bets in any of these areas because it's either goes in the too hard pile, or it goes in outside circle of competence, or it's too expensive. So if I'm not making a bet, it doesn't matter whether I'm right or wrong, right? So what I'm saying is that there's no way I'm going to sell the Turkish warehouses to buy TSMC. Because that that trade makes no sense to me.

• 1:13:00Shaan Puri?

  Right.

• 1:13:00Mohnish Pabrai?

  The mistress looks much uglier than the wife.

• 1:13:04Shaan Puri?

  Yeah. And there's no bonus points for difficulty.

• 1:13:07Mohnish Pabrai?

  We call it the valuation.

• 1:13:08Shaan Puri?

  Yeah.

• 1:13:08Mohnish Pabrai?

  Yeah.

• 1:13:08Shaan Puri?

  You, when I came to your house once, you were telling me about your investments in coal and you've talked about how you look for things that are hated and unloved.

• 1:13:16Mohnish Pabrai?

  Yeah.

• 1:13:17Shaan Puri?

  It's a clue for you to go go spend some time.

• 1:13:19Mohnish Pabrai?

  Yeah.

• 1:13:19Shaan Puri?

  Because you think that there might be opportunity there. I feel like the, right now, in my world, the hated and unloved bucket is SaaS companies, vertical SaaS companies. I saw you invested in Constellation.

• 1:13:31Mohnish Pabrai?

  Yeah.

• 1:13:31Shaan Puri?

  So I'm curious, and I've been thinking about this too, there's, you know, a lot of great businesses are on sale right now.

• 1:13:37Mohnish Pabrai?

  So that was an area, that was an area where things fell within circle of competence.

• 1:13:42Shaan Puri?

  Okay.

• 1:13:43Mohnish Pabrai?

  And it made sense. So the idea that Betsy in HR is going to fire up some AI, AI software, whatever, and develop her own software and get rid of Workday or whatever else they're using in HR is just a pipe dream.

• 1:14:03Shaan Puri?

  Yeah.

• 1:14:03Mohnish Pabrai?

  So I think what is not understood well by the market is that software is not coding. Okay?

• 1:14:12Mohnish Pabrai?

  Coding is automated and will get even faster and whatever, but it may be at most one fifth of the pie. And so just because you can get something coded quickly doesn't mean that Adobe is going out of business, or you don't need Photoshop and you don't need all the products that they have. And, and so I actually feel the market has got it wrong. So in, in my view, the advantage will go to the incumbents. So an Adobe will be able to reduce its costs because, I mean, Microsoft's laying off people. They're all laying off people, right? Because they don't need so many, because they can, they can automate it.

• 1:14:55Mohnish Pabrai?

  So all of these incumbents are going to reduce their costs. Now, they may also end up reducing price.

• 1:15:01Shaan Puri?

  Right.

• 1:15:02Mohnish Pabrai?

  But I don't really see, uh, they may not even need to reduce price. Okay. Depending on the, you know, how much the moat is. I don't see their cash flows going down. And, and so if you drop the price in half and the cash flow is not going down, uh, you know, where do I sign? You know? And, and I specifically only invested in the Mark Leonard universe of businesses because he has a unique mouth. So the reason why I invested in mouth, uh, is Mark Leonard is no one else has ever cloned Constellation and no one else ever will be able to clone Constellation.

• 1:15:47Shaan Puri?

  Explain who he is, because he's this mysterious guy. There's no, like, there's like two photos of this guy on the internet.

• 1:15:53Mohnish Pabrai?

  Mark is a highly, highly unusual leader. Okay. There's no other person like Mark. Let's put it that way. What he's built at Constellation.

• 1:16:05Mohnish Pabrai?

  Is very unique. So there are probably seventy to a hundred thousand vertical market software companies, private companies in the U. S. They have a team, a biz dev team that touches all these companies twice a year with a phone call and twice a year with an email. Okay. And in fact, the funny thing is I was in Omaha at the Berkshire meeting and a guy comes up to me and says, Mohnish, I'm a huge fan of yours. I'm in the Constellation M and A team. I said, don't go anywhere. Need to talk to you, right? So tell me what's going on. And you know, I tried to get a conversation going because, you know, Constellation is such a black box. Right. But anyway, they have this large M and A team.

• 1:16:50Mohnish Pabrai?

  They buy a company like every three days or something, right? Yeah, they bought like two hundred companies last year, for example, right? And they bought more than a thousand companies and they don't use bankers, right? And so they're doing direct deals. And now I think paying, they might be paying five times cash flow or something, or maybe six times cash flow. But then almost immediately, within a year or two, the effective price becomes like three or four times cash flow because they bump up the revenue a little bit, they bump up the license fees about twenty percent, whatever. And then they've got all these best practices that they built up. Now, they don't tell the company to do this and that, but they say, look, you're in this business. Here's, you know, eighty other companies we have like this, and this is what we've learned. So this is what we suggest. Right.

• 1:17:35Mohnish Pabrai?

  And you do your thing and whatever you want. So they actually extract Right. Uh, more efficiency out of their engine. So on an organic basis, if they were not buying anything, they'd be growing about three percent a year. So these companies they're buying are not dying. On average, they are still growing. Right. So if you think of a, if you think about buying a business that's growing three percent a year and, you know, interest rates are where they are, you would be fine paying fifteen times cash flow. That would probably be a proud way the deal should be done somewhere between. Explain, what's the math there? I'm, I don't understand. The math there is that a business is doing ten million in, in sales and let's say they're putting one million to the bottom line. Okay. And that one million is going up three percent a year. Okay.

• 1:18:17Mohnish Pabrai?

  Now, let's say you were buying that company for ten million. Okay. Your alternative is put it in treasuries. You put it in treasuries, you're gonna get four hundred thousand a year. Right. Okay, you put it here, you're getting a million a year, right? And the million is growing, but it has more risk than treasury. So you won't pay exactly what a treasury is paying. So that's the math is, you know, the the risk free rate effectively makes it that if you knew a business was growing at three percent a year, you would be willing to pay in a low interest rate environment ten, fifteen times cash flow, whatever. And so they're they're effectively buying it for three or four times because they get these efficiencies.

• 1:18:58Mohnish Pabrai?

  So now you're taking the cash flow the business is generating and you're reinvesting it at a twenty five percent rate. Right? I mean, that's and then you're continuously doing that. Right. So nobody else has the patience to put in the engine to touch the seventy thousand twice a year. And also, the more difficult part is integrating them, right? So the culture to say, let's do this and that, in many ways, constellation is superior to Berkshire Hathaway. Berkshire Hathaway buys businesses of all kinds. These guys buy only one kind of business, right? And they're buying one kind of business and and they're buying it in a delegated manner now

• 1:19:42Mohnish Pabrai?

  because the people doing the deals are not even at headquarters. They don't even need an approval for it. They've been told any business up to twenty million, you can just do your deal. And as those teams have keep keep doing that and have a track record, the bump up how much they will need. So so it's actually a delegated model now at this point. And so from my point of view, you've basically got a mousetrap that's growing cash flows at twenty, twenty five percent a year. What should you pay for a mousetrap that's growing cash flows twenty five percent a year? You would be paying forty times. If you knew that was gonna continue forever. Right. You'd easily pay forty, fifty times. It went down to teens multiple. Right. And it came down to a point where even someone like Mohnish, a chief's kid like Mohnish got interested.

• 1:20:26Mohnish Pabrai?

  And and the thing is, so I I think that the DNA he has is very, very special. And this universe of companies that he's going after is too small for private equity. Right. Private equity hates doing these itty bitty deals. Right. Right? And the second is, they don't wanna buy and hold them. So he's buy and hold, these guys want to flip. So the frictional cost of buying a tiny company and then trying to find another buyer and all that, there's too much nonsense involved. So quite frankly, the only competition they would have would be if someone decided, I want to do everything exactly the same. And the market could tolerate three constellations. It's large enough for three or four constellations. But there are none, there's only one.

• 1:21:11Shaan Puri?

  Right.

• 1:21:11Mohnish Pabrai?

  So that's why we are in. And now the thing is that we don't need, you have to understand the 4% rule of Buffett, right? Only 4% of his bets work. So if you look at my bets, like, you know, airports, coal, warehouses, constellation, if all of them work, now, if you ask me about each one, I'll give you a case why it works. All of them not gonna work. Because there's no way, if all of them work, we're doing 100% a year. Okay, that's not gonna happen. But if half of them work, we have a home run. Even if 40% work, we have a home run. So this is a very forgiving business. And so that's where this is, which is, I don't know which half works.

• 1:21:56Mohnish Pabrai?

  I wish I knew.

• 1:21:57Shaan Puri?

  Yeah, if you knew.

• 1:21:58Mohnish Pabrai?

  Yeah.

• 1:21:58Shaan Puri?

  If only.

• 1:21:58Mohnish Pabrai?

  I don't know which half works. So like, I know that our coal bets, for example, there are things that can cause that bet to fail. They are low probability, but they could happen.

• 1:22:08Shaan Puri?

  Right.

• 1:22:09Mohnish Pabrai?

  So maybe those things happen, maybe they don't happen, I don't know.

• 1:22:12Shaan Puri?

  Right.

• 1:22:12Mohnish Pabrai?

  Constellation, maybe cloners arrive. I don't know, maybe the DNA of the country deteriorates after Mark is gone, I don't know. Right? So there are these unknowns. But it's a favorable bet, it's not 100% bet, it's a favorable bet. And as long as we keep making these favorable bets, we're okay.

• 1:22:30Shaan Puri?

  So Howard Marks came on the podcast.

• 1:22:32Mohnish Pabrai?

  Oh, very wonderful.

• 1:22:32Shaan Puri?

  And he was, he laid out why the S and P might be a bad bet for the next 10 years. And his take was basically, if you look at the current P/E ratio of the S and P, I think it was like 23 or something like that, that the forward 10-year return had vacillated between negative 2 and 2%. Anytime that had happened.

• 1:22:50Mohnish Pabrai?

  Yeah.

• 1:22:51Shaan Puri?

  And so I just want to give you kind of like a, just quick reaction bullish bearish on the S and P index right now, if you were to be an investor.

• 1:22:59Mohnish Pabrai?

  Bearish.

• 1:22:59Shaan Puri?

  Bearish, same reason?

• 1:23:01Mohnish Pabrai?

  Yeah, Howard is very smart, I don't disagree with that.

• 1:23:05Shaan Puri?

  Yeah. GLP-1s, so it's amazing, we have a miracle drug.

• 1:23:09Mohnish Pabrai?

  The best thing since sliced bread.

• 1:23:13Shaan Puri?

  And it puts sliced bread out of business. I read a stat that the GLP-1 drugs, Ozempic and the others, they're apparently generated double the revenue of the AI companies. So it's like 79 billion a year versus, you know,

• 1:23:28Mohnish Pabrai?

  And we are embryonic right now.

• 1:23:30Shaan Puri?

  And we're early stages.

• 1:23:31Mohnish Pabrai?

  And also, I think the the science is going to get a lot better.

• 1:23:34Shaan Puri?

  Yeah, so like, give me your, how you're thinking about that right now, whether from investor point of view or just.

• 1:23:39Mohnish Pabrai?

  Well, I think, I think from an investor point of view, for me, it goes a too hard pile. And the reason it goes a too hard pile is industries with rapid change are the enemy of the investor, according to Warren. So we go, he was king, then Monjaro became king. And then now they're talking about some of these tablets. The tablets are going to have a hard time because they have to go through the liver and all that. But basically, to me, I, I think that this trajectory is going to continue. But given the valuations and given where it's headed, it's, there are too many.

• 1:24:11Shaan Puri?

  Right.

• 1:24:12Mohnish Pabrai?

  Coal is simpler.

• 1:24:13Shaan Puri?

  A few years ago, when I was at your house, I asked you about Bitcoin. And you similarly were like somewhat bearish on it. But you said, you know, ultimately too hard pile for me.

• 1:24:21Mohnish Pabrai?

  Yeah, it's also too hard pile, outside confidence.

• 1:24:23Shaan Puri?

  Has anything changed in your opinion? Because the more time goes by, in a way, like all money is a confidence game, as you know, right? Every currency, every gold bar is a confidence that this will, this will last. I was curious if anything had changed over time for you with Bitcoin?

• 1:24:38Mohnish Pabrai?

  I, I, I prefer gold to Bitcoin. It's not used by a bunch of scammers and, you know, ransom seekers and whatever else. So to me, the whole thing is in the too hard pile. But I would just say that, given that we already have gold, why do we need Bitcoin?

• 1:24:59Shaan Puri?

  Okay, I won't debate you on that. It'll be a four hour podcast. Yeah, there's a, a couple of life models I wanted to ask you about. Because I asked you many of the investing truths.

• 1:25:07Mohnish Pabrai?

  Yeah.

• 1:25:07Shaan Puri?

  But then some of yours, I feel like maybe are related to investing, but probably not. One was. Don't die at 25 and get buried at 75.

• 1:25:17Mohnish Pabrai?

  Yes.

• 1:25:17Shaan Puri?

  What do you mean?

• 1:25:18Mohnish Pabrai?

  So that's a quote by Ben Franklin. As you know, I have no original ideas. So Ben Franklin said that many people die at 25 and are buried at 75. And basically, what that's saying is that you've stopped growing and you've stopped kind of doing things and you're kind of just coasting. You know, I had discussed a stock with Charlie in my last meeting with him. And he was buying that stock six days before he died. Okay, he was 99.9 years old. He didn't know he was going to die in six days. But when you have a 99.9 year age, you know, life expectancy is not 20 years or 10 years.

• 1:26:01Mohnish Pabrai?

  Okay, but he was, I saw Charlie make investments and bets and decisions, ignoring his mortality. Like, like he was 25. He was making the bets as if he was 25. And so I think that living till the very end, truly living, is really important. So we, we, we want to be pursuing our passions. We want to be getting our music out. We want to be doing the things that we want to do for this very finite time we have here.

• 1:26:35Shaan Puri?

  What does it mean, get your music out? I saw that on your, your list, but I didn't know what it meant.

• 1:26:40Mohnish Pabrai?

  Well, all of us have music in us. And it's different, you know, for the musicians, it is actual music that they, but, but, but the thing is, we have to understand who we are. And understanding who we are is not easy, but we have to understand who we are. And we have to understand what would be something we want to bring to this world that makes the world better and makes us feel a sense of accomplishment for doing that.

• 1:27:09Shaan Puri?

  Right.

• 1:27:09Mohnish Pabrai?

  So we, we all have special talents and there are, there's no person who's got nothing, if you will, they, everyone has something special. We have to get that out because that's going to be a fulfilled life.

• 1:27:23Shaan Puri?

  September 28th, 2075. Apparently that's the date I'm gonna die.

• 1:27:32Shaan Puri?

  One of your pieces of advice is, and I quote, "Ask God Google when you are going to die and act accordingly." Last night I Googled when I would die. I gave it all my info. I told it I'm a non-smoker, this few years old, I have done this, et cetera, et cetera. And it gave me a, hey, here's a range.

• 1:27:50Mohnish Pabrai?

  Yeah.

• 1:27:51Shaan Puri?

  And here's the most likely date, September 28th, 2075.

• 1:27:54Mohnish Pabrai?

  Awesome.

• 1:27:55Shaan Puri?

  All right, now what do I do? You freaked me out. Now what do I do?

• 1:27:58Mohnish Pabrai?

  So contrary to Seneca, life is short. And Gandhi has a quote, he says, "Live as if you were to die tomorrow, learn as if you were to live forever." Right? And even Steve Jobs said that if he spent two, three, four days doing not what he really wanted to do or loved doing, he would make a change.

• 1:28:20Shaan Puri?

  Right.

• 1:28:20Mohnish Pabrai?

  So I think that 2075 seems a really, really long ways away. You know, like 49 years or whatever. But it's not that far away. And I think that there's a Buddhist saying about living in the moment. And living in the moment is fantastic. So I think that treating every day as if it's your last and living it to the fullest for the full 49 years, that's what you want to be doing. So I think, you know, people say, "Oh, I'm going to graduate, then I'm going to work three years at McKinsey, then I'm going to get some experience, then I'm going to start my business." You know, Buffett would say to that, "That's like saving sex for old age." Not a good idea. Okay? So don't make a lot of long-term plans.

• 1:29:04Mohnish Pabrai?

  We have to enjoy today.

• 1:29:07Shaan Puri?

  Yeah, don't wait to live.

• 1:29:08Mohnish Pabrai?

  We have to enjoy every day. So I think getting the music out, doing what we love to do, working with people we like, admire and trust, and pursuing our passions, we have to do that all the time.

• 1:29:21Shaan Puri?

  Right. Those are sort of like the eat clean, exercise, get good sleep. What those are to health?

• 1:29:26Mohnish Pabrai?

  Yeah.

• 1:29:27Shaan Puri?

  I feel like what you're describing is to like, living life well.

• 1:29:29Mohnish Pabrai?

  Absolutely.

• 1:29:30Shaan Puri?

  Yeah. You know, one of the things that I think is your, part of your music you get out is that not only do you study investing and study companies to invest in, but you study the investors. And my favorite learnings from you have actually been the stories and the insights you have having studied all the great investors. I want to ask you about a couple of names I didn't ask you about in previous ones. The first is Ed Thorp.

• 1:29:55Mohnish Pabrai?

  Right.

• 1:29:55Shaan Puri?

  Tell me about Ed Thorp. What do we learn from Ed Thorp?

• 1:29:58Mohnish Pabrai?

  The first time I met Ed Thorp, I was naked.

• 1:30:05Shaan Puri?

  Go on.

• 1:30:05Mohnish Pabrai?

  So just to give you the long form answer, so Ed Thorp, MIT trained PhD mathematician, very smart. He actually worked with Claude Shannon, and if you study Shannon, this podcast on him and all that. But Shannon is, you know, probably one of the smartest humans around, ever lived. But Ed Thorp basically used MIT's mainframe computer to figure out how to optimally play blackjack. Right? And he came up with what we now call basic strategy. And at that time, in the early 60s, when he, when he did this, casinos in Vegas and Reno, et cetera, played single deck blackjack to the end of the, end of the deck. And blackjack is a game where every time a card is played, the odds change.

• 1:30:49Mohnish Pabrai?

  And so if a deck gets, you know, filled with more aces and tens, whatever else, then you're basically, as a, as a player gonna, it's in your favor. And smaller cards, it's against you. So he's counting cards, it's easy to do. And when the deck got loaded, he increases bet, not loaded, he reduces bet. And he cleaned the casinos out. And at that time, the casino was a mob run. And so they basically showed him a baseball bat and said, don't ever come back. Okay? And so-

• 1:31:18Shaan Puri?

  Did they even know what he was doing, or they just said?

• 1:31:20Mohnish Pabrai?

  They-

• 1:31:20Shaan Puri?

  We don't need to know.

• 1:31:21Mohnish Pabrai?

  They knew that they were losing money. They didn't know why they were losing money. And that's all they cared about, that they were losing money.

• 1:31:28Shaan Puri?

  Right.

• 1:31:29Mohnish Pabrai?

  And so he went back and he's a, you know, very meek, timid guy. He said, wow, this is like, like, they might actually like, you know, kill me or something. So he said, I'm not going back. But to get back at them, he wrote a book called Beat the Dealer. Which sold millions of copies, which basically says, here's how you beat the casinos. Okay. And the casinos freaked out because they said, now we've got like 10,000 head tops are coming at us. And so Blackjack became a game from then till now, which where the rules have continuously changed. Where they started not playing to the end of the shoe, they introduced multiple, multiple decks and all these different. And all the different, you know, rule changes and everything else to keep up with all of that.

• 1:32:13Mohnish Pabrai?

  And it's been a kind of, and you know, the movie 21, where the, the MIT kids went in with all of that. So anyway, he did well, he, he, he wrote Beat the Dealer. And then he realized that there was a better casino than Vegas, which was the New York Stock Exchange. And there's something known as the Black Scholes formula. Okay. Which is the way how options are priced. So the guys who came up with the Black Scholes and another guy, they got the Nobel Prize for that. Basically, it, it tells you, if you've got a stock with whatever volatility, how to price the options, the call options, whatever else, else on that. Ed Thorp cracked how options were priced before Black Scholes.

• 1:32:58Mohnish Pabrai?

  But decided instead of getting a Nobel Prize, he was going to make money off it. Okay. So he's. Good choice. He, he set up a entity called Princeton Newport Partners. And they killed it, like 25, 30% a year and no down years and any of that. And did that for a while, became very wealthy. He moved to Newport Beach, became a professor at UCI. And then someone introduced him, just think about, this is like a Forrest Gump story. Someone introduces him to Ken Griffin, you know, Citigroup founder. Whilst, while he's at Harvard, you know, training out of his dorm room. Ken asked, because Ed was not using his, all his algorithms and everything else, he'd retired. Ken asked if he would give it to.

• 1:33:44Mohnish Pabrai?

  To him, Ed talked to Ken, realized he's very unusual and said, you can have it all and I want to invest with you. And so he becomes one of the early investors in Citadel. So that engine just keeps going.

• 1:33:57Shaan Puri?

  Oh, my God.

• 1:33:58Mohnish Pabrai?

  And then also, uh, he meets Buffett for Bridge, I think in the seventies. And realized this is the guy and he puts a bunch of money with him. So, you know, he's invested with Ken Griffin, with Warren Buffett, with himself, Princeton Newport Partners, and the casino, all of the above, right?

• 1:34:15Shaan Puri?

  Legend.

• 1:34:15Mohnish Pabrai?

  Now, I'm in, I'm in Irvine, California. I'm at this club where I go play racquetball. And I'm getting ready for my racquetball game. So as I'm getting ready, I'm naked. And this guy is older guy is looking at me and there's a Wall Street Journal next to my, and he says to me, what do you do? I said, oh, I'm, I run a hedge fund, right? And he starts talking to me and I forget that I'm naked. Okay. And then he says, I'm Ed Thorp. And I get so excited. I said, oh, my God, Ed Thorp. And I go up to him and I'm talking. And then I realized, Mohnish, you're naked. You know, this is not appropriate. So I said, Ed, can we just meet for lunch? You know, I said, I, I, I promise you, I won't show up this way. Okay.

• 1:34:55Mohnish Pabrai?

  And he said, absolutely. Right. And so then I met him for lunch and got to know him. In fact, I just got a Christmas card for him and he wrote me a nice note. Uh, but Ed is fantastic. I think that's a great guy. And you know, he's, I think, ninety, great health. And you should get him on the podcast.

• 1:35:10Shaan Puri?

  He also beat roulette too, did he not?

• 1:35:12Mohnish Pabrai?

  Oh, yeah. He had a, he had a device by which they could, uh, I forget, there, there's something where they wore.

• 1:35:19Shaan Puri?

  Shoe or something.

• 1:35:20Mohnish Pabrai?

  Yeah, yeah. There's something they wore which would kind of tell them what is going on with roulette and all that.

• 1:35:24Shaan Puri?

  I mean, that is an unbelievable story. You mentioned Ken Griffin. I've heard some of the kind of Ken Griffin lore. What do you know about him and what kind of made him special and why maybe Ed initially spotted that this guy might be a little bit different?

• 1:35:36Mohnish Pabrai?

  So I met Ken around two thousand or so. I was running an IT company and, um, someone I knew said that they were looking for consultants. And my wife went in as a consultant to Citadel. Okay. So she's actually at Citadel. Uh, Ken is like, there might be like ten people at Citadel that time. And she'd come home every evening with a whole bunch of Ken stories. Like, she said, she'd tell me, this guy is very unusual and the place is very unusual. Everything is very unusual. So he, he had hired some whiz bang Russian mathematician, PhD, postdoc, whatever, who's working with the algorithms.

• 1:36:20Mohnish Pabrai?

  And everyone at Citadel would come to this Russian guy with their problems. And Ken didn't want anyone coming to him. He just wanted him to crank without anyone bothering him. So my wife told me that there's a temp that was hired. And Ken told the temp that here's your desk, here's you, here's the mathematician. No one crosses. So the temp says, oh, what do I do? Nothing. Your whole job is to make sure no one crosses, no one talks to him. So she's just looking at this temp and the temp herself is in shock. Someone's paying me to like, you know, file my nails. So yeah, Ken is a very intense guy. But I think, I think he's very smart.

• 1:37:01Mohnish Pabrai?

  I think he found all the different nooks and crannies, built a tremendous business. And so I have a lot of respect for him. Awesome. Did a great job.

• 1:37:10Shaan Puri?

  Yeah, I, I feel like Ken Griffin, uh, intensity stories is something that, that I can binge on. I've heard, you know, when Enron was going out of business, did you hear the story?

• 1:37:19Mohnish Pabrai?

  Yeah, they all went in and they bought all, got all the traders.

• 1:37:21Shaan Puri?

  Got all the smart guys out?

• 1:37:22Mohnish Pabrai?

  Yeah.

• 1:37:23Shaan Puri?

  Like a rescue mission?

• 1:37:24Mohnish Pabrai?

  I just read the other day that they had made an offer to some guy at Harvard or whatever, some new grad. And Ken asked him, so let's say you made 10 million a year, what would you do? He said, oh, I'd quit, I'd go prime the tallest peaks, this and that, whatever. So Ken says to him, please reject our job offer. You know, we've already made the offer for you. We can rescind it, but please don't accept it because we really don't want someone like you.

• 1:37:47Shaan Puri?

  Right.

• 1:37:48Mohnish Pabrai?

  We, we, we don't want someone at 10 million who dies at 25.

• 1:37:54Shaan Puri?

  Right. You know, you've done podcasts like these before with me and then others. I think our podcast together, more than five million people have listened. However, the sad part of that is I bet if I talk to those five million and I say, what'd you really take away? What'd you remember? What was the thing that you took? I'm not sure how many would have something that clicks. And so I want to make it easy for them this time. What's the thing that they can't miss out of this one? Because I don't want people to just listen, be entertained and go back to doing things exactly how the way they were.

• 1:38:21Mohnish Pabrai?

  Lead an aligned life. So who we are is hardcoded at the age of five. So between our genetics and what happens till in the first five years. How old are your kids?

• 1:38:33Shaan Puri?

  I have a six-year-old, five-year-old and a two-year-old.

• 1:38:35Mohnish Pabrai?

  Okay, so you've got some work you can do for the two-year-old, but the six and five-year-old, the cake is already baked. Okay. And especially after they're about 12, after they're 12, the only thing you can do for them is control who their peers are. What happens with us humans is we show up in this world without an owner's manual. Okay. We don't know what our calling is. The calling is predetermined at the age of five. If we don't follow that calling, this is our inner map and this is how we are externally. We are misaligned. And to have a great life, it needs to be like this. Now, to get from here to here means you have to understand who you are.

• 1:39:18Mohnish Pabrai?

  And there are clues to understanding who you are. So what you have to do is whenever you do any activity, you have to ask yourself, how much did I like that? And when you meet someone, how much did I like meeting that person? And so you have to try to get to the point where the glove fits. So you may be a lawyer, but you were meant to be an artist. Or you may be a musician, but you're meant to be a running back. Okay, so I mean, I found it out by going through these industrial psychologists who we did all this work with and all that. And, you know, I was able to get to what my calling is when I was 34 or 35 years old. Till then, I was wandering the wilderness, completely lost. Right? And then life became a lot better.

• 1:40:03Mohnish Pabrai?

  Getting to an aligned life is the most important thing. It's not being a great investor or, you know, finding great investments or any of that. I think the thing is you have to get your music out and you have to understand what that music is and you have to live in an aligned life. And it's worth the pursuit, however painful it may be. To understand that as early as you can in life. The shortcut is you could go through a psychological test with a psychiatrist.

• 1:40:33Shaan Puri?

  What do you ask them for? What are you asking them to do? Is there a name for this? It's just.

• 1:40:37Mohnish Pabrai?

  You're gonna tell them that I want to understand who I am and what is my calling in life? What am I supposed to be doing? Now, you could go to my guy, you can go to him.

• 1:40:46Shaan Puri?

  Yeah, who's your guy?

• 1:40:46Mohnish Pabrai?

  Uh, his name is Jack Skeen.

• 1:40:49Shaan Puri?

  I've met, I've met Jack.

• 1:40:50Mohnish Pabrai?

  Okay.

• 1:40:51Shaan Puri?

  Yeah.

• 1:40:51Mohnish Pabrai?

  All right.

• 1:40:51Shaan Puri?

  Yeah, he does the kind of full life three sixty sort of analysis.

• 1:40:54Mohnish Pabrai?

  Yeah, so, so you can go to Jack and Jack can only do like twenty a year or something. Okay, so he can't do it at scale, but he may know others.

• 1:41:03Shaan Puri?

  Right.

• 1:41:04Mohnish Pabrai?

  And so that's a pretty foolproof way to get there. Other than that, I think you have to feel your way. If you don't not willing to do that, then you have to look at what you like, what you don't like. You have to look at whether doing something energizes you or doesn't energize you, that sort of thing, right? And so you have to find what you love doing. And if you only do what you love doing, you'll do it very well.

• 1:41:26Shaan Puri?

  And why do you think most people don't do that?

• 1:41:28Mohnish Pabrai?

  It's because the world tells us what we are supposed to do. And we think that what the world tells us what we're supposed to do is what we're actually supposed to do. For example, the human brain is set up optimally to start specializing after the age of eleven. And from the age of eleven to twenty is a window to specialize. That is the exact window when the education system makes you a jack of all trades. So like Michelangelo, you know, he was doing his sculptures and paintings and all that, ten, eleven. Buffett picking stocks.

• 1:42:01Shaan Puri?

  Right.

• 1:42:01Mohnish Pabrai?

  Uh, Gates coding at eleven or twelve, right? So you have to try to, within the context of a world that wants to be a jack of all trades, start getting to what is your calling, like the way Buffett and Gates did it. They were in a world of jack of all trades. But within that world, Gates spent an inordinate amount of time doing coding. He would slip out of his parents' home at night and code all night and come back and sleep and whatever. And so he got ten, twenty thousand hours of coding experience by the time he was in his early twenties.

• 1:42:33Shaan Puri?

  Right.

• 1:42:33Mohnish Pabrai?

  And nobody could touch him after that. So, yes, we have to, at that age, that's your job as a parent. Make sure the kids at eleven or twelve, you're trying to figure out what they're good at and trying to increase the time. That they get for that.

• 1:42:46Shaan Puri?

  Well, I don't know what my calling is just yet. Actually, if I look back at that age, I was doing something very similar to this. The two things I really loved to do back at that time was I loved to play any kind of game where there was a score. I was playing online poker at a very young age, things that related to business and money. And then the other was I was doing improv all the time. I loved it. What's a podcast but an improv session? I just did this for whatever, three hours and it was no problem, right? And could have known that signal at a younger age.

• 1:43:16Mohnish Pabrai?

  I think if you're not there, you're damn close.

• 1:43:19Shaan Puri?

  Yeah. I want to leave you with one thing. I have a gift for you in this envelope. I want you to take a look. We asked somebody who knows you well to write a letter and it's your friend Guy Spear.

• 1:43:30Mohnish Pabrai?

  Oh, wow.

• 1:43:31Shaan Puri?

  And Guy wrote this letter for you. He knew you were here today.

• 1:43:34Mohnish Pabrai?

  All right. So let me just start reading it because I really like to read it later at leisure, but that's so that's awesome. So the title is what I did not learn at HBS. Mohnish Prabhar taught me everything I need needed to succeed in business. Dear Mohnish, this is one. Dear Mohnish, I met you some years after my MBA. But the truth was despite the degree, I knew next to nothing about business. My real education didn't begin until we met for dinner at the restaurant at the Delamar Hotel in Greenwich, Connecticut. I remember that evening vividly. I came away from that one dinner with more ideas than I had in two years at Harvard, books I'd never heard of and ideas I'd never thought of. You introduced me to Power vs. Force by David Hawkins and to Gandhi's autobiography,

• 1:44:19Mohnish Pabrai?

  The Story of My Experiments with Truth. We discussed Robert Cialdini's influence, the psychology of persuasion, but what struck me was that you had not merely read about his ideas, you had put them into practice in your own life in a way that I did not even know was possible. Sitting opposite you, I realized that I was a conventional thinker. You, on the other hand, had a very unusual mind, someone who knew how to get things done in the real world and translate ideas into action. I myself was very misaligned at the time. I'm deeply grateful that you were willing to become my friend. That allowed me over time to untangle some of the misaligned elements

• 1:45:03Mohnish Pabrai?

  in my personality.

• 1:45:05Shaan Puri?

  Alignment.

• 1:45:06Mohnish Pabrai?

  You couldn't give me a better gift. This is very special.

• 1:45:10Shaan Puri?

  Yeah.

• 1:45:10Mohnish Pabrai?

  Thank you so much.

• 1:45:11Shaan Puri?

  Well, I want to thank Guy for doing it. We called him last minute. I said, you know, who knows him better?

• 1:45:15Mohnish Pabrai?

  Excellent.

• 1:45:15Shaan Puri?

  Mohnish, thanks for doing this.

• 1:45:16Mohnish Pabrai?

  Okay, awesome.

• 1:45:27Shaan Puri?

  Hey, let's take a quick break. I want to tell you about a podcast that you could check out. It is called The Science of Scaling by Marc Robert. He was the founding CRO of HubSpot and he's a guest lecturer at Harvard Business School. The guy's smart and he sits down every week with different sales leaders from cool companies like Klaviyo and Vanta and OpenAI. And he's asking about their strategies, their tactics and how they're growing their companies as, you know, head of sales or chief revenue officer. If you're looking to scale a company up, if you're a CRO or a head of sales that's looking to level up in your career, I think a podcast like this could be great for you. Listen to The Science of Scaling wherever you get your podcasts.