Pod Insights Motley Fool Hidden Gems Investing What’s Cooking at Toast About this episode … and why the stock is “nowhere near fully valued.” (00:21) Tim Beyers and Mary Long break down earnings from Toast, the restaurant tech company, and discuss Microsoft’s latest development in quantum computing. Then, (18:00), Kirsten Guerra joins Mary to check in on Roblox, how it stacks up against other gaming companies, and why the platform’s young user base concerns some investors. Companies discussed: TOST, MSFT, RBLX, META, SNAP Host: Mary Long Guests: Tim Beyers, Kirsten Guerra Producer: Ricky Mulvey Engineers: Dan Boyd, Rick Engdahl Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 This episode is brought to you by Indeed. You're ready to level up your business, but the pressure to find the right person to make that happen is intense. Indeed sponsored jobs can help carry the load. It boosts your job post to help it reach quality talent fast. Cut through the chaos with Indeed sponsored jobs. Get a $75 sponsored job credit at indeed.com/podcast. Terms and conditions apply. Hiring now? Then this is a job for Indeed sponsored jobs.
0:35 Speaker 01 A new state of matter has entered the chat. You're listening to Motley Fool Money.
0:50 Speaker 01 I'm Mary Long, joined on this early Denver morning by Mr. Tim Byers. Tim, thanks for being here. How's the caffeine treating you this morning?
0:58 Speaker 02 Oh, I haven't had any yet. I'm going into the coworking space, so I'm ready to go, but I am non-caffeinated. So you are listening at your own risk.
1:08 Speaker 01 This is Tim Beyers at the beginning of the day. I feel like that's a treat. We might get some especially hot takes in the pre-caffeine version of you.
1:16 Speaker 02 Maybe.
1:17 Speaker 01 To set us up for hot take potential, we'll kick things off with Toast. Tim, there are certain stocks that I love to talk to certain analysts about, and knowing that Toast reported yesterday, I was amped to get to talk to you about the company today because I know that it's one of your highest conviction positions.
1:33 Speaker 02 Yeah, still my highest conviction. Not one of highest.
1:36 Speaker 01 Indeed.
1:37 Speaker 02 Yeah.
1:38 Speaker 01 So we'll start there. For folks who are listening, who are maybe less familiar with your love of Toast and perhaps the stock in general, you talk a lot about migraine level problems. What migraine level problem is Toast trying to solve?
1:50 Speaker 02 So if you're a restaurateur and you have multiple locations, so let's say you have a few bistros, let's say three to four, up to, say, 20, and you need, because this is the truth about restaurants, there's a lot of moving parts. You are ordering inventory, you are managing a staff, that staff generally has higher than average turnover, you have a menu that is going to be changing on a relatively frequent basis, you have delivery portions that are, you know... All of this, all of these moving parts do require some systems and there are lots of systems that need to talk to each other. So if you're a restaurant operator, you can
2:33 Speaker 02 either build that yourself, hire somebody to build it for you, or you can outsource that operation completely. In other words, all of these systems need to be in place. So either the point of integration is you as the restaurant operator and you just want to sell food. You want to sell really good food, or you get somebody to do it for you. Now, you can hire consulting firm to do that, but Toast is a provider that does all of that. So they take that thing that a restaurant operator knows they must do, especially if you have a small restaurant group, and takes that pain away from them and charges them
3:14 Speaker 02 a fee for it that turns out to be pretty reasonable. And there's a lot of restaurateurs, I know we talked about this in the pre-show notes, Mary, where you do have testimonials that Toast posts from time to time where they say, "I make more money with this thing because I turn over tables faster. I just don't have to deal with the infrastructure that I would otherwise have to deal with." And that is a heck of a selling proposition.
3:40 Speaker 01 Yeah, that selling proposition seems to be turning out pretty well for Toast. They were GAAP profitable for the first time in the history of the business for the full year, brought in $19 million in net income. They were also able to reach that milestone while adding about 28,000 net new locations. Those are some stats that jumped out to me, but what about you, Tim? What's your headline from Toast's latest earnings?
4:02 Speaker 02 Strong and steady wins the race here. I mean, they are just continuing to go, and notice I didn't say slow and steady because they're not slow. They still grow, you know, they still grew 29% year over year, but these are fairly strong numbers. So just to give you a sense of it, overall revenue up 29.15%, subscription revenue up almost 41%, which is really nice. Subscription gross margin up to 70%, which is about in line with where they've been in recent And quarters fintech revenue, which is they get a take off of the amount of business done in in a restaurant. So, you know, they process payments, they get a little cut of those payments.
4:43 Speaker 02 The more payments there are, the more money they make. That was up 28% year over year. Their gross profit, and this is up 35% year over year. So, I mean, really quite good here, Mary. The other thing is they have what they call a core profitability margin. I track it in my spreadsheet and I show it now as 29.37%. That is up from last year where it was 10.7%. And it's it's been around that 30% mark in in recent quarters. They have said in years past that they could get somewhere on an ongoing basis to between 30% and 35% at that level, you know, of core profitability margin.
5:26 Speaker 02 It's the the sum of the adjusted EBITDA divided by the sum of subscription gross profit and fintech gross profit. Just think about it as the the unencumbered money flowing through restaurants that Toast is helps, you know, execute either that fintech revenue or the subscription that the restaurant pays. But otherwise, I would say the two things that really drive value here are the revenue per restaurant, which has been relatively stable. It's about 40,000 per restaurant location, roughly been that for a few quarters now. But the restaurant locations are expanding.
6:06 Speaker 02 It was up 26% year over year, another 7,000 net new ads, you know, this past quarter, Mary. So as long as that continues to be true, if Toast is in more places and they either hold steady or slightly like rate of inflation increase, the amount they get per location, I mean, the stock is not anywhere near fairly valued if that continues to be true over a long period of time.
6:34 Speaker 01 So everything you're saying to me sounds not just pretty good, but pretty awesome. Like, again, I understand why this is your highest conviction stock. And yet, after these earnings came out yesterday in aftermarket trading, the stock was down a little bit slightly this morning. Again, we're recording this pretty early, but the stock was pretty steady. What did Wall Street love about this?
6:56 Speaker 02 They didn't like the earnings per share. They didn't like the... I mean, it seems as though, I'm not entirely clear if the outlook was disappointing, but the certain... certainly the earnings per share number was disappointing, Mary. They came in at roughly six cents a share in earnings for the most recent quarter, and the estimate was for 17 cents. So that's a big miss. I don't get too hot and bothered about per-share numbers because share counts change wildly, you know, particularly with growth companies. And so it's really difficult, you know, when you are predicting a per-share number, not only are you attempting to predict the top-line growth, like, what is the growth in the net
7:37 Speaker 02 income, you are trying to predict the growth in that net income divided by some guess about the number of shares that will be there at that particular point in time. And, you know, if the company hires a bunch of people, issues a bunch of equity, the diluted shares outstanding can spike. And so, you know, that EPS number can go down. And, to be fair, Toast does issue equity. They do try and hire, in particular, serious engineering talent. They are in a hiring, you know, period right now. So I'm not too surprised that the EPS number didn't meet the expectation. I just don't place a lot of faith when it comes
8:20 Speaker 02 to forecasts missed or exceeded in per-share numbers. I'd be more concerned if, like...
8:29 Speaker 02 Like this kind of reaction or something worse than this kind of reaction. It's just down about 4% this morning would be way more understandable. If like the locations came in really short, so like they'd been getting at least, you know, 6,000 net new locations every quarter, Mary. If suddenly it went down to like 3,000, you'd be like, okay, wait a minute. What's going on here? That would be a serious cause for concern. This doesn't feel like a serious cause for concern.
9:02 Speaker 01 I took a little gander on the Toast website ahead of us recording this. And there's a testimonial displayed about midway down one of the pages that quotes Wayne Carrington, who's the owner of Rock and Ramen in New Rochelle, New York. And he is singing Toast praises and saying with Toast, the average check size is up 15%. That's another $120,000 a year when we're at full capacity. This stuck out to me because, you know, as you're describing the migraine level problems that Toast addresses for restaurateurs. A lot of those strike me as addressing and improving efficiencies on the backend. But this testimonial seems to suggest that, okay, it's not just stuff on the backend that Toast can help restaurants improve. They can also lead to higher checks at the front of the house.
9:46 Speaker 02 Sure.
9:46 Speaker 01 How exactly does Toast do that?
9:48 Speaker 02 Well, they do that with the point of sale system. We missed you yesterday. We were downtown. Ricky was there though, and, and we were at a coworking space. And they have a bunch of restaurants downstairs where this coworking space is. So I went to one, got myself a sandwich. I mean, it was pretty good. I'm not sure the French dip was worth $17, but that's a totally different thing. I mean, I, so yes, I paid $17 for a French dip sandwich, but it was decent, right? It was decent. The point of sale system was a very large, it wasn't even an iPad. It was like a screen. It was almost like, you know, an external laptop screen. And it was just swiveled out facing me. And it was just a, you know, a point of sale system. And it said right down there in the bottom, powered by Toast.
10:34 Speaker 02 And where you get those new and improved check sizes from, Mary, is in those point of sale systems, Toast allows you to customize and say, hey, highlight the stuff that you want to sell.
10:47 Speaker 02 And so, you know, what's the first thing that I see on that point of sale system? The stuff that they want to sell, the specials. And then if I want to get to the thing that I want to get to, well, then I'm going to scroll through the screen and it absolutely allows me to do that. And I did that to get to the French dip sandwich. But what it wants, what, you know, right there, that is super valuable real estate. And Toast is letting that restaurant operator say like, yeah, sell the stuff that's going to make you the most money. And that's how you get better check sizes. So yeah, it does solve that problem via a very well constructed, clean point of sale system.
11:29 Speaker 02 That's just one part of a full ecosystem that they provide restaurant operators.
11:33 Speaker 01 We're going to move on to another story. Yesterday, the Wall Street Journal reported that Microsoft researchers claimed to have created a chip that leverages, wait for it, a new state of matter that would serve as the foundation for quantum computing. New state of matter really caught my attention. What is that new state of matter?
11:51 Speaker 02 Yeah, it sounds very Star Trek, doesn't it?
11:52 Speaker 01 It does. It sounds, I'm like, this has got to be the big story. This new state of matter is called a topological superconductor. It's a material that's not a solid, not a liquid, not a gas. Again, this, that sounds like the really big deal to me. But how material is this news for Microsoft's future business?
12:11 Speaker 02 Well, it isn't yet. I mean, we've, you know, you've, you actually have to make something that is commercially viable before it becomes material. But as a matter of, of material science, it is potentially very significant. Quantum computing is, is really hard because you are, you are essentially, a, a quantum state is somewhere between a zero and one. In a binary computer system, you know, a silicon based, you know, binary computer system, you have ones and you have zeros. And a combination of ones and zeros is what gets you code. And that's, that's how you program a computer system. In a quantum system.
12:55 Speaker 02 Your superposition is between, you know, sometimes we say it's zero and one at the same time. It's not entirely accurate. It's somewhere between zero and one. So it's a, it's, it's a superposition system. You know, you have a multi-dimensional option where you can almost think of it as a spherical and then all particles, everything else, moving inside that sphere all of the time. So the superposition is really hard to determine and because everything is moving, you have like a bunch of hyperactive kids running around a playground and you can't pin anything down. And so why is it hard to, you know, to actual quantum computing?
13:35 Speaker 02 Because you can't pin anything down, which is why you have to do quantum computing at, you know, very close to absolute zero temperatures. You have to freeze it down to nothing. So you take these particles that are constantly on the move and just like, you know, come on kid, cool it. You know, slow down for God's sake. You know, that's what you're doing. You're slowing them down. And so this topological superconducting technology, as it were, has something that, and I, you know, I am sure that we have engineers who know
14:16 Speaker 02 this way better than I am. So I am apologizing upfront for getting this wrong and we would love for you to write in and correct me for where I have this wrong. But my understanding here, Mary, is that we have this idea in a topological superconductor called a, a Majorana-bound state. So M A J O R A N A, Majorana. And so the idea of a bound state, particularly on the edges of a, of a system, they're essentially a quasi-particle and they can be If I'm understanding it correctly, they're located at the edges or boundaries of the
15:00 Speaker 02 material and they add some amount of predictability into the system. So in a very unpredictable, very hyperactive system that has to be cooled to the, you know, to the point of absolute zero in order to generate some amount of predictability and slow movement. So we can, you know, essentially put boundaries around particles to create a predictable superposition. The idea of these bounded, bounded areas, creating a little more predictability seems to me to make quantum computing more viable. Now, I am not a material scientist,
15:43 Speaker 02 so I may have that totally wrong. But I think that's the exciting part about this is it does appear that this system as presented could be more predictable. And predictability in a quantum system is really tough. It's really tough to do that. But the more predictable it is, given the amount of variables that can be processed in a quantum system, that's the, that's the advantage of a quantum system. You have a binary system can, you know, think of it this way, it can compute like X variables. A quantum system, because it has so much more surface area, so many more variables, that is X to the 10th power or whatever. So my
16:27 Speaker 02 ability to compute a whole bunch more variables goes up logarithmically in, in a quantum system. So if I make that system more stable, more predictable through something like a topological superconductor, that's winning. And this is winning in so many ways. You can understand why Microsoft and Alphabet want to do this because who are the two companies, along with Amazon and Nvidia and others, that want to win the AI race? That would be Microsoft and Alphabet. And in order to win, you know, compute power is a big deal.
17:06 Speaker 02 And so quantum computers are a potential, AI is a potential catalyst for quantum research. So it's not too surprising to see this, but I would not get excited about this being commercially viable soon. I think it's going to take a while.
17:24 Speaker 01 Potentially very exciting development, but yeah, still very, very early days in the technology, probably a bit too soon to make a real move on it. Tim, I'm going to double down on your offer to our material scientists and engineering minded listeners. If you've got some input on Tim's description of how exactly this Majerana chip could work, you can write to us at [email protected] . Tim, thanks so much for taking a look at Toast and for kind of giving a morning explainer of quantum computing and the potentials there and doing that before having any caffeine for the day.
18:00 Speaker 02 I know. Like I said, listen at your own risk.
18:10 Speaker 03 Your trading questions don't always pop up during market hours. That's why Schwab offers 24/7 support from real people with deep trading expertise. That means you can talk through platform tools, work through decisions and pressure test your thinking no matter the hour, because sometimes real traders need more than a password reset. They need a second set of eyes to help work through strategies. Learn more at schwab.com/trading.
18:43 Speaker 01 For better or worse, Roblox is known for having a young user base, but it is making real strides in aging up that demographic. Up next, Fool analyst Kirsten Guerra joins me to check in on the gaming company.
18:59 Speaker 01 Kirsten, this recording that we're doing right now, it's not going to air for a couple of days, but the viewer should know, we are recording this on Valentine's Day. We're talking Roblox today, and I know you love Roblox. So I thought maybe you could kick us off with sharing, getting a little vulnerable, perhaps, sharing any romantic words about this company to kick us off, snippets from a love letter, a romantic haiku, perhaps? Anything you got for us?
19:23 Speaker 04 I'm not in love with Roblox, Mary, no. But my portfolio loves the flow. The gains keep growing from abi to abi. So thank you for this massively multiplayer UGC platform, Bobby. The CEO's name is Dave, but that didn't rhyme, so that's what you get.
19:41 Speaker 01 I was gonna say, for anyone listening who might be wondering, what in the world did I just tune into? Well, we'll zoom out a bit. We're talking Roblox today, checking in on this gaming company. Kirsten, for those who are maybe less familiar with the platform, know that this is a gaming company. Help us understand how this is different from other gaming companies, whether that's Microsoft, Activision, Nintendo, et cetera.
20:01 Speaker 04 Yeah, well, all the other names that you mentioned, they own, develop, and kind of produce their own games. Microsoft and Nintendo actually have the extra layer than of the fact that they create consoles that many people play on, Microsoft Xbox and Nintendo Switch. Roblox does not sell a console. Instead, you can access Roblox from across any console, PC, mobile, even VR headsets. It is cross-platform. It does not sell hardware, nor does it even create its own games. Roblox has millions of games, or what they like to call experiences, on their platform, but they are not designed by Roblox. Instead, Roblox hosts and provides the developer tools for users to create games on Roblox. And so if you think about this,
20:46 Speaker 04 maybe in the context of movies, and Activision might be more like the Universal Pictures. They both create and distribute their own content. Roblox is far closer to maybe a YouTube, the centralized platform where creators go to distribute and monetize their own content and creations. And so YouTube, like Roblox, just takes a cut of all the spend that happens on the platform in exchange for the hosting, distribution, and those developer tools.
21:14 Speaker 01 Roblox posted their fiscal 2024 results earlier this month, earlier in February. These numbers all looked pretty healthy to me. I'll give an overview of what I'm talking about. You've got fourth quarter revenue up 32% year-over-year. Full year revenue also up about 29%, 30%. Bookings, which is kind of the more telling topline indicator here that investors like to hone in on, that was up 21% for the quarter, 24% for the year. Daily active users, hours engaged, both of those metrics up about 20% for the fourth quarter, slightly more when you look at the full year. Free cash flow up 417% for the year. Those all sound pretty good to me, Kirsten, but you are the analyst. Any notes on Roblox's performance for the fourth quarter and really for the full past year? How have they been doing recently?
22:00 Speaker 04 I mean, what am I supposed to say, Mary? You took all the good numbers. You're right, a lot of what looks like strong numbers reported this quarter, but it's all about perspective. And so digging in deeper specifically to the daily active users there, as you said, up 19% year-over-year, sounds good. But sequentially, meaning from Q3 to Q4, daily active users actually fell. And that's not the first time that that's happened for Roblox, to be sure. But Q4 is typically a strong quarter of user growth, given all the gift card gifting that drums up new users around the holidays. But this time, a 4% or so drop from nearly 89 million daily active users to 85.
22:42 Speaker 04 And Roblox points to Turkey here, which completely banned the platform for all of Q4. That certainly would have contributed to user drop, but I'm not sure it's the complete story. Overall, though, what we have right now, I would say, is a single data point. So this could be the start of a downward trend, which would certainly be problematic for a stock like this with high expectations that are built in. But it could just as easily be kind of a nothing burger, quick dip before a return to growth, steady growth on the daily active users, more like what we've seen so far. So for now, not enough to call this a trend, but definitely something I will be watching for next quarter.
23:22 Speaker 01 I pull out those good numbers, but I turn to you to give us the context to make those numbers make sense. We'll say, I'm not just good at pulling out good numbers. Something that sticks out to me with Roblox in particular is that they are spending more on stock-based compensation than they're making in operating cash flow. That doesn't seem like a good number to me. We'll flip the question here. Is that a red flag to you, a yellow flag? What do you make of that, that setup?
23:44 Speaker 04 Yeah, stock-based comp has always been at least a yellow flag for this company. It's excessive. You called out before a huge jump in free cash flow this year. And so, yes, I appreciate your positivity. Let us take a moment to appreciate that because in part, what happened there was that Roblox has put up a lot of capital expenditure over the past couple of years, building out Roblox Cloud to support all of this real-time immersive 3D interaction. And as they did that, they kept insisting that once some of this build out on our data centers creates redundancy, then future spend will be less and we'll see free cash flow rise as that capex kind of tapers off. So let's give them some credit
24:24 Speaker 04 here. True to their word, we are seeing exactly that play out. However, another contributor to that free cash flow rise is the increased stock-based comp that you pointed to. And so that's essentially a non-cash way that Roblox rewards its employees. And it's a great tool to have when you are an unprofitable, rapidly growing company as Roblox is. But issuing those shares also dilutes shareholders and it's always been a question mark for Roblox, but the dilution has gotten worse. It has grown to 4.4% dilution, kind of compounded annually over the last three years. Ideally, I'd rather see that below 3%.
25:04 Speaker 01 Roblox has a reputation for catering primarily to a younger audience. What is it about the platform that is so appealing to young kids in particular?
25:15 Speaker 04 I mean, thinking about this, when I was a kid, I would spend hours staring into a big, ugly monitor, typing out plain text messages to my friends on AOL Instant Messenger. Why did that appeal to me? But kids are very social, and naturally, they gravitate toward free-to-use, easily accessible, social environments, increasingly digital. And that is Roblox. It's just the most immersive one we've seen yet.
25:43 Speaker 01 Despite having this reputation for having an audience of primarily young people, I'll point out, and management really would like me to point out, that over 61% of Roblox's daily active users are over 13, and that that cohort is growing. How exactly is Roblox attempting to age up its user base?
26:02 Speaker 04 I'm sure Dave would send his thank you for pointing that out. Yeah, that's usually, that's how social networks grow, right? Young people tend to grasp it first. Facebook started with college students, then users nucleate from there. So the 23-year-olds learn about it from the 20-year-olds in their circles, then the 25-year-olds learn about it from the 23-year-olds. Now, my 80-year-old grandma has been on Facebook for many years. So it's partly that, this kind of natural user nucleation process that just takes time. But also, in Roblox's case specifically, it's about encouraging games or experiences that feel appropriate for those older audiences. So for one, Roblox is encouraging development of specific genres in their games,
26:45 Speaker 04 sports, racing, action, and battle royale especially. Then the other big thing is improving the discoverability algorithm. So, you know, when a 34-year-old woman logs into Roblox to see what it's all about, the homepage should not present her with the same games that are popular with 12-year-olds, right? Or she'll probably churn from the platform. So as those mature games come online, Roblox is doing a lot to make sure that users are first presented with content that will keep them engaged and keep them on the platform.
27:16 Speaker 01 Last fall, in October of 2024, Hindenburg Research, a notorious short seller that has now closed up shop, they published a report about child safety concerns at Roblox. There were other allegations in this report, predominantly like inflated numbers, that we'll touch on in a minute, but for now, I want to focus on that child safety piece. These are serious concerns and are very legitimate, but my question is that that's a legitimate concern anywhere on the internet? Why does this seem to be a bigger concern in regards to Roblox than it does for Snapchat, or Instagram, or YouTube?
27:51 Speaker 04 It is a concern everywhere. As you said, we all want children to be safe on all platforms. Roblox, as I mentioned earlier, is the most immersive social environment we've ever seen that's easily accessible to kids, second really only to the real world. And so a lot of social platforms, like you mentioned, have transformed from more of a town hall feel when they started to a living room model. That's how Mark Zuckerberg puts it. A lot of those platforms are now built to center connection with close friends and people you know. Roblox also tries to connect you with friends, but when you drop into some random experience in Roblox, you're almost certainly going to be interacting with a
28:29 Speaker 04 lot of randos as well. And so in 2024, Roblox spent 915 million on infrastructure, trust, and safety. It's also the founding partner of Roost, which stands for robust, open, online safety tools. It has open sourced a lot of the AI-based tools that it has developed for things like detection of policy violations that happen both in text, in chat between users, and also via voice. So I think Roblox knows the risk of getting this wrong, and therefore takes it very seriously.
29:00 Speaker 01 The other piece of that Hindenburg report is the suggestion that Roblox had inflated metrics, particularly user numbers and time spent on the platform. Roblox totally rejected the claims of that report. How seriously do or did you take those Hindenburg allegations when they came out? And now, after Hindenburg has closed up shop?
29:19 Speaker 04 Yeah, with short reports, it always depends on the outlet. But Hindenburg did have some credibility in general. I wouldn't associate, by the way, their closing shop with this report. That doesn't change anything too much in my mind. Regardless, it's tough because any short report writer is third party to the company they're talking about. Like unless you're talking a whistleblower, which comes from inside the company, which was not the case here, then it's just a group of people on the outside trying to understand and pick apart how the company is measuring things internally. And so I won't say on record that I know Hindenburg got this wrong because I don't know that for sure. There's a chance, right? And all we can really do as outsiders and as investors is to weigh how much validity
30:01 Speaker 04 we think is there and to factor that into the risk reward equation for how much you're willing to pay for a share of the company.
30:09 Speaker 01 Kirsten Guerra, always a pleasure to talk to you about any company, but especially Roblox. Thanks so much for taking the time to come on to Motley Fool Money.
30:18 Speaker 04 Thanks for hosting my poetry, Mary.
30:20 Speaker 01 Open invite.
30:28 Speaker 01 As always, people on the program may have interests in the stocks they talk about, and The Motley Fool may have formal recommendations for or against, so don't buy or sell stocks based solely on what you hear. All personal finance content follows Motley Fool editorial standards and is not approved by advertisers. The Motley Fool only picks products that it would personally recommend to friends like you. For Tim Beyers and Kirsten Guerra, I'm Mary Long. Thanks for listening. We'll see you tomorrow.
Previous The Infrastructure Behind the AI Revolution Next Walmart, Etsy Face Tighter Wallets Page updated November 16, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated