Pod Insights Motley Fool Hidden Gems Investing David Gardner, The Case for Rational Optimism About this episode You don’t have to look far to find a lot to worry about. But, a long-term bet on negativity is a bet against history. David Gardner is a co-founder and Chief Rule Breaker at The Motley Fool. Ricky Mulvey caught up with David for a conversation about: - Why buying and holding works. - Rational optimism. - The future of space travel. Check out David’s weekly show Rule Breaker Investing at the link below, or wherever you listen to podcasts: https://www.fool.com/podcasts/rule-breaker-investing/ Companies discussed: NVDA, SPOT, AMC, META, RKLB Host: Ricky Mulvey Guest: David Gardner Producer: Mary Long Engineer: Rick Engdahl Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 This episode is brought to you by Indeed. You're ready to level up your business, but the pressure to find the right person to make that happen is intense. Indeed sponsored jobs can help carry the load. It boosts your job post to help it reach quality talent fast. Cut through the chaos with Indeed sponsored jobs. Get a $75 sponsored job credit at indeed.com/podcast. Terms and conditions apply. Hiring now? Then this is a job for Indeed sponsored jobs.
0:31 Speaker 01 There's a tendency, of course, with our new year's resolutions to get excited and to go all in, see where the market is, think about some of the exciting industries of today and think, oh yeah, I should load up and put it all in this one thing. And I hope anybody listening to us will think more about their first 20 investments and taking, let's say, $2,000 and investing it $100 each in 20 different stocks and start there and build from there.
0:58 Speaker 02 I'm Mary Long and that's David Gardner, co-founder and chief rule breaker here at The Motley Fool. He's also the host of our sibling podcast, Rule Breaker Investing. My colleague Ricky Mulvey caught up with David for a wide ranging conversation about rule breaker investing and how its principles apply not just to stock picking, but to life. They also discuss why individual investors don't have to think in one-year increments, finding companies that add real value to the world, and how to use the market as a teacher.
1:37 Speaker 03 So David, I'd like to start off the show with a little bit of storytelling as we welcome in some newer investors and people who have hopefully been listening to this show for months and even years. I've been working at The Fool for a few years now and often when I meet people who learn that I work at The Motley Fool, they'll tell me some version of this story. You know, when I just started learning about investing, I read your articles. And I've heard that from, I've heard that from journalists. I've heard that actually from a, from a CEO we had on the show. So people from all walks of life coming to The Motley Fool to learn about investing. And you know, I'm hopeful that we'll have some of those stories starting as we as we start 2025. But as you think about your experience co-founding this company and being here through
2:21 Speaker 03 the years, do you have a favorite story in particular that starts with the line, when I wanted to learn about investing, I came across The Motley Fool?
2:30 Speaker 01 Well, I'm happy to say, Ricky, 31 years in, that we have a lot of those. And I often think of them as campfire stories, and we're all around a great big campfire. And my hope for our company is that we keep reaching as many people as possible and grow the number of people at the campfire. But I will say, at the end of last year, on my podcast, it was my December 2024 mailbag, I closed with a note from somebody who, I'll summarize it, I hope anybody who's inspired will listen to the final mailbag item, because Dave Smallco's story is phenomenal. But to summarize it, Dave Smallco had never written in before. He had subscribed to The Motley Fool when it was a print newsletter in 1993. A few years before that, his dad had died young and had left $250,000 for his mother to support
3:15 Speaker 01 her in CDs. That at that time, we're paying 8% interest. And his dad's instructions, his dying father's instructions to Dave, his son, were just roll it over and keep it going and support her. And Dave, at the age of 28, was savvy enough that he had a CPA, so he was an accountant, but he had very little experience with the stock market. So he found himself spending time late night in libraries locally, reading Morning Star. And then he came across this thing called The Motley Fool. And at the age of 28, he made a decision against his dad's wishes that I know makes his dad so, so proud. Dave tells the story of taking that $250,000, realizing it's not going to pay 8% interest forever. And
4:00 Speaker 01 if we roll this over, my mom won't have anything in 10 years. So Dave allocates it 50 to this, 50 to that, it's $250,000. He puts 80 in individual stocks. And he knows enough to pick some good stocks, but it was just a third of the portfolio. One of those stocks was Microsoft. He allocated $15,000 to Microsoft. That was his 6% stake at the time. And he tells the story on the mailbag on Rule Breaker Investing a couple of weeks ago of what happened. And in so many words, what happened was that he held. He held through the Great Recession, through the dot bomb era, 2000, Great Recession 2008,
4:42 Speaker 01 through the COVID bump, up and down. And Microsoft on its own is a 500 bagger. And he was constantly told by people, especially financial professionals, to lock in those profits, to sell. And he said he always felt comfortable because it was diversified. It was a large, it was a huge stake in Microsoft. But that ended up putting three grandchildren, two great grandchildren through school, his mom, fully supported, able to travel. It is just a beautiful story of somebody who kind of, like a rule breaker, goes against the conventional wisdom. He was diversified, right? Microsoft was just a 6% stake back in the day. But if you hold a great company for a generation, this is the kind of thing
5:25 Speaker 01 that happens. And Ricky, this is one of the messages that I hope my own rule breaker style will remind us of. I don't want to make it exclusive to me at all. I think The Motley Fool has coached so many people around the campfire to hold.
5:36 Speaker 03 Well, I can give you plenty of reasons. Also, it would have been very smart to sell Microsoft throughout those years with Steve Ballmer's leadership. You have a new CEO coming in, Satya Nadella. Why don't we lock in a few, some of those gains for just a little bit, David, as we find out what this new leader is going to do? I know there are some, some fools who have been listening for, for a while, but I also want to recognize, hopefully, some, some folks listening that maybe just started a job and getting some, some disposable income that they're, they're looking to invest in the stock market. Maybe they're seeing their friends right now, making extraordinary gains on, on social media as we're back into one of those cycles. But I think a lot of the general advice is, is stayed the same. What would you say to that person who is just
6:18 Speaker 03 now getting excited about investing in the stock market with maybe 100 or an extra 200 bucks a month?
6:24 Speaker 01 Well, first of all, congratulations. I hope that 100 or 200 dollars is true savings. And that's, I think, where we always need to start, Ricky. And I know we've done this for a long time at The Motley Fool, but a lot of people are new to this. I think you have to save more than you spend. That's the hardest thing to do. Truly investing is easier than that. And so, congratulations to that person who is saving more than their Spending and I would say keep doing that every two weeks. A hundred dollars is great. Two hundred dollars is great. When we started the Motley Fool thirty years ago, you'd have to pay commissions. That would eat up a lot of that money if you tried to invest regularly. But these days, commissions, many brokerages, charge nothing for commissions. So there's no, there's no friction cost for your one hundred to two hundred dollars. I would say every two weeks.
7:09 Speaker 01 Put that money into the market, stay one hundred percent invested your whole life long. And make sure you love and believe in the investments that you're making. Funds or stocks. Hopefully for me, stocks. Dave Smallco, the story I just told. Microsoft was just one of his holdings, but if you find a great company, one or more great companies and hold on to them. As you were pointing out, Ricky, there are all kinds of reasons to sell in the near term. But if you truly are saving more than you're spending. Showing patience and dollar cost averaging on a regular basis, whether it's weekly, quarterly. Annually into the market. And invest your whole life long. I think that you will do really, really well. So I think there's a tendency, of course, with our New Year's resolutions to get excited.
7:53 Speaker 01 And to go all in, see where the market is, think about some of the exciting industries of today and think, oh yeah, I should load up and put it all in this one thing. And I hope anybody listening to us will think more about their first twenty investments. And taking, let's say, two thousand dollars and investing it a hundred dollars each in twenty different stocks and start there and build from there.
8:14 Speaker 03 I appreciate you saying not to go all in, even if you are thinking that you have the next Microsoft on your hands. It's diversification in time are the common themes of what you're saying. And very important for anyone newer listening and not so newer listening as well. We focused on some fundamentals, we had some storytelling, but there is a favorite foolish tradition. Which is sort of ragging on market forecasts. And I know this is one of your favorite topics. I got one from Goldman Sachs.
8:39 Speaker 01 Great.
8:39 Speaker 03 Headline, the S and P five hundred is expected to return ten percent in twenty twenty five. There's some very smart bankers that will tell you exactly what they think will the stock market will do this year. David, you've been doing this a long time. What do you expect the market to do in twenty twenty five?
8:54 Speaker 01 I think the
8:55 Speaker 01 Markets going up this year Ricky and that's because I think the market's going up every year and my record as a market timer predicting one year ahead each year somewhere around this time is enviable because I think most people are kind of a coin flip and I get it right two thirds of the time and that's because two thirds of the time the market rises and I think it's always worth expecting it to rise but recognizing it may not in fact one year in three the market loses value earlier you and I talked about making a whole life commitment to investing so any given year doesn't matter that much to me the Goldman Sachs example you cited they basically predicted what would be a traditional market year about a 10% gain now coming after two very good years in which the S and P 500 rose more than 20% back to back years that's a little contrary that's probably a little bit more bullish than a lot of forecasts but I think the market's going up this year I don't put a percentage on it because I don't really care that much I don't like it when the market goes down who does but I feel very confident that the real conversation is of course about the long term and be invested your whole life so that one year doesn't really matter much but I think the market's going up this year
10:04 Speaker 03 Good I hope so too I understand why the large banks like offering the I'll call it the false certainty of very specific market predictions it it makes you feel more comfortable that the market is more certain than it actually is over the short term over the long term it's been the greatest the greatest wealth generation machine ever for people that have stayed invested for for decades we see the large banks doing this offering one year market forecasts but when you think about the foolish style of investing why don't fools think in terms of those one year increments
10:39 Speaker 01 Well it's because we don't have to I mean the the beauty of being an individual investor especially if you're self-directed if you're rolling up your sleeves and doing at least some of it yourself is that you're in command when you give your money away to somebody else to manage they're in command and of course a lot of people make good decisions and they don't want to spend that much time so they put it toward index funds which the motley fools always favored and index funds are have very low costs usually and typically Mimic the market's returns. So that's a perfectly good approach. But even then, those those funds rebalance on a regular basis. So that means they they can't allow any stock to become too big or too successful. If Nvidia starts becoming a titan, they have to start selling Nvidia and put it into things that are down
11:24 Speaker 01 in order to maintain the charter of the fund, which is to remain highly diversified. And so they're having to play a quarterly or one year kind of a game. I think a great advantage to those who want to be self-directed, I think a lot of them are listening to us right now, are that you can actually make these decisions yourself. You can decide whether you want to cash in and increase your tax bill this year or not. When you're investing in managed mutual funds, you're handed a tax bill near the end of every year that you didn't have much control over. And the average managed mutual fund turns over 70 to 100% in a given year. So seven out of 10 positions in actively managed mutual funds are no longer the same by December 31st from the first day of that year. There's huge activity and turnover.
12:09 Speaker 01 And we we benefit so much as fellow fools from finding good stuff and sticking with it. So I think we don't have to think in one-year increments. It's fun to make predictions, and of course, they're quotable for Goldman Sachs and their ilk this time of year. But I guess I would I would rhetorically ask Ricky, where is the reporting at the end of that year on who said what? And who got it right and who got it wrong? And what anybody's baseball stats card looks like for their annual market predictions? We seem enamored of making them at the start of the year. Very few people are around at the end of the year holding anyone accountable with any kind of scorecard, which is why I spend so little time looking at that.
12:50 Speaker 03 Well, you mentioned friction there and the lack of friction for for selling and buying. The advantage of it being for the individual investor where you don't have to pay a salesperson commissions for buying anything, but then you mentioned the amount of turnover going on in these in these actively managed mutual funds. It's never been easier to sell as well as the flip side of it being much easier to buy. So we kind of ragged on the one year. But then what is your expectation? I'll make you, how about how about a forecast for 2044? Or 2045, if we're not thinking in one term, one-year increments? What's your expectation for the stock market then five, 10, even 20 years from now? For someone who is investing regularly?
13:32 Speaker 01 I'm pretty sure when I was asked this by somebody 20 years ago, I said about the same thing, and I hope it's about happened. 20 years is a good amount of time, first of all, Ricky, because it's a fourth or fifth of a life. It's long enough to really not be able to visualize what the world's going to look like, but it's still short enough to be meaningful and worth talking about in a way that is rational. So I would say rational expectations of a rational optimist over the next 20 years are that the stock market would return roughly 10% a year. Goldman Sachs's call for 2025, two years and three, I think I've already given you this ratio, but it's really helpful to remember at all times. Two years and three, over those 20 years, the market will go up. One year and
14:16 Speaker 01 three, the market will go down. So something like, yeah, 13, 14 of those 20 years, the market will go up. This year might be one of them, or we might be one of the six or seven that goes down over the next 20 years. And one year in 10, I would say twice over the course of the next 20 years, there will be a horrifically bad bear market. And over the last 20 years, we can see it. We can see the great financial recession, 2008, '09, and then 2022 was absolutely brutal. For me, as a motley fool, stock picker and rule breaker investor, I think I got cut in half in 2022. Others may have done better than I, but that's a really, really bad year. So I think twice over the next 20 years,
14:59 Speaker 01 there's going to be a very, very bad stock market for reasons we can't quite predict. And those usually last 18 months or so. The average bear market, six to 18 months. So just realize, and they always go down faster than they go up. That's one of my watch words. So I would say, in conclusion, it'll be a great 20 years. You will be well rewarded to invest and invest regularly. And I would say, you're even more likely to outperform if you take my rule breaker approach to investing, which means you're holding for long periods of time, the best companies of our time. And that's my thought about the next 20 years.
15:37 Speaker 03 Well, and I've been trying to almost root for bear markets as someone who is hopefully going to be investing for decades to come. And when you mentioned 2022, that's when did I ended up making some of my best decisions. I won't say smartest because I got lucky with some of them. But there were a lot of big, great, strong companies that people were down and out on. I'll think of one Spotify, for example, where people thought they would never be able to make money because they're going to have, they're going to pay too much to artists. You have competition from Apple. There's no pricing power. And people gave investors a million reasons to sell that company. But it's one, David, that I use every day that I enjoy. And it's been, has been so far for me. I'll call it a long term winner. I want
16:18 Speaker 03 to focus on this idea, though, that sort of what's changed and what's stayed the same. Because in my anecdotal and small, smaller amount of time investing, I've just, I've noticed more pumping on X and especially Reddit, as the market has gone up over the past two or so years. I found one subreddit. It's called the race to 10 million, where over 200,000 people seem to be trying to day trade their way into intergenerational wealth. And for you, as someone who has observed how people talk about stocks on the internet for a while, do you think, has the discourse changed? Or is it just the mediums?
16:56 Speaker 01 Well, I think that it's inevitable that you're always going to have some people who are hoping to speculate their way toward great wealth as quickly as possible. I can't imagine that ever not being the case. Certainly, before the internet ever existed, there were penny stock pump and dump schemes. There were boiler room operations, often driven by the financial professionals that were trying to use penny stocks to jack up returns. It almost always ends badly. Those who were big fans, the apes and chimps around AMC, we've watched that stock. Anybody can take a look at the five year graph of AMC stock to see what inevitably happens to these kinds of approaches to investing. It's not investing,
17:39 Speaker 01 it's trading. And especially, you're hoping to sell something that you just bought to somebody else who'll pay more. You hope a lot more as quickly as possible. And while that will work for some people, it's going to be a tiny minority. And usually, the people are orchestrating what's happening. Those are the people who are making money. Classically, penny stock pump and dump schemes were rigged by professionals selling naive people the shares that they had pre-bought at penny stock prices elevated for them and leave other people holding the bag. So it's sad to watch that. It's going to happen in every generation. And yes, the internet does enable that in some cases, whether it was AOL chat rooms back in the day, so-called,
18:22 Speaker 01 or Reddit and aspects of Reddit today. I'm not going to call that out any much more than you and I just did. I think it's sad, but I often think it's for a lot of people, it's a step toward understanding what actually works. So I think a lot of people left holding the bag on AMC stock, which has basically declined from 300 to 6 in the last three or four years. I think that that was a lot of younger people and people who have a lot more time to recover and maybe learn the lesson there. You know, it is worth just calling out briefly that 2022, you mentioned Spotify, Ricky. And Spotify in 2022, just in one year alone, lost, as you mentioned, a lot. It actually lost 66% of its value in 2022.
19:04 Speaker 01 Nvidia got cut in half in 2022. So many great, strong companies had really, really bad years. But all the returns that we quote at The Motley Fool about how well Nvidia's done for us, Netflix, Intuitive Surgical, MercadoLibre, all of those returns include every bad period. And I think people have to have to understand that. In the end, we're going to make money as investors by finding real things that add real value to the world. AMC has not added any meaningful scaled real value to the world for quite a long time, and it's not going to anytime soon. So Nvidia is for real because Nvidia is at the vanguard of technology today.
19:47 Speaker 01 And all of those gains, to me, are real. I would encourage everybody to look at what they're investing in, asking, do I see in the world that we're living in today? Do I see the effects of the products and services of this thing? Is it growing and is it helping the world? Is it exciting and dynamic? Or is it some bizarre sidelight being promoted by some small group of people on some hidden place on the internet? And if you're in that place, I would get out of it as quickly as you can.
20:16 Speaker 03 I want to move this conversation a little bit to rational optimism. I've heard you recommend the book and I've also had David Meyer recommended the book to me as well. So I've started, I've started looking at it.
20:27 Speaker 01 Love it.
20:27 Speaker 03 We talked, we talked about 2022 and I think there's also a lot of investors who were investing through 2021 and they wished, they wished they just sold a little bit, David. And that, that honestly, that includes me too. Ha, I should have gotten out a little bit on these stocks before they had the crushing returns of 2022. And one of the main ideas in the rational optimist is that what makes people deeply human and different from other animals is our ability to combine ideas as a species, to hear an idea and then add our own thoughts to it and then share it with other people. This ends up building things like mobile phones where you have the phone meeting the internet, a technological peanut butter and jelly sandwich,
21:07 Speaker 03 if you will. There's an idea that I saw on X that I wanted to run by you and see if you had any additions or thoughts on it.
21:15 Speaker 01 Great.
21:15 Speaker 03 Is we combine and talk about it on this podcast. This was from a user called TheLongInvest. And he wrote that just buy and hold. This advice is nonsense. The truth is buy, hold, reassess, trim. Buy, hold, reassess, trim. Not trimming when a market correction is expected is ridiculous. And what you've just described, David, would be described as ridiculous by this user on X. And I think a lot of people feel that way when, you know, ah, maybe I just should have sold a little bit of my high growth tech stocks in 2021. When we think
21:56 Speaker 03 about Matt Ridley's idea, what would you add or combine to that idea after hearing it?
22:02 Speaker 01 Well, first of all, the idea of buying and holding, which are the first two words that you just gave from that person are great. Both of those are what's really going to make you wealth over the course of your life as an investor, to buy and to hold. Then the concept of trimming, that's something that I'm certainly in favor of in, in some real world situations. For example, if you hold a stock that goes up 100 times in value, You probably need to trim some of it over the course of time because it will take over your whole portfolio and possibly make it hard for you to sleep at night. So there are great reasons, especially when you hold great winners, to trim if you like.
22:43 Speaker 01 I do not believe trimming in reaction to perceived market conditions is going to work very often. I would encourage anybody who thinks that to make sure they're accountably scoring themselves. I would love to see the final results of somebody who is regularly saying, "Well, based on the market being a little overvalued, I'm going to sell this year." I actually think that you'll do better if you just keep holding than if you try to trim selectively. Whenever you trim, which might feel good, the question then is, how much in taxes did you just have to pay, capital gains taxes, because you just trimmed down some of your future money? And then second, where did you invest it? Some people trimmed away from Nvidia and put it in something that didn't do nearly as well as Nvidia.
23:24 Speaker 01 And so for me, as a rule breaker investor, I do think there are different types of stocks on the market. Again, I'm specifically focused on the rule breakers. These are companies I don't want to trim. But if I were in cyclicals, if I were in stocks that maybe are there mainly to generate income or that are reacting to perceived short-term market conditions, if that's my perspective, perhaps I would be more in favor of trimming. But at least for the kinds of companies that I'm always talking about, Shopify, you know, long-term winners like Meta Platforms, these are companies, just do the math. Go ahead and trim, you know, 1/10th every three months and see what regularly doing that looks like. It looks like less money than if you just bought and held.
24:07 Speaker 01 Also, it's a lot easier to spend time buying and holding than to have to constantly actively trade in, trade out, in my experience. But I want to make it really clear, there are many ways to approach the market. That person is probably acting well within how they think about things. Some people wait for dips, but Ricky, I've always said dips, wait for dips. I think that we should always be investing and adding. It's very hard to know where the market's headed next, and I challenge people to be really good at that and think they should allocate accordingly.
24:39 Speaker 03 We mentioned meta platforms and that the market is a teacher earlier and I'm glad you mentioned that because I, you know, I mentioned Spotify being a good idea. One of my worst ideas was buying meta and then saying, you know what, I'm going to trim a lot of this because the price has gone up a lot. Now I can get my cost basis out. David, I did what was the opposite of what rule breakers do. And then I missed out on some of the, the great gains that meta had in 2023 and 2024.
25:06 Speaker 01 Well, you just did something very foolish, very capital foolish that a lot of Motley Fool people, including me, do, do. And that is you said, I made a mistake. I'm human. I think one of the things that defines Motley Fool podcasts, I've certainly tried to do this over the years as often as possible myself, is to talk about the mistakes that we've made. And in fact, one of the fun studies we once ran on Motley Fool Stock Advisor, I assume it's still true today, but Motley Fool Stock Advisor is a service now in its, wow, 23rd, fourth year, would have done better had we never sold any stock in Motley Fool Stock Advisor, which we've done a number of times. It would actually have better returns today. This needs to be updated and confirmed, but I believe, last I looked at it, this
25:51 Speaker 01 was true. I think it's still true today. Motley Fool Stock Advisor would have more, made more money for members had we never once recommended a sell than when we did sell. And the reason really is because when you sell out a great winner, that is so costly to, versus selling out something that ends up dropping. Because the best you could ever do with a sell, for example, I once sold Strayer Education. I was like, I don't think this one's going to do well anymore. We're out. And I was right. Three years later, it was down 75% from where we sold it. But I also said, sell ARM Holdings, which over the next six or seven years went up 700%. And there's not even any difference between
26:31 Speaker 01 the numbers plus 700% and minus 75%. The huge cost is the opportunity cost of selling winners. And so that's very important for me to communicate to our members and listeners. And I know you do a good job of it, too. We want people to understand the biggest mistake you can make is of course, to sell a significant Winner. That's much worse than having a bad stock pick, which, by the way, I've done all the time. I've talked about that a lot on the podcast. So thank you for being capital F foolish with me, Ricky, and with our audience and speaking to the very human that lives in all of us that makes mistakes on a regular basis, which is part of the reason, by the way, I try to take out the number of decisions I make. If you just buy, buy and buy some more over the course of
27:12 Speaker 01 time, you don't end up ruining your sell decisions, selling Apple in 1997, or Netflix in 2008.
27:20 Speaker 03 Or you get to sell on your own terms. I'll hear from fools that I sold this stock. Why did you sell this particular stock? Oh, it's because my kid was going to college, right? I needed to fix a hot water heater going on at my home. Well, hopefully, the hot water heater is for an emergency fund, but you get the idea. David, if you're going to play this game, you have to be a long-term optimist, which is going to be, which can be exceptionally difficult. Few things to be pessimistic about. Crushing national debt. We got drones over New Jersey. We don't know what they're doing. There's plenty of geopolitical risk going on with a war between Russia and Ukraine. You don't know what China's going to do with Taiwan. There are things to be scared of and pessimistic about.
28:01 Speaker 03 What are the reasons then? Not just the past market returns, but why should someone listening to this be a long-term optimist?
28:08 Speaker 01 History's on your side.
28:10 Speaker 03 All right, next question.
28:11 Speaker 01 Yeah, I mean, my often when I was talking to people last year and they were upset about the election and on either party, just the whole feeling. Dave Barry, the humorous Miami Herald columnist, always does a year-end review and hilariously, I recommend reading Dave Barry's column about 2024 and the craziness of the year we just lived through. But as we got near the end of last year, and it's true right here at the start of this year, you can, you can call it every bad thing, some of which are serious and some of which drones, anyway, to me, not that serious. You can call it every bad thing. And yet I would ask you rhetorically, why is the stock market at all time highs? And the reason is because the stock market is smarter than reacting to near term.
28:55 Speaker 01 If it bleeds, it leads headlines. The stock market is reflecting the growth of business. American business is the best business in the world. American business has better products and services today than at any point in history. And we often are in danger of taking things for granted, like how cheap it is to tap in over FaceTime with a relative halfway around the world for free, or to eat food that is far healthier, or drive cars that are far less dangerous in every way to the environment and to humans than they were 25 years before. These things are constantly improving around us. AI is here to make things even better than that.
29:34 Speaker 01 And so I think it's very obvious, if anybody takes a moment to look at the graph of the S and P 500, or Dow Jones, if you like, or the NASDAQ, over any meaningful period, call it the last 10 years, call it the last 25 or 50, it goes lower left to upper right. And each of the really hard things that we lived through, which were really hard, 2008, '09 was really hard, each of those things, look at backwards through a meaningful amount of time, is a small blip on the graph. At the time you're living it, it doesn't feel good. But there is, there are very rational, repeatable reasons why things go lower left to upper right over the last 50 years and will over the next 50 years.
30:19 Speaker 01 And that's really what has to be spoken to. I don't feel like I have to prove out why that is or that that is. Those are the facts. I think I would need to hear from somebody to explain to me why that won't continue to recur when I'm very confident that it will. And I think, Ricky, a lot of the Motley Fool has always started with people who are optimists. Our company's been built by optimists, and most of the people who are staying with us 20 years later with their memberships and really grateful, stories like the one we talked about at the top of our interview, those are people who are optimistic. They recognize the goodness that's in the world. And I think that's so important to call out at all times, maybe, maybe especially this year, I'm not sure. But the American economy, by the way, is such a wonderful, Warren Buffett, never bet against America, he's right.
31:05 Speaker 03 So David, one industry that I'm optimistic about in my lifetime, and this is from looking at companies and talking to leaders of these companies, and just reading the news. And to me, that's the future of space. And what's possible is low Earth orbit develops, where companies are sending satellites into low Earth orbits, hopefully putting research projects up there. One example I heard from the Sierra Space CEO, Tom Weiss, which is a company working, it's a private company, but they're working on building space planes that go to and from low Earth orbit, hopefully building super refined manufacturing for glass and microchips. One example the CEO told me about, David, is that even 3D printing organs, where the
31:47 Speaker 03 problem in Earth is gravity, where these cell structures collapse in on themselves. But you could imagine, hopefully, a factory in low Earth orbit where they're able to do that and build these cellular structures on top of each other without the pressure of gravity and hopefully saving lives. This is also one that is nascent. These companies are not particularly old. Profits are extraordinarily far out. Hard to think of these companies in terms of particular operating metrics. Someone who's trying rule breaker style investing, how should I be thinking about the future of space and investing in these types of companies?
32:23 Speaker 01 Well, first of all, I think you should be paying attention, and clearly you are, Ricky. I love your description there. And there are enough interesting things happening. I read 1440 Daily, which is sort of my every morning check in with the news. It's neutral and it tends to focus on a lot of the innovation that's happening in our world. So I don't spend a lot of time worrying about all the bad stuff or obsessing about that. I spend no time watching cable news, but 1440 Daily is a wonderful way to start my day. And I'm constantly encountering news stories, new tech developments like the one you just described. And I think that is just phenomenal on its own. Pinch yourself that you get to live over the next decade and through so many of these kinds of innovations.
33:05 Speaker 01 And then in terms of low Earth orbit space or the space industry overall, I'm very excited about it. I love the shift that we've had basically from government Sort of government monopolized approach to space to the private sector. It's worth always pointing out to people that the private sector dwarfs the public sector in the United States of America and many of the best countries in the world today. And so, opening up the private sector where most of us in the US work every day. We work in the private sector, providing a product or a service to people who are willing to pay, we hope, above our costs for our product or service. That gives us profit, allows us to pay dividends, grow stocks over time. We all win together, which is the way good economies work.
33:48 Speaker 01 So, how could I not be excited about the prospects in space? With that said, it's still so early. So, there's a little bit of me thinking back to 10 years ago when 3D printing was first hitting. I was excited about it and 3D Systems was a really great stock pick for me, before it became a really bad stock pick by me over the course of time. Today, 3D printing, I mean, we've already mentioned in this conversation, but it's popping up in new and interesting ways 10 years later, and it's still early days for 3D printing. So, I think whether it's the internet 30 years ago, AI today, space today, so many things. It's worth paying attention, but maybe not getting too excited or speculating. People who put a lot of money in Virgin Galactic, ticker symbol S P C E,
34:33 Speaker 01 because of the opportunity for tourists going into space, have lost a lot of money over the last three years. I'm just checking the stock. It's lost about 500 times of its value. Like, that's about 99% of its value from its highs. It's a penny stock today. But, you know, Rocket Lab, other... Often, I'm looking at the market caps of companies, Ricky, to see sort of, does this company, has it reached a really meaningful state of size and dependability? And Rocket Lab, I was looking at recently. It's $16 billion market cap. So, that's a small to emerging midsize market cap company. You know, these companies often, at the bleeding stage,
35:19 Speaker 01 are not going to be making money for a while. So, you have to look and see the burn rate. You know, how much longer can they lose that much? Money without going back to the market and weakening their balance sheet. So I would say in a lot of ways, always have your eye on the future. That's actually my license plate on my car here in Washington DC. It's future. If anybody's in the greater DC area ever sees a Tesla driving around with the with the with the license plate, future, that's me. So I try to stay in the future and live backward to today and think about what are the things that really matter? And let's get our money there, positioned in the rule breakers of their time. To conclude my possibly long shaggy dog answer, I think it's really helpful to make sure we're invested in things that are real and reaching scale. So Amazon was losing money for a long time. We were invested all the way through and I'm so glad we were.
36:04 Speaker 01 They had real customers buying real products, starting with just books and CDs back in the day. But it was all real and it was scaling and growing. Sometimes the exciting tech developments where you hear about this company that's doing this crazy thing are not as real as that. So I really prefer to stay focused on the top dogs and first movers in the important emerging industries.
36:27 Speaker 03 And what you've just described is one reason I'm struggling with Rocket Lab is a shareholder. It's done fabulously well. There are signs of adoption. It's putting rockets into space. It's not a top dog, but it's number two after SpaceX. It's hoping to get a rocket in the air called the neutron rocket, which dramatically increases the amount of weight that it can take to low earth orbit from a few hundred pounds to the weight of essentially two to three adult elephants. But it is something where, as you can tell, I'm excited by the technology, but I can't give you, I don't know all of the adoption use cases and there's a lot of, there's an end to the story where that rocket doesn't quite work out. It's not the top dog and investors retract and decide that,
37:10 Speaker 03 you know what, this space is not as exciting as we thought it once was.
37:14 Speaker 01 Well, it's a volatile company, Ricky. Just looking at the last few years, I mean, this is a stock that if you'd bought four years ago today, you would have watched it get cut in half three and a half years later. So you'd be sitting there going, wow, I don't like this stock very much. But of course, it's now gone up about four times in value or so in just the last six months, something like that. So, I mean, it This is kind of what it looks like when you find early emergent companies. I really don't know whether it will work out or not for Rocket Lab, but I think it's a fun one to have in one's portfolio. And I've always said, make sure you can sleep at night with the allocation you have in each of your stocks. I've said it's really one of my portfolio principles for rule breakers to establish your sleep number.
37:59 Speaker 01 What is the percentage you would allow your largest holding to become of the overall 100% pie of your portfolio? I would say that's your sleep number. And so if anybody, and everybody's different. Some people are comfortable with 20% of their portfolio in one stock. Some people don't want anything more than 5% of their portfolio in any one stock. So it always starts with knowing yourself. But given that, I think there's room in anybody's portfolio for this kind of company, as long as it's not causing you to lose sleep at night or the tail that wags your whole dog. Unless you maybe work at Rocket Lab, you already know of the next thing and you're like, we're going to crush SpaceX. I don't know, that's not me. But I think it's great to be invested in companies that look like your best vision for our future. And that feels like a cool one to me.
38:44 Speaker 03 Let's move on to a technology that is more developed than low earth orbit. And that's artificial intelligence. This is also one that's easy to be pessimistic about. I don't have to look far on the internet to find long-term pessimists about artificial intelligence, whether it being the percentage of doom, people thinking that it will cause civilization collapse because of super intelligent robots coming to take us all. I know it's something James Cameron has been worried about for a number of decades since creating the Terminator movie. But when you're looking at artificial intelligence through the lens of long-term optimism, through the lens of rational optimism, why is it something that you're hopeful about?
39:21 Speaker 01 Well, because it's going to make us smarter and it's going to improve so many things around us. Tied very closely to AI is of course robotics. And once you start putting AI into robots, you start seeing a much more automated world where a lot of the jobs that are lower quality jobs today, that ideally humans could spend their minds and their potential on higher callings. I think a lot of those jobs are going to be taken over. The amount of automation just in for that amazon.com uses today is remarkable and has been for quite a while, but you ain't seen nothing yet. So I'm very confident that AI is is obviously for real. One of my favorite lines from Stuart Brand, the longtime tech visionary.
40:04 Speaker 01 Stuart Brand said, you know, when a new technology shows up, an important one, a big one, you're either part of the steamroller or part of the road. And so I think it's it's very much worth being part of the steamroller with AI. And I appreciate caution and cautionary thinking there. And, you know, so I think there has to be always a balance, but let's not make the mistake of of doubting the Internet, doubting e-commerce, which is what we faced as early stock pickers online with fool.com. A lot of people didn't even believe in e-commerce. I remember being on CNN and and, you know, championing the idea that people would give their credit cards over the Internet. And that was at at the time, that was questionable.
40:47 Speaker 01 That seemed a little crazy because, you know, who's or will that person on eBay actually send you the thing that you just bought from them online, whatever online means. These things we take for granted today. They've been such an enabler for our economy worldwide. That'll be the case for AI as well. And yes, AI will be used for ill in the same way that the Internet has been used for ill. It's a powerful tool, but we're going to be part of the steamroller at the Motley Fool on this one.
41:12 Speaker 03 And as we start to wrap up here, your show Rule Breaker Investing is not just an investing show. You also talk about life. You talk about business. You talk about games, a number of things. And we've talked about rational optimism in terms of space, in terms of artificial intelligence, the future of the American economy. But to take a step back more personally, how have you applied rational optimism to your business at the Motley Fool, to your life, to your career?
41:38 Speaker 01 Well, I think there are so many different examples, but one that comes to mind quickly is just that the importance of culture and corporate culture, both for us at The Motley Fool and I would say for everyone listening to me who is in a workplace today, whether it's a remote one or a local one, culture. I did a great interview years ago with Danny Meyer, who is the longtime successful New York restaurateur, Shake Shack, Union Square Hospitality Group, just a wonderful man and a wonderful entrepreneur. And he talked about scaling from those early first restaurants that he had and what he realized since he couldn't be at his second restaurant. Like, he had incredible vision for how to run a restaurant, but as soon as you start expanding, you can't be all places. And what he did is he hired for culture.
42:22 Speaker 01 He hired for people who may not have even been the top performers at his company, but he hired and rewarded the people who carried an understanding of hospitality and the ethos that meant so much to that business, the business he ran. So every business is different, but thinking about prioritizing the culture carriers, championing those who live and breathe the mission of the organization, multiplies your impact, certainly did for Danny Meyer, far beyond that single restaurant or that single website or first application. So that would be an example for me of a timeless truth that is not an investing lesson per
43:03 Speaker 01 se, and it's not just a life lesson per se, it's in that middle space, Ricky, which is sort of business and professional, like what wins in the marketplace. Of course, we want to be invested in the companies that do that, and we want to start those companies or work at them our whole lives long. But I love observing, like, what are the businesses that are truly great? I'll give another quick example, Old Dominion Freight Line. This is a trucking company. Most people may not have heard of it, although they are a Major League Baseball sponsor these days and they're kind of a bigger deal. But this is a family-run business, it's third generation, and in an industry that's largely unionized, Old Dominion has remained largely free of that because they treat their employees so well. They're constantly coaching up people who want to drive a truck.
43:48 Speaker 01 Or if you're already driving a truck and you want to go into IT at the company, they're coaching you up over the course of time. That is so endemic to their culture. And that's such a strength that why Old Dominion, I'm happy to say, one of my stock picks for Motley Fool's stock advisor has been and will continue to be such a long-term winner. So I think looking past the charts, the ticker symbols, and looking at the guts of something and say, what's the culture there? And is that a culture that I believe will win? Is that something I want to be associated with, either work in it or invest in it? I think those are great rational and often optimistic conclusions that we can learn and act on.
44:24 Speaker 03 I think that's a great place to end it. David Gardner, I'm so grateful for the time that you've spent with us on Motley Fool Money. You have a show we should plug. It's called Rule Breaker Investing, our sister show in the Motley Fool Podcast portfolio. Thank you for your time, for your insight, and thank you for being here.
44:39 Speaker 01 Thank you, Ricky, and thank you for you and all the work that Mary and the team does to make this our best podcast. So it's a delight to be on.
44:53 Speaker 02 As always, people on the program may have interests in the stocks they talk about, and The Motley Fool may have formal recommendations for or against. So don't buy or sell stocks based solely on what you hear. All personal finance content follows Motley Fool editorial standards and are not approved by advertisers. The Motley Fool only picks products that it would personally recommend to friends like you. I'm Mary Long. Thanks for listening, fools. We'll see you on Monday.
Previous Amazon and Disney See Ad Dollars Next Cloudy With a Chance of Burgers Page updated November 16, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated