Pod Insights Morbid The Murder of Martha Moxley (Part 2) About this episode (Part 2 of 2) On October 30, 1975, fifteen-year-old Martha Moxley failed to return home after a night out with friends in Belle Haven, an exclusive wealthy enclave in Greenwich, CT. The following morning, Moxley’s badly beaten body was discovered underneath a tree, just a few hundred feet from her house, triggering one of the most notorious murder mysteries in the state’s history.
Transcript 10,791 words · 7 speakers
0:01 Speaker 00 Hey there, I'm Kat. I'm a college athlete. I was diagnosed with ankylosing spondylitis, which causes back pain and stiffness every day. With Cosentyx, I'm able to stay active.
0:14 Speaker 01 Cosentyx secukinumab is prescribed for adults with active psoriatic arthritis, ankylosing spondylitis, or non-radiographic axial spondyloarthritis. Available in both IV infusion and self-injection. Don't use if allergic to Cosentyx. Get checked for TB before starting. Increased risk of infections and lowered ability to fight them may occur. Like TB or other serious bacterial, fungal, or viral infections. Some are fatal. Tell your doctor if you have an infection or symptoms like fevers, sweats, chills, muscle aches, or cough. Had a vaccine or plan to, or if IBD symptoms develop or worsen. Serious allergic reactions and severe eczema-like skin reactions may occur. Learn more at 1-844-COSENTIX or cosentyx.com.
0:55 Speaker 00 Move and feel better. Ask a rheumatologist about Cosentyx.
1:01 Speaker 02 Too soon for Black Friday at Lowe's? Not when the deals are this good. Get your choice of a DeWalt 20V Max Reciprocating Saw or Circular Saw for just $99. Plus, MyLowe's Rewards members get free same-day delivery. Black Friday deals are on now at Lowe's. In-store and online. Valid through 11/4. $25 minimum and loyalty membership required. Order eligible items by 2 P.M. Subject to weight and size restrictions and availability. Terms at lowe's.com/shippingterms.
1:30 Speaker 03 Ryan Reynolds here for Mint Mobile. I don't know if you knew this, but anyone can get the same premium wireless for $15 a month plan that I've been enjoying. It's not just for celebrities. So do like I did and have one of your assistant's assistants switch you to Mint Mobile today. I'm told it's super easy to do at mintmobile.com/switch.
1:49 Speaker 04 Upfront payment of $45 for three-month plan equivalent to $15 per month required. Intro rate first three months only, then full-price plan options available. Taxes and fees extra. See full terms at mintmobile.com.
2:00 Speaker 05 Hey weirdos, I'm Ash.
2:02 Speaker 06 And I'm Alina.
2:03 Speaker 05 And this is Morbid.
2:17 Speaker 06 This is morbid.
2:18 Speaker 05 Morbid in the afternoon.
2:21 Speaker 06 Um, and I'm trying to think of, uh, I saw, cause like last time I think we were like, okay, like set your timers, cause we're about to start the episode. I saw some funny ass people being like, it starts at 69 seconds. So like it starts at oh, point oh three seconds.
2:37 Speaker 05 So now you're never gonna know when it starts.
2:39 Speaker 06 So I think you guys are funny.
2:41 Speaker 05 You guys are funny.
2:42 Speaker 06 But I don't think we have a ton of business. Um, just some, the, the normal stuff. If you guys haven't bought tickets to the live show at Radio City.
2:51 Speaker 05 What are you doing?
2:53 Speaker 06 Buy tickets to it. Cause I'm telling you, it's gonna be a blast. We, we've really nailed some stuff down.
2:58 Speaker 05 Yup. We're reeling it in.
2:59 Speaker 06 It's gonna be fun. We have some fun merch.
3:01 Speaker 05 Yes.
3:02 Speaker 06 Um, we have a special guest and it's just gonna be a really fun time.
3:05 Speaker 05 Fitz from Romania.
3:06 Speaker 06 Yeah.
3:07 Speaker 05 Literally.
3:07 Speaker 06 So get your butt there.
3:09 Speaker 05 And then you can just wander around New York.
3:10 Speaker 06 Yeah, all night.
3:11 Speaker 05 Yep.
3:12 Speaker 06 Actually don't, because I've been saying, I mean, you shouldn't anyway, but like.
3:14 Speaker 05 That was always just a joke to begin with.
3:16 Speaker 06 I keep seeing these reports on the news the last couple of days of.
3:19 Speaker 05 I don't watch the news.
3:19 Speaker 06 People are like, they're getting film of like, in the middle of the night, people are just going into manholes. And then some people are like crawling out of manholes. It's just like a group of men.
3:30 Speaker 05 What?
3:31 Speaker 06 Who, and they don't know what they're doing.
3:32 Speaker 05 Are they the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles?
3:34 Speaker 06 That's the running joke.
3:35 Speaker 05 That's the general consensus.
3:37 Speaker 06 But that's very dangerous. Like, don't do that.
3:40 Speaker 05 Yeah.
3:41 Speaker 06 Like, if you're one of those people, stop doing that. Don't do that.
3:44 Speaker 05 Emerging from a manhole, you could get saccharibingst real quick.
3:48 Speaker 06 Absolutely.
3:49 Speaker 05 That's crazy.
3:49 Speaker 06 Yeah, I'm saying.
3:51 Speaker 05 And I was like, you're going into the sewers?
3:52 Speaker 06 That's what I'm saying. Nobody knows what they're doing. Nobody really knows what the situation is. It's been a couple of nights of them like seeing these videos.
4:01 Speaker 05 I really hate that.
4:02 Speaker 06 So there, so that's going on.
4:04 Speaker 05 Yeah.
4:05 Speaker 06 That's spooky.
4:06 Speaker 05 That's something.
4:07 Speaker 06 Pretty spooky. Uh, so don't do that. But also, um, on a totally different note, um, what you should do is preorder The Butcher Legacy.
4:16 Speaker 05 Honestly, it's not even that much different of a note, because your book has some weird shit.
4:21 Speaker 06 Exactly. So there's that. And also, um, I don't know if you've noticed, some of you have. I'm doing a little, uh, series, like a video series. I'm trying my hand at it. It's a lot of work. I don't know how to put these videos together. I'm, anybody who puts videos together and edits and does all this stuff all by themselves.
4:39 Speaker 05 Influencers in the wild. You have a tough job.
4:42 Speaker 06 Props to you for being able to edit a video because it's hard.
4:45 Speaker 05 It is hard.
4:45 Speaker 06 Uh, but yeah, so I'm doing a little video series where I'm going to go through the chapters of the butcher legacy.
4:51 Speaker 05 I love it.
4:52 Speaker 06 Give you a little sneak peek of every chapter, a little hints, little Easter eggs.
4:55 Speaker 05 Yeah, Easter eggs, exactly.
4:56 Speaker 06 So keep a lookout for those. I'm putting them on TikTok and Instagram. I think a couple of people might've thought it had to do with, um, the Salem slicer game that, that morbid is doing with hunter killer. Those are two different things. Just in case you were confused.
5:11 Speaker 05 So these are not like game pieces or anything like that. We'll do another video.
5:14 Speaker 06 Yeah, for sure. Um, so these are just, keep a lookout for them. I'm calling them the evidence recovery series. So keep an eye out.
5:21 Speaker 05 I love it. It's so fun. It was a very good idea.
5:23 Speaker 06 It's been a really fun thing to do. Uh, and I'm trying to think if we have any other business.
5:29 Speaker 05 I think it starts now. I think it starts.
5:31 Speaker 06 Oh, wait. Also, preorder the Salem slicer. If, if, if you want that game, the game is so much fun.
5:36 Speaker 05 It's incredible.
5:37 Speaker 06 Yeah, it's really fun.
5:38 Speaker 05 A lot of people are getting theirs in the mail, like the ones that we sent out and like our friends and family are so excited.
5:43 Speaker 06 I'm so excited to see everybody get them. Um, but yeah, I think that's it.
5:47 Speaker 05 Okay, it starts now.
5:49 Speaker 06 Now.
5:49 Speaker 05 All right, Carl, stop your timer.
5:51 Speaker 06 All right, starts now. All right. So when we last left you guys.
5:54 Speaker 05 Yeah, you left us on a fucking cliffhanger, Big Red.
5:57 Speaker 06 Sure did, because I talked about the Sutton report that was put together that was never made public. Only bits and pieces of it.
6:05 Speaker 05 I think that's the weirdest thing ever.
6:07 Speaker 06 But one of the things that did come out from it was that Tommy Skakel lied about his whereabouts or, or more his actions that night.
6:16 Speaker 05 Yeah.
6:17 Speaker 06 Cause remember he said he just like went inside and started a project that didn't exist.
6:21 Speaker 05 On Abraham Lincoln.
6:22 Speaker 06 That was proved to not exist.
6:24 Speaker 05 And the teachers were like, nobody gave a fuck.
6:26 Speaker 06 But what else came out in this report was, um, some stuff about Michael Skakel.
6:32 Speaker 05 Interesting. I did not see that coming. When you said that, I said, qual?
6:37 Speaker 06 Yeah, it's pretty crazy. Now, as private investigators were digging into the Martha Moxley case, the state's attorney was doing their best to keep the press and the public. You know, in the loop with regard to the newly reopened investigation. Among other things, John Solomon was eager to employ the latest technology in DNA. Because obviously that's coming out, that feels like it's going to open a million doors.
6:59 Speaker 05 Yeah, that's huge.
7:00 Speaker 06 They hoped that was going to identify the suspect, like bar none. The news that they might soon be able to identify the killer did prompt both Tommy and Michael Skakel to have a change of heart with their initial stories.
7:12 Speaker 05 Oh.
7:13 Speaker 06 So that, so the word comes out like, hey, maybe we could identify someone like we have DNA. We have the Sutton Report. They were like, actually, we'd love to tell you what we were actually doing that night.
7:22 Speaker 05 Alrighty.
7:23 Speaker 06 Um, and they did admit to police that they lied about the night of the murder. And they would like to offer new alibis.
7:29 Speaker 05 Okay.
7:30 Speaker 06 Which obviously in and of itself does not identify them as murderers.
7:34 Speaker 05 It just doesn't look good.
7:35 Speaker 06 Because unfortunately, they were teenagers at the time. So you have to look at it like that. Uh, in Tommy's case, the alibi was more or less similar to what he had offered the first time he was interviewed. But he dropped the story about doing the project. That didn't exist.
7:50 Speaker 05 The teachers were like, bud, you really got to stop this because we have no proof of that.
7:54 Speaker 06 You're not doing a project on Abraham Lincoln. It's just not doing. Uh, but he copped to being drunk at the time.
7:59 Speaker 05 Okay.
7:59 Speaker 06 Because remember, they were young. They were like 15 years old at this point. They were young. Michael's new alibi, on the other hand, was surprising.
8:08 Speaker 05 Because he had said he was at another cousin's house, right?
8:11 Speaker 06 So like you just said, according to Michael, he returned from his cousin's house around 11:00 PM, remember? But he didn't go to bed, as he had previously stated. Before he said he got home around 11:00 PM and he just went to bed.
8:24 Speaker 05 I thought that was a little cry cry because like these kids all like to have a lot of fun and go around, you know?
8:29 Speaker 06 Now, this is a little shocking.
8:31 Speaker 05 Okay.
8:32 Speaker 06 What he did. He brought this forward.
8:35 Speaker 05 Okay.
8:35 Speaker 06 Uh, instead, he claimed he wandered around the neighborhood.
8:40 Speaker 06 Looking into the bedroom windows of his female neighbors.
8:43 Speaker 05 Oh.
8:44 Speaker 06 Until, that's not even the shocking part.
8:46 Speaker 05 Oh.
8:47 Speaker 06 Until he returned home and climbed the tree outside of Martha's window and masturbated in the tree.
8:54 Speaker 05 Oh, what the actual fuck?
8:58 Speaker 06 Yeah.
8:59 Speaker 05 He just told investigators that?
9:02 Speaker 06 Yeah. He said, that's what I was actually doing.
9:05 Speaker 05 And what'd they do when they heard that?
9:07 Speaker 06 I mean, I wasn't there, so I don't know what their exact reactions were.
9:11 Speaker 05 How'd they proceed?
9:12 Speaker 06 I, I imagine they said, oh.
9:15 Speaker 05 Yeah.
9:16 Speaker 06 Oh, okay.
9:17 Speaker 05 The fuck?
9:18 Speaker 06 Um, so what made his new alibi so surprising wasn't just that it outed him as a teenage peeping Tom and a public masturbator. Like, those are pretty.
9:30 Speaker 05 That's a big deal.
9:31 Speaker 06 That's, that's a lot, but.
9:33 Speaker 05 Not a public masturbator.
9:34 Speaker 06 I think the more, what's crazy is the more shocking thing was that he essentially placed himself at the scene of the crime.
9:41 Speaker 05 Crime scene, yeah.
9:42 Speaker 06 Making himself now, not his brother Tommy, the last person to maybe see Martha alive.
9:49 Speaker 05 Okay.
9:50 Speaker 06 The new alibi wasn't just a bizarre twist.
9:53 Speaker 05 I'm also saying, that's just not even an alibi.
9:55 Speaker 06 No.
9:55 Speaker 05 You can't call that an alibi.
9:56 Speaker 06 I guess, I, I mean, it is because it doesn't prove he murdered her.
10:01 Speaker 05 His alibi is that he was masturbating outside her bedroom window?
10:04 Speaker 06 I'm not out here saying it's a good thing to be doing.
10:06 Speaker 05 Fuck.
10:07 Speaker 06 But technically, it's an alibi. You're telling them where you were, but, and it doesn't obviously make him just from that a murderer?
10:15 Speaker 05 No, just a creep.
10:16 Speaker 06 Just a creep. But what the bigger problem there is, like they were saying, he placed himself at the scene of the crime, essentially. So it's like, that's what makes it more like, huh? Like, sure, that's an alibi, but it's not a good one, my friend.
10:31 Speaker 05 Scene of the crime.
10:32 Speaker 06 Yeah. It also called into question the original timeline, and it raised new questions about the reliability of the original investigation, which was already.
10:41 Speaker 05 Yeah, pretty bad.
10:42 Speaker 06 Shaky. Now, within days of the murder, investigators had ruled Michael Skagel out as a suspect. That was in the beginning. Based on the fact that he was confirmed to have been at his cousin's house when they thought the murder occurred around 10:00 PM.
10:56 Speaker 05 Okay.
10:56 Speaker 06 He was, they, the cousins were like, yep, he was there.
10:59 Speaker 05 Yeah.
10:59 Speaker 06 But the only reason, this is wild to me, the only reason investigators believe the murder occurred at 10:00 PM? Was not based on medical examiner evidence.
11:09 Speaker 05 Oh.
11:10 Speaker 06 Like it should be.
11:10 Speaker 05 Yup.
11:11 Speaker 06 They were basing it on reports from neighbors about the agitated barking dogs in the neighborhood that were barking at 10pm.
11:20 Speaker 05 Gotta be fucking kidding me.
11:22 Speaker 06 Yeah.
11:22 Speaker 05 You, that's base, that's the same as like eyewitness testimony, like that's never, that's not that reliable. And it's actually even worse because there's, no, there's no eyewitness.
11:32 Speaker 06 That on the same level as eyewitness testimony. You're literally saying animals made noises
11:40 Speaker 05 Right.
11:40 Speaker 06 At a time one night. So someone must have been being murdered.
11:44 Speaker 05 And you're relying on people's memory of what time that was, which like, again, people have shaky memories.
11:50 Speaker 06 And just the fact that dogs bark.
11:54 Speaker 05 Yeah.
11:54 Speaker 06 Dogs bark.
11:55 Speaker 05 My dog barks for no fucking reason for sometimes.
11:58 Speaker 06 My dog barks sometimes when they see their own reflection in the window.
12:02 Speaker 05 Yup.
12:03 Speaker 06 My dog barks at my other dog when my other dog is laying down and she wants to play.
12:08 Speaker 05 Yup.
12:09 Speaker 06 My dog barks sometimes when they fart.
12:12 Speaker 05 To bark. My dog.
12:14 Speaker 06 Yeah.
12:14 Speaker 05 My dog barks when she farts too.
12:17 Speaker 06 Sometimes it upsets them or the other one barks when the other one farts.
12:20 Speaker 05 Dolores, when she farts, she, she chases her butt and barks. And I'm like, bitch, that was you.
12:25 Speaker 06 That was you.
12:25 Speaker 05 It's almost like she's like mad at her butt for betraying her.
12:28 Speaker 06 The thing like, dogs are awesome.
12:30 Speaker 05 Yeah.
12:31 Speaker 06 Dogs are awesome.
12:32 Speaker 05 But they're gonna do wily shit for no reason.
12:34 Speaker 06 They're barking at their own farts. So it's like, we're, we're, we're using them as a forensic tool now? Like what, when did that happen?
12:40 Speaker 05 Yeah, they're not canine dogs, babe.
12:41 Speaker 06 That's insane to me to be like, well, dogs barked around 10pm, so that was obviously when the murder happened. It's like, no, I think they were just barking.
12:49 Speaker 05 And again, like not even, take the dogs out of it. You're relying on the neighbor saying what time that happened. That's no good.
12:56 Speaker 06 What's even worse with this is the medical examiner had never really agreed with investigators stated time of death.
13:02 Speaker 05 And they're, they're the expert, I would say on this.
13:04 Speaker 06 Examiner, yeah, they got the actual biolot, physiological evidence that shows that this is when they had actually placed Martha's time of death anywhere between 9:30pm and 5am.
13:16 Speaker 05 That's a big window.
13:18 Speaker 06 It was only because investigators believed the local dogs to be more reliable than the medical examiner essentially.
13:25 Speaker 05 You shitting me?
13:25 Speaker 06 That they were able to rule Michael Skakel out in the first place. That was the only reason he was ruled out.
13:30 Speaker 05 That is so.
13:31 Speaker 06 Because he had an alibi for when the dogs were barking.
13:35 Speaker 05 That's brutal.
13:36 Speaker 06 Not when the medical examiner is saying it could have occurred.
13:39 Speaker 05 That's crazy.
13:40 Speaker 06 Yeah. Also, now that he'd admitted to trying to, trying to watch Martha through her window after he'd returned from his cousin's home.
13:48 Speaker 05 Mm hmm.
13:49 Speaker 06 Michael hadn't just ruled himself back in as a suspect. He'd effectively moved himself to the top of the list.
13:55 Speaker 05 Yeah, you're masturbating outside of her window.
13:57 Speaker 06 And he's at the scene.
13:58 Speaker 05 Yeah.
13:59 Speaker 06 That's, she was 200 feet from her house.
14:01 Speaker 05 Right.
14:01 Speaker 06 Like, you're there.
14:03 Speaker 05 Yep.
14:04 Speaker 06 Now, although no one outside Sutton Associates knew it at the time, there was a lot more that made Michael Skakel a strong suspect than just a bizarre new alibi.
14:13 Speaker 05 And this was, the Sutton report was like, like their family hired that, that law group. So this is interesting.
14:20 Speaker 06 Yeah. According to the Sutton report, because remember, we got little bits and pieces of it.
14:25 Speaker 05 Yeah, not the whole thing.
14:26 Speaker 06 At the, quote, "At the very least, it is fair to say Michael Skakel has, for whatever reason, often acted out in certain ways to arouse suspicion." Reportedly, Michael once even confessed to the murder of Martha Moxley in a therapy session while a patient at the Elon Treatment Center.
14:42 Speaker 05 Oh, fuck.
14:43 Speaker 06 In fact, while he was at the Elon School, Michael confessed multiple times to murdering Martha Moxley in both group therapy settings and in private conversations.
14:54 Speaker 05 Okay.
14:55 Speaker 06 Although he would later recant at least one of those confessions in an email correspondence with one of the other students at Elon, the discovery of that information would have been damning if it had been made public and it wasn't at the time.
15:08 Speaker 05 That's so tough. I know with like therapy.
15:10 Speaker 06 Yeah, you have to be careful with that stuff. When he was informed of his son's confession at the Elon School, Rushden Skakel immediately pulled the plug on the entire investigation, paying any remaining fees and ending multiple years of work. Since everyone involved in the private investigation had signed a confidentiality agreement.
15:30 Speaker 05 I wish you guys could see my face right now because my face is saying, what?
15:35 Speaker 06 What? Uh, well, all the people involved in the private investigation had signed a confidentiality agreement. So they were all prohibited from disclosing any information contained in the report to law enforcement or to the public.
15:47 Speaker 05 And then DA brother.
15:48 Speaker 06 Once again, it seemed that Skakel's money and power had kind of shielded his family from any responsibility. But there was one thing he hadn't counted on.
15:56 Speaker 05 Stop what?
15:58 Speaker 06 It was true that every investigator on the case had signed a confidentiality agreement.
16:01 Speaker 05 But?
16:02 Speaker 06 But the young employees who'd been tasked with organizing the information for the investigators had not been required to sign anything.
16:11 Speaker 06 When that young man, one young man.
16:14 Speaker 05 He who shall not be named.
16:16 Speaker 06 He has remained anonymous. Learned that the report and Skakel's confession to murder were being shelved and would not see the light of day. He stole the report and sent it to Dominic Dunn.
16:26 Speaker 05 Not all heroes were capes.
16:27 Speaker 06 Because he had seen Dominic Dunn talking about the case on the news and he was like, I think you should have this.
16:32 Speaker 05 Wow, that's always like my favorite part of a story when one person is just like, I think you should look at this.
16:38 Speaker 06 I love when one person just is like.
16:41 Speaker 06 Dominic Dunn had built a respectable career for himself as a writer covering crime. But he also wasn't exactly an investigative journalist at the time, like which.
16:50 Speaker 05 He actually shifted a lot after the murder of his daughter.
16:53 Speaker 06 Which is what was required if the Sutton report was going to be put to good use. You need an investigative journalist of some sort. So rather than pursue the story himself, Dunn forwarded the report to former Los Angeles police detective turned author, Mark Furman.
17:07 Speaker 05 Okay.
17:08 Speaker 06 Dunn didn't know personally, but he respected the work he had done.
17:12 Speaker 05 Okay.
17:12 Speaker 06 Now, although he would eventually make a name for himself as an author and journalist, Furman first became a household name. Some people might be like, wait a minute.
17:20 Speaker 05 The name sounded familiar.
17:22 Speaker 06 He was, he became a household name across America during the OJ Simpson trial.
17:26 Speaker 05 Oh, okay.
17:26 Speaker 06 In 1994. He was an LAPD detective and he investigated the murder of Simpson's wife, Nicole Brown Simpson, and her friend Ron Goldman. And was the investigator who found the notorious bloody glove.
17:38 Speaker 05 Oh shit.
17:39 Speaker 06 During the trial, though, several witnesses for the defense testified that Furman had previously made racist statements in their presence, leading the defense to charge that Furman had tampered with evidence in order to obtain a conviction. Despite there being no evidence to suggest the glove had been planted by anyone, the controversy and documentation of, you know, his past, essentially the remarks he had made, it made him a pariah everywhere, like in law enforcement, you know? He retired in 1995, the next day, the next day.
18:09 Speaker 05 The very next day.
18:11 Speaker 06 The next year. And he did write Murder in Brentwood, about the Simpson murder and the trial.
18:16 Speaker 05 Oh, okay.
18:17 Speaker 06 Murder in Brentwood had really impressed Dominic Dunn. And so when he came across the Sutton Report, Furman was the first person that came to Dunn's mind.
18:26 Speaker 05 Okay.
18:27 Speaker 06 Because he was like, he knows how to do this shit.
18:29 Speaker 05 Yeah.
18:29 Speaker 06 Now, after reading the Sutton Report, Furman placed a call to Dorothy Moxley, who by then had moved to New Jersey to live near her son.
18:38 Speaker 05 Okay.
18:38 Speaker 06 Unlike Dunn, who'd written a fictional account of the case, Furman wanted to write a nonfiction account. And not only intended to emphasize the countless mistakes made by law enforcement, but he also wanted to identify Martha's killer in this book. He later said, "I felt like I had a heavy burden on my shoulders. I just told this woman who's been waiting 23 years for some solution to her daughter's homicide, that I could solve it. So I had no choice then. I actually had to go out and solve it." Now with Dorothy's consent.
19:09 Speaker 05 It's a lot to task yourself with.
19:10 Speaker 06 Now with Dorothy's consent, Furman got to work digging into the case, but immediately ran into problems when word of his intentions reached the local police.
19:19 Speaker 05 Ah.
19:20 Speaker 06 Sensing that Furman was planning to smear them in the investigation with his book, Furman was shut out by local law enforcement and claims, he claims that he was threatened with arrest if he went near any residents of Belle Haven.
19:34 Speaker 05 Allegedly.
19:34 Speaker 06 Allegedly. That's what is claimed. Fortunately, he soon found an ally in retired Greenwich detective Steve Carroll, the original lead on the Moxley case.
19:45 Speaker 05 Okay.
19:46 Speaker 06 He later said his absence of ego at not being able to solve this case was a great contribution because he admitted things that I think other detectives wouldn't have.
19:55 Speaker 05 Okay.
19:56 Speaker 06 Which is like really impressive that Steve Carroll. I like that he said his lack of ego at not being able to solve this case. Like, he didn't go into this being like, whatever, we did all we could and this isn't my fault. Like, he was like, no, I think we fucked up along the way and it couldn't have been solved.
20:08 Speaker 05 You have to be willing to admit fault.
20:10 Speaker 06 Yeah, once Dorothy Moxley gave her consent for Carol to speak with Furman, the former detective became Furman's greatest asset as he attempted to navigate a community that was very vocally opposed to his presence.
20:22 Speaker 05 Yeah.
20:31 Speaker 03 Ryan Reynolds here for Mint Mobile. I don't know if you knew this, but anyone can get the same premium wireless for $15 a month plan that I've been enjoying. It's not just for celebrities, so do like I did and have one of your assistant's assistants switch you to Mint Mobile today. I'm told it's super easy to do at mintmobile.com/switch.
20:51 Speaker 04 Upfront payment of $45 for three-month plan, equivalent to $15 per month required. Intro rate first three months only, then full price plan options available. Taxes and fees extra. See full terms at mintmobile.com.
21:01 Speaker 01 Every family has one. The person who says, oh, I don't want anything this year. Cool. Super helpful. Here's the fix. Coop Sleep Goods. It's the rare gift that gets used every single night instead of shoved in a closet by January. Coop's Holiday Gift Guide is now 25% off, packed with best-selling adjustable pillows, cooling sheets, and toppers. And while you're there, grab one for yourself. I mean, you've been powering through this whole year on fumes. You've earned it. Every order comes with a 100-night trial, so there's no guesswork. Give yourself a damn break. Get 25% off the Holiday Gift Guide for a limited time at coopsleepgoods.com/comedy. That's C-O-O-P, sleepgoods.com/comedy.
21:52 Speaker 06 Now, the problem with the Moxley case is that regardless of how many mistakes were made in the investigation, the fact remained that there also was little for investigators to go like work with here. Journalist Joel Lang wrote, "As damning as the evidence may seem, it proves little." Anyone might have, and this is true, you have to look at, at first, when you first look at this, you say, "Oh, my God, how could it, how could you not?" And it's true. It's, it looks damning. It does. When you really pull apart the pieces, though, you go, "Well, you have to think of every part of this."
22:24 Speaker 05 Because anybody could have taken that golf club.
22:26 Speaker 06 Anyone might have dropped the club outside, and anyone might have picked it up.
22:29 Speaker 05 Mm-hmm.
22:30 Speaker 06 Who knows if one of them had just had the club, dropped it outside somewhere, someone found it, picked it up.
22:36 Speaker 05 Somebody stumbled upon it.
22:37 Speaker 06 No one the police interviewed said that they saw Tommy with the golf club.
22:40 Speaker 05 Okay.
22:41 Speaker 06 So there's just that. And I'm just, just from like a purely like, sure, perspective, you know what I mean? Like, sure, somebody, is it likely? I don't know.
22:51 Speaker 05 Yeah.
22:52 Speaker 06 You know, like, it's just, but you have to think of these things.
22:54 Speaker 05 It's too bad they weren't able to get any prints off of it.
22:57 Speaker 06 I know. But, I don't know. Maybe somebody was wearing gloves. Who knows?
23:01 Speaker 05 Maybe.
23:02 Speaker 06 Now, in fact, even with all the circumstantial evidence pointing towards the Skakel house, investigators still had the wrong person as their prime suspect in the case. Of course, the only people who knew that were contractually bound to secrecy. Because remember, they were going after Tommy.
23:17 Speaker 05 Right.
23:18 Speaker 06 But Furman may have had the one piece of evidence that would break the case wide open and finally shed light on the identity of Martha's killer.
23:26 Speaker 05 Okay.
23:27 Speaker 06 In the spring of 1998, Furman's book Murder in Greenwich: Who Killed Martha Moxley was published, much to the consternation and very much to the ire of the investigators at the Greenwich Police Department and in the state's attorney's office. In the book, Furman laid out the facts as they were known, paying particular attention to the myriad of mistakes made by investigators, and asserts the widely accepted theory that a wealthy and powerful family had stymied the investigation from the start. That's what he says in the book.
23:56 Speaker 05 I like that word, "stymied."
23:57 Speaker 06 But the real bombshell was that Furman took the rare step of naming the person he believed was responsible for Martha's murder.
24:03 Speaker 05 That's bold.
24:04 Speaker 06 He named Michael Skakel.
24:06 Speaker 05 Interesting. You gotta be, you gotta have balls to do that, because...
24:13 Speaker 05 What for so many reasons.
24:15 Speaker 06 Yeah. Murder in Greenwich was an immediate bestseller and it also attracted scathing criticism.
24:21 Speaker 05 Sure.
24:21 Speaker 06 Particularly from those Furman sought to undermine with the book.
24:24 Speaker 05 Hmm.
24:25 Speaker 06 Like Frank Gahr, a firmer Greenwich detective who was working for the state at the time the book was published, said Furman has the luxury of not having to back up anything he says. So he can name anybody he wants and he can say anything he wants in that book, which I was like, technically you can't.
24:40 Speaker 05 No.
24:40 Speaker 06 Not if he doesn't want to be sued.
24:41 Speaker 05 I was gonna say.
24:43 Speaker 06 But Greenwich Police Chief Peter Robbins shared a similar sentiment about the work, telling a reporter, his real intent was to make money. I don't think he was necessarily attempting to solve a crime. Like damn.
24:53 Speaker 05 Okay.
24:54 Speaker 06 So relying heavily on the Sutton Report and interviews conducted with Michael Skakel's classmates at the Elon School, Furman laid out a very plausible case against Skakel, while also exposing how the case had been so badly botched by investigators in the first place.
25:08 Speaker 05 Mm hmm.
25:09 Speaker 06 Furman told a reporter, I can find very little they did correctly in the investigation. I don't want to be smug or arrogant about this, but I obviously know much more than they do.
25:19 Speaker 05 Dang.
25:19 Speaker 06 Like fuck. Now, on June 18th, just one month after the publication of his book, Connecticut's Chief Court Administrator Erin Ment, announced that a one-person grand jury comprised of Superior Court Justice George Thim, was being called upon to review the evidence against Michael Skakel.
25:38 Speaker 05 Never in my life have I heard of a one-person grand jury.
25:42 Speaker 06 That's the, and also, oh, so suddenly.
25:45 Speaker 05 Yeah, everybody doesn't like this book and they think like.
25:48 Speaker 06 Everybody thinks the book is a bunch, a crock of shit and all of a sudden they're like,
25:51 Speaker 05 A load of marlucky.
25:52 Speaker 06 We are gonna bring him in front of a grand jury. It's like, wait.
25:55 Speaker 05 Yeah.
25:55 Speaker 06 Which one is it?
25:56 Speaker 05 Make that make sense.
25:57 Speaker 06 Like, interesting. Now, the announcement of the grand jury came as a surprise. Not only because, like you said, it consisted of one man, but also because.
26:05 Speaker 05 It's not so grand.
26:06 Speaker 06 It doesn't seem grand to me. I don't know who George is, but he's gotta be real grand.
26:10 Speaker 05 He's grand. Like, I'm sure he's a great guy, but.
26:12 Speaker 06 But also because Connecticut does not require a grand jury before felony charges can be filed.
26:18 Speaker 05 Oh.
26:18 Speaker 06 According to Connecticut lawyer Norman Paddus, grand juries in Connecticut are only. Only used for political purposes. Having a grand jury provides insulation for a prosecutor in a politically sensitive case.
26:30 Speaker 05 Interesting.
26:31 Speaker 06 Because the decision to indict is made by a panel of anonymous citizens.
26:34 Speaker 05 Or just one.
26:35 Speaker 06 Or just George.
26:36 Speaker 05 Or just Grand Master George. Also, I was like, I'm sure he's a great guy. I really went on a limb there.
26:42 Speaker 06 Yeah.
26:43 Speaker 05 Who knows?
26:44 Speaker 06 Who, I don't know George.
26:45 Speaker 05 That he's a great guy, but I
26:46 Speaker 06 I don't know him.
26:47 Speaker 05 As a gal, you can never say you're sure a man is great.
26:50 Speaker 06 No, so I just
26:50 Speaker 05 I'd like to recant that.
26:52 Speaker 06 I stay over here saying, I don't know George.
26:54 Speaker 05 Yes.
26:54 Speaker 06 I don't know about him.
26:55 Speaker 05 That he's great is what I should have said.
26:57 Speaker 06 So another way of saying all this is, in other words, the district attorney can't be blamed if the accused isn't indicted because it was the grand jury that made the decision, not the prosecutor.
27:06 Speaker 05 All right.
27:06 Speaker 06 So it's just to keep them from the, I didn't do it. To anyone who had been following this case, it looked like, whether investigators liked it or not, the publication of Murder in Greenwich had managed to break the case somewhat.
27:18 Speaker 05 Yeah.
27:18 Speaker 06 Like at least move something along.
27:20 Speaker 05 Right.
27:20 Speaker 06 But when he was asked about the matter, Detective Frank Gar dismissed the suggestion that the book had anything to do with the filing.
27:27 Speaker 05 So then what was it?
27:28 Speaker 06 We've talked to hundreds of people and gathered some information that was previously unknown. So we reached a point where having a grand jury was an option. The books added interest to the public and the media, but they had no impact on the investigation.
27:41 Speaker 05 Was it like public pressure after people read the book?
27:44 Speaker 06 Whatever you say.
27:44 Speaker 05 Yeah.
27:45 Speaker 06 Okay.
27:45 Speaker 05 Sure.
27:46 Speaker 06 For decades, Martha Moxley's friends and family had desperately sought answers to her remember brutal murder, but were just, again, stymied, since you like that word.
27:59 Speaker 05 Period.
27:59 Speaker 06 They were stymied at every turn.
28:01 Speaker 05 Yep.
28:01 Speaker 06 Now, after more than 20 years, it looked like Martha might finally get the justice that she deserved. Of course, nothing in this case is straightforward at all.
28:11 Speaker 05 No.
28:11 Speaker 06 And there was no reason to believe that would change.
28:14 Speaker 05 Oh.
28:15 Speaker 06 At least of all.
28:16 Speaker 05 You really just
28:16 Speaker 06 Yeah. Well, and least of all because of the publication of this book.
28:22 Speaker 05 Yeah.
28:22 Speaker 06 Yeah. So on July 12th, 1998, the one man grand jury proceeding.
28:28 Speaker 05 George.
28:28 Speaker 06 It began in Bridgeport, where Justice George Thim began hearing testimony and reviewing the evidence in the case. Among those seated in the gallery were Dorothy and John Moxley.
28:38 Speaker 05 Okay.
28:38 Speaker 06 Who were accompanied by former Greenwich detective Daniel Hickman.
28:43 Speaker 06 Hickman told a reporter, "I'm very glad we're doing this. Glad we're investigating this matter a little further. I hope something good comes out of this for the sake of the family and the community." Yeah. Given the number of times the Skakel family had kind of thwarted investigators' attempts to get answers into the Moxley case, it should come as no surprise that the grand jury hearing was pretty similarly frustrating, and it ultimately dragged on for 18 months. Wow, holy shit. During that time, the majority of the Skakel family members, who were expected to testify publicly, stated their intent to skip the hearing. Is that allowed? Yes. Rushden Skakel was particularly adamant in his refusal, telling reporters, "I wasn't there personally. I was hunting when the slaying happened." So he saw no reason why he should be there.
29:28 Speaker 06 Okay. I wonder, I don't know if, I'm just like making this up, but I wonder if you could be held in contempt of court for not showing up to testify when you're called upon? I would think so. I looked at Deb. Debbie's just like shrugging and being like, "Yeah, usually, right?" Like, you would think. You would think? Yeah, that's typical. It's interesting. Yeah, okay. But others who refused to testify or otherwise attempted to stonewall the prosecution, including Sutton associates Detective Willis Krebs and Elon School owner Joseph Ricci. Okay. Krebs cited attorney-client privilege as his reason for not divulging the names of those interviewed during the investigation. I mean, that makes sense, I guess. But the judge rejected the claim, and Krebs- Okay, and it doesn't. It doesn't make sense.
30:13 Speaker 06 The judge rejected the claim, and Krebs was compelled to release the names. Ricci's refusal, on the other hand, proved a more challenging matter. Okay. Because he's the Elon School. In his case, he is- He is the Elon School. In his case, he cited doctor-patient confidentiality as his reason for declining to testify or release information about Michael's time at Elon. Which, that's a lot more. Unlike, yeah, unlike Skakel's contract with Sutton, the mutually assured privacy between a doctor and their patient is taken very seriously in the legal system. Yeah. Skakel's lawyer, David Grudberg, said, "It completely undercuts that privilege if you can change the rules after the fact." In response, the prosecution argued that the confession,
30:58 Speaker 06 quote, "had nothing to do with Skakel's treatment or any illness."
31:01 Speaker 05 Okay.
31:02 Speaker 06 Therefore, should not be privileged information.
31:03 Speaker 05 Which I can get that.
31:04 Speaker 06 Which if you're saying he was talking in private conversations with like fellow students, I would think, yeah, that wouldn't have anything to do with his treatment. Deb Deb has just informed us that she's not positive, but she said, because she doesn't know Connecticut law, but she said-
31:18 Speaker 05 She only knows mass law.
31:19 Speaker 06 There is the possibility that Rushden Skakel especially,
31:22 Speaker 05 The father.
31:23 Speaker 06 The father would not be compelled to testify because of like the parent.
31:28 Speaker 05 Child.
31:28 Speaker 06 It's kind of like a spousal.
31:29 Speaker 05 It's privilege, yeah.
31:30 Speaker 06 Privilege. So that makes sense, I suppose.
31:33 Speaker 05 Yeah, no, I can see that.
31:34 Speaker 06 But yeah.
31:35 Speaker 05 I'm interested though, because obviously it was more than him that refused. So I'm like, what did everybody else say?
31:38 Speaker 06 Yeah. Now, again, they're saying, they're claiming that his confessions, Michael's confessions, had nothing to do with his treatment.
31:46 Speaker 05 So that's why they should be allowed to have the doctor testify.
31:49 Speaker 06 Ultimately, the judge sided with the defense and any statements Michael made while at Elon were deemed inadmissible. Why is that hard to say?
31:57 Speaker 05 Interesting.
31:58 Speaker 06 Yeah. Finally, in January 2000, the grand jury ruled that even without the incriminating statements made at Elon, there was sufficient evidence to charge Michael Skakel with the murder of Martha Moxley. That's without the confession.
32:11 Speaker 05 I was just gonna say, okay, so then what's the evidence?
32:13 Speaker 06 But in an odd twist.
32:15 Speaker 05 This is the twistiest case I've ever heard.
32:17 Speaker 06 The arrest warrant and any associated documentation related to the case would not list Skakel by name, as he was a juvenile when the murder was committed.
32:27 Speaker 05 Okay.
32:27 Speaker 06 In response to news of the indictment, Skakel's lawyer, Michael Sherman, told reporters, "If he's arrested, he's going to plead not guilty. Come to court and we'll go to trial. He's innocent. He has nothing to do with this murder. This is not a case that will result in a plea bargain."
32:41 Speaker 05 Okay.
32:42 Speaker 06 Now, as expected, on January 20th, an arrest warrant was issued for Michael Skakel, who surrendered at the Greenwich Police Department that afternoon, where he spent roughly 30 minutes before being released on $500,000 of bond. Yeah.
32:57 Speaker 05 I, that's shocking.
32:59 Speaker 06 For those who'd lived in Greenwich since the murder occurred, it was a moment they never thought would come. Bellhaven resident Martha McEntree said, "A lot of people would like to see closure. If an arrest is heading towards that, then I think that's a relief for everyone."
33:11 Speaker 05 Yeah.
33:12 Speaker 06 The arrest was followed by the usual cries of innocence from, you know, Skakel's lawyer, Michael Sherman. But Skakel himself seemed interested only in protesting the arrest directly to Dorothy Moxley herself.
33:23 Speaker 05 Oh.
33:24 Speaker 06 With Sherman's encouragement allegedly.
33:27 Speaker 05 His lawyer.
33:27 Speaker 06 Yeah. Michael reached out to Dorothy.
33:32 Speaker 06 Much to her surprise and disappointment. She later said, "What he said to me was, Dorothy, I feel your pain, but you've got the wrong guy." And she says, "I was incensed that he would call me Dorothy. I'm sorry, but I do believe I deserve some more respect than that. He should have called me Mrs. Moxley, and he shouldn't have talked to me. It wasn't the right thing to do."
33:54 Speaker 05 Yeah, there's so much wrong with that.
33:56 Speaker 06 To encourage him to call her mother.
33:59 Speaker 05 Yeah. Like, well, like, exactly what she said, put some respect on her name. It's Mrs. Moxley.
34:06 Speaker 06 And she said, "He shouldn't have called me at all."
34:08 Speaker 05 Shouldn't have called her at all. And the fact that he didn't said, "I can feel your pain." No, you can't.
34:13 Speaker 06 Yeah.
34:13 Speaker 05 You don't know a mother's pain whose daughter was slaughtered.
34:16 Speaker 06 200 feet from her home.
34:18 Speaker 05 15-year-old daughter. Like, no, you can't feel her pain. Don't ever say that.
34:23 Speaker 06 Yeah.
34:23 Speaker 05 That's nuts. That whole entire decision is nuts from start to finish.
34:28 Speaker 06 Now, two weeks later, on February 8th, Michael Skakel was arraigned on one count of second-degree murder in juvenile court. After reviewing the evidence and the circumstances surrounding the case, the juvenile court judge had the case transferred to the Criminal Division of the Superior Court, ending the period in which Skakel's name was withheld from any official documents.
34:48 Speaker 05 Because now he's an adult.
34:49 Speaker 06 Now, the case was preceded by the usual round of pre-trial hearings, but the prosecution was dealt a significant blow on August 7th, 2001, when their star witness, former Elon student Gregory Coleman, was found dead from an apparent drug overdose. Coleman was one of the two students who testified to the grand jury that Michael had confessed to killing Martha while at Elon, and his testimony was key to securing a conviction.
35:19 Speaker 05 I just wanted to let that hang in the room for a minute.
35:22 Speaker 06 Fortunately, the judge allowed the prosecution to present Coleman's deposition at trial in lieu of his testimony.
35:28 Speaker 05 Okay.
35:29 Speaker 06 But the lack of his presence was a major source of frustration, obviously. Now, Skakel's trial began on May 7, 2002, at the county courthouse in Norwalk. As expected, the trial had drawn a ton of people, like a huge crowd of observers and journalists, many of whom were hoping for an appearance of like a rich and famous attendee at the trial.
35:49 Speaker 05 Yeah.
35:50 Speaker 06 And they weren't disappointed, I guess. As early as the first day, many members of the Skakel and Kennedy families were in attendance to support Michael.
35:59 Speaker 05 Oh.
35:59 Speaker 06 Including his cousins, Robert F. Kennedy Jr.
36:03 Speaker 05 Shut up.
36:04 Speaker 06 And Douglas Kennedy.
36:06 Speaker 05 I didn't even know there was a Douglas.
36:07 Speaker 06 Yeah, there's a Douglas, there's so many of them.
36:09 Speaker 05 I knew about R K.
36:10 Speaker 06 The Kennedys are far reaching. Dominic Dunn said, "The thing that I've always found so curious about the Kennedy's support of Michael is that Michael wrote a treatment for a book in which he says absolutely terrible things about his cousins, the Kennedys, and yet Bobby Kennedy Jr. was up here hugging him and supporting him."
36:27 Speaker 05 Public, public appearances, babe.
36:29 Speaker 06 Yeah. In his opening statement, prosecutor Jonathan Benedict laid out the state's case against Michael, stating with their belief that both Michael and Tommy had been vying for Martha's attention. And while she had no real interest in either of them.
36:44 Speaker 05 Yeah.
36:44 Speaker 06 She clearly favored Tommy a little over his brother.
36:47 Speaker 05 Okay.
36:47 Speaker 06 And I think that.
36:48 Speaker 05 Yeah, based on like her diary and everything.
36:50 Speaker 06 There's entries in her diary where like Michael was mad because she was quote unquote "leading him on."
36:54 Speaker 05 Yeah, he seemed, he seemed kind of protective over his brother.
36:57 Speaker 06 Yeah, and he seemed like, yeah. Now, it was the state's assertion that after the group of friends had gone their separate ways that night, Michael returned from his cousin's house and coaxed Martha outside and made a romantic or physical overture.
37:11 Speaker 05 Okay.
37:11 Speaker 06 To her, you know? When Martha rejected Michael's advances, he became physical and eventually attacked her with the golf club.
37:18 Speaker 05 Okay.
37:18 Speaker 06 Now, and I want to claim, say this again, that this was the prosecutor Jonathan Benedict's like theory.
37:26 Speaker 05 Yeah, it was the argument in court.
37:27 Speaker 06 I'm not saying that's what happened.
37:28 Speaker 05 Right.
37:29 Speaker 06 In his statement Benedict acknowledged that it was incumbent upon the state to prove not only that Michael was a killer, but that he had intended to kill Martha that night. To that end, the prosecutor used a large projection in the courtroom to show the jury and observers the crime scene photographs, showing the extent of the brutality Martha had suffered before her death.
37:48 Speaker 05 Oh.
37:49 Speaker 06 And he said, and I agree with him, "I can think of no photos more compelling of substantiating an intent to kill."
37:55 Speaker 05 Yeah.
37:56 Speaker 06 There is no way whoever did that to Martha did not intend to kill her.
38:00 Speaker 05 That was not an accident, no.
38:01 Speaker 06 No, as for how the case was finally broken at the time Benedict told the jury, "Sometimes some people simply can't keep a secret." That, as you will see, is how things eventually unraveled for Michael Skakel.
38:13 Speaker 05 Hmm.
38:14 Speaker 06 In his client's defense, Michael Sherman refuted the state's claims and their theory, arguing that after years of bad police work and pressure to solve the case, investigators decided to just pin the murder on Michael.
38:24 Speaker 05 Okay.
38:25 Speaker 06 He said, "The case that we have is based loosely on a very shaky house of cards, and mostly wild cards, and a few jokers as well."
38:33 Speaker 05 Okay, let's not get super theatrical with it.
38:36 Speaker 06 I'm not out here trying to judge, uh, statements in a courtroom.
38:39 Speaker 05 I'm always out here trying to judge statements in a courtroom.
38:42 Speaker 06 That made me go, "Ugh."
38:43 Speaker 05 Yeah, exactly.
38:44 Speaker 06 That was not a good one.
38:45 Speaker 05 Cause you could've just ended it out like-
38:46 Speaker 06 A shaky house of cards.
38:47 Speaker 05 Cause I was nodding, I was like, "Yeah."
38:49 Speaker 06 Yeah, shaky house of cards.
38:50 Speaker 05 But the jokers.
38:51 Speaker 06 I love it, mostly wild cards, maybe a few jokers. I'd be like, "Nope, try it again."
38:56 Speaker 05 You overdid it, you overdid it.
38:57 Speaker 06 I'd be like, "Run it again, Michael, run it again."
38:59 Speaker 05 He didn't run that with like-
39:00 Speaker 06 Yeah.
39:01 Speaker 05 Anyone.
39:01 Speaker 06 He didn't read that for anyone, I feel.
39:03 Speaker 05 No.
39:03 Speaker 06 Read that in front of someone and see if they go, "Ugh."
39:06 Speaker 05 "Ugh."
39:06 Speaker 06 That's like, "Ugh."
39:07 Speaker 05 Yeah, I don't like it.
39:39 Speaker 01 pillows, cooling sheets and toppers. And while you're there, grab one for yourself. I mean, you've been powering through this whole year on fumes. You've earned it. Every order comes with a 100 night trial, so there's no guesswork. Give yourself a damn break. Get 25% off the holiday gift guide for a limited time at coopsleepgoods.com/ comedy. That's C-O-O-P, sleepgoods.com/ comedy.
40:07 Speaker 06 Now, the state's case against Michael was entirely circumstantial and it hinged very significantly on the testimony of Gregory Coleman.
40:14 Speaker 05 Right.
40:15 Speaker 06 Who'd heard Skakel's confession.
40:17 Speaker 05 But he had passed away, right?
40:18 Speaker 06 Yes. Coleman's death before the trial was a big problem for Benedict. However, several weeks into the trial, the prosecutor was contacted by Jennifer Pease, another former Elon student who offered to testify and corroborate Coleman's statement that Michael not only confessed to the murder, but also that he believed, and I quote, "he was going to get away with murder because he was a Kennedy." So this is what Jennifer Pease was saying that she could back up. She told the jury that Coleman had confided in her that he thought Michael Skakel was, quote, "sick" and that Skakel had, quote, "beat some girl's head in and killed her with a golf club."
40:58 Speaker 05 Oh shit.
40:59 Speaker 06 Yeah. The testimony from Jennifer Pease went a long way to corroborating Coleman's earlier statements and those of his widow who testified prior to Pease.
41:09 Speaker 05 Wow.
41:10 Speaker 06 On June 3rd, the prosecution and defense gave their final statements before the jury retired to deliberate.
41:16 Speaker 05 That's today.
41:17 Speaker 06 Oh my God, that's to- I'm not kidding, guys.
41:19 Speaker 05 We don't do this on purpose. Today is June 3rd, though. That's so weird.
41:25 Speaker 06 What the fuck?
41:25 Speaker 05 This happens to us so often. I don't know. I had to stop you before you got any further.
41:30 Speaker 06 You guys, I swear on everything, we do not do this on purpose.
41:33 Speaker 05 No, in fact, we were supposed to- we were- a lot of times, we're supposed to record earlier than we do.
41:38 Speaker 06 Yeah, and then we don't. And when we do record, it ends up falling on the date.
41:42 Speaker 05 Yeah, because we were going to record this yesterday, but then we didn't.
41:44 Speaker 06 Yeah.
41:45 Speaker 05 So, that's weird.
41:47 Speaker 06 What the fuck?
41:47 Speaker 05 That's weird.
41:48 Speaker 06 That's weird. Okay, wow. Well, on June 3rd, the prosecution and defense gave their final statements before the jury retired to deliberate. In his closing remarks, Jonathan Benedict focused on the sheer brutality of the crime and Skakel's sense of untouchability afforded to him by his family's wealth and power. He said, this is really graphic, by the way.
42:09 Speaker 05 Okay.
42:09 Speaker 06 He said, "The act of stabbing her through the neck from one side through the other is the most emphatic evidence of pure hatred, rage, and intent to kill."
42:18 Speaker 05 Mm-hmm.
42:19 Speaker 06 Now, in his final argument, Michael Sherman was blunt and simple.
42:24 Speaker 05 He didn't practice this one either.
42:26 Speaker 06 Good morning. He didn't do it. He didn't do it. He doesn't know who did. He wasn't there when the crimes were committed, and he never confessed. That's the whole case.
42:36 Speaker 05 Babe, that's not gonna convince me of anything. That's just gonna convince me you didn't have your morning coffee.
42:41 Speaker 06 Yeah, that did.
42:43 Speaker 05 The fuck?
42:43 Speaker 06 I feel like you, you should have done this earlier.
42:47 Speaker 05 Yeah.
42:47 Speaker 06 Like, I feel like this is one of those that you were like, "I did this before breakfast."
42:50 Speaker 05 Yeah.
42:52 Speaker 06 Just threw that one together.
42:53 Speaker 05 Yeah, that's a rough.
42:55 Speaker 06 But then he just used the rest of it. So that was his, like, here's what I'm gonna...
42:58 Speaker 05 Here's my argument.
42:59 Speaker 06 He didn't do it. He didn't do it. He doesn't know who did. He wasn't there. He never confessed. That's it.
43:03 Speaker 05 Are you gonna tell me why, though?
43:05 Speaker 06 And then the rest of the time, he just used to attack the prosecution.
43:08 Speaker 05 That's nice.
43:08 Speaker 06 The witnesses and the investigators for what he alleged was a concerted effort to frame Michael Skakel. He said, "I have to tell you, this is the worst one conspiracy I have ever seen."
43:19 Speaker 05 Wow.
43:20 Speaker 06 Now, the jury deliberated for four days before finally coming out on June 8th.
43:24 Speaker 05 Oh, my birthday. Hey!
43:26 Speaker 06 To find Michael Skakel guilty of the murder of Martha Moxley.
43:29 Speaker 05 Oh, a bad day for Michael.
43:30 Speaker 06 Now, when the verdict was read, Skakel swayed slightly and shook his head in disbelief. From somewhere behind him, a member of the Skakel family shouted, "Oh, my God." Martha's family, on the other hand, was very happy with the jury's decision.
43:44 Speaker 05 You waited that long for justice for your daughter?
43:46 Speaker 06 Dorothy told a group of reporters, "This whole thing was about Martha."
43:50 Speaker 05 Yeah.
43:50 Speaker 06 "I feel so blessed and so overwhelmed. This is Martha's day. I hope people remember that."
43:55 Speaker 05 Oh.
43:56 Speaker 06 Now, when asked about the verdict, his book had seemingly helped secure at the time, Mark Furman praised the jury. He said, "They were attentive. They gave away nothing. They made no mistakes. Even when I talked to them, they said they were of one mind very early on that he was guilty." Now, in late August, Skakel went back to the Norwalk Court for sentencing. And when asked whether he had anything to say for himself, Skakel went on the offensive. He attacked his accusers and repeatedly professed his innocence. Before passing sentence, Judge John Kavanuski's address to the court was pretty broad, just saying, "For the last 25 years or more, a period well into his adult life, the defendant has been living a lie about his guilt. Most importantly, this defendant has accepted no responsibility.
44:42 Speaker 06 He has expressed no personal remorse to this present day. All of this persuades me to impose a sentence which, on balance, is substantial." And with that, he sentenced Skakel to 20 years to life, to be served at the Garner Correctional Institution in Newtown, Connecticut.
44:57 Speaker 05 Okay.
44:57 Speaker 06 Now, his appeals began almost immediately after the sentence. In 2004, the Connecticut Supreme Court heard his claims that, among other things, his constitutional rights were violated when the state prosecuted him for a crime in which the statute of limitations had expired. The argument depended largely on Skakel having been underage when the murder was committed, and the judge in juvenile court had erred in transferring the case to criminal court. In their conclusion, the justices upheld the lower court's ruling, noting, "If the trial court erred in their actions, the defendant has not established harm."
45:33 Speaker 05 Okay.
45:34 Speaker 06 So they just kept it. They were like, no. Now, in subsequent appeals, Skakel's defense team made a number of claims of improper conduct, from claims of prosecutorial misconduct to the credibility of witness testimony and beyond.
45:47 Speaker 05 Okay.
45:47 Speaker 06 Each case was considered by the higher courts and rejected on the merits. Now, then in 2013, Skakel launched another appeal for a new trial, this time arguing that his original trial attorney, Michael Sherman, was incompetent and was more interested in building his own reputation and celebrity than he was in defending his client.
46:08 Speaker 05 Okay.
46:09 Speaker 06 Martha Moxley's friends, family, and neighbors waited more than 25 years for her to see justice, and it felt like it had finally been found.
46:17 Speaker 05 Yeah.
46:18 Speaker 06 But in November 2013, Judge Thomas Bishop agreed with Skakel's complaint and ordered a new trial.
46:27 Speaker 06 In his conclusion, Judge Bishop noted that Michael Sherman, quote, "was in a myriad of ways ineffective, and as such, there was no way to be certain that the jury was acting on the best information available."
46:37 Speaker 05 Okay.
46:39 Speaker 06 To Martha's family, who had been struggling through a frustrating investigation and decades of uncertainty in trials, the reversal was a massive disappointment.
46:48 Speaker 05 Of course it was.
46:49 Speaker 06 But one that was not entirely unexpected, unfortunately.
46:52 Speaker 05 Yeah.
46:53 Speaker 06 Given the extent of Skakel's resources.
46:56 Speaker 05 Mm hmm.
46:56 Speaker 06 Dorothy Moxley told reporters after Skakel was released on bail pending a new trial, "I guess I knew that the day would come." And she said, "It would have made my life much easier for this not to happen."
47:08 Speaker 05 Oh.
47:09 Speaker 06 That must be.
47:11 Speaker 05 Because they must have.
47:12 Speaker 06 I can't even like come up with how that would feel to have it like, finally, this is over, we can start healing, we can start moving on.
47:18 Speaker 05 Ever really believe it's true.
47:19 Speaker 06 But then it's just reversed.
47:21 Speaker 05 And that's the thing, they, and they were, it's like holding your breath, waiting for the moment.
47:25 Speaker 06 Like, because she believed that they got it right.
47:28 Speaker 05 Yeah.
47:29 Speaker 06 But she never believed that it would hold because she knows.
47:33 Speaker 05 They have infinite resources.
47:34 Speaker 06 Now, like Dorothy Moxley, the prosecution was ready when the reversal happened and had already started preparing for a retrial.
47:41 Speaker 05 Okay.
47:41 Speaker 06 Fortunately, however, the prosecution wouldn't have to go that route. In 2016, the Connecticut Supreme Court overruled the lower court and concluded that Skakel had in fact been given a fair trial, even if he didn't feel as though the lawyer provided the best possible defense.
47:57 Speaker 05 Okay.
47:58 Speaker 06 One of the justices wrote in their concurrence, "Sherman's defense need not have been the best decision, or even a good one. It need only fall within the wide range of reasonable decisions that a defense attorney might make."
48:09 Speaker 05 Okay.
48:10 Speaker 06 To those who'd been watching the case from day one, the state Supreme Court's decision seemed like an attempt to correct the previous injustice.
48:16 Speaker 05 Yeah.
48:17 Speaker 06 But there wasn't much time to celebrate.
48:19 Speaker 05 Okay.
48:20 Speaker 06 Cause this is.
48:21 Speaker 05 Up and down and up and down.
48:23 Speaker 06 In fact, despite having reinstated the conviction, the question of whether Michael Sherman provided adequate representation would be argued back and forth in the state Supreme Court for two more years. Until May 2018, when the court ultimately reversed their original decision, their earlier decision, and agreed with Skakel's complaint that his lawyer had been ineffective and thus he was originally deprived of a fair trial.
48:50 Speaker 05 Okay.
48:51 Speaker 06 From the moment he was arrested in 1991, nearly everyone in Greenwich, Connecticut, watched and waited to see how Michael Skakel's wealth and power would possibly help him in this scenario. They figured it was just a foregone conclusion that it was going to come into play.
49:07 Speaker 05 Yeah.
49:08 Speaker 06 To the shock of many, that proved ineffective when a jury found him guilty and a judge sentenced him to spend the rest of his life in prison. Securing Skakel's conviction in a lengthy sentence was a major victory for the prosecution, who had to, again, contend with really poor police work, missing evidence, the death of their star witness mid-trial. But in truth, his conviction was just never a sure bet. The case, there was a lot of circumstantial stuff and there was a lot of time between the crime and when the trial occurred. There was just a lot that were.
49:42 Speaker 05 A lot working against them.
49:44 Speaker 06 Yeah. Now that Skakel had once again managed to win a new trial and was out on bail, the district attorney needed to decide whether they could feasibly secure the same verdict nearly 30 years later, with many of their witnesses having passed away or simply forgotten the important parts of their testimony. Cause they're getting older.
50:03 Speaker 05 Right.
50:04 Speaker 06 That's, I don't remember 30 years ago.
50:06 Speaker 05 No, and it's, you can't necessarily rely on somebody's memory from 30 years ago as you're on a jury.
50:11 Speaker 06 And everybody's memory is different. It's like, I don't have a great memory. Like my friend, like Deb Deb will say things that are like, remember when this happened? I'm like, oh shit, yeah. Like, or I'll just be like, no, I don't remember that. Like, my brain, my memory is just like weird. I remember weird shit, I don't remember good shit. And it's like that, so you just can't be sure. But in the end, Chief State's Attorney Richard Collin Jello looked at the potential battle of a new trial and determined that retrying Michael Skakel simply wasn't a good use of the state's resources.
50:43 Speaker 05 I hate when they say that. Like, I get what they're saying, but I just hate how it sounds.
50:48 Speaker 06 He said, "I believe the state cannot prove the case beyond a reasonable doubt. Therefore, the state is going to enter a null pross," which means to be unwilling to pursue.
50:59 Speaker 05 Oh.
51:00 Speaker 06 Once it was formally entered in 2021, the null pross resulted in a discharge of the murder charge against Michael Skakel.
51:08 Speaker 05 So he was never necessarily proven innocent? They were just like, "We think you did this, but we can't prove it."
51:12 Speaker 06 Basically, we just don't think we can prove you guilty again.
51:15 Speaker 05 It's almost like what happened with the West Memphis Three. I know that's like a whole different process, but it's-
51:20 Speaker 06 That's like a little, that's more, we're not saying, it's like, basically, they can't, they, they just say that they did it.
51:30 Speaker 05 Mm-hmm.
51:31 Speaker 06 And the state will let them go, and that means they can't sue the state.
51:36 Speaker 05 Oh, okay.
51:36 Speaker 06 That's what it means with the West Memphis Three is like-
51:38 Speaker 05 So that's a little different.
51:38 Speaker 06 That's an Alfred plea.
51:39 Speaker 05 Yeah.
51:40 Speaker 06 This is them being like, "We just don't think putting resources to retrying you will get us the conviction."
51:47 Speaker 05 But we still think you did it.
51:48 Speaker 06 But like, and I don't even know, I don't even know if it's, we still think you did it. I think it's just like, we don't think we have-
51:54 Speaker 05 We just can't prove it.
51:55 Speaker 06 We're not going to put the resources forward because we don't think we could get a conviction again.
51:59 Speaker 05 Wow.
52:00 Speaker 06 So you will be released. Um, so although, so he was a free man once again.
52:07 Speaker 05 Okay.
52:07 Speaker 06 Although it is possible that Skakel could be charged again and taken to trial. That is a thing. In the absence of the, you know, any new compelling evidence of his guilt, it seems pretty unlikely because nothing has come out since then that points to him.
52:22 Speaker 05 Yeah.
52:23 Speaker 06 Regardless of the prosecutor's decision, Dorothy Skakel remained convinced that they got it right the first time.
52:30 Speaker 05 Yeah.
52:30 Speaker 06 Um, while she was disappointed with the outcome, she told reporters she was, quote, satisfied with the efforts of police and prosecutors.
52:36 Speaker 05 All right.
52:37 Speaker 06 So like damn.
52:38 Speaker 05 At least she had that.
52:39 Speaker 06 A very impressive outlook.
52:40 Speaker 05 Yeah, she did. That's.
52:42 Speaker 06 But sadly, on December 24th, Christmas Eve, 2024, Dorothy Moxley died at her home in New Jersey at the age of 92.
52:50 Speaker 05 Wow.
52:51 Speaker 06 But from complications of the flu.
52:53 Speaker 05 Oh, that's awful.
52:54 Speaker 06 Now technically, Martha Moxley's murder remains unsolved to this day and is currently inactive.
53:02 Speaker 05 Oh, it should be active.
53:03 Speaker 06 Which makes me crazy.
53:05 Speaker 05 It should be active.
53:06 Speaker 06 Because regardless, I, that's like.
53:09 Speaker 05 A 15 year old girl was murdered.
53:11 Speaker 06 The facts of the case, I am not giving my personal opinion on this. The facts of the case are Michael Skakel was convicted of the murder.
53:19 Speaker 05 Mm hmm.
53:19 Speaker 06 He was granted a new trial.
53:22 Speaker 05 Mm hmm.
53:23 Speaker 06 And they chose not to pursue it. So he was freed. That's just the facts of the case.
53:27 Speaker 05 Yep.
53:27 Speaker 06 I don't know. Again, no more compelling evidence has come forward to that we know of. Or that has been released, I should say, or come public to say that he did it or that anyone else did it. And that's what's really frustrating is it's like, we don't have anything else. There's nothing else we can dig into.
53:47 Speaker 05 They need to review that evidence.
53:48 Speaker 06 I want to look at that evidence again.
53:50 Speaker 05 Why is, did fingerprinting ever fucking happen on that thing?
53:54 Speaker 06 I don't know. Cause also the golf club broke. So I don't know if it was hard to get.
53:59 Speaker 05 Oh, who knows if they have both parts?
54:01 Speaker 06 Yeah, I don't know. I don't know exactly what parts they were able to like, or what the parts, what kind of condition they were in there.
54:09 Speaker 05 She was discovered with her pants like around her.
54:14 Speaker 06 Yes, and the, the medical examiner said there was no evidence of sexual assault, but there was red marks on her thighs that were like handprints that he believed were someone trying to wrench her knees apart. But there was no biological evidence of sexual assault that they found.
54:32 Speaker 05 Okay.
54:33 Speaker 06 That's not saying with 100% certainty.
54:37 Speaker 05 Yeah.
54:37 Speaker 06 But they were, they were fairly confident that they didn't believe.
54:40 Speaker 05 Oh, I think this investigation just was tough.
54:45 Speaker 06 It's got a lot around it. It's got a lot going on. But right now, you know. Michael Skakel is not a can, you know, not considered the person that did it.
54:57 Speaker 05 Yeah.
54:57 Speaker 06 Right now.
54:58 Speaker 05 But you know what we say, a cold case is never cold.
55:01 Speaker 06 Exactly.
55:01 Speaker 05 And technically because this is, it's open though, right?
55:04 Speaker 06 Yeah.
55:04 Speaker 05 It's open but inactive.
55:06 Speaker 06 It's, it's unsolved and inactive. I think it's just.
55:09 Speaker 05 Oh, yes. Okay.
55:10 Speaker 06 So it's, it's a bummer.
55:12 Speaker 05 Open it up.
55:13 Speaker 06 To see it solved regardless of who is the person they identify. I would like it to be solved.
55:17 Speaker 05 Yeah.
55:19 Speaker 06 Just for Martha's family.
55:20 Speaker 05 Yeah, their family deserved justice and so does Martha.
55:23 Speaker 06 Yeah. And for the people who have, but there was, there was a few names thrown around in this case. So it would be nice if you could, you know, exonerate those, those names or prove that somebody did it.
55:33 Speaker 05 Yeah, just, just have some certainty.
55:35 Speaker 06 You know, there's a lot of people that were involved in this case that are thrown around here.
55:39 Speaker 05 Yeah, yeah. Wow. What a, what a brutal case and just, just.
55:45 Speaker 06 It's awful.
55:46 Speaker 05 It's so awful and it's so messy and it's so sad.
55:49 Speaker 06 She's super promising.
55:50 Speaker 05 It's so sad for so many reasons.
55:51 Speaker 06 Life ahead of her. Yeah. Doing everything right. Just being a teenager in the eighties or the seventies.
55:57 Speaker 05 Seventies.
55:58 Speaker 06 And this is awful.
55:59 Speaker 05 Just go and hang out with their friends.
56:02 Speaker 06 And in a place that like, didn't have crime.
56:04 Speaker 05 Yeah, like a safe.
56:05 Speaker 06 You know, like, so like, this is just like even weirder and it's, and it makes you think more that this was someone who potentially knew her because like, it's not like random strangers were.
56:16 Speaker 05 Being attacked or anything like that.
56:17 Speaker 06 Skulking around Bellhaven.
56:19 Speaker 05 Yeah.
56:19 Speaker 06 Except for that hitchhiker that they claimed they saw that no one could ever. Yeah, nobody could prove if they existed or not.
56:26 Speaker 05 Yeah.
56:27 Speaker 06 But who knows?
56:28 Speaker 05 You never know.
56:28 Speaker 06 I don't know.
56:29 Speaker 05 You never know.
56:30 Speaker 06 Yeah.
56:31 Speaker 05 I think we need a fun fact.
56:33 Speaker 06 We do need a fun fact. Do you have a fun fact?
56:35 Speaker 05 Tebby has a good one.
56:36 Speaker 06 Oh, my God. I, Deb Deb just found the greatest fun fact that just like ruined my life with the visual as well. Cause that is the cutest baby elephant I've ever seen in my life.
56:45 Speaker 05 Are my favorite.
56:46 Speaker 06 Baby elephants suck their trunks for comfort, like a baby, like would suck their thumb or like a, like a pacifier. They suck their thumbs like just to, or their, their, their trunk thumbs.
56:58 Speaker 05 Yeah.
56:58 Speaker 06 Just to soothe themselves when they're tired, anxious, or away from their mamas.
57:04 Speaker 05 Oh.
57:06 Speaker 06 And please look at this elephant.
57:08 Speaker 05 Oh, my god.
57:09 Speaker 06 I think my entire life just changed because of that picture of that baby elephant.
57:13 Speaker 05 Elephant so much. Elephants are the best animals ever. They literally like, they hold funerals.
57:20 Speaker 06 Oh, they take care of each other.
57:22 Speaker 05 They live in communities.
57:23 Speaker 06 Protect, they save each other's babies.
57:25 Speaker 05 Yeah, like, they are, we are not, we don't deserve elephants.
57:29 Speaker 06 We don't deserve them at all.
57:31 Speaker 05 We don't, we don't deserve most animals, to be honest.
57:33 Speaker 06 My youngest had us watch a show on Disney Plus that was like called Elephant, I think, or something. And it was just about a whole fucking group of elephants.
57:41 Speaker 05 Oh, honey, I'm gonna watch that.
57:42 Speaker 06 One of the elephants saved another one's baby.
57:45 Speaker 05 They do.
57:46 Speaker 06 From being stuck in mud. Cutest thing I've ever seen. They like, never gave up. They were like, I'm saving this baby. So elephants.
57:53 Speaker 05 Oh, my god. Also, while we're talking about that, Drew and I have been watching this show, I think it's on Hulu. It's about the San Diego Zoo.
57:59 Speaker 06 Oh, my god.
58:00 Speaker 05 And it is so much fun.
58:02 Speaker 06 I love that.
58:02 Speaker 05 I don't necessarily recommend watching with your children because they do talk about mating season. I literally, I was just about to recommend it to Elena because they were talking about koalas and her girls love koalas. But then they were like, he's about to have sexy time with the other koala ladies. And I was like, okay, maybe don't have them watch that.
58:18 Speaker 06 She texted me, she was like, oh, my god, Deisha, watch this. And then like, 10 minutes later, she was like, scratch that. They should not watch this yet.
58:25 Speaker 05 Maybe not yet. You probably have to talk. But if you're like an adult who loves animals, it's a really good show.
58:33 Speaker 06 I love that.
58:34 Speaker 05 So check it out.
58:34 Speaker 06 Hell, yeah.
58:35 Speaker 05 With that being said, we hope you keep listening.
58:37 Speaker 06 And we hope you keep it weird.
58:41 Speaker 05 Just not too weird.
58:42 Speaker 06 Not too weird that you leave this case unsolved.
58:45 Speaker 05 Yes.
58:46 Speaker 06 Not that weird.
Previous The Murder of Martha Moxley (Part 1) Next The San Ysidro McDonald's Massacre Page updated October 30, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated