Pod Insights Morbid Esther Cox and the Great Amherst Mystery About this episode In the summer of 1878, eighteen-year-old Esther Cox was assaulted at gunpoint by a male acquaintance, leaving the Nova Scotia teenager traumatized and afraid. In the days that followed, Esther and those with whom she shared a house in rural Amherst began to notice unusual things occurring around the house including knocking on the walls and floors, objects flying around the house, and Esther suffering frequent seizures without any apparent cause.
Transcript 13,860 words · 5 speakers
0:00 Speaker 00 Here's a quick podcast for all you true crime fans. The Case of the Missing Reese's. It was me at the store with my mouth. Motive: Um, they're Reese's. What was I gonna do? Stop myself? Tune in next time to see if I do it again. Spoiler: I will. Wow, that had everything. Reese's, suspense, Reese's.
0:30 Speaker 01 Something wicked is brewing behind the walls of a remote Gothic manor. Victorian Psycho follows an eccentric governess whose arrival sets off a bloody string of strange and deliciously disturbing events. Micah Monroe stars as Winifred Naughty, a woman with a dark past and a vicious appetite for bloodshed, giving in to her most violent urges. What follows is a gruesome parade of savagery, butchered bodies, and increasingly grotesque acts of violence. Also starring Jason Isaacs, Thomason Mackenzie, and Ruth Wilson. Victorian Psycho is coming only to theaters November 13th.
1:08 Speaker 01 Calling all vampires, it's time to satisfy that eternal thirst at Burger King. Sink your fangs into the new Vampire's Bite Strawberry and Sprite. Refreshing sprites riled with bold strawberry flavor and served with a Sour Punch Candy straw for that extra bite. Sip if you dare. Vampire's Bite Strawberry and Sprite is here for a limited time at participating US Burger King restaurants while supplies last. Visit bk.com to learn more. Sponsored by Burger King.
1:38 Speaker 02 Hey, you weirdos. I'm Alina.
1:40 Speaker 01 I'm Ash.
1:41 Speaker 02 And this is Morbid.
1:55 Speaker 01 Oh my god, I've done this before.
1:57 Speaker 02 I have also done this before a few times.
1:59 Speaker 01 It's like deja vu.
2:00 Speaker 02 Oh my god.
2:01 Speaker 01 Deja vu all over again.
2:06 Speaker 01 What's up, girl?
2:08 Speaker 02 Um, I, I actually, Mikey thought of a very funny thing that I forgot to mention in our last episode.
2:13 Speaker 01 Oh, my God. Y'all, please, please go forth and conquer.
2:17 Speaker 02 This is just a, um, it
2:19 Speaker 01 It's a continuation.
2:20 Speaker 02 If I had shame, this would be embarrassing, but I don't.
2:24 Speaker 01 No, I don't think it's embarrassing at all. Even if you did have shame, I think this is so funny.
2:28 Speaker 02 It's pretty funny. So we told you guys last, in the bonus episode, that we got to go to New York with Sirius XM and we got to like, do advertising week for a couple of days there. It was a lot of fun. You met a lot of cool people and one of the people-
2:47 Speaker 01 What?
2:52 Speaker 01 Accessibility off.
2:57 Speaker 01 Yo, girl, it's not your pod.
3:05 Speaker 02 Keep it in.
3:06 Speaker 01 That was the television.
3:07 Speaker 02 That was, I hit the remote by accident.
3:09 Speaker 01 Guys, old morbid is just coming at you live without us even trying.
3:14 Speaker 02 It's just organically happening.
3:16 Speaker 01 We would have gotten fired for that before, but now it can be left in.
3:25 Speaker 01 Would have seen some consequences for that one, but we're gonna leave that one in.
3:29 Speaker 02 Yeah. Uh, because you know what? You know who else I saw in ad week?
3:34 Speaker 01 Yes.
3:34 Speaker 02 Um, it was Al motherfucking Roker.
3:37 Speaker 01 I was gonna say the exact same thing. First name Al, middle name motherfucking.
3:41 Speaker 02 I was in this, I got my microphone put on and then I was standing in this tiny little alcove, like a hallway. And Ash was in this little closet getting her microphone put on and he walked, he like brushed by, like right there.
3:54 Speaker 01 I know, I just missed him.
3:56 Speaker 02 Literally just like, I had put my hand out, like I didn't touch him, don't worry. Uh, but I like, I, I was like,
4:01 Speaker 01 I rested my hand upon Al Roker's shoulder.
4:03 Speaker 02 I did not touch him, but I said, I love Al Roker. And I said it in his eyes. Eyes on eyes.
4:11 Speaker 01 He said, I love Al Roker.
4:13 Speaker 02 Eyes. He locked eyes on me. I locked eyes on him and I said, I love Al Roker. Right in his, my face said it into his face. It was, we had, we were connected in that moment. And he go, and then I was like, oh my God, I just said, I love Al Roker to Al Roker in my head.
4:29 Speaker 01 At least you said more than I did. In my little alcove closet, I just went, Al Roker.
4:36 Speaker 01 I just said, I love Al Roker to his face and he said, thank you so much. And he put his hand on his, he was very, he was touched.
4:44 Speaker 02 By my incompetence. And so he.
4:46 Speaker 01 Do you have a hole in your sock?
4:48 Speaker 02 I do. I just figured that out. Now I can't stop. I'm so upset about it.
4:51 Speaker 01 Yeah, you can change them if you need to.
4:53 Speaker 02 I might change them.
4:54 Speaker 01 I get it.
4:54 Speaker 02 I don't think I can handle this.
4:55 Speaker 01 I understand.
5:02 Speaker 01 She fixed her shit.
5:03 Speaker 02 So I fixed my socks and, uh, but yeah, it was a real moment. And when he, when he walked away, I said, I said, so nice to meet you. And he said, you too. And then he kept walking.
5:12 Speaker 01 I didn't even hear that part.
5:13 Speaker 02 And I said, I can't believe that was the interaction I had with that. It felt right. It did. It really felt right. I don't think I could, I don't know what else I would have said.
5:23 Speaker 01 Al Roker is adorable.
5:24 Speaker 02 I love Al Roker.
5:25 Speaker 01 I've loved Al Roker since I was like born.
5:28 Speaker 02 That's the thing. I was like, this is a deep love and I, I don't feel like I can just say like, wow. And I felt weird being like, wow, I love you. Like I, that's weird.
5:37 Speaker 01 Saying I love Al Roker to Al Roker is much better. I love it. I mean, the first time I met Andrew McMahon, when I was 14 years old, he had lost his voice and I literally just said, I love you. And he was like, he nodded emphatically. He was like, wow.
5:52 Speaker 02 I wish, we have yet to tell that story to his face.
5:56 Speaker 01 He was like, wow, 15 years later, I'll meet you and it will be a lot different. You'll be a little more normal.
6:00 Speaker 02 A little more.
6:01 Speaker 01 A little, just a smidge.
6:02 Speaker 02 Uh, we, we have to tell that story to his face someday.
6:05 Speaker 01 I think we did. I think we did.
6:07 Speaker 02 No, I don't think we did. Cause you were too stressed out.
6:10 Speaker 01 Was I too embarrassed by that?
6:11 Speaker 02 Tell him that story.
6:12 Speaker 01 It was a little embarrassing.
6:13 Speaker 02 And I wasn't gonna out you like that.
6:15 Speaker 01 I thought we told him.
6:16 Speaker 02 No, I don't think we have yet.
6:17 Speaker 01 Andrew?
6:18 Speaker 02 No, but.
6:19 Speaker 01 Question mark.
6:20 Speaker 02 We'll let him know.
6:21 Speaker 01 Well, yeah.
6:22 Speaker 02 Question mark.
6:23 Speaker 01 All right.
6:25 Speaker 02 So when he, yeah.
6:27 Speaker 01 It's so good to be happy.
6:28 Speaker 02 That was, it is nice to be, to be happy and, uh, you know, all that stuff, but it is October.
6:35 Speaker 01 Octobre.
6:36 Speaker 02 It's Proctober. It's not Proctober. Last, last of, um.
6:39 Speaker 01 Yeah, I was like, what are you talking about?
6:41 Speaker 02 It's October. And so we're gonna have a lot of spooky stuff and this is one of them. This is also a little true crimey. Um, it's got a lot of the different elements to it.
6:51 Speaker 01 You get the best. To both worlds.
6:55 Speaker 02 Precisely. So I think you're really gonna like it. Uh, this is Esther Cox and the great Amherst mystery. Also, are you five?
7:07 Speaker 02 Are you a thirteen year old boy?
7:10 Speaker 01 It was just funnier, right?
7:15 Speaker 02 A thirteen year old boy has entered the chat.
7:18 Speaker 01 It was just.
7:19 Speaker 02 Uh, we're in a goofy mood.
7:23 Speaker 02 Alright, so we're gonna, we're gonna get into this, okay? Get your spooky pants on.
7:28 Speaker 01 Girl, they stay on.
7:29 Speaker 02 They are on all year round.
7:30 Speaker 01 Girl, my pants are always spooky.
7:31 Speaker 02 So let's talk about who Esther Cox was. I know.
7:38 Speaker 02 I'm gonna have to say this a lot.
7:40 Speaker 01 It's a great drag name.
7:42 Speaker 02 Alright. Hello? So let's talk about who.
7:49 Speaker 02 Hello? So let's talk about who Esther Cox was.
7:54 Speaker 01 Let's.
7:55 Speaker 02 So Esther was born on March twenty eighth, eighteen sixty. In Upper Stuyac. I looked up how to say it, Stuyac. Um, it's an unincorporated region of southeastern Nova Scotia.
8:08 Speaker 01 Nova Scotia.
8:10 Speaker 02 There you go. Uh, just a few weeks after she was born, though. Tragedy struck because her mom died of an undisclosed illness, which is really sad.
8:18 Speaker 01 Oh damn. I was, yeah, damn.
8:21 Speaker 02 Years after that, Esther's father, Archibald, which is a great name.
8:26 Speaker 01 Archie?
8:27 Speaker 02 Archibald, he remarried and he moved the family to East Machias. I looked up how to say that as well. That's in Maine. Um, that was to live with his new wife, so they all moved in with the new wife.
8:38 Speaker 01 She was nice.
8:39 Speaker 02 Um, there was, there's really like almost no account of Esther's life as a child, because remember it's in the eighteen sixties. Um, but it is known that her father eventually married a third time and that was followed by another move.
8:53 Speaker 01 Dang daddy.
8:54 Speaker 02 Because of all these major events happening in relatively quick succession, it would be pretty fair to say that her childhood was. A lot of upheaval.
9:02 Speaker 01 Yeah.
9:03 Speaker 02 You know what I mean? It wasn't very consistent.
9:04 Speaker 01 Yeah.
9:05 Speaker 02 In the summer of eighteen seventy eight, she was eighteen years old and was living in Amherst, Nova Scotia, in the home of her sister Olive and Olive's husband, Daniel Teed.
9:14 Speaker 01 I think Olive is the cutest name ever.
9:16 Speaker 02 Very cute name. Um, also in the home at this time, um, were Olive and Daniel's two children, five-year-old Willie and one-year-old George.
9:25 Speaker 01 Oh.
9:26 Speaker 02 And Olive and Esther's sister Jenny. So it was a full house.
9:29 Speaker 01 Yeah, a whole shebang.
9:30 Speaker 02 Yeah. Daniel was a shoemaker and a foreman at the local factory, and he was very widely respected around town. Um, they weren't super wealthy, but they were definitely comfortable financially. Author Walter Hubble wrote, "He never owed a dollar to anyone if he could pay it, and never allowed his family to want for any comfort that could be provided by his hard-earned salary."
9:49 Speaker 01 Alright.
9:50 Speaker 02 He was just a good provider.
9:51 Speaker 01 Yeah.
9:51 Speaker 02 Um, in fact, as far as anyone could tell, the house was really happy. It was filled with mutual support, and they all kind of just pitched in whenever they could. It was like a really good little family in there.
10:03 Speaker 01 Yeah, it sounds like it.
10:04 Speaker 02 Now, around town, twenty-two-year-old Jenny Cox, the sister, was considered the, quote, "village belle."
10:10 Speaker 01 Stop it.
10:11 Speaker 02 She was an unmarried woman of what was said to be considerable beauty. Um, Hubble described her as, quote, "quite a beauty, with light brown hair, eyes of grayish blue, and handsome teeth."
10:23 Speaker 01 Handsome teeth? Girl, your teeth is handsome.
10:29 Speaker 02 Handsome teeth.
10:30 Speaker 01 What is that? That's the first thing you said to Drew.
10:32 Speaker 02 Yeah, he, "I said you have handsome teeth, sir." I love Drew's teeth.
10:36 Speaker 01 Yeah, I do too.
10:37 Speaker 02 Yeah, as soon as I saw him, he smiled and I said, "Wow, great teeth."
10:40 Speaker 01 Yeah.
10:41 Speaker 02 And I, I stay, I remain, I stand on that business.
10:44 Speaker 01 Ten toes down.
10:45 Speaker 02 Although we did find out that you don't stand ten toes down.
10:48 Speaker 01 I don't, actually.
10:50 Speaker 02 Literally.
10:50 Speaker 01 We literally, like, did a foot thing at Cole-Han, when it, like, measures your feet.
10:56 Speaker 02 And actually, I do stand ten toes down.
10:58 Speaker 01 Oh, was it Debbie that didn't?
11:00 Speaker 02 Yeah.
11:00 Speaker 01 I think I did.
11:02 Speaker 02 I think you, yeah, you, I stand all on my toes.
11:05 Speaker 01 You are always ten toes down.
11:07 Speaker 02 I am always ten toes down.
11:07 Speaker 01 Debbie was not ten toes down. She was two toes down.
11:09 Speaker 02 Yeah, she was on her heels.
11:11 Speaker 01 I don't remember if I was ten toes down now.
11:13 Speaker 02 Ten toes down.
11:15 Speaker 02 So handsome teeth.
11:16 Speaker 01 Yeah.
11:17 Speaker 02 You know, Esther, on the other hand, was, you know, she wasn't conventional beauty standards did not apply.
11:25 Speaker 01 Well, you know what? Conventional beauty standards be damned.
11:27 Speaker 02 Yeah, she was shorter, you know, she had eyes that Hubble described as as though constantly asking, why do you look at me? Quote, I cannot help being unlike other people.
11:40 Speaker 01 That's how he wrote it.
11:41 Speaker 02 I kind of get it. I cannot help being unlike other people.
11:45 Speaker 01 Honestly?
11:46 Speaker 02 Valid.
11:47 Speaker 01 What it, what does that look like? I'm really trying to like, I'm trying to feel that wash over me. You just kind of look like a bitch when you do that.
11:57 Speaker 02 I mean, that is kind of like, what the fuck are you looking at?
11:59 Speaker 01 Yeah, but was it like, what the fuck are you looking at? Or was it like, oh, don't look at me?
12:03 Speaker 02 I don't know. I'd like to think that she's like, what the fuck are you looking at?
12:05 Speaker 01 Like, good for her.
12:06 Speaker 02 Yeah, but what Esther may have lacked in the conventional beauty side, she more than made up for in reputation in general being disposition.
12:16 Speaker 01 She was nice.
12:17 Speaker 02 She was a very hard worker. She really liked housework, was very good at it. Other domestic chores she was really good at. She was always willing to lend a hand to help out anyone, especially her sister, with any of the domestic responsibilities. She was helpful. She was kind.
12:33 Speaker 02 And she wasn't just popular in her home. She was popular with her peers as well. In his account of the Amherst mystery, Hubble claims Esther, quote, had numbers of friends her own age and was always in demand among the little children of the neighborhood.
12:46 Speaker 01 Oh.
12:46 Speaker 02 She was also very kind with kids.
12:47 Speaker 01 That's cute.
12:49 Speaker 02 And they knew that she would always make time to play with them, which is, that's a good person.
12:55 Speaker 01 Yeah, that absolutely is.
12:56 Speaker 02 All things considered, Esther had what most around Amherst would have considered a good, you know, but simple life.
13:03 Speaker 01 Yeah.
13:04 Speaker 02 Her popularity with her peers and others in town aside, life in Amherst at the end of the 19th century was like, not super exciting for teenage girls, I would say.
13:14 Speaker 01 Yeah.
13:15 Speaker 02 There was monotony with household chores and scheduled trips to church. The most excitement Esther was likely to see was when five-year-old Willie would get in trouble with his mother. For harassing the chickens in the yard by chasing them with a small club or throwing rocks at them.
13:30 Speaker 01 We should probably talk a little bit deeper about that.
13:33 Speaker 02 Thank you. My thoughts here are, are, should we go into Willie and the fact that he may be a little bit of a psychopath? Like, is that something we should maybe look into?
13:42 Speaker 01 Me thinks, yeah.
13:43 Speaker 02 I don't know. In the evenings, when the men would come home from work at the factories, you know, they would come home, they would get dinner. And then the women were expected to clean it all up. So they cooked the dinner, cleaned it all up.
13:53 Speaker 01 Bullshit.
13:54 Speaker 02 Uh, Hubble wrote, "One day was so like another that the week slipped away without perceptible difference," which is like, whoa.
14:01 Speaker 01 That's sad.
14:02 Speaker 02 As one of Canada's most famous ghost stories, the story of the Great Hamhurst Mystery has been told a lot of times over the last century.
14:10 Speaker 01 I don't think I've heard it.
14:10 Speaker 02 Yeah, it's, it's a big story up in Canada. Um, but no matter how or when it's told, it always begins the same way. With one exciting evening that took a very terrible and very heartbreaking turn.
14:22 Speaker 01 Oh, no.
14:23 Speaker 02 According to Esther's brother-in-law, Daniel, on the afternoon of August 28th, 1878, Esther agreed to go for a carriage ride into the Tantramar Marsh with Bob McNeil. He was a local man who, according to Daniel, quote, "had been paying her much attention." The plan was that they were going to drive through town and then come back to the house a short time later. But halfway through their ride, McNeil changed course and drove the wagon towards an isolated grove of trees. Uh, Daniel said, "When they had reached the grove, McNeil dropped the reins, leaped from the buggy and, drawing a large revolver from the side pocket of his coat, pointed it at her heart and commanded her to get out of the buggy, or else he would kill her where she sat."
15:07 Speaker 01 What the fuck?
15:08 Speaker 02 Yeah. Now, what happened next is not exactly known, like the details of, obviously. McNeil either robbed Esther at gunpoint, or he sexually assaulted her, or both.
15:22 Speaker 01 Yeah.
15:22 Speaker 02 Um, it seems like the consensus was that she was absolutely assaulted.
15:27 Speaker 01 Mm-hmm.
15:27 Speaker 02 Um, in Hubble's account of the events, supposedly told to him by Daniel Teed, her brother-in-law, uh, it was nothing, it was, he claims that it was nothing more than aggressive threats.
15:37 Speaker 01 Doubt it.
15:37 Speaker 02 Hubble wrote, "She was very much frightened, but refused to leave the buggy, telling him to get in and drive her home and not act like a madman." McNeil made more threats, but when he heard the sound of another buggy coming down the path, he got back in and drove Esther home without further incident.
15:53 Speaker 01 Oh, I didn't see that coming.
15:55 Speaker 02 Yeah, so he drove her home. When she arrived home, Esther was soaking wet and according to Daniel, quote, "in a hysterical condition from excitement."
16:03 Speaker 01 Yeah, so I would say that she probably didn't just sit on the buggy.
16:06 Speaker 02 No, definitely not. The next day, Bob McNeil left town and was never seen again.
16:10 Speaker 01 What?
16:11 Speaker 02 So he definitely assaulted her.
16:12 Speaker 01 Yeah.
16:13 Speaker 02 There appears to be little information known about Bob McNeil, and since he ran away and never came back. Like many of the young men in Amherst, he was a shoemaker. He worked at the shoe factory managed by Daniel Teed. And according to Hubble, he was a very average height and weight, had black hair and eyes, and wore a mustache.
16:32 Speaker 01 Wore a mustache?
16:34 Speaker 02 He just like, he was that guy. He was that 1800s guy.
16:38 Speaker 01 Wearing mustaches?
16:39 Speaker 02 He, to me, he seems like he looks like every other 1800s guy. Hubble describes him as, quote, "fine-looking."
16:46 Speaker 01 Fine.
16:47 Speaker 02 Just fine-looking.
16:48 Speaker 01 Fine.
16:49 Speaker 02 But when it came to his personality, not so fine. Those who knew him described him as a, quote, "rather a wild fellow," and he had a very cruel disposition.
16:59 Speaker 01 Yeah, I'm sure.
17:00 Speaker 02 In his childhood, he was known to, and this is a big trigger warning for animal cruelty. I'm sorry about it ahead of time. So you can skip probably 10 seconds if you want to.
17:12 Speaker 01 Yeah, do 30, just to be safe.
17:14 Speaker 02 You might as well, just, yeah. In his childhood, Bob was known to, quote, "skin cats alive and allow them to run about and suffer in that condition until death came to their relief."
17:24 Speaker 01 How dare you fucking say that to me?
17:26 Speaker 02 I told you.
17:27 Speaker 01 I can't leave. This is my job.
17:29 Speaker 02 I know.
17:30 Speaker 01 Oh, that's, no. I hope, oh, I hope the same happened to him. I hope he's in hell and it's happening to him all the time.
17:38 Speaker 02 Well, I mean, and Esther didn't know this about him, obviously, like his childhood shit. And so she had always kind of been fond of him, like she found him attractive, you know? We all fall for assholes sometimes.
17:49 Speaker 01 Oh, yeah.
17:50 Speaker 02 But what happened in that grove, whatever it was that happened in that grove that night, changed everything. It had changed her forever.
17:57 Speaker 01 Oh.
17:57 Speaker 02 Now, Esther's experience with Bob had clearly deeply shaken her. And in the days after it, she was depressed. She was very anxious. Like, clearly something bad happened. It wasn't just threats. On the evening of September 4th, she helped her sister with the household chores. Then around 7:00 PM, she said she wasn't feeling that great and went to bed to lie down. Jenny arrived home a few hours later and went up to bed. Uh, it was the room she shared with Esther. And less than an hour had passed when Jenny was jolted out of sleep because Esther was screaming.
18:28 Speaker 01 What?
18:28 Speaker 02 She said she could feel something moving in the mattress.
18:31 Speaker 01 What?
18:31 Speaker 02 Jenny jumped up and lit the lamp and the girls inspected every inch of the bed, but they found nothing.
18:37 Speaker 01 Okay.
18:38 Speaker 02 So this scene replayed itself the next night. With Jenny being woken up by Esther screaming at the top of her lungs. So she's thinking it might be a mouse, so they light the lamp again, investigate the room and find nothing. They even pulled out all the boxes from under the bed. And while they were standing in the middle of the room, Jenny and Esther watched as one of the boxes they'd pulled out from under the bed that contained quilts seemed to jump up and dump its contents onto the floor.
19:05 Speaker 01 What?
19:06 Speaker 02 This caused Esther and Jenny to scream a second time, which drew Daniel from his bedroom. Esther and Jenny explained what they saw, but Daniel just laughed at them. And after pushing everything under the bed, he was like, that was a bad dream. Bye.
19:19 Speaker 01 Yeah.
19:19 Speaker 02 Like, he's like, don't, don't waste my time. This is a lot. The next night Jenny was woken again from sleep for a third night in a row by Esther's screams. And she was screaming, wake up, I'm dying.
19:31 Speaker 01 Oh, fuck.
19:32 Speaker 02 Not wanting to cause another scene, Jenny replied, it's a nightmare. Cause she's like, this is the third night in a row.
19:38 Speaker 01 You gotta go to sleep, girl.
19:38 Speaker 02 But she did get up and light the oil lamp. She was like, it's a nightmare. Like, not a big deal. But as soon as the room was lit, Jenny could see her sister standing in the center of the room and her appearance was terrifying. Her entire body was rigid and contorted and her face was bright red. And her eyes appeared to be bulging out of her head.
19:58 Speaker 01 What the fuck?
19:59 Speaker 02 And she was gripping the back of a chair so hard, her fingernails left impressions in the wood.
20:05 Speaker 01 What?
20:06 Speaker 02 So Jenny again screamed for Daniel and Olive and they burst in a minute later. And as they burst in, Daniel and Olive managed to catch a glimpse of Esther's twisted body just before she went completely white and collapsed on the floor.
20:20 Speaker 01 Okay.
20:22 Speaker 02 Daniel helped her get back to her feet and back to bed, but she had barely laid down before she was on her feet again, screaming that she quote, felt as though she was about to burst into pieces.
20:32 Speaker 01 Uh oh.
20:33 Speaker 02 Which is so fucking scary.
20:35 Speaker 01 I just picture like ready or not.
20:36 Speaker 02 Right? They helped her to bed a second time, but all three couldn't help but notice that she looked like she was swelling up. Like, right in front of them. When she's saying, I'm gonna burst into pieces, and now she's swelling.
20:49 Speaker 01 This is horrifying. I've never heard anything like this.
20:52 Speaker 02 Daniel said to, uh, Olive, lay your hand on her. She's as hot as fire.
20:56 Speaker 01 What?
20:56 Speaker 02 Olive had barely reached out her hand. When out of nowhere, the house started shaking violently, as though it had been struck by lightning.
21:04 Speaker 01 No.
21:05 Speaker 02 And they heard a loud bang come from underneath the bed.
21:08 Speaker 01 No.
21:08 Speaker 02 Then, just as suddenly as it all started, the chaos just abruptly ended. And the house was quiet, and Esther's appearance returned to normal. A little pale, but normal.
21:17 Speaker 01 A little pale.
21:18 Speaker 02 A little pale. She didn't look great.
21:19 Speaker 01 Lost, lost a little color.
21:22 Speaker 02 Yeah, she lost a little color.
21:23 Speaker 01 What?
21:24 Speaker 02 Yeah.
21:25 Speaker 01 Hello?
21:26 Speaker 02 Right? Now, the next day, Esther slept later than usual. She got out of bed a little past nine AM.
21:33 Speaker 01 Crazy.
21:34 Speaker 02 But otherwise, she looked and felt normal, and it didn't seem as though there were any lingering effects to whatever had struck her the night before. Later that day, the family sat around the dinner table discussing what the fuck happened that, because this wasn't something. Luckily, this isn't one of those stories where there's like, wow, I guess we should just move on and never talk about that. No, they sat at dinner and they were like, so what the fuck was that last night? Like, what's going on? And they were like, what should we do about this?
21:59 Speaker 01 Yeah, like, why does this keep happening?
22:00 Speaker 02 But the conversation kind of just went nowhere, because like, what do you do? They all agreed no one would, would believe their story if they told it. And even if they did, again, what would anyone do about it?
22:11 Speaker 01 Yeah.
22:21 Speaker 02 Did you know that you can actually try rug colors in your own house before you even commit to them? Well, you can, for ten dollars. I, whenever I have decided that, like, oh, I need to upgrade a rug, or we move, and I need to get different rugs, I put off buying rugs, because in my mind, for some reason, you always have to buy it, and then it gets in the room, and you might not necessarily like it, or this color doesn't work with that color. But with Ernesta rugs.
22:47 Speaker 01 You can get five samples for $10 plus a $50 credit toward any rug that you end up liking. Designer quality, hand-selected by design experts, good housekeeping, home renovation, awards winner. Over 200 styles in wool, jute, sisal, and performance materials. The samples are oversized 12 by 12 squares so that you can see the color at full scale instead of on your computer screen. And you can actually literally move it around and put it up next to other things in your house and compare like, oh, do I like these colors together or do they clash? Seeing samples in the morning light too versus lamplight, that's super beneficial. And you can also see how that color of the rug might change in the room when it's actually next to the sofa. That's a game changer.
23:31 Speaker 01 The rugs are custom sized to the inch, made for your exact space, not just close enough. They're cut, finished, and delivered in as little as two weeks. Check for an Ernesta showroom in your area to see the styles in person. Visit ernesta.com and order five samples for only $10 and you'll get $50 toward any rug of your choice. That's E R N E S T A dot com.
23:57 Speaker 01 We know that the gut does a lot more than just help us digest our food. Everything is about the gut microbiome. It's like, I think your brain is connected to your gut microbiome. I'm hearing a lot about the gut microbiome lately and I want to keep mine in check, honey. There's growing research around how the microbiome is connected to things like immunity and mental well-being too. So if you're looking for digestive support, which I kind of feel like we all are at this point, Ritual has got your back, or rather, your biome with Symbiotic Plus. Symbiotic Plus is a three-in-one powerhouse of clinically studied pre, pro, and post-biotics to support a balanced gut microbiome with daily use. One daily mint essenced capsule for blow gut regularity support.
24:37 Speaker 01 Plus, it's vegan-friendly, it's formulated without GMOs, no major allergens, no animal products, no shady fillers or artificial colors. I have been taking Symbiotic Plus for a while now. I just know that I'm a girly who needs a probiotic. And then I said, why not pre and post and all of the above, just to make sure that biome- Was in check, honey. And I have always, always, always heard really, really great things about Ritual. So I started taking Symbiotic Plus and I definitely am a much more regular girly because of it. And, you know, I, I thank them deeply for that. I also love, I've again, always heard good things about Ritual. And one of my favorite things about the company is that they don't put those shady fillers in. They don't put those GMOs in.
25:20 Speaker 01 It's a nice, like, you know what's in the product. Support a balanced gut microbiome with Ritual Symbiotic Plus. Save 25% on your first month at ritual.com/morbid. That's ritual.com/morbid for 25% off your first month. Chilling crime cases are mysterious, but finding coverage shouldn't be. With the State Farm Personal Price Plan, you have options and can personalize your plan to help create an affordable price. So you can get back to cracking all of life's bigger cases. Talk to a State Farm agent today to learn how you can choose to bundle and save with the Personal Price Plan. Like a good neighbor, State Farm is there. Head to statefarm.com to get a quote.
26:02 Speaker 01 Prices are based on rating plans that vary by state. Coverage options are selected by the customer. Availability, amount of discounts and savings and eligibility vary by state.
26:16 Speaker 02 So days passed with no other activity, but one night in mid-September, Esther was getting ready for bed when she began to feel hot. Fearing again, that this could be happening again, she managed to make it to the bed and wake Jenny before she felt her body go rigid and start to swell again.
26:33 Speaker 01 Oh, no.
26:34 Speaker 02 Moments later, Jenny was by her side, trying to speak softly and like, just trying to calm her down and like, telling her to like, please remain calm. And she was like, hopefully this is just gonna pass really quickly. Esther did, as her sister suggested, so she tried to just remain still.
26:48 Speaker 01 Yeah.
26:48 Speaker 02 But because she wasn't reacting, it only seemed to make things worse. It was like her not reacting to it was making it worse somehow. So she's laying still and Esther and Jenny watched in amazement as the blankets and sheets started stripping themselves from the bed. Landing across the room in a pile by the door.
27:06 Speaker 01 Mm hmm.
27:06 Speaker 02 Like just flinging across the room. The experience clearly was terrifying, so both of them just start screaming because they don't know what else to do. Just before Jenny fainted beside Esther's bed.
27:18 Speaker 01 Oh, wow.
27:19 Speaker 02 Now, as they had before, Esther and Jenny screams brought the rest of the family running into the room. And they found Jenny collapsed and unconscious on the floor beside Esther, who was now laying unmoving and swollen on her bed.
27:32 Speaker 01 What the hell is happening here?
27:35 Speaker 02 They saw that the sheets and blankets were all in a heap on the floor. And this was very nice of them, not wanting her sisters to be exposed in their underclothes.
27:43 Speaker 01 Oh.
27:44 Speaker 02 Olive grabbed the blankets and placed one on Esther and another on Jenny. But as soon as she laid them across them, the blankets flew up into the air and across the room again.
27:52 Speaker 01 They said, no comforts for you.
27:54 Speaker 02 They said, no.
27:55 Speaker 01 Your underoos will be seen.
27:57 Speaker 02 Your underoos.
27:58 Speaker 01 Underpants.
28:00 Speaker 02 Now, after the.
28:02 Speaker 01 Underpants were exposed.
28:05 Speaker 02 You're so good at that.
28:07 Speaker 01 Underpants.
28:08 Speaker 02 Underpants. After they were exposed again, there was a series of loud bangs, all seeming to come from under the bed again. And all loud enough to shake the entire room.
28:19 Speaker 01 Is this man's under the bed?
28:21 Speaker 02 Then, Jesus, then like before, everything came to an abrupt stop. And Esther regained her composure and her appearance was once again relatively normal, probably a little pale.
28:31 Speaker 01 Yeah.
28:32 Speaker 02 And Jenny regained consciousness, though she said she had a fierce headache.
28:36 Speaker 01 I mean, I would think.
28:37 Speaker 02 Now, Daniel Teed had no fucking clue what was happening in his house at this point.
28:42 Speaker 01 A bunch of tomfoolery, I bet he thought.
28:44 Speaker 02 A fucking chicanery.
28:46 Speaker 01 Yeah.
28:47 Speaker 02 Uh, but at the very least, he knew it was having a physical effect on Esther. Um, and had begun to affect Jenny at this point as well. So concerned for them, he went into town the next day and spoke to Dr. Carey, the town physician.
28:59 Speaker 01 Hmm.
29:00 Speaker 02 Um, as he'd expected, the doctor didn't believe the story at all.
29:03 Speaker 01 The doctor said, you're cuckoo nuts.
29:04 Speaker 02 Even laughed in his face about it, which I was like, I don't know if you had to do that.
29:08 Speaker 01 That's a little bit rude.
29:09 Speaker 02 I don't know, is that part of your oath? What?
29:11 Speaker 01 Probably, uh, did they take the oath back then?
29:13 Speaker 02 Uh, probably. It's pretty old, Hippocratic oath.
29:16 Speaker 01 It's fucking old.
29:17 Speaker 02 Um, but still, Dr. Curry agreed to pay a visit to the house the next afternoon, but added that, quote, what Daniel had told him was nonsense and that he, quote, knew no such tomfoolery would occur while he was in the house.
29:30 Speaker 01 Bitch, I done told you.
29:31 Speaker 02 Dr. Koreet arrived at the teed house the next day and examined Esther. At the time, she was showing no signs of swelling, muscle rigidity, or tremors that they talked about the previous night, but she was feeling kinda shitty, like just unwell.
29:45 Speaker 01 Well, she also hasn't been sleeping.
29:46 Speaker 02 Yeah, and after looking at her over and asking a few questions, Dr. Koreet concluded Esther, quote, "seemed to be suffering from nervous excitement and had evidently received a tremendous shock of some kind."
29:59 Speaker 01 Okay.
30:00 Speaker 02 It's basically what they would always say to like, "Oh, this woman's hysterical."
30:03 Speaker 01 Yep. She's got the vapors.
30:04 Speaker 02 She's got nervous excitement, this one.
30:06 Speaker 01 She's just been doing too much.
30:08 Speaker 02 The doctor had just finished delivering this bullshit diagnosis to the family when, without warning, the pillow where Esther was laying came out from under her and flew across the room. And it looked like it as if it was pulled from by someone invisible out from under her. I like to think it was Esther as soon as this doctor turned around, just fucking launched that pillow at his head.
30:30 Speaker 01 Yeah, I like that.
30:31 Speaker 02 Cause I probably would. But no sooner had they put the pillow back under Esther's head, it flew out from her a second time, leaving Dr. Koreet completely stunned.
30:40 Speaker 01 Who's laughing at who?
30:42 Speaker 02 The doctor jumped up from his chair, but was quickly caught off guard by the sound of loud thumps coming from somewhere in the room. Before he could say anything, the sheets and blankets that had been covering Esther then flew off and landed in a pile again. And the activity was followed by an awful sound of metallic grinding that filled the room. Everyone in the room stared at each other like, what the fuck is going on? Hearing this like metallic grinding sound, which would sound so scary in that moment, having no like origin.
31:14 Speaker 01 Right. And just shits flying around the room.
31:17 Speaker 02 Well, then it's, and this, this is what is documented about it. Then they watched in absolute amazement as writing began to appear on the wall above Esther's head, and it said, "Esther Cox, you are mine to kill."
31:30 Speaker 01 What?
31:31 Speaker 02 Yeah.
31:33 Speaker 02 Exclamation point.
31:34 Speaker 01 Of course.
31:35 Speaker 02 Uh, uh, what?
31:38 Speaker 01 What?
31:38 Speaker 02 What?
31:40 Speaker 01 Hello?
31:40 Speaker 02 So obviously, everyone freaked the fuck out. And this isn't one of those situations where everyone was like, Esther Cox, you are mine to kill. Oh, no, what happened? No, they scattered everywhere. They all just went fucking running. They're like, fuck that.
31:54 Speaker 01 I'd run.
31:54 Speaker 02 They were checking on the children, because remember, there's children in this house.
31:57 Speaker 01 Oh, poor little babies.
31:58 Speaker 02 Checking on the children, looking for any sign of who could have written those words. And they were unable to find any evidence that anyone else in the house wrote it. When they returned to Esther's bedroom, a large chunk of plaster fell from the ceiling, just missing the doctor and landing at his feet.
32:13 Speaker 01 What the fuck is happening?
32:16 Speaker 02 To their amazement, Esther was still asleep at this point in her bed. Completely oblivious to all of it.
32:21 Speaker 01 Said, I gotta catch these, these are where I can get them.
32:23 Speaker 02 That's, I mean, I get that, girl.
32:25 Speaker 01 Said, honey.
32:26 Speaker 02 So the doctor returned to the house the next day to see Esther, who appeared to be completely unaffected by everything that had happened. But she was definitely more nervous than usual and would, quote, "jump at any noise."
32:38 Speaker 01 Um, because somebody said that they were gonna kill her.
32:40 Speaker 02 Yeah, I mean, there's that. The doctor returned several times in the weeks after this, during all which he would witness a variety of strange things, like flying objects, loud noises heard from all over the house. Eventually, the loud thumping, thumping sounds became so loud and lasted so long, they could be heard from outside the house.
33:00 Speaker 01 These poor kids were probably so scared.
33:02 Speaker 02 One reporter wrote, because this was like in newspapers. One reporter wrote, "Passersby, stop to listen." And the next day, the town buzzed with the story of the haunted house.
33:12 Speaker 01 What?
33:13 Speaker 02 So other people are hearing this.
33:14 Speaker 01 Okay.
33:15 Speaker 02 Despite all the attention Esther was getting from the people of Amherst, it seemed that no one, including Dr. Koreet, was able to explain what the fuck was happening to Esther and why.
33:24 Speaker 01 Yeah.
33:25 Speaker 02 In early October, Dr. Edwin Clay, the local Baptist minister, visited the house and examined Esther. He couldn't find any obvious explanation for the haunting. And he concluded Esther, quote, "must be possessed of an extraordinary amount of electrical power."
33:40 Speaker 01 Uh, okay.
33:42 Speaker 02 Nailed it.
33:43 Speaker 01 He said, "This bitch is the grid."
33:45 Speaker 02 The grid, right here. Dr. Karid agreed. He was like, "Absolutely."
33:49 Speaker 01 The grid.
33:50 Speaker 02 Yes, the grid. He was like, "You know what? The discharge of such great electricity must be the cause of the flying objects, the loud noises and the physical symptoms."
34:01 Speaker 01 And the weird writing on the wall that we saw that said it was gonna kill her.
34:04 Speaker 02 When it came to what to do, though, they had no fucking clue. They were just like, "Electricity, see you later. Good luck."
34:11 Speaker 01 Okay.
34:12 Speaker 02 Now, in time, Esther and Teed, in the Teed's house, became the biggest story in Amherst. Crowds gathered outside the house, trying to gain any kind of glimpse at any of the paranormal stuff going on, or hear any of the noises. Eventually, the audiences became so large that Daniel Teed couldn't disperse them on his own, and he had to call the police. At the same time, Esther's physical health continued to decline. In December, she came down with diphtheria and was confined to her bed for two weeks. During this time, the activity ceased entirely.
34:45 Speaker 02 Once she was recovered, she went to visit another sister who lived in Sackville, New Brunswick, for two weeks. The entire time she was away, nothing unusual happened at the Teed house.
34:57 Speaker 02 Based on that, everyone concluded, which I get, that whatever was happening, it must have been focused entirely on Esther.
35:04 Speaker 01 Yeah.
35:05 Speaker 02 That being said, while she was away in Sackville, Esther herself didn't experience any unusual phenomenon, and she said she was free from physical pain that had been inflicted on her for three months at this point.
35:16 Speaker 01 Yeah.
35:17 Speaker 02 So when Esther returned to the house after being away for a few weeks, everyone hoped the ghost, or demon, or whatever the fuck this thing was-
35:24 Speaker 01 The grid.
35:24 Speaker 02 -would have been left behind. Just in case, while she was away, Jenny and Olive relocated Esther and Jenny's bedroom to the other side of the house, hoping the new location might also aid in keeping this away.
35:36 Speaker 01 Yeah.
35:38 Speaker 02 Unfortunately, it didn't take long for them to realize that all of these hopes and all these efforts had been in vain, because not only did it return, the activity, with Esther, it was stronger and more aggressive than it had ever been.
35:49 Speaker 01 Oh, shit.
35:50 Speaker 02 The first night she was back in her own bed, Esther told Jenny she could hear a voice talking to her, and she believed it was the spirit who'd been tormenting her. The disembodied voice told Esther, quote, "It had once lived on the earth, but had been dead for some years and was now only a ghost."
36:06 Speaker 01 Metal.
36:06 Speaker 02 Very metal. And maybe more disturbing was the fact that according to the spirit, the house was going to be set on fire that night by another ghost who haunted the property.
36:16 Speaker 01 It it went too far.
36:17 Speaker 02 So this ghost is spilling the tea.
36:21 Speaker 01 Said my guy over here.
36:22 Speaker 02 He said, you know what I heard?
36:23 Speaker 01 Big arsonist.
36:24 Speaker 02 You know what I heard them talking about at the water cooler?
36:28 Speaker 02 Uh, so that's scary. So Esther and Jenny informed the rest of the household, hey, our house is going to be lit on fire by, uh,
36:35 Speaker 01 A water cooler ghost.
36:36 Speaker 02 An acquaintance of the ghost that is currently haunting us. Uh, but everyone just laughed at her, which I was like, I don't know, at this point, maybe.
36:43 Speaker 01 Uh, yeah, that's like, like you've seen miraculous things happen and now she's telling you fire is gonna happen.
36:47 Speaker 02 They were all like, no, this is crazy. It's going too far. Uh, none of them, you know, had been able to explain what they'd seen or heard in the house, but they firmly believed in Dr. Kari and Reverend, Reverend Clay's explanation. That it was just stored up energy and there was nothing to be scared of.
37:03 Speaker 01 That's insane.
37:04 Speaker 02 Took that as like, that's the, that's the answer.
37:06 Speaker 01 Bubble.
37:06 Speaker 02 According to Hubble, as they all stood together in the bedroom trying to calm Esther and Jenny, they quote, all saw a lighted match fall from the ceiling to the bed, having come out of the air.
37:18 Speaker 01 What? How, I'm, okay, here's the thing. I'm going to be honest with you. I'm trying to figure out how they could pull this off.
37:24 Speaker 02 Yeah.
37:25 Speaker 01 And I can't.
37:26 Speaker 02 And they're all seeing it.
37:27 Speaker 01 Figure it out.
37:28 Speaker 02 These people are like, the rest of the family is like calling the police when people show up and stuff like they, they don't want big crowds, like, and they're not enjoying this. But they're all saying they're seeing this.
37:39 Speaker 01 Yeah.
37:40 Speaker 02 Like. And Jenny luckily acted really quickly to like, uh, distinguish the mass, but that isn't extinguish, that's what it is.
37:49 Speaker 01 Why did I say just, she could not tell what the fire was?
37:52 Speaker 02 It says, it says distinguish, so you are not the only one. Um, so Jenny acted really quickly and extinguished the match just as it hit the bedclothes. Because it would have lit the whole bed on fire.
38:02 Speaker 01 Yeah.
38:03 Speaker 02 So it would have lit the house on fire.
38:04 Speaker 01 Yeah.
38:05 Speaker 02 Now regardless of what the rest of the family believed, Esther and Jenny were convinced that the thing that tormented them was a motherfucking ghost. Uh, also, they believed that it had its own kind of sentience and could hear and see everything that happened in the house. And if that were true, Jenny thought, then it logically followed that they could potentially communicate back with it.
38:24 Speaker 01 Yeah.
38:25 Speaker 02 If it can see us and it's telling us things, why can't we tell it things?
38:28 Speaker 01 Yeah.
38:29 Speaker 02 So upon suggesting this very thing to Dr. Karit, the statement was immediately followed by three loud knocks from the floor.
38:37 Speaker 01 It said, hey, what's good?
38:39 Speaker 02 It's like, it's like the spirit was like, hell yeah, brother. In response, Dr. Karit asked whether the spirit could hear and understand what they were saying, and the question was heard with more loud knocks. What followed was a series of questions from the family, which were answered by the spirit.
38:57 Speaker 01 He said, I, I have what you need.
38:59 Speaker 02 There were different, they tried to get like a system going where it was like one knock for no, three knocks for yes, kind of thing. It was able to answer various yes or no questions, indicating how many rooms there were in the house, and provide several other responses that supported Esther and Jenny's belief that it was more than just discharged energy. When Daniel asked whether the house was really going to be set on fire, the spirit gave three knocks, which is yes.
39:24 Speaker 01 Hell yeah, brother.
39:25 Speaker 02 Immediately after, the stunned family members watched as a dress flew from the closet and landed under the bed, where it just caught fire. By completely unknown means.
39:36 Speaker 01 Sporadically.
39:37 Speaker 02 Sporadically combusted.
39:40 Speaker 01 Okay.
39:41 Speaker 02 Just all up in there.
39:42 Speaker 01 Alrighty.
39:43 Speaker 02 Fortunately, Daniel was able to remove the dress from the bed and extinguish those flames as well before any damage to the house was done. Now, perhaps the most like, interesting and curious aspect of the whole situation was the wild shifts in temperament from one moment to the next.
40:01 Speaker 01 Yeah.
40:01 Speaker 02 Because at some point, the spirit communication was calm and very even, and it came off like... Kind of benevolent and helpful at times. Um, like it would warn the family, like when it warned the family members about the fire or it would warn them about something else. Other times, though, it seemed to mock them all, writing cruel and profane messages on the wall or seizing Esther with seizures and stomach pains that lasted for days.
40:27 Speaker 01 Yeah.
40:28 Speaker 02 It feels like there was two, like that ghost was saying.
40:30 Speaker 01 Yeah.
40:31 Speaker 02 Like when they, when she claimed she heard it talking to her, that there's another one.
40:35 Speaker 01 Good cop, bad cop kind of thing.
40:37 Speaker 02 Now, outside the teat house, the neighbors were beginning to arrive at their own conclusions about the haunting. Some accepted the girl's story entirely, believing the house was beset upon by ghosts. Others put the theory forth that Corrit and Clay seemed plausible, like the electrical energy idea.
40:55 Speaker 01 Okay.
40:56 Speaker 02 But then there was another group who was very skeptical and found the whole thing completely impossible.
41:01 Speaker 01 Which I get.
41:01 Speaker 02 Absolutely. They believed that rather than being tormented by ghosts, Esther was being tormented by a human being, specifically Bob McNeil.
41:10 Speaker 01 Where's he at?
41:11 Speaker 02 So, one reporter wrote, "Some say that the controlling agent in these phenomena is not a spirit, but a young man who is in a distant part of the province." According to that journalist, the individual is, quote, "A person whom Esther has regarded with a strong dislike, and prior to her illness, he is said to have talked to her in such a violent and extraordinary way as to cause her much alarm and leave a vivid impression on her mind."
41:36 Speaker 01 Yeah, he just talked to her, you guys.
41:38 Speaker 02 Yeah, he just talked to her really violently. All things considered, the people of Amherst had pretty good reason to be skeptical of the whole thing, of course. If she had just been like a victim of the strange events happening in the house, that would be one thing, but she kind of was part of it a little bit, passively at times. Like, um, when the entity would want to write like inappropriate and vulgar shit on the wall, it would do so through Esther.
42:02 Speaker 01 Huh.
42:03 Speaker 02 So it would tell her what to write and where to write it.
42:07 Speaker 01 Okay.
42:08 Speaker 02 So she's like actively part of this, at least, whether she's being controlled or not.
42:13 Speaker 01 So like when it said like, I'm Esther is mine to kill. She's the one that wrote that?
42:18 Speaker 02 That's not documented, but other times she was.
42:21 Speaker 01 Okay.
42:22 Speaker 02 So in early 1879, the skeptical position was given a little more credence when, after being sedated by Dr. Corrit during a really bad episode of stomach pain, Esther, quote, fell into a cataleptic trance during which she told all of Jenny, Daniel and the doctor about what had happened between her and Bob McNeil. According to Esther, Bob had, quote, unsuccessfully tried to assault her and they had a violent quarrel.
42:48 Speaker 01 Yeah.
42:49 Speaker 02 Um, just before he had vanished to Amherst, from Amherst. So after hearing this story, Olive remarked, it's Bob McNeil who's caused all this trouble. And from out of nowhere, they heard three short, sharp knocks.
43:01 Speaker 01 So, yes.
43:02 Speaker 02 So it's like, what the fuck?
43:03 Speaker 01 Where's Bob?
43:05 Speaker 02 Now, in January 1879, the noises, fires and constant public attention finally became way too much for Daniel and Olive Teed. And it was decided that it would be best for everyone if Esther moved out.
43:16 Speaker 01 Oh, that's so fucking mean. They said, we're done with all this. You gotta get the, we don't know what's going on.
43:23 Speaker 02 We've had enough of your shit.
43:24 Speaker 01 But truly, we really don't care. Please go.
43:26 Speaker 02 Yeah, we do not, we don't want to deal with this anymore. Simply don't. Um, so fortunately, she was quickly able to find new accommodations with a local couple.
43:35 Speaker 01 Okay.
43:36 Speaker 02 Named John White and his wife.
43:38 Speaker 01 Shut the fu- and Elena Urquhart.
43:40 Speaker 02 We let her in, okay?
43:42 Speaker 01 Yeah.
43:42 Speaker 02 We gave her shelter.
43:43 Speaker 01 You kind souls.
43:44 Speaker 02 Me and John White. At first, everything in Esther's new home seemed quiet and calm because we're great. Uh, but within two weeks, the activity started again.
43:53 Speaker 01 Okay.
43:54 Speaker 02 So terrified by the phenomenon, John's wife, me, insisted that Esther needed to fucking go.
44:00 Speaker 01 Oh, I mean.
44:01 Speaker 02 So she ended up spending most of her time living and working at the Whites Restaurant in town, where the noises continued to be heard and objects continued to fly across the room.
44:11 Speaker 01 Weird.
44:12 Speaker 02 It's all, it's like a poltergeist.
44:13 Speaker 01 Yeah, very much so.
44:14 Speaker 02 By the summer of 1879, the- The story of Esther Cox and the Great Amherst Mystery had spread all across Nova Scotia, thanks to curious journalists and others with, you know, an interest in the supernatural. Eventually, the story made its way to Walter Hubble, who we've cited a number of times, who spent the winter performing with an acting troupe in Halifax. And when spring had arrived, he was looking for a new subject for a book. Now, for most of his life, Hubble had been a writer and actor, just, you know, nothing to write home about. Had it not been for Esther's story, it's likely he wouldn't really be remembered publicly for for those two tasks.
44:53 Speaker 01 Yeah.
44:53 Speaker 02 But Hubble had always had a strong interest in paranormal activity, happenings. So when he read about Esther's plight, he really wanted to visit her. So he made arrangements, too.
45:03 Speaker 01 He said, I gotta see this bitch.
45:04 Speaker 02 He said, let me see what's going on right now. So he arrived in Amherst on June 11th, 1879, and his first stop was the Teed House, where he was introduced to Esther. He wrote Esther was very self-possessed and appeared to be in excellent health. By that time, Esther and the rest of the family had started referring to the ghosts in the house as Bob Nichol and Maggie Fisher.
45:26 Speaker 01 Okay.
45:27 Speaker 02 Which I kind of love.
45:28 Speaker 01 I do, too.
45:30 Speaker 02 I don't know why.
45:30 Speaker 01 There's Bob and there's Maggie.
45:31 Speaker 02 Yeah. At least these were the two most prominent ghosts in the house, but according to Esther, there were others. According to Esther, quote, "Bob and Maggie informed her it would be all right for her to share her story."
45:44 Speaker 01 Okay.
45:44 Speaker 02 They said, it's cool, you can talk to people.
45:55 Speaker 03 This episode is sponsored by Stella Rosa. Weirdos, Mikey here. After all the murder, mayhem, and deeply unsettling stories, sometimes a palate cleanser is exactly what you need. Stella Rosa Black is a semi-sweet, semi-sparkling red wine with ripe blackberry, blueberry, and raspberry flavors. It's dark, fruity, and honestly feels extremely appropriate for weirdos like you and me. Like, if a wine was going to join you for a creepy story at night, obviously it would be this one. Then there's Stella Rosa Moscato di Asti, a semi-sweet, semi-sparkling wine with ripe pear and apple flavors. It's lighter, bright, and basically the perfect palate cleanser to have after spending an hour discussing something deeply disturbing.
46:41 Speaker 03 I am not a huge fan of dry wine. I can't have things that taste like the barrel that they were stored in. I just like something sweet. I love the sweet things in life. And the best part about Stella Rosa is that it also is sparkling. I love me some sparkling water and I love sparkling wine. It's so refreshing and bright and it's so delicious. It's the perfect way to end a meal. I absolutely love it. Find Stella Rosa at stellarosa.com or at your local retailer. You must be 21 plus to drink responsibly.
47:20 Speaker 01 You know that feeling when you come home late from work and those puppy dog eyes just pierce right through your soul? Or when you're packing for a trip and your cat refuses to leave your suitcase? Yeah, we've all been there. Pet parent guilt is real. And you know what? It's completely normal. That's exactly why Hill's Pet Nutrition exists. They understand that being a pet parent means being human with all of our imperfections and daily juggling acts. Hill's science-led nutrition helps you give more love than humanly possible. Whether it's those long workdays or trying to balance attention between multiple pets, Hill's Pet Nutrition gets it. They've created science-based nutrition that supports your pet's lifelong health, so you can feel confident even when life gets hectic. Because you're only human, there's Hill's. Science does more. Ready to let go of the guilt? Find
48:04 Speaker 01 the right food at hillspet.com/podcast. That's hillspet.com/podcast. Chilling crime cases are mysterious, but finding coverage shouldn't be. With the State Farm Personal Price Plan, you have options and can personalize your plan to help create an affordable price, so you can get back to cracking all of life's bigger cases. Talk to a State Farm agent today to learn how you can choose to bundle and save with the Personal Price Plan. Like a good neighbor, State Farm is there. Head to statefarm.com to get a quote. Prices are based on rating plans that vary by state. Coverage options are selected by the customer. Availability, amount of discounts and savings, and eligibility vary by state.
48:51 Speaker 02 Ultimately, Hubble spent a little more than a month investigating the haunting of Esther Cox. And he admitted at first, he was very skeptical of her claims.
48:58 Speaker 01 Yeah, me too.
48:59 Speaker 02 In fact, his plan was to spend enough time with Esther to gather evidence of fraud and then expose her as a hoax.
49:06 Speaker 01 Oh dang.
49:06 Speaker 02 That was what he was going for.
49:08 Speaker 01 Dang Walter.
49:08 Speaker 02 I mean, he was like, I think it's fake and I'm gonna expose your ass. But Hubble said, I was willing to acknowledge that there might be a power of some kind about the girl. But of course, nothing supernatural. However, his supposed skepticism soon fell away when that evening at dinner, they were all seated around the table and they started to hear knocks.
49:29 Speaker 02 He said, we could all hear even the scratching sounds of invisible human fingernails and the dull sounds produced by the hands. As they rubbed the table and struck it with invisible clenched fists.
49:40 Speaker 01 Oh.
49:41 Speaker 02 So now convinced that what he was seeing was in fact real, Hubble immediately started booking a lecture tour for himself. And asked Esther if she would be willing to join him.
49:51 Speaker 01 He said, I gotta spread the good word, Esther.
49:53 Speaker 02 Yeah, he said, let's go. And Esther was like, hell yeah, let's go.
49:56 Speaker 01 Okay. I don't know what to make of this story.
49:58 Speaker 02 Nobody really does. Because by that time, she'd been asked to move out of her home and was living primarily in a small room at a restaurant.
50:06 Speaker 01 It's truly my favorite thing that they were like, yeah, sorry for what you're experiencing, but like, bye.
50:11 Speaker 02 John White and his wife, you know, they were like, ooh.
50:13 Speaker 01 It only went so far. She got kicked out twice.
50:15 Speaker 02 Yeah, she did.
50:16 Speaker 01 Her own family and them.
50:17 Speaker 02 She was starting to also face some hostility from the locals because they'd grown tired of all the attention that was happening around town. They just didn't want it anymore.
50:25 Speaker 01 God forbid a woman, a woman get attention.
50:28 Speaker 02 The tour began in mid-June with their first stop in Moncton. Unfortunately, Esther's ghosts appeared to have come along for the ride, though. And made themselves known before the speaking event even began, the first one. They caused chairs in the auditorium to move on their own. And I guess this is like, kind of fortunately for their, their plight.
50:48 Speaker 01 Yeah.
50:48 Speaker 02 Like, kind of sucks because they're fucking with the, with the whole show.
50:51 Speaker 01 Yeah.
50:53 Speaker 02 This delighted some in the crowd.
50:55 Speaker 01 I'd be delighted.
50:56 Speaker 02 Others became annoyed, particularly once it became clear that the spirits, spirits couldn't be controlled. So they were just like, really fucking up the whole thing.
51:03 Speaker 01 That would make me even more excited.
51:04 Speaker 02 I would love it.
51:05 Speaker 01 I'd be like, oh my god.
51:06 Speaker 02 During a church service, the day after the lecture, Esther was asked to leave after the service became interrupted when, according to the local press. Quote, "The ghost manifested itself by knocking on the floor of the pew in front." Which like, she can't do that.
51:22 Speaker 01 Yeah, that's the, how would she?
51:24 Speaker 02 Like, how is she interrupting all this shit?
51:26 Speaker 01 And church, I'm like, damn, you know no bounds, Esther's ghost.
51:29 Speaker 02 The diamond, I think. No, not long after their first lecture date, the tour began falling apart. During their travels, Esther repeatedly experienced a lot of physical symptoms like swelling, vomiting, and muscle rigidity.
51:42 Speaker 01 Ooh.
51:43 Speaker 02 Uh, each time she was evaluated by a doctor and they all said, you know, more or less the same thing, that she was suffering from symptoms of over excitement.
51:51 Speaker 01 Okay.
51:52 Speaker 02 But poor health was not the only problem that was happening. In each town they stopped at, advanced word of their arrival had given the local religious organizations time to organize a protest. Even back then, they were, they were at it.
52:06 Speaker 01 They were back at it.
52:07 Speaker 02 And Esther and Hubble were met with strong opposition in their spiritualist message. Uh, in a letter to the editor of one paper, a Presbyterian group wrote, "In the humanity propriety, religion and decency, we earnestly protest against a proceeding so base and disgusting. The civil authorities ought to interfere."
52:27 Speaker 01 It's like, girl, what are they supposed to do?
52:29 Speaker 02 And they're just telling you stuff.
52:31 Speaker 01 Yeah.
52:31 Speaker 02 They're just informing you of what's going on with her.
52:34 Speaker 01 Maybe exorcise her. Band together and exorcise the bitch.
52:37 Speaker 02 You know what you can do? Just not listen to her.
52:39 Speaker 01 Yeah, just fuck off.
52:40 Speaker 02 You could do that, the same thing that applies to social media now, applied to this then. If you don't fucking like it,
52:50 Speaker 01 Listen.
52:50 Speaker 02 don't listen to her.
52:52 Speaker 01 Yeah, it's pretty simple.
52:54 Speaker 02 That fucking hard, but instead they're like, no one can listen.
52:58 Speaker 01 People were hate-listening back then, too.
52:59 Speaker 02 It's true, they were.
53:00 Speaker 01 Yeah.
53:01 Speaker 02 Just in a total different way.
53:02 Speaker 01 There's always gonna be a subgroup of hate, like,
53:04 Speaker 02 Always.
53:05 Speaker 01 Hate content scrollers, hate content listeners.
53:07 Speaker 02 Hate protesters back then.
53:09 Speaker 01 You're just filled with stupid- Hate.
53:10 Speaker 02 Like, damn.
53:11 Speaker 01 Get a life.
53:12 Speaker 02 Just go do something. Get a hobby.
53:13 Speaker 01 Listen, my grandpa says it all the time. Get a life.
53:16 Speaker 02 Get a life.
53:16 Speaker 01 I love what he says.
53:17 Speaker 02 Instead of spreading the hate, spread the good word.
53:19 Speaker 01 Mm hmm.
53:19 Speaker 02 Tell people what you're doing.
53:21 Speaker 01 Mm hmm.
53:21 Speaker 02 Let her do her thing. People will listen or they won't. And then you go spread your good word.
53:26 Speaker 01 Papa says, get a life. I say, live and let live.
53:29 Speaker 02 Exactly. Now, with the lecture tour having fallen, you know, mostly apart, Hubble and his group returned with Esther to Amherst. And soon after, he informed her that he would be leaving. He was like, this is a lot.
53:41 Speaker 01 He said, sorry, I have been chased out of town.
53:44 Speaker 02 Yeah. Decades later, in 1879, Hubble published his account of the time he spent with Esther Cox investigating the great Amherst mystery. In a book called The Great Amherst Mystery, A True Narrative of the Supernatural.
53:57 Speaker 01 Hmm.
53:58 Speaker 02 The book went on to become a huge success, and it honestly brought Hubble up from amateur actor, which is what he was doing before this, to an internationally recognized author and a pseudo expert on the paranormal.
54:10 Speaker 01 All right.
54:10 Speaker 02 We got something out of it.
54:11 Speaker 01 Okay, Walter.
54:12 Speaker 02 Esther moved back into the Teed House, finally.
54:15 Speaker 01 They welcomed her back?
54:16 Speaker 02 They said, okay. But when the activity started up again a short time later, she was asked to leave again.
54:21 Speaker 01 Damn, this bitch is getting evicted left, right, and center.
54:24 Speaker 02 And she went to stay with the Van Ambergs, a local family with whom she had stayed with in the past. Initially, it was pretty quiet in the house. People even suggested Mr. Van Amberg, quote, possessed an influence over the ghosts similar to the alleged influence his illustrious kinsman was said to have over wild beasts.
54:42 Speaker 01 Whoa.
54:42 Speaker 02 Yeah.
54:43 Speaker 01 Okay, Mr. V.
54:44 Speaker 02 Van Amberg, he apparently was coming from a long line of people who could fucking tame wild beasts.
54:51 Speaker 01 He's like a lion tamer?
54:52 Speaker 02 Which is pretty fun. But if Van Amberg did have any control over Esther and her spirits, it didn't last very long.
54:58 Speaker 01 Oh.
54:58 Speaker 02 Uh, within a few weeks, it all started again. Pots, pans, clothes, and other valuables were thrown around the house on a near daily basis.
55:06 Speaker 01 Oh, darn.
55:07 Speaker 02 The tension in the house was thick.
55:09 Speaker 01 Yeah, you're ruining my shit.
55:11 Speaker 02 And it finally came to a head a few weeks later when the ghosts supposedly set fire to the Van Amberg's barn.
55:17 Speaker 01 That'll do it.
55:18 Speaker 02 And it destroyed everything inside. It was like genuine destruction.
55:21 Speaker 01 Oh, that's sad.
55:22 Speaker 02 Furious and distraught, Mr. Van Amberg had Esther arrested and charged as, quote, "an incendiary."
55:29 Speaker 01 Alleging that it was she who set the barn on fire to further her hoax.
55:33 Speaker 02 I mean, I do low key get why he would feel that way.
55:36 Speaker 01 I'd probably do the same thing.
55:37 Speaker 02 Yeah. According to one press account, quote, "The judge and jury were nonbelievers as far as ghosts were concerned." And Esther was found guilty and sentenced to four months in jail for arson.
55:47 Speaker 01 Four months, huh?
55:49 Speaker 02 It's pretty, uh, pretty brief stay for arson, I would say.
55:52 Speaker 01 Light arson.
55:53 Speaker 02 Light arson. Ultimately, she would only serve one month of her sentence.
55:57 Speaker 01 Is she like a celeb?
55:59 Speaker 02 Uh, yeah, because it was really due in large part to the number of respectable locals who spoke out on her behalf.
56:04 Speaker 01 Oh, that's nice.
56:05 Speaker 02 She did have some people in her corner.
56:06 Speaker 01 They said, no, it really was ghosts.
56:08 Speaker 02 After she was released, she found work as a live-in maid for Arthur Davison, the local clerk of the court. But as always, things started to go wrong almost immediately. In the Davison house, knives, forks, sewing needles, knitting needles, all manner of dangerous objects this time, not just pots and pans.
56:26 Speaker 01 Like sharp?
56:27 Speaker 02 Uh, they flew around the house with like, pretty regular frequency at this point. Uh, including one incident when a large fork struck Davison in the back of the head.
56:35 Speaker 01 Oh, fuck. Oh.
56:37 Speaker 02 Like the previous accommodations, uh, her time with the Davisons came to an end after his barn caught fire and was completely destroyed.
56:45 Speaker 01 What?
56:46 Speaker 02 Now, if she's still setting fires to prove this whole thing, that's bold.
56:51 Speaker 01 That's almost what makes me feel like it's real, though, because it's like, why would she do that again?
56:55 Speaker 02 Like you just came out of jail for that. But then again, she did get out after only a month. So it's like, she looks around and she's like, well, people will band together to get me out.
57:03 Speaker 01 And at least for her, jail was like a steady living, like, uh, situation.
57:06 Speaker 02 For a month, she had somewhere to stay.
57:07 Speaker 01 Yeah.
57:08 Speaker 02 Two hots and a cot, you know?
57:09 Speaker 01 Two hots and a cot. Jesus Christ.
57:12 Speaker 02 It's true.
57:13 Speaker 01 You're not wrong.
57:13 Speaker 02 For, for Esther, it's true. Now, after being kicked out of the Davison house after, you know, the barn set fire, Esther spent two months bouncing around from one home to another, never staying more than a few days. In early 1880s, she suffered another attack of physical symptoms that required Dr. Kari to sedate her with morphine. And she remained unconscious for several days before coming to and resuming her normal state.
57:37 Speaker 01 A lot of fucking morphine.
57:39 Speaker 02 Now this latest attack on her health and wellbeing proved to be the last.
57:43 Speaker 01 Oh, no.
57:43 Speaker 02 After a brief period of depression, she was resolved to reclaim her life. She was like, I cannot do this anymore. And she was like, I'm, I'm just moving on. I'm moving forward. I'm going to try to put this behind me and try to see if that will work. And within a few, a short time, she started seeing a man from town.
58:01 Speaker 01 Oh, honey.
58:03 Speaker 02 After a brief courtship, they married and they had one child. And it's unclear how or why the first marriage came to an end, because it did. But Esther would go on to marry a second time and have another child before leaving Amherst for good and relocating to Brockton, Massachusetts.
58:20 Speaker 01 Shut the fuck up. Shut the fuck up. That's like when it happened in the menu.
58:26 Speaker 02 And they were like, yeah, she's from Brockton. I was like, what? Like, what the fuck?
58:31 Speaker 01 Esther out here in Brockton?
58:33 Speaker 02 The most random town.
58:35 Speaker 01 Truly the most random town.
58:40 Speaker 02 What is Brockton known? Is it, uh?
58:42 Speaker 01 City of champions.
58:43 Speaker 02 City of champions, yeah. Like that's, I, if you had said like Palmer, you know, Amherst, Massachusetts.
58:50 Speaker 01 Cause it's like, that's like a western mass.
58:52 Speaker 02 Malden, Marlboro, like fucking Everett, Dorchester, Worcester. If you had said any of these towns, I'd be like, wow, that's weird.
59:00 Speaker 01 Brockton?
59:01 Speaker 02 Brockton.
59:02 Speaker 01 The fuck are you doing in Brockton?
59:04 Speaker 02 Like, I'm not saying, I'm just like, it's just so random.
59:06 Speaker 01 No, that's literally, it's just a random fucking place.
59:08 Speaker 02 Random. So crazy. It was like the menu moment for me. As soon as I read it, I was like, what?
59:15 Speaker 01 It's like you just hear like glass shattering. What the, what did you do in Brockton?
59:19 Speaker 02 Yeah. Now by that time, whatever had been haunting Esther Cox appeared to have left her. There's no further reports of supernatural phenomena after she got married.
59:29 Speaker 01 Makes no fucking sense to me.
59:31 Speaker 02 Yeah.
59:32 Speaker 01 Years and years and barn fires aplenty. And then she's just like, yeah, I want to get married and have some kids and it all stops.
59:38 Speaker 02 It's weird. It just went away.
59:39 Speaker 01 She like stopped swelling too?
59:40 Speaker 02 Yeah, she stopped all of it, I guess. Which like, that's weird, because she was swelling up and shit.
59:46 Speaker 01 I don't, this, I don't know what to make of this.
59:48 Speaker 02 I don't need, now, little is known about her life after she left Amherst.
59:51 Speaker 01 Little is known about her time in Brockton.
59:53 Speaker 02 Other than the documentation of her death on November 8th, 1912, at age 52.
59:59 Speaker 01 What the fuck? She only lived to be 52?
1:00:01 Speaker 02 Yeah, I mean, it is the 1800s, but.
1:00:03 Speaker 01 Yeah, but still.
1:00:03 Speaker 02 Now, the story of Esther Cox and the Great Amherst Mystery had captured the imagination and attention of people everywhere, all over the world, since it began.
1:00:13 Speaker 01 Wow.
1:00:13 Speaker 02 And it obviously inspired a lot of theories about where this all came from. Some, like Walter Hubble, believed that she was genuinely haunted. And others believed the entire saga was a hoax perpetrated by one person.
1:00:25 Speaker 01 I feel like I'm not in either camp.
1:00:27 Speaker 02 I know, it's a hard one to sit in.
1:00:28 Speaker 01 It is.
1:00:29 Speaker 02 Dr. Walter Prince wrote in 1919, um, in an article for the Journal of the American Society of Psychical Research, "The Amherst Mystery, we are informed on the best authority, is no mystery at all, except to persons who refrain from using their powers of observation and reason." So they're like, "It's really not a mystery unless you just choose not to see what's happening."
1:00:50 Speaker 01 Okay.
1:00:51 Speaker 02 He said, "The only mystery is that so many persons who should have known better are deceived."
1:00:57 Speaker 01 But like, how is she creating knocking in the, in the front pew when she was not there?
1:01:01 Speaker 02 Those are the kind of things, and also, it's like.
1:01:03 Speaker 01 And how did she make things fly?
1:01:05 Speaker 02 That's like, the knives and forks and shit, like, no one was saying, "I saw her throw these things."
1:01:11 Speaker 01 Right.
1:01:11 Speaker 02 Like, they were just flying around.
1:01:12 Speaker 01 I mean, I guess they're, I'm like, Criss Angel Mindfreak vibes, like, maybe she.
1:01:16 Speaker 02 Criss Angel Mindfreak.
1:01:17 Speaker 01 Maybe she figured.
1:01:18 Speaker 02 That's it. That's a tweet.
1:01:21 Speaker 01 Period.
1:01:22 Speaker 02 Yeah, like, that's it.
1:01:23 Speaker 01 But you know what? Like, he can, he can do, like, illusions and shit, maybe?
1:01:26 Speaker 02 Yeah, illusionists are definitely.
1:01:28 Speaker 01 Yeah, like.
1:01:28 Speaker 02 Maybe she's, she's one of the great illusionists of our time, you know?
1:01:32 Speaker 01 Maybe she's Esther Girl Mindfreak.
1:01:34 Speaker 02 Mindfreak. Esther Cox Mindfreak.
1:01:37 Speaker 01 I mean, it kind of works.
1:01:38 Speaker 02 Honestly should be titles.
1:01:40 Speaker 01 Esther Cox Mindfreak. I mean, it had to, like, the, like, that, people learned that shit somewhere.
1:01:47 Speaker 02 Yeah, I mean, we, look, we just said, people were already doing the, don't, you know, instead of me just not listening to something I don't like, I'm gonna try to make everybody not listen to something I don't like, back then.
1:01:59 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:01:59 Speaker 02 They were definitely doing Mindfreak back then.
1:02:01 Speaker 01 Exactly. They were, everything we're doing now.
1:02:03 Speaker 02 Mindfreak, you know, twerking, all of those things, they were doing back then.
1:02:07 Speaker 01 They were throwing ass. But. Yeah, I I don't know. I believe in hauntings like one hundred and fifty percent. But I've been to a lot of haunted locations at this point and nothing ever gets thrown. Like, I've never seen anything thrown and I desperately want to.
1:02:21 Speaker 02 Yeah, I would love to see something.
1:02:22 Speaker 01 Like, I've never seen the extreme sides that people talk about, and that does make you question.
1:02:30 Speaker 02 It makes me think of like, going back to like the energy kind of thing of it all, that like stored energy, especially traumatic energy or negative energy.
1:02:39 Speaker 01 I fully believe in that.
1:02:41 Speaker 02 Does that cannot cause things like that? But again, like you just said, I've never seen it happen.
1:02:45 Speaker 01 I've never experienced it. And we've been in some places where.
1:02:49 Speaker 02 I mean, in our house growing up, I remember me and my brother were downstairs and we heard a crash.
1:02:55 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:02:55 Speaker 02 And when we ran upstairs and his room was wildly haunted, it was my room first. And then I was like, fuck that.
1:03:00 Speaker 01 You said fuck this.
1:03:00 Speaker 02 You can have this. And he took it.
1:03:02 Speaker 01 Actually, you know what?
1:03:03 Speaker 02 And that, it was a, it was a framed picture that didn't just fall down on the wall.
1:03:09 Speaker 01 It like flew across the room.
1:03:10 Speaker 02 Went across the room and was leaning against the other side of the room. So I will say, I didn't see it with my own eyes, but I heard it.
1:03:17 Speaker 01 When I, like before I moved into my own papa's house and I used to like just stay for like the week or like some like time. I would sleep in that room from time to time. And do you remember the night that a box just slid across the floor out of nowhere? And I, I woke the entire house up because I screamed so loud. So I have seen things move.
1:03:35 Speaker 02 So, yeah.
1:03:35 Speaker 01 I've just not like, well, yeah, I mean, I can literally still see that in my head. That shit was crazy.
1:03:40 Speaker 02 Yeah, so I mean, I guess, I guess. You know what? I mean, it's not as egregious as knives and forks flying through the air and like pots and pans and shit.
1:03:50 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:03:50 Speaker 02 But it's something.
1:03:51 Speaker 01 Yeah, I don't know. Yeah.
1:03:52 Speaker 02 It's, it's, it's very unknown to me. But Dr. Walter Prince and many others in the field of paranormal research flatly rejected Hubble's account of this supposedly true haunting. Um, they were asserting that their steadfast belief was merely, you know, this was just a disingenuous marketing strategy to sell more books. That's what they were asserting. I'm not saying that. Author Lori Glenn Norris, whose two thousand and twelve book Haunted Girls tells a more detailed story of Cox's life.
1:04:21 Speaker 01 Iconic title.
1:04:22 Speaker 02 Right? Haunted Girl. Um, and it's Girl, sorry. I shouldn't have said Girls. It's Girl.
1:04:26 Speaker 01 There are many haunted girls. We are two of them.
1:04:28 Speaker 02 There's, there's only one. But I said Girls accidentally, but it tells a more detailed story of Cox's life. Um, and agrees with that sentiment that. Something else was going on. According to Glenn Norris, the haunting most likely started out as a prank by a young woman who was desperate for attention, but everything quickly spiraled out of control. After her mother's death, her father's remarriage, and being shipped off to live with her sister, her life probably felt like it was kind of falling apart.
1:04:56 Speaker 01 Yeah, out of her control.
1:04:59 Speaker 02 Add to that the assault and the death threats from McNeil, and it's very likely that Esther was in a mental health crisis and needed help.
1:05:08 Speaker 01 But then flipped that on its head, like you just said, there are energies that feed off of negative experiences, and I would assume that would have been a very negative experience for her.
1:05:20 Speaker 02 Yeah.
1:05:20 Speaker 01 And she was living with trauma.
1:05:22 Speaker 02 Yeah.
1:05:22 Speaker 01 So it's like maybe something was feeding off of that.
1:05:25 Speaker 02 I can see her doing it for attention, and then it's spiraling out of control during a mental health crisis, or I can see that side.
1:05:33 Speaker 01 Yeah, I agree with you.
1:05:35 Speaker 02 But Glenn Norris said, instead of helping her, the people who should have helped her, quote, "turned her personal crisis into a public sensation."
1:05:42 Speaker 01 Mm-hmm.
1:05:43 Speaker 02 More than a century later, her story has inspired countless books, plays, even an annual festival in Amherst known as Estherfest.
1:05:51 Speaker 01 There's an Estherfest, and I've never gone. I spent plenty of time in Amherst.
1:05:55 Speaker 02 The draw of the story is the fact that it's still one of the nation's great unsolved mysteries, while others use it as an opportunity to share their own ghost stories.
1:06:05 Speaker 01 So when are we going to Estherfest?
1:06:07 Speaker 02 Amherst Mayor David Krogan said, "I just like that it puts a spotlight on the town. I mean, it's a ghost story that apparently is one of the most well-documented supernatural events that have ever been."
1:06:17 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:06:17 Speaker 02 Although she appreciates that people are continuing to tell Esther's story, Lori Glenn Norris, her appreciation of the festival and celebration of Cox comes with a warning. She said, "I appreciate that we're still telling the story," but she warned, "hopefully people will take into consideration that there was more to her than to the 15 months, and how this type of thing can be so harmful to people." She said, "I'm not sure if Esther really ever recovered from it."
1:06:41 Speaker 01 Oh.
1:06:41 Speaker 02 Which, like, she also doesn't know that, because we don't have any documentation of how she was after she got married.
1:06:47 Speaker 01 Here's the thing, it kind of sounds like she did recover from it because She went on to have two marriages and two children.
1:06:52 Speaker 02 That's the thing.
1:06:54 Speaker 02 So it's like, and I lived a life in Brockton, Massachusetts.
1:06:57 Speaker 01 She recovered from it.
1:06:58 Speaker 02 So it's like, I appreciate though that she's saying, you know, like that.
1:07:02 Speaker 01 There's more to her than fifteen months.
1:07:03 Speaker 02 That there really could have been a mental health crisis here happening. That was, but we don't know that. That's the thing. Like, we don't know that.
1:07:11 Speaker 01 Yeah, that's just a.
1:07:12 Speaker 02 Documented to have mental health.
1:07:14 Speaker 01 That's a theory.
1:07:15 Speaker 02 Crises or anything like that.
1:07:17 Speaker 01 Right.
1:07:17 Speaker 02 That's a theory. It's a very good theory.
1:07:19 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:07:19 Speaker 02 There's also the very valid, if you are into supernatural theory, that something was going on here. There's also another theory that this McNeil guy was fucking tormenting her.
1:07:30 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:07:31 Speaker 02 Cause that's like a real theory.
1:07:32 Speaker 01 I kind of wondered that.
1:07:34 Speaker 02 Stalking and tormenting her.
1:07:35 Speaker 01 I actually kind of wondered that, especially when like the match fell from the attic.
1:07:39 Speaker 02 Yeah, it's like, that could have been, and it could be a combo platter.
1:07:42 Speaker 01 Cause also he just.
1:07:42 Speaker 02 Many different things.
1:07:43 Speaker 01 He just disappeared.
1:07:44 Speaker 02 Yeah, nobody knew where he went.
1:07:46 Speaker 01 So it's like.
1:07:46 Speaker 02 And he was.
1:07:47 Speaker 01 Did he just live in the, I mean, we've covered stories before where people have lived in the fucking walls.
1:07:50 Speaker 02 And he was known to be a dick face. And it's like, and it's not like they had simply safe back then where they would tell if he was in the fucking attic. Like they'd know.
1:07:58 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:07:58 Speaker 02 There was nothing. He could have climbed in an attic very easily and just lived there. And it's like, this guy was skinning cats alive. Like he was.
1:08:05 Speaker 01 Say that to me again.
1:08:06 Speaker 02 But that's, it's the truth. Like he was a straight up monstrous human being. This would not be out of the realm of possibility. He tried to assault her or did assault her.
1:08:17 Speaker 01 It sounds like he did.
1:08:18 Speaker 02 It's not out of the realm of possibility that this McNeil guy made it his fucking business to torment her afterwards.
1:08:25 Speaker 01 Mm hmm.
1:08:25 Speaker 02 Like, you don't know. And even if he started to, and then it turned into something else, because he had literally driven her to a mental health crisis.
1:08:32 Speaker 01 Yup.
1:08:33 Speaker 02 Where she was just continuing it because she believed she was still in it.
1:08:36 Speaker 01 Yeah. And not even realizing that she was continuing it.
1:08:39 Speaker 02 Or it's a fucking demon.
1:08:41 Speaker 01 Could be.
1:08:42 Speaker 02 I mean, it's all, what do we know?
1:08:44 Speaker 01 Here's the thing.
1:08:45 Speaker 02 What does anybody know?
1:08:46 Speaker 01 We said it in the alien abduction episode. There's just so much out there that we don't know about.
1:08:49 Speaker 02 We don't fucking know. It could be any of these things. I'm willing to believe any three of them.
1:08:53 Speaker 01 I am too.
1:08:53 Speaker 02 Makes sense.
1:08:54 Speaker 01 Maybe it's a combo of all of them.
1:08:55 Speaker 02 I think it's a combo of all of them, to be honest.
1:08:57 Speaker 01 That's a crazy story, though.
1:08:58 Speaker 02 Yeah.
1:08:58 Speaker 01 I didn't, I've said it fifty million times, but I really don't know what to make of that.
1:09:02 Speaker 02 It, that's the thing. A lot of these things, when we talk about them, like the Poltergeist or hauntings, usually at the end, I feel.
1:09:11 Speaker 01 I'm in one camp or the other.
1:09:12 Speaker 02 One, one way or another.
1:09:14 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:09:14 Speaker 02 This one, I feel.
1:09:17 Speaker 02 Conflicted.
1:09:18 Speaker 01 I do too.
1:09:19 Speaker 02 And it's, I don't believe it was just a straight up haunting.
1:09:22 Speaker 01 No.
1:09:23 Speaker 02 No, I don't think it's just clear cut haunting. I think there was other elements involved.
1:09:28 Speaker 01 Yeah, I feel like the.
1:09:29 Speaker 02 I think that could be part of it.
1:09:30 Speaker 01 I think there's absolutely an element of haunting and I think the McNeil thing, it's like, he assaulted her and then he just like left is not that believable to me.
1:09:39 Speaker 02 Yeah.
1:09:39 Speaker 01 I feel like.
1:09:41 Speaker 02 Something like we never heard about him again.
1:09:42 Speaker 01 I feel like he plays a deeper role than, than people realize.
1:09:45 Speaker 02 I think so too.
1:09:46 Speaker 01 What an interesting story though.
1:09:48 Speaker 02 Yeah.
1:09:48 Speaker 01 And I'm really trying to go to Esther Fest.
1:09:50 Speaker 02 That's the, we gotta go to Esther Fest.
1:09:52 Speaker 01 And I'll remember that there's more to her than fifteen months while I'm at Esther Fest.
1:09:55 Speaker 02 Hell yeah. So I found it. So, um, and remember this is Amherst, Nova Scotia.
1:10:01 Speaker 01 Oh yeah. So I've actually, um, asterisk, I've never been there. I thought we were talking.
1:10:05 Speaker 02 I should have corrected that.
1:10:06 Speaker 01 Cause I was like, I don't think you've spent a lot of time in it.
1:10:09 Speaker 02 You're like, I'm not positive, but something tells me.
1:10:12 Speaker 01 Also, that makes it even more random that she made her way to Brockton, Massachusetts.
1:10:16 Speaker 02 That's why it's crazy.
1:10:17 Speaker 01 I thought you meant like Amherst, like Western Mass. Yeah.
1:10:21 Speaker 02 Um, so Esther Fest is apparently, this is according to the website, is a celebration of the paranormal and horror that takes place in Amherst each October, inspired by Esther Cox and her story. So it's happening right now.
1:10:34 Speaker 01 I'm still trying to go.
1:10:35 Speaker 02 Yeah.
1:10:36 Speaker 01 Nova Scotia seems dope.
1:10:37 Speaker 02 Yeah, it seems like it's a fun, the great Amherst street party is part of it.
1:10:42 Speaker 01 Uh, yeah, I'd like to go to there.
1:10:44 Speaker 02 This looks like fun. Uh, the grand, the great Amherst street party takes place on the eighteenth of October. Live music. This is live music with second toe.
1:10:56 Speaker 02 Which I think is a band.
1:10:56 Speaker 01 Little piggy.
1:10:58 Speaker 02 Bouncy castles.
1:10:59 Speaker 01 I mean.
1:11:00 Speaker 02 Vendors, face painting, horse and wagon rides.
1:11:03 Speaker 01 Horse and wagon rides.
1:11:05 Speaker 02 Like this is.
1:11:06 Speaker 01 What was the last thing you said?
1:11:07 Speaker 02 A petting zoo.
1:11:08 Speaker 01 A petting zoo?
1:11:08 Speaker 02 And so much more, it says.
1:11:10 Speaker 01 I think we ought to book tickets.
1:11:12 Speaker 02 That looks like fun.
1:11:13 Speaker 01 Yeah, it does. It looks like a busk.
1:11:14 Speaker 02 It does. It looks like a, like a Berkshire bust. It really does.
1:11:18 Speaker 01 I am obsessed and I think we'll maybe go next year.
1:11:22 Speaker 02 So if you're in Amherst or if you're in Nova Scotia at all, go like our friend Jordan from nighttime podcasts. Go.
1:11:29 Speaker 01 My God, Jordan, go to Esther Fest and tell us everything.
1:11:32 Speaker 02 Because it looks cool.
1:11:34 Speaker 01 Go oot to Esther Fest and tell us a boot it.
1:11:38 Speaker 02 We're the worst.
1:11:41 Speaker 01 All our Canadian listeners said bye.
1:11:42 Speaker 02 They said fuck you.
1:11:43 Speaker 01 All right, guys. Well, that was a good story, Alina.
1:11:46 Speaker 02 It was a fun one.
1:11:47 Speaker 01 I liked it. And we hope you keep listening.
1:11:51 Speaker 02 And we hope you keep it.
1:11:52 Speaker 01 Weird. But it's so weird that you don't go party your ass off at Esther Fest and make things fly, baby.
1:11:57 Speaker 02 Esther Fest. Esther Fester. Esther Cox Mindfreak.
1:13:33 Speaker 04 Hi, I'm Jake Grez, also known as Nurse Jake. As a travel nurse, I've worked in all kinds of places, different settings, cities, and climates. Every assignment brings on a new challenge, which is why I always bring my figs. These scrubs are built for whatever the job throws at you. They're breathable, flexible, And comfortable in any environment. No matter where I land, I know they're going to keep me looking and feeling my best. And don't sleep on the details. The pockets, the features, the finishing touches. Everything has a purpose and it makes a real difference when you're moving nonstop. The fit is clean, tailored and super polished and they come in a huge range of colors. In other words, they feel great throughout a 12 hour shift and they always look good. See every healthcare professional on Instagram.
1:14:13 Speaker 04 If you work in healthcare or know someone who does, check out Figs and get 15% off your first order at wearfigs.com with code FIGSRX. That's wearfigs.com code FIGSRX.
1:14:27 Speaker 01 Here's one holiday mystery officially solved. What to get the man in your life. The Old Spice Holiday Gift Pack is that perfect gift that he's actually going to use. It's also a great value since each ready to gift pack includes four, one, two, three, four, honey. Full size products. There's a deodorant, body wash, body spray and a shampoo. Choose from scents including Swagger's Cedarwood scent and Fiji's Palm Tree and Coconut scent. Old Spice makes holiday shopping easy, leaving more time for building that epic backyard snow fort. I'm obsessed with that. I will absolutely be putting this in Drew's stocking. Buy Old Spice Holiday Packs for a limited time to give the gift of scent this holiday season.
Previous October Bonus Episode - Corpse Medicine: Tomb to Table Next The Wyrick Family Haunting Page updated November 1, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated