
Summary
Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.
Author Richard Chizmar joins the hosts to discuss his thriller novel Killing the Boogeyman, the conclusion of his Boogeyman trilogy. Chizmar explains how he accidentally started the series while mowing his lawn, why he incorporated meticulously staged mundane photos into the books to mimic true crime, and how his editor convinced him to structure the narrative as a trilogy. Throughout the conversation, the guest and hosts bond over their shared love of true crime, nostalgia for childhood in the pre-internet era, and a lifelong belief in the supernatural and the uncanny.
- Incorporate real-world media like staged photographs at the end of chapters to make a fictional story feel grounded in true crime. 4:50
- Remember that a story's emotional resonance often rests on shared universal childhood memories rather than just the author's personal life. 47:29
- Treat early manuscript drafts as a private workspace and do not show them to anyone until you are ready. 56:53
Chapters
- 0:08Intro and Book Club Announcement
The hosts introduce the episode and announce the special guest, Richard Chizmar, and the new book in the Boogeyman series.
- 0:52First Book’s Surprise Success and Decision to Continue
Chizmar explains how the first Boogeyman book unexpectedly became a hit, leading him to write a second book despite initial plans to stop at one.
- 3:33Writing Style: True Crime Vibes and Photo Integration
Chizmar discusses his choice to write the series with a true‑crime feel and to include realistic photos at chapter ends to enhance immersion.
- 6:22Blair Witch Marketing and Legal Hurdles
The hosts recount Chizmar’s attempt to emulate Blair Witch marketing, the legal objections he faced, and the creative compromises he made.
- 38:33Choosing Childhood Horror for Kids
The hosts discuss selecting age‑appropriate horror films for their children and the surprising lack of fear they experienced.
- 41:42Title Creation and the Boogeyman Series
The conversation turns to how the author settled on the titles for his trilogy and the influence of his friend Ed.
- 59:11Vulnerability in Storytelling
The author explains how he incorporates personal, vulnerable moments into his fiction and the impact on readers.
- 1:10:44Closing Reflections and Future Projects
The episode wraps up with final thoughts on the series, future plans, and a brief sponsor break.
- 1:12:00Balancing Personal Life and Writing Process
They talk about the challenges of editing, collaborating with editors, and the emotional roller‑coaster of publishing a book.
- 1:17:58Introduction and Writing Process
The hosts introduce the episode and discuss how the guest writes and edits his manuscripts, emphasizing the importance of trusted readers before publishing.
- 1:20:00Mannequin Scenes and Horror Inspiration
The conversation shifts to the unsettling mannequin scenes in the books and how they influence the writer’s horror storytelling.
- 1:22:45True Crime vs. Horror Fiction
The hosts explore the differences between true crime and horror fiction, debating what each genre can convey about murder and fear.
- 1:29:30Stephen King Collaboration Story
The guest recounts his long‑time friendship with Stephen King, detailing how their relationship evolved from magazine submissions to co‑writing a book.
- 1:48:00The Boogeyman’s Supernatural Edge
Discussion of how the third book blurs the line between human and supernatural, referencing real‑life killers and horror tropes.
- 1:48:39Halloween and the Boogeyman Theme
The hosts wrap up with a playful segment on Halloween, the boogeyman myth, and a series of “Would You Rather” questions that tie back to the episode’s spooky tone.
- 1:57:13Defining Horror and Thriller Boundaries
The hosts discuss how the author’s definition of horror is broad and how his novel straddles thriller and horror genres.
Highlights
- 1:34
Accidental Trilogy Originstory
The guest explains that there was never supposed to be a second book, let alone a trilogy, but a sudden idea while mowing his lawn changed everything.
- 4:02
True Crime Photography Strategystrategy
The guest discusses why he placed mundane, non-gory photographs at the end of each chapter to make readers question whether the book was real.
- 6:22
Blair Witch Marketing Jealousyinsight
The host and guest reminisce about the original marketing for The Blair Witch Project and express regret that modern legal departments prevent that level of immersive pranking.
- 20:24
Writing as Memoirinsight
The guest reveals that while the murders in his books are fictional, the names, hometown, and childhood friends are entirely real.
- 1:34:09
Collaborating with Stephen Kingstory
The guest shares the surreal story of how an email exchange about an unfinished story led to him co-writing Gwendy's Button Box with Stephen King.
- 1:36:33
Stephen King Rejects an Endingstory
The guest reveals that Stephen King rejected his original ending for Gwendy's Button Box because it was too dark.
Quotes
“I actually remember telling my editor and my agent, I'm like, that's it.”
Unnamed speaker · 1:46 “I love true crime. So that was the thing. It's like, you know, I've always thought, you know, if there was a local case, and it was the right thing, and I felt like I could add something to the stories and, and, you know, in a dignified way, and honor the victims and the, and the survivors.”
Unnamed speaker · 3:33 “The photos, that's what kept making me go back and Googling whether this was real, because they came out so real. And it felt like a true crime book. Oh, I bet.”
Unnamed speaker · 4:06 “I was like, this is gonna scare the crap out of you. It didn't scare them at all.”
Unnamed speaker · 39:37 “I know. Cause I'm like, you and like John are the only two people, like my husband and Ash are the only people that I'm like, read this and tell me if it's okay.”
Unnamed speaker · 1:18:06 “That actually didn't make sense.”
Unnamed speaker · 1:18:52 “I was like, I don't like, I don't feel right doing that right now.”
Unnamed speaker · 1:22:30
Sponsored segments
- Ashley 0:08–0:33
- Ashley 1:05:14–1:06:32
- Ashley 2:10:29–2:10:34
About this episode
Weirdos! We are stoked to bring you this special Bonus MORBID BOOK CLUB episode, #sponsored by our friends at @ashleyofficial ! This month we are joined by the incredible Richard Chizmar to chat about his upcoming release, Killing the Boogeyman available everywhere on 10/6/2026! Richard takes us behind the scenes of the writing process of this series that blends memoir and horror, talks about ticking of not one- BUT TWO dream collaborations off of his bucket list, and what it’s like to spend YEARS willingly inviting the Boogeyman into your brain! #ashleypartner
Transcript
30,051 words · 4 speakers
Topics
- The Boogeyman
- Chasing the Boogeyman
- Becoming
- Killing the Boogeyman
- Becoming the Boogeyman
- Coraline
- Paranormal Activity
- Jurassic Park
- Maryland
- Chitty Chitty Bang Bang
Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated