Ep. 1416: Crisis Incoming with Michael Covel on Trend Following Radio
Michael Covel's Trend Following
- 1h 31m
- Transcript
Summary
Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.
This episode explores the realities of systematic trend following, risk management, and the distinction between skill and luck in finance. The guest Ewan Kirk discusses his transition from mathematical physics to building a major systematic trading firm, emphasizing rigorous statistical testing, computer programming literacy, and the inevitability of losses in investing. Later, economist Campbell Harvey joins to analyze why standard metrics like the Sharpe ratio fail when asset returns exhibit skewness, explaining how random strategies can easily outperform over short periods and why understanding downside tail risk is essential for investors.
- Do not expect any investment strategy to never lose money, as even outstanding systems experience predictable drawdowns. 17:23
- Apply the scientific method to financial research by attempting to prove your own trading strategies wrong rather than right. 24:59
- Recognize that volatility is symmetric and treats upside and downside equally, failing to capture the directional risk of skew. 1:04:47
- Avoid selecting investment strategies solely based on past backtests without rigorous out-of-sample testing to guard against pure luck. 1:11:59
Chapters
- 0:00Opening Remarks and Crisis Warning
The host sets the stage by warning listeners about impending market turmoil and the need for systematic trading.
- 3:19Introduction of Guest and Background
The host introduces Ewan Kirk, head of Cantab Capital, and outlines his career path from physics to finance.
- 5:36Early Career at Goldman Sachs
Ewan discusses his first interview at Goldman Sachs and the importance of programming skills in quantitative finance.
- 11:26Rise of Trend Following in Europe
Ewan explains how trend following gained traction in Europe, citing AHL and the scientific approach to investing.
- 31:01Addressing Criticisms of Systematic Trading
Ewan responds to critics who claim systematic trading adds no value to the economy, defending its role for investors.
- 32:05Small Business Perspective and Employment
Ewan highlights Cantab Capital’s role as a small business, providing jobs and incremental improvements.
- 39:45Risk Management and Client Communication
Ewan emphasizes the importance of risk weighting, client understanding, and transparent communication.
- 50:49Skill vs. Luck in Investment Performance
The conversation shifts to distinguishing skill from luck, using examples from hedge funds and sports.
- 55:19Survivorship Bias and CEO Risk Tolerance
Explores how survivorship bias affects perceptions of skilled managers and how CEOs’ high risk tolerance shapes firm dynamics.
- 58:40Markowitz’s 1952 Paper and Skewness
Examines Markowitz’s portfolio theory, its reliance on normality, and the importance of accounting for skewness in risk assessment.
- 1:02:42Normal Distribution Misconceptions in Finance
Discusses the flawed assumption of normality in asset returns and introduces the concept of skewness (SKU).
- 1:09:20Risk vs. Uncertainty in Portfolio Management
Highlights the difference between risk (volatility) and uncertainty (unknown inputs) in practical portfolio construction.
Highlights
- 3:44
Growing From Small To Billionsstory
Ewan Kirk discusses the growth of Cantab Capital from a small outfit managing thirty million to over five billion in assets.
- 4:38
The Holy Grail of Consistencyinsight
The speaker explains that consistent, predictable profits are a holy grail that traders never actually reach; instead, strategies rely on taking small losses before capturing major trend periods.
- 6:50
Programming As Modern Literacyinsight
Ewan Kirk argues that computer programming is today's literacy for quantitative finance, comparing a mathematician who cannot program to a novelist who cannot write.
- 11:26
Why Europe Grew In Quantsinsight
Ewan Kirk speculates that the rise of European trend following firms stemmed from a more rigorous scientific and statistical approach compared to traditional US methods.
- 29:21
Approaching Performance As Chancestrategy
Ewan Kirk explains that when explaining monthly gains or losses, their firm approaches the question from the perspective that the result was pure chance and tries to prove otherwise.
- 31:01
Questioning Economic Utilitydebate
Ewan Kirk addresses critics who question the economic usefulness of quantitative funds, comparing their value to other non-essential services like restaurants and car manufacturers.
- 1:03:42
The Flaw Of Normalityinsight
Campbell Harvey critiques Harry Markowitz's foundational portfolio paper, noting its hidden footnote that optimization only works under normal asset returns and zero preference for skew.
- 1:26:04
The Dice Simulation Problemstory
Campbell Harvey uses a roll of 36 dice to illustrate how regression to the mean and luck can make top-performing investment managers appear exceptionally skilled.
Quotes
“You need a system. You need an approach.”
Unnamed speaker · 0:26 “There's no guarantees. But at least I'm telling you that.”
Unnamed speaker · 2:15 “The other thing to remember, of course, is that trend following systematic trading, the money comes from somewhere.”
Unnamed speaker · 33:39 “Managed futures has got positive SKU. And it's almost by construction, because when things are going up, you're buying. That's the same as replicating a long call option.”
Unnamed speaker · 1:19:50 “If you do like the sharp ratios of different investment styles, or maybe even like hedge fund returns, you'll see a wide variation in the average sharp ratios.”
Unnamed speaker · 1:19:19 “So if you believe the actual track record and you actually analyze it in this way of creating alternative histories, then it really helps you avoid the mistake of firing a skilled manager, basically because they've had some bad luck.”
Unnamed speaker · 1:27:31
Sponsored segments
- CamHarvey 1:30:02–1:31:08
About this episode
Please enjoy my monologue Crisis Incoming with Michael Covel on Trend Following Radio. This episode may also include great outside guests from my archive. --- I'm MICHAEL COVEL, the host of TREND FOLLOWING RADIO, and I'm proud to have delivered 10+ million podcast listens since 2012. Investments, economics, psychology, politics, decision-making, human behavior, entrepreneurship and trend following are all passionately explored and debated on my show. To start? I'd like to give you a great piece of advice you can use in your life and trading journey… cut your losses! You will find much more about that philosophy here: https://www.trendfollowing.com/trend/ You can watch a free video here: https://www.trendfollowing.com/video/ Can't get enough of this episode? You can choose from my thousand plus episodes here: https://www.trendfollowing.com/podcast My social media platforms: Twitter: @covel https://twitter.com/covel Facebook: @trendfollowing https://www.facebook.com/trendfollowing/ LinkedIn: @covel https://linkedin.com/in/covel/ Instagram: @mikecovel https://www.instagram.com/mikecovel/ Hope you enjoy my never-ending podcast conversation!
Transcript
14,255 words · 3 speakers
Topics
- Sharp ratio
- AHL
- Goldman Sachs
- SKU
- London
- Man
- Man AHL risk management
- Cambridge
- Man AHL strategy selection
- Cantab Capital
Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated