Pod Insights Masters of Scale Stephen Colbert + DonorsChoose's Charles Best — The power of small goals About this episode Startups are audacious. They’re big. They’re world-changing. But you can’t achieve scale on day one. Sometimes the best way to achieve that monumental success tomorrow is to take a teeny tiny step today. This is what Charles Best did when he founded one of the world’s first crowdfunding platforms, DonorsChoose. For 20 years, the nonprofit has been helping public school teachers get funding and supplies for classroom projects and it all started with just a handful of projects in the Bronx, where Charles was a public school teacher. Now it funds thousands of projects in all 50 states, raising almost a billion dollars in the process. Charles did it by adeptly creating a flywheel that matches for donors and grantees, allowing them to connect directly with one another, and doing it all one small step at a time. Cameo: Stephen Colbert!!!
Visit DonorsChoose.org http://DonorsChoose.org
Learn more about US campaign funding laws: https://www.fec.gov/introduction-campaign-finance/understanding-ways-support-federal-candidates https://www.fec.gov/introduction-campaign-finance/understanding-ways-support-federal-candidates/
Read a transcript of this episode at https://mastersofscale.com https://mastersofscale.com/
Subscribe to the Masters of Scale weekly newsletter at https://mastersofscale.com/subscribe
See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
Transcript 0:01 Speaker 00 We've all spent money on something that seemed incredible but didn't live up to the hype. A kitchen gadget, a car. When it doesn't deliver, the disappointment is real. Marketers suffer from this too. Chasing metrics that look great but don't translate into revenue. LinkedIn calls that bull spend. Invest in what matters and reach the right buyers with LinkedIn Ads. You can target by company, industry, job title, and more. LinkedIn Ads also generates the highest ROAS of all major ad networks. Spend $250 on your first campaign on LinkedIn Ads and get a $250 credit for the next one. Just go to LinkedIn.com/scale. That's LinkedIn.com/scale.
0:44 Speaker 00 Terms and conditions apply. The very best founders I know are brilliant at building systems. They connect teams, they remove bottlenecks, and they eliminate single points of failure. And yet, when it comes to their own wealth, most are running a disconnected stack. A tax accountant here and a state attorney there, a wealth manager who doesn't talk to either one of them. Creative Planning was built to fix exactly that. One integrated team of tax professionals, state planners, investment specialists, all coordinated by a dedicated wealth manager who sees your full financial picture and keeps every piece working together.
1:27 Speaker 00 Proactive tax efficiency, estate strategy, investments, all under one roof. Creative Planning, where wealth works together. Learn more at creativeplanning.com/mastersofscale.
1:41 Speaker 01 AI is full of possibilities. Enterprises run on realities. That's why Pega combines the world's most powerful AI with the governance, transparency, and control enterprises demand. So you can move faster, adapt faster, and scale AI with confidence. All the power of AI, none of the uncertainty. Learn more at Pega.com/AI.
2:06 Speaker 02 Microphone recorder, mic stand base. Okay. Here we go.
2:14 Speaker 03 Stephen Colbert is the kind of guy who always has a goal. Currently, his goal is to set up the microphone we sent him for our interview. It arrives in a serious-looking Pelican case.
2:29 Speaker 02 It looks like I've just been given the nuclear football.
2:36 Speaker 02 That goes in there.
2:38 Speaker 03 Although daunting for some, Stephen is now accustomed to being his own production team, thanks to three months of filming at home during quarantine.
2:47 Speaker 02 That goes in there.
2:51 Speaker 03 He also knows that to achieve any goal, you have to start somewhere. In this case, start screwing in the mic stand.
2:59 Speaker 02 There you go. That's it. Woo.
3:03 Speaker 03 Almost there.
3:05 Speaker 02 Reading and hold on. And are we rolling? Yeah. Six, seven, eight.
3:12 Speaker 03 And magic.
3:19 Speaker 03 Sound quality now higher than your average Zoom call. Goal achieved.
3:25 Speaker 02 Look at that. Put me in, coach.
3:28 Speaker 03 But that was nothing compared to the goal Stephen took in 2007. Possibly the most daunting goal there is. He ran for president of the United States.
3:47 Speaker 02 I believe the first reason I decided to run was because I showed up in a poll. And in the poll, I was beating Joe Biden.
4:04 Speaker 03 At the time, Stephen wasn't a host of a late night talk show. He was the fake host of a fake talk show, as he reminds us.
4:12 Speaker 02 Well, of course, my character immediately sees that if he's on the political map. I mean, listen, he didn't choose this path. Destiny chose him and a polling company. And, and therefore, who am I to deny the American people, 2.5% of whom think I should be president of the United States? Well, let's respond to the call of a troubled nation.
4:36 Speaker 03 But a goal of this size is bound to have setbacks.
4:40 Speaker 02 Now, the network was not thrilled. They're like, no, look, you can't run for president. I'm like, well, we're running for president. We're 100% ready. Stop me. said, "Well, look, ultimately, we're not going to allow you to run for president."
4:55 Speaker 03 Stephen Colbert was not about to be deterred by a bunch of TV lawyers.
5:02 Speaker 02 I'm like, "Oh, so I'm canceled? Is that what you're saying? Because I'm running for president.
5:08 Speaker 02 Because you don't know anything about comedians if you think that you're going to stop me from doing something because you don't think I should. And, uh, but I said it at a high volume, and there might have been a few salty words in there.
5:19 Speaker 03 Game on.
5:21 Speaker 02 We do it. We decide to run.
5:25 Speaker 03 Of course, Stephen's actual goal was not to get elected, but to satirize the election process.
5:32 Speaker 02 I was very interested in corporate money in politics. So what I wanted to do was I wanted to run for president and to be fully sponsored by a corporation.
5:40 Speaker 03 Next goal: find a sponsor willing to play along.
5:44 Speaker 02 We wanted to be the Nacho Cheese Doritos Stephen Colbert Campaign for President. And it turned out there was some legal problems there.
5:53 Speaker 03 To overcome this problem, Stephen would fight fiery chips with fiery chips. His legal team found a loophole. Instead of Doritos sponsoring his candidacy, they would sponsor his coverage of his own candidacy.
6:09 Speaker 02 And it became the Nacho Cheese Dorito coverage of the Stephen Colbert Run for President with your host, Stephen Colbert.
6:22 Speaker 03 Goal achieved. Colbert's run for president was off to the races in South Carolina.
6:31 Speaker 02 I hold a rally, and I'm shaking hands, and I'm doing all the things you do. I've got my little campaign team in the car, running around.
6:39 Speaker 02 I'm pressing the flesh with local leaders, and people want to give me money.
6:45 Speaker 03 Stephen launched his parody campaign to shine a light on money in politics. Now, real voters wanted to give him real money, which was a problem.
6:56 Speaker 02 And the one thing that our lawyers are saying, "Don't take more than $5,000 from anyone."
7:06 Speaker 02 Like you can't take, because then you're a federal election and then you will get in trouble. Like you, you personally, I'm like, well, I don't want that. I don't mind Viacom getting in trouble, but I'm, I'm important.
7:16 Speaker 03 Stephen had a challenge and he was presented with a solution to this problem. Enter the founder of Craigslist.
7:24 Speaker 02 Craig Newmark comes on the show and he said he'd like to make a donation to the campaign. We said, no, no, no, you can't, you can't, you can't give me any money. And he goes, oh, no, no, not to you. I'd like to give it to an organization called Donors Choose.
7:39 Speaker 03 Donors Choose, a nonprofit that connects donors with local classrooms in need of supplies for students all over the country. And Craig Newmark was a board member.
7:49 Speaker 02 I thought perhaps people could make donations to Donors Choose in your name. And that would be a way of them showing their support without running afoul of federal guidelines. And like, that's pretty great.
8:02 Speaker 03 It was a neat solution to a vexing challenge. Goal achieved. But Donors Choose founder, Charles Best, took the idea to the next level.
8:11 Speaker 04 We came up with an idea for a philanthropic presidential straw poll where there would be a page dedicated to each presidential candidate, filled with classroom project requests reflecting their background. And you could give to a project on your favorite candidate's page in what we called a straw poll that makes a difference. And we pitched it to Stephen, saying, this could be your way to engage your followers and viewers and ensure that their money is actually being put to great use.
8:40 Speaker 03 Colbert won that straw poll, but the real winners were the public schools of South Carolina. Stephen's on air promotion drove huge donations. So Stephen was meeting goal after goal in his quest to run for president. But there was trouble ahead.
8:55 Speaker 02 I mean, I had to drop out. I had to drop out eventually because the Democrats would not let me on the ballot.
9:02 Speaker 03 This was a tough blow and Stephen felt it.
9:06 Speaker 02 I couldn't, I couldn't sleep the night before they were voting. I was up all night going, well, everyone is raised in America with the idea that any child could grow up and be president of the United States. But not you, Stephen Colbert. The Democrats won't let you on the ballot. And I know it was just a joke, but it still, it still felt bad.
9:35 Speaker 03 It was a serious setback, but you recall that Stephen's actual goal wasn't to get elected. It was to shed light on the electoral process and how it moves money. For this, Stephen was still in the game with Donors Choose at his side. Meanwhile, back on the actual campaign trail, things were heating up. A young senator named Barack Obama had come out of nowhere and was neck and neck with the legendary Hillary Clinton.
10:01 Speaker 02 Pennsylvania was gonna settle it. That was gonna be the big thing. Pennsylvania's gonna settle it. It didn't, of course.
10:07 Speaker 03 Stephen understood the platform that he had, and he leveraged it to achieve his new goal: use his political momentum to get money in the hands of classrooms that needed it.
10:18 Speaker 02 We took the show to Philadelphia, and we had people donate to Donors Choose, either in the name of Barack Obama or Hillary Clinton.
10:30 Speaker 03 And the donations poured in. Thousands of people donated to Philadelphia classrooms, and hundreds of thousands of dollars were raised. A fake campaign with real results for Donors Choose. And it's worth pausing just a moment to ask why Stephen said yes to Charles in the first place. Yes, Charles solved the problem of campaign donations. And yes, Stephen is a generous soul. But Stephen says there was also something else.
10:57 Speaker 02 They were engaging in this satirical, benign game. They became players in the scene. And what I was doing was a scene with the audience, and the audience is the other player, and they wanted to improvise with me. And so the audience donated to my campaign was accepting my initiation and then yes-anding it, and then I had to deal with their initiation, which was actual cash. And then Charles and Donors Choose comes in to say, "Here, here's our acceptance of your audience's initiation. We're gonna add this to the scene."
11:40 Speaker 02 What I loved about them was their understanding of how they could engage in it in a positive way that had real impact in the world, yet lived in the fantasy world of the character. Their playfulness was actually an excellent tool to do something good in their mission.
11:57 Speaker 03 Today, Stephen Colbert is on their board of directors and has raised millions of dollars for Donors Choose. But it started with a single self-contained success. I believe the secret to success lies in F tags. Finite, tidy, achievable goals. If you leverage each small win into the next, and the next, and the next.
12:25 Speaker 03 You've got to have incredible talent at every position.
12:30 Speaker 05 There are fires burning when you're going home. Can you believe it? Such an idiot. And then you go back to, this is totally going to be amazing. There are so many easy ways. I have no idea what to do. Sorry, we made a mistake. But you have to time it right. Oops. Working out of a three-bedroom apartment. Stuff that just seems absolutely nutballs. 10 years later, it's like, well, that's just how you do it. We haven't made it just how you do it.
12:55 Speaker 03 This is Masters of Scale.
13:04 Speaker 03 I'm Reid Hoffman, co-founder of LinkedIn, partner at Greylock, and your host. And I believe the secret to success lies in F tags. Finite, tidy, achievable goals. If you leverage each small win into the next, and the next, and the next. Here's a riddle for you. What do you get when you cross the wicked witch with a bumblebee? Answer: a bee hag.
13:30 Speaker 03 Bad jokes aside, BHAG also means something else. BHAG is short for Big Hairy Adacious Goal. It's a concept Jim Collins introduced in his book Built to Last, and business leaders talk about BHAGs constantly. There's nothing wrong with setting big, audacious goals. In fact, I encourage it. But setting wildly ambitious, long-range objectives doesn't tell you much about how to start. If you set out to climb a mountain, you need to know which boulder to grab first. Hint: It should probably be one you can reach. On today's episode, we're going to set aside the BHAGs, the Big Hairy Adacious Goals, and focus on the F-Tags, Finite, Tidy, Achievable Goals.
14:15 Speaker 03 I wanted to talk to Charles Best about this because as founder and CEO of the charity Donors Choose, he knows all about F-Tags. For 20 years, Donors Choose has been helping public school teachers get funding and supplies for the classroom. In that time, the organization has grown from funding a handful of projects at a single school in the Bronx to funding thousands of projects in all 50 states. This spring, they raised millions of dollars and counting for their Coronavirus Relief Fund, providing teachers with Learn at Home kits to send to students lacking vital resources. And I should add, if you'd like to share this episode with a friend, send this link, listen.masterscale.com/donorschoose.
15:00 Speaker 03 That's listen.masterscale.com/donorschoose. Donors Choose was the world's first online crowdfunding platform founded years before Kickstarter, Patreon, or Indiegogo. But Charles didn't set out to make crowdfunding history. He had a more modest goal in mind.
15:21 Speaker 04 I wanted my students to read Little House on the Prairie, but I only had my own copy and I didn't have any funds to give each of my students the book. So I would go to Staples that had a 24/7 shop by Union Square in Manhattan at like 5 o'clock every morning and photocopy that day's section of Little House on the Prairie to give to each of my students.
15:40 Speaker 03 Charles was a first-year history teacher at Wings Academy in the Bronx. Lacking a budget for basic supplies was an everyday reality for him and his fellow teachers.
15:50 Speaker 04 My colleagues and I were spending a lot of our own money on school supplies. We'd buy copy paper, pencils, poster board, everything we needed to equip our classrooms. But then in the teacher's lunchroom, I would find us talking all the time about even more stuff we wanted for our students that we could not continue to go into our own pockets for. My colleague wanted to take her students on a field trip to the Museum of Modern Art. The art teacher wanted to do a wall-to-wall quilt with her students and she needed fabric and thread and sewing needles.
16:22 Speaker 03 But something about that particular early morning made Charles see things in a different light.
16:28 Speaker 04 It was as I was making those photocopies that I thought about all the other resources that my colleagues wanted to give to their students, that field trip, that art project, that science experiment that just needed a microscope, that I thought, all right, I'm gonna put pencil to paper and draw out this website where teachers can post classroom requests and donors can choose projects that they want to support.
16:52 Speaker 03 What Charles was talking about was crowdfunding, a system that's utterly commonplace today for filmmakers looking to finish a short or founders looking to fund a product. In the year 2000, this crowdfunding concept was decidedly less mainstream, but it wasn't entirely new.
17:11 Speaker 04 The Statue of Liberty in 1885, Joseph Pulitzer used his newspaper to get like 140,000 people to make small donations to fund the installation of the Statue of Liberty.
17:23 Speaker 03 This is a fascinating piece of history we can take just a moment to revisit.
17:31 Speaker 03 1885, a disassembled Statue of Liberty sits in New York Harbor. Funds to install the statue have dried up and Congress can't agree on a bill to fix it. Enter renowned newspaper publisher Joseph Pulitzer. He runs ads in his paper, The New York World, asking citizens to chip in. 160,000 people do, with most donations coming in at less than a dollar each. Of course, we know how that story ends, and we have the statue to prove it. But do you know the story of the first online crowdfunding campaign?
18:15 Speaker 04 In 1997, the British rock band Marillion
18:23 Speaker 04 went straight to their fans for online donations to fund a reunion tour.
18:28 Speaker 03 The band was short, around $60,000. Their manager told them they would need to find something else to do.
18:38 Speaker 03 So the band reached out to their email list contacts, all 6,000 of them. They hit their goal, then hit the road.
18:47 Speaker 03 Oh, and they fired their manager.
18:53 Speaker 03 To this day, Marillion is cited as the fathers of online crowdfunding. But they hadn't built a platform to collect donations, which brings us back to Charles.
19:05 Speaker 04 And then in 2000, DonorsChoose started. And I think it's fair to say it was the first platform dedicated to crowdfunding, if you define that as supporting a project that someone on the front lines has created.
19:17 Speaker 03 The teachers of Wings Academy in the Bronx were certainly on the front lines. Public schools have always been chronically underfunded, especially in lower-income neighborhoods. Schools tend to supplement hollow budgets with things like bake sales or raffles for their parents. But in our poorest communities, that's just shifting the burden to families that are already struggling. Charles wanted a way to reach beyond those families, to people, maybe even strangers, with the means to help.
19:47 Speaker 04 It just occurred to me that there were people out there who would help teachers like us if they could see exactly where their money was going. It just kind of made sense.
19:55 Speaker 03 Charles set out to put his idea in motion, which, back in 2000, wasn't as simple as setting up a WordPress site.
20:02 Speaker 04 I knew nothing about programming. And there was a programmer who had recently immigrated from Poland, who for $2,000 was willing to take my pencil and paper drawings and turn them into a super rudimentary website. It was so rudimentary that the backend was one page and you'd have to scroll down and down and down for like 15 minutes to get to the teacher or project record that you were looking for.
20:26 Speaker 03 Bare bones website aside, Charles' vision for Donors Shoes was as a sort of philanthropic marketplace. Any public teacher can list a class project on the site. But unlike most other crowdfunding platforms, the money donated isn't sent to the school itself. Donors Shoes stays in the equation.
20:46 Speaker 04 We vet and authenticate each teacher's project before it's posted to the public site. When the project is funded, we don't give the teacher cash. We purchase the materials and have them delivered to the classroom. Even if it's a field trip, we're paying the museum. We're paying the bus company taking the students to the museum.
21:04 Speaker 03 Once received, the teachers and students document themselves using the donated goods. Pictures of kids reading the books or sewing their quilts or attending the museum, along with a handwritten thank yous and a full financial report are then sent to every donor who contributed. Charles' first great challenge was to build this charitable marketplace from scratch, which is definitely a BHAG. But Charles turned this BHAG into a series of F tags. I asked him about it. You know, a marketplace startup is, you know, it's not one of those things where you build it and people will come. What were some of the secret tips or the grit or the hustle for getting that initial flywheel going?
21:48 Speaker 04 I turned to my mom because she made a famous roasted pear dessert. She would do these pears with orange rind and apricot jam and spices and roast them in the oven and the juices would swirl all around and they tasted something delicious. So I asked my mom to make a left Of those roasted pears. And then I brought the pears into the teacher's lunchroom. And as my colleagues got ready to pounce, I said, hold up, there's a toll. If you eat one of these pears, you have to go to this new website that just got built called Donors Choose. Ask for whatever it is you most want for your students. Propose the project that you've always wanted to do with them. And that sounded like a good enough deal for my colleagues to scarf the 11 pears and then post the first 11 projects on our site.
22:32 Speaker 03 I've spoken before on this show about the importance of hand crafting your core experience and getting your first interactions right before trying to scale them. That's true in spades for Donors Choose. The first interactions were so handcrafted, they were almost exclusively sourced from Charles himself.
22:51 Speaker 04 My aunt, who's a nurse, she funded the first project. But then there were 10 more projects and I didn't know more donors to fund those. So I funded them myself, which I could afford to do because I was living at home with my parents and they weren't charging me any rent. And because I gave to my colleagues projects anonymously, they mistakenly thought that the website actually worked and that there were all these donors just hanging out on the site, waiting to fulfill teachers' classroom dreams. And that rumor, that false rumor, spread across the Bronx and teachers started posting hundreds of projects.
23:23 Speaker 03 Charles knew he had to get that flywheel turning by any means necessary. Because if your platform doesn't start gaining momentum, your marketplace falls apart. But in this case, it was only gaining momentum on one side. There weren't actually scores of funders awaiting these projects. So Charles leaned on another part of his teeny ecosystem.
23:47 Speaker 04 I was in a really tough spot, not knowing what I was going to do. And my students came to the rescue. They volunteered every day after school for about three months to spread word to potential donors. They addressed and compiled 2,000 letters to people by hand. We semi-legally got the addresses out of my college and high school alumni directories. What was prohibited was mechanical reproduction, but this was full manual by hand reproduction. That was going to be my excuse if we were caught.
24:17 Speaker 03 Charles knew exactly how to motivate his students to finish each of those 2,000 F tags.
24:23 Speaker 04 They could see the potential of this experiment to enrich their lives at school. I think they also felt really bad for me. We sorted the mail ourselves to get the cheapest postal rates. So every desk in my classroom represented a different part of the country piled high with envelopes. And then we carted those sorted letters to the post office, crossed our fingers, and it worked. My students' letters generated $30,000 in donations from people all over the country. We had simply told them that we had built this website where someone with $10 could be a classroom hero, and that was enough to get the first donors on the site.
25:00 Speaker 03 As Hail Marys go, this one was well aimed. Charles had graduated from Yale, and before that, from an exclusive private boarding school. His alumni lists were flush with targets that might be in a good position to help. But more importantly, his outreach strategy made a modest, specific ask. "Give $10, become a classroom hero." The letters addressed by real students in their own real handwriting. Charles and his volunteers were offering a simple, clear step toward feeling like a hero. They could leverage the simplicity of their request to immediate effect. $30,000 later, the donors' side of the flywheel was up and running.
25:43 Speaker 03 Donors Choose was on its way. Charles' insight had been not only in spotting and harnessing this invisible network of helpers, it was in identifying the hook that would compel them to action, isolating the needs of the teachers into something simple, tangible, and finite. Each donor played their part in achieving this satisfying F tag.
26:07 Speaker 04 This is cliched, but I did read that book, Getting Things Done. I've forgotten everything in it, other than if something will take you less than two minutes to accomplish, it doesn't matter if it's high priority, just do it the moment you see it.
26:21 Speaker 03 Charles had finally gotten his momentum. He watched as Donors Choose grew incrementally, but steadily, from a few schools in the Bronx to classrooms all over the city. Then came September 11th, and classrooms in Lower Manhattan needed the city's support.
26:39 Speaker 04 Teachers at the public schools beside Ground Zero start posting projects on our site to recover from the attacks on the World Trade Center. There was a high school art teacher in the Bronx who wanted to bring in an artist who had immigrated from Afghanistan so students could meet someone from that country. There was a math teacher whose students' calculators were sealed at the disaster site.
26:59 Speaker 03 Charles saw that this could be a moment to highlight these classrooms in their time of need. It was time to leverage the power of small goals into a larger movement. He started reaching out to press outlets to try to get some traction.
27:15 Speaker 04 I think I called 100 reporters. None of them would give me the time of day. One of my first calls was to a New York Times reporter. She responded very nicely but said that we were kind of small potatoes and that if she was ever doing a listing of online charities, which at the time was a new concept, maybe, you know, she'd put us on that list, but we weren't exactly newsworthy.
27:35 Speaker 03 A little disheartened, but not discouraged, Charles kept working his way through his media contacts.
27:41 Speaker 04 I called up Jonathan Alter, senior editor at Newsweek. I called him first because his last name started with A, and so he showed up first in the alphabetical directory. And I called him during my lunch hour, and his assistant must have been out to lunch because he picked up the phone, and he was the first reporter not to hang up on me.
27:58 Speaker 03 Alter wrote up Donors Choose for Newsweek's website, calling in an experiment that might one day change the face of philanthropy. The Newsweek piece was Charles's first big press write-up, and Charles sought to leverage this small win into a bigger one. So he reached out again to that reporter from the Times.
28:17 Speaker 04 I went back and said, hey, Newsweek saw us as newsworthy, at least for their website, so won't you give us a second look? And then she said, I wouldn't touch your story with a 10-foot pole now that another reporter has covered you. The New York Times does not follow in the footsteps of other publications. And I felt like a total idiot. And I wrote her an email apologizing for being so dumb. The reporter wrote back saying, you know, you shouldn't feel quite so bad because you never had a chance in the first place. Because her editors had asked her to focus on charities responding to 9/11.
28:51 Speaker 04 And that gave me my last opening because I had not told her about the projects related to nine 11.
28:57 Speaker 03 Charles took that opening and spent the weekend sending her a rundown of projects from classrooms near ground zero. He also called and left a voicemail asking for one last look.
29:08 Speaker 04 And Monday, I was back at school teaching. I checked email in between periods. The reporter had written back. She wanted to come do an interview for a major future story in the New York Times. I was so over the moon that I forwarded it to my friend, saying, guess who said she wouldn't touch our story with a 10 foot pole and now wants an interview? I beat my chest. I talked all kinds of smack. And then I realized that I had not hit forward. I had hit reply. I tried to yank the electrical cord out of the socket to turn off the computer, but it was too late and I sent that trash talking email directly to that New York Times reporter.
29:52 Speaker 03 Like the mountain climber looking for a boulder to grab on to, just take the next right step.
30:00 Speaker 00 We all know the disappointment that comes when a grand gesture falls flat, something that seemed impressive in the moment, but didn't deliver the results you expected. Marketing budgets too often fall into that trap, aiming for big impressions, big reach, but without the revenue to back it. LinkedIn has a name for it, bull spend. LinkedIn ads generate the highest ROAS of all major ad networks. They target by company, industry, job title, and more. Spend $250 on your first campaign on LinkedIn ads and get a $250 credit for the next one. Just go to LinkedIn.com/scale. That's LinkedIn.com/scale. Terms and conditions apply.
30:43 Speaker 00 When you've built substantial wealth through your business, it's often tied up in a single equity position. The upside is real, but so is the risk, and knowing when to act isn't always obvious. Creative Planning works with business owners to build a strategy around concentrated equity, when to diversify, how to manage tax risk, and how to protect what you've spent years building. Creative Planning: where wealth works together. Learn more at creativeplanning.com/mastersofscale. Stripe Treasury is your new financial operating system built for what's next. With Stripe Treasury, the place your business accepts payments is also where you can store balances, move funds, and pay vendors worldwide.
31:27 Speaker 00 If you're building for global scale, get a business bank account that lets your money move instantly, whenever and wherever you need it. Learn more at stripe.com/treasury. Stripe is not a bank. Banking services provided by Fifth Third Bank, National Association Member, FDIC.
31:46 Speaker 03 We're back with Charles Best, founder and CEO of Donors Choose. When we left Charles, he had utterly blown it with a reporter from The Times, putting his feature story in jeopardy. He wasn't sure what to do, so he just put one foot in front of the other and walked himself over to the cupboard where they keep humble pie.
32:06 Speaker 04 I sent another email apologizing for being so dumb again. She took mercy upon me and did proceed to write a feature story saying that Donors Choose might be the future of philanthropy.
32:18 Speaker 03 Well, it is awesome, even in these small crisis moments, to see people rise above themselves and rise above ego to say, "Look, your stupid email isn't what matters here." Charles' ability to make amends simply, not to mention that reporter's understanding, led to Donors Choose enjoying steady growth after a round of national press. But as they scaled, their high-touch approach proved to be a challenge.
32:47 Speaker 04 I think we benefited from not having any other crowdfunding sites to look at. Because if we did, we would have realized that we were setting out to create a very labor-intensive approach to integrity and to transparency.
33:04 Speaker 03 Remember, Donors Choose buys all the classroom supplies. And so they found themselves shipping them off to schools in farther and farther flung districts.
33:14 Speaker 04 In those early days, we sent each teacher a disposable camera to take photographs of the project in action. We sent them a stamp envelope for sending us back the student letters. Early funders heard about this model and thought, that is insane. That is so labor-intensive, inefficient, fundamentally unscalable. You'll never be able to grow. You should get out of the way and just rely on the honor system and on social networks to grow this community.
33:45 Speaker 03 But there's a reason Charles didn't listen. He knew there was value in building this intense layer of integrity assurance, seemingly scalable or not. We'll dig into that guarantee a little more in a moment. But it was that promise of integrity that helped bring Donors Choose to someone whose endorsement is a scale multiplier all on its own. In 2003, Oprah had Charles on her show. You can guess what happened next.
34:13 Speaker 04 She said our name directly on air. In fact, she went into the green room and she said, because you are a teacher, I'm going to make an exception to our normal rules. The normal rules being that people should go to oprah.com and find the link. But she said, I'm not doing that. I'm going to call out your website address directly. So we just like melted down. And I think it took us like two hours before we could even stand up a front page, you know, our equivalent of a fail whale. But we then started getting phone calls from people all over the country asking if Donors Choose could expand to public schools in their cities and states. And that's what got the ball rolling to our expanding beyond New York City.
34:53 Speaker 03 The expansion to other regions marked a massive jump in scale for the organization, which meant all of those handcrafted, high-touch ways Donors Choose did things would have to find a way to grow as well.
35:06 Speaker 04 Much of our quest over our first decade was taking all of those pieces of integrity assurance and enabling donors to see their impact and to make each of them scalable. We developed an electronic procurement system where teachers go shopping for the stuff they need and where purchasing and invoicing and payment and even items being out of stock all happens via XML or CXNL.
35:30 Speaker 03 Using tech to buy project materials was a start, but it was only one part of solving the integrity equation at scale.
35:38 Speaker 04 We used to pay college students to vet and review each teacher's project request, which involves doing some basic fact checking, making sure that the teacher's essay aligns with the materials in their shopping cart, and then emailing the teacher follow-up questions if they haven't explained what students are going to learn. We don't want the projects on our site to be wish lists of just the stuff I need this year. We want each request to be a true project, a specific learning experience that needs certain materials to come to life. And so we'll need to send follow-up questions to the teacher to help them stick to that standard.
36:13 Speaker 03 Making sure all listed projects were worthy of Donors Choose standards was paramount to maintaining donors' trust. But it's also a challenge to scale. Charles couldn't afford to throw money at the problem. Once again, Charles looked more closely at the resources he already had and took it one step or one F-tag at a time. Last time, the answer was using his own students to hand-address letters. This time, the answer lay with teachers.
36:44 Speaker 04 We realized, wait, probably the most rigorous, expert, dedicated reviewer would be a teacher who's had like 30 projects funded on our site. So how about when you get more than 20 projects funded on our site as a teacher, we will invite you to volunteer your time to become a teacher screener. We train them and there's no one more dedicated to the work than someone doing it out of the goodness of their heart as part of the community. And not only are they more rigorous, they're way faster at doing it.
37:18 Speaker 03 Before we move on, let's also take a moment to highlight something we just heard from Charles.
37:24 Speaker 04 We don't want the projects on our site to be wish lists of just the stuff I need this year. We want each request to be a true project.
37:33 Speaker 03 This attitude embodies what makes Donors Choose approach so compelling. It's hard to manifest a sense of growing momentum from crossing off a shopping list. But helping a special project get funded is an excitement generator. It's the heart of what crowdfunding is all about. But back to the problem at hand, how to scale the process of vetting those projects? The one area that Charles says Donors Choose is having a harder time doing that is in one of the most valued, handcrafted aspects of the donor experience, the student thank you letters. You'll remember that core to the lifecycle of each project is documentation by teachers and students.
38:16 Speaker 03 They take pictures on their field trip or hatching their butterfly cocoons. They then send those photos with handwritten thank yous to Donors Choose HQ where the letters are verified and sent to the donors themselves. From my own experience as a donor, let me tell you that receiving the thank you packet from the kids is a pure delight. It's a human, tangible way to close the loop between donors and students. So it wasn't a part of the process they could compromise.
38:46 Speaker 04 With photographs, digital photography came along and we were able to just let teachers upload photos of their project instead of walking around with huge sacks like Santa full of disposable cameras, walking them over to the photo development store. But then honestly, those student letters, there has been no digital solution. We just have a group of volunteers who eyeball those letters on their way to donors because we would never want to give up a donor's home address to the teacher. So those letters need to go through our office and it does look like Santa's workshop with a whole lot of burlap bags full of packages of thank you letters. But that one piece, we are able to handle efficiently, even though we do so in an old school way.
39:28 Speaker 03 One small thing you might do is you might have the teacher upload the pictures of the letters because then you could create like a little digital montage. You know, you could even have like all the kids say, "Thank you" into the smartphone, right? Like, you know, "Hey, thank you, yay!" So with a little montage and you could create a digital thing that way. Still do the physical letters, but you could do that as an add-in that I think might be fun.
39:55 Speaker 04 Our CTO and Head of Product are going to be cheering for you and brandishing this podcast when they hear the words you just said. And I suspect we will be building exactly the feature you just outlined.
40:06 Speaker 03 Yes, I suspect you got there anyway. It was a natural kind of like, "Ooh, we have smartphones. The teachers have a smartphone. What can we do to make this more human?" Because obviously reducing friction is one of the really important things to get to scale, but people don't realize that increasing the value, the emotional connectivity also creates the ability to scale, right? And so it isn't just like, okay, how do we take all the friction off? That's important, but also how do we create that emotional touch, that magical moment? Because obviously, as you guys are the leaders in, is that magical moment then brings the donor back to do it again. Harnessing this so-called magical moment is key to leveraging small wins to tackle big problems.
40:49 Speaker 03 Much like customer outreach is a constant in business, re-enlisting past donors is a constant undertaking in the nonprofit sector.
40:58 Speaker 03 Development directors work hard to find new ways to reengage their mailing lists. That means, from the donor's perspective, it can feel as though the work is never done. There are only so many urgent request emails you can get before you start tuning them all out. By contrast, the Donors Choose classroom campaigns always have an end. And when it's time to reengage givers, they do it by flagging projects similar to ones they backed before. It frames reengagement on a case-by-case, opt-in basis.
41:34 Speaker 04 This school year, we'll receive millions of dollars for classroom projects on our site. Roughly half of that will come from what we call citizen philanthropists giving $15 and $20 at a time to classroom projects that they pick by hand on our website. And another roughly half of that will come from foundation and corporate partners who give to classroom projects on our site at great scale. But that doesn't mean that they're writing a blank check to Donors Choose the organization, far from it. It means we're working with a corporate partner on a category of classroom project that reflects their geographic footprint, that reflects what they produce and make, and in ways that
42:19 Speaker 04 will engage consumers or their employees. So for one, that could mean a match offer for classroom projects within 10 miles of all 700 of their car dealerships. Or it could mean a match offer for classroom projects seeking robotics equipment, because that's what the company makes.
42:41 Speaker 03 I want you to pay special attention to this insight from Charles. Donors Choose has built search functionality into their interface that lets donors find projects close to their heart. That's based on subject matter, geographical region, and even teacher name.
42:57 Speaker 04 Couple of years ago, our chief financial officer was talking to a colleague about this book he had read called Drunk Tank Pink by a NYU Business School professor, Adam Alter. And in that book, the author cited research that people are more likely to donate to hurricane relief if the first letter of the hurricane is the same first letter as their own name. Because we were in an open office, I overheard that conversation. And I walked over and we three as a group were like, what does this mean for us? And we realized, well, we've got four million donors who've given to classroom projects. We've got more than half a million teachers who've gotten projects funded. They've all got names, and maybe we could match them up based on a shared name.
43:43 Speaker 04 It resulted in a test that we ran on Valentine's Day a few years ago, where we divided our donors into three randomly assigned groups. One group got a poem saying-
43:52 Speaker 02 Roses are red, violets are blue, we heart this teacher and hope, hope you do too.
44:02 Speaker 04 And underneath that poem was a generically selected classroom project that was urgent, but otherwise generic. A second poem said- Roses are red, violets are blue, give to a teacher in a classroom near you. And underneath, we would show a classroom project targeted to your IP address or your billing zip code. So we would do what's supposed to be the holy grail of hyperlocal geo-targeting. But the third poem said- Roses are red, violets are blue, give to a teacher with the same, same name as you.
44:43 Speaker 04 And we would show underneath that poem, a teacher from a Ms. or Mr. Hoffman, and encourage you to check out this project from a teacher who simply shares your last name. And you won't have to guess which poem performed the best.
44:59 Speaker 03 The data was clear. The name matching poem performed three times better than the runner-up, the one based on location.
45:10 Speaker 03 We could spend an entire follow-up episode diving into the psychology of this insight. But the main point is crystal clear. Personalization matters when it comes to asking people to pitch in and solve problems. Our human need to do good in the world is so, so personal. Finding new ways to leverage that need into collective action has been the secret to Donors Choose's growth. From picking projects close to your heart or your name, to receiving reams of photos and thank you letters, the act of giving is tangible, personal, and intimate. And when the project is complete, the evidence is right there in your hands.
45:53 Speaker 03 It gives both donor and recipient an almost addictive sense of accomplishment. A box, fully checked, an achievement high. Stephen Colbert experienced that feeling too.
46:06 Speaker 02 The whole idea of Donors Choose puts you and the people who you are helping directly in contact with each other. And I found that very powerful. Those letters from the children, the letters from the teachers, made it very real for me. And I didn't want that to end. In fact, the next year, when we took the show to Iraq, Charles said, "Hey, we're actually expanding to military bases. What if we gave money for just very specific military bases?" And we raised a half a million dollars for military base projects. And then the year after that, when we were doing the rally on the Mall...
46:44 Speaker 03 That was 2010's Rally to Restore Sanity and/or Fear. The sort of satirical, but also real rally at the National Mall in Washington DC. Colbert co-hosted it with Jon Stewart of The Daily Show, and it drew around 215,000 people.
47:01 Speaker 02 People on Reddit saw that we played games with Donors Choose, and someone from Reddit came to me and said, "Hey, if we raise a half a million dollars for Donors Choose, will you do an Ask Me Anything on Reddit before you go to the rally?" And I literally did the Ask Me Anything on the train down to go to the rally because right before it started, they made it to a half a million dollars. And so what do you want more? A way to play your own game that does something good in the world and makes people happy and feel included in the art that you're creating? It had everything. And a lot of that came from the leadership of the organization that was willing to take a risk on us. Because Satire has also always got a little bit of knife in its hand, but they understood where we were poking it and they were okay.
47:42 Speaker 03 Once more, Donors Choose saw what goal Stephen needed to accomplish, just as much as Stephen saw what they needed, and they worked to achieve it together. This approach has proven essential during this spring's unprecedented disruption due to the coronavirus. Avid listeners may remember I spoke with Charles back in April about what Donors Choose was doing during the COVID-19 crisis. As stay-at-home orders drove kids of all ages out of schools and into remote learning environments, Donors Choose had to rethink entirely their mission and workflow.
48:19 Speaker 04 It actually represents a pivot from our model. Our model takes several weeks for a teacher's project to get crowdfunded. And when that project is crowdfunded, we only ship materials to a verified school address. So neither of those things are going to work in this situation.
48:38 Speaker 03 Charles worries that one of the fallouts from the coronavirus is a deepening of the class divide, and thus, the performance divide between richer and poorer students.
48:48 Speaker 04 When kids, especially kids in low-income communities, cannot go to school, their home circumstances, the resources available in their homes, are going to define their education. And yet, at the same time, those kids' teachers know exactly what those students need to keep learning from home. They know which of their students are experiencing homelessness and need hygiene items or groceries to be able to focus on their schoolwork. They know which of their kindergartners need crayons and construction paper and magnetiles. They know which of their students need great books to read.
49:27 Speaker 04 And so what we've been doing as business and government agencies rush to equip health workers and as food banks ramp up to feed the hungry, we've been in a mad dash to develop a mechanism for public school teachers in high poverty communities to send their students personalized education care packages containing the stuff their kids need to keep learning from home and shipping those directly to students' homes.
49:57 Speaker 03 So far, thousands of teachers have been connected with funding that will go straight to these student "learn from home" kits, a number that will surely be higher by the time this episode airs. If you've enjoyed this episode and you want to share it with a friend, an easy way to share it is to send this link, listen.masterscale.com/donorschoose. That's listen.masterscale.com/donorschoose. This link will go right to the episode and it'll open the episode in whatever podcast app your friend uses. Tackling inequality during a pandemic is a huge undertaking, but Donors Choose is
50:38 Speaker 03 fighting it in typical style by zeroing in on a single manageable problem. They've focused on optimizing the delivery of the basics, knowing that those small care packages will make a huge difference in how successfully kids can learn from home until it's safe to return to school. We're all hoping that soon, Donors Choose, like everyone else, can revert to the regular funding models and routines. We're all hoping that we can find our way out of trying and troubling circumstances. In times like these, small steps are sometimes the only ones we can take. So the more finite, tidy, achievable
51:18 Speaker 03 goals we can lay our hands on, the easier it will be to do the right thing, and then the next right thing. I'm Reid Hoffman. Thank you for listening.
51:29 Speaker 00 Every business hits the same wall the moment your business outgrows the systems that got you here. Spreadsheets everywhere, five different logins, data scattered across entities that don't even talk to each other. If your finance team spends more time finding data than using it, that's when you need the Intuit ERP. Intuit Enterprise Suite is the AI-native ERP solution that's powerful, painless, and proven, built for businesses scaling fast without the complexity that usually comes with it. From the makers of QuickBooks, learn more at intuit.com/erp.
52:09 Speaker 06 Humans will never be more intelligent than AI.
52:12 Speaker 02 There's going to be two types of companies. Those are great at AI and those that went out of business because they weren't.
52:17 Speaker 01 How do we build a future that is human-centered? I'm Rana Elkhoyubi. And on my podcast, Pioneers of AI, we answer that question and so many more. As an AI scientist, entrepreneur, and investor, I know what it takes to build AI that works for everyone. Every week, I sit down with the pioneers shaping our future and we take you behind the scenes of the AI that's transforming our lives. Find Pioneers of AI wherever you tune in.
52:51 Speaker 02 Hey listeners, Bob here. If you listen to Rapid Response on Masters of Scale, you may be missing half the show because every Friday, we release a second Rapid Response exclusively in the Rapid Response feed. The guests and topics are just as compelling and timely, from Ford CEO to NASA's administrator to the lessons from the devil wears Prada. It takes about 10 seconds to find. Just search Rapid Response wherever you listen to podcasts and hit follow to make sure you never miss an episode. I hope to see you there.
53:29 Speaker 03 Masters of Scale is a Wait What original. The show is recorded remotely with sanitized audio gear. Our executive producers are June Cohen and Darren Triff. Our supervising producer is Jay Punjabi. Our producers are Chris MacLeod, Adam Skuse, Jenny Cataldo, Jordan MacLeod, Katherine Clark Gray, Hallie Bondi, Christina Gonzalez, and Ben Manila. Our editor-at-large is Bob Safian. Original music and sound design by Ryan Holiday and Daniel Nissenbaum. Audio editing by Keith J. Nelson. Mixing and mastering by Brian Pugh. Special thanks to Chris Ye, Elisa Schreiber, David Sanford, Saieda Sepieva, Adam Heiner,
54:12 Speaker 03 Emily McManus, Kelsey Capitano, Tim Cronin, Sarah Sandman, Charlie Meneses, and Colin Howarth. Visit mastersofscale.com to find the transcript for this episode and be sure to subscribe to our email newsletter.
Previous Rapid Response: Burning cash, accepting turbulence w/Delta CEO Ed Bastian Next Rapid Response: A new playbook for new times, w/Ford Foundation president Darren Walker Page updated October 21, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated