Pod Insights Masters of Scale Peloton’s John Foley – How to turn skeptics into fans About this episode Casual fans come and go. But converts stick with you – and spread the word. The trick is knowing how – and WHEN – to convert skeptics into super-fans. No one knows this better than Peloton co-founder and CEO John Foley, who has one of the most epic “No-to-Yes” stories in startup history. When he founded the company in 2012, skeptics abounded – especially among investors. But John pushed forward, convincing co-founders, angel investors, and then riders, one at a time. As he converted those skeptical customers – in their flagship fitness studio, in their stores, and on their at-home bikes – the feedback loops kicked in. After pedaling in place for years, Peloton rocketed up the hill to its 2019 IPO. Cameo appearances: Melanie Curtis http://melaniecurtis.com/about/ (professional skydiver).
Read a transcript of this episode at https://mastersofscale.com https://mastersofscale.com/
Subscribe to the Masters of Scale weekly newsletter at https://mastersofscale.com/subscribe
See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
Transcript 0:01 Speaker 00 We've all spent money on something that seemed incredible, but didn't live up to the hype. A kitchen gadget, a car. When it doesn't deliver, the disappointment is real. Marketers suffer from this too. Chasing metrics that look great, but don't translate into revenue. LinkedIn calls that bull spend. Invest in what matters and reach the right buyers with LinkedIn Ads. You can target by company, industry, job title, and more. LinkedIn Ads also generates the highest ROAS of all major ad networks. Spend $250 on your first campaign on LinkedIn Ads and get a $250 credit for the next one. Just go to LinkedIn.com/scale. That's LinkedIn.com/scale. Terms and conditions apply.
0:48 Speaker 00 The very best founders I know are brilliant at building systems. They connect teams, they remove bottlenecks, and they eliminate single points of failure. And yet, when it comes to their own wealth, most are running a disconnected stack. A tax accountant here and a state attorney there, a wealth manager who doesn't talk to either one of them. Creative Planning was built to fix exactly that. One integrated team of tax professionals, state planners, investment specialists, all coordinated by a dedicated wealth manager who sees your full financial picture and keeps every piece working together. Proactive tax efficiency, estate strategy, investments, all under one roof.
1:32 Speaker 00 Creative Planning, where wealth works together. Learn more at creativeplanning.com/mastersofscale.
1:41 Speaker 01 AI is full of possibilities. Enterprises run on realities. That's why Pega combines the world's most powerful AI with the governance, transparency, and control enterprises demand. So you can move faster, adapt faster, and scale AI with confidence. All the power of AI, none of the uncertainty. Learn more at Pega.com/AI.
2:06 Speaker 02 I don't know, Reid. I don't know what I could have done differently. I think I'm a pretty good salesman. I believed so passionately in what we're doing, and I still do. And I was explaining it as best I could.
2:21 Speaker 03 That's John Foley, co-founder and CEO of Peloton. And he's taking me back to 2012, when he first started pitching his idea to investors.
2:30 Speaker 02 I had a 10 out of 10 business on a silver platter, going to strategics, going to angels, going to venture capitalists.
2:39 Speaker 03 John envisioned a connected stationary bike that would deliver live classes to the home. He thought he would cruise to an easy victory with his 10 out of 10 idea. But it turned into an epic uphill climb.
2:56 Speaker 02 Here I was, I have 15 years of tech leadership experience, and I was sure that venture capitalists were going to throw money at me because it was such a good idea and I was an experienced guy.
3:07 Speaker 03 And what was your experience like? Because that was clearly the dramatic buildup for the "but instead..."
3:13 Speaker 02 But instead, three years later, after pitching hundreds of venture capitalists and thousands of angels, I hadn't raised a dime of money from an institution.
3:27 Speaker 03 Fans of Peloton know all about tough climbs, but this was a hill so steep, John couldn't see the top. Every investor was a skeptic, and they all had different ways to say no.
3:41 Speaker 02 There were 10 or 12 buckets of no's. It was my age.
3:50 Speaker 02 Half of the VCs didn't like hardware at all.
3:55 Speaker 02 Fitness was a dopey category plagued by bad teams and bad products and bad marketing and gimmicks and fads.
4:08 Speaker 02 A lot of people in the valley didn't understand boutique fitness.
4:13 Speaker 02 "Oh, you're a New York City company. I've made a commitment to my family that I'm only going to sit on boards in California."
4:21 Speaker 02 No investors wanted to look at this thing. They wanted nothing to do with it.
4:27 Speaker 03 John took hundreds of no's from venture capital firms, thousands from angel investors as he tried to fund his 10 out of 10 idea. But of course, this isn't where his story ended. The buckets of no's eventually became a chorus of yes.
4:52 Speaker 03 Eight years later, Peloton is a publicly traded company with a valuation of nearly $20 billion. John and his team ultimately converted skeptical doubters into diehard believers, and then rode their enthusiasm all the way over the hill. How did he do it? Stay tuned.
5:11 Speaker 03 I believe you clear your path to scale by converting skeptics to fanatics. The best megaphones for your product are the ones who doubted you at the start.
5:23 Speaker 03 You've got to have incredible talent at every position.
5:26 Speaker 04 It's like this huge push. There are fires burning when you're going home. Can you believe it? Such an idiot. And then you go back to, this is totally going to be amazing. There are so many easy wins. I have no idea what to do. Sorry, we made a mistake. But you have to time it right. Oops.
5:42 Speaker 05 Worked me out of a three-bedroom apartment. Stuff that just seems absolutely nutballs. 10 years later, it's like, well, that's just how you do it. We haven't made it. Just how you do it.
5:53 Speaker 03 This is Masters of Scale.
6:00 Speaker 03 I'm Reid Hoffman, co-founder of LinkedIn, partner at Greylock, and your host. And I believe you clear your path to scale by converting skeptics to fanatics. The best megaphones for your product are the ones who doubted you at the start. I want you to think of a food you love, but not just any food, one you used to hate. For me, it was stinky cheese. When I was a kid, nothing could sound more revolting. But fast forward to adulthood, and it's one of my favorite indulgences. In particular, I have a fondness for this one pungent cheese called epoche. It's very soft, rubbed with brine and brandy, and aged for six weeks.
6:41 Speaker 03 In its original, unpasteurized form, epoche is banned in the United States. It's a cudgel of a cheese. It'll punch right through whatever else is on your plate. Now, did I convince you? Not all of you, definitely not the lactose intolerant, but a few of you may drop some poisson into your next Instacart. And if we were together in person, I'd have even a better chance. Why? Because an impassioned testimonial from a trusted source is a powerful thing. It can overcome skepticism, especially if the person testifying was once a skeptic. And especially if the skeptic can try it for themselves. Now, it's not easy to convert full-on skeptics.
7:26 Speaker 03 And let me be clear, you don't want to pursue them at the expense of friendly early adopters. But if you can find a way to hack that skepticism and convert it into a passion for your product, you'll create an organic, loyal following that bind themselves to your brand. Why does it work? Because it's vanishingly rare that we can admit to ourselves, "I was wrong." And when we get to that state of self-discovery, it imprints itself on our memory and fuels our newfound love of the thing we had hated so. That's why casual fans can come and go, but converts will stick with you and spread the word on your behalf.
8:07 Speaker 03 I wanted to talk to John Foley about this because as the co-founder and CEO of Peloton, he knows a lot about the conviction of true fans. It turns out, he knows a lot about skeptics too, as you'll hear. Peloton is a brand with a very passionate fan base, and that was true even before the global pandemic put gyms and fitness classes on pause. Peloton stationary bikes have a connected tablet that lets you take part in remote cycling classes. They've won over a million connected fitness subscribers and a user base of over 2.5 million members. But before that, they faced years of existential struggles. I'll let John put this in his way.
8:46 Speaker 02 We were just sure that tens of thousands of people were going to throw money at us, and it was crickets.
8:53 Speaker 03 We'll get to that uphill climb in a little bit, but first, some background. John grew up in the Florida Keys. His mother was a homemaker. His father was a pilot for Delta. When it was time for college, John's family knew money would be tight, so his father gave him the best advice he knew.
9:10 Speaker 02 My dad brought home a US News and World report, "Best Schools for Your Money." I got into Georgia Tech, which was apparently a good school for your money. There's a co-op program where you work six months a year and you go to school six months a year, so that you can pay your way through college.
9:26 Speaker 03 Was that six months on, six months off particularly useful for entrepreneurship at all? One of the things that I've been mulling for years is that, roughly speaking, one of the things I say is entrepreneurship can't be taught, but it can be learned. But was that at all helpful as a precursor to the entrepreneurial journey?
9:45 Speaker 02 I wonder. That's a good question, Reed. And I'll put a finer point on it. It was three months on, three months off. You weren't comfortable. You were constantly putting your life into a car and driving 1,000 miles across country. It did give you the sleep on the couch and the work ethic for the rough times of entrepreneurship. I guess there was a correlation.
10:05 Speaker 03 I think you're maybe literally the only person I've ever talked to who's worked on the factory floor of M&M and Mars. John got a job at a Waco, Texas factory for Mars M&M.
10:17 Speaker 02 At one point, I was a shift manager for Skittles and Starburst. But our plant also made Snickers and Twix. Only we made 6 million Snicker bars a day, which was just hard to get your brain around.
10:28 Speaker 03 It's not easy to see a path to entrepreneurship with 6 million Snickers bars whizzing by. And John had another hurdle. He studied industrial engineering, which isn't the most common background for tech founders. It's led him to face some skepticism in the field.
10:44 Speaker 02 Looking back, mechanical engineers, electrical engineers are much more respected in tech. So I've had to fight through that and let people know that I'm not soft or whatever the stereotype might be.
10:54 Speaker 03 And I don't share that stereotype at all, but I think it's insufficiently techie is, I think, what the inaccurate stereotype is.
11:01 Speaker 02 That's it. That's fair.
11:02 Speaker 03 Yeah. Well, so my major was symbolic systems and my CS friends, comp sci friends, said, oh, yeah, that's comp sci light.
11:09 Speaker 02 Oh, boy.
11:10 Speaker 03 It was like, okay, so I'm familiar.
11:12 Speaker 02 You've had the pebble in your shoe as well.
11:14 Speaker 03 If you're unfamiliar with the nuances of engineer politics, here's a little context. Industrial engineers are in charge of operations. They streamline production. Electrical and mechanical engineers get into the technical nitty gritty, working with pure math and physics. They tend to be better represented among Silicon Valley founders. But John's father didn't know that when he advised his son on career options. And the way John's dad formulated advice gives us a window into how people make up their minds and maybe how to change them.
11:49 Speaker 02 My dad told me that if I wanted to be a business guy, you might want to look at industrial engineering because the CEO and the president of Delta at the time had gone to Georgia Tech and had been industrial engineers.
12:02 Speaker 03 John's father based his advice on the most successful business leaders he knew. And that's what all of us do. When we form our understanding of the world, we start with what's familiar. We give extra weight to what we seen firsthand. And that's helpful to remember when we think about how to convert a skeptic. Sometimes there's just no substitute for letting people see things with their own eyes. John's answer to the skeptics was to become a tech executive anyway. He left the manufacturing world to work at CitySearch, get his MBA at Harvard, and eventually join Barry Diller's empire at IAC.
12:36 Speaker 02 It sounds big in corporate, but so many fantastic leaders and fantastic entrepreneurs were in that world.
12:44 Speaker 03 We've had some of those entrepreneurs on the show, including Dara Khosrowshahi of Uber, Selena Tobakawala of Evite, and of course Barry Diller himself.
12:54 Speaker 02 He understood the entrepreneurial spirit. So what we did at IAC Read, which not many people know, is several times I would go to Barry and say, I have an idea. I want startup risk. I want startup upside. Will you agree to fund this? You own it as IAC, but I get to start a company.
13:13 Speaker 03 John spent over a decade at IAC, acting as CEO of several in-house startups. Then he left for Barnes & Noble. So what made you decide to go take on The Nook with Barnes & Noble?
13:27 Speaker 02 Every time we did something at IAC, the press would read Barry Diller launches this, or Barry Diller does that. I think I was about to turn 40 and I said, I want to be my own person. I'm not really an ego-driven guy, but I just kind of wanted to spread my wings.
13:41 Speaker 03 The Nook was Barnes & Noble's answer to Amazon's Kindle, an e-reader device to drive sales of digital content.
13:48 Speaker 02 In our minds' eye, we raised the pirate flag and we were going to take down Amazon. That turned out to be a bad ship. You're glad you weren't on that pirate ship.
13:58 Speaker 03 Yes, that one got sunk by the Navy. There are several reasons why The Nook struggled to topple the Kindle, but one theory goes back to how customers perceived its maker. Barnes & Noble was seen as a brick and mortar store, one that only sold books, while Amazon was seen as a digital store for everything. That gave Amazon more credibility to create their own hardware and therefore a head start. Over time, The Nook had thinner offerings in apps, games, and video, and they just couldn't convert skeptics as fast as the Kindle or the emerging iPad. But working on The Nook did have a solar lining. It brought John an aha moment.
14:42 Speaker 02 I was in a boutique fitness class, a cycling class, and I was thinking to myself, but Nook and the Kindle are hardware and software platforms for consuming content at home.
14:58 Speaker 02 And I said, could you build a fitness platform, hardware and software that allowed you to consume the content at home? And it was like, of course you can. It's called a big tablet and a bike or a treadmill. And you bring the class content. And it was very clear to me.
15:13 Speaker 03 With this moment of clarity, the concept of Peloton was born. The reality would take a bit longer. John started drawing up plans for Peloton in 2011 with his first co-founder, Tom Cortese from IAC. The concept was simple. Make it easier for busy people to take great spin classes with great instructors anytime. He saw an indoor bike with a tablet attached to it that could stream classes live. Or after the fact, an app would run with a bike to track data like heart rate or RPM. And that data would show up on a leaderboard so riders could race against each other up the virtual hill. Many features and iterations were yet to come, like the live class studio in New York
15:57 Speaker 03 and the showrooms worldwide. But John could see the core idea clearly. In 2012, John left Barnes and Noble to make Peloton official. He added three more co-founders, all of whom are still with the company. John had his dream team. Expectations were high. And you already heard what happened next.
16:18 Speaker 02 Three years later, after pitching hundreds of venture capitalists and thousands of angels, I hadn't raised a dime of money from an institution.
16:28 Speaker 03 So why couldn't John convert these skeptics? He still puzzles over it. Here's his take.
16:34 Speaker 02 I thought I was good, but clearly I wasn't because my success rate on these meetings was one out of 100 people would give me a check.
16:42 Speaker 03 In these meetings, John heard a lot of reasons for skepticism. But one of them particularly stung. They had their doubts about him.
16:51 Speaker 02 Everybody dreams of being the Mark Zuckerberg, I guess, at 19. You have an idea and people are throwing money at you and you never really have a boss, maybe because you're always calling the shots. But for me, it was the opposite. It was 20 years of schlogging it out as kind of a corporate guy. And I thought that was going to be an asset that I had experience. It turns out that was a liability. I was like, wait, what? My experience is a liability. Everyone found a reason not to like me at that point.
17:16 Speaker 03 Well, but this is actually related. One of the things that is unusual about your story is that typically the kind of the 20-year career path of being a very successful executive in a number of different industries doesn't actually prepare you for entrepreneurship. The rulebook for being a really successful executive is very different from the rulebook of being a successful entrepreneur, as you know, because you've done both.
17:40 Speaker 02 Yeah.
17:41 Speaker 03 This innate suspicion of career executives is, I can attest, a real phenomenon. And this kind of skepticism isn't just based on surface assumptions. Corporate management rewards conservatism, while entrepreneurship favors the bold. Like many founders, John was facing bias based on a handful of facts about him. To be clear, there were plenty of biases John Foley wasn't facing. As a white, male Harvard graduate with a rich alumni network, he could get into rooms that female founders and founders of color are often shut out of. For John, getting into the room wasn't the problem. The problem was converting the skeptics. John heard no so many times, it's a bit difficult to imagine him carrying on.
18:26 Speaker 02 Everyone says, well, how did you take so many no's? 400 no's from 400 institutions and then thousands of no's from angels. You know, why did we keep going? I believed that there was something here and I still firmly do. I believe that we are in out one of inning one of this opportunity of what Peloton is going to do from a technology platform globally and structure-led fitness to homes, eventually hundreds of millions of homes around the world.
18:55 Speaker 03 Well, it's a combination of believing in yourselves and the belief that there is a fitness market here that can be revolutionized by tech that essentially everyone's missing. The good news of the fact that Venture doesn't get it is they're not funding any competitors.
19:09 Speaker 02 Hundred percent.
19:10 Speaker 03 And so if you can make it through, you can make something very unique. John wasn't getting any traction with VCs, but he had started converting a few key skeptics into fanatics. His co-founders, Tom Cortese, Hisao Kushi, Yoni Fang, and Graham Staton. He pulled them away from promising careers by painting the picture of a wide-open fitness category and a device that would bring it into millions of homes. The prototype was still in its early phase, the network of users not yet built, so John couldn't yet ask a funder to hop on a Peloton and take a spin. He had to convert skeptics on the power of story and vision alone. He described a network of home writers, thousands per class,
19:54 Speaker 03 pedaling away at the same time to the same live instructor and a gamified leaderboard system. And the best part was, no one else was doing it. John leaned into that pitch, and one by one, he won over a few early believers, angel investors going in for blocks of $25,000 or $50,000 at a time. Those investors included John's brother-in-law, his co-founders, and John himself. Every check mattered. Each one strengthened his resolve and built Peloton some runway to prove their case.
20:26 Speaker 02 Three years later, I had 100 checks from 100 angels that amounted to roughly $10 million. And that's how we capitalized the first three years of Peloton.
20:37 Speaker 03 Thousands of pitches to get 100 yeses shows incredible grit. But I have to go back to the earlier question. Why couldn't he convert the skeptics in those VC firms? My take, they were actually the wrong VCs. Well, if I were giving advice to your younger self, I'd probably say, only go to VCs who are the eccentric VCs. Don't go to mainline VCs. Because mainline VCs are going to be the, is this enterprise software? Do you look like one of the other things that have had a multi-billion dollar exit yet? Oh, no, you don't? Oh, well, then I'm not interested. Right? And they won't say it that way. They'll actually take a bunch of your time because you've got enough of a pedigree and something interesting enough that you'll go do 1,000 pitches, and then it's a problem.
21:20 Speaker 02 Yeah, you're right. It is good advice to go to the contrarian and to the more think-for-themselves venture capitalist. And that's eventually what I found in Lee Fixell.
21:29 Speaker 03 Lee's great. I was literally on the phone with him yesterday. Lee Fixell is an investor who now sits on the board of Peloton. Here's one of the most important things to learn about converting skeptics. The earliest stage of your org actually isn't the time to convert full-on skeptics. It's just not efficient. These early days are the time to recruit your loyalists, the people most inclined not just to like you, but love you. And this goes for your investors as well as your customers. After a thousand pitches, John had gotten really good at painting his vision. What was missing was a way to be more selective in his targets. Some skeptics will simply never be moved. Others will only be moved when they see the data.
22:14 Speaker 03 So discerning which are movable becomes its own invaluable skill. How do you do this? Just by asking, what does this person value above all else? And am I offering something that speaks to that value? When you pitch a mainstream investor, they value a sure thing. They want you to look like every other deal they've seen succeed. When you pitch an eccentric VC, and of course, I consider myself one, they value ideas that are contrarian, the ones that don't look like every other deal.
22:48 Speaker 00 We all know the disappointment that comes when a grand gesture falls flat, something that seemed impressive in the moment, but didn't deliver the results you expected. Marketing budgets too often fall into that trap, aiming for big impressions, big reach, but without the revenue to back it. LinkedIn has a name for it, Bull Spend. LinkedIn Ads generates the highest ROAS of all major ad networks. They target by company, industry, job title, and more. Spend $250 on your first campaign on LinkedIn Ads and get a $250 credit for the next one. Just go to LinkedIn.com/scale. That's LinkedIn.com/scale. Terms and conditions apply.
23:32 Speaker 00 When you've built substantial wealth through your business, it's often tied up in a single equity position. The upside is real, but so is the risk, and knowing when to act isn't always obvious. Creative Planning works with business owners to build a strategy around concentrated equity, when to diversify, how to manage tax risk, and how to protect what you've spent years building. Creative Planning, where wealth works together. Learn more at creativeplanning.com/mastersofscale. Stripe Treasury is your new financial operating system built for what's next. With Stripe Treasury, the place your business accepts payments is also where you can store balances, move funds, and pay vendors worldwide. If you're building for global scale,
24:17 Speaker 00 get a business bank account that lets your money move instantly, whenever and wherever you need it. Learn more at stripe.com/treasury. Stripe is not a bank. Banking services provided by Fifth Third Bank, National Association Member, FDIC.
24:34 Speaker 03 We're back with John Foley of Peloton. We were talking about how you convert skeptics into fanatics. So far, we focused a lot on the skeptics John and his co-founders faced as they tried to get funded. Peloton did start to gain traction, not with mainstream VCs, but by converting one angel investor at a time with a power of story. So what do you think was the key things that the, call it wisdom of the crowd VCs, weren't getting? Was it that the demand was so high? Was it the stickiness? What was the thing that was like, kind of like, no, no, this is why it was contrarian and right?
25:12 Speaker 02 Yeah. One of the things that I still think a lot of investors in the world hasn't woken up to is what a gorgeous category the fitness world is, how much willingness to pay from a consumer and how passionate people are about fitness, how much time they want to spend, how much money they're willing to spend, how much they care about it, how much they're proud of it. I mean, going back 15 or 20 years, you knew a couple of people, I'm sure, Reid, that had Iron Man tattoos.
25:40 Speaker 03 That's Iron Man, the distance triathlon, not the Marvel hero. And in truth, I don't think anyone has ever shown me theirs.
25:48 Speaker 02 If you did a Iron Man, you got a tattoo because you're so proud of yourself, right? And then you see women in New York City walking around with SoulCycle tank tops. And people want to talk about, they're proud of their fitness routine. People love fitness. So when I'd go in and I would say, we are going to be the tech disruptor in fitness. They would hear, fitness is a dopey category where there's been no capital and no software and no media and no innovation. And I would say, exactly.
26:22 Speaker 03 This was back in 2012, when boutique fitness studios were booming.
26:29 Speaker 03 SoulCycle, the biggest name in spin, was six years old.
26:34 Speaker 03 Its rival, Flywheel, had just turned two.
26:39 Speaker 03 Bar classes, hot yoga, CrossFit and bootcamps were taking over New York, LA and San Francisco.
26:50 Speaker 03 But the crossover to streaming content was still in its infancy. Most at-home fitness instruction lived on YouTube.
26:58 Speaker 03 It seemed to John like an inflection point was coming and he wanted Peloton to drive it.
27:06 Speaker 03 Having exhausted every VC fund they could think of, John and his co-founders turned to Kickstarter to recruit some new fans. If the funders remained skeptical, surely showing them thousands of ready consumers would change their minds. How did Kickstarter play into all of this?
27:23 Speaker 02 For the first almost two years, we hung everything on it. We knew that at this point, the investors didn't see it. But we thought the consumers might see it. So we thought that if we could put a prototype together and tell our story in a four-minute Kickstarter video, you remember that year or two or three that Kickstarter was kind of a big deal. It felt like all fundraising was going to take place on that platform for a hot second, right? And we were right in that vortex.
27:48 Speaker 03 You may have heard of that vortex John mentions has the reality distortion field, and it's actually an effective way to convert someone from a skeptic to a fanatic. Some founders are famously good at generating reality distortion fields, from Elon Musk to Steve Jobs. In fact, the term "reality distortion field" was coined for Jobs by an Apple exec who borrowed it from Star Trek. It's meant to convey charisma, but also something more: the ability to convince everyone around you that your idea is not just epic, but inevitable. It's more than just storytelling, it's world-building. As John pointed out, Kickstarter as a platform is good at conjuring this vortex.
28:31 Speaker 03 Build your page, make your video, and it just feels like the pledges are about to come rolling in.
28:37 Speaker 02 And so, we were head of steam, so excited, spent meaningful money on creating our video to tell our story because we wanted it to be as blue-chip as we could afford, which was, looking back, not blue-chip at all.
28:49 Speaker 03 John has gone on the record before about just how "not blue-chip" the process was. They ran into prototype troubles, one bike came back 40% too big, another was so wobbly they had to ask the writer in their video, who happened to be John's wife, to pedal very slowly.
29:06 Speaker 02 But we were proud of it at the time, and we launched it, and we were so excited, and we were just sure that thousands, tens of thousands of people were going to throw money at us, and again, it was crickets.
29:18 Speaker 03 Only 178 people bought a Peloton bike from the original Kickstarter, and there's no sugarcoating it. This setback hurt. It's one thing to say that venture capitalists doubt you, it's another to say that consumer doesn't want you. You've been betting everything on the promise that if you build it, they will come, and they didn't. This actually happens a lot with crowdfunding. It turns out, it's better for rallying your own supporters than it is for finding new ones. It's definitely not the place to convert skeptics, but in John's case, there's something else they'd come to learn. No video of someone using the Peloton would be as convincing as a customer trying it out for themselves.
30:01 Speaker 03 And this was the insight that ultimately let Peloton break out. Peloton is a tech-centric company, but it isn't tech-only. At the heart of the Peloton experience is a real fitness studio with real instructors and real cyclists pedaling together in real time with people at home on their Peloton bikes. This vertical integration from the real-life studio to the bike at home defines Peloton today. But it turns out, that was a bit of an accident. One of the things you undoubtedly really stuck your guns on was the vertical integration. Everything from the bike, to the media elements, to the production of media. Undoubtedly, you got a ton of, "Ah, that's really expensive, you're trying to do too
30:46 Speaker 03 much." What gave you the conviction to stay with that vertical integration?
30:51 Speaker 02 Yeah, I will say, we didn't dream up the idea of being so vertically integrated. We were forced into doing it. In the early days, as kind of tech entrepreneurs, we went to SoulCycle and we went to Flywheel and said, "You guys have studios, you have instructors, you run classes, you are effectively the media, you have the brand, and you do all that. We could, together, put a camera in your class, and we could be the hardware and software team over here, and we could partner." We didn't have the money to create a studio, to hire the team, to hire the instructors, all of that stuff wasn't in the original plan.
31:31 Speaker 03 Notice how SoulCycle and Flywheel reacted. And remind yourself to think twice before you ever make this mistake. Both of these fitness studios were skeptical that John's idea would do anything but cannibalize their business. They both said no, and Peloton was forced to go it alone.
31:50 Speaker 02 Looking back on it, we're very happy the way it worked out because we think vertical integration has now created a stronger platform.
31:57 Speaker 03 John and his co-founders had imagined themselves as a hardware and software company, delivering classes that other companies organized. But they found themselves not only building bikes and tablets, but creating their own functioning cycling gym.
32:12 Speaker 02 We hired these instructors, and we had the production techs and maintenance folks, and we had 30 or 40 people working in that studio. Which felt like incremental burn for a young tech company, right? Hiring 30 or 40 non-tech people, you get anxious, you and I get anxious about that. The beautiful thing was, though, that you had paying customers coming in to fill up those 55 bikes to take the local spin class. So notionally, that studio and the instructors and the salaries were paid for via the side P and L of the studio business.
32:52 Speaker 03 Of course, the local spin class did more than cover the cost of the studio. It seeded the Peloton universe with its first passionate fans. Fans who had the opportunity that hundreds of potential investors hadn't. The ability to try the experience for themselves. The studio was a powerful rainmaker for Peloton, but there were some learning curves, to be sure.
33:16 Speaker 02 We built a bike for the home, the core Peloton bike, and then we had the studio bikes. And, you know, on the 10-yard line, we said, oh, shoot, we don't want this 22-inch tablet in front of the person coming to take the local class because they don't need the video content. So right away, we had to scramble and build a second hardware and software platform. And then, by the way, there's a third hardware and software platform of the instructor bike because we wanted that instructor to be fed stuff from the data warehouse of, hey, it's Reid Hoffman's 100th ride. Give him a shout out. R. Hoffman in Palo Alto, you're going to carry us up the hill in 3, 2, 1, everyone, everyone follow R. Hoffman.
33:59 Speaker 02 And it's, oh, my gosh, I got a shout out from this, you know, my sensei, this instructor that I've been following for, you know, six or 12 months.
34:09 Speaker 03 These in-person riders were quickly converted to Team Peloton by the quality of the experience. In fact, they were excited enough to tell their friends, both in and outside of New York City. With each live class, Peloton grew in popularity, and their studio got better at filming and creating content for those streaming at home. It was a virtuous cycle that got Peloton's flywheel turning. And to keep it turning, John and his team had to get people to try those bikes. They had been stuck in first gear in their quest to win converts, until they built a functioning model. As soon as there was something to try, turning skeptics into fanatics grew a lot easier.
34:51 Speaker 03 They experimented with Facebook ads, pop-up shops, but their greatest success came from what tech guys like me think of as an unlikely place: an old-fashioned brick-and-mortar store. Peloton opened their first showroom in Short Hills, New Jersey, an affluent commuter satellite of New York. In their showroom, customers clicked their feet into the pedals and listened to the music, cranking through headphones, as their video instructor guides them through their climb. Everything that had been theoretical on their Kickstarter video was now tangible and real. John's team had calculated that to keep the doors open, they needed to sell one Peloton bike a day.
35:32 Speaker 03 But soon after opening their first showroom, they were averaging four. Curious skeptics were converted into paying customers through this physical experience. And it's worth noting, this "try it, you'll like it" persuasion model isn't new, but it is effective. Think of the TV show Shark Tank. The entrepreneurs always have Mark Cuban and Barbara Corcoran taste and touch and try things. It's not just good TV, it's good business. You can hear it in their voices when you've converted a skeptic into a fan. And I want to stay with this idea for a moment, because the truth is skeptics are rarely persuaded by words alone.
36:14 Speaker 03 It often takes physical, tangible experiences to win them over. And I want to give you another, very physical example of how skeptics are converted to fanatics. We'll start, as one does, inside a Cessna.
36:34 Speaker 04 There are propellers spinning. It's windy. Wind rushes into the fuselage and you feel it on your face. You have your goggles on, you're ready to go.
36:49 Speaker 04 You're probably imagining, "What the hell am I doing?"
36:58 Speaker 03 That's professional skydiver Melanie Curtis. And if anyone knows about converting skeptics, it's her. Melanie is the co-founder of Highlight Pro Skydiving Team. So she's seen her share of reluctance at 13,000 feet.
37:13 Speaker 04 The ideology of no way, no how, never gonna do it. You see that a lot. And so there's this very electric part of converting people, right? And going, "How do we break through an ideology like that?"
37:29 Speaker 03 Melanie has 24 years of experience breaking through that kind of ideology and turning skeptics into fanatics like herself. Her own path started with the physical experience of her first jump.
37:45 Speaker 04 I'm in the small aircraft.
37:49 Speaker 04 My best friend from high school is making her first jump. And because of weight and balance, she's going first.
37:57 Speaker 04 I will never forget the visual of her climbing out onto the wheel of this Cessna and her just disappearing. Like, she was just gone.
38:11 Speaker 04 And I, I mean, I just, I still don't even have the words. I will never forget that.
38:24 Speaker 03 Melanie has done some 11,000 jumps since that day. But how do you convince someone else to take the leap? The key is to listen to what stories they tell themselves and then tell a new one.
38:39 Speaker 04 Certainty is very seductive. We are so certain that we can't do certain things. So maybe someone is really blocked in a relationship. Or maybe they're really blocked and they're feeling just unenlivened.
38:55 Speaker 03 In cases like this, skydiving becomes the metaphor for taking the leap.
39:01 Speaker 04 There is nothing like exiting an aircraft in flight. When you let go of that airplane, that is a point of no return. You can't get back in the airplane. So there's this powerful surrender. There's a powerful choice to go, I feel afraid and I'm going to do this anyway. And I'm going to be open to what I might get from it.
39:24 Speaker 03 The end goal for Melanie is not getting the person to jump. Instead, she wants to give them the power to make that choice for themselves.
39:34 Speaker 04 I don't actually try to convert people. I try to genuinely understand people and what they are looking for and what might benefit them for real in their lives.
39:45 Speaker 03 And this brings us back to John. Trying to understand people and what might benefit them was his goal at Peloton 2. Every improvement they made to their system was shaped by what the customers needed from it. The flexible remote workout, the friendly competition, the feeling of community, the reminders to come back. These are all ways to encourage you to keep writing. And that's the true business proposition of Peloton. Unlike physical gyms, whose business model depends on some members just never showing up, Peloton wants their students to show up again and again.
40:25 Speaker 02 The first year of Peloton, we started sending 100 Ride t-shirts. When you do your 100th ride, you get a Peloton 100 Ride t-shirt. It's one of the most coveted things in our community and you earn it. It's gamified. You can't buy it.
40:40 Speaker 03 If it sounds odd that a t-shirt can motivate riders in a serious way, then you have a lot to learn about gamification, where even simple online badges can prompt engagement. The 100 Ride shirt is a coveted item because you can't buy it outright. Remember those Iron Man tattoos John spoke of? People now get tattoos of the Peloton logo. That's a real thing. Once Peloton sales started to take off, all the feedback loops started working the way they're supposed to. More users meant more riders. More riders meant more people clamoring to visit the live studio in Chelsea.
41:23 Speaker 03 Home riders formed Facebook and meetup groups to connect with each other. Some started organizing yearly pilgrimages to the Chelsea studio. After peddling in place for years, Peloton was rocketing up the hill. And something interesting happened. Eventually, VCs started coming around. The same ones who had been so skeptical the first time, some might think that this was the stuff of dreams. All the people who passed you by having to bow their heads and whisper, "I was wrong." But I cannot say this loudly enough. Do not make them do that.
42:04 Speaker 03 The way you convert non-believers to believers and skeptics to fans is not to force a ceremonial eating of crow. Because guess what? People do not like that. Persuasion is tricky when someone's ego is at stake. A better way is to say, "Hey, you were right, but things have changed. Let me show you what's different now and why we're a great bet. Remember my favorite stinky cheese? I don't think I was wrong as a child not to appreciate it. What changed is I grew up." In Peloton's case, a lot changed between their first 100 investors in 2012
42:47 Speaker 03 and their IPO in 2019. They smoothed out the kinks in their production line. They found a target audience and proved a market for a $2,400 bike by selling millions of them. They also showed the passion of their fans. So of course, they became an ever safer bet. And this is perhaps obvious, but the ultimate way that you convert skeptics is by being right, by having the data that demonstrates success, and then finding ever wider ways for people to come along for the ride. Which brings us to the COVID pandemic, which I don't need to remind you changed a lot about the world as we know it.
43:28 Speaker 03 I suspect the pandemic has had this weird, complex impact on Peloton. There's the obvious things, which is people's exercise at home and everything else, but then also like the studio and the operations and all the rest get much more complicated.
43:43 Speaker 02 You're absolutely right. It's multifaceted for our business. One, it's the usual, everyone's working from home and adjusting to that. Two, it's the learning that our retail stores, you know, we are a multi-channel marketer. We have 100 stores globally in four countries, and we have inside sales and we have the website. Our sales have been so incredibly strong, even though our stores are closed. So last night on the earnings call, a couple analysts were saying, well, do you need the stores? And I said emphatically, yes, we love our stores. When you think about new products that we're going to bring to market, if you want to
44:24 Speaker 02 go try the new X or Y device, you might go to the Palo Alto Stanford Shopping Center and go to our store and poke around and get on one of the bikes or get on one of the treads or one of the new products and have somebody explain to you what the difference is and feel which one's better for you. And we think that physical piece of Peloton still matters.
44:43 Speaker 03 Of course, Peloton had to close their physical studio. So they pivoted to an increased focus on how to make their leaderboards feel more intimate.
44:53 Speaker 02 When you think about a leaderboard with 30,000 people on it, or a couple hundred thousand people, you quickly bump into the impotence of abundance. When you think about Google in the early days, you don't need 17 million search returns, you need five that are the right information, right? A leaderboard with hundreds of thousands of people, isn't that motivating incrementally more than 2,000 people? Maybe it's less valuable because you feel less intimate and less connected.
45:23 Speaker 02 So we launched this tags concept where you might have the LinkedIn group, or the Palo Alto group, or the Microsoft senior exec, or whatever tag you might want to have. And when you get on the leaderboard, you can tag, and all of a sudden, you click into the Microsoft executive tag, and Peggy Johnson is there. And you're like, oh, my God, I didn't know she had a Peloton bike, but there she is. I high five her. I can video chat with her. And it takes that 200,000 into something instantly more intimate, and relatable, and personal. So as we get bigger, you want to make sure that when there's 100 million people on your platform, it feels like it's more intimate than it was yesterday, which is counterintuitive, but you do it through connecting people with people they know.
46:09 Speaker 03 It's hard to know what the next few months will bring. During the first wave of the pandemic, Peloton was named one of the three safest stock bets during quarantine. By the time you hear this, something may have changed again. But one thing will remain true. We're sure to continue to change our minds all the time. We doubt something one day and believe it the next. So if you have something, an idea, a company, a cause, and you want to get others to believe, the best way to convert them is to meet them right where they are. Do your best to show them why your path is the right one. Better
46:51 Speaker 03 yet, get them to see it for themselves. And if they don't, or won't, invest your time in someone who will. If you're lucky, you'll be able to go back to your doubters in the not-too-distant future and say, with perfect grace, you were right, but things have changed. I'm Reid Hoffman. Thank you for listening.
47:13 Speaker 00 Every business hits the same wall the moment your business outgrows the systems that got you here. Spreadsheets everywhere, five different logins, data scattered across entities that don't even talk to each other. If your finance team spends more time finding data than using it, that's when you need the Intuit ERP. Intuit Enterprise Suite is the AI-native ERP solution that's powerful, painless, and proven, built for businesses scaling fast without the complexity that usually comes with it. From the makers of QuickBooks, learn more at intuit.com/ERP.
47:53 Speaker 06 Hey listeners, Bob here. If you listen to Rapid Response on Masters of Scale, you may be missing half the show because every Friday, we release a second Rapid Response exclusively in the Rapid Response feed. The guests and topics are just as compelling and timely, from Ford CEO to NASA's administrator to the lessons from The Devil Wears Prada. It takes about 10 seconds to find. Just search Rapid Response wherever you listen to podcasts and hit follow to make sure you never miss an episode. I hope to see you there.
48:30 Speaker 07 Humans will never be more intelligent than AI.
48:33 Speaker 01 There's going to be two types of companies. Those are great at AI and those that went out of business because they weren't. How do we build a future that is human centered?
48:43 Speaker 07 I'm Rana Elkhayubi, and on my podcast, Pioneers of AI, we answer that question and so many more. As an AI scientist, entrepreneur, and investor, I know what it takes to build AI that works for everyone. Every week, I sit down with the pioneers shaping our future, and we take you behind the scenes of the AI that's transforming our lives. Find Pioneers of AI wherever you tune in.
49:14 Speaker 03 Masters of Scale is a Wait What original. The show is recorded remotely with sanitized audio gear. Our executive producers are June Cohen and Darren Triff. Our supervising producer is Jay Punjabi. Our producers are Chris MacLeod, Adam Skuse, Jenny Cataldo, Jordan MacLeod, Catherine Clark Gray, Hallie Bondi, Christina Gonzalez, and Ben Manila. Our editor-at-large is Bob Safian. Original music and sound design by Ryan Holiday and Daniel Nissenbaum. Audio editing by Keith J. Nelson. Mixing and mastering by Brian Pugh. Special thanks to Chris Ye, Elisa Schreiber, David Sanford, Said Assepeva, Adam Heiner, Emily McManus,
49:57 Speaker 03 Kelsey Capitano, Tim Cronin, Sarah Sandman, Charlie Manessis, and Colin Howarth. Visit mastersofscale.com to find a transcript for this episode and be sure to subscribe to our email newsletter.
Previous Why your company needs new rituals w/Shishir Mehrotra (YouTube, Coda) Next Rapid Response: What you can learn from how schools are pivoting, w/ Success Academy's Eva Moskowitz Page updated October 21, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated