Pod Insights Masters of Scale Open or closed? The answer is both, w/Joi Ito About this episode No organization that’s entirely closed — or entirely open — can scale as successfully as an organization that combines both. Yes, it invites a bit of chaos – but chaos breeds innovation. Joi Ito has spent his career championing radically open systems, from Creative Commons to cyber currency. As a past director of the famed MIT Media Lab, he focused on facilitating conversations that keep pace with the shifting challenges we face in our companies, institutions and societies. Cameo appearance: Megan Smith (former U. S. Chief Technology Officer).
Subscribe to the Masters of Scale weekly newsletter: https://mastersofscale.com/subscribe
See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
Transcript 0:01 Speaker 00 We've all spent money on something that seemed incredible but didn't live up to the hype. A kitchen gadget, a car. When it doesn't deliver, the disappointment is real. Marketers suffer from this too. Chasing metrics that look great but don't translate into revenue. LinkedIn calls that bull spend. Invest in what matters and reach the right buyers with LinkedIn Ads. You can target by company, industry, job title, and more. LinkedIn Ads also generates the highest ROAS of all major ad networks. Spend $250 on your first campaign on LinkedIn Ads and get a $250 credit for the next one. Just go to LinkedIn.com/scale. That's LinkedIn.com/scale. Terms and conditions apply.
0:49 Speaker 01 AI is full of possibilities. Enterprises run on realities. That's why Pega combines the world's most powerful AI with the governance, transparency, and control enterprises demand, so you can move faster, adapt faster, and scale AI with competence. All the power of AI, none of the uncertainty. Learn more at Pega.com/AI.
1:20 Speaker 02 Chicago in the 80s, it's the middle of the AIDS crisis. House music was kind of just peeking out, but it was a very vibrant period for nightclubs. I discovered that on the north side of Chicago, there was a really interesting vibrant club scene.
1:36 Speaker 03 That's Joey Ito, director of the MIT Media Lab, describing his former life as a DJ in Chicago in the 1980s.
1:44 Speaker 02 Our club, it's in the basement. They used to put sawdust on the floor because it would get pretty grummy.
1:51 Speaker 03 That vibrant and grimy nightlife scene was very different from where Joey spent his daylight hours.
1:59 Speaker 02 I was studying physics at University of Chicago, which was, I wouldn't call it a monoculture, but a lot of people with very similar values, very focused and intent on getting a good education, competing with each other.
2:10 Speaker 03 The contrast couldn't have been starker. Despite its intellectual pretensions to openness, the university felt like a world closed off to new ideas.
2:23 Speaker 03 But the nightclubs felt like a constant vibrant culture clash of people's styles and values, an open house that anyone could enter, and they did.
2:32 Speaker 02 We had people like Iggy Pop and Run DMC and Madonna. You had the city aldermen, the drug dealers, the mafia, the goths, the bartenders, really a community.
2:44 Speaker 03 It was an unlikely, chaotic group of people.
2:48 Speaker 02 There were always fights going on. You know, Iggy Pop would come and throw a bottle at one of our bartenders.
2:54 Speaker 03 It was the music that kept everyone in balance.
2:57 Speaker 02 The music at the time was everything from techno to industrial music to house music. The manager would say, you know, those kids on the dance floor, get them over to the bar to have a drink, and those college kids, get them onto the dance floor. And see the goth kids in the court, get them out of here, they're way too drunk.
3:12 Speaker 03 As a DJ, it usually fell on Joey to get the people to do what the manager wanted. Want the hip-hop kids off the dance floor? Play something by The Cure. Want the house fiends to pick up the pace? Put on Farley Jackmaster Funk. Want to ruin everyone's night? Joey was the puppet master, and his records were the strings he pulled.
3:45 Speaker 02 The DJ by playing the music could get people to drink, could get people to come in, could get people to leave, and then you'd get the last call for alcohol, and the DJ was in charge of getting them all out of the room. And what I realized was that the music that you played was an essential component to the atmosphere of a club and also the culture of the club.
4:04 Speaker 03 Actually, puppet master is the wrong term. Joey was more like a conductor, and his unlikely rotation of music maintained the harmony between the very different groups of people who felt at home in his club.
4:17 Speaker 02 There was a loving community that was trying to protect the runaway kids, that were trying to make sure that the drug dealers didn't sell drugs to the people who had AIDS. And it contrasted starkly with the competitive monoculture of this community I was in in university.
4:38 Speaker 03 This nightclub was the opposite of the kind of monoculture you see in a university or any kind of members-only club. A members-only club is exclusive. It keeps other people out, and the privileged few who can get in know what to expect. That's the attraction, but it's also the weakness. Those members will never be exposed to truly new ideas. And many scale companies seem like staid, members-only clubs, set in their ways and closed to the world. They have a lot to learn from the wild diversity at Joey's nightclub. I wouldn't recommend scaling that nightclub. That's a recipe for chaos.
5:21 Speaker 03 But the vibrancy, the openness, the sharing of the dance floor? Every company needs to take these ideas to heart. I believe no organization that's entirely closed or entirely open can scale as successfully as an organization that combines both.
5:42 Speaker 04 You've got to have incredible talent at every position.
5:46 Speaker 05 There are fires burning when you're going home. Can you believe it? Such an idiot. And then you go back to, this is totally going to be amazing. There are so many easy wins. I have no idea what to do. Sorry, we made a mistake.
5:58 Speaker 04 But you have to time it right. Oops.
6:01 Speaker 06 Working out of a three-bedroom apartment. Stuff that just seems absolutely nutballs 10 years later, like, well, that's just how you do it. We haven't made it just how you do it.
6:12 Speaker 03 This is Masters of Scale.
6:20 Speaker 03 I'm Reid Hoffman, founder of LinkedIn, partner at Greylock, and your host. And I believe no organization that's entirely closed or entirely open can scale as successfully as an organization that combines both. Many organizations, businesses, government agencies, universities are essentially closed, top-down, hierarchical, members-only, speak out of turn, and you'll be asked to leave. You have to be part of the in-crowd to contribute. However, in organizations and communities that are open, there is no in-crowd. Anyone can join and contribute. Ideas are
7:02 Speaker 03 judged on their merit. Think of open competitions, open-source code, or even the proverbial town square. Openness always invites a bit of chaos. You run the risk of losing control, but it's a risk well worth taking, because openness also breeds innovation. New points of view can surface from anywhere and bring novel solutions to problems. Knowing precisely which aspects of your organization should be open and which should be closed, and to what degree, will set you on a path to rapid scale.
7:43 Speaker 03 I wanted to speak with Joey Ito about this, because Joey has been instrumental in the growth of my own ideas about networks and openness. Joey's an entrepreneur, investor, and theorizer who spent much of his career championing radically open systems, from Creative Commons to cyber currency. Joey also railed against established, top-down institutions, from governments to banks to universities. Six years ago, Joey accepted a role inside one of these famously closed universities. As director of the famed MIT Media Lab, Joey's evolved from a staunch believer in radically open communities to a nuanced advocate for
8:26 Speaker 03 bringing openness to previously closed organizations. Joey and I come at the idea of openness from different angles, but both our approaches aim to drive innovation at scale and involve many, many people along the way. The way that I normally introduce Joey is "college dropout," director of the MIT Media Lab. It's a quick way to help people begin to understand him.
8:52 Speaker 02 I dropped out of college three times. Well, actually, I dropped out of college twice and a doctorate/PhD program once. It felt like there was more I could learn online than I could learn in an academic program.
9:03 Speaker 03 Joey dropped out to become immersed in that nightclub community. It was not the first radically open community that Joey had become involved in. As a high school student back in Tokyo, Joey had worked in his father's research lab. It gave him access to computers and the early internet.
9:19 Speaker 02 At night, I would program video games and also break copy protection on software on the Apple computer.
9:26 Speaker 03 Yes, you heard him right. Joey's teenage years were spent breaking copyright on software. But the thing that really excited Joey about these new technologies were the communities that were forming around them. Online bulletin boards were just emerging, and people from across the world engaged in conversations they could never have in their everyday lives with people in other countries of higher social status. These communities cut through hierarchy. They flattened the playing field. And it's fair to say that not everyone appreciated that. Joey tested this newfound access in his Tokyo high school.
10:09 Speaker 02 Once I got into the university networks, I realized that a lot of these professors who wrote the textbooks that we were using would answer email if you said, "Yo, I'm a high school kid in Japan, and I just read your textbook, and I have a question about this thing." And my physics teacher hated it because I would come in and say, "Well, but I talked to the author of the book, and he says you're wrong." And so I got a C in physics.
10:29 Speaker 03 He may have barely scraped through his physics class, but Joey took a lot of lessons from those open online communities. After fully immersing himself in Chicago's club scene, Joey returned to Tokyo to open a nightclub of his own. But technology kept creeping back in. And you go to Tokyo, but then you start thinking, "Okay, I should maybe think about the technology business." What led you to start thinking startups, venture capital? What led you into that direction?
11:03 Speaker 02 And I want to just establish for the record that I am not even close to the level of strategic that you are. I just kind of stumble around, you know? And so...
11:14 Speaker 03 Geniously stumble around, yes.
11:16 Speaker 02 I'm aware of my opportunities. I just don't plan them. And so I went back to Japan, had a nightclub, was doing events, was interested in media. So I was working for NHK, the broadcasting company, and was just kind of running around. And I did computer networks, but just out of curiosity.
11:31 Speaker 03 Joey's curiosity and his open collaborative network of like-minded tech pioneers meant he soon had skills that were in great demand, particularly from big companies finding their way in the new frontier of the internet. Joey would need to speak the language of business if he was going to work with these top-down, prestige-driven organizations. He set up a consulting practice.
11:56 Speaker 02 I didn't know how to run a company, but I set it up anyway. And at the time, I remember going to negotiate, you know, office lease. And they said, well, you know, what about the security deposit? And how did it? And like, I'm gonna have to talk to my lawyer. And I was like, Mom, what is a security deposit?
12:13 Speaker 03 Joey may not have understood the fine details of office leasing, but he and his hacker friends were landing contracts with big clients like IBM and Sun Microsystems. Their open community had accelerated their learning, and they're among the few people with the skills that the big institutions needed.
12:32 Speaker 03 Another company they worked with was a fledgling internet listing site called Yahoo. Joey and his team offered to set up Yahoo's Japan service.
12:41 Speaker 02 And we went over and people were like sleeping under the desks. And I got a deal. It was a verbal commitment that I would get 50% of Yahoo Japan in exchange for setting it up, doing the servers.
12:51 Speaker 03 Joey told his friend, SoftBank founder Masayoshi-san, about this verbal commitment with Yahoo.
12:57 Speaker 02 And I was telling him about, oh, wow, there's this Yahoo thing. It's really cool. And this is when I learned about sort of Masayoshi's style. He was like, he immediately flew to California and said to Yahoo, we're gonna invest in your company. And if you don't let us invest, we'll invest in a competitor. And I don't know if there were any competitors. And he came back to Japan and said to me and my gang, well, you're clearly not gonna get 50% of Japan. We're gonna fund it, but we'll give you 1%.
13:23 Speaker 03 Hearing Joey tell this story, you might believe Masayoshi's style consists of winning at any cost. But Masa may have also realized that Joey would have trouble making the Yahoo deal work on his own. Joey knew how to build a nightclub community, and he knew how to forge a loose alliance between brilliant hackers with big ideas. But he also needed his mom's advice on a security deposit. The fact that he was satisfied with a verbal agreement from Yahoo underlined this naivete, as did Joey's next move with Masa.
13:56 Speaker 02 And I looked at them, I said, "You guys are a bunch of software distributors. You don't have any technical people. How are you going to build this thing?" He says, "Well, you guys can build it." And I said, "Okay, well, screw your 1%. I want," I think, I can't remember what it was, like $20,000. And he was like, "Okay, fine." And so, we built the first Yahoo Japan beta server. Took us a long time to get paid, which was annoying. But then Yahoo made a ton of money.
14:19 Speaker 03 That missed opportunity taught Joey at least two lessons about working within the established hierarchy of large, closed organizations.
14:27 Speaker 02 I realized later I should have taken the 1%, but I also realized that without capital and without the ability to execute at a corporate level, I'd just be that kid with the ideas.
14:39 Speaker 03 For Joey, it wasn't enough to be that kid with the ideas. He wanted to take his ideas and shepherd them into becoming a reality. The best way to do that? Learn to harness the power of the closed corporate world that Joey and his hacker friends had scorned. So Joey set up a consulting business that would tap the freewheeling new ideas that were burgeoning on the internet. Ideas about engaging a wider audience, communicating freely, and making them accessible to all, and then present them in a way the closed business world could understand and run with.
15:15 Speaker 02 We built a bunch of businesses. I would say that if it weren't for the fact that I was working with a guy who had been in business for 10 years, who knew how to operate a business, it probably would have taken me a lot longer before I actually had something that made money at scale.
15:30 Speaker 03 Alongside his consulting practice, Joey both joined and created some of the online communities that emerged in the 1990s. Many of Joey's early communities skewed heavily towards complete openness with anonymous users and a rule-free ethos.
15:50 Speaker 03 Joey thrived in this kind of chaos, but even he experienced the downside.
15:55 Speaker 02 First of all, it started with a mailing list called NetSurf, where we would all share our links about interesting websites that we'd found. And at some point, some slightly troll-like people were hanging on the mailing list. And I said, you know, you guys, this is like my living room. Get out of here. Don't behave like that. They said, this isn't your living room. And I said, but it's on my server. They don't care. This is a public space. I can say what I want. And I thought, that's kind of weird because I've created it, I'm running it. But all right, fine, whatever, you know, I've lost control of this mailing list.
16:26 Speaker 03 So to escape the trolls, Joey set up a channel on Internet Relay Chat, or IRC, a network of servers that allowed users to chat in real time. It was still open, but he could kick out the trolls.
16:39 Speaker 02 I said, you know what, I'm going to call the channel Joeyito, because then there will be no doubt that I'm in charge. So we created a channel called Joeyito, and it was just my friends.
16:50 Speaker 03 But while the troll problem had been solved, it was clear Joey wasn't quite as much in control as he thought he would be.
16:57 Speaker 02 But I remember a time when somebody came into the chat room and said, so what does Joeyito think? And I said, well, I think that-- and then, not you, the channel. And so then I realized that even if you name the thing your name, it's still not your place.
17:10 Speaker 03 What Joey learned was a classic lesson of the limits of radical openness. When you create a very open, lawless system, you foster open conversations. But you also create a safe place for trolls, people who act in bad faith to disrupt a system and drive others away from using it. It's a phenomenon that almost every open platform grapples with today, from social media channels to Wikipedia. But the trolls on the Joeyito chatroom didn't deter the real Joeyito from his love of all things open. He saw the risk of opening up. People will express their own views. You may lose control of the conversation.
17:50 Speaker 03 But he also saw huge benefits: innovation, inclusiveness, the wisdom of crowds. And we'll hear how Joey leaned into the movement toward open platforms right after the break.
18:12 Speaker 00 We all know the disappointment that comes when a grand gesture falls flat, something that seemed impressive in the moment, but didn't deliver the results you expected. Marketing budgets too often fall into that trap, aiming for big impressions, big reach, but without the revenue to back it. LinkedIn has a name for it, bull spend. LinkedIn ads generate the highest ROAS of all major ad networks. They target by company, industry, job title, and more. Spend $250 on your first campaign on LinkedIn ads and get a $250 credit for the next one. Just go to LinkedIn.com/Scale. That's LinkedIn.com/Scale. Terms and conditions apply.
18:55 Speaker 00 When you've built substantial wealth through your business, it's often tied up in a single equity position. The upside is real, but so is the risk, and knowing when to act isn't always obvious. Creative Planning works with business owners to build a strategy around concentrated equity, when to diversify, how to manage tax risk, and how to protect what you've spent years building. Creative Planning, where wealth works together. Learn more at creativeplanning.com/mastersofscale. Every business hits the same wall the moment your business outgrows the systems that got you here. Spreadsheets everywhere, five different logins, data scattered across entities that don't even talk to each other.
19:38 Speaker 00 If your finance team spends more time finding data than using it, that's when you need the Intuit ERP. Intuit Enterprise Suite is the AI-native ERP solution that's powerful, painless, and proven, built for businesses scaling fast without the complexity that usually comes with it. From the makers of QuickBooks, learn more at intuit.com/ERP.
20:05 Speaker 03 Before the break, we heard how Joey established himself as a go-to internet consultant in Tokyo in the 1990s, building Yahoo Japan among other websites. After a series of ups and downs familiar to all founders, Joey was in a position to make investments of his own. It was the early 2000s, and blogging had just emerged as a disruptive force in media and politics. Joey saw in blogging the same radical open ethos he'd seen on the bulletin boards of the early internet. Blogging leveled the playing field between everyday people and the closed world of established media companies. There was an unfettered sharing of ideas that anyone could participate in.
20:47 Speaker 03 And it was around this time that our paths first crossed. I was at PayPal at the time. That was when you were saying, "I'm convinced that there's this entire new kind of web tool revolution, the kind of revolution of communities, of networks, of social identity." I had thought a lot about social identities, but I hadn't thought about the open network side of these things. You were like, "Well, there's this really great company, Six Apart. We should invest in this one together." And I was like, "Sure, why not?"
21:14 Speaker 02 The key word for me, and probably why you ended up building more successful companies than me, was really "community." So I was into chat rooms, into bulletin boards, and into social media, but from the perspective of a bunch of people having a conversation.
21:30 Speaker 03 Healthy communities foster open conversations. And I did think about community in this respect, but Joey is right. It wasn't a focus on openness that helped me build scale with LinkedIn. Rather, it was my belief in the value of building networks that are open in some respects, but closed in others. LinkedIn was an open community in that anyone could join, but it was also a collection of closed communities. We required real-name sign-ups, and we only allowed you to connect to people you know and who agree to the connection. We held to the balance of open and closed that we believed would foster trust in a business community.
22:13 Speaker 03 It's this trust that attracted more people to contribute and fueled scale.
22:21 Speaker 03 In any company or community, you have to strike this balance between open and closed. Another organization that has famously struck this balance is TED. For years, TED was an expensive, elite, invitation-only conference. So when they first put their talks online for free under a Creative Commons license, it was a radically open move. June Cohen, one of the executive producers for Masters of Scale, was previously the executive producer at TED. She led the charge to put TED Talks online. And June also launched TED's Open Translation Project, which allowed volunteers around the world to subtitle the talks. She has a story that perfectly encapsulates
23:06 Speaker 03 this balance between open and closed systems. I asked her to share it.
23:11 Speaker 07 When you talk about open systems, I think people often picture them as a mosh pit, you know, where everyone chaotically does whatever they want. But the most effective open systems usually have a lot of hidden structure. So our translation program at TED was very open, but it wasn't a mosh pit. We put a lot of structure in place to support great work and also to prevent mischief.
23:36 Speaker 03 The potential benefits were clear to June from the start. Still, it was a scary move.
23:41 Speaker 07 It's one thing to believe hypothetically in the power of crowdsourcing, but it is a totally different thing to put your speaker's words in the hands of people you don't know who speak languages you don't understand. So the day the translation program launched, we got a panicked message from one of our Polish translators. He told us that the Polish subtitles on five talks had been mistranslated. They were just gobbledygook. Well, it turns out that those five bad translations were actually done by a professional translation house we had hired to help us launch. It looks like they had just run them through an auto-translator. They probably figured, oh, it's Polish. They'll never know. As it turns out, the only truly bad translations we ever experienced
24:26 Speaker 07 came from professional translators. They were caught and corrected by our volunteers within 36 hours of launch. Why? Because the volunteers were in it for more than just money. They cared. And that's the power of openness.
24:41 Speaker 03 TED's Open Translation Project scaled to more than 20,000 volunteers working in 120 languages. It paved the way for TED's international growth, including a TV show in Japan hosted by none other than Joey Ito. And to me, that story, in which the scary-sounding volunteers saved TED from the paid professional translators, encapsulates so much about the way open and closed systems can join forces and play to each other's strengths. These ideas about openness were gaining momentum in the early 2000s. Wikipedia launched in 2001. Creative Commons issued its first license in 2002.
25:26 Speaker 03 And Joey was one of the earliest commentators on the movement. In 2003, Joey put out his famous essay, Emergent Democracy. It described how loose networks of individuals were using blogging and other online tools to effect change in society and politics from the ground up.
25:45 Speaker 02 It was really this idea that we would see an emergent ability to cause action, to think as a community. It was kind of collective action and collective intelligence. But back then, it seemed very rosy. Like, if we could just connect everybody and get everybody the opportunity to say everything they want, we'd have direct democracy in the world become peaceful and everybody would realize that all people were good. And then game on.
26:15 Speaker 03 Joey saw the evidence all around him for the benefits of collective action and direct democracy. And he became a champion of all things open. He joined the boards of Creative Commons, the Mozilla Foundation, and the Open Source Initiative. As an investor, Joey placed bets on startups that championed bottom-up initiatives: Kickstarter, Flickr, Twitter. You can probably see why Joey's path and mine kept crossing. We co-invested in a number of companies, and we agreed in the opportunity of open platforms. But we had a fundamental disagreement. Because I believed the biggest opportunity lay with closed networks, or mostly closed networks, ones that required a real identity
27:00 Speaker 03 and connected you only to people you know. Our views on open versus closed networks have evolved over the intervening years as some of our expectations have been confirmed, some confounded, and some exploded. As you'll hear from this exchange, it is a subject we can still talk about endlessly.
27:19 Speaker 02 I think that your notion of having closed networks and trust as a key piece was prescient of the issues that would come.
27:29 Speaker 03 I think the obvious truth is to create innovation, you want to have as much breadth of allowing the innovation, e.g. open networks, as possible. But then the question is, as a business creator and as an investor and as a capitalist, you want to actually capture as much of that value, so you want to tend to be more closed. We were just in constant conversation, and I think mostly we kind of said, look, we'll both bet and invest on both sides, and we'll see how it plays out.
27:57 Speaker 02 Yes, and we know how it turned out.
28:00 Speaker 03 Yes. Well, the tightly bound networks had a faster growth towards equity value, although maybe impossible without the open systems.
28:13 Speaker 02 I think the open protocol lowered the barrier to competition, first of all, and allowed a kind of scaling.
28:20 Speaker 03 Well, you wouldn't have been able to create those new companies without having the platform be sufficiently open that they could all go create. So, you know, anything from Google to Netflix to Facebook wouldn't be created unless the Internet was open.
28:33 Speaker 02 That's right.
28:34 Speaker 03 And so you need that baseline open system to create all that value, which is the value of the open systems. One of the reasons we still talk about this is because the dynamic between open and closed systems is constantly shifting. Open systems are great for idea generation and evolution, but if you're going to scale rapidly any of these ideas, a closed system or at least tight rules often works best.
29:02 Speaker 03 And the organizations that stand to gain the most by embracing some openness are those that are traditionally and staunchly closed. Corporations, universities, government agencies. So what happens if you're working in one of these closed systems? How can your company harness the power of radical openness without descending into a disorganized free-for-all? An expert in this area is Megan Smith. Megan was chief technology officer for the White House under President Obama. She has a number of tactics that harness the power of radical openness, and she's put them to great effect in some of the most complex organizations on the planet.
29:44 Speaker 03 One innovation close to her heart is the Solution Summit she helped plan for the United Nations. The summit aims to unearth solutions for the UN's Sustainable Development Goals.
29:54 Speaker 06 And so we said, what if we just put up a webpage and say, "World"? What do you already have that solves these goals that's either working now or promising? And so we posted that on the UN site, and then we blasted an email pointing at it through lots of ministries of science and technology, and through all the fellows, like a Shoka fellow, TED fellow, all our colleagues, and out went the word. And in came 800 submissions from 100 countries in two weeks.
30:20 Speaker 03 The results that came from opening up this traditionally closed system were astounding.
30:26 Speaker 06 And we saw extraordinary things. A team flying drones to plant a billion trees a year. A team teaching law in prison in Uganda because thousands of people had gone to jail with no representation. Now lots of people, in fact, thousands are getting themselves out of jail. There's a guy named Ben O'Horos building a floating fab lab in the Amazon. We have 400 indigenous tribes that come indigenous people who are there with their incredible capabilities around bio. Information and indigenous knowledge that could merge together with, you know, modern machine tools and capabilities. And the only rules were, we want breadth of ideas and we want breadth of humans because the world is full of lots of talent. And so we got that.
31:10 Speaker 03 It was Megan Smith who invited Joey to apply for the position he now holds, the director of the MIT Media Lab. The Media Lab was founded in 1985 by Nicholas Negroponte, and for decades, the lab has been a hub of cross-disciplinary innovation. The Media Lab also has an unusually close relationship with the corporate and startup worlds, which means that MIT-born innovations frequently make their way into the hands of consumers. Technologically, it was right up Joey's alley.
31:42 Speaker 02 I didn't know anything about the Media Lab, and I really had no intention of ever of being in an academic institution. But I came here to do an interview, and we spent two days just meeting students and faculty and staff. And it turned out to be still probably the most interesting two-day series of conversations I ever had. And I said, if I can hang out with these people every day, I'll do anything to do that.
32:10 Speaker 03 This was the kind of institution Joey could fully embrace. A place that described its work as anti-disciplinary was always going to appeal to Joey. It was almost like coming home. Just like the clubbers in Chicago or the voices from far-flung corners of the globe in those early days of internet bulletin boards, the Media Lab was a community of open voices freely sharing ideas.
32:38 Speaker 03 How much did you see in that first two days in the Media Lab that it reminded you of the DJ dance floor?
32:45 Speaker 02 So, that's really an interesting question, because I'd thought of the parallels. Actually, the reason I dropped out of college to go to the dance floor was because I loved the community. And this is a community I want to be in. This is the lost tribe that I've been looking for. And if it means doing operational stuff that I never really thought was my forte, um, fine.
33:08 Speaker 03 The Media Lab melded the powers of the closed institution with the powers of an open network. But Joey wanted to make the Media Lab even more open. He wanted to crack a door and bring the world in.
33:21 Speaker 02 I realized, coming from the internet, that there are people doing cool stuff all over the place. TED was publishing their videos all over the place. And so it was very counterintuitive to me to have something be closed. So it felt like a computer that wasn't connected to the internet.
33:36 Speaker 03 Joey set out to connect the metaphorical computer of the Media Lab to the internet of the world. He knew that any closed organization would run the risk of stagnation. So Joey started stirring things up at the Media Lab with a series of open programs, including open competitions, open classes, and an advisory council and director fellows program that brings outside voices regularly into the lab.
34:03 Speaker 02 Instead of just being a closed community, trying to make it an open community was one of my areas of focus. A lot of that also is about a culture change in the lab. But I think, you know, the students already had that intuition, right? And I think they were already kind of breaking the rules and posting stuff onto YouTube. So a lot of it was just unlocking stuff that just wanted to happen.
34:22 Speaker 03 Joey was taking his philosophy of radical openness and supercharging what it could do by harnessing the power of a top-down institution. The irony isn't lost on him. You said to me, I remember this conversation, you said, you know what my career is? My career is breaking monopolies, right? Like, it's kind of going up against the monopolies. Because the telcos actually didn't want an internet. They wanted a, no, no, like, we control everything, you pay us for it, versus permissionless innovation.
34:49 Speaker 02 We were fighting against some pretty awful institutions like the telcos, who were, to me, trying to prevent this dream of open access to everyone at low cost.
34:59 Speaker 03 This tension between the radically open and the radically closed does not need to be a zero-sum game.
35:05 Speaker 02 And we were beating up mainstream media like they were the evil empire. But then we realized, wait, we're killing, we're, they're about to die. So the reason I'm on the New York Times board is kind of like you're jumping in to do CPR. I didn't mean to really hurt you that bad, you know, we were just punching you. But now, in retrospect, this kind of institution bashing that we were doing, now I'm on the institution side realizing that we need institutions. And so there's this kind of interesting, healthy balance. So I feel I'm spending almost as much time trying to protect our important institutions, while at the same time, I guess we often call this a radical flank, but using the somewhat radical disruptive people to make sure that the people in the institutions are thinking about innovation and about the future and not sitting on the laurels.
35:52 Speaker 03 Getting the open-close balance right is the key challenge, and it is different for each specific situation. How do we tweak the level of openness in any organization to ensure the greatest impact? Here's Joey's view from his seat at the Media Lab.
36:09 Speaker 02 It's a very complex system with all these parts interrelated. But I think the key point is that you need to be in conversation across engineers and social scientists, across Silicon Valley businesses and the regulators. You actually, in fact, have to work together, not only to think about and understand the problems, but to forcefully come out with things like open letters, with going to companies and questioning their work, and actually building examples of things that work properly. This is what I learned from Arab Spring. You know, "Hey, yay, finally, emergent democracy is here." "Oh, no, a lot of people are suffering." And so this time around, we have to be a bit more intentional in trying to get the arc to bend towards justice, rather than just to leave it up to the market and a whole
36:54 Speaker 02 bunch of hackers.
36:56 Speaker 03 Only by continuing to have these open conversations can we keep pace with the shifting challenges we face in our companies, our institutions, and our societies. It is a conversation we all need to be radically open to having, and no one should be closed off from.
37:16 Speaker 03 I'm Reid Hoffman. Thank you for listening.
37:27 Speaker 03 Hey, listeners, Bob here. If you listen to Rapid Response on Masters of Scale, you may be missing half the show because every Friday, we release a second Rapid Response exclusively in the Rapid Response feed. The guests and topics are just as compelling and timely, from Ford's CEO to NASA's admin- ...to the lessons from The Devil Wears Prada. It takes about 10 seconds to find. Just search rapid response wherever you listen to podcasts and hit follow to make sure you never miss an episode. I hope to see you there.
38:04 Speaker 03 Humans will never be more intelligent than AI.
38:07 Speaker 01 There's going to be two types of companies. Those are great at AI and those that went out of business because they weren't. How do we build a future that is human centered? I'm Rana Elkhayubi, and on my podcast, Pioneers of AI, we answer that question and so many more. As an AI scientist, entrepreneur, and investor, I know what it takes to build AI that works
38:30 Speaker 02 for everyone. Every week, I sit down with the pioneers shaping our future, and we take you behind the scenes of the AI that's transforming our lives. Find Pioneers of AI wherever you tune in. We all know the really prominent technology podcasts out there, but they're not actually helping the majority of people understand this space. With Future Proof, that's what we want to do. We want to talk to everyone from the top AI labs to the real builders, the people who are rolling up their sleeves, building this technology on a day-to-day basis. I'm Reid Albergati. I've been covering technology for more than a decade. If you want to really learn, whether you're in the tech industry, adjacent to it, or
39:11 Speaker 02 just curious about it, subscribe to Semaphore's Future Proof wherever you get your podcasts or watch it on YouTube.
39:19 Speaker 03 Masters of Scale is a Wait What original. The show is recorded on-site in California and produced at the studio inside SY Partners in New York. Our executive producers are June Cohen and Darren Triff. Our producers are Chris MacLeod, Adam Skuse, Jenny Cataldo, Dan Kedmi, Jordan MacLeod, and Ben Manila. Our supervising producer is Jay Punjabi. Original music by Alison Leighton Brown. Sound design, mixing, and mastering by Brian Pugh. Special thanks to Chris Ye, Bob Safian, Elisa Schreiber, David Sanford, Saida Sepieva, Christina Gonzalez, Sarah Sandman, and Lauren Passell. Visit mastersofscale.com to find a transcript for this episode and be sure to subscribe
40:04 Speaker 03 to our email newsletter.
Previous Take bigger risks, w/Shellye Archambeau Next The case for bootstrapping, w/Mailchimp's Ben Chestnut Page updated October 24, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated