Pod Insights Masters of Scale How to price your product to scale, w/ClassPass's Payal Kadakia About this episode The price that bleeds your business could also save it. We're revisiting a classic episode with ClassPass' Payal Kadakia to focus something every entrepreneur struggles with: pricing. When you invent something innovative, you can’t know how to price it on Day One. But you need to get people in the door — a LOT of people — even if you have to price your product fatally low at first. In this episode, ClassPass founder and chair Payal Kadakia shares the winding path to the right price — and how the journey revealed what was most valuable about their service.
Read a transcript of this episode at https://mastersofscale.com https://mastersofscale.com/
Subscribe to the Masters of Scale weekly newsletter at https://mastersofscale.com/subscribe
See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
Transcript 0:01 Speaker 00 We've all spent money on something that seemed incredible, but didn't live up to the hype. A kitchen gadget, a car. When it doesn't deliver, the disappointment is real. Marketers suffer from this too. Chasing metrics that look great, but don't translate into revenue. LinkedIn calls that bull spend. Invest in what matters and reach the right buyers with LinkedIn Ads. You can target by company, industry, job title, and more. LinkedIn Ads also generates the highest ROAS of all major ad networks. Spend $250 on your first campaign on LinkedIn Ads and get a $250 credit for the next one. Just go to LinkedIn.com/scale. That's LinkedIn.com/scale. Terms and conditions apply.
0:48 Speaker 00 The very best founders I know are brilliant at building systems. They connect teams, they remove bottlenecks, and they eliminate single points of failure. And yet, when it comes to their own wealth, most are running a disconnected stack. A tax accountant here and a state attorney there, a wealth manager who doesn't talk to either one of them. Creative Planning was built to fix exactly that. One integrated team of tax professionals, state planners, investment specialists, all coordinated by a dedicated wealth manager who sees your full financial picture and keeps every piece working together. Proactive tax efficiency, estate strategy, investments, all under one roof.
1:32 Speaker 00 Creative Planning, where wealth works together. Learn more at creativeplanning.com/mastersofscale.
1:41 Speaker 01 AI is full of possibilities. Enterprises run on realities. That's why Pega combines the world's most powerful AI with the governance, transparency, and control enterprises demand. So you can move faster, adapt faster, and scale AI with confidence. All the power of AI, none of the uncertainty. Learn more at Pega.com/AI.
2:06 Speaker 02 Every weekend, I felt like I was a little like mini roadshow, where my parents would come with me and I'd have my costume and my cassette and I'd have to like walk in and make sure like the music played all right.
2:26 Speaker 03 That's Pyle Karakia. She's been onstage since she was three years old.
2:32 Speaker 02 My earliest memories would be waking up on Saturday morning and going to one of my friends' basements and we would dance together with a group of 10 girls and learn Indian folk dances, which really connected me to my culture, it connected me to my ancestors.
2:48 Speaker 03 Her talent for what we'd now call Bollywood-style dance was a combination of technical skills with empathy.
2:55 Speaker 02 Indian dance has a lot of skills associated with it from just like regular technical skills, but it also has this beautiful expression associated with it, too, which taught me like, wow, like you can actually help someone feel something when you express yourself.
3:09 Speaker 03 Dance gave Pyle a form of expression, but what she cared about most had less to do with what she expressed and more to do with how the audience experienced it.
3:18 Speaker 02 I'm always performing for other people and I even think about rehearsals and even when I think about music, I'm like, how is someone else going to feel when they hear this and when they see this and when they see these costumes or they see us in this formation?
3:33 Speaker 03 Pyle kept paying attention. She danced her way through her childhood. She danced through college at MIT. She danced through her first job as a management consultant. In 2008, she founded the Saw Dance Company to realize her own vision for Indian classical performance, and her eyes never left the audience.
3:52 Speaker 02 Whenever I am practicing or rehearsing, I'm always thinking about my audience. It's like, it's very similar to always thinking about your customer.
4:03 Speaker 03 Pyle is constantly asking herself, how is my audience going to react to this move? How is this beat going to make them feel? How are they going to be transported by these costumes or this music or that twirl? When you're in the spotlight, you have to ask those questions. And company founders are also in a kind of spotlight with customers tracking their every move. Pyle knows this firsthand because when she's not dancing, she's also the founder and chair of ClassPass, the fitness subscription service. Her years watching the audience would serve her well in this different kind of spotlight. Change the rhythm and suddenly everyone's murmuring and fidgeting in their seats. One step in the wrong direction and you can lose the whole crowd.
4:48 Speaker 03 There was nothing quite like ClassPass when Pyle launched it. There was no preset choreography, no rhythm norithlon. And that meant she had to make up some of the moves as she went, improvising in public on many of the things her customers cared about most.
5:04 Speaker 03 For example, and especially pricing. How do you know what price to put on a first of its kind product? How do you gauge what's low enough to entice crowds of new users, but high enough to keep you in business? You probably won't know for a while. And in your company's early days, I'd argue it's more important to get users in the door, even when you're taking a very steep loss. But when you ultimately need to change the price, they'll grumble for sure. A few might storm out. But if you brought enough of them in and you've created something really compelling, many of them will stick around. That's why I believe the price that bleeds your business may save your business.
5:50 Speaker 04 You've got to have incredible talent at every position.
5:54 Speaker 03 There are fires burning when you're going home. Can you believe it?
5:57 Speaker 05 Such an idiot. And then you go back to, "This is totally going to be amazing." There are so many easy wins. I have no idea what to do. Sorry, we made a mistake.
6:06 Speaker 06 But you have to time it right. Working out of a three-bedroom apartment. Stuff that just seems absolutely nutballs. 10 years later, well, that's just how you do it. We haven't made it just how you do it.
6:20 Speaker 03 This is Masters of Scale.
6:27 Speaker 03 I'm Reid Hoffman, co-founder of LinkedIn, partner at Greylock, and your host. And I believe that the price that bleeds your business may save your business. Nearly all startup founders essentially start out deep in the red. It's why I call startups "the walking dead."
6:46 Speaker 03 The cost of serving your first few customers is astronomical, and you're in a race to bring those costs down and revenue up as quickly as possible. Depending on the price point you set, each new customer may dig you deeper in the grave or lift you out of it. That all depends on what we here in Silicon Valley call your "unit economics."
7:09 Speaker 03 How much do you spend on that customer? And how much do you make in return? The MBAs will tell you to work out those numbers as soon as possible. In their view, the prudent entrepreneur first proves that the unit economics are sustainable. Once you can say, "Yes, here's what customers will pay for my service. I'll break a profit by this date." Then you're free to scale, and not a moment sooner.
7:34 Speaker 03 But Silicon Valley, as regular listeners may have noticed, tends to operate by a different set of rules. Frequently, you have to scale first and figure out your unit economics later. In fact, putting off this question is the prudent route for anyone playing in a winner-takes-all market. Your competition won't wait for you to figure out your unit economics. They'll take all of your customers while you're still in the middle of your MBA calculations. And then your unit economics are really irretrievably bad. So you have to be prepared to lower prices to unsustainable levels, give your work away for free if you must, and even as you hemorrhage cash, keep telling yourself what many of Silicon Valley's iconic entrepreneurs have told themselves:
8:17 Speaker 03 "I'll figure out a way to break a profit later." I want to give you a sense of how an entrepreneur starts flirting with fatal prices in the first place. It has nothing to do with gutsiness or heedless risk-taking. In fact, the best entrepreneurs that I know are highly risk-intelligent, and they would absolutely love to figure out what their unit economics are before they scale. So why don't they? Because the most scalable ideas require a leap into the unknown.
8:46 Speaker 03 They don't begin with a business plan. They begin with an observation of human nature, driving a crazy hypothesis, a nagging thought that might sound a little something like this.
8:57 Speaker 02 I've danced my entire life. It's such a big core part of who I am. I danced through MIT, I danced through Bain. It was something I just never let go of. And I wanted people to have something like that, that they could run to and go to and feel sort of refreshed in their life.
9:11 Speaker 03 Pyle Kadakia has danced her entire life. It's essential to who she is. And she wanted other people to have something like that. That was the inspiration for ClassPass, her fitness subscription service. For a flat monthly fee, users can sign up for a staggering variety of fitness classes. They can dance if they want to, or do hot yoga,
9:36 Speaker 03 or spin classes.
9:41 Speaker 03 The sheer variety of classes is precisely what makes ClassPass such a hit. Since it launched in 2013, ClassPass has scaled to more than 40 cities worldwide. But the variety is also what makes ClassPass such a fiendishly difficult thing to price. How do you set a fee for a grab bag of different classes that people use in different amounts? How do you get the whole range of customers and fitness studios to all agree that the price is right? Pyle couldn't answer any of those questions at the outset of her entrepreneurial journey. In fact, she originally tried to sidestep those questions entirely. Before ClassPass, she had a much less complicated business plan. In 2011, she founded a startup called ClassTivity. The idea behind ClassTivity was quite simple.
10:26 Speaker 03 She would create an online hub where users could sign up for all types of classes, not just fitness, but painting classes, pottery classes. Any activity you could hope to master, you could find on ClassTivity. In short, it would be a search engine for classes.
10:41 Speaker 02 I was online, I was searching for a ballet class. I obviously had used things like Zocdoc, OpenTable, SeamlessWeb. It made sense. I was like, okay, let's build an OpenTable model for classes.
10:52 Speaker 03 OpenTable lets you search restaurants near you and find, well, an open table at the right time. With ClassTivity, Pyle aspired to the same model, offer comprehensive listings, and a pass-through service for reservations.
11:06 Speaker 02 It made sense to investors. I raised capital. I hired a team that bet on the idea.
11:11 Speaker 03 So how would ClassTivity break even? Simple. Like OpenTable or Seamless, she would charge a small transaction fee. And like that, she'd be in business. In fact, Pyle was so convinced she'd be in business, big business, that her team invested a year and a half in web development.
11:30 Speaker 02 We just wanted it to be perfect because we just thought it would work.
11:33 Speaker 03 It was gorgeously designed, a fully realized vision, ready for launch day. Frequent listeners of this show may recall my theory that you never want to release a fully realized vision in the software world. In fact, if you're not embarrassed by your first release, you've released it too late. Many successful entrepreneurs have discovered this counterintuitive theory the hard way. They perfect their product, as Pyle did, and then on launch day, well, I'll let her tell the rest.
12:02 Speaker 02 June of 2012, we launched ClassTivity, finally open to the public. We had thousands of classes listed, a beautiful design. And I would say we did about 10 reservations a month. It was terrible.
12:16 Speaker 03 Yes, she said 10 reservations a month.
12:20 Speaker 02 I mean, our whole entire business was obviously based on the revenue share we would get off of every transaction. And the business model was built on getting millions of transactions, you know, through the platform, and we weren't doing that.
12:31 Speaker 03 So you launched with this notion of being the Yelp or the review site and the ability to choose good classes and be informative.
12:39 Speaker 02 Right.
12:40 Speaker 03 And then what you found is people used you as a search engine, but didn't actually book.
12:44 Speaker 02 Right.
12:45 Speaker 03 I hear this story all the time from entrepreneurs who failed and those who succeeded. The difference? The successful ones keep trying, not by digging in and assuming they were right, but by asking themselves over and over, where did we go wrong? Pyle's team started with the problems they could see on the website itself, which created another problem.
13:06 Speaker 02 In the middle of the summer, we started playing with buttons.
13:10 Speaker 02 I always remember I call it the summer of buttons because we were contemplating, "Well, maybe it's because the color is wrong," or "the shape is wrong," or, you know, we were thinking it might be a UI problem, and it wasn't.
13:20 Speaker 03 The summer of buttons. I know a lot of entrepreneurs who have lived through that sorry season. And I sympathize with Pyle. When your service is underperforming, it's incredibly tempting to hyper-focus on the user interface, because that's under your control. You can swap out colors and move the buttons around the page for months. Sometimes it creates a breakthrough. More often, it's a dead end. Interface changes are really useful for improving a user interaction that's fundamentally working. What design can't do is solve a fundamental problem in your business model. All those other entrepreneurs who survived a "summer of buttons," they all came to a similar crucial insight, which Pyle has carried with her throughout her career.
14:06 Speaker 02 I think the other thing I've realized over time is that technology actually wasn't going to solve everything for me. And I think a lot of times, you're like, "Oh, I have an engineer to build the site, and I don't need to do anything," or "I don't need to get any other information," and that was actually wrong. It was really to see if I can actually get someone to class in any mechanism possible, even if it was manually making reservations, which we did a lot of, once we figured it out. Because it wasn't important yet to get to a place where we were building scalable technology, because we didn't actually even have one customer.
14:36 Speaker 03 But ultimately, if you're a visionary like Pyle, you're not just trying to change the way a user interacts with a button. You're trying to change the way they interact with the real world. And she was not about to change the world at the rate of 10 reservations a month.
14:52 Speaker 03 I want to bring out something Pyle didn't do at this critical junction in her career. She didn't go on autopilot. And believe me, after pouring a year and a half of work into a website, you'd want to go on autopilot. Instead, Pyle had a moment of reckoning.
15:09 Speaker 02 I remember there was this clear day. It was about two months after we had launched. And I think I just had to have that honest moment with myself. I was talking to an advisor. We had money in the bank, you know, so I wasn't actually worried. But the worst thing you could do in that moment is actually just coast and let it fail.
15:24 Speaker 03 You can't rebuild from a bank balance of zero. You need money in the bank. And the hard truth is you can't even begin to test your theories on pricing until your customers reach some level of critical mass. You can either go the conventional route and get your unit economics to work before you scale, or you can do it the Silicon Valley way by bleeding your business with super-low prices that massively build your customer base. But the hard truth is you can't do either of these with 10 reservations a month. Pyle would have had to build a new runway after that failure to launch. But this is one of my favorite things about entrepreneurship. You have to refine your theory of human nature.
16:04 Speaker 03 Every consumer internet entrepreneur, and arguably every entrepreneur, period, needs to have a theory of human nature. Your product should be based on your theory about how humans behave, both as individuals and as groups. That theory should underlie your strategy, your product design, your incentive program, every decision you make. For Pyle, she kept returning to that founding theory that everyone should discover a fitness routine that doesn't feel like a chore, but a calling or an escape. You shouldn't force yourself to go to class. You should feel compelled by the class itself. It should be for them like dance was for her, a source of inspiration. But there was a fundamental flaw in her theory,
16:48 Speaker 03 one that she wouldn't discover and never could have known until she really started asking her users, "What do I have to do to get you off your couch and into a class?"
16:59 Speaker 02 To me, the hunt was to get someone to go to class. And I think all ideas were on the table, but I just was like, "Let's go build something new."
17:09 Speaker 02 We were sitting behind the screen here, right? For a year and a half, we were building API integrations. We were building like scrapers to get the schedule data. We weren't talking to our partners or our customers. And that was also something that we started doing.
17:22 Speaker 03 Pyle started interviewing fitness studio owners. She asked one after the next, "How do you get people to sign up for a class?" And immediately, she spotted a pattern of responses.
17:35 Speaker 02 Many of them were offering a first class for free. Till this day, most studios do that.
17:40 Speaker 03 A free class? That might not sound innovative, but free is actually the force multiplier that countless Silicon Valley companies have used to achieve scale. It's like the dynamite that they use to blast through mountains of indifference. And like dynamite, freebies are also pretty dangerous. You better know what you're doing and set off a controlled detonation. Freebies are an extreme example of the fatal pricing that will bleed your business. There's no faster way to get a lot of people in the door than with a giveaway. But if those freebie seekers don't convert to paying customers, then you're just left with hemorrhaging. For the price that bleeds your business, to save your business, you need a conversion path. Pile devised the perfect experiment.
18:25 Speaker 03 She'd already partnered with studio owners across the city. She had a central view of all their freebies, and it occurred to her that she could bundle all of those free classes together into one package deal. A user could then hop from class to class and perhaps discover their true fitness calling. And Passport would benefit by bringing them in the door of all those varied studios.
18:48 Speaker 02 We had this idea of packaging it together into one product called the Passport. Said, what if we could offer a 30-day period where people could go and try 10 classes? And on the other side of it, we would do retargeting and remarketing to get you to go back to these studios. This was a new idea. It was great that we had built a lot of the scheduling software. And what was nice is people did like this idea. So we started finally seeing reservations. We had people buying this product.
19:14 Speaker 03 The Passport was an immediate success. User enthusiasm ran so high that when their 30-day grand tour expired, some users tried to cheat the system.
19:25 Speaker 03 They signed up for a new passport under a new email address. Basically, they started forging passports. Pyle was delighted.
19:33 Speaker 02 So we started thinking about this and I was like, OK, everything is really actually pointing towards a subscription because people were signing up with multiple email addresses. So we did a survey and 95% of our users said they would buy the product again if they could go back to their favorite studios.
19:47 Speaker 03 Through the power of free, Pyle had discovered a whole new market. You might call it the market for fitness dabblers. To Pyle's surprise, they never discovered their fitness calling through one class alone. They found their fitness calling through a variety of classes. Her vision had come into focus and it revealed a picture that she could have never foreseen.
20:09 Speaker 02 They wanted to do a spin class on Monday, a dance class on Thursday, a yoga class on Saturday. And I think the other really beautiful thing here was that people realized their potential. And I think, for me, as a founder with the vision we always had, I wanted people to find what I had had in dance. In a strange way, this passport product, that was the magic to it. And that was, that still is part of the core of what made ClassPass everything it is, is that people loved variety and no one realized that. There was this market out there for dabblers when everyone was trying to push everyone to be like complete loyalists. And there are definitely both sides and I think people go in and out of those cycles in their life. But there was only sort of the gym for the dabbler.
20:50 Speaker 03 She could see it. A confederation of gyms for the fitness dabbler. One ClassPass to rule them all. And 95% of her users wanted it. Now she's on to a truly scalable idea and she's about to take an extraordinary leap into her theory of human nature.
21:11 Speaker 00 We all know the disappointment that comes when a grand gesture falls flat, something that seemed impressive in the moment but didn't deliver the results you expected. Marketing budgets too often fall into that trap, aiming for big impressions, big reach, but without the revenue to back it. LinkedIn has a name for it: Bull Spend. LinkedIn Ads generate the highest ROAS of all major ad networks. They target by company, industry, job title, and more. Spend $250 on your first campaign on LinkedIn Ads and get a $250 credit for the next one. Just go to LinkedIn.com/Scale. That's LinkedIn.com/Scale. Terms and conditions apply.
21:54 Speaker 00 When you've built substantial wealth through your business, it's often tied up in a single equity position. The upside is real, but so is the risk, and knowing when to act isn't always obvious. Creative Planning works with business owners to build a strategy around concentrated equity, when to diversify, how to manage tax risk, and how to protect what you've spent years building. Creative Planning: where wealth works together. Learn more at creativeplanning.com/mastersofscale.
22:25 Speaker 00 Stripe Treasury is your new financial operating system built for what's next. With Stripe Treasury, the place your business accepts payments is also where you can store balances, move funds, and pay vendors worldwide. If you're building for global scale, get a business bank account that lets your money move instantly, whenever and wherever you need it. Learn more at stripe.com/treasury. Stripe is not a bank. Banking services provided by Fifth Third Bank, National Association Member, FDIC.
22:58 Speaker 03 Scale entrepreneurs don't just posit a theory. They go one step further and ask, "So how can I use this theory to change human behavior?" In Pyle's case, she was asking, "If my mission is to get everyone to lead a more fit lifestyle, how do I facilitate that?" Now, most entrepreneurs take the easier path to scale. They play to our vices, because vices are actually much stronger than the virtues. So for example, convincing someone to floss or convincing someone to go exercise is actually much, much harder than to convince them to watch something scandalous. You know, the equivalent of people who slow down to look at the burning car on the side of the road. One thing I've been saying for the past 13 years is that I tend to invest in companies
23:43 Speaker 03 that play into one or more of the seven deadly sins. Facebook plays into our vanity. LinkedIn? Greed, naturally. I could go on, but the point is, you don't just want a trigger for user behavior, you want a hair trigger. Now, Pyle might not be able to tap that hair-trigger response to exercise, because that's just human nature. She's trying to rev up virtuous behavior, which is much harder to get started. But the hardest ideas are often the most scalable. And it's one reason I admire Pyle's relentless pursuit of this business model. She'll have to fight to get users into the habit of exercise, and their habits will shift unpredictably, which means her prices will be highly unstable as well.
24:27 Speaker 03 And even if she compels users to try out a few classes, that will only solve half her problem.
24:34 Speaker 02 There was another problem, which was that people weren't going back to these studios.
24:39 Speaker 03 That's right. The other half of her user base, the studio owners, were essentially asking, "What's in it for us? Would any of those users, taking advantage of our first free class, ever return as paying customers?"
24:51 Speaker 02 And that was ultimately the promise we had made. And these studio owners were giving us these classes for free. So, long term, it wasn't great for our partnership with them. But the good side of this product was we realized people loved variety.
25:03 Speaker 03 So, Pyle had to make a decision. Would she continue selling a 30-day passport? Or would she remove that expiration date and enable users to take a variety of classes indefinitely? In essence, should she rebuild her business model? That wasn't an easy decision, because ClassTivity was finally coming out of the red. They were making money. It was a simple business model based on a small transaction fee for each booking.
25:31 Speaker 02 We actually were 100% profitable, because we weren't paying the studios. But at the end of the day, I was fast-forwarding in my head. And I'm like, "This just feels like a bad-deal site, you know, and a bad program." And I didn't want to change people's lives for a month. I wanted to change people's lives constantly. And the only way to really do that was through a product that was going to have more retention. And so, we decided to move into the subscription. And I think, you know, my team was like... I think they were tired. I think people have to remember, this was three years in. Right? And, I mean, at this time, we were also making every reservation manually. We all stayed up till 2, 3:00 in the morning every night. A reservation would come in. We didn't build the technology early on. It would literally send one of us an email. We would go and onto the site, make their reservation,
26:14 Speaker 02 and send a confirmation back to the customer. And so, all of us were doing that. That we were all doing customer service. So there was a little bit of that of people just being like, well, we finally are there. Like, why do we need to change? And what we ended up agreeing on, which was fine, because I didn't know, is we actually didn't know if the passport would become lead gen for the subscription. So we decided to not completely let go of the passport at the time. And then when we launched ClassPass, we realized it was just tweaks to it, right? So from an engineering perspective, it was the passport. It was just with, you could go back to a studio. Okay, great. And it was a monthly subscription.
26:49 Speaker 03 So in 2013, one year after the launch of ClassTivity, Pyle launched a service that would become her second startup. She called it ClassPass. For a $99 a month membership fee, users could sign up for 10 classes a month. They could dabble away indefinitely. And if that doesn't sound like a radical departure from the passport, then consider the user response.
27:11 Speaker 02 Three months into the subscription, the revenues of ClassPass overtook the revenue from the passport. And I think the other part was they started getting these letters from our members that were just about their lives changing and that they never enjoyed working out and they look forward to working out and they felt more confident. They got a promotion. They found love. Like, it was this interesting thing where I realized I had changed people with the product and that was really what I had set out to do.
27:39 Speaker 03 It was as if her users had said, forget ClassTivity. Forget the passport. Forget all of the work you've done over the past year. We now dub you ClassPass. When your users send a clear signal to scale a product, you have to jettison any other products that might steal your team's attention. We talked about this in detail on the episode called "The Big Pivot" with Stuart Butterfield from Slack. Because shuttering a legacy product is never easy, but it's easier when it's failing. It's much harder when you've seen modest success like Pyle did with Passport. That's when you'll really struggle to throw away your hard work and that modest stream of revenue. Sometimes, a blunt-talking mentor can help you rip off the Band-Aid.
28:24 Speaker 02 I remember talking to another advisor and he told me to get rid of the passport. He was like, "It's crack to you guys." I mean, it was kind of funding our business in a way, right? Because we were making cash from it. It took me about three months to kind of come to terms with that. I felt like I had given them what I wanted, right? Like that mission inside, like it literally was realized in the subscription product. And so decided to shut down the Passport and Classivity. And I remember him saying to me, you know, "The Passport will be a chapter in your book." And, you know, in the halls of ClassPass today, I mean, the Passport is like a data field, right? Like, my engineer's like, "What was that?" And I'm like, "Right." He was totally, absolutely right.
29:04 Speaker 03 So with Classivity vanishing down the memory hole, Pyle could give her undivided attention to her newest venture, ClassPass. She had hopeful investors, she had wildly enthusiastic users, and the thank you letters to prove it. She was poised for a rapid expansion into new cities. She would get to test her theory of human nature on a global scale. Only one piece of the puzzle remained: the price. At what price could she enroll enough subscribers to this new model of fitness? She had an inkling of what users might pay.
29:37 Speaker 02 So we have this product out in the market, $99 for 10.
29:39 Speaker 03 So for $99, her users could take up to 10 classes each month. Why 10? It seemed generous enough. The average user took five classes. So the average user probably wouldn't even notice the cap, or so she thought.
29:53 Speaker 02 You know, one of the things that was interesting is 10 classes, actually, to some people was impossible. And to some people, it wasn't enough. And we also started getting people who were sometimes churning, saying, "Oh, I only went to eight." And I'm like, "This is so interesting that people were like tying themselves to this number."
30:12 Speaker 03 Notice how she didn't expect users to tie themselves to this number. In fact, they tend to tie themselves up in knots when you try to change that number. This is the Gordian knot of user expectations, and there's no easy way to untangle their demands. Almost any move you make, after you've slapped an initial price on your product, comes with a risk of sending your customers scattering. When users sign up for that price, the one you probably used in marketing, the one that your earliest fans decided was worth it, you've sort of made a promise. At the very least, you've solidified a key part of your company's brand. Think about Subway Sandwich Shop and their inescapable earworm. $7 foot long just doesn't have the same ring to it.
31:00 Speaker 03 So when you hike your prices, even by a negligible amount, some of your users will feel like you've broken your promise. At that point, it's personal, and it can drive even your most passionate fans to come at you with pitchforks. So why risk it at all? One word: competition. Pyle noticed them closing in. It started with a successful experiment that ClassPass ran to test their users' appetite for classes.
31:27 Speaker 02 And so we wanted to, once again, experiment with this idea of what if we didn't put a number on it to see what would actually happen? And so we launched this summer promotion called Unlimited Summer,
31:42 Speaker 02 where people could go to as many classes as they wanted to. And we saw people love it.
31:46 Speaker 03 This flat monthly fee, offering unlimited access, is another classic pricing model to bring customers in the door. There's no faster way to get them to commit than to create a subscription, especially one that auto-renews. In some cases, monthly fees create a cash cow. They feel like a bargain to customers while actually creating profits. In other cases, monthly fees with unlimited access bleed your business in the short term, but save it in the long term after a crucial price hike. Pyle doesn't know yet what her unlimited pricing will do for her bottom line, but she knows it'll give her the critical insight she needs into customer behavior. And from that, she can make sure her price was right. For now, though, it was working. Demand had surged.
32:31 Speaker 03 Customers loved the offering. It seemed like the right time to start a round of funding.
32:36 Speaker 02 And then we announced our Series A, our $10 million round. And it was a great moment. And always in hindsight, I'm like, I don't know if I would have done that, because what it did is it spurred competition in every market.
32:48 Speaker 03 Pyle's Series A financing round brought in real money, but it also brought in the wolves. ClassPass competitors started popping up all across the US, and they each had the benefit, not only of Pyle's idea, but also of a fresh start. They weren't beholden to those promises of pricing of number of classes that ClassPass had made.
33:08 Speaker 02 And everyone was copying the unlimited model. Right? And so it became a little bit hard to go back on that.
33:13 Speaker 03 Imitation is the sincerest form of flattery, right? If you pilot an idea and everyone copies it, it's a good indication that you're on to something. But it also means two things. One, if you don't lean all the way into that idea, your users might drop you for the five, 10, 20 similar products that have popped up. And two, you better start sprinting. With all those competitors fielding the unlimited model, Pyle found herself locked into it. Not only that, she had to both perfect that model and get it up and running before any of her competitors did.
33:47 Speaker 02 So we went to the ground and, you know, we had to fight our own battle too.
33:50 Speaker 03 So let's hit the pedal of the metal. Let's go as fast as possible.
33:53 Speaker 02 Completely did. Yep, absolutely.
33:54 Speaker 03 For ClassPass, that meant staking flags in the national fitness landscape. City by city, they decided, which they could not afford to lose.
34:04 Speaker 02 Me and my co-founder sat down and we're like, let's just go. And we decided it was called Operation 2015. It's 20 cities by January 1 of 2015. So in two and a half months, we decided to launch 12 additional cities on top of what we were going to.
34:19 Speaker 03 They were definitely going to need a bigger team.
34:21 Speaker 02 I remember that whole weekend, we just spent, you know, interviewing sales folks. We sent them out into the markets and we did it. And so by January 1, we were in 20 markets.
34:30 Speaker 03 20 new cities, 12 of them in two and a half months. Make no mistake, Pyle and her team sprinted.
34:37 Speaker 02 We needed to make sure like the studios we were getting on board were right. So we had someone go and try them.
34:42 Speaker 03 Pyle basically airdropped employees into new cities like soldiers.
34:46 Speaker 02 We always just send people in.
34:48 Speaker 03 Soldiers who could reach her personal line around the clock.
34:52 Speaker 02 You have a problem, like, you know, call my cellphone.
34:55 Speaker 03 Everyone at ClassPass sprinted for those grueling two and a half months. And when they looked up, they'd done it. They were in 20 cities and their competitors mostly left behind. But the problem with being that far ahead in uncharted territory? There aren't any footpaths you can follow or markers you can orient yourself with. Pyle had latched on to the unlimited model, but she hadn't yet figured out the unit cost of each bundle of fitness classes. She'd made a big Promised her users, but they hadn't made any promises in return. Some took the unlimited offer seriously, attending so many classes, they did more than bleed Pyle's business.
35:34 Speaker 03 They caused a hemorrhage. For them, ClassPass was a bargain. Others barely took a class. For them, it was absurdly expensive. And this split in behavior is one that many businesses grapple with. How do you set a single price when usage patterns vary so wildly? How do you know who your loyal users are? How do you know just how much they'll pay? What are their breaking points? You cannot answer these questions by running limited time only experiments with your pricing. You have to go all in to really understand how users will respond. And Pyle had just grabbed this bull by the horns. ClassPass was a rollicking success. Now she had to figure out how to sustain that subscription model indefinitely.
36:17 Speaker 03 The price that bled their business could save their business if she gets the numbers right.
36:22 Speaker 02 This is when we went through a series of price changes and we spent, you know, the next year and a half doing it. And look, there's no blueprint, but I also didn't want to be a gym membership in the sense of like making someone sign a year long contract to really be able to benefit from people not going. It was a little bit hard because we were kind of flirting with like two different models and trying to change people's behavior.
36:43 Speaker 03 Pyle was torn, smaller bundles of classes for lower fees or unlimited classes for a higher one. They just didn't have enough data to decide what was going to be the most sustainable. ClassPass tried to run both models simultaneously.
36:57 Speaker 02 So we ended up launching a five pack and a 10 pack. But what that meant, because we knew the lower usage users would go on the five and the 10, the unlimited plan had to go up even higher.
37:07 Speaker 03 And this process of fine tuning prices rarely goes off perfectly the first time.
37:12 Speaker 02 It's hard. We couldn't predict where usage would fall. We did a small price increase and it wasn't enough, which is really hard to do, right? When you know you put it out there, it's a hard moment. And then it didn't work because we were churning out a lot of the users who weren't going to enough classes because the price was higher. And we were trying to find this price point where maybe it was low enough where the lower usage users would stick with us. It just, it wasn't happening. So after the first price increase, I think I started realizing, I'm like, we're just going to keep having to increase price.
37:41 Speaker 03 So the way Pyle sees it, the price changes were a difficult but necessary part of keeping ClassPass available to more users, keeping it running for that matter. Her customers felt differently. After the unlimited subscription price went up for the second time, one user tweeted, "Raise your hand if you've been personally victimized by ClassPass." "No, no, canceling my membership now," tweeted another. To be clear, ClassPass was not the first company to experience that particular kind of customer riot, and they definitely won't be the last. When Netflix raised its subscription prices, customers were outraged, not necessarily about the new price tag, but how it made them feel. "I can definitely afford it," one angry customer said. "But I'm dropping them on principle."
38:25 Speaker 03 When LastPass, the popular password storing app, raised its premium prices by just $1 a month, a customer tweeted,
38:33 Speaker 02 "This is a slap in the face."
38:35 Speaker 03 Some amount of backlash is inevitable. It's just human nature. No one ever wishes they could pay more for a service, no matter how much they love it. And what happens frequently in growth cases like ClassPass is you start with a business model that's unsustainable. It's the only way to hook that vital set of early users. But if you stay with that business model, you die. This was also true of PayPal. Our burn rate was tens of millions of dollars each month. That was considered crazy at the time. Now, it's a bit more common. For example, Uber's burn rate is considerably higher. Eventually, they'll have to change their pricing, either how they pay drivers or charge customers some years down the road. It's hard to predict, and I bet Uber's executive team
39:20 Speaker 03 couldn't tell you right now either. It's the nature of working in fields where The rules are still being written. At PayPal, one of our early promises was simple. Add a friend to the platform and you'll each get $10. It was an easy, effective way to build out our early user base. But eventually, it got so expensive that PayPal's co-founder, Peter Thiel, wanted to scrap the entire idea and break that early promise in order to keep costs down. But from my point of view, there was a way to keep that sparkly, eye-catching promise intact. We just had to dim the sparkles a bit. We still gave users and their friends that gift of $10 each, but to get it, you had to give us a little more. You would have to enter your credit card, validate your bank account, and load 50 bucks
40:04 Speaker 03 into your new PayPal account. We kept that promise of $10. You just had to work a little harder for it. And this brings me to my next point. When you're making the critical transition from bleeding your business to saving your business, you have to be hyper-aware of avoiding a mob reaction. And mobs rally behind very simple statements. They're gonna get fired up if they read PayPal stops giving new users the money that they promised them. But they're probably not gonna linger for too long on PayPal asks for slightly more information from new users, but continues to give them the money that they promised them. You have to know what is it about your service that your customers find invaluable?
40:45 Speaker 03 Protect that, and that's the only promise that really matters. Pricing riots die down, and if you have a service that customers really love, they are eventually gonna let you out of the doghouse. Take it from Pyle. Yes, the uproar about class pass pricing got very loud and pretty mean, but at the end of the day...
41:05 Speaker 02 We lost very little of our members. Some of them, I think, supplemented their classless membership, so they stayed on the 10-pack and they ended up getting a gym membership.
41:14 Speaker 03 So Pyle inadvertently catalyzed a reaction that was ultimately at the heart of her company's mission. Get people exercising exactly as often as they wanted. Some of your users were sticking with 10 classes a month, maybe so they could try out Taekwondo, or spin, or dance every once in a while. But taking the money they might have spent on an unlimited pass and spending it at their local gym instead. And the entire process, the price tweaking, the different models, the customer reactions, taught Pyle a lot about the alignment of mission and money.
41:46 Speaker 02 And I think I've learned this lesson. Whatever your vision is and your business model need to align. When you're realizing that the business is hurting at the expense of your mission actually working, that's not a great setup.
41:59 Speaker 03 And chances are, if your vision and your business model are truly aligned, you've created something you love. Meaning, there's a good probability that other people out there are gonna love it too. And if they really do love it, and you've built something both innovative and invaluable, like a Netflix, or a LastPass, or a ClassPass, your users will put down their pitchforks. And they'll plan their next workout while binge watching an entire TV season. Because for Pyle, it's something about the feeling that ClassPass offers that's important. It's a feeling she's ready to chase alongside her users.
42:36 Speaker 02 It's a feeling of being limitless, right? It's a feeling of, I can work out and I can go to class. It's not just about like, the prices and if the product is unlimited. And we're still on that journey of making sure that the product feels that way. And I think that's on us to figure out, because that is what our core mission is.
42:54 Speaker 03 I'm Reid Hoffman. Thank you for listening.
42:59 Speaker 03 If you've heard anything on this show that you want to write in an email to your team, you're in luck. We post the full transcript of every episode on our website, mastersofscale.com. While you're there, sign up for our weekly email. You'll know first when each episode launches, and we'll pull out the most interesting threads from the show. Finally, if you love the show, we'd love you to leave us a review on iTunes. We read every one, and it helps us make each episode better than the last.
43:29 Speaker 00 Every business hits the same wall the moment your business outgrows the systems that got you here. Spreadsheets everywhere, five different logins, data scattered across entities that don't even talk to each other. If your finance team spends more time finding data than using it, that's when you need the Intuit ERP. Intuit Enterprise Suite is the AI-native ERP solution that's powerful, painless, and proven. Built for businesses scaling fast without the complexity that usually comes with it. From the makers of QuickBooks, learn more at intuit.com/erp.
44:09 Speaker 06 Humans will never be more intelligent than AI.
44:12 Speaker 07 There's going to be two types of companies. Those are great at AI and those that went out of business because they weren't.
44:17 Speaker 01 How do we build a future that is human centered?
44:23 Speaker 06 I'm Rana Elkhayubi, and on my podcast, Pioneers of AI, we answer that question and so many more. As an AI scientist, entrepreneur, and investor, I know what it takes to build AI that works for everyone. Every week, I sit down with the pioneers shaping our future, and we take you behind the scenes of the AI that's transforming our lives. Find Pioneers of AI wherever you tune in.
44:52 Speaker 03 Hey, listeners, Bob here. If you listen to Rapid Response on Masters of Scale, you may be missing half the show because every Friday, we release a second Rapid Response exclusively in the Rapid Response feed. The guests and topics are just as compelling and timely, from Ford CEO to NASA's administrator to the lessons from The Devil Wears Prada. It takes about 10 seconds to find. Just search Rapid Response wherever you listen to podcasts and hit follow to make sure you never miss an episode. I hope to see you there.
45:29 Speaker 03 Masters of Scale is a Wait What original. Our executive producers are June Cohen and Darren Triff. Our producers are Dan Kedney, Chris MacLeod, Natalie Chang, Jenny Cataldo, and Ben Manila. Our supervising producer is Jay Punjabi. Original music and sound design is by the Holiday Brothers. Mixing and mastering by Brian Pugh. Special thanks to Chris Ye, Elisa Schreiber, David Sanford, Saidi Sepieva, and Stephanie Kent. Visit mastersofscale.com to find the transcript for this episode.
Previous Be a painkiller AND a vitamin, w/Clara Shih (Hearsay Systems) Next The infinite learner, w/Barry Diller (Part 1 of our interview) Page updated October 26, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated