Skip to content

How Many Carbs Should You Actually Eat? with Dr. Ben Bikman

Live Like a Girl with Dr. Mindy Pelz

Hosted by Mindy Pelz

1h 7m
Transcript

Original podcast

Where to listen

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

Dr. Mindy Pelz and metabolic scientist Dr. Ben Bikman discuss the science of carbohydrates, the female hormonal cycle, insulin resistance, and modern metabolic health. They explore why women experience a built-in state of insulin resistance during the luteal phase due to progesterone, why post-menopausal women face new metabolic realities as estrogen declines, and how food quality—particularly the presence of fiber and avoidance of ultra-processed items—defines whether a carbohydrate serves as healthy fuel or metabolic stress. The conversation also addresses the role of GLP-1 medications, the connection between hyperglycemia and the sympathetic nervous system, and practical strategies for building sustainable dietary habits.

  • Every study measuring glucose tolerance during the menstrual cycle shows that the luteal phase is a state of insulin resistance. 15:55
  • The single simplest way to distinguish between good and bad carbohydrates is whether they are consumed with fiber. 29:50
  • Hyperglycemia activates the sympathetic nervous system, which can severely disrupt sleep quality and elevate blood pressure at night. 38:25
  • GLP-1 medications should be used temporarily to help manage cravings and build new habits rather than as a lifelong weight-loss crutch. 58:45
  • True fermented sourdough undergoes a process that significantly reduces both the digestible glucose and the anti-nutrient content. 51:59

Chapters

  1. 0:00
    Podcast Introduction and Reset Academy Overview

    Host Mindy Pelz introduces the podcast, her Reset Academy, and sets the stage for the episode’s focus on carbohydrate science.

  2. 2:04
    The Luteal Phase and Carbohydrate Resistance

    Mindy explains how a week in the menstrual cycle increases insulin resistance, causing carb cravings and weight gain, and introduces Dr. Ben Bikman for deeper insight.

  3. 4:06
    Carb Timing and Hormonal Windows

    They explore how carb intake should align with menstrual phases and metabolic states, noting the luteal phase’s heightened insulin resistance.

  4. 7:00
    Good vs. Bad Carbohydrates: Fiber and Processing

    The hosts discuss how fiber content and processing determine whether a carb is healthy, advocating for natural, high-fiber carbs.

  5. 16:00
    The Role of the Nervous System in Metabolism

    Mindy and Ben discuss how sympathetic versus parasympathetic states influence insulin resistance, cortisol, and the effectiveness of fasting.

  6. 17:13
    Post‑Menopausal Carbohydrate Strategy

    The conversation shifts to post‑menopausal women, addressing changes in insulin sensitivity, estrogen loss, and the need for mindful carb choices.

  7. 22:00
    Fermentation, Anti‑Nutrients, and Bread Choices

    The hosts cover how fermented carbs reduce anti‑nutrients and improve digestibility, and they weigh the pros and cons of sourdough versus regular bread.

  8. 47:32
    Food Pairing and Glycemic Control

    They debate the benefits and drawbacks of pairing carbs with fats or proteins to modulate blood sugar spikes.

  9. 53:05
    Sourdough Starter Selection

    Mindy explains how to choose authentic sourdough starters free of added vinegar.

  10. 53:38
    Substack Promotion

    Mindy invites listeners to join her Substack for deeper content and community.

  11. 54:57
    GLP‑1 Drugs and Carbohydrate Abuse

    Discussion of GLP‑1 medications as a response to widespread carbohydrate overconsumption.

  12. 55:42
    Evolving View on GLP‑1 for Weight Loss

    Ben shares his shift from opposing to supporting GLP‑1 for learning to control carb cravings.

Highlights

  • 12:38

    Luteal Phase Insulin Resistanceinsight

    The guest explains that progesterone acts as the hormone of gestation, inducing a natural state of insulin resistance during the luteal phase of the menstrual cycle.

  • 18:59

    Metabolic Shift in Menopausedata

    Post-menopausal women lose the protective metabolic buffering of estrogen, resulting in fewer and larger fat cells and a shift toward greater metabolic vigilance.

  • 22:41

    Brain Energy Deprivationinsight

    The guest discusses research showing that the post-menopausal female brain becomes insulin resistant and starts burning through its own white matter for ketones to make up for the energy gap.

  • 39:28

    Hyperglycemia and Nighttime Stressinsight

    High blood pressure, elevated heart rate, and nighttime anxiety can be driven by going to bed hyperglycemic, which activates the sympathetic nervous system.

  • 48:37

    Glycemic Impact of Pairingstrategy

    Combining carbohydrates with high amounts of fat can flatten a glucose spike but creates a calorie-dense combination that promotes fat storage.

  • 1:03:21

    Differential GLP-1 Responsedata

    A 1996 study cited by the guest reveals that lean women experience a massive GLP-1 release after a high-carb meal, whereas women with obesity showed no elevation above baseline.

Quotes

  • “There's something powerful that shifts when a woman realizes she's not broken. She's just been given the wrong information.”
    Mindy Pelz · 0:12
  • “I said that there is a week in every woman's menstrual cycle where her body just handles carbohydrates completely differently.”
    Mindy Pelz · 2:03
  • “70% of all the calories consumed on this planet come from a single macronutrient, carbohydrates.”
    Mindy Pelz · 3:30
  • “Progesterone is a hormone that will not only stimulate some insulin resistance, but I say this with a tremendous amount of sympathy too, because that's, that's when she's the most insulin resistant, but progesterone is also a hunger signal.”
    Unnamed speaker · 14:27
  • “I initially came out very opposed to the use of GLP-1 medications for obesity.”
    Unnamed speaker · 55:42
  • “The drug starts to have diminishing returns. That's been well shown at two years.”
    Unnamed speaker · 58:19
  • “GLP-1s can help with addiction. In fact, this has been shown with cocaine addiction, with alcohol addiction, heroin, gambling.”
    Unnamed speaker · 59:51
  • “Just control your carbs. That is going to be the primary villain that is making you not feel your best.”
    Unnamed speaker · 1:08:57
  • resetacademy.drmindypels.com 1:18–1:29
  • Qualia Magnesium Plus 31:35–32:48
  • Substack 53:43–54:52

About this episode

Are carbs actually bad for you, or have we been asking the wrong question? In this episode, I'm sitting down with metabolic scientist Dr. Ben Bikman to unpack one of the most confusing nutrition conversations happening right now. We talk about how to know how many carbs your body can handle, why your muscle mass and activity level matter, how carbohydrate quality changes your metabolic response, and why the answer may be different depending on where a woman is in her hormonal life. Ben also explains what happens to insulin sensitivity across the menstrual cycle and after menopause, why fiber matters, how he thinks about food pairing, what a CGM can tell you, and why his perspective on GLP-1 medications has evolved. In this episode: Are carbs actually bad for you? How many carbohydrates should you eat? Good carbs vs. highly refined carbsWhy fiber changes the conversationWhy muscle gives you more metabolic “wiggle room”Carbohydrates, blood sugar, stress, and sleepCan food naturally stimulate GLP-1? More on Dr. Ben Bikman Dr. Ben Bikman is a metabolic scientist and professor whose research focuses on insulin resistance, metabolic health, and the ways nutrition influences human metabolism. He is the author of Why We Get Sick https://benbikman.com/books/ and the upcoming book The Carb Crisis https://link.amazon/B096Jd0u4, which explores carbohydrates through the lens of metabolism and other factors that may influence how our bodies respond to the foods we eat. The Carb Crisis Book: https://link.amazon/B096Jd0u4Website: http://benbikman.com/Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/benbikmanphdFacebook: https://www.facebook.com/BenjaminBikmanPhDYouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@benbikmanTikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@benbikmanphdX: https://x.com/BenBikmanPhDFor more resources related to today’s episode, visit the podcast episode page: drmindypelz.com/ep371 https://www.drmindypelz.com/ep371 Connect with Dr. Mindy: Join Reset Academy https://resetacademy.drmindypelz.com/reset-academy?utm_source=libsyn&utm_medium=podcast&utm_term=&utm_content=loc-description&utm_campaign=reset-academyWatch the episodes on YouTube https://www.youtube.com/@DrMindyPelz?sub_confirmation=1Follow Dr. Mindy on Instagram https://www.instagram.com/dr.mindypelz/Subscribe to Dr. Mindy’s newsletter https://www.drmindypelz.com/ Disclaimer: This podcast is intended for educational and informational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional medical advice. Always consult a qualified healthcare professional before making changes to your diet, fasting routine, or lifestyle.

Transcript

0:00
1:07:27

12,542 words · 2 speakers

Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.

Topics

  • GLP-1
  • Sourdough
  • The Carb Crisis
  • CGM
  • Fast Like a Girl
  • Reset Academy
  • Brigham Young University
  • Nutrient Global Database
  • GLP-1 retitriotide
  • GLP-1 drugs

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated