Skip to content

TLPP: Your Therapist is Crazy w/ Andrew Hartz

Lions of Liberty Network

1h 1m
Transcript

Original podcast

Where to listen

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

In this episode, the host is joined by Andrew Hartz from the Open Therapy Institute to discuss the infiltration of radical identity politics into the mental health profession and how everyday patients can navigate it. Hartz explains how traditional therapy organizations and academic training programs have increasingly centered extreme political agendas, from calls for papers on systemic oppression to continuing education credits for drag shows, often at the expense of clinical evidence and patient care. The conversation also explores broader themes of mental health, secondary gains, emotion regulation, and the irreplaceable value of genuine human relationships in an era of growing institutional dysfunction and AI chatbots.

  • Patients can use the Open Therapy Institute national directory to find vetted, non-activist therapists they can trust. 4:40
  • Mental health professionals should avoid over-accommodating symptoms with secondary gains that accidentally entrench mental illness. 22:34
  • People experiencing anger can often slow down their reactions by identifying the underlying feelings of powerlessness or inadequacy. 42:36

Chapters

  1. 0:00
    Episode Introduction

    Hosts introduce the episode and set the stage for a discussion on therapy and AI.

  2. 0:32
    Merchandise and Community Perks

    Andrew discusses the institute’s exclusive merch and how it serves as a perk for insiders, reflecting the community culture.

  3. 4:54
    Open Therapy Institute’s Core Services

    Andrew outlines the institute’s national therapist directory, journal, research, conference, and podcast, emphasizing its growth and impact.

  4. 5:39
    Critique of Activist Therapy Practices

    Andrew critiques the APA’s Division on Psychoanalysis for its focus on identity politics, arguing it detracts from evidence‑based practice.

  5. 12:44
    Real‑World Examples of Activist Therapy

    Andrew shares anecdotes from clinics where therapists diagnose based on demographics, illustrating the harmful effects of activist approaches.

  6. 14:17
    Funding and Survey Initiatives

    Andrew explains plans to fund research and conduct a national patient survey to measure the prevalence of activist practices.

  7. 14:56
    Closing Reflections and Takeaways

    The hosts wrap up the episode, reflecting on the importance of evidence‑based practice and the challenges of navigating activist influences in therapy.

  8. 38:40
    Evidence‑Based Alternatives and CBT Focus

    Andrew advocates for cognitive behavioral therapy and other evidence‑based interventions, noting their effectiveness and limitations.

  9. 40:00
    Emotion Regulation and Anger Management Techniques

    Andrew details practical strategies for slowing down emotional reactions and building reflective capacity in therapy.

  10. 46:49
    Personal Coaching Story and Applying Therapy Skills

    Luke shares his experience coaching his son’s soccer team, using therapeutic insights to navigate frustration and communication.

  11. 50:22
    Humor as a Therapeutic Tool

    Andrew discusses the role of humor in therapy, its benefits, and how to use it effectively with patients.

  12. 54:02
    Robin Williams and Matt Damon Case Study

    Speakers analyze the therapeutic relationship between Robin Williams and Matt Damon as an illustrative example.

Highlights

  • 3:56

    Starting the Open Therapy Institutestory

    Andrew Hartz explains how an unexpected Wall Street Journal op-ed and outreach from Dr. Phil led to founding an organization providing vetted, non-activist therapists.

  • 6:05

    Radical Papers in Therapy Journalsdata

    Hartz reads from an APA division call for papers that focuses heavily on identity politics, imperialism, and capitalism while omitting core clinical topics like research and treatment.

  • 8:46

    Accrediting Drag Shows for CE Creditsinsight

    The discussion highlights an APA-accredited continuing education talk featuring a drag show performance titled Feel the Fucking Fantasy Redux.

  • 12:49

    Demographics Informing Clinical Diagnosesstory

    Hartz describes working at a prominent clinic where a white girl's anxiety was attributed to privilege and a black girl's to racism.

  • 18:23

    Rise of Social Justice in Therapyinsight

    Hartz notes that radical ideological shifts in mental health accelerated significantly between 2017 and 2020, alienating centrist and moderate professionals.

  • 22:12

    The Danger of Secondary Gainsinsight

    Hartz explains how rewarding or praising symptoms like test anxiety or depression can actually worsen them by providing secondary gains that entrench the behavior.

  • 27:37

    Unpacking Incoherent Academic Jargoninsight

    Hartz reads a real academic sentence concerning cis hetero patriarchal racial capitalism, illustrating how contemporary writing often lacks clear meaning or truth.

  • 56:38

    The Irreplaceable Human Elementinsight

    Hartz argues that unlike AI chatbots, human therapists provide real emotional reactions, boundaries, and interpersonal friction that are crucial for healing.

Quotes

  • “If you can slow down the process and kind of be like, oh, I'm actually feeling super powerless right now. And that's the trigger for me.”
    Unnamed speaker · 45:34
  • “It's so much about the relationship more than necessarily the advice.”
    Unnamed speaker · 54:32
  • “Being able to model being upset or assertive or having a conflict.”
    Unnamed speaker · 55:54
  • “There are other things that he did around like um.”
    Unnamed speaker · 56:07
  • “And I'm actually worried about people seeing a therapist that has no boundaries and has no desire and has no feelings and doesn't really.”
    Unnamed speaker · 57:05
  • Open Therapy Institute 58:27–59:43

About this episode

Andrew Hartz is a psychologist and the founder of the Open Therapy Institute — a national directory of vetted, non-activist therapists, plus a peer-reviewed journal, conference, and podcast. He wrote a Wall Street Journal op-ed about political activism in mental health, got a grant to do something about it, and hasn't stopped since. We talked about: what an activist therapist actually looks like (APA's division on psychoanalysis lists 90 talks with zero mention of therapy, evidence, diagnosis, or treatment — but plenty on colonial domination, carcerality, and proximity to whiteness); how APA accredited a drag show called "Feel the F***ing Fantasy Redux" for continuing ed credits; a keynote speaker who co-translated Communism for Kids and wrote Abolish the Family; clinics diagnosing patients differently based on their race; patients being referred out for having the wrong politics; how mental health activism is backfiring on the people it claims to help (secondary gains and the evidence against rewarding symptoms); when this all started (earlier than you think — 2014, accelerating through 2019); why Lacanian nonsense writing infected academic psychology and what that sentence actually is; what CBT can and can't do; humor as a mature defense mechanism and why patients who laugh have better outcomes; why AI therapists worry Andrew more than most people realize; and Lou volunteering to coach soccer for a team of first graders despite having never played the sport. Find a vetted therapist → opentherapyinstitute.org Read the journal → Open Inquiry in Mental Health on Substack https://openinquirymentalhealth.substack.com/?utm_source=global-search TIMESTAMPS: 0:00 — Intro — Andrew Hartz and the Open Therapy Institute 3:23 — What is an activist therapist? The APA call for papers read aloud 6:24 — APA's division on psychoanalysis: 90 talks, 800 attendees, zero mention of therapy 8:29 — APA accredited a drag show for continuing ed credits 10:08 — Keynote speaker co-translated Communism for Kids, wrote Abolish the Family 11:53 — Lou's SJW Therapist sketch — and how close to reality it actually is 12:21 — Diagnosing people by their race — a white girl's anxiety vs. a black girl's anxiety 13:17 — The intake form that starts with pronouns — and what that signals 14:01 — Patient referred out for thinking she didn't get a fellowship due to affirmative action 14:41 — Who's paying for this? Insurance, premiums, and activist therapy 16:16 — "Evidence is Western" — activist therapists and why they reject research 17:25 — When did therapy start going this route? 2014, accelerating through 2019 19:47 — Lou's SJW Therapist video: January 2019 — right on time 20:12 — Mental illness as identity — secondary gains and how compassion backfires 21:33 — Test anxiety, extra time, and why rewarding symptoms makes them worse 23:52 — Lou used to wet himself before tests. He is not ashamed. 26:06 — The incoherence of activist academia — can anyone read this sentence? 27:23 — "Counter the extractive relations of cis heteropatriarchal racial capitalism" — a real sentence 29:54 — Lacan, oracular interpretations, and how academic nonsense writing spread 33:45 — If you have to build a birdhouse, the sentences have to make sense 36:36 — Greg Lukianoff, CBT, and what good therapy actually looks like 38:10 — Anger, dysregulation, and slowing down the loop 41:53 — What therapy cannot do: eliminate human emotion entirely 42:44 — Lou and the spiral — and why self-control matters 45:32 — Lou volunteered to coach soccer. He doesn't know how to play soccer. 49:30 — Humor as a mature defense — why patients who laugh have better outcomes 52:56 — Was it Good Will Hunting? What Robin Williams got right about therapy 54:55 — AI therapists — what they can replace and what they can't 57:17 — The danger of chatbot therapy for people who struggle with real relationships 58:03 — Open Inquiry in Mental Health journal and how to find a vetted therapist Watch full episodes on YouTube → https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J4Vb53s4I0A&list=PLb5trMQQvT077-L1roE0iZyAgT4dD4EtJ Listen on Apple Podcasts → https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-lou-perez-podcast/id1535032081 Listen on Spotify → https://open.spotify.com/show/2KAtC7eFS3NHWMZp2UgMVU Co-host of Happy Hour Econ → https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/happy-hour-econ/id1863476697 Lou's book — That Joke Isn't Funny Anymore: https://amzn.to/3VhFa1r TheLouPerez.com | [email protected] Newsletter: https://substack.com/@louperez #MentalHealth #Therapy #ActivistTherapy #OpenTherapyInstitute #AndrewHartz #CBT #Psychology #LouPerezPodcast #LionsOfLiberty #AITherapy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Transcript

0:00
1:01:43

9,961 words · 5 speakers

Topics

  • AI therapists

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated