Pod Insights Lions of Liberty Network TBNS: What Your Union DOESN'T Tell You (Until You Try To Leave!) About this episode David Osborne joins Brian Nichols to reveal how public sector unions trap members into paying union dues long after they quit - and why leaving your union is nearly impossible right now. Osborne is the former CEO of Americans for Fair Treatment and helped start the Fairness Center, a public interest law firm representing teachers, firefighters, police, and municipal workers against their own unions. This is a throwback to Episode 233, April 2021, with a five-year scorecard on what he got right and what he missed. Inside, you'll hear the uncensored breakdown of the union resignation window, the restrictive membership forms nobody reads at orientation, and the clause that makes public employees pay dues regardless of membership status. This is the playbook nobody hands you when you take a government job. And here's the part that should bother you... the union never had to win. They just had to make leaving expensive enough that you stopped trying. What happens to your paycheck when the organization that's supposed to protect you is the one you need protection from? At 6:00, the Pennsylvania teacher whose own union blocked where her money could go - even after they agreed she'd never pay them a dime. At 10:17, the gym membership analogy that explains the whole trap in sixty seconds. And at 25:30, the specific request David made to the Supreme Court in April 2021 - and the answer he got eight weeks later. Subscribe for new episodes every Thursday. This episode is powered by Cardio Miracle - lower your resting heart rate, lower your blood pressure, improve your pump. Head to cardiomiracle.com/TBNS and use code TBNS for 15% off. Full episode library at briannicholsshow.com. Reach out at [email protected] or @BNicholsLiberty on X, Facebook, and Instagram. Educated. Enlightened. Informed.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 Back in 2021, a lawyer sat right there and told me something I didn't believe. He said, there are people in this country who quit their union, get kicked out of their union, and still have to pay union dues, every paycheck for the rest of the year. He compared it to a gym that cancels your membership and then keeps charging you and won't let you in the building? I laughed because it sounded made up. It wasn't. Yeah, let's talk about that.
0:39 Speaker 00 Well, hey there, folks. Welcome to today's throwback episode of The Brian Nichols Show. I am, as always, your humble host, joining you from our lovely Cardio Miracle Studios here in sunny eastern Indiana. The Brian Nichols Show is powered by the best heart health supplement in the world. So if you want to learn how to lower your resting heart rate, lower your blood pressure while improving your pump at the gym, just like I did, stick around. We'll talk about that later in today's episode. Or if you really want, you can just go ahead and scan that little QR code over my shoulder. Or if you're an audio listener, head to cardiomiracle.com/tbns. But let's go ahead and jump into today's episode. And here's the deal for today.
1:23 Speaker 00 We're going back to episode 233, and that is April of 2021. And on the show, we had David Osborne. At the time, he was the CEO of Americans for Fair Treatment. Before that, he helped start the Fairness Center, which is a public interest law firm in Pennsylvania that did one thing, represent public employees who got run over by their own unions. So that's teachers, firefighters, cops, state and municipal workers. But the reason we're pulling this one back out isn't nostalgia. It's because David made a very specific prediction in this conversation. Actually, it was a specific ask.
2:04 Speaker 00 And about eight weeks after we recorded the episode, he got an answer. He didn't want. So we're going to run the clips and I'll jump in in between. And at the end, we have our scorecard. What David nailed, what was whiffed, and where David Osborne is sitting today. So let's start with who actually gets hurt here, because it's probably not the ones you're thinking of. David Osborne from the Americans for Fair Treatment. David first in the program when he was part of the Fairness Center back a few years ago, focusing on helping protect public sector employees' rights. He's joined the program
2:44 Speaker 00 now to give those union employees a voice, standing up against their public sector unions and what we can do at the Brian Nichols Show audience to help support their cause. With that being said, on to the show, David Osborne, here on the Brian Nichols Show.
2:59 Speaker 01 Brian, how you doing?
3:00 Speaker 00 Good, David. Thanks so much for joining the program. So glad to have you back on the show and so glad to see you've been having a lot of wild, exciting adventures happening over in your world, namely, you're in a new position over at the Americans for Fair Treatment. You last joined the program back, I think it was like episode 60, 69, 68, somewhere in there, when you were a part of recent guests, it was the Fairness Center. So I know you've been very busy. Let's dig into what's been happening over in your world.
3:28 Speaker 01 I work on an organization called Americans for Fair Treatment. It's a nonprofit that helps people who've been failed by their public sector unions. So we've worked with teachers, firefighters, law enforcement, state municipal employees, among others, who were counting on their union to treat them fairly. And many of them have come to the conclusion that they're really better off without a union.
3:50 Speaker 00 So you say they've come to that conclusion. And we've talked to Nathan, most recently here on the Fairness Center. And we hear that it's mostly because a lot of people just don't realize what's happening behind the scenes. But when people do start to wake up to the nitty gritty, the dirty details of what their contracts actually say, what maybe they weren't told that they should have been told, we see more often than not that people are starting to say, well, this is, this is wrong. And they're looking for outlets. So let's start off here, setting up what brought you going from the Fairness Center to the Americans for Fair Treatment. What was that progression like?
4:29 Speaker 01 Sure. I joined and was part of starting the Fairness Center because I was convinced there were people in Pennsylvania who really cared about public employees and I had to be convinced that these public employees were not treated fairly by their unions. The reason that was surprising to me is that I lived in Florida at the time where public sector unions just don't have as much of a hold on state politics. Not saying that they do their job that well, I'm just saying that to the extent that they're active, they're in the, at least in the ballpark. What I learned was happening in Pennsylvania, and really this is happening across the country, is that public sector unions seem to be, public sector union officials seem to be more concerned with growing their power and their status than they were in properly representing these
5:12 Speaker 01 particular employees. So again, we're talking about teachers, first responders, state municipal workers.
5:18 Speaker 00 Failed by their union, not failed by management, not failed by the taxpayer, failed by the organization taking money out of their check to protect them. And let's make that concrete right now because David told me a story back in 2021 that really drives this point home. Her name is Jane Ladley. She's a Pennsylvania teacher and she had religious objections to funding the union. And Pennsylvania law actually accounts for that. You can send the money to a charity instead. So it sounds like the system's working, right? Well, watch what the union did with it instead.
5:59 Speaker 01 One of the first stories I heard, for instance, was a woman who was, her name's Jane Ladley. She was forced to pay the union as a condition of employment as a teacher. And at that time, that was the law. Unions couldn't do that. But she had some religious reasons for not wanting to pay the union. And as a result, there was a law in place that allowed her to object on religious grounds, to payment of any fee, any payment of any kind to the union. But the union was actually using that very process against her to make sure that the money they knew they would never get their hands on was going to a nonprofit that they would have approved otherwise. So for instance, she wanted to send, there was another
6:41 Speaker 01 woman that I worked with who wanted to send her money. She was experiencing the exact same thing, wanted to send her money to a local pregnancy center that helps women who chose not to undergo an abortion. That was something she felt very strongly about. Well, the union said, no, we'll only allow you to give your money to a charity that counsels women on all options. Of course, that was antithetical to what she believed. So even though they weren't going to get the money, they wanted to make sure that the money that would otherwise go to them was going to a charity that they would support. That's the stuff. Again, that's a constitutional issue. You might think of it as a small issue because there were small dollar amounts involved, but these were high value because
7:24 Speaker 01 they were, they were high principle issues. So after meeting with a number of these folks, I agreed, what you need here is a public interest law firm. I had gone to law school to help people to make a difference in the world. I know a lot of lawyers say that, a lot of lawyers don't follow through on that. I wanted to follow through on. And so when I came up to Pennsylvania, I started representing these people and it wasn't just them. It was, it was one, one public employee after another who was forced to support politics that they didn't agree with, who was forced to support candidates that they would have never supported, and they didn't have any say in the matter, really, without a lawyer.
8:01 Speaker 00 That's wild. That's wild. So timeout really quick there.
8:04 Speaker 01 Sure.
8:05 Speaker 00 Because I think there's going to be a lot of people who are going to hear this, and they're probably in the public sector union right now. And they maybe don't realize that this is happening to them. So they, I say they, should at the very least be trying to find some outlets that they can, I guess, utilize that can help them raise this awareness up to other folks who are in the union. Because I was talking to Nathan last time from the Fairness Center, and one of the stories he told was just mind blowing to me that the audacity of one of the public sector organizations saying, don't ask that question. Don't worry about that.
8:40 Speaker 01 Right.
8:41 Speaker 00 How dare you? The money that you're paying, well, not even just paying, it's being forcibly taken from your paycheck, whether you like it or not, it's going to these union dues. It's just insane.
8:50 Speaker 01 Right. Well, Brian, Nathan and I worked closely together for years at the Fairness Center. We worked on the legal side. So when these things would come up, these folks needed a lawyer. And the reality is if you go out in the private market and try to pay for a lawyer for these things, you're going to burn through a few hundred dollars in a couple of hours before the value, at least the monetary value of your claim is already exhausted. As you and I know, the Constitution matters a lot more than that. So somebody, some lawyer was needed to fight for these folks.
9:23 Speaker 00 I mean, think about what that actually is. The union was never getting that money. Not a dime of it, but they fought anyway over where a teacher's own paycheck went. One woman wanted to fund a pregnancy center and the union said, no. It had to be the organization they approved. Small dollars, huge principal. And, and that's, that's David's whole point. But, okay. The obvious response is fine, then leave. Just quit. Walk, walk away. And this is where David gave me the analogy that it's kind of stuck with me for the past five years. Take a listen.
10:02 Speaker 01 If you've ever tried to resign from your gym or end your Verizon plan, you'll experience just a piece of what public sector employees experience when they try to leave their union. But again, the public sector unions are far more savvy and less interested in customer service because they have a monopoly over these people in their workplace.
10:22 Speaker 00 Right.
10:23 Speaker 01 So some of the forms that public sector unions are making people sign in order to become members are highly restrictive. They're signed in circumstances that, that prevent a public sector employee from reading or understanding them. And then when they go to resign, what they realize is the unions made them sign an agreement that, for instance, this is a hot one right now, that they agreed to pay union dues regardless of their membership status. Make any sense to you?
10:50 Speaker 00 How is that legal?
10:52 Speaker 01 This would be like if you had your, you're trying to get out of your gym membership and they said, you can quit your gym membership, but you still have to pay all the dues that you would have had to pay. There are times where you might have to pay a month or two. We're talking about for a year. And you don't get to use the gym while you're paying those dues. That's the worst part of this. The union will kick you out, but make you pay dues regardless of your membership status.
11:16 Speaker 00 Wow.
11:17 Speaker 01 Just one example among many of some of the, some of the difficulty that people run into when they're getting out of unions. We are hip to all these tricks. These are the, in fact, we put something on the website just recently detailing three of the different ways that government unions will use to try to keep people in. That's one of them. Restrictive terms that you don't understand until you actually go to resign.
11:41 Speaker 00 So David, what other things are there as red flags that people should be looking out for? Because I'm sure your average employee who's hearing this are like, oh, what? Like, that's a thing? So I'm sure you come across us all day long, like my day job, we're in greater telecom and cybersecurity. So when I'm talking to an IT director and they start talking about like a phishing attack, I'm like, I get you and I speak your language. But if I were to go ahead and start talking to Suzie down in accounting, she might not know exactly what the phishing campaign is like. We're going to go phishing as a team? Like, what is this? So I think there are a lot of people who maybe they don't understand just because they don't speak legalese. They don't know what to look for. So maybe you can do a little bit more of that.
12:21 Speaker 01 Well, you don't, you don't have to understand legalese to see the biggest problem about public sector unions. So right now in New York, Pennsylvania, Massachusetts, Illinois, among others, there are progressive politicians and public sector employees who are working together to raise taxes and grow government. In Pennsylvania, for example, the governor's calling for a $4 billion, B billion with a B, tax increase.
12:46 Speaker 01 More than half of those who are supporting that budget increase are public sector union officials who've been supporting Governor Wolf, the most liberal governor in America. During the 2020 election, public sector unions across the country spent about $250 million on politics and at 90% or so went to Democrats. Unfortunately, that means that the public sector unions that are looking to go government end up having enormous influence over the Democrats that they've campaigned for.
13:15 Speaker 00 It's a slush fund. That's all it is.
13:17 Speaker 01 What do public sector unions, what do public sector unions get out of that? Well, big government means more public employees, more members, more union dues. In other words, the pathway to growing public sector unions is to grow government itself. And what I'm describing is really a vicious cycle.
13:37 Speaker 00 That's a super vicious cycle, to say the least. It's gonna be, it's like an avalanche. It's just gonna keep getting bigger and bigger and bigger until it implodes on itself. That's just like the inevitable outcome.
13:49 Speaker 01 Right. Well, and we run into public employees all the time who are actually funding that vicious cycle, didn't really realize what was going on. But I mentioned that 90% or so of that $250 million across the country were going to Democrats. That does not reflect membership. Many members believed that the union would be a protection for them when an employer comes after them unjustly. Sometimes the union does that, but the primary purpose of public sector union officials right now is to grow their power and influence. And they've done that largely by co-opting and living off of the Democratic Party. I don't know that it had to be the Democratic Party. It certainly could have looked some
14:33 Speaker 01 other way, but this is how it has evolved in this country. And in public sector union employees, the folks that unions are supposed to represent, when they find that out, a lot of them want to take a step to declare union independence. This is not something I want to be a part of.
14:50 Speaker 00 You can quit your gym membership, but you still have to pay all the dues. Oh, and you don't get to use the gym. Like, that's not a metaphor he was reaching for. That's the actual arrangement here. You sign here, agree to pay dues regardless of membership status. And notice what he said right after. We're hip to all these tricks because that's the imbalance. On one side, an organization with lawyers, a payroll deduction pipeline, and a permanent seat in your state Capitol. On the other side, a fourth grade teacher trying to read a form she signed at orientation.
15:32 Speaker 01 Now, the reason that I'm now at Americans for Fair Treatment is that filing these kinds of lawsuits, helping these individuals, irreplaceable. It's a big part of how these folks can take the power back. But what Americans for Treatment helps people do is when they don't have a lawsuit, when they want to speak out, when they want to, like you're talking about, educating their coworkers, and they want to make some other difference, say with the legislature, they need the tools to do it. They're going up against a big union machine that works alongside big government to grow government and to increase taxes, and they are just a little guy on their own.
16:12 Speaker 00 So let's talk about what you've been doing then. And that is working at the Americans for Fair Treatment and giving these folks a platform. So let's start off introducing the Americans for Fair Treatment. What is the mission, the goal of the organization as you've started it?
16:29 Speaker 01 Help to educate public employees as to their constitutional rights with respect to public sector union issues. And we connect people, once we've educated them, with resources that they need to adequately defend those rights. So we like to tell people that we help to move them from a position of union dependence to a place of union independence. And that can look like a lot of different things. There are some people who want to declare union independence by resigning from their union, by quitting and ending their dues payments to support things that they really don't support. And then for some people, it looks like you're kicking the union out altogether, maybe starting their own union or decertifying the old union and negotiating directly with their employer.
17:15 Speaker 01 The problem for a lot of these public employees is they've expressed it to me is that the union has made themselves appear to be irreplaceable.
17:24 Speaker 00 Right.
17:25 Speaker 01 That's why dependence happens. What after people, after people are properly educated about their rights and then are connected with resources, they realize that the union has sold them a lot and that in reality, the union is out for itself. It's out to enrich its public employee, its public sector, union officials and to grow in power and influence and ultimately to achieve social goals that many of the folks that they're supposed to represent never supported in the first place.
17:58 Speaker 00 Big union machine, big government and one person standing alone. So what do you actually do with that? Because here's what I really do appreciate about David. He didn't build a complaint. He went out and built a service and he explains it with an analogy I love. Buying a house is complicated. So an entire industry grew up around it. Inspectors, realtors, closing attorneys. Nobody hands you the keys and says, good luck. But he then built the same thing for leaving your union. Let's walk through some of the action items that you as an organization can help with these, these public sector employees right now who are looking for an outlet. What's the, I guess the value add, if you will, that Americans for Fair Treatment represent?
18:43 Speaker 01 Well, public sector unions control your dues payments, control your, your, the windows in which you can resign from the union, speak directly to your employer. Any public employee that wants to declare union independence is going to run into some issues. What Americans for Treatment has done is crack the code. We know how public employees can assert independence and when they're ready to do it, when they want to do it, we can lead them down the path. They don't have to start from scratch. One of my friends describes some of what we do is there, if you're looking to buy a house, it's a complicated process, not insurmountable, but it's complicated. A whole industry has arisen.
19:25 Speaker 01 Around buying a house, you've got people who who inspect homes for a living. You've got realtors who make the deal happen. You've got lawyers who draft up the documents. We all, we do all that when it comes to asserting one's union independence. So letters, we've got letters on our website that you can use to resign from your union. We've got, we've got forms that people can use to file with their labor relations board when they feel like they've been wrong. Or they want to start their own union.
19:55 Speaker 01 And we've got plenty of resources. All you have to do is call us. And we can walk you, walk you through and help you find some of those things. Nice thing is we do it all for free.
20:04 Speaker 00 Oh, free. People like free, David. So when we're talking about these specific resources, particularly, I guess, like specifics. What resources are you referring to?
20:14 Speaker 01 So I mentioned, I mentioned a letter.
20:16 Speaker 00 Into that a little bit.
20:17 Speaker 01 Many people have gone through the resignation process using the letters that we provide on our website. It's not terribly complicated, but if you had to sit down and start from scratch, you wouldn't know how to do it. Moreover, there are complicated rules that unions make you follow in order to get out of your union.
20:33 Speaker 00 You spoke of that last time that they would, and even like in the renewals, they would throw in like, if you don't get the letter in a certain like timeframe between like when the first meeting was to the last meeting. And then you're like, oh, wait, what? And then like, oh, too late. Sorry, you're renewed already. Letters, forms, labor board filings, all for free. See, that was the part that got me in 2021 and it still gets me today. All right, last clip. And this is where I asked him the question that I ask everybody. Forget the problem for a second. Paint me a better future. What does winning actually look like? And listen close to this one because everything in the scorecard hangs on what he says right here.
21:16 Speaker 00 And as we turn towards where we're ending the show, I like to paint a better future, a better picture. That's what we like to do in sales, right? Paint that new reality. So David, what's the new reality? What's, what can folks who maybe have found that the public sector, unions, the public sector career path? It's just now they're realizing it for what it is. It's inefficient. Now they're finding their money is just being ripped away from their paychecks without their consent. What can those folks do? Where is that positive image for the future for them?
21:48 Speaker 01 It doesn't have to be that way. I think union independence looks like it's a place where individuals can freely talk about their union, about their political beliefs, outside of work, without reprisal of the union at work. I think people should be listened to by their unions. They should have the choice not to fund a union. They should have a choice to leave a union at any time. And ultimately, I think they should have the choice to work directly with their employer to effect changes in their own terms and conditions of employment, should they desire, and to do that without a union. Right now,
22:28 Speaker 01 that last bit is something that public employees really don't have a choice about. Right now, you could assert your independence from the union to a point. You could stop paying dues. If you could stop supporting the union, you could stop being afraid of the union. You could sue your union when it fails to properly represent you, or takes actions that are inconsistent with your employment goals. But the reality is, in most places in America, that unions still has the ability to forcibly represent you. It's something they call exclusive representation. And the US Supreme Court has, for a long time, saw that there is a First Amendment problem
23:11 Speaker 01 with the idea of being exclusively represented, forcibly represented, by an organization that does not speak for you. It's like putting words into your mouth. And that's a big problem that many are urging the Supreme Court to address now. It's also a problem that many state legislatures are looking at. But one thing that public sector employees can do, even though that is not an option right now in many places, is to stand up and show political support for their ability to speak directly with their employer, to kick out their union when it's no longer doing its job.
23:46 Speaker 00 Well, that's a heck of a call to action, if I ever heard one, David Osborne. All right, and now it's time for the scorecard. And of course, we get to Monday morning quarterback. Here five years later, but hey, let's have some fun and grade today's conversation. And here is what he got right. Number one, the money. He told me about public sector unions and how they spent $250 million on politics alone in the 2020 cycle. 90% to Democrats. His own shops research now puts the 2024 cycle, you ready for this? Over $900 million, not 250, $900 million.
24:31 Speaker 00 So yeah, he wasn't wrong about the direction. Maybe he was wrong about the ceiling. He undershot it by almost four times. Number two, the exits keep coming. The four largest government unions have lost over 320,000 members, another 380,000 plus fee payers gone. In California, the share of rank and file state workers actually paying dues fell 8%. He said, people leave once they know they can. And they did. Number three, the pathway to growing public sector unions is to grow government itself. That line was the thesis of the whole conversation and it's the frame damn near every fiscal fight in this country has run on since.
25:15 Speaker 00 And he didn't invent it, but he did say it plainly in 2021 and it certainly held up. Now, what David got wrong? And here's the part I gotta be honest about, right at the end, he made an ask. He said, exclusive representation, the rule that says one's union speaks for you, whether you join it or not, is a first amendment problem. And then many are urging the Supreme Court to address it. And we recorded that in April 2021 and then in early June 2021, about eight weeks later, the Supreme Court declined to hear it. Thompson v. Marietta cert denied, no explanation, and they've passed on it every time since. As of this year, 2026 exclusive representation, still standing every single place it stood
26:00 Speaker 00 in 2021. That was the whole ballgame for him and the court walked away from it. Second miss, but this one is bigger. David's entire model was bottom up. Educate the worker, hand them a letter, one resignation at a time until the thing gives. And that's not what happened. March 2025, executive order 14251. Forty federal agencies stripped out of collective bargaining on national security grounds? A second order in August widened it. TSA's contract terminated, 47,000 workers. Bureau of Prisons, 30,000 more. February of this year, the Ninth Circuit cleared the whole thing.
26:42 Speaker 00 So over a million federal workers, not one of them opted out. Now, I know a lot of you guys are cheering. I get it. But go back and listen to what he actually asked for in that last clip. He said people should have the choice to leave. The choice to work directly with their employer. The choice. That word was in there like four times. A president canceling contracts by executive order? That's not choice. That's the same top-down power, just aimed the other way. Different hand on the lever, but it's the same lever. If we were right in 2021 that coercion was the problem, we don't get to stop caring about it when it's our guy doing it.
27:29 Speaker 00 And here's what I love about the ending of this episode. David didn't quit. He went upstream and he stepped out of the CEO chair at America's for Fair Treatment. And at the end of 2021, he is still their special counsel. But today, David Osborne is the Senior Director of Labor Policy at the Commonwealth Foundation. He co-wrote The Battle for the Worker Freedom, the report that grades every state's public sector labor laws. Illinois got NAF. And he's publishing in Reason, Law and Liberty, and The Washington Times. He's on Fox News Radio breaking down union political spending. And he went from suing on behalf of one retired teacher in Chester County
28:10 Speaker 00 to sitting in front of legislatures rewriting the rules everybody plays under. Because the Supreme Court told them no. So he stopped waiting for nine people in robes to make a decision and went around and found 50 state capitals instead. Five years later, he's still in it, just playing on a bigger board. All right, folks, that's gonna be our throwback episode on today's episode of The Brian Nichols Show. If you got some value, do me a favor, go ahead and give today's episode a share. When you do, tag yours truly at BNicholsLiberty on X, Facebook, and Instagram, and ask for The Brian Nichols Show. You can find us wherever you find your favorite podcasts or video shows. So if you're listening to us on the go, head to Apple Podcasts, Spotify, YouTube Music,
28:54 Speaker 00 wherever it is you consume your podcast content. I like podcast addict personally. And then if you're looking to find us on the video version of the show, head to YouTube, Rumble, X, Facebook, wherever it is you consume video content, I'm pretty sure The Brian Nichols Show is likely there. And one final ask, and that is, if you got some value from today's episode, go ahead and give us a five-star rating and review. I would greatly appreciate it, and it really helps the show more than you'd know. With that being said, folks, thank you for joining us, and I guarantee that if you continue to stick around by hitting that subscribe button, you're gonna find that at least a few of the thousand-plus episodes, oh, they should leave you educated, enlightened, and informed.
29:38 Speaker 00 With that being said, it's Brian Nichols signing off here on The Brian Nichols Show. We'll see you next week.
Previous TLPP: Jailed. Deported. 195 Countries. 499 Days. With Michael Zervos Next FF: Neurosurgeon Turned Regenerative Medicine Pioneer Dr. Jeff Gross on Peptides, Stem Cells, and Healing from Within Page updated November 9, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated