Pod Insights Last Podcast On The Left Episode 603: The Black Dahlia Murder Part IV - Exquisite Corpse About this episode The story of The Black Dahlia Murder comes to a close this week as the boys look into one of the most popular suspects in the case: George Hodel, the possibility that the killing had connections to the world of Surrealist Art, "Mind Hunter" John Douglas's theory on the case, as well as the alternative theory that points fingers at a prominent Los Angeles doctor named Walter Bayley.
Transcript 19,278 words · 7 speakers
0:01 Speaker 00 In New Orleans, truckers keep getting sideswiped the exact same way. When a man is found murdered under questionable circumstances related to these accidents, the rubber hits the road. And what the feds uncover is a complex scheme of staged wrecks, financial fraud, and a pair of conspiring lovers behind it. This is a story about fake accidents that lead to real consequences. Listen to "Over My Dead Body," Operation Sideswipe, wherever you get your podcasts. Audible subscribers can binge all episodes early and ad-free right now. Join Audible in the Audible app or by subscribing on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.
0:46 Speaker 01 Last Podcast on the Left is all about the facts. So when Southern New Hampshire University came on as a sponsor, it was time to do some research. Turns out, they offer more than 200 online degree programs, and get this, criminal justice and psychology are some of the most popular. Classes have no set meeting times and tuition rates are some of the lowest in the U.S. Want to learn even more about SNHU? Visit SNHU.edu/last.
1:16 Speaker 02 There's no place to escape to. This is the last podcast.
1:19 Speaker 03 On the left.
1:23 Speaker 02 That's when the cannibalism started.
1:35 Speaker 01 Wow, a lot of people wondered, would they ever record again? Would God stop Last Podcast on the Left from happening due to one of his many myriad of mysteries and control of the elements?
1:52 Speaker 00 I think it's Los Angeles trying to keep a rap on what we gotta fucking tell people about.
1:59 Speaker 01 You know what we gotta do? Honestly, we gotta move Larry Hardner shot at down. The fire is coming for Larry Harnish. Save Larry Harnish. Someone's gotta get the box of papers. He's got a box of papers. He's surrounded by books. They can't be doing anything. Someone go get the Black Dahlia papers. Sorry Larry, we gotta leave you behind.
2:19 Speaker 04 Welcome to Last Podcast on the Left, ladies and gentlemen. My name is Marcus Parks. I'm here with the concerned Henry Zebrowski.
2:25 Speaker 01 Not flammable. Henry Zebrowski can't be set ablaze.
2:30 Speaker 04 We're doing okay.
2:31 Speaker 01 Too wet.
2:32 Speaker 00 All of my horses are safe.
2:33 Speaker 01 My pack of farm is doing so well.
2:37 Speaker 04 Good, good, good.
2:38 Speaker 01 I let my butlers go. That was like the hardest part was letting them go. It was because I went to the servants' quarters and I asked them like, I do feel like you should burn alive with that house. And my, the head concierge of my foyer, he said, yes, sir, yes, I agree, sir. But still, against my own better wishes, I let them go.
2:59 Speaker 00 Yeah, and I thought, you know, I'm almost thinking about like, I have a personal water reservoir and I'm thinking about maybe letting the city use it. But I think for now, I'm good to just keep it for my own baths.
3:10 Speaker 01 Yeah, because don't you, seriously, right?
3:13 Speaker 04 Because you gotta get that good water, you know?
3:15 Speaker 01 What do I do with my natural well? My natural water source? I'm using most of that water to perfect my white, white rice recipe. Yeah, which is extremely good. The whitest of all the rice. White rice.
3:27 Speaker 04 Well, here we are in Los Angeles. The fires are going and we're talking about Black Dahlia, part four.
3:36 Speaker 01 Still.
3:37 Speaker 04 So now that we've covered our man Leslie Dillon, whose story shows more than anything just what police corruption can do to a murder investigation.
3:44 Speaker 01 Leslie, leave her alone. Wesley.
3:47 Speaker 04 Let's explore the worlds of two suspects who have nothing to do with the mob or the LAPD. These suspects are your old fashioned Los Angeles characters. Doctors who are both their own little individual labyrinths of secrets and lies.
4:03 Speaker 01 There's something that gets added to you, I think, when you're an LA doctor. Oh, yeah, yeah. Like, like how like mysteriously attractive your dentist is, Eddie. Oh. You know what I mean? Like, there's certain things, you meet somebody and like, LA is one of those places when you meet a doctor, you're almost like. Well, because they're all actor wannabes. Yeah, they are. They all have a script. They all were like handsome, they were beautiful people.
4:26 Speaker 04 My doctor has a better headshot than I do.
4:28 Speaker 01 Yeah, hey, like.
4:29 Speaker 04 Really good.
4:30 Speaker 01 You've only been in town for a year plus.
4:32 Speaker 04 That's true. Now, our first spect is included here, not necessarily because we think he killed Elizabeth Short. He probably didn't, but he is included because he is absolutely fascinating with surprising connections to both Hollywood and the world of fine art.
4:47 Speaker 01 It's all, it's the character most people lead with in a Black Dahlia series, but we're not like that.
4:52 Speaker 04 Yeah.
4:53 Speaker 01 You fucking pieces of shit. We went through a more important theory, alright? Now, we're gonna get to it because that's when we chose to do it, right Marcus?
5:01 Speaker 04 Goddamn right. It's our fucking choice.
5:03 Speaker 01 That's right.
5:04 Speaker 04 When we do what?
5:05 Speaker 01 Yeah, we put the most entertaining stuff in the end. Because that's where it belongs. As far as I'm concerned, why do you think they do Rosalita for 15 minutes? At the very end of the show.
5:15 Speaker 04 Our second suspect, however, has some extremely compelling, personal connections to Elizabeth Short and the neighborhood where she was found. And this suspect also slides nicely into the profile that Mindhunter author John Douglas drew up for the perpetrator of the Black Dahlia murder. So, let's get into these suspects, starting with probably the most well-known accused killer of Elizabeth Short, Dr. George Hodel.
5:40 Speaker 01 With probably one of the most perfect fancy pervert mustaches in all of history. He has got such a good mustache for eating the ass of a child. It's almost like, did he do it on purpose? Which was first? Yeah.
5:56 Speaker 04 Well, the additional source for George Hodel, by the way, is Exquisite Corps: Surrealism and the Black Dahlia Murder by Mark Nelson and Sarah Hudson-Bailas, which is an absolutely fascinating book, full of incredible art, if you can find it.
6:09 Speaker 01 You should have seen me, uh, reading that in the, by the light of my car. So, I was in my car, charging my phone, or out of power for the last several days, and I sat there and I'm reading the Exquisite Corps book, going through it. I read it from cover to cover.
6:23 Speaker 04 Yeah, I did too. It's a great book.
6:24 Speaker 01 It's a great book. It's also like, it's definitely a more, it's a, it's a better version of the George Hodel story, even though it doesn't have all the details that Black Dahlia Avenger has and all this up, even though, whether or not you think they're fake or whatever. But I'm sitting here reading this book and I get to this section. With all the autopsy pictures, mixture, you know, comparing him to the surrealist paintings. And my neighbor, I just hear a ding ding ding, and a headlamp comes into it. And I just look into my neighbor, looking down, and I just see the pool of light just on to the dead, open pussy of Elizabeth Short. Right, like, Anthony just sitting in the dark, you know, the wind's like whipping around and shit. And he comes in, he's just like, "I got that battery pack you asked for." "What are you reading?"
7:08 Speaker 01 "This is my show." And then, I, I'm, I'm not even joking, I sat with him for 20 minutes and I gave him the whole rundown. And I just, he got the podcast. He got the podcast from me in the car. So, yeah, he got to see it too, and that was just, yeah, it was fun.
7:21 Speaker 04 That's great. Now, the reason why we know so much about George Hodel and his connections to the Black Dahlia murder is because his son, Steve Hodel, is so convinced that his father did the crime that he's written nine books on the subject.
7:35 Speaker 01 I hate my dad! He does. He's like, "My daddy never ate my ass." No, that's not true, I'm sorry, Steve Hodel, please don't sue us.
7:45 Speaker 00 Don't send the police after us.
7:47 Speaker 01 Please, Mr. Hodel. But these guys are, it, it's interesting. He not only thinks that his father did the Black Dahlia murder, but he thinks his father is the biggest criminal that has ever lived. He thinks his father has done every murder.
8:00 Speaker 04 He thinks his father is a supervillain. Like, his father is like the head of the Guild of Calamitous Intent.
8:05 Speaker 01 It's, it's close, but...
8:08 Speaker 04 He's bad, yeah, he's definitely bad. But, you know, let's get more into this story. Now, while nine books make Steve sound like a crackpot with a penchant for self-publishing, he was actually an LAPD detective supervisor for 24 years. He's conducted thousands of criminal investigations and has been involved in 300 murder cases. But because of his resume, he does, according to his very own book, hold himself in very high regard.
8:33 Speaker 01 He really does. He's pretty good. Well, he doesn't sound not, I don't want to be mean, he's...
8:39 Speaker 04 Doesn't sound like he's sure of himself, much like Papa was.
8:43 Speaker 01 Ah.
8:44 Speaker 00 See, I'm a Larry Harnish guy, so Steve can go fucking suck it.
8:47 Speaker 01 Yeah, Team Larry, dude. I want, it's me, I'm fucking sitting here Larry, listen dude, let's fucking go to his house, man, let's TP his house. Come on, man.
8:57 Speaker 04 We're talking about Larry Harnish like the audience knows who the fuck he is. The audience doesn't know who the fuck Larry Harnish is just yet, alright?
9:03 Speaker 00 He's our fucking boy, dude. He's my fucking secondhand soldier, my man general.
9:08 Speaker 04 We talked about him at the end of last episode. He is the grumpy, he is now the self-proclaimed grumpiest man in the world.
9:14 Speaker 01 I love him.
9:15 Speaker 04 But according to Steve Hodel, according to himself, Steve was a real-life hero born out of the imagination of Hollywood. Steve wrote this about himself.
9:25 Speaker 01 Citizens saw me exactly as they knew me from television. Tall, trim, and handsome. With spit-shined shoes and a gleaming badge. There was no difference between me and my actor cop counterparts on Dragnet or Adam 12. Have you ever had a semen fucking shine?
9:45 Speaker 01 Tell me, buddy. Have you ever shined your shoes to the nice dollop of African semen? Come on, enjoy yourself. Enjoy yourself at the airport, just like I did. Looking handsome on my way down to my ninth rape case of the week.
10:00 Speaker 00 I bought a spit shine, but never a cum shine shoe.
10:03 Speaker 01 It's so hard to do because you gotta wait.
10:05 Speaker 00 Yeah, yeah, yeah.
10:06 Speaker 01 So hard.
10:07 Speaker 00 It's like you gotta show them your breasts.
10:08 Speaker 01 Yeah, you said, you said to look away, to look away while you sit there and he's just like, yes, sir, yes, yes, very feminine, sir, very feminine.
10:17 Speaker 04 I tried bringing him a magazine, he said he didn't want it.
10:21 Speaker 01 Very good, sir. Yes, good, proud, American magazine, I come.
10:25 Speaker 00 I told him I drew nipples on my balls for him.
10:27 Speaker 01 Ah, very good. Ah, very good little tits. Tap a butt of the dick.
10:33 Speaker 04 Now, after Steve's father, George Hodel, died in 1999, Steve went through his father's things and found pictures of a woman he didn't recognize. Pictures that appeared as if they were from the 1940s. As Steve stared at these pictures more and more, he came to believe that these were never-before-seen photos of Elizabeth Short. Now, we're not alone in saying that the girl in these pictures is absolutely not Elizabeth Short.
10:58 Speaker 01 We know for a fact, definitely one of them is not Elizabeth Short.
11:01 Speaker 04 Yeah, I mean, and these two pictures don't even really look like the same woman.
11:04 Speaker 01 No, they do not. No, no, no, they kind of look, kind of maybe the same, but they just kind of look like ladies.
11:09 Speaker 04 Yeah, black-haired ladies.
11:11 Speaker 01 Yeah, and it's black and white, so we can't really tell.
11:13 Speaker 04 But the photographs were close enough of a match to send Steve on a mission to delve into his father's past to see if there was some nefarious connection. Because Steve did know that his father, George Hodel, had a checkered past, to say the very least.
11:27 Speaker 01 I think that, obviously, just George Hodel's actions as a whole will put him on the suspect list.
11:34 Speaker 04 Sure.
11:35 Speaker 01 I think it makes a lot of sense, and I think that Stephen Hodel feels a lot of guilt in that way. But he also might have some of his father's traits in a way, in terms of being extremely bullheaded about very arcane things.
11:47 Speaker 04 Could be.
11:47 Speaker 00 So George is definitely a prick bastard, whether Steve's right or not.
11:50 Speaker 01 Absolutely. Hey, no, Eddie, don't, let's, don't tell him yes. Let Eddie choose after the story. Let me see if he decides George Hodel is bad or not.
12:00 Speaker 04 So George Hodel, Steve's father and the main suspect of this section, was a Los Angeles native born in 1907. He was a musical prodigy with a genius IQ of 186, who eventually decided on a career in medicine.
12:13 Speaker 01 Yes, I did receive one more point than Einstein, and I believe it was because that when I took the test, I was fully aroused. I'm the horniest 10-year-old that's ever been. He had the mustache and she was five. It felt... Off his mom's pussy when he was coming out. Let me glue this on my son.
12:37 Speaker 04 After med school, Hodel made a name for himself in Hollywood as a sort of doctor to the stars, partnering with a mysterious Japanese physician about whom little is known.
12:48 Speaker 00 Someone's gotta get the opium.
12:49 Speaker 04 Yeah. George also ran a venereal disease clinic, and as a result, he was put in charge of controlling venereal disease in the city of Los Angeles when he was named head of the LA County Health Department in 1939. In other words, Hodel had direct connections to the grubbiest parts of this city, and he was a powerful man with a lot of connections to boot.
13:10 Speaker 01 I consider myself more of a vagina sheriff. I try to make sure every vagina is clean, it is within the justice system. And when it is not, it is thoroughly banished.
13:24 Speaker 04 So George, how do you do those things? Like, what's your main, like, what's your main goal here?
13:29 Speaker 01 I just can tell when a woman is clean by the way she sits in a chair.
13:33 Speaker 00 What is your favorite venereal disease?
13:36 Speaker 01 Honestly, it's so hard to choose. It's like choosing which child of mine to have sex with. And it's glaucoma, because glaucoma doesn't allow you to see who you're having sex with.
13:45 Speaker 00 It's the best to go on a pretzel, you think.
13:50 Speaker 04 No, I don't know for sure, but it seems like George Hodel's inside track to Hollywood and beyond ran through a childhood friend. This is incredible. George grew up with Hollywood legend John Huston. The guy, he fucking directed The Maltese Falcon, played the main villain in Chinatown.
14:05 Speaker 00 Angelica Huston's dad.
14:07 Speaker 04 Yeah.
14:07 Speaker 00 Danny Huston's dad.
14:08 Speaker 01 And they all, they whole, that's the connection.
14:12 Speaker 04 What?
14:12 Speaker 01 I'll get back to it.
14:14 Speaker 00 The street I used to live on was named after him.
14:16 Speaker 04 No shit?
14:17 Speaker 01 Yeah, that was like where he, I honestly think that, where we lived specifically in North Hollywood. I do weirdly think that's a lot of places where they would like put their like malls. They would put their like ladies when they were working at the studio.
14:30 Speaker 04 Gun malls.
14:30 Speaker 01 Yes, the ladies, their girlfriends would stay where we live in North Hollywood, and their wives would be in the homes.
14:36 Speaker 04 On the other side of the hill.
14:38 Speaker 01 That just got burnt down, and then they are just, and then John Huston would work at the studios that are down the street. To come over North Hollywood, fuck all the ladies on the side, and then go home.
14:46 Speaker 00 Come wash their penis and then come home.
14:48 Speaker 01 In the LA River?
14:51 Speaker 04 Now George and director John Huston remained friends into adulthood. And they were so close that after John Huston divorced his wife in 1933, George married her soon after.
15:02 Speaker 01 Is that close?
15:04 Speaker 04 I think it is, cuz he, well, he knew John Huston, that's how he knew this woman.
15:08 Speaker 01 And they used to go on double dates with each other's wives, and then they swap wives essentially?
15:12 Speaker 04 I don't know if they swapped wives, I just know that John Huston divorced this woman Dorothy, and, you know, George Hodel picked her up.
15:19 Speaker 01 Sucked, yeah, yeah, sucked her up. I can still taste John's kisses.
15:25 Speaker 01 I love five layers of my friend's kisses right on your lips.
15:28 Speaker 04 John Huston is a scary looking man. Yes, he is. That's why he's one of the greatest, like, his villain and his portrayal of the villain in Chinatown is one of the greatest villain portrayals in cinematic history. Yeah, absolutely. Well, John Huston's ex-wife would become Steve Hodel's mother. Although she and George Hodel were divorced by 1944, after Steve's mother filed a complaint of extreme cruelty. Now by 1945, George Hodel was one of LA's reigning shady weirdos, performing illegal abortions in between hedonistic orgies held at his Frank Lloyd Wright Jr. designed home, which had been bizarrely constructed in the style of a Mayan temple.
16:06 Speaker 01 The Shangri-La of Los Angeles.
16:08 Speaker 04 Yeah.
16:09 Speaker 01 Have you ever seen it? Have you ever driven past it?
16:11 Speaker 04 No.
16:11 Speaker 01 It is, it's beautiful. It's in Los Feliz. You go by, it is this, it looks sort of like a mini Mayan version of the Chrysler Building, where it's like, it's got like these kind of mirrored tower to the top. It's extremely beautiful. And you could see, you're like, oh, where do chorus girls go to get murdered on group by Hollywood millionaires? You're like, that house! It makes a lot of sense. If you look at the inside of it, all the sales pitches of it, cuz there was a whole, when he was trying to sell the house, George Hodel took all these self-pictureed, like, oh, he took pictures inside the house of him, like, modeling it, and it looks like a James Bond villain's house. And it's just him just being like, wouldn't you love to live in the opulence of Shangri-La? Wouldn't you love to sit in the living room of Shangri-La?
16:56 Speaker 01 And it's just all like, looks like Kanye West's house, where everything's made out of cinder blocks. Yeah, and it's all tile and concrete, so if you kill a girl, you can just clean it with a hose. Super easy.
17:09 Speaker 04 Now, on May 9th, 1945, suspicion fell on George when his secretary suddenly died in his presence. On that night, George allegedly called his ex-wife and told her to come over to his secretary's apartment. When George's ex-wife arrived, she found George's secretary unconscious from a barbiturate overdose. Incredibly, Hodel's main concern was not his secretary, but the two manuscripts that she had written, manuscripts that he gave to his ex-wife to burn. Hodel's ex-wife did as she was told, and the secretary quickly died from an overdose, while Hodel moved on with his life, having squashed whatever secrets she may have had.
17:46 Speaker 01 So just let that stick in your head. That is like one of the big cruxes of this entire story.
17:52 Speaker 04 That is extraordinarily easily disproved.
17:55 Speaker 01 Of course. But it's like, these are the things that Steve Hodel will build the George Hodel story around. Stuff like this. The idea that he said, "Burn these manuscripts, do these." And it's also crazy to think that he was so mean and so crazy, but his ex-wife kept coming back.
18:09 Speaker 04 Yeah.
18:10 Speaker 00 You know, powerful man. He got lots of money and stuff.
18:12 Speaker 04 Yeah, that happens a lot in abusive relationships.
18:14 Speaker 01 That's true.
18:15 Speaker 00 It's also just like shows how easy it was to just get away with killing someone back then if you had just like a moderate amount of money.
18:21 Speaker 01 Yeah. Oh, and it continues to this day, Eddie. Don't worry. Live from your grave. This podcast is brought to you by Squarespace. Squarespace is an all-in-one website platform that helps you stand out online. Yes, that's right. You don't have to smash your face with a hammer. You can just start a business. It's got everything you need on Squarespace, from securing your domain to building a professional site and showcasing your work all in one place. Let's say you want to show everybody how you can carve your ribs out of your lower abdomen so that you look more like a Ken doll. That's amazing. You can bring your vision to life with AI-powered design or curated templates, plus flexible editing
19:04 Speaker 01 tools that help you create something that truly reflects your style, especially if you are somebody that is trying to corrupt the young men of America. That's what Squarespace is really going to help you. Squarespace makes it easy. It makes it easy for you to put all it together, and you just go to Squarespace and do it all. Thanks, Brayden. Head to Squarespace.com/left for a free trial. And when you're ready to launch, use offer code LEFT to save 10% off your first purchase of a website or domain.
19:33 Speaker 01 For kids, summer means freedom. And as adults, summer still means freedom. Thanks to Mint Mobile's Summer Sale. Right now, all of Mint's plans are $15 per month, even unlimited. Free yourself from big wireless and switch to Mint for high-speed data and coverage on the T-Mobile 5G network. Straight up, Mint's gonna save you money. It does every month. Mint Mobile has all of the perks of all of the major other telephone providers, but this is the one that's actually saving you the dimes you need in order to really put them where they belong, which is, I guess, at the gas station. So Mint Mobile's gonna help you pay for the one gallon of gas that you need.
20:18 Speaker 01 All right, but you will. And thanks to Mint, because at least Mint Mobile cares about your wallet. To get your new wireless plan for just $15 a month, go to mintmobile.com/lpots. That's mintmobile.com/lpots. Cut your wireless bill to $15 a month at mintmobile.com/lpots. That's it. There's no cash. Upfront payment of $45 for three months, $90 for six months, and $180 for 12 months. Plan required, $15 per month equivalent. Taxes and fees extra. Initial plan term only. Greater than 50GB may slow when network is busy. Includes up to 20GB hotspot. Capable device required. Availability, speed, and coverage varies. See mintmobile.com.
21:05 Speaker 01 If you've been thinking about securing your home with SimpliSafe, now is the time. Right now, you can save 70% on a new system, the biggest savings of the year. Unlike traditional security systems that only alert you after a break-in is already underway, SimpliSafe is built to stop it before it starts. Smart, AI-powered cameras watch for potential threats and alert a live US-based agent to intervene. The agent intervenes in under 30 seconds, speaking through the camera to stop an intruder in their tracks and calling for urgent 911 dispatch when it's needed most. And that's why we use it here at the studio. It's extremely powerful. It keeps all the people trying to shut us down and quiet us down, all the government agents, all the various process servers, all the various barbarians that are literally trying to like
21:49 Speaker 01 come into our very studio and stab us, stab us and capture us and kidnap us. But thanks to SimpliSafe, they stop all that. We ain't been kidnapped once. SimpliSafe is offering their biggest savings of the year right now. Seventy percent off your new system with professional monitoring. When you visit simplisafe.com/left. That's simplisafe.com/left. And when you order right in left at checkout, it tells them we sent you and it really helps the show. SimpliSafe, ahead of crime, in real time.
22:21 Speaker 04 Now, when it comes to Hodel's connections, he would host gatherings at his home that centered around drug-fueled hypnotism sessions that were led by George himself. Yes. And that's when he wasn't hosting the orgies.
22:32 Speaker 01 Now, we're going deeper. Deep one, on the count of three, you will turn into the horniest chicken I've ever seen. Three. Cock.
22:45 Speaker 01 Cock. Very good. Yes, very good. Yes, very good. Are you not a chicken anymore? Wolf. Wolf, wolf. Yeah. I'm not telling you hypnotize a dog.
23:00 Speaker 01 Easy to do, let's all fuck it. Come on, John Huston. Let's get Betty Davis. Let's get her a fake cock and have her fuck this dog in front of us, huh? Yeah, all right. Sure, she has Betty Davis eyes, but how about a Betty Davis vagina? Yeah, let's check her.
23:15 Speaker 04 The thing is that Betty Davis and George Hodel probably did meet each other at the very least. Because Betty Davis was actually very big in the modern art scene in Los Angeles. That's it, that's one of the things I found out is that actually the people that are most responsible for modern art coming to Los Angeles are Vincent Price, uh, number one.
23:34 Speaker 00 That makes sense.
23:35 Speaker 04 Yeah, Vincent Price, um, John Huston and Edgar G. Robinson.
23:39 Speaker 00 That's awesome.
23:40 Speaker 01 Yeah, isn't it crazy? And but also the story will go.
23:43 Speaker 04 And Betty Davis was also in the art scene a lot as well.
23:45 Speaker 01 Yeah. Yeah, all of, basically, most of LACMA was like brought here by Vincent Price.
23:51 Speaker 04 Yeah.
23:52 Speaker 01 It's fair, it's fascinating.
23:53 Speaker 00 That's very cool.
23:53 Speaker 04 Yeah. Yeah, it's crazy shit. Uh, but George Hodel was ensconced within the Los Angeles art scene at this time. And these gatherings at George's place were attended by a wide range of artists, writers, and people in the film industry. For writers, for example, novelist Henry Miller was a frequent guest at George Hodel's home. And Henry Miller, if you'll remember, could himself write quite the tawdry tale.
24:16 Speaker 01 Yes, I went and I dropped off some Troporif. I had a two extra copies of Tropic. of cancer for some reason, I dropped them off in some little libraries in my neighborhood.
24:24 Speaker 00 Oh my god, nothing makes me happier than putting a satanic book in a church library.
24:28 Speaker 01 It really makes me happy. I just think it's important for some lady to read about poetry about anal warts. It's important. Have you ever read Henry Miller?
24:38 Speaker 00 No.
24:38 Speaker 01 I'll give you some.
24:39 Speaker 00 Alright, great. I'll not read it then too.
24:44 Speaker 04 But George's company most infamously included the surrealist painter and photographer Man Ray. Now, while people like Henry Miller came in and out of George's world and knew him pretty much as a local eccentric, Man Ray was a family friend of the Hodels and took what I'd call a suspicious amount of photos of both George and his ex-wife.
25:05 Speaker 01 And you could, the reason why it's suspicious is because they are like, because Man Ray will go on and kind of deny whatever connections. Everyone denies connections to George Hodel, but he obviously was friends with them. He took pictures of like candid pictures of his kids, candid pictures of them hanging out. Yes, Man Ray could be, people did pay him to go and take pictures at their home, right? Like to come and do a big photographer, like, you know, you go do whatever, uh, I don't even know what the term it is. Like a big, like actual put together choreographed films, photo shoot.
25:34 Speaker 04 A family photo?
25:35 Speaker 01 Yeah. But with families.
25:37 Speaker 04 A family photo shoot?
25:38 Speaker 01 Yeah, people do that. But Man Ray would do them. What do you think is fascinating?
25:42 Speaker 04 Yeah, I mean, you get incredible fucking photos. I mean, Man Ray is nothing if not extraordinarily talented. I mean, his work is incredible. Um, you know, despite what we may say about his personal life.
25:52 Speaker 00 Yeah. How many photos of your wife in someone else's possession is too much?
25:58 Speaker 00 They say like five.
25:59 Speaker 01 Well, it depends on what situation.
26:02 Speaker 00 Yeah.
26:02 Speaker 01 If it's from across the street.
26:04 Speaker 00 If I paid them to take pictures.
26:07 Speaker 01 As many as we.
26:08 Speaker 00 As many as I paid for.
26:09 Speaker 01 Well, and they're gonna go through all the negatives anyway and choose.
26:12 Speaker 00 Yeah, yeah, yeah.
26:12 Speaker 01 So you don't even get to choose those pictures.
26:13 Speaker 00 Yeah.
26:14 Speaker 04 But to understand why the connection between George Hodel and Man Ray is so interesting, you gotta understand a little bit about surrealism, which is the art movement that Man Ray belonged to and the one that George Hodel was obsessed with.
26:25 Speaker 01 So fucking get your holes ready, dude, because it's time for, oh shit, do we got a good link for this yet? It's art history. It was last podcast on a lot. This is the most extreme shit we have ever covered, dude. Fucking coming for you surrealism. It's the art of space. The art of space.
26:49 Speaker 01 Yeah, no, I'm glad you guys fucking prepped it, but you guys lubed up the chamber. Thank you. Ready, ready for art history.
26:57 Speaker 04 Well, basically surrealism was the next step after the Dada movement. Defined in the book Exquisite Corpse as a heady call to arms, extolling freedom of imagination and liberation from social constraints.
27:09 Speaker 01 All anal.
27:12 Speaker 04 Style-wise, it's just like it sounds, like it's surreal, it's unsettling stuff. You know, Salvador Dali, he's the most well-known surrealist artist out there.
27:19 Speaker 01 Okay, so the good shit.
27:20 Speaker 04 Everyone, yeah, the good shit. Everyone's got, everyone's seen a surrealist painting in their life.
27:24 Speaker 01 Yeah, fucking stupid clocks can't not be melted and shit. Fuck you, time dude, so dumb. It's hard, you never, I know you're afraid of clocks in the first place because you don't even like the concept of time. I know, Eddie. You said clock! I know. I'll fucking rip your hand off if you put a watch on it. I know. I'm gonna fucking chew on your fingers. This is just art history, Eddie.
27:44 Speaker 04 Not times.
27:45 Speaker 01 It's not real.
27:46 Speaker 04 You calm down, you good?
27:48 Speaker 01 Yeah, very warm.
27:49 Speaker 00 Yeah, any number under 13 just fucking gets me going.
27:52 Speaker 01 He has a hard time with it. He has a hard time with it, he can't deal, he loves a baker's dozen. But the surrealism, also remember, it, the goal was to break through, they, they were having problems with the, what they did, viewed as like the staid kind of realism movement that was happening. And surrealism came out of World War I because of the horrors and the atrocities that humans did. The idea was to sort of break through to the subconscious in many different ways. So they would try all these different exercises to try to get through to the subconscious and create that, and from a direct concept from the artist to the canvas.
28:26 Speaker 04 Now, at times surrealism was an interplay of irrationality, eroticism, and violence. And when it came to women in surrealism, they were rarely displayed as fully human entities in surrealist art. Rather, the women in surrealist paintings and photography, particularly the works of Man Ray, featured recurring motifs of bisected and fragmented women, just as Elizabeth Short was bisected and fragmented. Now, many of the surrealists were fascinated with violence, both real and imagined. In the real world, they were captivated by true crime stories, violent accounts of Catholic saints, and Jack the Ripper. But they were also obsessed with the fictional writings of the Marquis de Sade, particularly his unfinished novel, 120 Days of Sodom.
29:10 Speaker 01 Yeah, dude, it's about 30 days too long.
29:14 Speaker 01 Solo. We all see, you saw Solo, right?
29:17 Speaker 04 I didn't see Solo.
29:17 Speaker 01 You've never seen it?
29:18 Speaker 04 No.
29:19 Speaker 01 Let's go take a look at it.
29:20 Speaker 04 I've read like graphic representations of 120 days of Sodom though, it's a fucking foul.
29:25 Speaker 01 Yeah.
29:25 Speaker 04 It's awful.
29:26 Speaker 01 Yeah, it's a fun or whatever. Some people like it.
29:30 Speaker 04 No, I haven't seen, I mean, it's not like every graphic representation, because if you've graphically represented the things that um, happened in 120 days of Sodom, uh, you would be producing child pornography.
29:41 Speaker 01 Well, that's the part you really gotta skip. That's what I'd say. I'd say that is, less is more.
29:48 Speaker 04 Now to briefly recap the story, because it is important. 120 Days of Sodom is a novel from 1785 about four rich libertine Frenchmen who spend four months in a secluded castle in the middle of the forest, trying to top each other in the realm of sexual perversion.
30:04 Speaker 01 It's a true exploration of the rarer fragrances.
30:09 Speaker 04 And what are the rarer fragrances?
30:10 Speaker 01 Every single time you hear the term, like George Hodel, this is a thing that comes up a lot in like, like artsy fartsy old school erotica, like, ah, yes. Ah, the exploration of the rarer fragrances. Which always means butthole. Yeah, oh yeah, yeah, yeah. The rarer fragrance. Yeah, pussy juices. It's pussy juices and butthole. Yeah. Messes.
30:30 Speaker 04 Mm-hmm. We're using 20 victims and eight male accomplices with large penises. Accomplices de Sod simply called the fuckers.
30:38 Speaker 01 Yes, hey, yeah, we're the fuckers, you order. Yeah, we're the fuckers, just so you know, I gotta, I gotta hard out at eight.
30:46 Speaker 01 Yeah, I gotta be fucking at the White House. Tonight. But when I'm done with this, it'll be the Brown House, you know? Yeah, I'm saying anyway, but that's just kind of a joke between fuckers.
30:59 Speaker 01 We mostly say that, you know how it is, I come out, I fuck. You know, sometimes I shoot myself in the head and I wake up and I'm just alive again and I just go out and I fuck again and I get ripped apart by a bunch of dogs and then all of a sudden I just wake up again and I go and I fuck and then I get burnt alive with a bunch of acid and shit, I don't know, man, I'm sorry. Did you mean to order suckers? Because we're fuckers.
31:27 Speaker 01 That's the sucker.
31:29 Speaker 04 Well, using 20 victims in this story, the four Frenchmen engage in incest, rape, necrophilia, bestiality, coprophilia, urine drinking, vomit drinking, and child sex abuse, until it all culminates in murder most foul, and I do mean foul.
31:45 Speaker 01 I do everything but feet stuff. That's the only thing I can't stand. I can't stand feet, but otherwise, I'll fuck a jar of peanut butter into the mouth of a giraffe. All right, I will fuck whatever it is you knew. I got a nine inch cock and it doesn't matter, it works until I'm dead.
32:03 Speaker 00 What's coprophilia?
32:04 Speaker 04 Uh, eating shit.
32:05 Speaker 00 Ah, cool.
32:06 Speaker 04 Yeah, hell yeah, you learned something new today.
32:07 Speaker 00 Well, thank God.
32:10 Speaker 04 But above all else, the novel 120 Days of Sodom is so depraved as to be totally surreal, and the surrealist movement of the 20th century loved the novel for both its style and because they fancied themselves as libertines free from all social constraints.
32:24 Speaker 01 Surrealists, much like any group of artists, they fancy themselves a little bit more hardcore than they actually are.
32:33 Speaker 04 Oh, yes. As the wife of surrealist painter Max Ernst put it, "Most surrealists flew close to the flame of Despard on an intellectual level, but as for emulating the fantasies of Despard's personae, they didn't even try."
32:45 Speaker 01 They're a bunch of people that wear suits too much to be eating that much shit.
32:50 Speaker 00 Oh, yeah, yeah.
32:51 Speaker 01 You know, they all wear suits.
32:53 Speaker 04 But because the surrealists didn't dabble, that did not mean that some of them weren't associated with the people who did, people like George Hodel.
33:01 Speaker 01 I view George Hodel as a Jeffrey Epstein-like character.
33:03 Speaker 04 Yeah, he's very close to that type, yeah, just like this sort of like rich puppet master with a lot of very famous friends, a lot of very well-known friends.
33:13 Speaker 01 That insulated him.
33:14 Speaker 04 That throws a lot of parties.
33:16 Speaker 01 Yes.
33:16 Speaker 04 Uh, and comes very close to getting, uh, to getting some sort of comeuppance, but never quite gets there.
33:22 Speaker 00 Someone who's a lot of fun until you really get to know him.
33:24 Speaker 01 Well, the problem is it's a lot of-
33:25 Speaker 04 A lot of fun for about an hour and a half.
33:27 Speaker 01 And it's a lot of fun that you're definitely having at somebody else's expense and you're not asking a lot of questions about, and then what it does in its own- Is that it creates its own secret keeping mechanism as we've seen George Hodel is a he is a lot of money. He has weird, uh, we don't really know what he does for a living. He does a bunch of different stuff, right?
33:45 Speaker 04 Yeah, he's a doctor, Hollywood doctor to the stars, but it's very vague.
33:48 Speaker 00 So it gives them drugs.
33:50 Speaker 01 Yes, and helps them with venereal diseases on the down low. Helps them with abortions on the down low, helps them with any very, any various problems that would be considered publicly embarrassing. That is somebody who traffics in secrets, like that is his job is to traffic in secrets. So then what is happening is that then other secrets congregate and it takes a type of person. And I think George Hodel, it's why we think he could have within his depths. He might be one considered to do, he would have considered to do the Black Dahlia murder. Because he just was so kind of in his own world of, of ideas that no one cared. He viewed himself as past everyone.
34:27 Speaker 00 Steve's blowing up daddy's spot, man.
34:29 Speaker 01 You leave daddy alone, Steve.
34:33 Speaker 04 Now, the surrealist painter and photographer Man Ray moved to Los Angeles at the age of 50 after escaping World War II Europe. And he eventually made friends with George Hodel in Los Angeles. Man Ray's work, which often featured nude women, was said to be the finest defense of surrealism's central theme of transgressions via eroticism, which pointed more towards death than sexuality. In one photograph, Man Ray did a self portrait of himself lying on top of the dead body of a woman killed by a gunshot. And in one of his paintings, Man Ray portrayed an abstract female bisected at the waist, just like Elizabeth Short was. Both of these works were finished in the 30s, years before the Black Dahlia murder. And we're not saying that Man Ray was directly involved in the killing of Elizabeth Short.
35:18 Speaker 04 But he has been named as a person who may have involved himself in George Hodel's more disgusting pursuits.
35:24 Speaker 01 He was around for the parties. Yeah, I, I, Man Ray was probably around for a lot of the parties and Man Ray was one of these guys. But I think that that was his main connection to this art world, like he had other.
35:34 Speaker 04 Was Man Ray?
35:35 Speaker 01 Was Man Ray was the guy that was his like buddy. That was the guy that was like showing up and taking pictures of other people and doing other things. And then may or may not have taken a bunch of naked pictures of his daughter.
35:44 Speaker 00 Yeah, so you don't have to be so weird. Now, did he took a picture on top of an actual dead woman or was it staged?
35:51 Speaker 04 No, staged.
35:52 Speaker 00 Oh, okay.
35:53 Speaker 01 It was art, Eddie.
35:56 Speaker 04 Now, we don't know for sure how Man Ray and George Hodel connected in the first place, but George Hodel was certainly an arty weirdo and in the Los Angeles art world in the 1940s was predictably small. George Hodel's throwing around a lot of money and he's buying a lot of works of art. And that's the thing, is that no one can really figure out why Man Ray went to Los Angeles in the first place, although he said it was to get as far away from the war as possible. What we do know is that Man Ray was close to George Hodel in the 11 years he lived in Los Angeles, and this was confirmed by George Hodel's daughter, Tamar.
36:26 Speaker 01 There was a little bit of a hint of why he went to Los Angeles in terms of apparently the art scene itself was starting to die out in New York. So all of surrealism, right after World War II, came to New York and it turned into this essentially kind of a commercial enterprise. Salvador Dali, everyone kind of got mad at Salvador Dali because at this point Salvador Dali was on like television shows, he was showing himself to be the face
36:51 Speaker 00 Yeah, he's working with Walt Disney.
36:53 Speaker 01 Yes, he's doing all of these things and he's making a lot of money and he's taking private commissions and to them, he's ruining surrealism because he's making it about commercialism. And so that might be one of the reasons why Man Ray moved from New York to LA.
37:05 Speaker 04 Yeah. But as far as Man Ray's connections to George Hodel goes, George Hodel's daughter, Tamar, said that Man Ray often photographed the whole family. And she said that he took nude photographs of her on occasion when she was still a young teenager. That, however, is not the worst of what happened to Tamar in George Hodel's home, because the thing that happened to Tamar is the catalyst to why we even know about George Hodel in the first place. And that's what makes me fucking wonder so much, is like, we just know George Hodel because of what I'm about to talk about. How many George Hodels have existed in Los Angeles?
37:39 Speaker 00 Oh, buddy.
37:40 Speaker 04 Like, how many have existed in this city and over the last, you know, 120 some odd years?
37:47 Speaker 00 I'd say up to like this century.
37:50 Speaker 04 Oh, of course.
37:51 Speaker 00 It was, because...
37:52 Speaker 04 Now, there's still a George Hodel today, but how many have there been?
37:55 Speaker 00 I mean, at least, I'm gonna say 150.
37:58 Speaker 01 Oh, years up, there is a pack of them. I think that anybody could go to a place where it is, it was lawless out here. And if you had a lot of money, you could really figure it out. And then if you read the works of Kenneth Anger, this happened way more than we even think it did, but then that might be exaggerated.
38:12 Speaker 00 It's also, not only was it lawless, like it wasn't even in check, like New York's in check with the mafia. You know, like the mafia wasn't even in control out here.
38:21 Speaker 01 No.
38:21 Speaker 04 Well, in October of 1949, Tamar Hodel, who was then just 14 years old, she told police that during one of her father's orgies at their home, he had raped her, and this act was witnessed by two other people. Hodel was soon arrested and put on trial for this horrific crime. Now, George Hodel's lawyers had a simple plan for getting their client acquitted. Their plan was to discredit Tamar Hodel completely, to make her look crazy, and they partly did so by using the Black Dahlia murder. During a conversation with the man who rented a room in their home, Tamar had said that her father's house had secret passages, and that her father was going to kill her and everyone else in the house because he had an insatiable bloodlust. That bloodlust, Tamar had said, had already taken a victim,
39:06 Speaker 04 the infamous Black Dahlia. Now, Tamar was obviously making a joke. She said so.
39:11 Speaker 01 Yeah, she said that they were talking about it sort of in a ridiculous way of the other things that he could have done.
39:16 Speaker 04 Yeah.
39:17 Speaker 00 Because it was the most popular news story of the time, probably.
39:19 Speaker 04 Exactly. It's the worst thing you can say that someone did. Like, oh, he killed the Black Dahlia killer, you know? It's like, it's a byword for psychopath.
39:26 Speaker 00 Yeah, yeah, yeah.
39:27 Speaker 04 But the lawyers used these comments to make Tamar look like she'd say just about anything to smear her father, and their scheme worked perfectly. While there was plenty of evidence against Hodel, he was eventually acquitted of all charges, although he did make a few well-placed bribes along the way to make sure that happened. Again, the corruption muddles things. But what was interesting about the acquittal was the reaction from Man Ray, or should I say, the lack of reaction from photographer Man Ray. A year after George's incest trial, Man Ray sent a friendly postcard to George from Paris, asking Hodel if he wanted anything from France besides a coquette, which is another word for a tart or a floozy.
40:09 Speaker 01 You know, I always like to write postcards casually, my friends saying, "You want me to traffic a woman for you?"
40:15 Speaker 01 Heard you're lonely. I actually can, I can abduct a woman for you and take her from this country if you want.
40:20 Speaker 04 Yeah, even in joking, who says that?
40:22 Speaker 01 Hey buddy, hey Marcus, so you're going, oh, I see you're leaving town. When you come back, could you bring me a traffic woman? Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. I don't like her to like it. I don't want her to agree. I want her to be against her will. Yeah, younger the better. Thank you if you could, baby. Looking for a baby?
40:38 Speaker 04 Well, this tone suggests that Man Ray was not in the least bit disturbed by Hodel's incest trial. But when it comes to the surrealist link to the Black Dahlia murder, one of the most interesting parallels involves a game called Exquisite Corpse, which is what the book we use today is named after.
40:53 Speaker 01 Does sound like one of those like, the blood on the dance floor kinda like weird like nu metal bands. You know what I mean? Like one of those weird screed medals?
41:02 Speaker 04 Oh, there had to have been a screamo band called Exquisite Corpse at some point.
41:05 Speaker 01 Yeah, right?
41:05 Speaker 04 There's a band called The Black Dahlia Murder.
41:08 Speaker 01 Our friend!
41:10 Speaker 00 It's like if artists played The Aristocats.
41:13 Speaker 01 Aristocrats. It's, well, the exquisite corpse is a fun name, but it is just a game.
41:18 Speaker 04 Yeah, and it's not necessarily to see who can do like the most disgusting thing or anything like that. Like, it's just to kinda see who can do the most inventive thing. Well, in the exquisite corpse game, three artists take turns drawing a section of a body without seeing any other section. The first takes the head and shoulders, the second draws the torso, and the third finishes up everything below the waist. Exquisite Corpse was particularly popular with the surrealists, and in 1934, an exquisite corpse drawing by four noted surrealist artists that bore a large number of similarities to the mutilations performed on Elizabeth Short's body got published. And this is about 13 years before Elizabeth Short was killed.
41:57 Speaker 00 Whoa.
41:58 Speaker 04 In this delicate crayon-on-paper depiction of a woman's body, the figure's breasts are replaced by simple circular shapes that enclose asymmetrical triangles. As you might remember, when we talked about Elizabeth Short's autopsy, her right breast was removed, which left behind a circular wound. And on her left breast, a triangular shape was cut out of her skin, just to the right of her nipple. In the exquisite corpse drawing in question- There's also a yellow mark just above the genital area, which corresponds to the vertical incision made on Elizabeth Short's body in the exact same place. But most important was the position of this drawing's arms. See, a woman with her arms raised above her head was a weirdly common motif in surrealism,
42:43 Speaker 04 but it was specifically common in the works of Man Ray. In multiple Man Ray photographs, he features solitary nude women over and over again with their arms bent, held over their head. And the woman in the exquisite corpse drawing we're talking about here has her arms in the same position. The position of the arms in both the drawing and Man Ray's photos mirror the exact way Elizabeth Short's body was found.
43:08 Speaker 01 I feel like I know her, but sometimes my arms bend back.
43:12 Speaker 00 Yeah.
43:12 Speaker 01 It's again, it's another David Lynch connection.
43:14 Speaker 00 Yeah, man.
43:14 Speaker 01 It's just a picture of the, the picture of the lady is a definite connection.
43:17 Speaker 04 Yeah, but this motif didn't stop with Man Ray. There was an incredible amount of surrealist art by multiple artists created both before and after the Black Dahlia murder that look uncannily like the crime scene photos taken in Lamert Park in a way that no other art movement connects to a specific murder.
43:35 Speaker 01 Well, you know what the, do you know what the Minotaur means?
43:37 Speaker 04 The Minotaur, I mean, the Minotaur is, I mean, that's a little too fu- like, I thought about going into the Minotaur, but the Minotaur is like a massive side quest.
43:46 Speaker 01 Just quick, the reason why the Minotaur is even used, the position that she's in, it was considered to be the Minotaur position. The Minotaur was this, was this half man, half beast character that was put in the center of a labyrinth. And because he was this abomination, and then Theseus went all the way through to attack the monster, and then he used a golden thread to find his way out of the labyrinth. But the whole thing is about, what they say, it's about the Freudian dip into the subconscious, going through the labyrinth to find the Minotaur, which is the thing inside of you that you maybe don't want to see, or the thing unknown inside of you that you don't want to see, and then pulling it out, which is why the surrealists were using that.
44:22 Speaker 00 So in this theory, Elizabeth Short was an art piece?
44:25 Speaker 01 Yes.
44:26 Speaker 04 Well, let's get into it. Now, the posing of Elizabeth Short's body has always been one of the biggest question marks in the Black Dahlia case. One that no one has ever been able to fully satisfy. In fact, it's one that most people haven't even been able to approach.
44:38 Speaker 00 No.
44:38 Speaker 04 But author Steve Hodel, George Hodel's son, he thinks that he cracked it, using something he calls a "thought print."
44:45 Speaker 01 You know how your fingers got a print, and your butt's got a print?
44:49 Speaker 00 Okay.
44:49 Speaker 01 When you sit in the sand?
44:51 Speaker 00 I'm with you.
44:51 Speaker 01 Sometimes, your thought could have a print.
44:54 Speaker 00 Oh, Jesus.
44:54 Speaker 01 Yeah, no, listen. No, listen, it's easy to do. My thumb print?
44:59 Speaker 00 Uh huh.
45:00 Speaker 01 My fingerprint?
45:01 Speaker 00 Yeah.
45:01 Speaker 01 My butt print?
45:02 Speaker 00 Gotcha.
45:02 Speaker 01 My thought print?
45:03 Speaker 00 I don't like it.
45:06 Speaker 04 According to Steve, thought prints, like fingerprints-
45:09 Speaker 01 It's like a fingerprint.
45:10 Speaker 00 Okay, alright.
45:11 Speaker 01 Like a butt print. It's different every time, everybody got a different butt.
45:14 Speaker 00 God damn it, Steve, you gotta get out of here.
45:17 Speaker 04 Well, thought prints relate to the potential identification of a specific individual through his or her own unique thinking and thoughts.
45:25 Speaker 01 It's a thought print.
45:26 Speaker 04 Yeah.
45:31 Speaker 04 Well, the thinking behind the posing of Short's body, Steve maintains, is that the killer was a surrealist who wanted to shock the world with the most transgressive work of art in history. This would be a surrealist who took the motifs of bissection, raised arms, and mutilation to the next level by using an actual woman as the canvas.
45:48 Speaker 01 Genius.
45:51 Speaker 01 Absolutely exemplary.
45:52 Speaker 04 And the reason why they call it the "minotaur position," you know, with the arms raised up, is because of a Man Ray photograph called, uh, "Minotaur," uh, which is shows just a woman's torso and her arms raised up above her head, and the shadows make it look like a bull's head. You know, like the, the, the breasts, the nipples of the eyes.
46:11 Speaker 00 Yeah.
46:11 Speaker 04 You know, and the arms are the horns, but that's how it came to be known as the "minotaur position."
46:15 Speaker 00 I gotcha. I just don't think an artist could keep their mouth shut if they did accomplish this.
46:20 Speaker 01 Well, now, the idea is that then they, the show-off of the corpse is their gallery.
46:25 Speaker 00 Oh, but they would like to say that I'm the one? I'm the greatest!
46:30 Speaker 01 He created the Minotaur of Short. Get possible, yes.
46:34 Speaker 04 Well, and that's the thing is that there are other theories that would make that even more difficult. It's been posited in the past that the Black Dahlia murder was the work of more than one person because of the differing ways in which the body was mutilated and manipulated at the crime scene. But the authors of the book Exquisite Corpse take that theory one step further. They submit that a group of people familiar with surrealism may have tried to recreate an exquisite corpse game with the body of this young woman.
46:59 Speaker 01 What's so hard is to be the first one and then you got her there, she's alive and stuff. And you're like, well, if I just put a hat on her, you know, and then other guys like, well, then what do I do? Like, put a sash on her?
47:14 Speaker 01 And next thing you know, honestly, you just become fashion designers and you're just dressing this woman. If she was art, it could have birthed the first murder critic. And that's what we are. That's what we are. You know what? I don't get it.
47:29 Speaker 01 Just a second. Sorry, uninspired.
47:33 Speaker 04 Well, in keeping with the general idea of the exquisite corpse game, multiple people may have taken turns with Elizabeth Short's body, each of them inscribing their signatures on her legs, genitals, torso, breasts, and face.
47:45 Speaker 01 What if I just, again, what if I just wanted to draw on her? We're artists, right? Can I just draw a circle on her or something?
47:51 Speaker 04 Here's a knife. Have fun.
47:52 Speaker 01 I just would wish I could get a marker or something. Can I get a paintbrush?
47:58 Speaker 04 No, knives only.
47:59 Speaker 01 I just, I hate this surrealist thing. I thought this was imagination. The D could be for Tali.
48:05 Speaker 04 It could.
48:05 Speaker 01 Oh shit, he did it with the lobster. It's the lobster did it.
48:09 Speaker 04 Or du con.
48:13 Speaker 01 And all the poop in her from Poop Caso. That doesn't even make sense. I wouldn't allow that. That doesn't make any sense. Poop Caso. If it was piss. I was, I realized that she wasn't filled with piss. Changed it at the last second.
48:27 Speaker 04 Wow, quick thinking.
48:28 Speaker 01 True.
48:33 Speaker 01 You're just sitting here doing pissed shit, man.
48:38 Speaker 01 She's a regular cum brand. Cum brand? No, Rembrandt. It doesn't really matter. No, we're, now we're over. We're gone. We're in the, we're in the Palisades.
48:50 Speaker 04 Well, thus inspired, the authors wrote, "This group would have crafted what they viewed as the most exquisite corpse of all."
48:57 Speaker 01 Yes! Would not be the most devilish shovel!
49:02 Speaker 04 And that's the, kind of, the problem with a lot of these theories, is that they do require cartoonishly villainous characters.
49:08 Speaker 01 Yeah. Well, and I also will put the exquisite corpse book, which I love, and I love all the art history in it, I will put it almost in the true crime, like, overboard world of thinking, they kind of act like they, they're treating these surrealist painters like the West Memphis Three. Just because they were like, hanging out and doing all these like, quote-unquote, like, weird, dirty things, like that they were then criminals. It kind of feels like you're getting mad at people for listening to Marilyn Manson and you think it's gonna cau- it's causing school shootings. Where it's like, no, this is, that, artists are inherently, I love our artists, pussies. Yeah! You're not going to do this. They're cowards! It's just physical, they're not physical. Yeah.
49:50 Speaker 01 They're mental. You know what I mean? This is a mental, spiritual creatures. Like, it's gonna be the big jump. The idea of four of them getting together to do it would be, I think, a bit impossible. Especially if somebody like George Hodel, because unless George Hodel killed all of them. The only way this hold, that theory to me holds, is that George Hodel did the Black Deli, but he also killed everybody involved.
50:12 Speaker 04 Mm-hmm.
50:12 Speaker 01 I just don't think they would stop at one person. I think if it was an art piece, they would kill multiple people. Especially if they didn't get caught and got this much press. Well, look at Leopold and Loeb. Those are guys that were definitely did it for the art of it. They did it for the mental exercise of it.
50:27 Speaker 04 The thrill.
50:27 Speaker 01 Yes.
50:27 Speaker 04 Yeah. So now that we've talked about the surrealist links to the murder, let's return to George Hodel and how he came to be connected to the Black Dahlia. See, while his lawyer did succeed in getting George acquitted by making George's daughter look crazy because of what she'd said about George being the Black Dahlia killer, the plan backfired when the police opened a file to thoroughly investigate George for the murder.
50:48 Speaker 01 Isn't this interesting in the fact that this is how much time has changed? Where back in the day, they actually were offended by the fact that they thought that he fucked his daughter, instead of it like covering for him? Like they were mad, they covered for the other people, but they didn't cover for George Hodel. They went looking for George Hodel, unlike Jeffrey Epstein, when the entire South Florida judicial group all like flipped over backwards to make sure that he was fine.
51:12 Speaker 04 Yeah, no, and not in Los Angeles, not with George Hodel.
51:15 Speaker 01 Not with this one.
51:16 Speaker 04 Yeah. Well, the cops snuck a bug into Hodel's house and tapped his phone. But because George had connections, he was well aware he was being monitored, and therefore engaged in lots of loud sex, erotic poetry readings, and an inordinate amount of toilet flushes to toy with the cops.
51:32 Speaker 01 Another log gone, another log missed. I hope you enjoy this next show I'm about to do for you, Lieutenant. Oh, oh, oh, I'm touching my butthole. I'm touching my butthole, Mr. Homicide Detective. Oh, oh, oh.
51:50 Speaker 00 I'm shitting on a plate and feeding it to my daughter.
51:54 Speaker 00 Shitting on a plate.
51:55 Speaker 01 Come and get me, come and arrest me.
51:59 Speaker 04 Well, Hodel was also aware that his phone was being tapped. And during a conversation with a friend, Hodel said, quote,
52:05 Speaker 01 Supposing I did kill the Black Dahlia? I couldn't prove it now. I can't talk to my secretary anymore because she's dead.
52:15 Speaker 04 Now, a lot of people have used this statement as proof that George Hodel killed Elizabeth Short. But one has to question why Hodel would say something so damning when he knew the police were listening.
52:24 Speaker 01 Because why wouldn't they come and arrest him immediately?
52:26 Speaker 04 Well, most likely, Hodel said it because he knew there was no truth to it. Because Hodel obviously liked playing with people. For example, his secretary died in May of 1945, almost two years before Elizabeth Short. Short was killed. In fact, the secretary died before Elizabeth Short even came to Los Angeles.
52:43 Speaker 01 So the manuscripts that she was asked to burn, whatever that was.
52:47 Speaker 00 It's filled with a bunch of other haunted shit.
52:49 Speaker 01 That's the thing. It's like, that's my main thing with George Hodel is I think he's guilty of plenty of other things that he didn't want people to know about. He physically could not have ran into Elizabeth Short.
52:59 Speaker 00 I think every suspect has killed somebody but Elizabeth.
53:03 Speaker 01 Everybody has done crimes to everybody else but Elizabeth Short. She is still the only person that has not been touched by any one of these people. George Hodel definitely killed the secretary. I think he absolutely is a murderer. I think he's a pedophile and a rapist, but he's not the Black Dahlia murderer.
53:23 Speaker 04 See, when it comes to making George a good suspect, the connections more or less end with all the surrealist stuff. It's very interesting, of course.
53:29 Speaker 01 Oh, yeah.
53:30 Speaker 04 That's why we talked about it. It's fascinating to see all of these parallels.
53:33 Speaker 01 Also, you wonder if it's just because their goal is to go back into the subconscious, right? So they're creating these subconscious works of art, oftentimes because of the material that they were reading too, all the Freudian analysis, all the other stuff.
53:47 Speaker 04 All the marquis de Sade.
53:49 Speaker 01 It was all very sexual and dark. So what they were doing was accessing their imagination to be totally pure. But let's just say maybe they had preconceived ideas of the drawings that they want to make. Humanity, they're trying to do what they, they're trying to do experiments, but you're pulling stuff out that just might be really common. One female surrealist, I forgot her name, she talked about the bisected woman imagery for as a celebration of women. This was like, when she was.
54:15 Speaker 00 She's only painted for China.
54:17 Speaker 01 Yes. But she said that it was a, it was a way for essentially these nerdy, sexless men to understand women. Like, they actually viewed it as a way for, they, they put women on a pedestal in that world. That's kind of why they were torn apart all the times, because they were kind of viewed as sort of like art pieces, which is dehumanize, dehumanize a woman. But it doesn't mean you're killing them.
54:40 Speaker 04 Yeah, that doesn't. As far as George Hodel goes, Steve Hodel maintains that George's handwriting is similar to the letters that the so-called Black Dahlia Avenger sent. But, there's absolutely no evidence connecting Elizabeth Short to George Hodel in any way whatsoever.
54:56 Speaker 01 There isn't any. The handwriting analysis goes back and forth.
54:59 Speaker 04 It really does. No, I mean, like I said, that's something that Steve claims, and you know, there's plenty of arguments to be made against the handwriting analysis.
55:06 Speaker 01 Did you try to read the chapter on the handwriting analysis in Black Dahlia Avenger?
55:09 Speaker 04 Uh, no.
55:10 Speaker 01 It's like forty pages, talking about Ts and Ps and Bs and Hs and Os and Ns.
55:20 Speaker 04 How about Qs?
55:22 Speaker 01 No. Uncommon letter.
55:25 Speaker 04 Not in, I don't think they were in the Black Dahlia Avenger.
55:29 Speaker 01 But it's just this breakdown of like, as you could see with the lilting surface of the, of his second Os, within each one of his words with two Os. You're like, no, I don't, it's a, it's a, it's a goblin cock, I'm gonna fucking jump off a bridge. If I hear one more thing about Ps and Ps, I'm gonna fucking kill myself. I'm gonna walk into the fires.
55:50 Speaker 00 What do they think about lowercase Js? Cause those are very important.
55:55 Speaker 01 A lot of them really tell you how you feel about certain religions. How crooked your Js are.
56:02 Speaker 04 Well, the thing is that two women who knew Hodel, they were convinced that he knew Elizabeth. But, most of the people who knew and worked with George Hodel said that he never met her, and Elizabeth Short never mentioned George Hodel, nor did she mention a George Hodel type to anyone she knew. And the thing is that also the people who knew George Hodel said that there was no way he would have, like, if he would have killed a woman, he would not have displayed her body out for all the world to see and then communicated with the press about it. He would have kept it a secret. Like, George Hodel was a man of secrets.
56:35 Speaker 01 I, in my mind, it's the, if you did that as a George Hodel, why in the ever living fuck it would ever leave that killing floor? Like, I feel like it's one of those things where you would bring people to the killing floor. Your George Hodel was, he always, he did not like- He didn't leave his house. You know what I mean? Like, the parties came to him. Things came to him. So, the fact that he would then go out of his way to portray this, it doesn't fit his character.
57:02 Speaker 00 Yeah, but she was hollowed out. They took the blood out of her. You know, maybe they were trying to make it so it wasn't as stinky. They could have...
57:08 Speaker 01 You're correct. They did. Definitely. It was for transport.
57:11 Speaker 04 Yeah, but the thing that drives the story the furthest from George Hodel is the location of the body. Hodel had no reason to be in Lamert Park. It was a 30-minute drive from his home, and there's no reason why George would dump Elizabeth Short's shoes and purse in a trash can on Crenshaw Boulevard. Hodel also didn't drive a black Ford sedan like the one seen on the morning of the body's discovery, seen by two different people. And most importantly, he was recovering from a heart attack in January of 1947. That heart attack had kept him in the hospital for a month, which meant that he was far too weak to murder Elizabeth Short with such brutality, never mind strong enough to move the body. Basically, Hodel was investigated because he had bribed his way through his incest trial and had skated the charges.
57:52 Speaker 01 And he was probably a pretty well-known creepist.
57:55 Speaker 04 Yes, and I think that George Hodel, he's one of those characters, and I think people like him and Jeffrey Epstein, that they do have their claws in deep to certain people in the government, and certain people out there, like, in administrative positions. But others take one look at him and say, "I'm not going within 10 fucking feet of that guy, and I want to see that fucker in a jail cell."
58:16 Speaker 01 Because they were correct. Because you look at somebody, Jeffrey Epstein, technically, I mean, yes, he was a financial advisor, but the way he really made his money was by being a spy. And then you also wonder with George Hodel if he did something along the same lines.
58:27 Speaker 04 Uh-huh. Well, two members of the DA's office were demoted because they lost George Hodel's incest case. So, it's said that the DA put him on the suspect list for simple revenge.
58:38 Speaker 01 Totally can see it. That makes total sense to me.
58:41 Speaker 04 Let's just make his life hard for a little while.
58:42 Speaker 01 Fuck this piece of shit. He thinks he's bigger than us? He's not bigger than me. We're the gangsters. We're the LAPD. He's not bigger than us. This whole theory, so like, leading from last episode into this episode, this is getting towards the end of the actual, of the time investigation.
58:58 Speaker 04 Yeah.
58:58 Speaker 01 Because as they were going, this is one of the last real suspects. That they hit too. So by the time they got to him, I think they were so angry at being questioned for so long that they were like, "You're not bigger than us. Like, we cover up other crimes, buddy."
59:12 Speaker 04 Yeah.
59:13 Speaker 01 Like, "We cover up, we are, we are, yes, we're the LAPD, yes, we run a racketeering organization, yes, we do human trafficking, but we're not pedophiles." Like, that was the line at the time.
59:23 Speaker 00 Yeah, they're like, "He was an embarrassment to them." And that's kind of the reason why they threw the book at OJ when they finally got him for the trophy thing.
59:30 Speaker 01 They had to, because someone had to, someone had to say something.
59:32 Speaker 04 Yeah, what they call it, the fifth quarter.
59:34 Speaker 01 Yeah.
59:34 Speaker 04 Yeah. Now, Steve Hodel still believes wholeheartedly that his father is the best suspect. Despite his best efforts, though, Steve says that the Black Dahlia case is still unsolved for several reasons. For one, when Elizabeth Short was still alive, she obscured her life to everyone she knew, which makes putting together a clear picture of her a near impossibility. That, that is actually, that's absolutely true, but it's not proof of George Hodel's guilt.
59:58 Speaker 01 No, it just shows how difficult it is to investigate a crime when the killer, like, what we are now in the world of in these theories is that the killer was not remotely connected to Elizabeth Short, did not know Elizabeth Short, was not connected to anybody around Elizabeth Short. There is a, this is somebody outside, this is an outside actor, and it's extremely difficult to catch somebody for a motiveless crime.
1:00:19 Speaker 04 Yeah, especially if they just do it once.
1:00:21 Speaker 01 Yeah, and they do it for sexual thrills.
1:00:22 Speaker 04 Yeah, because that's the reason why most serial killers get caught, is that it's not necessarily because the cops are so damn good at their job. It's that when a serial killer kills another person, and another person, and another person, they get sloppier the longer they go on, and they eventually just make a mistake that's so egregious that, basically, they fall into a cop's lap.
1:00:41 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:00:42 Speaker 04 You know, it just happens again and again.
1:00:43 Speaker 00 Start getting cocky.
1:00:44 Speaker 04 Yeah, they am. Well, second, Steve says that reporters and detectives have bought into various myths about the case, which have clouded their minds to the truth, which is what every single person who covers this case says about every other person's theory that isn't their own.
1:00:58 Speaker 01 Exactly. That's why I am sick of the various myths, and I'm sick of people having their minds clouded, because I know what happened. We talked about it last episode. Her waist just did that. She did this to herself?
1:01:10 Speaker 00 Yeah.
1:01:10 Speaker 01 This is suicide. All of this was simple cool.
1:01:14 Speaker 04 Actually, I did read, and I think, I can't remember which book it was, but when they were at the crime scene, one of the detectives did, uh, step over Elizabeth Short's body and say, "God, these suicides just break me up."
1:01:27 Speaker 01 Jesus Christ, like people are made out of Legos?
1:01:33 Speaker 04 But most importantly, from Steve's perspective, he claims that every detective who worked this case has intentionally sanitized or destroyed information connecting the killing to George Hodel because of Hodel's powerful connections and the possible compromat he may have obtained on those connections during his many orgies.
1:01:49 Speaker 01 It's been like 80 years.
1:01:52 Speaker 04 Mm-hmm.
1:01:52 Speaker 01 Wouldn't that stuff, is it some of that heat died down on some of these?
1:01:56 Speaker 04 It's all been burned away, it's never coming back.
1:01:59 Speaker 01 You know, I've never been to an orgy without a bunch of cops. Well, somebody's gotta, someone's gotta hold the line.
1:02:05 Speaker 04 That is true, that is true.
1:02:06 Speaker 01 Absolutely, with all the ticker tape everywhere and you got all the cars driving through.
1:02:10 Speaker 00 They got the cuffs.
1:02:11 Speaker 04 I mean, all the orgies that I've been to have been pretty chill affairs.
1:02:15 Speaker 01 Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. I've watched a lot of orgies through glass and what I've noticed from watching them, I can see that, yes, humans do need to communicate, don't they?
1:02:26 Speaker 04 Mm-hmm. Orgies are more awkward than anything.
1:02:28 Speaker 01 Yeah, I bet.
1:02:29 Speaker 04 They're very awkward.
1:02:30 Speaker 01 I just know I come in three minutes and I can't imagine the hang. I can't imagine right as soon as I've done blown and I'm just sitting there like, "Well, ew, okay, well, so are we getting food or..."
1:02:41 Speaker 04 And that's the awkward part.
1:02:42 Speaker 01 Yeah, oh, yeah, yeah. "Hop, hop, hop, oh, yeah!" And then, "Well, I guess, I'm, I'm, let me let you, let me let you go."
1:02:51 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:02:52 Speaker 01 Imagine if they were all great conversationalists, they wouldn't have to fuck each other.
1:02:57 Speaker 01 Then it would turn into an improv show.
1:03:08 Speaker 01 You know what I've been putting off? Really getting my feet fixed. Cause I've really, you know, I've been afraid to do it, simply because I'm afraid of the power I unleash having two perfect...
1:03:21 Speaker 01 Sumptuous feet, but you know, there's no right time ever. And investing can feel the same way. The hardest part of investing? Starting, just like taking care of your feet. Acorns gets you past that part under five minutes and lets you start investing with whatever you've got right now. Even your spare change. You got 15 cents? You're in the market, baby. You don't have to have it all figured out just to start and Acorns is here to help. Sign up today at acorns.com/left and Acorns will add a $5 bonus investment to your account. That's acorns.com/left. Acorns.com/left.
1:04:03 Speaker 01 Individual is not a customer of Acorns and was compensated in tier two for providing this endorsement. Compensation provides an incentive for the promoter to positively endorse Acorns. Material may be biased. View important disclosures at acorns.com/influencers. Investing involves risk, including the loss of principal. Please consider your objectives, risk tolerance and Acorns fees before investing. Investment advisory products and services offered by Acorns Advisors LLC. Acorns, an SEC registered investment advisor. Brokerage products and services are provided by Acorns Securities LLC, an SEC registered broker dealer, member FINRA/SIPC. For more information, visit acorns.com.
1:04:48 Speaker 01 Acorns.
1:04:54 Speaker 01 This episode is sponsored by BetterHelp. If there was one thing I could permanently delete from my mind, it would be the sight of a famous Canadian body horror movie director and his backside. And I saw that accidentally in a room. In Toronto, is that vague enough or no? BetterHelp therapists, they can help you clear some of those thoughts that you're having that are taking up way too much mental space. And with insurance, many members pay $15 or less, some pay $0. And yeah, you might not have seen one of the best directors of a generation who obviously dips into drama, body horror, sci-fi, and novel adaptations.
1:05:38 Speaker 01 All right, you may not have seen the undercarriage of this old man, sure. But I'm certain there's many things that you wish the therapist could just delete. And that's why you're in good hands. BetterHelp therapists are fully licensed in the US with at least three years and 1,000 hours of hands-on experience. And when it comes to matching with therapists, BetterHelp does the initial work for you. Just take a short questionnaire to help identify your needs. Not happy with your match? Switch to a different therapist at any time for BetterHelp's tailored recommendations. BetterHelp is now a network with more than 125 health plans with many copays as low as $15 for eligible members. And if you don't have eligible insurance or live outside the US, you can still get 10% off your first month. Sign up and get 10% off at betterhelp.com/lastpod. That's better H E L P dot com slash last pod.
1:06:27 Speaker 01 Everybody hates bank fees, right? Well, that's where Chime comes in. They're not like traditional old banks who charge fees and gatekeep perks. Chime offers the most rewarding fee-free banking, all with no overdraft fees, no monthly fees, and no minimum balance fees. You get 5% cash back on Chime card in a category of choice like gas or groceries, all while building credit through everyday spending. Plus, you can grow your money faster with a savings rate that's nine times the national average. And SpotMe lets you overdraft up to $200 fee-free. Join the millions who are already banking fee-free with America's number one choice for banking. Head to chime.com/left. That is chime.com/left.
1:07:11 Speaker 01 Sign up now, it only takes a few minutes. Chime is a fintech, not a bank. Banking services and Chime card are provided by Chime's bank partners. Qualifying direct deposits
1:07:21 Speaker 04 Well, Steve also claims that a string of dozens of unsolved Los Angeles kidnappings and murders suddenly stopped in 1958 when George Hodel moved to the Philippines, which is where he died sometime after. In fact, Steve lays dozens of murders at his father's feet, making George Hodel one of the most prolific serial murders of his day.
1:07:46 Speaker 01 Well, this is the issue. That issue is what he lays on George Hodel after the fact. It'd be different. I honestly think it would be different if he just, he killed a black Dahlia and that was like it. Like if it was just that and he wrote the one book, I'd actually be way more like willing to believe the theory. But then it's like eight books later, now it's like, he blew up the Hindenburg, he's the Zodiac Killer, he's the fucking zebra killer, he shot Abraham Lincoln. Like, every single crime that was around, he just applied to his father.
1:08:18 Speaker 00 How little was he around his own dad?
1:08:21 Speaker 01 Very little. That is true.
1:08:22 Speaker 04 Yeah, yeah, very, very little. But in the end, as much as I admire Steve Hodel's enthusiasm, I agree with the many people who say that there's just not enough evidence to make George Hodel the one who killed, mutilated, and posed Elizabeth Short. As far as the surrealism angle goes, though, I'm not going to say that a surrealist artist murdered Elizabeth Short for an art piece. But it is possible that surrealist art, however unconsciously, may have influenced the killer as opposed to being a straight up inspiration.
1:08:49 Speaker 01 Well, yeah, because we know it was mainstream.
1:08:51 Speaker 04 Yeah, well, I mean, by the year Elizabeth Short was murdered, it wasn't necessarily mainstream in America, like, but it was still pretty popular.
1:08:57 Speaker 01 They were using it in like commercials, it was on, it was in like magazines, it was very fashionable.
1:09:02 Speaker 04 It's around.
1:09:03 Speaker 00 It's mainstream like amongst artists, probably.
1:09:05 Speaker 04 Oh, very much so.
1:09:06 Speaker 01 But they were using it in commercials. Like Salvador Dali was on television.
1:09:09 Speaker 00 Yeah, yeah, yeah.
1:09:10 Speaker 04 I mean, it had certainly stabbed its way into the collective unconscious of the country. And it is possible that whoever killed Elizabeth Short may have either seen some surrealist artwork, or may have accidentally tapped into surrealist imagery during the murder and the posing of the body. Because the similarities between the crime scene and the dozens of surreal art pieces is just too crazy to ignore.
1:09:29 Speaker 01 But there's also, there is, which we're going to get into now, there is a practical stuff. There is practical things that could have happened.
1:09:37 Speaker 04 Mate, well, as far as the bisecting of the body goes, yes. But as far as the posing goes and the very specific way in which everything was left.
1:09:45 Speaker 01 Unless you flop a bag down with a body in it and you drag it out by the arms. You leave it one side, you grab out, you have that bag, you put it back in the car. You get the other half of the body, come back out, drag it out, flop it there. You're running, you're not even thinking about it. You just dragged it and you've left it, arms open like a wheelbarrow.
1:10:02 Speaker 04 Maybe. Were there like footprints around and stuff?
1:10:05 Speaker 01 No, they all got destroyed by the reporters and the police.
1:10:07 Speaker 04 There was one footprint.
1:10:08 Speaker 01 Yeah, there was that one footprint.
1:10:09 Speaker 04 There was one footprint, but it didn't match anything that they ever found. Well, FBI serial killer criminologist John Douglas does not think that the Black Dahlia Killer is an art lover, nor does he think that our main suspect Leslie Dillon is the culprit. And this brings us to the next section of our episode, the profile.
1:10:26 Speaker 01 We're gonna nail it down. We're getting them.
1:10:29 Speaker 04 Now, I know some people have problems with John Douglas, but while he can be hit or miss, you have to admit that he does sometimes nail it. So his opinion on who might have killed Elizabeth Short at least warrants a listen. John Douglas is the guy that mind, like he wrote Mindhunter and the TV show was, you know, based on him and so on and so forth. Well, I want to hear what he has to say.
1:10:48 Speaker 01 Here's the thing, he created modern profiling. And so anything that you could say, yes, I don't think he's 100% on the money. But if there's one person that knows and then has researched the criminal mind for 10,000 hours, it is John Douglas.
1:11:01 Speaker 04 So in his profile of the Black Dahlia Killer, John Douglas surmises that the man who murdered Elizabeth Short was white and in his late twenties, possibly older, but possessing no more than a high school education. Racist. This man lived alone and worked with his hands instead of his brains, possibly as a butcher, slaughterhouse worker, or some other profession where buckets of blood was the norm. At the very least, this man might have been a hunter who knew how to field dress a deer. The killer, Douglas continued, was compulsive, patient, rigid, and deliberate in everything he did. And when he drank, he was likely to become even more of a difficult person. Because of this, the killer probably had a record for either threatening or assaulting someone with a knife.
1:11:43 Speaker 04 Lastly, the killer probably frequented sex workers and was under a A lot of financial and personal stress in the time leading up to the murder. As far as how the murder went down, Douglas painted a picture in which the killer and Elizabeth Short spent several days together. Days that the killer would have spent drinking. At one point, Elizabeth may have rejected his advances or mocked him for some physical or mental disability. And when that conflict met the underlying stress and the alcohol, the killer snapped and took out all his rage on Elizabeth. As far as Cottner and Aff went, that was just to make the transport of the body a little easier.
1:12:18 Speaker 01 Yes.
1:12:18 Speaker 00 Which is where we land on almost everybody.
1:12:21 Speaker 01 Pretty much. For the most part, some people still, like, because this is where he's...
1:12:24 Speaker 00 Except for the surrealists.
1:12:24 Speaker 04 Yeah, if you're in the hotel camp, then her body was cut in half deliberately is a part of the art piece.
1:12:30 Speaker 00 Yeah.
1:12:31 Speaker 04 But for Douglas and those who subscribe to his profile, the location where Elizabeth's body was found is the single most important clue.
1:12:38 Speaker 01 This is, I believe this. This is what I, this is my big thing.
1:12:41 Speaker 00 Okay.
1:12:41 Speaker 04 Douglas suggests that the killer, quote, "wanted to put the fear of God into the neighborhood in Lament Park for personal reasons."
1:12:49 Speaker 01 And part of the reason why I agree with this is the old timey pictures. If you go back and look at the Black Dahlia crime scene, one thing that's particularly very interesting about the field is how, literally, how flat it is. They said that from that street, on a clear day during that time period, 1947, you could see the Hollywood sign. And so this thing was flat. This is flat, flat, flat. It's a canvas. It's literal. And the way it was placed was so obvious. It was so, it was obviously what we've been talking about forever. It was meant to be seen. Whoever did this wanted people to see it. And it's who's gonna see it? Yes, the world, but first, Lament Park.
1:13:32 Speaker 04 Uh huh. As far as personal reasons go, the killer may have been working a construction job in the area that was put on hold. Or he could have had an emotional connection that was severed, like I say, he played sports in a field that was bulldozed for new housing developments. He'd be mad at the neighborhood. It's like, basically, this guy is, who's mad at the neighborhood?
1:13:50 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:13:51 Speaker 04 Or mad at somebody in the neighborhood.
1:13:53 Speaker 01 Yeah, the T-ball coach. He did it.
1:13:56 Speaker 00 Seems like they were mad at Elizabeth Short.
1:13:58 Speaker 04 Yeah, also mad at Elizabeth Short, but mad at the neighborhood as well.
1:14:02 Speaker 00 Yeah.
1:14:02 Speaker 04 But no matter what it was, the killer almost certainly had a personal connection to Lamert Park, or specifically, that street, or that block. Additionally, Douglas thinks that the killer's behavior after the body was found would stand out, because he would have been anxious about leaving behind evidence, or about someone seeing him dump the body. His neighbors may have noticed him cleaning his car or his home in a panic. They may have seen him ravenously consuming every piece of media about the murder. He would also have been heard ranting about how ineffective the police were in their investigation, and about how Lamert Park used to be a safe neighborhood.
1:14:34 Speaker 01 You see this time and time again, serial killers, more often than not, they're cop groupies. They like to go and they like to hang out, they go to where the crime happened again and again and again. They go and they talk to police that are actively investigating the crime, because they're obsessed with their own crime, and half of them fancy themselves a police officer.
1:14:51 Speaker 04 Yeah, and they also like to hear the cops describe the crime back to them, and they're also trying to see how much information the cops have, and if it's possibly running towards them.
1:14:59 Speaker 01 Yes.
1:15:00 Speaker 04 But, this guy's need to consume information may have inspired him to create his own news stories, which is why he mailed Short's belongings to a newspaper instead of the police, and why he communicated with them for a short time afterward.
1:15:13 Speaker 01 Because we still believe that the person who sent the Mark Hanson book, and all of her personal effects, if isn't the killer, knows the killer.
1:15:24 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:15:24 Speaker 01 And has access to the killer.
1:15:25 Speaker 00 Or just found the shit.
1:15:26 Speaker 04 That's the other, that's the other possibility, is that he may have just found it in a trash can and decided to have fun. You know, you just, you really have no fucking idea.
1:15:34 Speaker 01 No.
1:15:35 Speaker 04 And as far as why there were no more killings in the same style as the Black Doll You Murder, Douglas thinks that the killer removed himself from society by either engaging in a concentrated campaign of self-destruction, or by committing himself to a mental institution. It's also possible, Douglas thinks, that the killer just drifted away into the darkness after it became apparent that the police were never gonna come close to linking him to the murder of Elizabeth Short. Now, one of the people who thinks that there's very much something to John Douglas's profile is a former Los Angeles Times reporter named Larry Harnish. We're finally here to Larry Harnish.
1:16:10 Speaker 01 I want to tell you, Larry, you got a good sense of humor already. And listen, we're here.
1:16:15 Speaker 04 We're here.
1:16:16 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:16:16 Speaker 04 We're here, we're helping. We're around, yeah. And that brings us to the third section of this episode, the actual good suspect. Now, author Larry Harnish disputes almost every fact about the Black Dahlia case that's been put forth and says that he has the proof to back up most of his debunks.
1:16:31 Speaker 01 Yes.
1:16:32 Speaker 04 If not all, but he's waiting to release this information until he finds a publisher for his Black Dahlia book, which is totally understandable. So, while that, I'm saving it for the book argument that might sound a little cagey.
1:16:43 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:16:43 Speaker 04 I'll say that the theory Larry Harnish puts forth as far as who he thinks killed Elizabeth Short is highly compelling. I, for one, would absolutely read his book once it gets to a publisher. Because it does seem like Larry might have the goods to blow the lid off this whole fucking thing.
1:16:58 Speaker 01 He's got two things that I like. Number one is I love his attitude, right? He's at, he says that Black Dahlia changed his life. He doesn't like true crime.
1:17:06 Speaker 04 Hates it.
1:17:07 Speaker 01 He hates the rest of true crime, but he says that his job is to take, he's trying to take the story, right? He's trying to flesh it out fully. Number two-
1:17:13 Speaker 04 I kind of love a guy who hates the genre he's in, though.
1:17:15 Speaker 01 Yeah, me too.
1:17:16 Speaker 04 I kind of like that. I kind of like that.
1:17:18 Speaker 01 Always. It's like, I didn't expect to be a podcaster.
1:17:21 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:17:21 Speaker 01 You know what I mean? And then, number two is like, he says, so yes, all this, he has all this proof that we're waiting to hear on. But I, I do think that it's in there because I know that he does have access to files that are no longer available.
1:17:33 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:17:34 Speaker 01 And he talks about them all the time. And he also said the only actual dependable information that you could tell about the Black Dahlia is from the original newspaper clippings.
1:17:44 Speaker 04 Of course, that makes a lot of sense. And also, it's not like the killer's out there killing people, you know? It's like the information isn't- hurting the world if he keeps it secret for now for his own good. So good on you, Larry.
1:17:55 Speaker 01 We just want to find out what the exact details of how he debunks everything. That's what I want to know.
1:17:59 Speaker 04 Publish the butt. Now, as far as how Harnish got into the Black Dahlia scene, he was a copy editor for the Los Angeles Times, who got an assignment to write a 50th anniversary story about the Black Dahlia murder in 1997. And he soon became obsessed, like so many others, before and after.
1:18:15 Speaker 01 I literally don't know what I'm gonna do after the series. I've been consuming nothing but Black Dahlia information for about a month. It's got you to stop talking about drones, which is wild. It's the only other thing I can talk about.
1:18:26 Speaker 04 Yeah. Well, so far Larry Harnish has interviewed 150 people, including people who knew Elizabeth Short personally and members of the Short family.
1:18:34 Speaker 01 He got everybody.
1:18:35 Speaker 04 Yeah. As such, Harnish obviously feels quite close to the story and wants to reclaim Elizabeth Short from what he calls the Dahlia freaks.
1:18:43 Speaker 01 That's me. I'm a Dahlia frick. You better come and punish me, Larry. Oh, you got a problem, Larry? Why don't you come down and give old Henry a spanking? Because I need some discipline. I'm just a dirty old stinky Dahlia freak.
1:19:00 Speaker 01 Side stories, LPOTL. I want to reach out, Larry. Well, he also, I remember, you know why I liked him the fir- one of the first things I liked him is I watched one of his October AMAs and the first thing he said, he's like, "I don't want to see a single Black Dahlia costume on Instagram."
1:19:13 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:19:14 Speaker 01 He was like, "I don't want to see one. It gets me angry."
1:19:16 Speaker 04 Yeah, that's intense.
1:19:18 Speaker 01 Yeah, oh yeah.
1:19:18 Speaker 04 Now, when Harnish started looking into the story, he was focused on Lamert Park because he, like John Douglas, believed that the location of the body was the most important clue. But after looking into the history of the neighborhood from every possible angle, the most interesting thing about it was that a famous mobster lived just a few hundred feet from where Elizabeth Short's body was found. And, but that was more or less common knowledge by that point. But in August of 1997, a filmmaker sent Harnish a box of materials related to the case. And amongst the paperwork was a wedding certificate for Elizabeth Short's older sister. When the witness listed for the wedding, her address was 2959 South Norton Avenue, which was exactly one block. From where Elizabeth Short's body was found.
1:20:03 Speaker 01 And he said, which I do agree, he was like, this seems to be a key, like this is a big key to this case that we have not seen yet, which is what puts Elizabeth Short anywhere near Lamont Park? Like what puts her there directly?
1:20:20 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:20:20 Speaker 01 And having her older sister be connected to somebody that lives in the very block where she was put is so suspicious.
1:20:27 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:20:27 Speaker 01 I don't know what to say.
1:20:28 Speaker 04 I mean, it's fucking, it's huge and it's completely verifiable. Like this is something there, there is no rumor here. There's no he said, she said, this is paperwork. There's a paper trail.
1:20:37 Speaker 01 Yeah. And the witness of a wedding is obviously someone who's incredibly close to the family. Well, they said it was technically, they said it was whoever they could get, but it was a neighbor. It was somebody that they knew. So it was.
1:20:47 Speaker 04 Someone from, it was actually, they went to their church. They went to church together.
1:20:49 Speaker 01 Yeah, from Presbyterian people.
1:20:51 Speaker 04 Yeah. Well, as it turned out, this witness was the daughter of a prominent Los Angeles surgeon named Walter Bailey, a surgeon who was well capable of bisecting a body.
1:21:02 Speaker 01 Yeah. Yeah. Cause they own the house that the witness lived in. So first thing he's like, all right, who lives at this house? So he found it, it belonged to Walter Bailey and he was a surgeon.
1:21:12 Speaker 04 Hmm. Now that alone doesn't make Walter Bailey a suspect, but when Harnish began looking more into Bailey's story, he found a heretofore undiscovered web of scandal and controversy, which all pointed towards Bailey being the guilty party here. See Bailey was a respected Los Angeles surgeon in the 1930s up until the early 40s. And he had a private practice just five blocks from the Biltmore Hotel. That's like I said, like the, the little pieces just kind of fill in like bit by bit by bit.
1:21:44 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:21:44 Speaker 04 And if you, cause you, if you'll remember, the Biltmore was the last place that Elizabeth was seen alive. But by 1946, Walter Bailey had fallen on relatively hard times. Having lost much of his status as a surgeon because he was suffering from early onset Alzheimer's disease and his personality was changing as a result.
1:22:00 Speaker 01 I'll kill. I mean, I'll have breakfast.
1:22:06 Speaker 01 Are you my son no good?
1:22:09 Speaker 04 Bailey was therefore, he was under a lot of emotional and financial pressure. That ticks off a big box on John Douglas's profile. Even more stressful though was Bailey's personal life. During the time of the Black Dahlia murder, Bailey was in the process of separating from his wife because he'd been having an affair with a fellow doctor.
1:22:28 Speaker 01 Dude, this lady.
1:22:30 Speaker 04 This doctor had immigrated from Austria during World War II and had become a partner in Bailey's medical practice. Now, multiple people said that Walter Bailey had become a totally different person in the last years of his life. He actually died not too long after Elizabeth Short was killed, like a little under a year, right?
1:22:47 Speaker 01 Yes.
1:22:47 Speaker 04 Yeah, and his death certificate listed a condition called encephalomalacia, which might explain quite a bit here. This condition, encephalomalacia, effectively shrinks the brain and causes mental impairments that can lead to atypical violence.
1:23:03 Speaker 01 Dude, that's what the wife was saying, that he had changed into somebody else. That when she was dealing with him, all of a sudden, he was, he'd slipped into this early onset dementia and it made him extremely mean. And then, have you seen the pictures of Alexandra Parteica?
1:23:20 Speaker 04 Uh-uh.
1:23:20 Speaker 01 Dr. Parteica, his mistress.
1:23:22 Speaker 04 Let's not get too many names in here.
1:23:23 Speaker 01 I love, I love her.
1:23:25 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:23:25 Speaker 00 Okay, oh, the Austrian doctor?
1:23:27 Speaker 01 Yeah, yeah, hers, the lady.
1:23:29 Speaker 00 Do you think she was a Nazi doctor?
1:23:30 Speaker 04 No, she was fleeing the Nazis.
1:23:31 Speaker 00 Oh, okay.
1:23:32 Speaker 01 Yeah, she was, she looked evil. She had an evil face.
1:23:35 Speaker 04 Mm-hmm.
1:23:36 Speaker 01 Continue.
1:23:37 Speaker 04 Well, Harnish also spoke to a professor of neurobiology, who said that Bailey may have suffered a series of dementia-related mini-strokes that could have resulted in lower impulse control when it came to violent and/or sexual urges, but would not have greatly affected his ability to be an effective surgeon. But most interesting is what went down with Walter Bailey's lover. See, Bailey changed his will in December of 1947, almost a year after Elizabeth Short was murdered and just before he himself expired.
1:24:05 Speaker 00 Well, he had to take her out of the will because she was dead.
1:24:07 Speaker 01 That's the thing. That's the thing.
1:24:10 Speaker 04 Well, in the change, Bailey disinherited his wife and his adopted children, leaving half of his estate to his siblings and the other half to his Austrian lover. Who may or may not have been controlling Walter when his mental faculties faltered.
1:24:24 Speaker 01 That's their saying that maybe he pulls Elizabeth Short in there. They're playing these weird games with his new hot Austrian evil wife. Right girlfriend, whatever.
1:24:34 Speaker 00 Yeah, this is how you do a C-section.
1:24:36 Speaker 01 This is how, yeah, you want to see what happens?
1:24:38 Speaker 04 That's not what Larry Harnish says.
1:24:39 Speaker 01 Come on now, let's get all in. No, there's an entire, there's, talk about every, every direction. There's a whole other Dr. Alexandra Parteica. Fucking rabbit hole to go down.
1:24:52 Speaker 04 But Walter hadn't yet divorced his wife when he made this change to his will. So his wife started a lawsuit for her share of Walter's estate. Claiming that Walter's lover was blackmailing him with a secret that would destroy his life. A secret that would be exposed if he ever went back to his family. This isn't, these are court filings. This is, and this was, and this court case was covered in the newspaper. Like it was a fairly big deal. It was a minor story. Actually in Los Angeles at the time, but multiple newspaper stories about this lawsuit.
1:25:23 Speaker 00 Yeah, and Austrians love secrets.
1:25:25 Speaker 01 They do.
1:25:27 Speaker 04 We know that. We've proved that for a fact.
1:25:29 Speaker 00 Very much so. And little cubby holes.
1:25:32 Speaker 04 Well, but this whole secret keeping mechanism was why Walter cut her and the kids out of his will. Now, you can go to Larry Harnish's website, LM Harnish, that's H A R N I S C H dot com.
1:25:46 Speaker 01 Oh, yeah.
1:25:47 Speaker 04 Yeah, put in the code grumpy for 20% off.
1:25:52 Speaker 04 To read his theory as to how the murder might have gone down and why Elizabeth Short may have called Walter Bailey from the Biltmore Hotel on January 9th, 1947.
1:26:01 Speaker 00 In fact, you could rent a room at his place. You could stay there and he'll just talk at you all night long. It's called layer B and B.
1:26:09 Speaker 01 The key though is don't even bring up George Hodel because you will be on the street.
1:26:15 Speaker 04 Yeah. But the most important thing leaking Bailey to Elizabeth Short is the body's location.
1:26:20 Speaker 01 This is, and I just can't. It's the, how do you put it? It's the only evidence. It's the only actual evidence that actually points towards an actual suspect. It is the, in terms of that we know something about what puts her in that field.
1:26:37 Speaker 04 So there's one, there's one investigative direction.
1:26:40 Speaker 01 Yes, that is the only one we've found.
1:26:42 Speaker 04 Well, going off Douglas's theory that the killer had an emotional connection to the neighborhood, Walter Bailey's wife was living at the house in La Mer Park at the time. And it's assumed that Bailey left the body just a block from his wife so he could frighten her and put the fear of God into the neighborhood, as John Douglas put it.
1:26:59 Speaker 01 And that would fit the profile.
1:27:01 Speaker 00 Yeah.
1:27:02 Speaker 04 Now Larry does hold back on quite a few details that I would love to hear explained further. And I, I truly do believe that he has the goods to back up his claims.
1:27:10 Speaker 01 You know why I do believe the goods that he has? Because of how much I've listened to him. And I've listened to him for hours and hours and hours and hours. And the, his AMAs, people are just asking random ass questions. And he, he's got an answer. He says, I know. I like when he says, I don't know. Cause he doesn't know. I, I see him saying, I don't know. He's not just making up answers. And he's also like, he has an answer for everything. He says, it's all in the book. And I was like, I just want to read the Goddamn book.
1:27:35 Speaker 00 Yeah. You want to scare your ex-wife though, you don't kill another woman.
1:27:42 Speaker 04 That is the.
1:27:43 Speaker 01 True, no, it's flimsy. It is as flimsy as the rest of it.
1:27:46 Speaker 04 Yeah, I don't like, that's the thing is that like, it is a connection. It's just the motivation is a little like, I don't know. It's a little wonky, yeah. Like the, the motivation.
1:27:55 Speaker 01 Throw a brick through her window. Well, this is the thing, you're always talking. That's honestly Eddie, great advice.
1:28:00 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:28:02 Speaker 01 If you have an ex-wife, great advice. Don't kill a woman and leave it in her neighborhood. Just break her windows to scare her a little bit. Yeah, I think that this is, it's different. But the, uh, this is the problem, right? Is that there is, this is the best one and it's still not particularly great.
1:28:18 Speaker 00 I'm still on Leslie Dillon and Mark Hanson.
1:28:21 Speaker 01 Sure.
1:28:21 Speaker 04 So, and so am I. And I mean, that's the, I, I really, I want to hear Larry Harness's explanation as to why like Walter Bailey would send all the shit to the newspaper, even if he was in a debilitated mental state. It doesn't make a lot of sense.
1:28:33 Speaker 00 Could have been another person threatening him.
1:28:35 Speaker 04 Or it could, yes, it could be.
1:28:37 Speaker 01 Yes, it could also be he's.
1:28:39 Speaker 04 But who is the soft voiced man? Like, you know, who called like before sending the shit?
1:28:44 Speaker 00 There were so many people claiming shit, you know, left and right.
1:28:46 Speaker 04 But the soft voiced man called and said that he was gonna send shit before he sent the shit.
1:28:50 Speaker 01 Well, it could still, unless, what we were saying before, that he just knew who did it versus did it.
1:28:57 Speaker 04 Or he may have just found the shit and decided to play his own game. That's also possible.
1:29:01 Speaker 01 Larry Harnish, which I do sort of agree with. I do think a lot of this has to do with that he was a high-profile case and a lot of people are trying to get in on it. So there was like, people were playing games. He thinks that the Black Dahlia Avenger was a prankster, which I do, I think that goes, I think that might go too far. I don't know.
1:29:15 Speaker 00 It's a hell of a prank!
1:29:16 Speaker 01 It is. It's the truth, it is.
1:29:18 Speaker 00 Yeah, yeah, yeah. See Ashton Kutcher pulling this shit off.
1:29:21 Speaker 01 No, no, no. The only prank that Ashton Kutcher could pull off was convincing us all that he's a normal human being.
1:29:29 Speaker 04 But as far as why Harnish couldn't get his book published, he thinks that it's because Steve Hodel blew up the Dahlia investigation with his book, Black Dahlia Avenger. Not surprisingly, Harnish does not think much of Hodel and his theories, but the two of them do agree that Leslie Dillon was not the man who killed Elizabeth Short.
1:29:45 Speaker 01 Larry, I'm not trying to be angry with you. It's the fact that the story, the George Hodel story is great for TV. It's great for TV, it's great for movies, it's the funnest storyline, it's the one with the most fun characters, it's got the most LA history that everybody likes to hear about. There was an entire television show that was made about this, the entire fabrication of the George Hodel story that even blew that further, even exaggerated it further. So that's why they like the George Hodel story, Larry. I think you're more correct, but the other one's more fun.
1:30:13 Speaker 04 Yeah. Well, concerning the Leslie Dillon story, Harnish says that author Pugh Eatwell cherry picked information to make Dillon look like the only possible killer. Harnish believes that Dillon was absolutely in San Francisco at the time of the murder, and if, and he said if Eatwell had talked to him for five minutes, he would have told her so.
1:30:30 Speaker 01 No, Larry, we're answering your calls, okay?
1:30:32 Speaker 00 Yeah, yeah, yeah.
1:30:33 Speaker 01 You're here, we're on the show, we're talking with you about it, man, all right? It's not like these other people won't.
1:30:38 Speaker 04 Yeah, Harnish actually doesn't like any of the Black Dahlia books out there, and he has something to say about every single one. Severed by John Gilmore, 25% mistakes and 50% fiction.
1:30:48 Speaker 00 Boom, done, got you!
1:30:50 Speaker 04 Black Dahlia Avenger, fabricated crap.
1:30:52 Speaker 00 Roasted!
1:30:55 Speaker 04 Black Dahlia Files, painfully stupid.
1:30:58 Speaker 00 Coming for him!
1:31:00 Speaker 01 Larry, can I just ask honestly, you didn't do this, right? As a toddler?
1:31:06 Speaker 01 Did you do this as a toddler?
1:31:08 Speaker 04 Yeah, and personally, I still think Leslie Dillon is a pretty good suspect despite the problems. Uh, and I, I guess maybe I should say that like Mark Hanson is still a really good suspect as far as being involved goes. But you know, I'd love to be proved wrong if there's a more likely story out there, if I could hear all this fucking debunk evidence that Larry Harnish has.
1:31:27 Speaker 01 I want it, but I, I wonder, like, the, the main explanation would be if it is somebody, if it is Walter Bailey, even just in the line of Walter Bailey, right? Somebody that he has all the, he could have been in the neighborhood. All he had to do was take the Black Dahlia, like see Elizabeth Short on the street. Let's say he is now at the top of his fugue, he picks her up for the quote-unquote "missing week", she is dead in a, in this man's house, like for that week. And then eventually is put outside, like she's either refrigerated, or there's something else that happens within it.
1:32:01 Speaker 00 But can't they tell?
1:32:02 Speaker 01 I don't know, I don't know.
1:32:04 Speaker 00 If someone's been dead for a while?
1:32:04 Speaker 01 I don't think, I don't know if they could in 1947.
1:32:06 Speaker 04 I think they would have been able to tell, like.
1:32:08 Speaker 01 If it was frozen, it'd be different, but if it was a, she must have been somewhat.
1:32:13 Speaker 00 Her skin would start curling up or some shit.
1:32:15 Speaker 04 Yeah, if, if the, if the dead body, if the body was dead for that long.
1:32:19 Speaker 01 Like a Hanes, like a Hanes neck.
1:32:20 Speaker 04 He's totally right.
1:32:23 Speaker 00 No more bacon. Leaving the body.
1:32:24 Speaker 01 No more bacon's in your Black Dahlia.
1:32:28 Speaker 04 No, I, no, her body definitely would have, if it would have been, if they, the most likely thing is, um, quite possibly, like if we're talking about Walter Bailey here, that, you know, she was going through her address book, he, she just was there for hours trying to call anybody. And then just Walter Bailey was like a name. Maybe she had the address of his office written down, which was five blocks from where she was sitting at that moment. So she may have called him up and said like, "Hey, can, think you can help me out?"
1:32:54 Speaker 01 Oh, sure.
1:32:55 Speaker 04 "Think you, think maybe you can do something for me?" And then, you know, they start hanging out, uh, they hang out somewhere for days, because that's the thing is that.
1:33:02 Speaker 01 Or does he need all of this unless he just sees her, says, "I'll give you a ride"? That's all you gotta do. He's, she's now in his car. Like if she's just five blocks from him, I'm just saying a motiveless, what we're talking about is a motiveless murder. And that is the hardest part, is that that's, that is what we're looking for in all of this chaos, is the whys. Everyone wants to know why. We don't even know how, we don't know where, like.
1:33:26 Speaker 04 Yeah, there's still, and there's, the connection between, you know, Bailey and Elizabeth Short is that, you know, like Bailey went to his sister, her sister's church. So like, you know, he's a well-respected surgeon, so it's, you know, quite possible that Elizabeth Short did know Walter Bailey.
1:33:40 Speaker 01 Or knew, or had, or friends of friends of friends knew.
1:33:43 Speaker 04 Or at the very least had his address, you know, maybe his net, maybe his, I don't know, maybe his number.
1:33:48 Speaker 01 But Larry Hardness is also the one that showed that it's the hardest people to get the information from are the people that actually knew what was happening.
1:33:54 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:33:54 Speaker 01 Is that the people that would have answered these, a lot of these questions didn't want to. The family were very closely guarded, and he said, you just noticed that anybody whose life was actually affected by this crime doesn't want to have anything to do with it. But everybody and their mother can't wait to jump in on this story because of just how juicy it is.
1:34:12 Speaker 04 Now, in the end, the thing that makes all this so difficult to piece together is the mystery of Elizabeth Short herself. She lied about her life to just about everyone she spoke to, telling people that she was an actress, or a waitress, or a war widow, or a grieving mother, or the grieving mother of a dead child, none of which was true. But because we know so little about the facts of Elizabeth herself, it's difficult to put together a narrative. And it's especially frustrating by the fact that living memory in this case is just out of the reach of present day. The youngest people involved in this now, I think, are in their 80s or 90s, and that's like the paper boy.
1:34:46 Speaker 01 Oh, man, I'm getting, I don't know, just hopefully that they are really doing well with the congressional hearings coming up, and it's so important for 80-year-olds to have something to do.
1:34:54 Speaker 04 Mm-hmm. Well, that's why the Black Dahlia murder drives people crazy, why every person who has a pet theory thinks that everyone else is an idiot.
1:35:01 Speaker 01 Everybody else is an idiot!
1:35:02 Speaker 04 Fucking dumb dumb.
1:35:03 Speaker 01 People stupid, I know what's up!
1:35:05 Speaker 04 Yeah, and why no one can seem to agree on even some of the most basic facts of the case. But if there's a single thing that everyone can agree on, it's that the history of the Black Dahlia herself will forever remain the most elusive mystery of all. And that lost history really is the only thing that could ever put together all the pieces that would give us a clear picture of just who killed Elizabeth Short.
1:35:30 Speaker 01 So saying the person that most obfuscated the person who killed Elizabeth Short.
1:35:36 Speaker 01 Was her, her himself.
1:35:37 Speaker 04 Yes.
1:35:38 Speaker 01 Well.
1:35:38 Speaker 04 Well, the person who obfuscated the story the most.
1:35:41 Speaker 01 She did.
1:35:41 Speaker 04 Was was herself.
1:35:42 Speaker 01 God help us.
1:35:43 Speaker 04 Because just we can never put together because all of the stories that she told to everybody else. Like you just can't, you have this entire group, like you just have, it's trying to solve a murder based on a novel. About like a novelization of someone's life, you know, like it doesn't, you can't really, you don't know what's true, what's not. So you can't really follow any sort of investigative lines. Uh, and you can't really make it anywhere because Elizabeth herself was not truthful to even her mother, even well, yeah, of course. Not even her mother.
1:36:12 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:36:12 Speaker 04 How many of us, are you truthful to your mother, Henry?
1:36:15 Speaker 01 I tell her how many times I masturbate every week.
1:36:19 Speaker 04 But her sisters, her friends, you know, like everybody, she told a different story to everybody she knew. And it just made it a complete mystery.
1:36:25 Speaker 01 I'm hearing you, Marcus. We're doing a fifth episode. No. Yeah, no, I'm hearing you, buddy.
1:36:30 Speaker 04 Nah, I'm done.
1:36:31 Speaker 01 I'm hearing it. No, we're, we're about to head into some rough waters.
1:36:37 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:36:38 Speaker 01 For this next series. Very excited. Um, we are extremely sorry that we are not in Atlanta.
1:36:44 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:36:45 Speaker 01 We are currently, uh, we are working because we are broken. But we're here in Los Angeles in the center of three different fires. We're not going anywhere. So we're a couple of them were small. We got a little baby ones. We got some big ones. We got some baby ones.
1:36:59 Speaker 04 They got the sunset one under control. I think it's back to three.
1:37:02 Speaker 01 Ah, good. I just want to say, uh, thank you guys for people reaching out, asking us if we're okay.
1:37:07 Speaker 04 Everybody is so sweet.
1:37:09 Speaker 01 They really are. Here's your episode. You got your episode. So no, we're alive. Um, and we're going to continue forward. And I think that this should just show that COVID didn't stop us. Nope. Nothing stopped. We're fucking, this train goes, this train goes. All of the trains don't go. This train goes.
1:37:24 Speaker 04 One way or another, we figure it out.
1:37:26 Speaker 01 This train, and that's what we're going to keep doing. We're going to chug a, chug a, chug a, chug all the way through every single piece of tragedy that 2025 is going to give us. This is our version of a fireside chat.
1:37:40 Speaker 01 I am physically warm from the flames.
1:37:42 Speaker 04 Yes. Uh, go to patreon.com slash last podcast on the left to see us be physically warm. We have video episodes available. You can watch side stories on YouTube. You can also follow us on Tik Tok and Instagram at LP on the left. Don't forget to check out our Twitch streams at LP and TV.
1:38:00 Speaker 01 They're canceled for the week, but they're back on there. You can get them on there.
1:38:03 Speaker 04 Yeah. Twitch.tv slash LP and TV and see all the VOD stuff on YouTube. Uh, and don't forget to come out to see us on tour. I mean, I know we can't make Atlanta, but we're goddamn gonna make it to Texas.
1:38:14 Speaker 01 Oh, yeah.
1:38:14 Speaker 04 For our show in Dallas.
1:38:16 Speaker 00 Well, that in Atlanta is postponed. We will be redoing the show.
1:38:20 Speaker 01 Oh, yes.
1:38:20 Speaker 00 Hold on to your tickets.
1:38:21 Speaker 01 Yes, we're coming right back.
1:38:22 Speaker 00 Coming. Don't worry about it. It's definitely gonna happen. We're just not leaving our fucking wives behind.
1:38:27 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:38:29 Speaker 04 Coming back as soon as we can. Uh, and yeah, don't forget about shows in Toronto, Detroit, uh, and
1:38:36 Speaker 01 Nashville.
1:38:37 Speaker 04 Nashville coming up in the next few months.
1:38:39 Speaker 01 And this shit's gonna be good.
1:38:40 Speaker 04 Uh, I'm so exhausted. I'm about to die. Can I go home now?
1:38:43 Speaker 00 You are released. Wonderful job, Marcus.
1:38:47 Speaker 04 Really good job. Thank you. You as both of you as well.
1:38:49 Speaker 01 Really good stuff, guys. Hail, sweet Satan.
1:38:52 Speaker 04 Oh, Huguen.
1:38:53 Speaker 00 Hell, Larry fucking harness.
1:38:56 Speaker 01 Yeah, well, Larry, I don't know what you've done.
1:38:58 Speaker 00 Ten pound cock on the man.
1:39:00 Speaker 01 Dude, I want fucking, I'm gonna buy you lunch. I wanna see your dick. Come on, buddy. We're serious broadcasters. We have a New York Times bestseller.
1:39:13 Speaker 04 Unfortunately, unfortunately, that is true.
1:39:15 Speaker 01 Larry, does that hurt? I know it does.
1:39:18 Speaker 04 I'm sure it hurts quite a bit.
1:39:19 Speaker 01 I'll fix it though.
1:39:20 Speaker 04 I'm sure it really.
1:39:21 Speaker 01 We're gonna fix it, Larry.
1:39:22 Speaker 04 It really hurts. We're trying. We're trying. That's what we're here to do. We're really trying to make this book deal happen. We want you to get a publisher.
1:39:30 Speaker 01 Just Larry, as far as just don't turn like Zionist, just don't do bad shit in the next six months. Just stay under the radar and get that book out.
1:39:37 Speaker 04 Just do what most, just talk about only Black Dahlia and you'll be fine. That's it. Goodbye, Larry.
1:39:44 Speaker 01 Which is what this podcast is about to become.
1:39:45 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:40:50 Speaker 05 Hi, I'm Angie Hicks, co-founder of Angie. One thing I've learned is that you buy a house, but you make it a home. For decades, Angie's helped millions of homeowners hire skilled pros for the projects that matter. Angie, the one you trust to find the ones you trust. Find a pro for your project at angie.com.
1:41:05 Speaker 06 Talk about regrets. We all know someone who's been in a car accident and said, "I don't need to call a lawyer," only to regret it after their pain and damages were worse than expected. When someone hurts you, you deserve to be compensated fairly. Morgan & Morgan is America's largest injury law firm, fighting for the people for over 35 years. Injured? Visit forthepeople.com/podcast. That's forthepeople.com/podcast. Their fee is free unless they win.
Previous Side Stories: Christmas Crimes Next Side Stories: Body Parts for Sale Page updated November 5, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated