Pod Insights Killer Stories with Harvey Guillén The Eleven Who Went to Heaven: The Case Against Ed Bell Pt. 1 About this episode Edward Harold Bell was serving a 70-year prison sentence for murdering a man when he sent a letter to Houston reporter Lise Olsen. He told her he’d also killed 11 girls in and around the Interstate-45 corridor between Houston and Galveston back in the 1970s. He named some of these victims and described others with initials, locations, and years. And he included a poem that he titled “The Eleven Who Went To Heaven.”
Lise joined the efforts of Detective Fred Paige to investigate Bell’s links to the unresolved cases he alluded to… and together, they uncovered a long list of eerie coincidences and compelling circumstantial evidence.
You can watch Lise and Fred’s investigation unfold in the docuseries The Eleven. And check out Lise’s nonfiction book, The Scientist and the Serial Killer, debuting in April 2025: https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/720488/the-scientist-and-the-serial-killer-by-lise-olsen/
Keep up with us on Instagram @serialkillerspodcast! Have a story to share? Email us at [email protected] .
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:02 Speaker 00 This episode includes discussions of violence and murder. Consider this when deciding how and when you'll listen. In 2011, investigative reporter Lisa Olson receives a handwritten letter in the mail. There, at the top of the page is her name, scribbled out in mostly capital letters. But it's not from an old friend or a member of her family. It's been sent to her by a convicted murderer named Edward Harold Bell. And in it, on lined notebook paper, he includes a poem he wrote.
0:38 Speaker 01 And what of the innocent ones who fell, by the way? Will the henchmen of Uncle Sam ever pay? All of those who fell were as brave as brave can be. The only coward who was there was me.
0:51 Speaker 00 When he sends this letter to Lisa, Bell is already in prison for murdering a man in broad daylight in front of the man's family. Now, he's claiming responsibility for more murders. The victims, all teenage girls who disappeared from in and around Houston and Galveston, Texas throughout the 70s. They later turned up dead, but their killer or killers were never caught. Bell lists some of these girls in his letter. He names three of them. Others, he only refers to by their initials or hair color. Sometimes he includes years or locations that are meaningful to their cases.
1:32 Speaker 00 He calls his poem about his alleged victims, "The Eleven Who Went to Heaven."
1:43 Speaker 00 Welcome to Serial Killers, a Spotify podcast. I'm Janice Morgan. You might recognize me as the voice behind the investigative docu-series Broken and the true crime podcast Fear Thy Neighbor. I'll be your host for the next few weeks, and I am thrilled to be here. We'd love to hear from you. Follow us on Instagram at SerialKillersPodcast and share your thoughts on this week's episode. Or if you're tuning in on the Spotify app, swipe up and leave a comment. To help us tell today's story, we interviewed Lisa Olson, the investigative reporter and author, whose work on this case is featured in the docu-series The Eleven. We're so grateful she could share her expertise. Stay with us.
2:29 Speaker 00 So, Miki, you're a producer here, and you brought us this story because you have a connection to the case, right?
2:35 Speaker 02 Yes, so I've been on this show for a while now, and it's been sort of a passion project to research this story, not just because it's one of the most unforgettable and bizarre true crime cases that I've read, but also because it all took place kind of close to my hometown.
2:51 Speaker 00 And where is that?
2:53 Speaker 02 I grew up in one of the communities between Houston and Galveston along Interstate 45 in Texas. And so when I read this story, I know all the roads they talk about. I can picture all of the landmarks. I've even walked along one of the waterways where two of the victims were found. But I had never heard about these victims or these crimes when I was growing up. I'd never heard of Ed Bell until a few years ago, when I came across the work of a now-retired Galveston police detective named Fred Paige and a Houston-area investigative reporter and author named Lisa Olson. The investigation they did is incredible, and for today's episode, I had the privilege
3:35 Speaker 02 of getting to talk to Lisa about her work on these cases.
3:41 Speaker 00 It was 2011 when Lisa Olson first became aware of a suspected serial killer named Ed Bell.
3:47 Speaker 01 I was working on a story for the Houston Chronicle about the unidentified bed, which is something that's kind of obsessed me for a long time.
3:57 Speaker 00 That's Lisa talking about an unrelated, or maybe not-so-unrelated, article she was working on at the time.
4:04 Speaker 01 I was interested in the case specifically of a torso of a teenager in a purple surf shirt that was found floating in a bayou near Houston in the 70s. And I was looking for cases where there was enough identifying information linked to the body that I thought, maybe I could write about it and help solve a case.
4:25 Speaker 00 Her article quotes a forensic anthropologist who believes that, due to the age and the amount of remains recovered, it's not possible for investigators to identify the gender. After the article publishes, she gets a call from a man named Fred Paige. He's a detective in Galveston, an island off the coast of Texas, about 50 miles from downtown Houston. He's working to solve some cold cases from the 70s, and he thinks that several of the homicides could actually be connected to the same killer.
4:56 Speaker 01 He said, you know, in fact, I think that is a teenage girl's body. And I think I know who killed her. And he was the first person who told me about Ed Bell.
5:05 Speaker 00 Lisa won't receive that poem we mentioned earlier for a few more months. But Fred tells her it was actually two other letters that Bell sent from jail that originally piqued his interest in Bell as a potential suspect. Both were sent in 1998, one to the Galveston County DA, the other to the Harris County DA. In the letters, Bell confesses to having a hand in the deaths of seven girls across those counties, four fewer than the 11 he'll later claim. What really grabs Fred's attention is how Bell describes an unsolved double homicide from 1971. The victims were teenagers and best friends, Debbie Ackerman and Maria Johnson.
5:50 Speaker 00 Bell even includes their names for the DA's. And then he goes on to list a lot of specific details about the murder, like how he bound their hands and feet, how he'd shot them from a bridge with a specific gun. He even includes the specific locations of their bullet wounds. As far as Fred could tell, it's pretty accurate.
6:12 Speaker 01 And if you kind of think about this, you know, Texas prisons don't have a lot of internet access. He had details in that letter that had a lot of information about a crime that had been committed in 1971. And he was writing it more than 20 years later.
6:29 Speaker 00 To Fred, it seems like Bell might have actually been involved. Because if he totally fabricated his story, it's a stunning coincidence. And if he read about those details long ago and is now lying and taking credit for a crime he didn't commit, he has an incredible memory. By the time Detective Fred Paige calls Lisa, the DA's office in Galveston had tried to talk to Bell about making an official on the record confession. But he refused to cooperate. And that kicked off a never ending cycle of confessing and recanting over several years. Without more to work with, there's not much the DA's office can do. So they dropped their investigation.
7:13 Speaker 00 But Lisa was just starting hers.
7:17 Speaker 01 The first thing I asked Fred is, have you ever talked to Ed Bell? Ed Bell was in prison. I knew he was in prison, from what Fred told me, for another murder, entirely unrelated murder, of a young man. So he was available to talk. He had a long time in prison to kill time.
7:36 Speaker 00 And Fred says, no, he hasn't spoken to Bell yet. It's not an easy ask, coming from a homicide detective. It would be more straightforward for Lisa to request an interview as a reporter. So she does just that. Ahead of the interview, Lisa studies the case Fred has already put together. So far, Fred has focused on two double homicide cases in particular. We mentioned one already.
8:01 Speaker 01 Debbie Ackerman and Maria Johnson. They were surfer girls. They were friends. Debbie Ackerman was a really good waterskier. She had competed in waterski contests.
8:13 Speaker 00 Debbie and Maria were murdered in November 1971. That month, the 15th, Monday, was a school holiday, an extra day of freedom, so Debbie and Maria planned to make the most of it. A few students were hanging out at an ice cream shop that morning and saw the girls outside. According to one friend, Debbie and Maria said they planned to hitchhike into Houston, which isn't all that unusual for the time. Catching rides from strangers, if you can't drive yourself, is just something that happened back then. Debbie and Maria waited outside the ice cream shop for someone to pick them up. A driver in a white van finally stopped and talked to them. By the way they interacted, one witness assumed it was somebody they knew.
8:59 Speaker 00 The girls climbed in and the van took off.
9:03 Speaker 00 Two days later, Maria's body was found in the murky waters of Turner Bayou, in the middle of nowhere, over 20 miles from Galveston.
9:13 Speaker 00 Maria's hands and feet were bound and she was partially unclothed. She'd been shot and left near a wooden bridge. Investigators determined she was probably killed late on Monday night because that's when a local heard gunshots ring out across the field. Debbie was found soon after Maria, not far away. She too had been bound, undressed, shot, and left in the water. According to the medical examiner, her wounds suggested she had tried to save her best friend by placing her body in front of Maria's. The case did get media attention, but it took a while for people to connect this double homicide to a second similar crime.
9:54 Speaker 01 The general public didn't realize that in fact, four girls were likely abducted and then killed from Galveston Island from points that were very close to each other.
10:05 Speaker 00 Another pair of best friends disappeared from Galveston about three months earlier. They too were killed and their bodies left in water. They just hadn't been found yet.
10:23 Speaker 00 On August 4th, Sharon Shaw woke up at the home of her best friend, Rhonda Renee Johnson, who typically went by Renee. Confident Sharon was athletically gifted, especially at water skiing, and Renee loved to have fun. And with freshman year of high school looming over them, the inseparable best friends were living for that summer of 1971. That day, they decided to go from Webster, their hometown, to Galveston about 30 miles away. Their first stop was Wick's Ski School, but the water was rough and choppy, not great conditions for going out on the bayou. So they met up with their friend Glenda along one of the city's hotspots, the seawall that runs along the beach.
11:08 Speaker 00 Now, Glenda had a convertible and a driver's license, so the friends spent the late morning cruising up and down the coast. Around lunchtime, Sharon and Renee realized they needed to get back home. They told Glenda they didn't need a ride, they would hitchhike. Then, they vanished.
11:30 Speaker 00 Their remains weren't found until winter of 1972, about three months after Debbie and Maria's bodies were found. In January 1972, a couple of teenage boys thought they saw a volleyball in the water, but it turned out to be a skull. Officials later found a few other bones nearby, but not many. Dental records confirmed that the skull belonged to Renee Johnson. Sharon's remains were found the following month, just a quarter of a mile away from her best friend. This time, the investigators recovered 29 bones, along with some black twine and a surfer's cross, a popular piece of jewelry in the 70s.
12:13 Speaker 00 An autopsy couldn't confirm Sharon's cause of death, but the medical examiner concluded she was killed.
12:20 Speaker 01 The thing was that because Rhonda Renee Johnson and Sharon Shaw's bodies were dumped in a lake, their remains were actually found after the two other girls, which is maybe a little bit why in 1971, there wasn't a panic right away, because those four cases, which obviously Fred found so similar later, weren't associated in time as closely at the moment that they happened.
12:44 Speaker 00 A connection was eventually made, though. Local detectives wondered if an interest in surfing could be the common thread between the four victims. There were other commonalities, too. Both sets of best friends, both known to have been hitchhiking, both last seen alive in Galveston, and all found in remote waterways. All these years later, Lisa Olson and Fred Paige want to prove another connection: Ed Bell. In 1970, Bell met a man named Doug Prunes, a local Galveston legend. His surf shop was a popular teen hangout back then, and Bell, an avid diver, did business with him.
13:27 Speaker 00 Debbie and Maria were known regulars and Belle spent a lot of time there too. Maybe that's why Debbie and Maria seemed to know the person driving the white van that day. In 2011, Lisa gets the opportunity to interview Belle in person.
13:43 Speaker 01 Media interviews in prison are limited to an hour. So I had an hour to try to talk to this guy and convince him to tell me whatever he would tell me about these murders.
13:56 Speaker 00 Belle's now in his early 70s with a white crew cut and hard of hearing. It makes their conversation difficult through protective glass, but there's another challenge too.
14:09 Speaker 01 What was the problem was to get him to talk about what I wanted him to talk about. And Ed spent a lot of time talking about his life, about, you know, growing up. He was a proud Aggie. He had gone to Texas A&M, been in the marching band. He was all excited to talk about that.
14:26 Speaker 01 And then he would talk about how women wanted him, you know, sexually. Which is kind of a weird thing for me as a woman interviewing him. But, you know, you just sort of listen. You try not to really react. So eventually I get to his ears in Galveston. I ask him about running a dive shop in Galveston, which I knew he ran. So that would have been a place where he really, very likely would have met these girls.
14:55 Speaker 00 Lisa gets Belle to admit that Maria and Debbie had been in that dive shop. But for all this talking, Belle doesn't give up much else. That is, until the interview is almost over.
15:08 Speaker 01 I had about, say, five minutes left when he started to tell me that yes, he had killed a bunch of girls in Galveston and that he thought there were 10 or 11 when he was living in Galveston and in the Dickinson area. But he said, "I don't want to tell you in prison because they're always listening and watching me. I think I'll send you a letter with their names." So in the prison interview, I said, "Well, do you know their names?" And he said, "Yes, I know most of their names." And I said, "Well, you know, can you give me at least their initials?" And so in the first interview, he gave me a couple of initials of girls,
15:49 Speaker 01 and he said, "10 or 11." And then he said, "I will write you with more details later." And I thought, "Well, he may or may not, right?"
15:58 Speaker 00 He does. In July 2011, Bell sends Lisa the first of two letters. Much of it is in the form of a list. For example, "3 Galveston, 2 Fall 1971, 1 Fall 1976, 2 Webster, 1971, July, 1 Blonde, 1 Brunette." The list goes on, with Bell reducing the bright lives of these young girls to bullet points. But for Lisa, the good news is, aside from the fact that Renee and Sharon disappeared in August 1971, not July, Bell's list seems to support
16:39 Speaker 00 her and Fred's theory. Then Lisa gets another letter from Bell. It's the one with his "11 Who Went to Heaven" poem.
16:48 Speaker 01 And he seemed proud of it. You know, it was an accomplishment that he was excited to talk about. At that point, you know, Ed Bell was not someone who had been interviewed. Ed Bell's murder of Larry Dickens had been an infamous murder at the time, but Ed Bell had, by the time I met him, he had been in prison for almost 20 years. He'd been in prison from the 90s to 2011, hadn't had too many people to talk to. So he was, at that point, excited about someone visiting him. And so that's, I think, why he ended up writing me and, in fact, sending me down what was then a multi-year effort to try to figure out if Bell really was a serial killer, as he said he was, or if he was just a big liar.
17:39 Speaker 00 Detective Fred Paige had already linked Bell to the murders of Debbie Ackerman, Maria Johnson, Sharon Shaw, and Renee Johnson. But over the years, Bell had confessed to killing anywhere from seven to 11 female victims. Soon, Fred and Lisa are basically partners in their investigation, and they want to find out exactly who Bell claims he killed.
18:01 Speaker 01 We started with the ones that he most solidly identified, the ones where he gave names or where he gave the dates. He talked about Colette Anise Wilson. He used her middle name for some reason, in Alvin in 1971, which actually that predated the other murders. So if that was true, that would have been his first murder.
18:23 Speaker 00 In the summer of 1971, Colette Wilson was immersed in band camp. She played the clarinet. And every day after camp, her band director would drop Colette off in the same spot where her busy mom could easily swing by and get her. But when her mom arrived on June 17th as planned, Colette was nowhere to be seen. Her skeletal remains were found a few months later near a reservoir west of Houston. Colette's father, a dentist, confirmed her identity using her teeth. Ed Bell used Colette's full name in his letter. And Lisa and Fred learned that the spot where Colette's mother was supposed to pick her
19:07 Speaker 00 up was right along Bell's commute to work. Bell didn't receive much attention at the time.
19:14 Speaker 01 Her family and even police had developed another theory about a different killer. And there was a man prosecuted for Colette Wilson's murder. Now, did Ed really kill her? It could be.
19:28 Speaker 00 Then there were the other victims Bell alluded to. One he identified only as Gigi in Houston. Fred and Lisa believe the initials could refer to Gloria Gonzalez, a bookkeeper who was last seen at her Houston apartment in October 1971, and whose death was already tied to Colette Wilson's.
19:49 Speaker 01 We knew that at the same time Colette and Ace Wilson's body was found, that another girl named Gloria Gonzalez, who was kidnapped in Houston, her bones were found mixed with Colette Wilson. So if he was telling the truth about Colette Wilson, he most likely killed Gloria Gonzalez, whose bones were found there.
20:09 Speaker 00 Which makes sense. The remains of two murder victims were found mixed together in the same place, so they probably had the same killer. After Gloria and Colette were found in November 1971, investigators concluded the following: Gloria was most likely strangled with some kind of cord or rope, while Colette died from blunt force trauma. The further Lisa and Fred went, the more legitimate the crumbs Bell dropped in his letter seemed. He included the name Pitchford in one, along with a few other details, like that the girl was blonde and wearing a black coat. He also implied he found her near a mall in Houston called Gulf Gate.
20:53 Speaker 00 As it turned out, a girl named Kimberly Pitchford had disappeared one evening in January 1973 after driver's ed class. She was wearing a black coat she'd just gotten for Christmas. Her body was found two days later near a drainage ditch with a bridge nearby, not far from I-45. It was also close to Highway 6, which led straight to Bell's home at the time. It's the same highway Colette Wilson disappeared on.
21:23 Speaker 01 There's not much evidence in that case, except for the chilling story that I have since heard from many people who've reached out to me, that they were followed by a man that looked like Ed Bell on I-45, or on the service roads when they were kids, because people during that era in the 70s were walking along I-45 because it wasn't as big of a busy road, that they were going to the mall. And one of the people who says she was followed along that road and at the entrance of her neighborhood was one of Kim Pitchford's best friends.
21:56 Speaker 00 Another name that appears in Lisa and Fred's investigation is Brenda Jones. In July 1971, she vanished on her way home from visiting her aunt at the hospital. She was also found in the water, under a bridge, but actually in Galveston proper. Like some of the other possible victims, her wrists and ankles were bound, and she was in a state of undress. Bell knew the hospital Brenda visited too. He'd once been admitted there for psychiatric treatment. He was released the year before Brenda's murder, but we know he returned to that hospital at least once, when he tried to abduct a patient there.
22:36 Speaker 01 We know he was lurking outside that place, both during and after he was in treatment. He had ability to go and come from there, he had access to a vehicle, and that he took her in a vehicle to a remote area, and that she believed she was able to survive just because she kept him talking about himself. And the whole time she would never tell anyone, and she was brought back to the hospital.
23:01 Speaker 00 When the woman initially reported what happened, she wasn't taken seriously, but her story never changed. If you're keeping track, Brenda Jones would make eight possible victims Lisa and Fred have identified. They believe she's one of the, quote, "five girls in Galveston" Bell mentioned. Not everyone is convinced, though, mostly because Brenda was black and most of Bell's other alleged victims were white. But Lisa and Fred believe the connections are just too hard to ignore. Then there's the unsolved murder of Susie Bowers in 1977. She disappeared while walking in her Galveston neighborhood, just a few blocks from where Sharon Shaw and Renee Johnson were last seen.
23:45 Speaker 00 Bell has made statements that could tie him to Susie. He told Lisa that he killed a girl in Galveston a year or two before Larry Dickens, the murder that ultimately landed him in prison. Susie's case is the only unsolved murder that seems to check all the boxes. And then, there's this coincidence.
24:06 Speaker 01 At the time, Ed was running a series of crew boats out of Galveston that were being used to send supplies to offshore rigs. He still ran his dive business, but he had these crew boats. But anyway, at the time, his main crewman for those boats, who he was giving rides to and from, the pier, lived within a block of Susie Bowers' grandparents. And he was there all the time.
24:33 Speaker 00 Not to mention, two years later, Susie's remains are also found in a remote field next to a canal out in Altaloma. Lisa and Fred know Bell used to live nearby, so they tracked down an old neighbor of his who confirms where Bell parked his trailer back in the mid-'70s. The spot is roughly 20 miles from where Susie went missing, and just 2.3 miles from where she was found. If Bell really killed 11 girls, that leaves two more. And Lisa and Fred have identified who they think those two could be. It's another best friend double homicide case that matches part of Bell's list. Two in Dickinson, one blonde, one brunette.
25:18 Speaker 00 Their names are Brooks Bracewell and Georgia Gier.
25:22 Speaker 01 The striking thing about these two girls was not necessarily what Ed had said about them, but the fact that first their abduction site was near where he was known to go. He had, according to police records, tried to abduct two other girls who lived very close to these two girls that same year.
25:42 Speaker 00 In September 1974, Brooks and Georgia decided to cut class. That afternoon, they ended up at the El Rancho Motel in a public area with games like pool and pinball. Other kids from school, even Brooks' older sister, were there too. When it was time to go, some of the kids caught a ride with a friend, but there was no room in the car for Brooks or Georgia. It wasn't a big deal, though. They weren't far from home and could walk. But as the car pulled away, one boy looked back at the girls. It looked like they were trying to hitchhike.
26:19 Speaker 00 When the girls didn't come home that night, their parents involved the police, but they assumed the girls had run away. It took years to finally track them down, out in a drainage ditch and in an oil field. By then, there were few remains left and even less forensic evidence. The murders went unsolved. With so many connections between Bell and these unsolved murders, it might seem a little baffling that the DA's office ended their investigation so quickly, until you learn about one of Bell's other claims. It turns out, in addition to these murder confessions, he's been trying to tell another
26:58 Speaker 00 story for years, one that he says explains all of his predatory behavior and involves a vast brainwashing conspiracy he believes is run by the government. He calls it "The Program," and it's kind of like a nightmarish version of The Truman Show. He even referenced it in the poem he sent to Lisa.
27:18 Speaker 01 And what of the innocent ones who fell, by the way? Will the henchmen of Uncle Sam ever pay?
27:26 Speaker 00 Maybe the DA's office found it hard to take his confession seriously in the midst of ranting about a conspiracy. But what if he wasn't making it all up? Thanks for tuning into Serial Killers, a Spotify podcast. I'll be back next Monday with part two of this story. We'll dig deeper into Ed Bell's claims about the program and reveal the most compelling evidence that Lisa and Fred found during their investigation. A big, big thank you to Lisa Olson for her time and expertise. If you haven't already, check out the docu-series, The Eleven, and look for her book, The Scientist
28:09 Speaker 00 and the Serial Killer, coming out in April 2025. Along with The Eleven, we also found Catherine Casey's book, Deliver Us: Three Decades of Murder and Redemption in the infamous I-45 Texas Killing Fields, extremely helpful to our research. Stay safe out there. This episode was written and produced by Mickey Taylor, edited by Connor Sampson and TTU, fact-checked by Lori Siegel, and sound design by Spencer Howard. I'm your host, Janice Morgan.
Previous Hunting a Serial Killer: The Colonial Parkway Murders Next The Eleven Who Went to Heaven: The Case Against Ed Bell Pt. 2 Page updated November 3, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated