Pod Insights Killer Stories with Harvey Guillén Best of 2024: Israel Keyes Pt. 3 About this episode As our Best of 2024 selection, we're featuring our three-part series on notorious serial killer Israel Keyes.
Israel Keyes died having only confessed to a handful of murders and crimes. Researchers and investigators are left piecing together evidence to solve cold cases.
Keep up with us on Instagram @serialkillerspodcast! Have a story to share? Email us at [email protected]
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:02 Speaker 00 Due to the nature of this killer's crimes, listener discretion is advised. This episode includes discussions of rape, kidnapping, murder, and suicide. Consider this when deciding how and when you'll listen. To get help on mental health and suicide, visit spotify.com/resources.
0:25 Speaker 00 Over the course of six months in 2012, Israel Keyes gave FBI agents the names of three of his murder victims: Samantha Koenig and Bill and Lorraine Carrier. He recounted the events of one of his first-ever victims, a teenage girl he says he abducted and raped along the Deschutes River in Oregon sometime between 1996 and 1998. He claimed he intended to kill her, but didn't go through with it. The FBI has since tried to identify this survivor. If they've succeeded, they haven't released any additional information to the public, and beyond that, investigators have only ever linked one other case to Israel Keyes:
1:07 Speaker 00 the 2009 disappearance of a New Jersey woman named Deborah Feldman. Deborah's remains still haven't been found, but the FBI believes she's the fourth victim of Israel Keyes. The circumstances of her disappearance match statements Israel made about a victim he buried in New York, and like Samantha Koenig, her name was also found on Israel's computer. How many more victims did he have? There's only one person who knows for sure, and he ended his life in his prison cell back in December 2012. But that hasn't stopped investigators from trying to connect more cold cases and bring closure to victims' families.
1:50 Speaker 00 Today, with the help of Josh Hallmark, we're discussing three missing person cases that he believes could be connected to Israel Keyes.
2:01 Speaker 00 I'm Vanessa Richardson and this is Serial Killers, a Spotify podcast. You can find us here every Monday. Be sure to check us out on Instagram @serialkillerspodcast. And we'd love to hear from you, so if you're listening on the Spotify app, swipe up and give us your thoughts. This is the final part of our series on Israel Keyes. In our last two episodes, we discussed Israel's confessions to the murders of Samantha Koenig and Lorraine and Bill Courier. The FBI believes Israel may be responsible for more murders, but Israel's death in prison put an end to the confessions. Now Josh Hallmark walks us through the unsolved murders he believes have the strongest links
2:44 Speaker 00 to Israel Keyes. Stay with us.
2:55 Speaker 01 It's back to school, back to work, back to cozy nights at home season. And ADT is here to handle your home security so you can focus on spending time with the people who matter. Get professionally installed systems you can access from the ADT Plus app. Plus reps on call 24/7 at the most company-operated monitoring centers in the industry. You deserve cozy time at home. ADT will keep an eye out. When every second counts, count on ADT. Visit ADT.com today.
3:23 Speaker 02 Observe: The North American Dad. 50s, great polo collection. He enters his vehicle information on Carvana. An offer appears in minutes. Remarkable. He squints, reads it again, smiles and says, "Dang, that's a good offer." The highest form of approval. No haggling, no hassle, no one called him "boss." He's still on the couch. Astonishing. Sell your car today on carvana.com. Pickup fees may apply.
3:56 Speaker 00 It's March 1998. Suzanne Suzie Lial is a 19-year-old college sophomore.
4:04 Speaker 03 She was a student at SUNY Albany. She had just transferred there. She'd been at another SUNY campus in New York and decided to switch to SUNY Albany. She grew up in Ballston Spa, which is outside of Saratoga Springs. And so she wanted to go back to the Albany area to be closer to her parents, but also to be closer to her boyfriend, who was in the area. She was big into computers, loved writing poetry. She was really into horses. You know, even her mom said like she was a little bit nerdy, but just like a brilliant, really kind-hearted, thoughtful girl. Everyone I've talked to says she was just like wise beyond her years, very mature, and just a very insightful, interrogating person.
4:48 Speaker 00 She works part-time at a video game and software store called Babbage's, located at the Cross Gates Mall in Albany. On March 2nd, she takes a bus from campus to work, finishes her shift, and Josh says this is where the timeline gets confusing. According to the New York State Police, she catches a bus back to campus and arrives at the Collin Circle stop at SUNY Albany around 9:25 PM. She's less than 1,000 feet from the campus's towering dorm buildings, and no one knows what happens to her from there. She's never seen again. But Josh isn't so sure that Suzie got on the bus after work.
5:30 Speaker 03 What's frustrating about Suzie's case is we don't know where she was last seen. So she had been getting ready for midterms, and so she wasn't really participating in any socializing. So she took the bus to her job at Cross Gates Mall, and she got off and she walked out what is essentially an employee's only entrance, and it leads into a loading bay, which is not super visible from the parking lot or the rest of the mall. And what she normally would have done is from there, walk to the bus depot and take the bus back to her dorm. We know for sure she left work that day and we know for sure she exited through the normal route. They have talked to the bus driver who drives that route and they
6:15 Speaker 03 talked to a girl on her floor in the dorm and they both believe they saw her that night.
6:21 Speaker 00 But Josh wonders whether they actually did see Susie that night.
6:25 Speaker 03 You know, we've talked a lot about this. She was part of their normal routines. So weeks later, if they're interviewed, it would be really challenging to say like, yes, on this night we saw her because they saw her most nights in this exact same manner.
6:41 Speaker 00 Christopher Kunkel is a forensic psychologist and criminal investigative consultant who's been involved in Susie's case.
6:48 Speaker 03 I went there recently with Chris Kunkel and if she was abducted, walking from the bus stop to her dorm, it would not have gone unnoticed. It's a very short distance. It's very open. It's basically a giant circular roundabout with a lawn in between and two, I think, 10 to 12 story dorms. So highly visible, short distance. It also echoes because you're in a quad. So you're in between all these buildings. And we tried to come up with a million different scenarios where she somehow gets abducted in this short distance with no one seeing and it just, nothing worked. So it is of both of our opinions that she likely never made it onto the bus after work.
7:33 Speaker 00 What's indisputable is that Susie never makes it back to her dorm that night.
7:38 Speaker 03 The next day, her debit card is used. $20 is taken out of her account. It's used at a convenience store about a mile, mile and a half from her school. And they don't have an ATM camera, but they have a camera in the convenience store and they find a man who was in there around the time the transaction happened. They call him the Nike guy because he was wearing a Nike hat. And he becomes kind of suspect number one.
8:07 Speaker 00 Not technically a suspect, a person of interest. Others are considered over the course of the investigation, including Susie's boyfriend.
8:15 Speaker 03 They track down Nike man and they can rule him out. But they interview him and ask him if he saw anyone else in there at the time. And he said something to the effect of, A tall, white man dressed like a farmer. So that lead dies there. And so now they're focused solely on her boyfriend and his family. They can't rule him out, but they can't rule him in. And then when there's all this debate about whether she was abducted from campus or the mall, her Babbage's ID badge is found on campus in a place that there's no reason for her to have been there. It's an area where, and this was in the press, her boyfriend's parents would pick her up.
8:59 Speaker 03 They would pick her up in that area as opposed to near her dorm. But as we know, she had no intent of going there because she was studying for her midterms. And everyone agrees she took school very seriously and would not have strayed from that plan. And there's also no communication that indicates that the plan ever changed. So it's odd that her ID badge is found after multiple searches in an area that was searched, but in an area that she would not have gone that night. And that's kind of where publicly at least, the investigation into Suzie's disappearance ends. Where Keys comes into play is, you know, I had known about Suzie's disappearance before I knew about Keys. There was a lot of media surrounding it, particularly at the 10-year anniversary.
9:44 Speaker 03 So when I get the Keys files and I go through the NamUs45, I'm shocked to see Suzie is on that list.
9:50 Speaker 00 You'll remember the NamUs45 from our first episode. NamUs is a national database for missing people. The FBI found photos of people of all ages, races, and backgrounds on Israel's computer, some alongside missing person flyers and news articles about disappearances. When they ran the photos and names through the NamUs database and found 45 matches, Suzie was one of those matches. Israel, it seemed, had taken an interest in her case.
10:21 Speaker 03 Then I start understanding Keys and, you know, Keys had never been looked at because no one could connect him to the area, but his cabin is just three hours from Albany. And at the time that Suzie disappeared, he was living there full time by himself. So there's that. And then shortly after Suzie disappeared, Keys enlisted in the military. And that kind of mirrors what happened with the Deschutes girl as he commits this crime close to home, panics, and then leaves the area almost immediately. Then we start going through the FBI tips and there's a very credible account of a woman who believes she encountered Keys in a Marshall's parking lot as the Marshall's was closing
11:05 Speaker 03 in 1998. Suzie disappeared in 1998. She said she was walking out to her car. She'd parked far away from the store entrance in an unlit area. And when she got out there, there was a young man who looked to be in his late teens or early twenties. He was tall. Her description of him, which is apt and also hilarious is that he looked like Beaker from The Muppets.
11:28 Speaker 00 The woman says the man stared at her as she put an item she purchased in her car. In an otherwise empty parking lot, he stood uncomfortably close and he asked her strange questions.
11:40 Speaker 03 Like, "Does anyone know you're here? How old are you?" And that's when she was like, "Old enough, leave me the fuck alone," or something like that. And she said that it was only when she got aggressive with him that he kind of scampered off a little bit. But she could see him watching her as she got into her car and drove off. What's strange is these questions come up over and over and over again and Keys tips and encounters. Keys in a parking lot or a cemetery in kind of the far end of it and he approaches someone and starts asking weird questions like, "Would anyone know if you went missing today?" Or "If you didn't come home, would anyone notice? How old are you?" So there's that, which again, like, doesn't add up to a lot, but then you look at the
12:25 Speaker 03 witness and she is an attorney. She has a lot to lose for making false reports to the FBI. She also is trained on remembering specifics and details. And unbeknownst to her, like, Keys was in the area at the time. Keys was known to... Frequent mall parking lots. Keys enlisted in the army directly across the street from the Marshalls. So this is an area he knew well. It's in a hotspot. It's close to his house, but not so close that it's in his own backyard. And then around the same time, less than a mile away, Susie disappears from a mall parking lot or a campus parking lot. So that was kind of the most compelling evidence for me to take this seriously, in
13:09 Speaker 03 addition to her being on his computer. So then we started looking at more dates. We knew that for Keys to enlist, he had to get his GED and get a social security card. He didn't get that because he was basically born off-grid. And from where he was living, he would have to do both of these things in Albany. It was the closest location for him to do that. So we don't know exact dates, but we do know that between at least October of 97 and July of 98, when he finally enlisted, that he had to go to Albany at least three different times. And that location is, like I said, directly across from the Marshalls, and you can see SUNY campus from that location.
13:54 Speaker 03 There is also a Hertz rental car directly next to the enlistment office, and we know that he was renting cars at the time from Hertz.
14:01 Speaker 00 As the coincidences piled up, Josh found he wasn't alone in his thinking.
14:07 Speaker 03 Chris Kunkel, before Keys was on his radar, had always believed it was a serial killer. He just said it was too clean for it to be a first-time act. And then he found out from my show that Susie's name was on Keys' computer. And so we started talking and comparing notes. And I think our cases that it was Keys got stronger and stronger. There's also the computer element. Keys was a computer video game guy. His cabin didn't have electricity, so in order for him to play video games or use a computer, he'd have to go to a store like Babbage's to do that. Susie, when she was at her previous SUNY campus, which was closer to Keys' cabin, worked at a Babbage's there, also closer to Keys' cabin. So again, there's a lot here that mirrors the crimes we know about. We've got
14:52 Speaker 03 The test ATM use. We've got a tall white guy who dresses like a farmer in that location at the time the card was used. That's how Keys is often described. We've got Suzie on his computer. We've got them both being into online communication, her working at a store, which is the one of few places Keys would be able to actually access the internet at that time. So, very compelling evidence.
15:16 Speaker 00 And Josh says that something happens on the 15th anniversary of Suzie's disappearance. Her name trends on Google, which isn't necessarily strange. The anniversary could explain the spike in press coverage. But of all places, Suzie's name trends in Houston, Texas, at a time we know Israel was in Texas. Working against the theory that Israel had a hand in Suzie's disappearance is the fact that he once told the FBI that he didn't kill anyone until after he joined the military. And as Josh mentioned, Suzie disappeared beforehand.
15:52 Speaker 03 But then in subsequent interviews, they asked him, "The longest you ever went without killing someone?" And he said, "Well, when I was in the army."
16:01 Speaker 00 Implying he had, in fact, killed before and stopped after he registered at an enlistment office located just one mile away from Suzie's campus. If you have information related to Suzanne Lyles disappearance, contact the New York State Police at 518-783-3212, or submit an anonymous tip to your local FBI office. In earlier episodes, we spoke about how Israel Keyes only named three victims, Samantha
16:45 Speaker 00 Koenig and Bill and Lorraine Courier. But in interviews with the FBI, he made references to many others.
16:52 Speaker 03 He says he killed a male-female couple sometime after the military, but before 2005. He says that the remains were never recovered. He didn't see a lot of press about them. And then he talked about details about the actual murder itself.
17:10 Speaker 00 Nothing specific, apart from a general location. He said he committed the murders in Washington and buried the remains near a valley. But the FBI believes he might have abducted the couple from a neighboring state.
17:24 Speaker 03 What's interesting is there's only one such occurrence of an unsolved, missing male, female couple in Washington or its surrounding states between 2001 and 2005. And it's Gene Hyatt and Kami Volandraff.
17:40 Speaker 00 In November 2011, Eugene, who goes by Gene, and Kami are staying on the Oregon coast. They're teenagers, 18 and 16. Gene's family rented an oceanfront condo for Thanksgiving and invited Kami to stay with them. One morning, while Gene's father is in the shower, they tell Gene's grandparents that they're going out for a walk, heading down to Boiler Bay State Park to look at the tide pools. They leave around 10 a.m., and they never return.
18:10 Speaker 03 The local law enforcement almost immediately decided that they had been swept to sea, that there was like a rogue wave that took them out to sea.
18:19 Speaker 00 It wouldn't have been the only time something like that happened in the area Gene and Kami were in, but Josh has since called the rogue wave theory into question.
18:28 Speaker 03 Essentially, the Coast Guard has said, and all my research into like wave and tidal patterns have said, like, it is very rare, almost unheard of, for two people to be swept to sea and then never seen again. Almost always what happens is tidal patterns are circular, so essentially they would have been swept out to sea, but then very shortly thereafter, come back to shore. I've also been to this area on, I think, the week of the 20th anniversary of their disappearance, at the same time they disappeared. And it's low tide, and where they were purported to be is like... Quite high above the tide level and there were tons of fishermen out there.
19:09 Speaker 03 And all I could think is like, even if there was some rogue wave that was able to somehow at low tide, drag them off an elevated viewpoint into the ocean. Someone would have seen this happen because they both would scream and make noise and potentially get away or, you know, get back to shore. And the fact that neither of their bodies were ever recovered, no one saw them go in, no one heard them go in, is unreasonable to me.
19:36 Speaker 00 When Josh looked into Gene and Kami's disappearance, he started to take note of possible connections to Keys.
19:43 Speaker 03 When they disappeared from Depot Bay, Oregon, Keys was living in Nia Bay, Washington, which is essentially along the same highway, Route 101, and only, I think, like a seven hour drive.
19:57 Speaker 00 In statements to the FBI, Israel spoke about driving long distances. He drove from Chicago to Vermont in the abduction of the couriers, and once mentioned driving more than 300 miles with a victim alive in his car.
20:11 Speaker 03 You know, for us, a seven hour drive is quite long, but relatively speaking for him, it's nothing.
20:18 Speaker 00 Israel appeared to have a thing for couples and told authorities he often chose smaller victims to make the abduction and disposal process easier.
20:28 Speaker 03 They were slight, they were theater kids, you know, just walking out to go look at the ocean. But from Keys' perspective, would be very easy victims.
20:39 Speaker 00 Gene was between 5'6" and 5'8", 140 to 150 pounds. Kami was 5'7" and weighed around 130. And when Josh visited Depot Bay, he noticed something about the route Gene and Kami likely would have taken.
20:54 Speaker 03 What stood out to me is the pathway from their condo to this area is mostly along the highway, but there is one little area that is entirely shrouded from the parking lot, from the park and from the highway. And it's where you would enter or exit southbound from the park in a car.
21:13 Speaker 03 So that stood out to me because when I go to these places, I always have to think about the logistics. Like, how could Keys have done this? Like, where could he have done it where no one would have seen him? How would he have gotten back to his car? It's all kind of boring and tedious. But here, it was like, this stood out to me immediately. It's like, oh, this would make sense why no one saw them there that day, because they never made it there, even though it's such a short span. He could have parked his car here, and they could have come up, and he could have grabbed them both.
21:40 Speaker 00 After Jean and Cami disappeared, investigators and volunteers performed thorough searches of the area. The Coast Guard got involved. No evidence is found. Then, four days later...
21:52 Speaker 03 Jean's shoe is found on a nearby beach. And this is after it's in the press, that they believe they had been swept out to sea. And I've seen pictures of the shoe, and again, like, pictures will never do something justice, but it does not look like it's been in the water for days.
22:08 Speaker 00 Stranger still, a few days later, a friend of Cami's family is on the beach helping another search party.
22:15 Speaker 03 And she's exiting the outdoor bathroom, and she encounters a young man who's asking a bunch of weird questions. Like, oh, what are you all doing here? Did someone go missing? What's going on? How long have you been searching? Have you found anything? And no one knows who Keys is at the time, but she describes him as looking exactly like a young Christian Longo, who had recently been arrested for killing his wife and kid. And if you look at pictures of Christian Longo at that time, he looks eerily like Israel Keyes. So it's not outside the realm of possibility that Keys would A, return
22:56 Speaker 03 to this scene, but also B, ask a lot of questions to see if he could find out about the investigation, but also just to kind of like... I guess taunt people, you know, he got off on emotional and psychological torture. So it would make sense to me that he would go down and just try to toy with people.
23:16 Speaker 00 Unlike Susie Lyle, Jean and Kami weren't found on Israel's computer. But Josh says he'd been looking into a young woman named Brooke Wilberger, who disappeared in the same area as Jean and Kami. Israel didn't have a hand in Brooke's disappearance. The man who murdered her later confessed. But Josh notes that the same newspapers that were covering Brooke's disappearance at the time were also covering Jean and Kami's case.
23:43 Speaker 03 And we know that Keys would look into disappearances and he would search area newspapers that would be covering those cases and look for missing person. And that's how he would read about his crime. So that's kind of the connection we have there. So again, a bunch of circumstantial evidence, but it's very clear to me and many professionals I've spoken to that they did not get swept away to sea. And so either they ran away, which everyone who knows them has said, like, there's no way, or they were abducted. And it just so happens that they almost identically match Keys' account of abducting a couple. And there's in fact, no one else who matches that account.
24:25 Speaker 00 All these years later, there's no more certainty. There's still work to be done, more evidence that needs to be found. And there's no telling which direction it will point.
24:36 Speaker 03 We know that Kami was wearing a bracelet when she disappeared. I have pictures of it. And so we are trying our best to match that up to pictures of jewelry found on Keys' property in New York, as well as the house he shared with his ex-girlfriend in Alaska. But yeah, I think that's one of those where like, we're kind of at a dead end unless law enforcement decides that they want to play with us.
25:00 Speaker 00 Josh has spoken with some of Kami's loved ones. He says he's gotten to know her cousin and best friend well. They both lived with Kami when she disappeared.
25:11 Speaker 03 Think that Keys makes the most sense. They haven't said this is what we think happens, but they've said, you know, this makes more sense than anything else we've heard.
25:19 Speaker 00 What they've heard is mostly what law enforcement believes. Gene and Kami were washed out to sea by a rogue wave during a storm that hit around the time they departed.
25:28 Speaker 03 Keys talked about reading about his crimes and his victims, and he was often surprised at what law enforcement or the media determined or hypothesized had happened. What he specifically says is, oh, presumed boating accident, or, oh, presumed lost in the woods, or, oh, presumed lost at sea. And it's interesting that, you know, those were the three examples that he chose.
25:59 Speaker 00 If you have information about Gene or Kami's disappearance, contact the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children at 1-800-843-5678, or the Lincoln County Sheriff's Office in Oregon at 541-265-4231.
26:26 Speaker 00 Israel Keyes abducts Samantha Koenig on February 1, 2012, and murders her later that night. The next morning, he travels with his girlfriend and daughter to Houston before driving to New Orleans to go on a cruise. He's weeks away from getting caught, from his house of cards coming crashing down. When the cruise finishes, Israel's girlfriend decides to go on a road trip with some friends. So Israel and his daughter drive to the Dallas area to visit his mother and sisters. But shortly after he arrives, Israel goes on a solo trip.
27:04 Speaker 03 Keys, in the middle of the night, basically leaves a note saying, "Going to bury guns," and disappears for three days.
27:11 Speaker 00 During that time, a 58-year-old Texas man goes missing, named James, aka Jimmy Tidwell.
27:19 Speaker 03 Jimmy Tidwell was living in East Texas, near the Louisiana border. And he was married to a woman named Carol. They had just bought this dilapidated house in the woods, and he was fixing it up. By all accounts, was a point of contention for the couple. It got bad enough that Carol moved in with her daughter. She didn't like being in this house, because it gave her the creeps. But also, she was a school bus driver, and her daughter lived closer to her route, so it just made more sense. Jimmy worked for a manufacturing plant in Longview, Texas. What we know is, he was at work, he worked the night shift, and he was headed back home around 5:00 a.m.
28:04 Speaker 03 He had all of his gear, his hard hat, his protective goggles, all these things he was required to wear for his job. And that's the last anyone has seen him.
28:15 Speaker 00 It's believed that Jimmy was last seen on February 15, 2012. But he's not reported missing until February 28, 13 days later. Over the course of their investigation, officials questioned Jimmy's wife, Carol. She's unable to give investigators a date and time she last saw her husband.
28:36 Speaker 03 Carol's story changes a lot, which has made her, I think, a focus of people's attention. She was living there part-time, there was a lot of contention between the two, so I can understand how her memory is not great.
28:47 Speaker 00 Despite suspicions originally cast on her, Carol has been cleared by law enforcement, and Jimmy's case remains unsolved.
28:56 Speaker 03 What's compelling about this, in terms of Keys, is, I would say, out of all of the cases we've looked into, this has the most compelling circumstantial evidence. For starters, Keys was in the area at the time. A Walmart receipt can place him about 20 miles away, shortly after Tidwell is believed to have disappeared. Keys bought a shovel, lubricant, and air freshener.
29:24 Speaker 00 Jimmy lived in a town called Mount Enterprise. Josh says Israel's mother and sisters, the ones he was visiting, were in the process of moving from the Dallas area to the town of Wells. We know that Keys visited Wells during his trip, but what's interesting is Mount Enterprise is only about a 40-minute drive from there, and Jimmy lived in a remote cabin in the woods, the kind of area Israel told the FBI he liked to stake out.
29:51 Speaker 03 Where things get interesting is the day after Jimmy disappeared, Keys set a house on fire and then robbed a bank. In the video of him at the bank robbery, he's wearing a hard hat, and he has long, thin, stringy hair, which Keys, at the time, had very short, thick, curly hair. When asked where he got the hair from, he said, "Human hair is very easy to find." And then he said that he glued human hair inside this hard hat, so it looked like he had longer hair. So Jimmy Tidwell's hard hat is never found. We know that Keys took Samantha's hair. And, you know, again, this could be biased,
30:34 Speaker 03 but if you look at pictures of Jimmy Tidwell and you look at the hair in Keys's helmet, it looks like the same hair. But again, like, I'm not a hair scientist, so, um, grain of salt.
30:48 Speaker 00 In conversations with the FBI, Israel denied killing anyone in Texas. But later, he seemingly walked back that statement without giving any specifics. He said something to the effect of, "I haven't been truthful about Texas." Josh brings the conversation back to the fire Israel set the day after Jimmy disappeared.
31:10 Speaker 03 We know that Keys often would burn buildings after crimes. Our opinion is to conceal evidence from the crimes. This was a, not vacant, but I guess abandoned home, not far from the bank he robbed, but far enough that his excuse that he did it as a diversion didn't make any sense, because it's about a 20-minute drive, they're in different jurisdictions, so it wouldn't be the same police responding to both events. And the events occurred four hours apart, so it would be a very terrible diversion. So he can't really come up with a reason for why he burned this house, except that it just needed to burn. There's no evidence of remains, but I don't know that it was searched for remains at the time. He did a heck of a job burning it. The house was completely destroyed.
31:54 Speaker 03 In fact, I went back two years ago and like the property 10 years later still smells like fire. There's so much circumstantial evidence. It lines up with a period where Keys is missing. He told his mom he was stuck in the mud for three days. He had turned his phone off at the time. He stopped using his credit card at the time. Jimmy disappears from an area he is in and would have reason to go back to because it's not far from where he knows his mother's about to move. Jimmy's hard hat disappears. Keys shows up with a hard hat in this bank robbery. So there's all that and that was compelling enough. But then we were cataloging items seized from the Anchorage house Keys lived in when he was arrested.
32:34 Speaker 03 And in it, there was a knife that had the name of a pipe fitting company based in Longview, Texas, company that worked with the company that Jimmy Tidwell worked with.
32:48 Speaker 00 If you have any information about the disappearance of Jimmy Tidwell, you're asked to call the Rusk County Sheriff's Office at 903-657-3581.
33:06 Speaker 00 With his death, Israel Keyes robbed so many people of closure, but experts are still trying to better understand his MO and victimology. Forensic psychologist Katherine Ramsland has suggested Israel Keyes may have had a fetish for missing persons and investigators and researchers are still piecing together his crimes and making what could be breakthroughs. For example, Josh now believes Israel's murders were not as random or disconnected as officials once believed.
33:39 Speaker 03 If you plot all of his travels on a map, along with all of his residences or familial residences, along with the name is 45, what happens is you see nine hotspots across the country where all of these places.
33:58 Speaker 03 Connect within 50 to 100 miles. And so you can target where he was likely committing his crimes.
34:04 Speaker 00 Josh covers this revelation in season two of his podcast True Crime Bullshit in an episode called Hot Spots. And it's proof that our understanding of Israel's crimes is still evolving. Recently, Josh says, a woman came forward who says she had a run in with Israel sometime between Samantha Koenig's murder and Jimmy Tidwell's disappearance. She apparently knew information about Israel that hasn't been made publicly available.
34:33 Speaker 03 She was in a cemetery visiting her grandmother. And she says Keys came running from the woods and tried to grab her. She got away. But what's so interesting is it's this tiny town called Vider, Texas, also near Wells. Keys would have been traveling from Houston to Lafayette, Louisiana around that time by himself or with his daughter, but no other adults. And then I just, I don't know why, because it seemed like there was no way. But I looked to see if there were any missing persons cases on that day. And a man disappeared while camping in Vider, Texas on that day.
35:08 Speaker 00 Another strange coincidence in a long history of others. There's a plaque on a gazebo at Matanuska Lake in Alaska, the place where the FBI found Samantha Koenig's remains, the only remains ever recovered from any of Israel Keys' victims. It reads, "With remembrance and respect, this space is dedicated to the cherished loved ones who were violently taken from their lives and ours." We can only hope that one day more will be found.
35:50 Speaker 00 Thanks for listening to Serial Killers, a Spotify podcast. We'll be back with a new episode on Monday. Be sure to check us out on Instagram, at Serial Killers Podcast. And we'd love to hear from you. So if you're listening on the Spotify app, swipe up and give us your thoughts. To report tips about the Israel Keyes case, call 1-800-CALL-FBI or visit FBI.gov/tips.
36:16 Speaker 00 Once again, we'd like to give a special thanks to Josh Hallmark for lending his expertise to today's story. You can check out True Crime Bullshit: Josh's Investigation into Israel Keyes, which is going into its sixth season, as well as Josh's other podcasts from Studio Both And on Spotify or wherever else you listen. Stay safe out there. Serial Killers is a Spotify podcast. This episode was written by Connor Sampson, researched, edited, and produced by Connor Sampson and Chelsea Wood, fact-checked by Laurie Siegel, and sound designed by Alex Button. Our head of programming is Julian Boireau. Our head
36:57 Speaker 00 of production is Nick Johnson, and Spencer Howard is our post-production supervisor. I'm your host, Vanessa Richardson.
Previous Best of 2024: Israel Keyes Pt. 2 Next The Yorkshire Killer Witch Pt. 1 Page updated November 5, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated