Pod Insights Jill on Money with Jill Schlesinger How to Retire Part One About this episode This weekend we're joined by Christine Benz, director of personal finance and retirement planning for Morningstar and author of the recently released book, How to Retire: 20 Lessons for a Happy, Successful, and Wealthy Retirement. The lessons range from nitty gritty financial matters to quality-of-life considerations that help pre-retirees and retirees maximize their “time on earth” allocations. Have a money question? Email us here Subscribe to Jill on Money LIVE YouTube: @jillonmoney Instagram: @jillonmoney Twitter: @jillonmoney "Jill on Money" theme music is by Joel Goodman, www.joelgoodman.com. To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 In the market to buy a new car? You are not alone. Navy Federal Credit Union members have a helping hand. Technically, a helping globe. A mission assistant. Whose mission is guiding you through your car buying journey. Offering low rates that can save you more. Your mission assistant helps your budget, estimate your payment, and understand your terms so you roll into the dealership ready to negotiate on your terms. Mission Assist. Everything you need to buy a car, all rolled into one. Navy Federal Credit Union. Our members are the mission. Navy Federal is insured by NCUA. Credit and collateral subject to approval.
0:30 Speaker 01 Make a bed you can't wait to unmake. Start with Bull and Branch's buttery soft signature sheets. Made with organic cotton. Only 1% of the world's cotton meets their standards of softness. Add pillows to sink into, and a duvet to pull close. Save 25% site-wide at bullandbranch.com with code ODYSSEY. Bull and Branch. Magic in every moment. Exclusions apply. See site for details.
0:58 Speaker 02 Welcome to the Jill on Money Show. It's Saturday, November 30th. I hope you had a good Thanksgiving, a good Black Friday, and that all is well this holiday weekend. This is the program that tries to help you take the mystery out of your financial life. We do that by asking you to do just a little bit of work by going to our website, jillonthemoney.com. And then in the upper right-hand corner, there is a button that says "Contact Us." Click that button. You'll be able to see a form that pops up. That's the email we receive. If you would like to join us live, you just check the box and we will do everything else. While you're on the website, don't forget to sign up for the free weekly newsletter. Today and tomorrow, I've got a great interview with Christine Benz.
1:42 Speaker 02 Now, maybe you've heard that name. She is the Director of Personal Finance and Retirement Planning for Morningstar. And she has just written a book that's called "How to Retire: 20 Lessons for a Happy, Successful, and Wealthy Retirement." So today, we're going to talk about why she's written this book, and tomorrow, we'll focus on more of the tips from that book. So I hope you enjoy it. This is the first part of my interview with Christine Benz. So Christine, why'd you write this book? Or why did you actually decide you wanted to pursue this idea of how to retire?
2:18 Speaker 03 Well, it was a little bit of me-search in that I, you know, getting to be in age and my peers are getting to be in age where all of this stuff is of greater interest to us for personal reasons. And so there were a lot of questions that I wanted to ask. And then relatedly, I had been kind of toiling exclusively in the financial area of retirement planning and along the way realized there was all kinds of stuff, frankly, more important questions that I wasn't really asking about the non-financial aspects of retirement. So things like healthcare and housing and purpose and identity, all of it's kind of the softer
3:00 Speaker 03 things, which I think go hand in hand with the financial piece. The financial piece is kind of table stakes, but you need to be thinking about what you will do with your days and how you will, you know, find relationships when you're no longer working and all of that stuff. So I wanted to write and work on a book that was very holistic in that way, which I think how to retire ultimately is.
3:23 Speaker 02 Yeah, and I think you've done a great job in a lot of different voices here. I just want to start with the foreword because Jonathan Clements is, has penned the foreword before he got this horrible diagnosis, right?
3:35 Speaker 03 Yeah, that's exactly right. So Jonathan was such an inspiration to me personally in my career trajectory. When I started as an analyst at Morningstar, which was sort of in the mid 1990s, I remember thinking it was part of my job to read the whole Wall Street Journal cover to cover, which is ridiculous, but that was what I was doing because I thought I needed to stay up to date on all these corporate actions and, you know, coming, comings and goings at various companies. And along the way, I stumbled upon Jonathan's column in the journal. He was the longtime personal finance columnist there and I was continually struck by the idea that this guy is telling people what they really need to know. A lot
4:20 Speaker 03 of this other stuff in the paper here is just noise, but here's someone who's just coming back to the idea of investing regularly, keeping your head down, buying low-cost index mutual funds and not monkeying around too much and not being too disturbed by the noise that inevitably accompanies market cycles. And so-
4:44 Speaker 03 I asked Jonathan to write the foreword to the book. He has written several books of his own and he has this humble dollar blog that he works on. And I'm glad no one was filming me jumping up and down in my kitchen when I saw his email that he said he would do it. And it was just such an honor. He wrote a beautiful foreword. And subsequently, Jill, as you alluded to earlier this year in the spring, Jonathan received a diagnosis that he has a lung cancer that has metastasized and is getting quite aggressive treatment for that cancer. But for someone who has always been incredibly healthy during his lifetime, which as long as I've known Jonathan, he's been so committed to exercise and healthy
5:28 Speaker 03 eating, healthy living, it was a really stunning, devastating blow. He's just in his early 60s.
5:36 Speaker 02 And what's also fascinating about this is that he is writing about his journey. I think that like as we talk about your book, it is also very fair to kind of to bring to the fore the fact that we always say, oh, you're planning for decades in the future and that you have to weigh that against this idea of you never know what could happen next. And so what I'm wondering for you is how you feel about having this whole book down and then hearing this about your friend and colleague?
6:13 Speaker 03 Yeah, it's you're absolutely right. The time on earth allocations, we talk about them less, but ultimately they're so much more important than how we allocate our investment portfolios. And by this life stage, you know, I've been working for three decades, as you've said, so you can kind of do the math on my age, you inevitably have loved ones in your life who you've lost. And to a person, when I think about some of the people who I've lost prematurely, they've all been incredibly committed to fitness, healthy living. And so there's only so much of this that is within our control, which is a striking aspect.
6:53 Speaker 03 Of Jonathan's diagnosis as well as several others that I've encountered with friends. So, yeah, it does kind of light a fire under me, all of us, I think, to kind of step back and say, well, how are we planning to use this precious remaining time? And we don't know how long it'll be. So, yeah.
7:16 Speaker 02 And you have this, you have a vast audience in the public eye, but at Morningstar, the kind of people who might choose to listen to your podcast or my podcast, look, the funnel is pretty narrow, right? They're nerdy people who are listening to a personal finance podcast, right?
7:31 Speaker 03 Right.
7:31 Speaker 02 And I like the idea that some of this book has less to do with the numbers. Like, of course, you know, we know that there's going to be an asset allocation and that, you know what I mean? But what were some of the lessons that took you by surprise, or may have changed the way you yourself will approach your own retirement?
7:54 Speaker 03 Michael Fink kicked off the book. He's a researcher and the head of the Financial Planning Program at the American College. And he talks about creating a vision for your retirement. Unfortunately, the way we work in this country is so intense for many of us that we arrive at retirement with just like pent up demand to do leisure activities or to get more sleep, you know, that we really don't spend time visualizing what we will do with those days. And yes, you know, you may want to golf or watch all the Netflix shows that you haven't been able to see or whatever, that inevitably will want to pursue
8:34 Speaker 03 leisure and travel. But Michael's point is that you need to relax from something. And I think we can all reflect on points in our careers where we've taken a break, where we've had a vacation or a sabbatical or whatever. And if you've been working really hard leading up to that break, it just feels so much better. And I think retirement is the same way, where you need to think about things that will give you purpose and perhaps a sense of identity that maybe reaches back into your career. And then
9:07 Speaker 03 The contrast with leisure and relaxation will be all the better. But I think unfortunately, a lot of people kind of stop their ideation around retirement with kind of the leisure visualization and don't, don't think enough about the other stuff.
9:22 Speaker 02 I mean, I like the idea that, you know, when he says, "Your life is basically a row of dots," right? And you keep kind of go like one bit at a time, but then how do you think ahead? It's very hard to imagine yourself in the future. And I guess that many of us do that, you know, through the lens of our own parents. I guess that for me, it's interesting to kind of look at maybe how my, my parents or my grandparents managed retirement as a model of maybe what I want or what I don't want. How do you visualize that for yourself?
9:57 Speaker 03 Yeah, absolutely, Jill. I think that is a beautiful way to think about it because we all have reference points from our own lives of people who have done retirement really well and those who maybe have had less successful retirements, either because they just kind of retreated to the couch and watched a ton of TV. And I think we all have reference points for that. And then you have people who have fully seized on this time in their lives and, and made the best of it. So I, I do think that it's helpful for all of us to, to reference the aging situations that we've observed often from helping family members through this period of their lives.
10:37 Speaker 03 And it's also, as you said, to, important to, to visualize the different stages of retirement because it's, I think it's kind of the human condition where you believe that it will ever be thus, that, that the body you're living in this moment will always be just as healthy as it is. And unfortunately, that's not the case, that we do need to kind of get ahead of some of the changes that it will, will inevitably accompany aging. And to the extent that you can do that, you can put yourself in the driver's seat, that it really is unfair to put loved ones around us in the, you know, unfortunate position of having to figure out. Well, okay, they can't stay in this house any longer. Where are they gonna go?
11:22 Speaker 03 Try to get ahead of decision making like that by, you know, pre-identifying, well, here's what I want and really articulating what you want and how you want your aging to unfold and, you know, what kind of supports you might want around yourself.
11:38 Speaker 02 How do you, how do you divide up the different stages of retirement? How would you do that?
11:42 Speaker 03 I think a big three is kind of a helpful way, you know, and it's been often shorthanded as like the go-go, slow-go, no-go periods of retirement. But I do think that that's a helpful way to visualize it. So go-go would be the early years where you have perhaps a lot of travel that you want to do. This is often people's healthiest part of retirement and it could be 10 years, it could be 20 years, it could be shorter. And those are often the high-spending years of retirement where staying put in your current home is going to be perfectly appropriate in many situations. And then kind of the slow-go would be you're maybe backing off on some of that travel.
12:26 Speaker 03 Maybe you're still going somewhere for the winter months or something like that, but you are not as comfy on overseas flights as perhaps you were when you were younger. Spending, when we look at the data, does tend to trend down during those slow-go years of retirement. And then no-go would be where someone has health conditions that are impeding their ability to do a lot, where, you know, maybe they are moving to some sort of situation where they have more supports around them, or at least moving to a living situation like a, you know, a condo or something like that where you no longer have stairs.
13:08 Speaker 03 And certainly, what we know when we look at the data is that health conditions can, can deliver some significant changes in terms of quality of life. And then we also know that the incidence of cognitive decline is much greater the further along in our aging cycle.
13:26 Speaker 02 You know, it's interesting because I'm just thinking about my, my mom who is in her eighties. And what's been fascinating to watch about retirement among her friends is that it's almost like they've benefited from the fact that, that, you know, they're lucky enough, they're alive and all this. It's almost like they've living long, healthy lives, but this, this entrance into no-go is emotionally very difficult, I think. I mean, it's one thing to be like, obviously you're traveling, you're fun. Well, everything's good. Slow go. Okay, I'm, I'm still feeling pretty good, but this no-go is
14:07 Speaker 02 really emotionally significant. Now, in, in putting this book together, or even in your experience as Director of Retirement Planning and Personal Finance, what tools do you think people have for, for entering and navigating these big transitions? Go-go to slow-go, but more importantly, I think to no-go, which is much more difficult as, as human beings to sort of like, okay, um, yes, my friend does have to go into assisted living. I may not, but maybe I will. And when should I do it? So what do you think are resources that people can use to have those kinds of conversations? And also for the person, him or herself?
14:48 Speaker 03 Yeah, it's such an important question, Jill. I was with my mother-in-law, my husband and I were with his, his mom over the weekend and she's in her nineties, still doing well, but we had been helping with various things in her condo. And my husband said on the ride back to our house, he was like, I don't know why it's so draining. And I said, because it's, it's sad. It's hard to see your loved one slow down in that way. And in terms of, you know, kind of getting our arms around these stages, there are actually tools where you can visualize your future self. I don't know if you've seen any of them, Jill, where you can actually like age yourself.
15:29 Speaker 02 Yeah.
15:30 Speaker 03 And I do think that it's helpful. I, I have not used one of those tools. I've been too scared, but um, really.
15:36 Speaker 02 We no longer have to dye our hairs.
15:38 Speaker 03 Well, that's true.
15:39 Speaker 02 It's fabulous.
15:40 Speaker 03 But the idea is to try to empathize with your future self. And I think that that can be such a valuable exercise, whether you do it literally by looking at a photograph of yourself, you know, 20 or 30 years into the future. But the idea is to try to articulate what you want, what you don't want, and to the extent that we can be clear about these things with our loved ones and share our thoughts on our attitudes toward care if we should need it. I think that's such a valuable step to take. And there are resources, I don't have any off the top of my head, but there are worksheets
16:23 Speaker 03 and such where you can document what you want in terms of your living situation if you're not able to make decisions for yourself. I would urge people to avail themselves of those kinds of tools. Cameron Huddleston has a great book, I think the book is called Mom and Dad We Need to Talk. And it's about kind of easing these conversations between parents and children. For those of us who don't have children, it's an even more difficult exercise, and I think it's incumbent upon us to really, truly lay the groundwork in terms of identifying what sorts of living situations we would find palatable if we should need help with our,
17:08 Speaker 03 you know, activities of daily living later in life, to pre-identify that rather than leaving, say, my nieces and nephews to sort that out for me.
17:16 Speaker 02 Right. You know, it's interesting, we've had a bunch of calls recently from our community, from our listeners, people who have gotten to the precipice of retirement, and they've got all the money stuff set, okay? But they really are having a hard time giving themselves permission to spend.
17:35 Speaker 03 Yes.
17:37 Speaker 02 How would you counsel people around that as a hurdle? That like, you know what? I've been saving my whole life and now I just, I'm so scared about the decumulation or spending phase.
17:51 Speaker 03 Exactly. I think this is a hugely under discussed problem, frankly. And it's almost perverse to talk about because we obviously have a lot of people in our society who are really undersaved relative to what they need for retirement where underspending is not at all an issue. But then this other segment, the one you reference, are the people who have identified as savers throughout their investing careers. And flipping that switch is really quite psychologically difficult. And my husband and I have a financial planner. She tells us that we will struggle with this, which is one reason why I think some people just think, I'm just going to keep working because I don't even want to deal with that
18:35 Speaker 03 sort of psychological pressure that I'll feel. But there are a couple of things that I think people can think about. One, Jamie Hopkins references in the book is this idea of trial running some spending prior to retirement. My husband and I recently had to buy a car and we were sitting there in the dealer's office and they're like, well, do you want to finance the car? And then they referenced some ridiculous interest rate and we're like, heck no, we're not financing a car. We'll pay cash. But then you do have to, you know, see how that feels. It doesn't feel great to see that big check going to this purchase. But I do think it's a good way to kind of get your sea legs with respect to seeing that it's not just you funneling money into your investment accounts.
19:20 Speaker 03 At some point, it has to start moving the other way. So I would say people should trial run that in the years leading up to retirement. And then some research that has been done by academics actually points to the value of perhaps some type of an annuity purchase figuring into this. And people who have that income that is coming regularly from this annuity buy might have a little easier time with it, with spending that money because they're not having to periodically invade their investment accounts. It's kind of a one and done purchase. So I think behaviorally, it might help address this permission to spend problem.
20:02 Speaker 02 If you've got a question about retirement or any other financial issue that's going on in your life, get in touch with us. Go to jillonthemoney.com and click the Contact Us button. You can subscribe to us on the Odyssey app or wherever you find your favorite podcasts. Please leave us a rating and review wherever you listen. And don't forget, do something nice for someone else today. Change your work, change your wealth, change your life. Thank you for listening and we'll talk to you tomorrow.
Previous Social Security Elimination Next How to Retire Part Two Page updated November 15, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated