Pod Insights Jill on Money with Jill Schlesinger How to Handle My Pension Options About this episode With various pension options to choose from, analysis paralysis is starting to set in. Have a money question? Email us here Subscribe to Jill on Money LIVE Subscribe to Jill on Money Newsletter YouTube: @jillonmoney Instagram: @jillonmoney Twitter: @jillonmoney "Jill on Money" theme music is by Joel Goodman, www.joelgoodman.com. To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:03 Speaker 00 Welcome to the Jill on Money Show. It's Wednesday, March 4th, and we are here trying to answer your financial questions. If you've got one, all you need to do is go to our website, jillonthemoney.com. And when you're there, in the upper right-hand corner, wherever you are navigating on that website, you will see a Contact Us button. When you click on that button, a form pops up. That's the email that we receive. If you're shy, and you don't think you want to come on the program, give us a lot of details. And again, please, don't forget about the whole, what do I spend every month? That's our big one that we always say, oh, follow up with how much money you're spending. And give us any other details, like good, good highlights, good color commentary. If you do want to join us on the program, check the box. Mark will do
0:47 Speaker 00 everything else. He'll bring you on the air live with us. We love talking to you live. Why? Because then I get to ask you more nosy questions. And sometimes you'll notice that some of the big questions that we are tackling have to do with the emotions that are underneath the actual financial question that you are posing to us. So that's why we like having you on the air. And if you are shy, don't worry, you can change your name, you can change your location, we'll protect you. But if you are shy, yes, we do emails. And today is an email show. So, this is from Jill, not me Jill, another Jill. Subject, prenup thoughts. Okay, Jill writes, "My daughter is in her early 30s. She recently got engaged. She's been working in a lucrative
1:28 Speaker 00 field, no debt, lives and works in California. She's got reasonable rent, she lives pretty cheap, and she's been able to save what I would consider a good amount of money. She maxes out her 401k, she's got $200,000 in brokerage and bank accounts. Her fiance is about the same age, he doesn't appear to have the same money saved. He's frugal, his career is not lucrative. Should I ask her to consider a prenup before getting married?" Well, I think that what you can do is try to encourage her to make sure she's having conversations with her fiance about money and how they manage it. And then have a real conversation about maybe what they should be doing is just keeping
2:10 Speaker 00 Their money separate because a lot of, a lot of the law around matrimony is simply about co-mingling assets. So I think that if you want to not have an actual prenup, this may not be enough money to really do that, but to at least have a conversation, it can address it. And if you don't co-mingle assets and something goes south, then maybe you can have that, you'll have that money separate. On the other hand, I do understand that a lot of the younger generation, Mark, I'm sure you've read this also. They are very much more into prenups. If you look at a lot of the data on who's actually creating prenups and postnups, which is like you're already married and you want to have some sort of agreement if things go south.
2:55 Speaker 00 They may be open to it. So just make sure that she has that conversation. I think that's more important than anything else. All right. Next up, we've got a question from Stephanie. Greetings Jill and Mark. I'm hoping to call it a career in two years if possible. I'm 61, wife is 59. I've been in healthcare for my entire life. I'm hoping to turn the page within the next 24 months. Here is our current financial situation. Holy smokes, Stephanie's gross pay 450 grand. Wow. I haven't always made this much money. It's only been for a few years. My wife runs the household. I will be entitled to a small pension when I turn 65, $600 a month.
3:37 Speaker 00 Social Security at age 67 will be $4,000. At 70, it's over $5,000. And my wife's social security, much less, not sure the amount. Okay, here's what I got. A 403B with $1.2 million, all pre-tax. I will begin Roth contributions starting this year. My wife has an IRA, $1.6 million, some is Roth. The rest is a stock portfolio she inherited and those funds are managed by her CFP. Oh my gosh, we own three properties, all paid off. Okay, house number one, $1.1 million. House two, $350,000. And then the third house is also $350,000.
4:22 Speaker 00 One of those two, they're going to sell when she retires. Emergency fund, 50 grand. We use a lot of money to pay for that third house.
4:34 Speaker 00 And she, there's a funny little side note that she basically is like, I needed an escape hatch, someplace to hide. Okay. They are trying to save a lot of money in the next two years, debt-free, drive older cars. We want to have a little bit more fun. They spend $6,000 a month and we anticipate an increase in our monthly spending in the early years of retirement, not by a crazy amount. Two adult children, financially secure. My father is 92, my mother is 84. I don't think I'm going to have to take care of them financially. Okay. Here's the plan. Work another two years, then work part-time. Remember that she's 61. So at 63, she says, I'm going to fill in for
5:15 Speaker 00 vacations. Ideally, I'd like to retire and be done. It's been a long career in trauma intensive care for the last 18 years. Mark, you thinking about our nurses in the, in the pit or what? I love those nurses so much. Okay. Ready for the questions? Can I retire in two years? Or should I extend for another year after that? That's number one. Number two, how can I lower my tax burden from that pre-tax 403B? Remember, she's got a $1.2 million pre-tax 403B. She doesn't have a CFP. She says the plan is in the hospital's plan, that 403B. Third question is, should she move
5:57 Speaker 00 her retirement fund when she retires or leave it where it is and see if they have a CFP? Okay. So let's do big picture. It sounds like she and the wife are managing money separately, but just to be clear, they've got $2.8 million saved up. There will be another 350, right? When the house number two is sold. So I guess the question is, can she do this two, in two years, be done?
6:27 Speaker 00 Making that 450 grand. And then maybe she just goes a little, like when she says part-time, I'm sure it's going to be much less. I don't know how much money she would make. Um, what do you think, Mark? Do you think that that's a possibility? I mean, she'll get, I'm, I'm sort of thinking that we wait for so, I, I don't know her health, but let's just say she gets her small pension when she turns 65. Let's say she's at 63 to, maybe she does like two years of part-time, just to get her to Medicare and keep, keep, keep some health insurance. Six grand a month. I'm just looking at this. So she'll have, I think I have the game plan. Mark, do you think she's okay for her retirement in two years?
7:05 Speaker 01 I do. I mean, really, it's just a seven-year gap that we have to cover until
7:09 Speaker 00 Yes.
7:10 Speaker 01 age 70. And she wants to reduce her tax burden. Well, tho- those are seven years to start reducing your tax burden.
7:16 Speaker 00 So that's what I'm thinking exactly. So here's what we think makes sense. So you have seven years at 63. I'm not even sure you need to work part-time unless you just want to, but let's just say that's gravy. So let's say that for those 63 to 70, and again, I'm presuming you're in good health because you wouldn't claim, you wouldn't wait to claim at 70 unless you were in good health. You said you needed 6,000 a month. Let's make it 7,000 a month. Okay. Let's make it that. Then let's say that you pull the money that you need over those seven years from that pre-tax retirement account. That's what you'll do. And you'll say, let's just say you took 100 grand a year out of that account. Just
8:00 Speaker 00 like, you know, for fun. 100 grand a year for seven years. Maybe it's even 120 grand a year. We'll make it nice even numbers. 10 grand a month. You'll have to pay tax on it. You do that for seven years. You claim your social security. You get that five grand. You will have, and we haven't even talked about your, your wife's money. And you will also have that extra money that you have from the sale of the second home, which will be in a brokerage account. And you're good. I think that's totally, I think that's worth, that's the, that should be the game plan. I don't think you need to convert. I don't think you need to worry about that. You pull the money out of the account. And you know, for all intents and purposes, even if you had to do a little bit, even a little more money over those seven years.
8:44 Speaker 00 Let's presume that if they're married filing jointly and they've got some income from other stuff, everything gets delayed till age 70. I mean, I think that in terms of social security claiming, but like you could take 150 grand a year out of that and you're still in the 22% tax bracket. It'll be better than what you're doing now. So work for two years, start pulling out, you know, at least 10, maybe 12 grand a month out of your retire, your pre-tax retirement account, pay the taxes, do live on the money. You'll still probably have money left at the end. You'll have your wife's money left at the end. You'll have money in a retirement account. All good. I don't know about the CFP. I'd really have to talk to you about it.
9:26 Speaker 00 Generally speaking, I would probably move the money out of the retirement fund. And if you want to hire a CFP to do this, you certainly can. And maybe you, you should, but maybe you should talk to your wife's CFP just because they know the story already. Anyway, get back in touch with us if you think you've got more follow-up questions. All right. Get ready for this. Marcus writes, I'm 49 years old, single, an air force veteran. My monthly expenses are $2,500 a month. I currently make $53,000 annually and bring in an additional 12 grand in VA compensation.
10:06 Speaker 00 At age 65, I will receive $1,700 a month in social security, 700 in pension, 14 a month in VA comp, all this money, my God. Would it be a smart financial decision to retire at age 62 or just wait till 65? I don't have kids, family that will need my assistance. I enjoy your show. Thanks for the help. Okay. Marcus is 49, got a lot of money, will have plenty of income. I think Marcus, the answer to this question is it's not financial. Uh, I think that obviously you'll have healthcare because you're an air force veteran, which is what most people, the reason why most people delay a retirement till 65 is for health benefits. You should do whatever you want to do. That's what I think. And I don't think it's a financial decision.
10:50 Speaker 00 It's about what you want to do. Okay, Tracy needs guidance on pension options. Okay, Tracy says, "I'll be 70 years old in July, single, no kids." Boy, we have a lot of singletons today. "Retired in 2022. Monthly expenses about, let's call it six grand a month, which includes 12 years left of a mortgage. Since retiring, I've been living off social security, which I began taking in, at the end of 2022, and the social security payment, 3750. 55 grand in an online savings account. I have a will way back when.
11:30 Speaker 00 In December, I rolled over my pre-tax retirement account into an IRA. It's about a million dollars. And there's a Roth account with 90 grand." Okay, so here are the pension options, okay? There's a basic plan has a choice to be made. And an annuity that increases 1% every month until I take it and it's available, nine grand a month. Oh, my God, this guy's gonna, or girl, I don't know if it's a girl or a guy. You get an annuity payment and a monthly payment, or you can get a lump sum with a lower annuity. You know, the lump sum is like between 500 and 600,000 dollars. But let me listen to this. "Some days," this is what Tracy says, "some days I feel as though I should just take the basic annuity.
12:15 Speaker 00 I need assistance running the numbers as to what my best option could be. Would it be best to roll over both lump sums into the Fidelity account? The basic plan rolling over the lump sum, taking the lesser annuity plus my social security would cover my monthly expenses. I look forward to your thoughtful and insightful guidance. Love your show." So, Mark, I have an idea what I would do. Okay, remember, this is somebody who is single. And you know, kinda it's 70 years old. I think there's like the monthly expenses would be covered almost either way with this choice, right?
12:53 Speaker 00 So either if you have a lesser annuity amount of 4,500 plus the social security basically covers completely. So the question is, how much will it give you peace of mind to have that nine grand a month just come in? How much will it bug you if you drop dead three days after you receive it that nobody else is going to get that money? Because there's the funny thing with an annuity. It's usually based on just your life, right? A straight line annuity and because you're not married and you don't have kids, no one else will get it. But maybe you don't care. So if you don't really care and you want to make your life easy, you can take that annuity amount.
13:34 Speaker 00 If you'd say like, like to have some of the annuity income and some of that peace of mind, but you can take the another chunk of money and half a million and pop it right into your retirement account with fidelity, then that's fine, too. I guess it really depends on like how you feel if something were to happen to you and you died suddenly after receiving an annuity, that whatever that annuity amount was would just go away as opposed to having a chunky lump sum that gets put into an account that somebody or even a charity would inherit. So Mark, which way are you leaning?
14:15 Speaker 01 Yeah, I mean, without knowing more info, I like the idea of just getting that straight annuity, 9,000 a month, knowing all my needs are covered right then and there and they're, you know, they're still social security, there's still a million dollars in the rollover. But you know, if there's a real, you know, if there's a favorite niece or nephew or something, then you know, I can be convinced otherwise.
14:35 Speaker 00 Yeah, I could go as I agree, I could totally see either way. So it's like, oh, I want to like have, I just don't want to think anymore. I really am interested because one of the things that I think this one sentence is really important to listen to. Some days I feel as though I should take the basic plan annuity because I think you want that peace of mind, but get back in touch with us and I think you're not going to go wrong either way. This is from Rich. Subject: This is important. Jill and Mark, you have to keep watching season two of Hijack. It has gotten so good. Keep the faith and keep watching. You're welcome. LOL. Rich?
15:15 Speaker 00 I did keep watching. I did.
15:17 Speaker 01 Me too, me too.
15:17 Speaker 00 And do you agree with Rich?
15:20 Speaker 01 Yeah, it's definitely gotten better. I'm not done. Actually, no, it only comes out weekly because it's on Apple TV, so you can't sit there and binge it. But I'm up to date. Yeah, it's gotten much better. I'm hooked.
15:30 Speaker 00 Yeah. I mean, listen, I'm in. He's amazing. So let's just be clear that he is so good. And I'm very, I'm always happy to watch him, you know, essentially read a telephone book. So that's good. It's not as good as the first season. It's gotten a little convoluted still, but I'm caught up as well. Also, Paradise coming back on Hulu. Are you watching that? Did you watch that?
15:53 Speaker 01 I don't know that. I know we are watching Shrinkin'. We're a big fan of that show.
15:57 Speaker 00 That's so good. All right, gang, if you've got streaming requests and suggestions for us, then please let us know. And you can do that at jillonthemoney.com and clicking the Contact Us button. You can also use that exact same button to actually just ask us a financial question. We'd love to hear from you. You can subscribe to us on the Odyssey app or wherever you find your favorite podcasts. Please leave us a rating and review wherever you listen. Put your hands metaphorically on someone's back. Come on, someone needs a little bit of a hug, someone needs a pat on the back, maybe you do it for real. I always ask permission, gang. I'm a hugger. I always ask people, you okay with me giving you a hug? It's kind of smart to do. Change your work, change your wealth, change your life. Thanks for listening. We'll talk to you tomorrow.
Previous On Track for FINE? Next Financially Supporting a Parent Page updated November 14, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated