Summary
Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.
This special Labor Day edition of the show features retiring automotive expert Mike Quincy reflecting on his 34-year career at Consumer Reports. The host and the guest explore the current landscape of the automotive industry, covering topics such as used cars, electric vehicles, hybrids, and the reliability of various car brands. They explain why Consumer Reports remains the gold standard in independent product testing, why high-end electric vehicles and certain luxury brands struggle with depreciation and reliability, and why hybrids and sedans remain the most practical and economical choice for everyday drivers.
- If your older car is running well and not costing you a fortune in repairs, continuing to drive it into the ground is the most economical decision. 7:02
- Hybrids from brands like Toyota, Lexus, and Honda offer exceptional reliability and massive cruising ranges, making them ideal for heavy commuters. 17:08
- Parents should buy teenagers safe, reliable sedans instead of SUVs or pickups, and avoid models with too many teenage passengers. 23:19
- Minivans like the Toyota Sienna and Kia Carnival are underrated, practical family vehicles that outperform SUVs in utility and fuel range. 42:51
Chapters
- 0:05Episode Introduction and Guest Reveal
Hosts introduce the special Labor Day episode and announce Mike Quincy as the guest.
- 1:13Mike Quincy’s Career Overview
Mike Quincy discusses his 34-year tenure at Consumer Reports and his retirement decision.
- 3:15Consumer Reports’ Credibility and Future
Conversation about Consumer Reports’ reputation, subscription model, and hopes for continued quality journalism.
- 7:01Car Ownership Decision-Making
Hosts ask Mike for advice on when to keep or replace a car based on costs and mileage.
- 7:36Hybrid vs. EV for Everyday Use
Discussion of hybrids as a practical alternative to EVs, especially for long commutes and high gas prices.
- 11:02EV Market Trends and Depreciation
Mike explains the rapid depreciation of high-end EVs and the cooling of the EV market.
- 23:19Choosing a Car for Teen Drivers
Mike gives guidance on selecting safe, reliable sedans over SUVs for teenage drivers.
- 26:58Industry Trends: Small Cars and Affordability
Exploration of market pressure for smaller, more affordable vehicles and the impact on used car prices.
- 30:55Specific Brand Insights: Volvos, Land Rovers, Fisker
Mike shares his experiences and reliability concerns with Volvo, Land Rover, and Fisker vehicles.
- 40:07Sports Cars and Retirement Fun
Discussion on affordable sports cars for retirees, including Miata, Mustang, and Nissan Z.
- 42:51Minivans vs. SUVs for Families
Mike advocates for minivans over SUVs for family practicality and space.
- 43:49Pickup Trucks for Work and Lifestyle
Comparison of the top pickup trucks and recommendation of the Ford F-150 for most users.
Highlights
- 4:45
Consumer Reports Test Trackinsight
The guest explains that Consumer Reports buys all of its own test cars and accepts no advertising, allowing reviewers to publish unvarnished truths about vehicle flaws.
- 11:02
The guest notes that high-end electric vehicles from brands like Audi, Mercedes, BMW, and Tesla experienced massive depreciation, losing up to 50% of their value after testing.
- 14:05
The guest reveals that startup electric vehicle maker Rivian ranked dead last in Consumer Reports reliability surveys, proving that legacy manufacturers still excel at mass production.
- 29:43
Long Commute Hybrid Benefitsstrategy
The guest explains that hybrid cars excel in heavy traffic because their electric motors allow them to creep along at low speeds without turning on the gas engine.
- 30:55
Volvo Reliability Rankinginsight
The guest points out that Volvos have never ranked at the top of reliability surveys and become very expensive to maintain once they are out of warranty.
- 33:03
Jeep Wrangler As A Toyinsight
The guest describes the Jeep Wrangler as a fun vehicle for warm weather or the beach with the top down, but warns that it makes a terrible, noisy daily commuter car.
- 40:07
The Mazda Miata Standardinsight
The guest praises the Mazda Miata as the ultimate affordable sports car, highlighting its exceptional manual transmission, reliability, and rear-wheel-drive performance.
Quotes
“Consumer Reports doesn't pull any punches. So if a car has flaws, and every car has flaws, we're going to point out what about the car is not so hot.”
Unnamed speaker · 4:24 “If the vehicle is running okay, and isn't costing you a lot of money every month, like you said, you just, you continue to drive it into the ground. That's the cheapest way to spend your automotive dollars.”
Unnamed speaker · 7:02 “The Sienna got real popular the last couple of years, and I'm not saying it's because I'm telling all the young families out there, forget an SUV, get a minivan. I love minivans.”
Unnamed speaker · 42:41
About this episode
After 34 years with Consumer Reports, Mike Quincy https://www.consumerreports.org/about-us/our-people/our-experts/mike-quincy/ is calling it a career, and on this Labor Day holiday, he joins us for his final appearance as the automotive writer at CR. Have a money question? Email us here https://www.jillonmoney.com/contact Subscribe to Jill on Money LIVE https://www.jillonmoney.com/pricing-page Subscribe to Jill on Money Newsletter https://www.jillonmoney.com/substack YouTube: @jillonmoney https://www.youtube.com/c/JillSchlesinger Instagram: @jillonmoney https://www.instagram.com/jillonmoney "Jill on Money" theme music is by Joel Goodman, www.joelgoodman.com http://www.joelgoodman.com/.
Transcript
8,045 words · 2 speakers
Topics
- Consumer Reports
- Miata
- Jill on Money
- New York
- Polestar
- Rivian
- Ford F-150
- Toyota Camry
- Tesla
- Fisker
Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated