Summary
Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.
Laura, a 59-year-old retiree living in the South with her 68-year-old husband, calls in to evaluate an annuity pitch from her long-time financial advisor. The couple retired at the end of 2021 with no pensions, relying on the husband's $28,000 annual Social Security, a $25,000 part-time income, and $30,000 annual distributions from a $370,000 pre-tax inherited IRA. Their remaining assets include $920,000 in personal IRAs, $200,000 in a brokerage account, $300,000 in inherited Roth IRAs, and $120,000 in cash and I-bonds, alongside a $600,000 home with a $300,000 mortgage. The advisor has proposed taking a $225,000 IRA and placing it into a variable indexed annuity that grows at 6% until income is turned on, offering a 5% joint life payout with upside market potential and downside protection, but also carrying high fees.
The host argues that the annuity is an unnecessary complication because the couple is already in strong financial shape and can easily fund their near-term gap using existing assets and scheduled distributions. Instead of paying high annuity fees that are two to three times the advisor's current 1% management fee, the host outlines a multi-year plan utilizing the inherited IRA, upcoming required minimum distributions from the husband's accounts, and eventual Social Security benefits to cover expenses. Furthermore, the host advises reducing near-term risk on the inherited IRA by laddering funds into certificates of deposit for the amounts needed over the next few years, and suggests shopping around for a fee-only certified financial planner to get a second opinion outside of the current advisor relationship.
- Review your short-term cash needs and consider laddering guaranteed instruments like certificates of deposit for money you must withdraw over the next one to three years. 20:35
- Evaluate whether high-fee financial products like variable indexed annuities are truly necessary when your existing retirement assets and scheduled distributions already cover your projected living expenses. 11:13
- Seek out a fee-only certified financial planner who does not collect commissions if you want an objective second opinion on your long-term retirement and investment strategy. 19:01
Chapters
- 0:03Podcast Intro and Guest Introduction
The host welcomes listeners and introduces Laura, the guest, setting the stage for the discussion about annuities.
- 1:30Laura’s Retirement Financial Snapshot
Laura details her age, retirement status, income sources, and current financial situation, including Social Security and part‑time work.
- 5:57Inherited IRA and Current Asset Breakdown
Laura explains the inherited IRA, other IRAs, brokerage holdings, Roths, and real estate, outlining her overall asset picture.
- 8:49Annuity Pitch Overview
Laura describes the annuity proposal, its growth assumptions, payout rates, and associated fees.
- 11:13Critique of the Annuity Proposal
The host challenges the annuity’s value, pointing out high fees and questioning its necessity given Laura’s financial health.
- 12:50Alternative Income Strategy Using RMDs
The host outlines a plan to use inherited IRA distributions and required minimum distributions to cover living expenses without an annuity.
- 17:00Closing Advice and Call to Action
The host wraps up with final thoughts on the annuity decision and invites listeners to reach out for further financial guidance.
- 18:11Discussion on Financial Advisor Relationship
Laura and the host discuss the role of their current advisor, fiduciary status, and the idea of seeking a fee‑only planner for an unbiased view.
Highlights
- 1:37
Retirement Assets And Income Sourcesdata
The guest outlines the couple's retirement setup, noting that they retired at the end of 2021 without pensions and live on a combination of the husband's Social Security, the guest's part-time work, and distributions from inherited traditional IRAs.
- 5:57
Complete Household Asset Overviewdata
The guest details their total net worth, which includes approximately $920,000 in personal IRAs, $200,000 in a brokerage account, $300,000 in inherited Roth IRAs, $120,000 in cash and I-bonds, and a home worth $600,000 with a $300,000 mortgage.
- 8:49
The Variable Indexed Annuity Pitchstrategy
The financial advisor proposed taking $225,000 from an IRA and placing it into a variable indexed annuity that promises 6% growth until income begins, a 5% payout, and downside protection despite substantial fees.
- 11:13
Unnecessary Product Complicationinsight
The host explains that the annuity is an expensive and unnecessary product for a couple in such strong financial condition, noting that the contract fees would vastly exceed their current 1% advisor management fee.
- 12:01
Creating Your Own Income Streaminsight
The host argues that guaranteed income products are often overvalued when investors can construct their own reliable income streams using existing assets and proper portfolio management.
- 20:35
Lowering Risk With CDsstrategy
The host suggests reducing portfolio risk on the inherited IRA by placing funds needed over the next one to three years into certificates of deposit rather than keeping them fully exposed to market volatility.
Quotes
“a $225,000 IRA, and putting it into a variable indexed annuity.”
Unnamed speaker · 9:04 “it would grow at 6% until we turned on the income stream, and that we could turn it on really at any point in time.”
Unnamed speaker · 9:13 “affected by the market, but also affected by the fees, which were really substantial”
Unnamed speaker · 10:10 “This is not guaranteed income.”
Unnamed speaker · 12:03 “I would say, okay, what amount of money do I know I need every year?”
Unnamed speaker · 20:35
Sponsored segments
- Jill on Money 0:03–0:29
- Money Moves 0:35–0:56
About this episode
Does the annuity pitch we've received make sense given our overall financial situation? Have a money question? Email us here https://www.jillonmoney.com/contact Subscribe to Jill on Money LIVE https://www.jillonmoney.com/pricing-page Subscribe to Jill on Money Newsletter https://www.jillonmoney.com/substack YouTube: @jillonmoney https://www.youtube.com/c/JillSchlesinger Instagram: @jillonmoney https://www.instagram.com/jillonmoney "Jill on Money" theme music is by Joel Goodman, www.joelgoodman.com http://www.joelgoodman.com/.
Transcript
3,897 words · 1 speaker
Topics
- IRA
- Social Security
- Roth IRA
- variable indexed annuity
- I-bonds
- Medicare
Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated