Pod Insights Jill on Money with Jill Schlesinger Can I Retire Before Kids Are Done With College? About this episode I'm 49 and would like to retire in seven years at 56 before my kids are finished with college. Doable? Have a money question? Email us here Subscribe to Jill on Money LIVE Subscribe to Jill on Money Newsletter YouTube: @jillonmoney Instagram: @jillonmoney Twitter: @jillonmoney "Jill on Money" theme music is by Joel Goodman, www.joelgoodman.com. To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 At T. Rowe Price, our experience helps us see investment potential differently. Instead of fast answers, we understand the true road to confident investing is curiosity. It's what drives us to ask smart questions about our ever-changing world. Like, how can clean water transform farmland? Can healthcare innovations create a healthier world? How will AI be a part of a new tomorrow? Our curiosity runs deep, and with it comes the power to help you invest more confidently. Better questions, better outcomes. T. Rowe Price, invest with confidence. Learn more at TrowePrice.com/curiosity.
0:30 Speaker 01 This show is brought to you by our sponsor, TruMe. As kids get older, navigating that first phone milestone brings a real tension between encouraging independence and setting healthy digital boundaries. You want them to reach you after school or check in from a friend's house, but handing over a standard smartphone with open browsing can feel overwhelming. TruMe is a phone and wireless service created specifically as a child's first phone, built to adapt gradually as their maturity develops. With the TruMe Parent Portal, you stay in control by approving contacts, scheduling screen time, managing approved apps, and using GPS location tools when needed, all with
1:12 Speaker 01 social media apps completely out of the picture. Beyond managing access, the portal provides useful usage and activity insights that serve as natural conversation starters. Rather than obsessing over every little thing they're doing on a screen, you get clear context to check in on how they are actually doing. Essential emergency calls like 911 always connect no matter your settings, giving you the confidence as your child takes their first steps into technology. Visit truMe.com to learn more and find the right first phone for your family. TruMe, protect childhood.
1:52 Speaker 01 Welcome to the Jill on Money Show. It's Wednesday, February 4th, and we are here answering your financial questions. If you have something on your mind, something bubbling up, and it remotely touches a dollar or changes the course of your financial life, why don't you get in touch with us? Go to jillonthemoney.com, click the Contact Us button, write us a note. If you would like to join us live, check the box. Mark does everything else because he is the best executive producer in the whole wide world. Hey, while you're on the website, don't forget to sign up for the free weekly newsletter. Check out all the free stuff that's there. You know, we've got another podcast, and it is called Money Watch. We release that on the weekends,
2:35 Speaker 01 and we do try to dive a little deeper into a specific topic. And maybe for folks who need a little refresher, maybe you'd like a little bit deeper dive when you're a younger person, and you think, hey, Jill, you and all your cohort here, you're talking too much about something or other. Check out Money Watch, right there, over there. Money Watch, Saturdays and Sundays. So you can do a little bit of both. Okay? Isn't that cool? All right. Today, we have to answer some emails because we are, you know, they're piling up. So I may bring Mark on just to torture him. He probably just wants to chill out a little bit, but so be it. Okay, so this is from Brian, who writes, "Hi Jill, I love listening to all of your shows. You give
3:18 Speaker 01 the best no-nonsense answers to such a wide range of questions." That's me, Mark, no-nonsense Schlesinger. "My question is," says Brian, "at what age do you think I'll be able to retire?" I know, it's pretty vague, "but my goal is around 56-ish. I'm open. I think I maybe even prefer to continue working in some sort of part-time capacity, or by starting a small service-based solo operator business, where I take on as much work as I want." So here's the information. "I'm 49 years old. I'm married. I've got three kids, 16, 13, and nine, living in New England."
4:00 Speaker 01 Got a single income. My wife is 43 and she has been a stay at home mom since 2010. I'm a managing partner of a successful small business. I have 20% ownership. My salary is about $175,000 a year and our company has profit sharing that has a defined benefit plan. Hmm, listen to this. 21 grand is what he's putting into his traditional 401k, 7 grand into a Roth IRA. Company contributions. There are some rules. He, he mentioned something called a safe harbor. That's basically when you have a bunch of highly compensated people and they limit the amount of money they'll put in for those highly compensated people.
4:41 Speaker 01 So what he's saying is that in addition to his 21 grand a year in his 401k, there's a company defined contribution plan. He gets about 20 grand a year from that. Defined benefit contribution credit last two years, it has been $60,000 a year. Holy smokes. Okay, he's got 700 grand. Let me, let me tally this up a little bit better. It's about 850 in traditional assets, 60 in a Roth, 250 in a brokerage. Uh, he's got $264,000 in the defined benefit plan, which is a cash balance. He's got, um, earnings in the business, uh, his share, $136,000.
5:24 Speaker 01 House is worth 600 grand, 200 grand on the mortgage. High yield savings account, 120. 529 plans for each child are 30 grand. Total is 103. That seems kind of shy on the needs there because let me just go back here. 16139, that's not going to go very far. Okay. Uh, business value is objective.
5:51 Speaker 01 Oh, boy. Partners and I have had an accountant give us a valuation that gives my share, that makes my share worth $800,000. Social Security benefit, $3,800. Not sure about my wife. She only has about 10 years, probably half of his. Anyway, he feels burnt out and he's thinking, maybe he'd sell out in 2032, which would be 56 years old. That would be the year my oldest finishes college. The middle will have two years to complete, and the youngest still three years from starting. Oh, here we go. My understanding is the FAFSA looks at the previous two years' income for need, so this large amount of income for one
6:33 Speaker 01 year wouldn't affect my oldest. It may affect the middle and would be soon enough to not affect the youngest. I could be wrong. We haven't gotten too deep in college planning, but a business sale in a year where FAFSA is analyzing our income would cost us tens of thousands of dollars. Our goal is to be able to help our children attend college and exit without being saddled with extreme debt, but we do not intend on funding the entire bill. Spending about 10 grand a month. 56, I know, seems early for retirement, especially because my youngest will only be 16. But where might I stand at that point? Is this remotely possible? How much would I need to earn at that rate, working part-time, to
7:15 Speaker 01 make this plan work? My intention would be to enter the Health Exchange unless the part-time work or business would offer something better, and that could add to the 10 grand a month. Yes, let's make that 12 grand a month, just for planning purposes. And that's me talking here. So, because you have kids and there's a lot of people depending on you having health insurance. Oh, my wife would be also open to some part-time income at some point. I look forward to hearing your response, and I hope to hear from you about my situation. Thank you for what you do. You help so many see a clearer picture of their future lives. Mark, get on that microphone, mister, and let's find out about Brian from New England,
7:58 Speaker 01 and whether this is all possible. It's fascinating because of that. Chunk of money from the business that does help him. And of course, the defined benefit plan is very helpful. I would follow up if he were on with us and I wish you came on the air with us. I would really want to know how that defined benefit works. If it's just a cash balance plan and we know how to grow it, that's easy. It's growing at a 5% fixed return. But I wonder if there's any monthly income choice on that. What do you think about Brian's goals here, Mark?
8:30 Speaker 02 Very, very close, probably too close for comfort. I mean, where he's at right now for the next seven years, based on what he's saving and this, you know, this is all pre-tax.
8:40 Speaker 01 Yeah.
8:41 Speaker 02 Probably going to have around, you know, he'll have four, $4 million, maybe a little more. So 10 grand a month at 56, very close. But, you know, if they're both willing to work part-time, you know, they could figure out a way to make it happen.
8:55 Speaker 01 Yeah, I mean, this is what I would say, Brian. I think that there is some way that you can cobble together a plan. I think that the areas that pop out to me are that, you know, 12 grand a month is a lot of money and a lot of the money that you have is going to be taxed. So even when you hear, if you hear $4 million from Mark, like, that's pre-tax. We got to pay tax on it. That's not actually enough money. So I think what you guys need to really consider is, would you rather work in this company, which you're a part owner of, and kind of stretch it into another couple of years beyond that? So be full-time till, say, you know, 58, 59? Or would you rather call it quits and really put the pressure on yourselves to come up
9:38 Speaker 01 with some part-time income that will cover most of the 12 grand a month that you need? Personally, because I'm a wimp and Mark may have a different opinion, I would rather work a little bit longer, just me. Because I feel like that will get, that'll help build up the pension, that gets you covered for healthcare, and it takes the pressure off having to find part-time income. And by the way, your wife hasn't worked in 15 years. It's going to be so easy for her to just go get a job. I don't know, maybe, but maybe not. All right, Don says he's 43 years old. He's single, he's got no kids, he's self-employed. He contributes eighty to a hundred thousand dollars a year into his investments. Holy smokes.
10:20 Speaker 01 So, you know, he's forty three and he's like, I want to retire like in the next five years. No debt, a very reasonable mortgage at two point seven five percent. And he's got a house that's worth, I don't know, it's probably nine hundred grand and he's got about a four hundred thousand dollar note that's left. He might sell this house and move somewhere else and get all the money out of this in terms of the equity. Meanwhile, I would, I mean, I could not give up a two point seven five percent mortgage in my whole life, I don't think. Okay, here's what he's got.
10:58 Speaker 01 Three sixty six in a 401k, one hundred seventy three grand in S and P exchange traded funds, a hundred sixty six grand individual stocks, some money in an IRA and a Robin Hood account and a whole bunch of cash, a hundred and ninety grand in crypto. He's got about one point one million dollars. He didn't give us one piece of information, right, Mark? How much do you think this guy spends? He's, I mean, he is investing eighty to a hundred thousand dollars.
11:29 Speaker 02 Yeah, I mean, I'm guessing he spends very, very little and that's really the only way it's going to work for him.
11:34 Speaker 01 Yeah, I want to know what your expenses are and then I want to know whether you would work part time. This is going to be like the young people want to retire episode. We're going to call this episode pipe dreams and unreal dreams or something like that. All right. Clint says that he and his wife make over the contribution limit for Roth IRAs. Oh, I have my Ed Slott slides here that I can look this up, Mark. So, the Roth IRA contribution limit is phased out this year, if you're married filing jointly, at two hundred fifty two thousand dollars, meaning you cannot use a Roth IRA and contribute to that. You might be able to do a backdoor Roth, but you can't do a straight up Roth contribution.
12:17 Speaker 01 Question from Clint is, am I still able to contribute to a traditional IRA while contributing to? My work 401k. Yes. Okay. Wait a second. You can do both. You can do what is called a backdoor Roth with an asterisk. If you don't have a traditional IRA account floating around, the way it would work is you'd open up an IRA account, you'd put in, let's see, how old does he, does he say? No. But let's pretend that he is, shall we give him, um, let's say he's under the age of 50. So for this year, you would open up a IRA account and this is a non-deductible IRA. You would put $7,500 into the account and immediately then transferred into a Roth IRA.
13:00 Speaker 01 That's why they call it a backdoor. It's like, whoops, I get to go in through the back door. A non-deductible IRA then turns into a Roth IRA. However, and I can't say this enough, you absolutely, positively must do this only if there is not another IRA account that's out there. Okay? So if there is, you can roll all that old IRA money into your current 401k. One of the things that he said, I'd never heard anyone mention going from maxing out a 401k to then the traditional IRA. Don't do the traditional IRA. You've got a bunch of money that's already in the traditional asset, the 401k. Let's get you to Roth.
13:38 Speaker 02 He's, he's basically saying, can I max out my 401k and then contribute to a traditional IRA? Yeah, you can, but I wouldn't. I really see no reason anymore to use a traditional IRA.
13:47 Speaker 01 It would be a certain circumstance, so not for everybody.
13:49 Speaker 02 Yeah. And also check, you know, if you're looking to get Roth money, check if your 401k has a Roth option.
13:54 Speaker 01 Yes, that's right. And that more and more are doing this, Mark. This is definitely the case. Here is a question from N who asks, my question relates to a Roth Thrift Savings Plan for my husband. I am turning 56 this year and took the federal government's early retirement option last September. My husband is a few years younger. He's 51 years old. He continues to work full-time. We've saved a good amount of money in our Thrift Savings Plan accounts with most of it going traditional. We've been thinking about doing Roth conversions now allowed within the TSP. But I wonder if we should just have all of his contributions go to Roth?
14:33 Speaker 01 And is that sufficient to mitigate the tax cliff we will encounter when we have to take required minimum distributions? He maxes out on his contributions were in the 24% bracket. Thank you for your show. I've been enjoying listening now that I'm retired. All right. Okay, Mark, I'm going all in on new money, absolutely positively going into the Roth. I don't know about the conversions. What do you think about converting? We don't really know about their other money, but I have a good sense that they're two government employees. That means they're both going to have pensions and that means they're going to be in a probably not leaving that 24% bracket.
15:13 Speaker 01 So it would be great to convert some of the money, but I don't know if they have the assets to pay for it. What do you think?
15:21 Speaker 02 Yeah, without knowing that info, it's hard to say. I mean, it's definitely appealing if they can pull it off and they have the assets to pay the tax bill. But as far as switching over to Roth, yeah, 100%. Your husband's 51. If he's going to be working for a few more years, there's no reason to do any more pre-tax.
15:36 Speaker 01 Yeah, absolutely. All right, last question. This is from Sarah. She writes, Hello Jill and Mark. We are making a plan to fund our child's college education. We are 50 and 52 years old. We work full time. Our child is at a top institution that is very pricey. We saved a good amount of money in her 529. It's only going to cover those first two years. In making a plan to pay for the second half of college, it looks like we could have a mix of loans. I'm just trying to figure out the best approach. Okay, so Sarah says, I have over a million dollars in my 401k. Does it make sense to take a $50,000 loan from there? Our house is paid off, so we could also do a home equity line of credit.
16:21 Speaker 01 I have a great credit score, so does a private education loan make sense? Again, she's covered for the first two years and I'm trying to plan for 2027. Basically, a lot of our wealth is tied up in 401k accounts and the house. All right, because they're 50 and 52. I mean, I don't know how much we really have to raise. My guess is when she said a top institution, like I have to say with that sarcasm, and it's pricey. So what do you think? It's probably 80 grand a year. So she needs 106, let's say she needs 150 grand. Should she take a $50,000 loan from the 401k and then do $100,000 HELOC? What do you think, Mark?
16:59 Speaker 02 I'm inclined to say no, I don't know a lot of the other details, but since they have so much money in their 401ks, I'm just going to assume, and they're over the age of 50, so I'm going to assume they're maxing out and maybe doing the catch-up contribution. If that's a case, between the two of them, that's probably 60 grand a year right there. I would pause your retirement contributions for two years.
17:19 Speaker 01 Just up to the match.
17:21 Speaker 02 Just up to the match for two years, put that money towards college and probably take out what will end up being a pretty manageable loan for the rest.
17:30 Speaker 01 Yeah, I mean, and the loan doesn't have to be a parent loan. I would rather use the asset you have, honestly. So I love that idea of just like, hold on, let's like, take a breath, pull back on our contributions, gather that money up, put it aside, and then, as you have that money, just shovel it into the 529, keep pumping that up. That is the best place to put that money, even if she's in college already, even if you just have to keep it in a money market. So it doesn't have to be taxed. So I think that's the game plan, gang. You don't have to go into super duper debt to get your kids where they need to go or where you would like them to go. So, I mean, look, it's great, paying for
18:10 Speaker 01 education's great, it's just a huge commitment. So I get it, and if you're kind of juggling that and you're wondering how to pay for college, you're wondering how to make sure you don't read the retirement account, you want to get in touch with us, go to the website, jillonthemoney.com, click the Contact Us button, and write us a note. If you want to join us on the show, check the box, Mark will do everything else. While you're on the website, you can check out all of the free resources, including our weekly newsletter, which comes out on Fridays, we've got a blog, there are other broadcasts, we have videos and resources, it's all there for you, it's very exciting. You can subscribe to us on the Odyssey app or wherever you find your favorite podcasts. Please leave us a rating
18:51 Speaker 01 and review wherever you listen. And don't forget, do something nice for someone else today. Change your work, change your wealth, change your life. Thanks for listening, we'll talk to you tomorrow.
19:07 Speaker 01 This episode is supported by What Should I Do With My Money?, an original podcast from Morgan Stanley. Hear real people sit down with their financial advisors to work through the questions too big to tackle alone, like diversifying concentrated stock, investing in private markets, adding crypto to your portfolio. The strategies are complex, the emotions are real. Search for What Should I Do With My Money? to listen in.
19:32 Speaker 03 The world is changing faster than most career advice can keep up with. It's true, industries are shifting, jobs are disappearing, and new ones are just showing up that didn't exist five years ago, five minutes ago, whatever. I am Suzy Welch, and on Becoming You, we talk about how to find the work that genuinely calls you and actually pays you what you want to be paid, even in today's marketplace. When you find that intersection, the possibilities are bigger than you think. Listen to Becoming You wherever you get your podcasts.
Previous Can Dad Retire Comfortably? Next Should I Pursue a Great Money Reset? Page updated November 14, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated