Pod Insights Jill on Money with Jill Schlesinger At What Age Would I Be Able to Retire? About this episode I live in a very expensive city and would like to remain here in retirement. Knowing this, how much longer will I need to work? Have a money question? Email us here Subscribe to Jill on Money LIVE Subscribe to Jill on Money Newsletter YouTube: @jillonmoney Instagram: @jillonmoney Twitter: @jillonmoney "Jill on Money" theme music is by Joel Goodman, www.joelgoodman.com. To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 If you've got a lingering credit card balance that feels like an endless loop, where making monthly payments barely felt like moving the needle, you may be able to get rid of that dread completely, once you start using Monarch. Instead of just showing your past purchases like other apps, Monarch has this incredible debt pay down simulator and visualizer that calculates an exact real world payoff date based on your balances. Seeing a concrete finish line on a visual timeline completely rewires your brain from "this will never end" to actually circling a date on the calendar. My favorite part is you can run side by side scenarios. You can tweak a monthly contribution by just 50 bucks and instantly watch that projected
0:42 Speaker 00 debt free date jump forward by months, putting total control right back in your hands. Plus, whenever you're debating an unexpected expense, you can just ask Monarch's AI assistant whether or not you can afford it without derailing your goals, taking all the mental friction out of tracking. Write your own money story with Monarch. Use code JILLONMONEY at monarch.com to get your first year of Monarch Core half off at just $50. That's 50% off your first year at monarch.com with code JILLONMONEY.
1:15 Speaker 01 Still wearing the same old underwear? Chances are it's time for an upgrade. Start with Tommy John, a 2026 men's health editor's choice in best men's underwear. Experience exceptionally soft fabrics, a fit that moves with you, and all day comfort across our premium underwear, sleepwear, and loungewear. One less gift to worry about, one more reason to treat yourself. Own gifting season with an exclusive 40% off for new customers. Head to tommyjohn.com/holiday and use code HOLIDAY.
1:50 Speaker 00 Welcome to the Jill on Money Show. It's Wednesday, January 21st. You know, this is about the time when everybody's resolutions just fall off. I know, not you. You are type A on it type of listeners. I get it. But for everyone else, just have a little compassion. People's diets, they're blown. They're not Doing Dry January anymore, and maybe they're not even keeping their financial resolutions. Does not matter. What we are here doing, me and Mark, the best executive producer in the world, is answering your financial questions. So, if you've got one, if something's going on, and it can be really big, it can be really small, anything that touches money in your
2:33 Speaker 00 life, we'd love for you to get in touch with us. Go to jillonthemoney.com, click the Contact Us button, write us a note, and if you'd like to join us on the air live, you check the box. While you're on the website, we encourage you to sign up for the free weekly newsletter. That'll get you our blog post as well. You can also subscribe to Jill on Money Live, where you have access to quarterly live webinars. Quarterly, four of them, gang. See, I'm doing the math for you. Forty-five bucks will get you access to those quarterly live webinars, so you participate live. You get the entire back catalog of the webinars. There's bonus audio and video content. I gotta put more bonus audio and video content up there, don't I, Mark? It's gotta refresh that a little more. Anyway, that will all
3:17 Speaker 00 cost you forty-five bucks for the next 12 months. Our upcoming webinar is on Thursday, February 26. It is with the king of all Roths, Ed Slott. He's the man. And if you just want that Ed Slott webinar in isolation, just one webinar, you can buy any single webinar for fifteen bucks. Pretty good deal. Today, Mark says we have a lot of emails, and we've let them pile up. I know, I like talking to you in person, I really do, but I don't want to penalize the shy folks. So, this is from Catherine, who writes, "I would very much appreciate your thoughts, and when do you think it would be feasible for me to
4:00 Speaker 00 retire?" I'm fifty-two years old, Catherine is. She's married, she's got two kids, sixteen and fourteen. She lives in a high cost of living area. And she said, "If I can afford it, I would like to continue living here in retirement as well." Okay. My current salary, $195,000 a year, no other income. My retirement savings, get ready for this, Mark, 851 grand. The lion's share is in traditional pre-tax, 716,000, Roth 135. She does have a nice, big, chunky emergency fund. It is $115,000. And she's got a low-interest savings account, 13 grand for quick access.
4:45 Speaker 00 My husband and I have joint stocks in an account worth about $227,000. No debt, no property, no pension. Okay, here's how the retirement contributions go. Three streams, 6% mandatory and then 8% employer contribution. So 14% of her $195,000 salary to a pre-tax 414H plan. Don't even ask me what that is, guys. I don't know what a 414H. I know it's part of the tax code, I've never heard of that.
5:20 Speaker 02 That's a new, yeah, I haven't even come across that in my CFP continuing ed.
5:24 Speaker 00 Hold on a second, let's just, we gotta Google this, hold on. Standby people, 414 plan.
5:29 Speaker 02 State and local government employees exclusively.
5:32 Speaker 00 Yes, okay, here it is.
5:34 Speaker 02 And no pension.
5:35 Speaker 00 That stinks, okay. All right, we're gonna get back to this. So it's a, whatever, it's a retirement plan for state employees and city. Okay, catch-up goes into a deferred 457 plan, 31 grand in 2025. So 14% of her salary plus 31 grand, then also a Roth IRA through a backdoor. Oh, boy, isn't that incredible? She and her husband file their taxes separately. Hmm, something's going on there. But again, because Catherine, you're not coming on the air with us, I can't ask the follow-up questions. Okay, on average, they spend 10 to 12 grand a month, 6,000 goes to rent. And by the way, everybody, I just want to point this out. She's in New York and six grand is a rent stabilized apartment.
6:20 Speaker 02 Seems high.
6:21 Speaker 00 Well, I don't know, if she has a three-bedroom, it's not, right? Because she has two, a 16 and a 14-year-old. Okay, so six grand rent, the rest is their expenses. Husband and I split the expenses where he is responsible for rent. He, she takes on the rest. I consider his portion of the expenses, right? That's six grand a month. That's a liability because while I have a stable job, his situation is more unpredictable. Uh, he owns his own business. He's got variable income. Both kids are going to college. They've saved $342,000 in 529 plans. Boy, I wish I had some of that money for retirement. I am not planning to retire in the next 10 years, at least. Okay, good.
7:02 Speaker 00 And she says, I know it's impossible for me to do so, but how about this question mark? Should she be prepared to work until 65, 67, or 70, maybe even beyond? Assuming I continue to contribute at the same rate as today. Social Security at 67, that's all I care about, gang, is four grand. It's about 5,100 at 70. She says, I assume that my expenses will decrease in retirement. Hmm, I doubt that. I would never, uh, just everyone listening, don't presume that. Unless you are paying for something like out of pocket that definitely will go down. I, I don't think, we, I think we should always presume you'll spend exactly what you're spending today.
7:44 Speaker 00 She's in good health, longevity in her blood. She has estate documents that have been drafted, but she's got to revise it when each kid reaches 18. I'm also considering whether now is the right time to buy long-term care insurance. I don't want to burden my children in the old age and would prefer to live independently as long as my health would allow. Okay, Mark, come on the microphone. What do you think about Catherine?
8:09 Speaker 02 I wish Catherine was on the microphone with us because this whole thing seems very separate to me. Like she gives us her income and her retirement savings, but clearly the husband's working because he's covering the rent. But I don't know what he's making. I don't know what he has saved and, and their monthly spend. I'm assuming that's both of them.
8:27 Speaker 00 Let's just say it's 12 grand a month. Half he covers, half she covers.
8:31 Speaker 02 Right, so is she asking us, will she have enough to cover her expenses or the whole thing?
8:36 Speaker 00 Let's say the whole thing.
8:38 Speaker 02 You know, she's contributing, you know, let's just say $40,000 a year. She's going to work for another decade. I put in 12 years. She's going to have around $3 million when she's 64. She will. I have no idea about her husband. So, you know, is that going to get her? Yeah, that'll probably get her what she needs when you factor in social security at 67.
8:56 Speaker 00 Here's what I'm thinking. I'm thinking, I want you to come back on the air, but here's what I really think. From your very specific questions, I think you should target 67. You've got to get these kids through school, right? So, we know she's got a 14-year-old. So, we've got like seven years more, right? She says, "I know I have to work 10 more years." So, let's say that she retires when she's 67, okay? She'll test it. You know, Catherine, you'll keep running these numbers, but I think in your head, I think you should target 67. I think that most likely, you'll defer, you'll wait to claim your social security until you're 70.
9:37 Speaker 00 You'll use some of that pre-tax money for the few years in between, and then you'll get this big chunk of money. We would love for you to get in touch with us and tell us more about why you and your husband have such different, why you're filing separately and what's really going on. There's a possibility, when you file separately, that maybe someone had to declare bankruptcy, or maybe there's a situation where people will be on income-driven repayment plans for their own loans well into the future, and that maybe having filing separately makes sense? I don't know. Let's get to an easier question. Catherine, get back in touch with us. Okay.
10:19 Speaker 00 Melinda wants to know, "What is an acceptable fee for a financial advisor?" Okay, let me just start by saying this. The acceptable fee is zero if all they're doing is actually managing money. That's my feeling. No, if they're just going to be money managers, don't hire somebody. But here is what Melinda says. She was quoted 1.25%, which would be approximately $4,000 a year for the approximate $330,000 invested in mutual funds. From a reputable advisor, the current funds that I have are about 0.75%. Wow, that's high. She's got a few different fidelity funds. Why is that so high? I'm gonna just look this up.
11:02 Speaker 02 It's gotta be actively managed because I have one of those same funds and it's basically free.
11:07 Speaker 00 Okay, so she has management of three index funds. She says, all she has is 330 grand. It's all she has. She's retired. She thinks her fund fees are high. Do I need someone to be watching and moving as times indicate? No, you don't. Then she says, my husband had made poor choices and doesn't have much invested. She's 70 years old and she will have to start withdrawing at 73. I mean, look, 1 and 1/4% is not terrible, but I'm not sure why you need this. I think that what you might need is like, if this is the situation where you're thinking like, hey, I need someone to move my money around? No, then it's not worth it.
11:49 Speaker 00 Maybe what you should do is frankly, be with, you know, you own fidelity funds. Just keep your money at fidelity and maybe use the fidelity service. What's that called again? I always forget, Mark. Gosh.
12:02 Speaker 02 Fidelity Go.
12:03 Speaker 00 Fidelity Go. Maybe you have a fidelity go account and you just let them do it. It'll be like 0.3%. But no, I don't think so. I don't think it makes sense to pay 1 and 1/4%. No, I do not. And they're not going to be able to find the top and the bottom of the market. Nobody can, okay? John wants to know, should I sell some restricted stock units in a technology company in order to buy real estate? My mindset is that I would be balancing my portfolio so that I am not just 100% in stocks and bonds. I'm 56. I'm well ahead of my retirement goals. I'm wondering the trade offs, taxes, loss of dividends, future gains.
12:46 Speaker 00 Should I use my RSU money to buy a rental property to create steady rental income in the future? The property in mind is a million dollars. Come on, John, I have a lot to ask about this. I mean, if you're really worried about just being in stocks and bonds, maybe you sell the RSUs anyway and just like peel off some of that consolidated position. And maybe you can create a brokerage account and maybe inside your 401k, can you add some other asset classes? I don't know if I would buy rental real estate. I don't know anything about you.
13:24 Speaker 00 So if you want liquidity, you could certainly sell RSUs to get that big bet off the table. That might be something very, very interesting. Okay, this last email is from Jeff who says he wants to know about payout options for defined contribution plans versus a traditional annuity purchase. Hi Jill and Mark. Thank you for the helpful perspective and insight you share with your listeners. I have a general question. It just doesn't seem to get enough airtime. In addition to my 401k as well as separate money in a brokerage account, I also have a defined contribution pension plan available to me upon retirement.
14:06 Speaker 00 No COLA. I may consider the annuity option when the time comes instead of a lump sum to be rolled over because it would provide some guaranteed lifetime income. Okay. I don't think you would be opposed to that choice because after all Jill loves pensions. But isn't that really the same thing as someone just buying an annuity with a 401k disbursement? After all, both types of lump sums could be rolled into an IRA for liquidity, which I know Jill also loves. My confusion is based on the fact that on your show you often frown upon annuities, but pensions are typically embraced. Can they be considered the same thing? What am I missing? Hopefully you appreciate that this question is philosophical. So I didn't put any numbers around it. Okay, here is what you're missing.
14:50 Speaker 00 Annuities, many annuities, not all of them, have wildly high fees. That's what we're missing. So here's the question that we would look at Jeff in your situation, which is if you had, let's just say you had a million dollars in your 401k. You say, you know what, I want to take half of it, buy an annuity, lose the access to the money, right? I lose my money, then I don't have that access to that money. I've lost that liquidity and I turn on an income generating machine. Sounds great. Would you pay 2.5% a year for that? I wouldn't. And that's what a lot of annuities cost, 2%, 3% a year. So it's not a bad idea, but I think in isolation it could work, but it's
15:30 Speaker 00 Very important that we would look at the cost of what that annuity is and what your alternatives are. Whereas with a pension, you have this lump sum that you could roll over and do whatever you want with, or a stream of income. And that is very different and has a much different cost structure associated with it. So I hope that helps. Okay, if you've got a question, if you've got something going on, philosophical, concrete, doesn't matter, go to jillonthemoney.com, click the Contact Us button. Of course, let us know if you'd be willing to come on the air live with us because we'd love to have you. Don't forget to sign up for the free weekly newsletter and subscribe to us on the Odyssey app or wherever you find
16:11 Speaker 00 your favorite podcasts. Please leave us a rating and review wherever you listen. And we ask that you lift someone up today. Change your work, change your wealth, change your life. Thank you for listening and we'll talk to you tomorrow.
Previous Can I Call It Quits and Live a Little? Next Inheritance Coming Our Way Page updated November 15, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated